Shadow and Rune Review - A Deckbuilding Skirmish Game
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Wackle from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Shadow and Rune by Michael Edis. Shadow and Rune is a one to four player deck building game, but I'm going to be focusing primarily on what I would argue is the main mode, which is a two-player head-to-head. There's also three to four player mode as well as a solo game to play through as well. Uh before we dive into it, this is a prototype, all rules and components of exchange, and I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. This is a deck building game. If you've played any deck building game where you start with 10 cards, you draw five, then you work your way through a card market as you add cards to your deck. A lot of the core structure here will be familiar. You're going to have your starting hand of 10 starting deck of 10 cards. You're going to draw five of them. There are eight coins over here. These are each worth one coin helping you buy cards. And there's two shadow bats that will start off in your deck. These top four cards are always in the market over here. We have a one, three, and five gold cards as well as a shadowbat. And then from there, you'll be picking six creatures, six units, basically minions, as well as six items to add to the market pool from a larger pool of potential cards. You'll be adding six and six to fully flush out your market. From there, you take your cards over here. For example, we have a shadowbat over here. We're going to play our shadowbat. We'll play it to the back row. It's going to come into play uh with summoning sickness exhausted. It can't activate. And it costs one action to summon it. And it's going to attack with adjacency. This little indicator here says that when it's here, it will attack over the line adjacently. It also does one damage, has one health, and would cost three gold to buy more of them from the market. That's your shadowbat. Now, you only have three actions per turn, which at first is more than you can do anything with anyways.
Like, what's the big deal? You play a card, I can't do anything. Next turn, maybe I go ahead and move it. You can move orthogonally for an action. Uh there's reasons why you want to be in different rows to combat different enemies, but moving and playing seems pretty basic early on, but your three action limitation will become more relevant later, especially when you're trying to play things like the Lich King, which will take three actions just to play, which means you can't activate anything else the turn you play the Lich King, unless you take advantage of either cards or abilities to do so. From there, once you're done playing all your cards, you get again playing cards and moving things around the board, spending your actions. We then go to the attack phase if you're able to attack. I'm not right now, but if this were here, I would be able to attack either dealing damage to my opponent, reducing his 30 life points, or alternatively taking out an opposing shadowbat, dealing one damage to it, taking it off the board.
So, you're either attacking enemy creatures on the opposing side, or you're attacking your opponent directly if there's an open slot to do so. And then we go ahead and we buy stuff. I have four coins over here, which means I can buy a few things. I could buy a stash, working my way my way up to those three gold cards to be able to buy more. Or alternatively, I can buy a bone soldier. These have two health and they can be spawned from your discard pile for two actions. So if you have a bunch of bone soldiers or bone archers for that matter, you can spawn them from your discard pile, making sure you can always bring people back into play, but you'll need the actions to do so. On the other hand, maybe I got the echo dagger. Deal a damage and all echo daggers deal an additional damage this turn. Echo daggers, if you lean heavily into those, can be a lot of fun. Playing a handful of echo daggers. Although in order to do that, you probably want to buy a bunch of things that help you draw cards. Fortunately, there are there's bone helms, there's goblin bows. These things will help you draw additional cards. And being able to draw into like five or six echo daggers is an incredibly powerful feeling. I say that because I haven't done so yet. I think the most I've ever done one turn is three. And even that was kind of fun. But anyways, you're basically trying to build towards you have a fixed card market over here. Buy as many cards as you're able to afford with your coins and then add them to your discard pile before they'll eventually shuffle back into your deck.
That's the core structure over here. You are playing a deck building game, which again, if you've played anything like Stars, Dominion, Ascension, any of those games, the core structure will be fairly familiar. You are doing so with a fixed market. This is not a rotating card market. These are the piles of cards that are available. There's a whole bunch of plate armors over here. You're going to decide which cards are in the game before you start, but from there, you can try to plan towards whatever build you think is going to be most efficient. And then from there, you're playing cards onto your board, spending actions in order to be able to play them, moving them around. You can also heal characters with actions, and you could damage your characters to earn actions. So, there's more of an economy pile over there as you try to work towards trying to attack your opponent. There's going to be ranged creatures over here. We have a goblin shaman. I think this is our own. No, but bone archers and goblin shamans are going to be our range creatures. They can attack from the back row as illustrated over here. Sometimes you have cards that activate attack in diagonals as well.
