Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wondrous Creatures Winterfall Expansion - TCbH Review

Transcript 6:20

You know what's cool about expansion reviews? You don't have to explain the game again. You can just get right into the game. What's new? What's cool? Final thoughts. And All right, let's get to the end and then we'll get to the meat of it. Wonders Creatures Winter Fall is a bunch of cool concepts that is marred by poor and at times thoughtless execution that doesn't make the game realistically better in any way. Okay, so what's in this frosty box of goodies? The first thing you'll notice are some plastic trays to organize your cards and components, some new captains and a boatload of cards including the adorable new spirit creatures with the fun imaginative designs you've come to expect out of this game. Team new Pokémon this game is not. But all of that is the familiar stuff. The really new aspect of the expansion which many of the new captains and creatures interact with is the new top and bottom section of the board which has snowfall events that happen according to a new time track overlay and an accumulation of snowfall in the six creature slots on display. When you take a creature, you get the snowfall then snowfall as well as the two creature types not otherwise featured in achievements are ranked for points at the end of the game. And this brings me to the one unambiguously awesome killer feature of this expansion which is blank achievement cards and creature tag tokens where you set out

the blank cards, shuffle up the tags, and distribute them to start. Infinitely more convenient for setup and execution. And while this isn't specific to this new thing, the remaining tags are used for the end game scoring conditions at the end. So I like that there's alternative pressures to getting the tags of the creatures that otherwise aren't included in the achievements. That's a nice added feature to an expansion. And that's what an expansion should do. It finds a need. It fills a gap. But what gap is Winterfall otherwise addressing? Competition over snowfall in a game with loads and loads of points and other system to give such a minor point reward seems wild. Incentivizing a stale market? We already have sweeping capabilities left and right. Interactions with the new spirit creature type and captains? It feels more like those interactions are there to justify the existence of the snow rather than the snow being an organic component to the game itself. And I don't hate it. The snowfall, the winter events, and the two mechanics I haven't even really talked about, the new aurora events which are put out on the board as snaggable and exhaustible little bonus nuggets from going to certain habitats, or the snowstorms that block the use of a habitat, or rather restrains the use of a habitat, meaning that if you park right next to that with the worker, you have to get creature instead of getting the food resource out of it, and getting

the snow if there's any accumulated snow in that creature's field. And these aren't bad, but they also don't feel like they add anything meaningful. So they just increase complexity of a game that's already kind of a kitchen sink, which could be a cool thing. I know a lot of gamers, and sometimes I have the instinctive reaction that just more is better, and that can have its purpose, but it's all brought down and then also held into great highlight when there's also some sloppy production going on. Okay, those inserts from earlier, they seem smart, but they are just a little off to me. Overly restrictive in some ways, too loose in others, and then using them, no matter how you slice it, your game is going to have to live in two full-size game boxes, neither of which seems fully utilized. Or how about setup? The Winterfall rulebook is almost as big as the base game, and the The involves so many steps that have changed, but instead of just having a completely new setup page, it continually has you go back and forth between the two rule books to navigate.

Your new cards, there's a noticeable difference in the colors of their backs. The originals were more teal, whereas the expansion is more emerald green. In person, it's very noticeable, and even more so when shuffling your decks and expansion cards are noticeably, though slightly, different size. Maybe a small thing, but as someone not entirely sold on the gameplay content to the expansion, this is an annoying reminder that the utmost care wasn't taken in Winterfall's execution. If the cards were up to snuff, if the insert were usable to get all the components into the base game box, or the expansion box fit everything, or there was some purposeful way of using the two boxes together, or if the rule books were more fleshed out, basically all the production stuff, if that were resolved, I would be a bit more forgiving on this expansion as a whole, but it doesn't change that mechanically it's not a game changer, either. Wondrous Creatures is a good game, and I like all of the Bad Comic Games I've played, but as much as I wanted to like Winterfall, I couldn't help but feel it drags the game down. It takes up more space, is more complicated, is harder to teach, is harder to set up, and the production makes the new materials stand out. If you want a game of complex interactions and really creative combos by the cards and creatures that you're playing, I absolutely recommend Wondrous Creatures, but I can't say that it's really

elevated in any way by the Winterfall expansion. That's our review, but let me know, what is your favorite expansion, and what are some other expansions that you've encountered that widen the game without necessarily making it any more deep or interesting. Put it in the comments, but as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help us grow, likes, comments, subscribes, checking out our Patreon, and even just sharing these videos across the internet do a tremendous amount to spread the word. But above all else, thanks for just being a great community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved