Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Arkham Episode | Season 2 Impressions | Roundtable ep_002

Transcript 1:34:45

All right. So, first of all, let's welcome everybody. Welcome the audience out here to the cardboard roundt. I think I'm calling this. This is my second episode. I did an episode on ARCs with a different panel. Today, we actually have Jared. Yes, there it is. Jared from Board Game Apprentice. Uh, your second time on the channel. And then Mark from actually Evil Machine. Uh, if you need board game inserts, I'll have the links down below. you make some of, if not the best inserts in in the world. Um, and honestly, some of the best prices. So, and you're not paying me to say that. Um, so I just wanted to kind of plug you a little bit.

The check did already clear. So,

yeah, it is the best. Um, okay. So, what we're going to do today is go through Arkham Horror, the card game. I am brand new. I've played one and a half campaigns. I'm have scenario two set up behind me. playing it a second time with my second investigator. Um, but we have two veterans here, so don't worry. So, hopefully this conversation is uh I don't know, helpful to both new to the game and uh veterans. A lot of this is pretty early takes. I mean, we all have had our hands on the the second chapter core box. And I don't know if I said that. That's what we're talking about. A second chapter core box, the reintroduction or I guess a new starting point into Arkham Horror the card game. Um, a little history though before we get in.

So, it launched in 2016. There's 10 years of content, like an insane number. I saw the content you have, Mark, and I don't even think it's all of it. It's kind of like a stupid amount. Um, the original core set was 2016, but there was it only was up to two players, so people were buying two of those. And then in 2021, there was a fanfare for the revised core set because it it it allowed you to build up to four investigators at one time in one box. I'm assuming that had a bunch of duplicates, so you can kind of build those decks out. Um, and that had the Night of the Zealot campaign. I don't know if either of you remember that campaign in particular. I've never played it, but um we'll we'll get into that in a little in a little bit, but I want to know a little bit from both of you. Maybe we'll start with Mark. Like, what pulled you into Arkham Horror LCG in the first place? Are you just a big Lovecraft fan? Is it the campaign style format? What?

I I mean, I love horror stuff in general. Um, I guess the the thing that brings me into this game in particular over others, and the reason why it's my it hovers between my number one and number two game of all time, um, is the fact that the story is so deep. It's it really has a story that you're traveling through it. Um, on top of the fact that the game play is also really well done. It's not just a game you play for the story, you also play it for the mechanics.

Jared, what do you think?

Yeah, so I got into it during the first revised course at like 21, I think it was. Um, so I got on to the the last like bringing on point that they were kind of doing. Um, but kind of what got me into it is that um I have a friend that's super into it. He does like costumes, he does music. it was like he he was like really sold this as like this thematic emergent kind of game and I totally fell in love with it with that you know revised core set. Um but I think what's kind of kept me on is that of all the campaign games that I've played this feels like the only one that kind of promises the um kind of good mechanistic kind of part of it. like the the actual core game of Arkham is so good and it helps that the the story that you're able to tell with these characters and go through these campaigns like both sides of that are so strong and that's so rare to see in games that kind of have this campaign structure. So just those two things together just keep me hooked on this game.

Yeah, I've wanted to play it for quite a long time. I was I think I know I haven't mentioned here yet. It was the before before banter. I was Marvel Champions. I'd bought everything up until X-Men and then I decided I just can't follow it any longer. even though X-Men was my first Marvel love as a kid. Um, but I mostly got that because I wanted to get my kids into it. Arkham Horror wasn't going to work for them, but I always had the allure of people saying it was a more thematic version. Storytelling was was a little bit better. I like the idea of like these different characters that you'd never heard about um from like the investigator perspective, but I hadn't just jumped in. So, I am that person that Fantasy Flight is looking for to try to extract every single dollar. And uh I think they might have gotten me. I don't want to spoil the end here. So for somebody that's never played, how would you all describe like what makes this game distinct from like Eldrich Horror, Arkham Horror Third Edition, or the other kind of like Lovecraft themed games? Like what's what's the what's the the hook here?

I think the the hook that really gets me is that um so I don't know if we've kind of described what the game is, right? Um so it is a a um you know game. you have your investigator, that's your character, and you have these player cards that make up your deck, and you play through this, you know, three to eight, you know, scenario campaign. Um, I think what really hooks me on to it is that progression that you get to upgrade your deck kind of as your character develops and it feels like you're experiencing the story, facing these monsters and all these like awful scenarios. Um, and that little iterative strength you get of and building up your deck. I think that is like the the most fun part of it for me.

What about you, Mark? I think uh one of the big ways in which it differs is that it gives you the combination of say a collectible living card game and a board game in that they use the cards as locations and every scenario has a new map you're playing out versus something like um Eldrich Horror or Arkham Horror the board game where you just have the board. It's always the same. Maybe some expansions add an extra board off to the side or there's some in the third edition of Arkham Horror, the board does change, but it's these kind of the same tiles in different orientations each time versus uh in the card game, you've got the board part of it made from cards. So, every scenario is drastically different and sometimes you don't even know what the map looks like until halfway through. um on top of the CCG part or LCG where you can really dive into the card play mechanism and ignore everything else and still have a deep rich experience there assuming you have a big enough card pool which I'm sure we will get to.

Yes, we will. One of the things that did stand out for me because I am fresh so fresh to this and I I didn't know that there was movement and movement adds so much to a game like this and I the only comparison I have is is Marvel Champions which I don't know there might be a scenario out there that I haven't played but that's just not what you do and uh being able to kind of like kite enemies around um you know Mark you and I had I think it was the second scenario that I have now where we had people chasing us this entire time and trying trying to run from them and get away and then like work that puzzle and and and try to figure out who they're going to go to next and draw them into different into different locations so we didn't get attacked and we could still get the clues and investigate. That was so much fun for me. Like that's that to me is like a really big standout is the movement portion and that you're not just moving to a spot and executing. You have to really think do I want to stay there? I'm literally in the middle of that second campaign right the second and I can't stay in the same place. I keep drawing the wrong wrong cards. What is it? The threat deck. The mythos, what is that called? Encounter deck.

The mythos deck.

Yeah. Uh so yeah, I I keep drawing more enemies. Um it so that was one of the big things for me that that stood out different than Marvel Champions. Um and you know, the deck building obviously is different, which we'll I think we'll get a little bit into. Uh that seems interesting. I like the progression of the deck as well. The XP system. That's something that that feels good. Mark, you and I, we did not have that um that great of a time with the XP system. I will say though, I did get six XP on my first scenario on my second campaign, which felt so much better.

Yeah. And the I'm sure we'll get to the campaigns and their length and the XP in a little bit, but the being able to

level up your character in between sessions does so much to make you excited for what's next. Because it's not just, oh, now we've got another level. It's we've got another level and I can't wait to pull out that cool sledgehammer, right? and uh or that new spell or whatever it is. Um, it really does add an extra element of excitement to keep moving forward even when and I didn't say if when things go horribly arry

that you Well, let's let's talk about that. You know, you are drawing tokens out of a bag. And I did, by the way, Mark, I got the acrylic tokens from Game here. Yeah. Um, and

I'm a coin capsule guy as an alternative.

You're a coin capsule? I Well, that's what Mark is as well. and I didn't have the coin capsules and I was, you know, I I I bought some mats too actually. Um, and I was like, you know what, let's just get the acrylic tokens and they are great. I will say I think the coin capsules are slightly heavier, which is in in their benefit,

but the bag, the Game Genic bag is giant, by the way, and I didn't know how I'd like it, but it has a really small opening and you can just really stir it around in there. I do like it better than the the original bag. As a total side note, we were talking about Dice Tower before this. They totally sold me on all the Game Gen stuff. I think uh I can't remember who did the video, but they did a video, maybe it was Z, did a video on all the Game Gen releases, and I was just like immediately like drooling like And this was right after I

I know.

Yeah, I I don't know what I'm thinking.

It's It's interesting because from the perspective of somebody who makes organizational stuff, I make tokens for the game. Actually, Arkham Art Game is the thing I make the most of for my Etsy shop. Um, you know, I'm looking at this new game genenic stuff and saying, "Oh, this is neat. They finally did all the stuff that we as the like players have been making ourselves." Um, but they kind of missed the mark on a couple things. Like the the acrylic tokens look great, but they don't include some of the newer uh symbols that came out in the original wave. So, if I buy the original wave of content, the chapter one, um, had new tokens that got introduced partway through. So, there's frost tokens as well as bless and curse tokens. And these new acrylic tokens don't include those. So, if I buy the new acrylic tokens, I cannot use them for some of the older campaigns. Like, I literally can't use them because it's missing stuff.

I'm just looking forward at this point, Mark. Stop. You know what? I'm I'm leaving all that behind which we'll we'll we'll get to that as well. We keep saying that but there there's so much more to talk about. But anyways, I don't even know why I got there. I just wanted to like show off some of the extra stuff. You gave me some bling as well, which I've been working with a little extra counter tokens and and uh the arrows and all of that stuff. So, all of that is is awesome. Um okay. So, what does one of the other things that about this system that I thought was interesting that I didn't I always thought of it as a solo game? My first experience was a co-op with you, Mark. Like, what does the system get right that most co-op games miss? Like, well, first we'll start Jared. Do you play it co-op or do you play it just solo?

Yeah, so this is actually um I'm I'm a big solo person. I have I usually play I will play this two-handed solo. Um but for me, like three players, two or three players is like the sweet spot for this. Um particularly, like you mentioned, things go wrong in this game. Um, but games of of of Arkham Horror the card game are just always memorable, right? You you you pull that, you know, autofail token, you get that like elite enemy at the wrong time and and sharing that experience with other people is just like a top tier like board game experience. So, um, I enjoy two-handed solo, like if I just want to play it. Um, but I think sharing this with like two or three other people is is great. Um, I will gripe. I I did one four-player campaign and I will never do another four-player campaign. I feel like that kind of bog down bogs down the game a little too much, but I think two or three is a sweet spot for me.

Do you think like spatially on the board it becomes too crowded?

No, it's more so you've Yeah. Going through the first scenario, I I think um or this first, you know, core campaign. I think they've balanced things better. Sometimes the the way that you know clues per investigator or damage per investigator balances sometimes at four player I feel like they get a little too wonky. like you need like, you know, sometimes like 16 clues or something. And in theory, it should work because everyone's kind of doing their own thing, pulling their weight, but I feel like in practice it just felt a little too uh a little too hard or or a little too wonky at four people.

I wonder if probability comes in with that bag, which actually I that's the whole reason I now I remember. That's why I wanted to I was showing the bag was because we were starting to talk a little bit about that random draw. Like do you think that that might be part of it? is it is kind of it seems like the bag is not in your favor. I don't know. I haven't done the math on it, but if you have more chances not in your favor from a probability perspective, you're probably more likely to to the go-to kind of idiom for for Arkham players, right? You only want to take a test that you're going to pass, right? Like you don't want to like just be pulling out of the bag willy-nilly. Um and just the more people you have, right, you're going to pull out of the bag more. you're going to get more of those um you know the symbols that have like direct negative effects if you pull them that are just always going to be bad. So yeah, I think that's also part of it is just like more more chances for bad things to happen with more people.

Right. Mark, do you play this much from a co-op perspective

or just with

So I've played it I've played it two, three, and four players as well as a ton solo. Um I am at the point now when I play it solo, I play it threehanded. Uh I am I I do have the benefit of having a table where I can leave it set up for days or even weeks at a time. Um so I don't necessarily need to get through a scenario in a single night. I can play it for an hour and walk away, come back and finish it the next night. But what I've found is um the game is notoriously difficult to play with one investigator like true solo uh because there are so many swings in not just luck from the bag but drawing those cards and what they're going to do with you and and whether you're even going to get your new fancy sledgehammer that you just bought. Whether you're going to pull it the entire game or whether it's going to be in your opening hand, there's so much randomness that with one character you can have a game where you fly through easy breezy, the next game you just get crushed. Two characters helps, especially when you can balance those two characters. Maybe one is better at dealing with enemies, another is better at finding clues. And then now if you're in a tricky situation, hopefully one of your people is better able to deal with that sort of randomness. Um, but what I've found over

time is that with more players or more investigators, uh, it seems to we, it seems to me to have it evens out some of that swinginess because you're pulling more stuff every round and you can better designate some things to a person who is ready to deal with it. Um, not always the case. And if you're playing with four people, that adds the element of, well, now you spend a lot of time conversing to try to think of how to best deal with it. Or people are just kind of going gung-ho and doing their thing and maybe making poor choices, but you're getting through it quickly. Um, I found with three characters playing solo, I have enough capability to deal with whatever comes up and sort of, you know, I can hand off that enemy to somebody else to shoot so I can deal with the clues or in the case of this um, the new campaign in the core box, I can have somebody who can put out fires, literally put out fires, so that the whole place isn't burning and there's nothing we can do. We're all going to die. Um, so I prefer I prefer playing it with multiple characters. Um, in terms of playing that way solo or with other players, I think it can be a very rich co-op game. If everybody is

able and willing to put in the time because it's not just the time playing the scenario, it's the time reading through the books and then the time leveling up your characters. And before that first game, it's the time of building your decks. if you're not just using the the pre-built list that comes with the game, which frankly is not good. You know, their pre-built characters are designed to show you a lot of cards, not give you an investigator who's ready to be successful.

Yeah. In our play, what stood out to me is there were rich strategic discussions that revolved around the cards in our hand, what our abilities were, like what we were set up to be able to handle. And it was more exciting than I had thought cuz typically a game like this I do to your point where it is so slow and methodical and and it it just it feels more comfortable to sit there by yourself and just kind of like go through it at your own pace or whatever it might be. But I felt like it was especially in in in the scenarios where you have to move around a lot. Um and we were trying to kind of kite these enemies into different areas and and oh you can take them and you can take that damage or that horror or whatever it might be. I found that actually to be way more rewarding than I had thought.

Um, and that's like non-withstanding like you know the the idea of whether a two-handed, three-handed, you know, true solo is best. Just actually playing with another person was exciting. We had some very exciting moments pulling from the bag. I felt like I pulled a lot of uh red uh the auto fail and then a few,

you know, what is it's not an auto win. What is that token called? This blue one

that Yeah, the the the elder sign the star there.

Yeah.

Yeah. You pulled that elder sign.

You pulled that elder sign more times in one game than I feel like I would pull it sometimes in a whole campaign. You had one game where you just were were you could do no wrong and it was amazing. Like you know you have those moments playing with a group.

Well, it's Arkham so. Yeah. But you have those moments playing some games where you want to stand up and cheer. Um, it's not Arkham, but I played in the one of these game groups that I host at my local maker space. We played Death May Die last weekend and we played a scenario where you have to actually flick things on the board. And I think you know what's you probably know what scenario I'm talking about. Yeah. Um, and the whole time I was like, "Oh my god." you know, we kept missing flicking these dice and I'm like, I've got a bunch of random people here and if we lose because of this, it's going to be this horrible time. And the first time somebody flicked that die and made it,

we stood up and cheered like it was it was this moment. And I feel like Arkham G because the stakes are so high because there is that auto fail but also that not auto success but like great token that triggers things. You can as a group really have cheer worthy moments because the story immerses you in what's happening. You feel like you have a stake in what's going to happen next.

And in true solo, do you actually or not even true solo in solo do you get those moments? I mean inside your head. I mean, every once in a while I'll be playing like Too Many Bones by myself and have this insane role and be like look around. Did anyone just see that? Like it there's no one to share it with. But yeah, Arkham has that those dramatic moments. Jared, do you cheer yourself on as you sit there and play?

I do. I do. I'm I'm a well-trained solo player, though, so I'm already always running that narration like in my head as I'm playing. So, Right.

I do.

Do you Do you all like the idea of a bag of tokens rather than some sort of dice system? Yeah, I am a I am an addict at bag, you know, any bag pulling game, just give it to me. I don't know why. It feels so much more exciting than flipping over a card or rolling a dice. Personally,

I rolling dice though is just like chucking dice. There is there is some dramatics there that just feels good.

It almost feels like you have a little more agency even though you have none whatsoever because you're actively throwing it here. I'm just like, "Oh, I feel like the fate is done here. I'm right now. I'm gonna I'm definitely going to pull the red." No, I didn't. Minus one. I probably would have passed. It's pretty good.

Yeah.

I Yeah. It's It's weird to think that a minus one is considered a good thing, right? Because often times minus is bad in Arkham. It's like, "Oh, minus one. That's fantastic.

Give me that minus four

or worse,

right?" Yeah. That's what I I noticed as I was looking through these tokens. I was like, I did not know they would go that high.

I think it's minus eight, maybe.

Yeah. I you know and it's interesting when you I I've listened to a lot of podcasts with of people who like this is their lifestyle game. They are experts. They can play at the expert difficulty and succeed. Um the difficulty on the game is is really it's even on easy it is not easy. And the bag does an interesting thing in a couple ways. One is that it can change throughout the campaign, which I think is the best part of the bag, where depending on choices you've made, different tokens wind their way into the bag, and by the end of the campaign, the the ratio of stuff that's going to happen for you is different from one play to the next based on your choices. Um, but also there is a degree of predictability that is hard with dice because, you know, you roll a six-sided die, it's one through six, even chance of each one. Um, but with the bag, you can say, well, there's only one plus one, but there's three minus ones. You know, you can look at how many there are. So it's not just a complete I mean it is random but the likelihood of certain things coming up are some things are going to come out more often than others. So you you have a little bit more of a way to predict what's likely to happen versus just a die roll.

I think tokens are the best way to screw somebody. It it's just one of the best ways you can possibly do it. Uh cuz to your point, yeah, you could really stack it against the player and even easy, not really easy, you know. I

I will say my true solo was significantly easier than our co-op first scenario. Um I think I must have gotten lucky or something. I don't know.

Well, and and I want to say one more thing about

Yeah.

Oh, go ahead.

No, have at it, Jared.

So, as far as the the bag goes, um you know, you know, as difficult as it is, I I do think that there's also you could kind of swing it the other way, right? if you want to add more positive tokens, but you're kind of that onboarding, right? Like I have no problem with hyper difficult games, but like I could see that being a turnoff for someone who's playing this for the first time and you're like getting kicked in the teeth and it's like, you know, maybe too far in that direction. But I do like I I do think that there's that little bit of like home ruling, home brewing that you can do of like adding another plus one or taking out bad tokens. Like that's not how I play, but I do like that the bag gives you that flexibility of like, okay, I want to adjust it one way or the other and and tailor it to how I want to experience Arkham. And Mark, you had an idea of a house interesting house rule.

So, I have a house rule I pull out every now and again when I am feeling particularly on edge. Um, sometimes if that red token comes out too many times, uh, it gets set aside and it stays out until it learns its lesson. And that happens when I pull the blue token. Then it's like, okay, you know, the bad one's been removed. I pulled the best token out of the bag. Now they'll both go in. And that actually um comes from I I'm a big fan of Gloom Haven. And Gloom Haven has a deck of cards and when you attack you know how much damage you're going to do and then you pull the modifier and it's like oh there's a lot of zeros, there's plus ones, minus ones, there's other stuff, but then there's like the double and then there's the fail. Um, but in Gloom Haven, those cards as you pull them from the deck, they stay out until you pull the double or the fail.

And then you shuffle everything back together at the end of the round. And so sometimes I feel like, you know what, that that fail token is causing me more distress than rationally it should. So I just need a minute where I know it's not going to come out. Now whether that is playing it correctly or not, you know, who's to say? Um, one of the things about

I'm sure uh one of the things about, you know, a cooperative game and especially a game in which you were not playing it, um, in any sort of, you know, official capacity, whereas you might, you know, with a competitive game going to a store playing Magic, for example, or whatever it is. Um because it's cooperative, like if you fudge the rules a little bit, but you enjoy it. Um does that break the game? Maybe. But sometimes, you know, depending on the evening and the the mindset, that little extra thing, seeing that token will not come out for four or five polls is enough to then get so when things go badly again, you're not ready to just give up. Anything else? We Go ahead. Go ahead, Jared.

Yeah. No. Yeah. Just the last point on difficulty. And I think just as we kind of talk about Arkham Horror the card game as a whole. Um I I think that's just one thing it like excels at, right? If you want to experience this game as the narrative kind of like roleplay your character, build like the most in character deck you want, right? You can tune down the difficulty and kind of experience it that way. But if you want to like crank up the difficulty, you know, build a hyper synergistic deck and like destroy the game, like you can also approach it from that way. So, I think it's just like one of those things where it just balances those two, you know, arms of how most people like try to, you know, enjoy games. I think it just does both those things real well.

But isn't the only fun way to break the game with those, you know, tons of of broken cards and combinations.

Well, that's why we have a current format now.

Ah, yeah. We'll get there.

Yeah.

Um, you have not seen Arkham broken. Uh, I can't speak to Jared's experience. I have broken Arkham by using some decks that I found online. My uh my deck creation is not super fantastic, but you can find decks that work so well together, especially once you've thrown 10, 15 XP into them, that it almost feels like you are unstoppable. And it is a very different experience. And one of the greatest things about the game, as Jared mentioned, is you have people coming into it who want the horror story and you have people coming into it who want the card play. And they're both drastically different.

They're both amazing. And you can tweak the game to make it way easier, way harder so that you can lean into that because building a really thematic character deck is not the best way to win the game. But sometimes you want, you know, your police officer with his trusty dog and his, you know, co- his uh partner at his side wielding shotguns and going nuts. And it's like you can build a deck that does that, but it may not on a mechanical level synergize. So if you then make the bag easier, you can have that experience the way you want to have it without it feeling like you're just going in to lose right from the start. I couldn't have drawn up a better segue to the next one. So we are here to talk about chapter 2 because somebody thought a fresh start was needed. It was 10 years of content, thousands of cards, new players completely overwhelmed. Um, the scenarios assumed this vast card pool.

Now, in my notes, I have February 2025. Is that true? Back in February 2025, they went into the legacy versus current environment pre-chapter 2.

I think that's when the official post went up for the the proposed formats that that we have now. Yeah.

Okay. So, so now in this new world there, to your point, there is no more broken environment if you play it the right way. So they're hopefully their their idea is to try to balance the game a little bit better and not have to deal with these probably a design nightmare dealing with these giant pools of cards. So for you all, did you find that there were barriers uh that actually kind of messed up your experience with these giant pools or um with the old kind of legacy environment system?

Uh I I I could take take it first, Mark. Um I mean personally for me, no. Um, so I'm not like a power deck builder. So like maybe it's more from the sense of like there's just so many options. And I mean this gets into another thing where I don't know um Mark if you use any like online like Arkham Cards, Arkham DB like these online resources to actually like manage and digest all the cards. I think that was the biggest hurdle is like there's so many options and so many cards that kind of fill the same niche where it almost feels inconsequential maybe like what card you're picking. Um and it gets a little diluted. So, I I wouldn't say it was like um I wasn't like breaking the game or anything, but sometimes it almost became a chore to go through that deck creation process where there's like hundreds of cards for that I could be taking at at a level zero deck and it's just like almost becomes a little bit of a chore. So at at certain points I was like self-restricting where um so for a while they were re-releasing the the campaigns and like these larger boxes that were all collected and I would sometimes just self-impose this restriction where I would only use like the collection that would have been available at the time and like you know I was already kind of self-imposing some like um card pool type stuff already.

So, um, personally, I'm not, you know, I think we're on the other side of the spectrum where now it's a very small card pool, but I I don't think there's anything necessarily wrong with, you know, trying to rein things back a little bit.

Mark, you feel the

um I, like I said before, not great at building decks. And it got to the point I don't have everything that's been released. I did not get the last two chapter 1 campaign and investigator sets, but I think I still have nine campaigns worth of content. Um, I stopped trying to build decks from just looking at my card pool and was exclusively using Arkham DB to find decks that looked fun and then pulling the cards. I just kept them all basically alphabetized by color um in a in some boxes um because the card pool did get if you weren't playing the game all the time, if this is not your lifestyle game, the card pool got to a point where it did feel impossible to feel like you've made good choices when, as Jared said, there are multiple things that kind of can fit in for the same role. or multiple cards that kind of do the same thing. Technically, one is probably better than the other, but if you can't remember all 400 of the orange cards you're going to pull from and which three are the best at this situation and then oh yeah, wait, no, your investigator also when they get to level two can for le can use level two um blue cards on top of their orange card. So, it's not just like, oh, I've got the orange cards to pull from. You also have all the blue cards and all the

neutral cards, and the next time you play an orange investigator, maybe you can pull from green and red cards. So, unless you know all of the cards in all of the colors, being able to make choices is so difficult because you're sorting through hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of cards. Starting with the smaller.

I was going to say, was the number 400 dramatic or was there really that many

cards in for one color?

I um I don't know the exact number, but I know that um if you count like not just the level zero cards, but the upgraded level cards, I mean, you have a giant stack in each color. Um, and when building decks, oftentimes you can't just look at the level zero cards and say, "This is the deck I'm gonna build, and then I'll upgrade it." Because so many of those leveled up cards don't have a level zero version that you can use at the start. So, you may say, "My strategy with this deck is going to revolve around this book, which allows me to trigger these other things." Well, you can't get that book without spending experience. So you have to know that that book is going to end up in your deck. So instead of just looking at half the cards which are level zero, you have to look at twice as many and look at the stuff you can't even use at the start in order to know that like eventually I want that. So I'm going to build something that synergizes around that thing and it just it becomes hard to deal with.

Jared, were you excited when you heard the announcement on current verse legacy? Did that like help like Will that free you up to enjoy deck building once again?

Yeah, I mean it's it's um I I think it's almost like enjoying like low-level like role playing games like it it's sometimes there's just something nice about the constriction and it kind of like forces you

to like man it's hard because like I don't want to make it sound like it was a negative thing about all the options and deck building, right? Like that was such a such a fun part of the game of like building this character out and doing these cool things. Um, but sometimes like being a little more constrained sometimes just frees you up a little bit where like I feel like from the beginning I'm able to plan like my my max XP deck from the beginning. Um, and I think this is another thing we we'll touch on with the general shorter campaign structure that they're going for. I think it's going to be a lot easier to do it over, you know, a three or five scenario um, campaign to like kind of have a vision of what that deck's going to look like at the end of that. So, I wonder if that's also going to make things a little easier maybe. Do you guys think this is going to free the designers up to, I don't know, create more interesting cards that they don't have to worry about having to deal with in a legacy system?

I think

I mean, I think we're at it.

What we saw with uh chapter 1 was there were a number of cards that they later put on their I think it's called the taboo list where they realized the card was too strong or broke the system in some way. I think there's only one card that they've outright banned because they realized just how far it could be taken. Um, but you know, there's a decade of design work and a decade worth of this card pool that they had to balance around. Now, starting from scratch, having that experience, being able to hopefully better understand how some of these interactions can be taken advantage of. Uh, I think this smaller card pool potentially will lead to a smoother experience um from the get-go and less chance of stumbling into broken combinations.

Yeah. And with Marvel Champions, I never deck built. I went to the Marvel DB and and picked the coolest sounding, you know, deck that somebody named some sort of really cool name and and I would put it together. And that actually led me to have to buy the Hulk deck and the Thor deck and all these others because they were the only ones that had those specific cards. I personally really love the idea and it gets me excited about following this game way more so that they're making a commitment to this true, you know, rotation just like you'd have in some sort of, you know, collectible card game because I won't be overwhelmed. I'm not the type of person. I don't know. I might be the type of person, but I do this YouTube thing, so I don't have enough time. Um, I I'll say I don't have enough time to sit there and know every card and and be able to look at that giant stack of cards. But when I was just spending my 6XP on, I don't know, I had like 10 cards I can spend it on or something. But it was exciting. It was exciting to look into, oh, what can that happen? Let me go look back through my deck. What does this do with the synergize? Can I remove that card now? I didn't really, you know, it didn't it didn't really work out for me last time when I played it. So, you know, I think that's like an interesting part of the game that sometimes gets lost with these pre-built decks that are on the websites that people kind of minmax. Um, not everyone likes that, but for me it's exciting. Do you think Jared you'll go away from these pre-built or not pre-built like you know these the internet decks on Arkham?

Yeah, actually I I've actually never I've not really I don't really like Net Deck for Arkham actually. I think I almost always uh kind of try to build it from scratch. Um and honestly the only way I'm able to do it and if anyone is getting into Arkham Arkham Cards is like my favorite app for managing cards. And it's almost like oh like instead of like scrolling on my phone I'll just like scroll through Arkham Cards and like build decks. Like in that app I have like a dozen decks of just like little things I've thrown together. Um and that's just like the personal way I I I approach it. Um, but yeah, no, no, no shame to, you know, Arkham Dvex are awesome.

So, let's pivot now to the actual core set. So, this is it's the new evergreen entry point. You have to have this thing to play going forward, right? Like there's no ifands or buts. If you're a veteran, you both have it. You're veterans that that went ahead and and got it. So, you you bit on that. Um, in the box, there's what, three scenarios, two I think it's 224 player cards. Um, you get the chaos bag tokens, all of that stuff to kind of get going out of the gates. Brethren of Ash is the three scenario campaign. Um, uh, I Mark, you've played it a couple times now.

Yeah, I played it, we played it once together,

um, and had a not, uh, super smooth run of it. Um, I I have then played through it a second time adding in cards from the standalone investigator decks that they also have released. Um, which greatly changes the card pool because the core game, the card pool that comes with comes with is very much like for the most part feels to me here are kind of utility cards you're going to always want to have as an option for whichever characters you're playing. Um, you know, one of the benefits of a larger card pool is you can then pull in cards that by themselves are more interesting or more specialized that you wouldn't want to use with every investigator because with some combinations they just won't help.

Um, my second run through the campaign with a bigger card pool was a whole different experience. It felt much less less random and less punishing because of the the deck creation part.

Right. And Jared, you have you gone through the full campaign yet?

Yeah, I've gone through it. I I went through it twice. So, I wanted just to get a feel for most of the investigator. So, the first time I just did straight core box and the second run I actually did so current the current format I think is the most two recent sets. So the the set technically previous from this one is Drown City, which is like the last chapter one set. So I used Drown City cards and this core set. So I did kind of open it up that that card pool a little bit. Um it wasn't super helpful cuz you know this kind of speaks to to why we have this chapter 2, but a lot of those Drown City cards are real kind of like specific niche into like existing archetypes that were already in Arkham. So like slapping them into a core set that doesn't have those other missing pieces like they weren't actually like terribly useful to be totally honest. Um but yeah, no suffice to say I went through it twice.

Yeah. So it comes with five investigators in the in the box. Joe Diamond, Trish Scarboro, Daniela Reyes, Dexter Drake, and Isabelle Barnes. I think these are all old investigators, right? Just with new stat lines and some I believe new abilities as well, but I I honestly um don't know. Do any of those stand out to it to to you or did they all feel pretty vanilla from your experience with those those core uh five out of the box?