There's the wolves that do that. Lots of cards with lots of abilities, but ultimately you're trying to deny your opponent, trying to deprive your opponent of their health, working them down from their 30 health in two versus two. in in in a head-to-head in higher player counts, you have more health. But, uh, at a at a head-to-head game, you're trying to reduce your opponent's 30 health down to zero by building a better deck through the minions and items and and economy and the money that goes into it. That's the core structure of the main game. There's also a solo, like I said, there's team modes as well. There's a solo mode that operates more like a Slay the Spire style game where you're basically working your way through a map over here, uh, visiting various opportunities to upgrade your cards as you take on various enemies. them operating with a bit of a simplified AI as far as how they operate. But that's basically the core structure of what Shadow and Rune is. It is a two-player head-to-head deck building game with team modes and with the solo mode all operating under the similar principles. The solo mode is probably the most different but still be very familiar if you've been playing through this. With that, let's go ahead and dive into our review of what I like, don't like, conceal this not liking.
Starting off with what I like. In general, this is a satisfying deck building game in a lot of ways. I do have complaints. I do have things that I think can be streamlined or optimized or make it flow a little better. But overall, I was fairly impressed with the core structure of what this does by giving you a deck building game with a solid skirmish mode in which the minions and the items are equally compelling. Like all of these cards are cool. Even right now, like this market over here that I set up for the sake of the review, I've never played with this combination. the idea of playing a game where you have the bone archers and the bone soldiers. Although I don't know if I care for the bone soldiers. If I have a deck full of bone archers and the plate armor, because plate armor gives you extra actions, a cost actions, helps you draw a card, giving you an extra action. If you have a bunch of bone archers and a bunch of plate armor, you can just constantly be spawning those things out into play just harassing your opponent. Again, going fully into echo daggers plus goblin bows means you're going to be constantly doing damage. Or even bone helms. Bone helms would be enough. In fact, bone helms you might need to because of the action efficiency. Bone helms cost zero. So, a bunch of bone helms, a bunch of echo daggers, and you're suddenly spawning into a whole handful of a whole bunch of cars that are coming out dealing tons of damage to your opponent. Combining various characters. Again, there's a whole bunch of characters over here.
There's range characters. There's characters that pull people back. There's characters that heal. There's characters that have your characters attack twice or deal extra damage. There's a ton of different variety as to how you're going to build. And it's up to you to look at the market at the beginning of the game and then try to think how you're going to work towards the market that you want, towards the deck that you want. And that's going to be a combination of dealing with whatever your hand gives you. you don't always have the amount of money you need, but also building up your economy so that more often than not, you can actually go ahead and buy the cards that will get you towards that engine. So, overall, I just I like fixed card market decks, and I like the combination of abilities that are going on here that make me want to experiment with different combos to more aggressively take down my opponent. The 30 health at first, it doesn't seem like a lot, but it's a decent amount. Meaning when I say a lot, what I mean by that is sometimes it feels like at first when you start playing this game, it might feel like you can't actually survive not being present in the beginning of the game to deal with the creatures your opponent's throwing at you. And they have a bunch of units on the board and you don't.
They're just attacking you every single turn, but you can afford one or two turns delay as you get things out into play, as you work towards that better deck. And so there is a tough balance in a decision space around how quickly do you get fast things onto the board. Is it worth just getting a bunch of shadow bats onto the board as aggressively as possible to be able to hurt your opponent? Like that could be something that's helpful. So overall, there's a lot of decisions based as far as the pacing of what you do and how you build your deck as well as how you're reacting to your opponent's deck. So the combination of abilities, the the trying to build out your deck as you start through the action system. The action system is an additional layer here. You're not just dealing with money as a currency. Your actions are a currency as well. how many actions you have to move around the board to be able to attack, to be able to play cards. You need to play into that. And you can do that either through damaging your own creatures or buying cards that give you extra actions or just not buying super expensive action cards that are going to take up your entire turn, which again is yet another decision space as far as how you manage all of this as you work your way towards taking out your opponent. As far as things I don't like in the game, most of the things I don't like don't come down to the core structure of the game. It does come down to I would say streamlining or things that could be improved upon. First of all, I wish there was more deck weeding in the game, like ability to purge cards from your deck that I like. One of the core tools you have in a good deck building game is being able to adjust your deck downwards as you need. And this game doesn't really have that as much. And so you do I I do want to see more deck reading in the the card abilities. I also want to see more items. There's a lot of characters, a lot of minions in the game, so you can see a fresh pool of minions every time you play or have a few repeats. Not every time you play,
you're going to run out. But for the most part, you can play it a few times before you start to feel sy on the minions. But even my second play with the items, the second play already felt like you saw most of the same items because it's only like again, you're taking six items per game, and I think there's eight or maybe nine items. There's not enough item variety. So, you're mostly seeing the same items every single time you play. So, I think they do need more items to flush out the opportunity to have those combos feel fresh and interactive, as opposed to right now, it's more the minions where things feel fresh because of the variety of minions they have. So more cars in general always a good thing with games like this because of that fixed market aspect, but for sure the items need to be fleshed out as well as the deck leading. I also think there's more room for general abilities as well as far as different ways they can interact with things or even the economy. I think a a big thing for me that felt a little interesting is the economy in this game.
It's too easy to get the higher value cards. Like a five gold card costs five gold. So you spend that five gold once and suddenly you're generating five gold. is too easy to work your way up towards the higher value cards, which means it's actually easier than you'd think to get start getting a whole bunch of goblin bows or lich kings in play by going towards those over there. I think the card economy almost needs to take a note from Dominion in terms of the way they scale. Like a one cost card is one, a two card cost is three, and a three card cost is six. There's a progression of scale that really makes you feel like you've earned those higher card costs. And this game doesn't have that as much. And the reverse problem as well because of the higher economy scaling is the things like, you know, you don't really have three card costs. So you well you you do if you want to buy a stash or a goblin bat, but nothing in the market that costs three, which means having three cards feels like you have to buy a starter card or nothing at all when you have three gold. So I think the overall economy scaling could be advantaged a bit more. Uh it could be could be tweaked a bit more to feel a bit more streamlined. And lastly, I'll say that the card art in the game at first I liked it. I do like the overall flow.
The board feels a little flat. Again, prototype, so I have no clue what's changing over here. But the card art I liked at first, but as I played this game, it's harder to tell at first because of the color palette they use, the things don't stand out as clearly. Yes, you can read everything. Yes, you can see everything, but there's not like a clear glance of that extra splash of color that might easily differentiate one card from another at a glance. So, it's it it does look good, but it's not as functionally helpful when you're trying to distinguish what's in play or even what's in your own hand as you start to build out that deck. And so I do wish there was more color to it. And I think the board in general as well could definitely improve from a graphic design aspect. It's functional. It does the job, but it doesn't look great overall. As far as what I can see others not liking, the biggest thing first of all, aside from the standard things in a deck builder, there's luck of the draw. Who will your cards combo in the right way? You can build a perfect deck and then just not have them combo at the right time in the right way. And you know, your opponent win wins not because they built a better deck, but because they had luck favor them. That will definitely be present in any deck builder. It's certainly present here.
But I'd say the biggest thing is the attrition of the game. You can get to a point where it's pretty clear that you're losing. The first half, not at all. If if somebody has 30 health and you have 22, you're still in this game. But when you get down to the weeds, when your decks are more fleshed out, when there's less room for that gap to develop, you can certainly get to a point in the last quarter of the game where it's pretty clear who's winning, but you just have to kind of you have to power through to get to the end or just resign, which is never a fun feeling. So, I do think that the the tail end can potentially have a little bit too much of an obviousness to who's winning the game. Like, as opposed to when you play a game like Dominion, which is pointbased, it's not necessarily as clear. I mean, sometimes it is, but other times you don't really know what's going on because the points are in the deck. Because this is a direct head-to-head game and because of the pacing of it, you can get towards that end game slightly not as good feeling when you know you're losing, but you still have to power it out for another 15 20 minutes. As far as final thoughts on Shadow and Rune, I overall really like what they're going for here. I think this is a very good concept, a very good combination of a deck building and a skirmish game that definitely surprised me in terms of how well it overall plays. The biggest thing is I do feel there's a lot of room for quality of life improvements from the way the game looks, from the economy of the game, from more abilities, from more item balance, uh, but having more items in the deck. There's a lot of small tweaks that I think this is a game that has a lot of potential to shine. And where it is right now, it feels like several tweaks away from exactly where I'd want it to be. Overall though, I still definitely enjoyed it. Uh, I'm going to give it a 3.5 out of five for right now. I think it has room to grow, but it does have those prototype quirks where I hope to see it develop and grow further. As it is, I still like already
what it's doing. And I think it's a good implementation of a deck building skirmish game. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out Star Realms if you just want a head-to-head game where it's all about building your deck, powering through, and hitting each other in the face until you reduce their life total to zero. Or alternatively, if you want another deck building skirmish game, check out Ignite. It's a game that also has like also needs a little bit of polish. is one of the games be harder to find nowadays. I think it also could benefit from a little bit of polish to it, but it's another game that was really fun with fixed card markets where you try to work your way much more of a grid-based system to go through as opposed to the slightly more abstracted puzzle, but it's another good deck building skirmish game. In any case, until next time, I hope you found this review helpful. As always, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco.