Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is that card as bad as you think it is?

Transcript 7:25

Is that card as bad as you think it is? Well, is it? This is one of my favorite questions to ask myself in Arkham Horror the Card Game. For those of you who don't know, a few years ago I set a challenge for myself to play every single player card in Arkham Horror the Card Game. During this challenge, I made a lot of big discoveries for how to approach the game and my evaluation of it. Every new run of Arkham is about learning more about the game for me personally, but I wasn't expecting this challenge to be so revolutionary for my line of thinking regarding card evaluation. What I ended up learning was that a vast majority of cards that I viewed as bad were only bad because I was playing them incorrectly. I was slotting them in the place of cards that I would call good, and then I would get mad that that card wasn't living up to those expectations.

So, instead, through the whole process, I started to look at these cards and begin to ask myself where did those cards fit best? It became less about bemoaning the lack of the value I was normally finding, but instead learning how to squeeze as much value that I could out of those cards in my deck. It was less about playing the best cards and more about playing the best card for [snorts] my deck. This discovery made me a better player and is fundamental in all of the deck building I do in Arkham to this day. But, have I fallen back into old habits? Did I fail to give a card its proper evaluation?

Is this card as bad as I think it is? Endurance is a card that came out in the new core box. It calls back to the talents of the original core with a much needed boost to its power level. However, if you've been to this channel before, you know that I am not a fan of these new talents. They are certainly stronger than their previous counterparts, but I still didn't think that they were very good. Resources were better spent elsewhere. You can find boosts in other areas. It's not worth the action. Yada yada yada. And a whole bunch of other criticisms. Basically, the bottom line was that I found them to be better, but still pretty bad.

Since then, I will admit, I doubled down on these opinions in other videos, but I've also seen endurance used to great success. More than once by different players. I'd like to even add that these are players that I think are very good Arkham players. But, it was so good, so much so in fact, that they would say that the card performed good, or dare I even say great. It was a fundamental part of their deck. It may not have been the best card in my mind, but for that game, it was the best card in their deck. Does that sound familiar? With these recent games I've watched, endurance has been on my mind. I know that there are some players I play with that bring certain cards to the table in an effort to convince that me of that my evaluation of it was wrong. For fun, of course. It's nothing serious, and I appreciate to be able to see certain cards in action that I otherwise wouldn't be drawn to play.

And I think this is the biggest challenge of card evaluation in Arkham Horror. A player's play style matters more for a card's power level than you may realize. Arkham is an incredibly open game with a large variety of ways for players to find their play style. They can find solutions to the challenges presented to them, and there are a lot of methods methods to solve these challenges that can widely be considered good. But, what makes an answer for a challenge better than another? Great question. I hear at PBG, we've talked a lot about tempo on the channel, and generally, the more tempo you get out of an action, the better that action was. The less you put in, and the more you get out, the better off you will be for the next challenge thrown your way.

That's just the the the general idea of tempo. But, with that said, at a certain point, tempo is tempo, unless we want to argue for an unhealthy tempo arms race. It's really what it comes down to. This also begins to beg the question, what if I value what I put into a card differently than what someone else values what they put into a card? To me, I look at endurance and I think about how I'd rather spend the resources or find the skill value, but someone else looks at it and thinks it's an easy way to get plus two fist for beating the hell out of an enemy. Then it goes even deeper. What if they view the singular resource as an easy solution to a problem that can be solved one time by the same card? So, rather than finding multiple solutions, they have one card solving multiple challenges. Or instead, what if they view a card like endurance as a way to open up another slot in their deck for other things? If they don't need stat boost for other cards, what cards they can can they play instead to improve their deck otherwise?

Is it really that deep? You might be thinking. Are people really thinking this way? Are people looking at endurance and going into this minutia of thinking, is it actually going to save me that much? Is it going to open up my deck for other ways? Are people really thinking this way? Yes. It's one of the many reasons that deck building in Arkham is so damn good because you can go that deep. You can make those discoveries and you can learn about yourself as a player and your play style. So, with all this said, is this card as bad as I think it is? For how I like to play, yes. I'm not a fan.

But, I understand why it can be the best card for the right deck. And I think that that discovery on Endurance from these last few days, that's the reason it's been on my mind. I think that my general evaluation of Endurance may have been a little bit off the mark in the big picture, but for me personally, I think I was on the money. But, I can also admit that, you know, maybe for the right deck with the right play style, for what it opens up, for what it offers, for how it may solve multiple solutions, Endurance may be the best card for the right deck. Thanks for watching. I tried something new with this video. I hope you guys dug it. It's been on my mind, like I said, Endurance. It's been It's been there. It's been thinking. I couldn't escape it. It's been on my It's been on my mind a lot, so I wanted to make something kind of putting these thoughts into a presentation format.

Never done a video like this before on the channel. Hope you guys like it. In the meantime, thanks for watching. If you want to support, leave a comment, like, subscribe. Join the Patreon if you feel so inclined. If you want to offer $3 a month, I would really appreciate it. In the meantime, thanks for watching. Have a good one. And as always, a GG's.

Progress saved