So I I think this is a standout for me for this core set where I think all five of these investigators are like like top tier investigators. Like I feel like, you know, one thing that you've seen uh I think I'm going to say this a lot as we talk kind of about this new core set is like the refinement of these cards and these classes that they've had 10 years to do and it feels like all of these core set investigators have a very clear identity of what they can do. And I think they they all have the potential like as this chapter 2 card pool grows, I I feel like these core set investigators aren't going to lose their space. Like I feel like they all serve a purpose and I think they're going to be very fun to kind of keep building as this card pool expands. But I think all five of them are are really solid.

Mark, you you dipped your toe into the pool into the extra investigators, but just for this core box, like what did what do you think about them?

So, I haven't played all of the investigators in the core box, but I will say I I agree with Jared. like I think what they gave you is really not um something you're going to abandon once you have some experience. Coming back to those characters is absolutely going to feel um like a good choice when the card pool expands. And one of the interesting things about Arkham in general is that the investigators give you very specific deck building requirements. Usually it's one or two colors you can pull from with a certain sort of level range in each of those colors. Um, a couple of signature cards and then a signature ability or two. Um, so the actual like in terms of the all the different mechanics in the game, what they do is not so limiting where you have to play an investigator one specific way. Um, but usually they give you ways to kind of take advantage of combinations of cards within a deck. And so I think they're all positioned pretty well for when as the card pool expands to find more stuff to bring in to lean into their specialties a little harder.

Um, none of the abilities seem like things where once you had more cards, you would just ignore them because now they seem underpowered. And one of the the reasons for this chapter two is because those combinations of cards were getting out of control and you were getting these way overpowered decks. You know, you could and it wasn't necessarily because of a specific investigator, but when the card pool got so big, you could build decks that were just trouncing the game. And so the complexity of the campaigns got bigger and more complex and more new mechanics to try to work within that. And so this starting over is a great point for saying the campaigns don't need to be overly complex to fight back against these overly optimized um sort of gamebreaking decks. One of my initial disappointments with the game was the investigators. I was under the assumption they'd be the same uh kind of structure as Marvel Champions where the the personalities in the cards and in Marvel Champions you get a set of I can't even remember 10 maybe 15 cards or something like that. It might be variable um but it that is your character and then you can kind of like add in to to kind of complement all of those. So I I was a little bit worried about the lack of personality after seeing that and I didn't know that till I was at your house Mark. I was like, "Oh, like these you could just put any card you want in here." And I thought,

"But in retrospect, in looking at like the the deck building requirements that you have, I think that is more of a feature than a bug." Have you both played Marvel Champions? So, Mark, do you like the this system over Marvel Champions where it's it really lets the player build whatever they want? Well, I think the the one of the big differences for me, Marvel Champions feels super fun to play a game of because by the end of your scenario of your fighting the Ultron or whatever you're doing, you've done hopefully everything your character is supposed to do. You know, if you're Iron Man, you've built out your armor and you've, you know, you're flying around and shooting things with your repulsor beams or whatever. uh you know like your card your deck your deck has a lot of specific cards but you're it's designed to get them almost all out in one game and in Arkham yeah you only have a couple of character specific cards uh but the makeup of what you're allowed to build your deck with the requirements for certain levels and color cards means that even if you're playing the same class of investigator a different investigator will actually feel different because their secondary card pool is going to come from a different color. Um, and then additionally, Arkham is difficult and

you don't have a lot of wiggle room in terms of, you know, you're not going to just easy breezy go through a scenario. And so small changes in your card pool make a big difference. So, you don't have the same level of custom cards for each investigator, but each one definitely feels different. And especially once you start leveling them up, each one feels very distinctly different. In the last revised corset, were there also five investigators?

Yeah, this new core set mirrors the previous revised core set pretty strongly. There are a few differences in the tokens, like it comes with the location arrows, which is really nice. Um, and there are a couple other minor differences there, but in terms of the structure of the campaign, uh, the amount of cards and the card pool, uh, it it feels very much like they just kind of said, well, if we had to start over again, what how could we do it differently but make it feel kind of the same? And uh you know even the structure of the campaign has three scenarios where the first one kind of gives you a lot of handouts and helps you get through it. The second scenario feels very much like a traditional Arkham horror card game scenario and then the third scenario just punches you in the face and says haha, you know. So the that was the case with the original core and that's still the case with this one.

Do you uh do you feel like for a new player that these five investigators are interesting enough in and of themselves without kind of going into a different card pool?

Yeah. And and um I I'll shout out one specifically um get too into the weeds here. So Isabella Barnes is um so there's five classes. One of them is survivor. That's always kind of like the the wild card class. Like doesn't really have the clear like you know guardian is like fight. You know the uh the seekers are very clue driven. Survivors are like the weird kind of wild card. Um, and she has this ability to like um take cards from your discard and put them back or skill cards from your discard and put them back in your hand. And like having an investigator that's able to like recur cards is like so incredibly like she's my most exciting one. Like I could see as skill cards and the card pool grows like she's going to be such a cool evergreen. That's the wrong word to use because evergreen is an actual term used to describe like this the content. But um she's really cool. But like then you also have like uh Trish, right? The rogue where like she gets like one free evade action. Like that's a cleancut, very easy to understand ability. You know, you get a free action, very easy to understand. So I feel like they really struck a good balance of having investigators that are going to um reward more advanced play, but also having ones that I think new players can approach and it's not like a wall of text that I'm trying to interpret. So I think they struck a really nice balance there. I will say one thing as a as a returning player that is is weird. So, so Isabelle is actually a new investigator. Um, but the other four are are kind of um, you know, reskins of of chapter one investigators, and I would say most of them have kind of like simplified abilities. So, it is I don't know, it's a little weird to see some of them um, come back and be kind of like a

a little step down, I think, from their

because you remember them as more basic. You're like, that's their personality. Yeah.

You're like, how did you get so cool all of a sudden?

Yeah. Joe Diamond in particular is one of my favorite chapter one investigators where he has like a little side deck of of hunches and you're able to draw from this side deck at certain points and he's like it's so cool investigator. You have like a little side deck of stuff and in this one I'm not I forgetting what his ability is. I think it's like something pretty basic like it's like an extra clue or something like that. Um so yeah, it was just like a little weird. Um again, not like taking away from them, but it's it's kind of funny to see him simplified.

Yeah, I played Joe Diamond. I actually really like playing him, but he was basic. I think he's the one that uh that is recommended if you're first starting out.

I think what's interesting about Arkham in particular is assuming they continue with what they were doing previous where every campaign also comes with uh uh new investigator cards. Initially it was all mixed into this kind of like monthly small release. um with their revised core set, they changed it to there's a big campaign box and a big investigator box that has five investigators and a bunch of cards. Um you know, every time you get one of these new card pools, you have these new investigators. And oftent times in the past, they would lean into kind of a new mechanic or a new way of thinking. One set had kind of blesses and curses as like the new mechanic. one set had tarot cards as this new mechanic. Um, so it's it will be interesting to see if they continue with that. But in the previous wave of things, it was really nice to get a new set of investigators that leans into this new kind of mechanic that the new card pool gives you a lot of and then go back to the old ones and say, "Well, now that we have this new mechanic, this kind of changes some of those interactions and this old ability can actually take advantage of that and breathe some new life into them." Um, I have yet to find more than one or two investigators in the dozens and dozens that I've played where after playing through them once, I was like, you know, that's fine. I don't ever need to come

back to them again.

And Joe Diamond, after you successfully investigate, you draw a card. And now that that that now I remember it. I had tons of cards in hand. It was kind of silly, which is nice. I love card draw. It's so good. I remember telling you very distinctly, oh, it says at the end of the round you have to discard down if you have eight or more cards, but that almost never really happens. And I had to discard like four four different times.

Four.

Yeah.

Well, I'm also probably an inefficient player, so I probably should have been using those cards for skill tests and and and all of that fun stuff. All right, so let's talk a little bit about the campaign, Brethren of Ash. um what you start in your friend's room and I don't want to spoil too much. I guess I I guess maybe this is the time to kind of spoil it, right? Like we have to kind of get into the nitty-gritty a little bit specifically. Mark, you and I had a situation uh that you know it would have been nice to know in hindsight. Um I believe in the very first scenario, but basically you start off in your friend's room. Uh, there are fires that are breaking out, hooded figures running around, your friend is gone, and you need to figure out where your friend is. That I don't know how else would you explain without fully explaining the rest of it. I guess I'm not pretty good at the semi-spoiler. So, so Arkham does this very interesting thing in which because the map is not fixed when you set up the game. Um, you're allowed to have a story where you don't know what's going to happen next. And they really take advantage of that because the first scenario starts with one location. You are in a room and you're trying to figure out where your friend is. And that's kind of what you've been given.

And then within the cards as you play, the story unfolds. And I will say that uh one thing in this first scenario um there is they give you a hint that a way to deal with something and as an experienced Arkham player. I interpreted it as one thing and we put a lot of effort into trying to deal with that situation. I don't want to give spoilers.

We really did. We put a lot of

We probably change our game the rest of the time.

We depleted about half of our health and our resources are everything trying to deal with it in a way that made sense based on the rules and how you would interpret that the hint only to find out that none of that mattered. And it was a little disappointing. Well, more than a little disappointing to me because I felt like it was one of those things where um if you're trying to play optimally, you got punished for it if you weren't able to uh instantly deal with the problem. Um but if you were more willy-nilly about it, then the punishment wasn't really that bad because they said, "Oh, never mind." Um, and there were a couple things in this new campaign that I feel like maybe as a design choice, they tried to, you know, give you uh ways to get out of bad situations that felt good versus rewarding smart play. It did in in the second playthrough. Did I am seeing those more forgiving points that I didn't see the first time. It does seem like and there are some hints I think in that first scenario we missed a hint uh in particular that we probably should have taken literally. Um did you have any any problems at all Jared or did you breeze right through that first scenario?

No, I I I I think I I think I chickenened out pretty early which is maybe why I didn't have as many problems.

Um but I I just want to say one thing that I I liked about this first scenario. Um, so, and I I'll compare it a little bit to um, so the original core set had had Night of the Zealot as the kind of um,

core campaign. In a lot of ways, this almost feels like a cover song, I think, of of Night of the Zealot where it kind of has like the same notes and the same beats, kind of just a different sound to it all. Um, but I absolutely love the uh, setting for this first scenario. um being Mscatonic University, which is like a pretty big, you know, like key uh landmark in in the Arkham, you know, mythos lore and stuff. Um you know, the first Night of the Zealot is just like you're like in a house and you go to a basement in an attic and like a living room and it's very small. It's like very cramped. Like it has it has a certain charm to it, but I like that this one if you were just playing this game for the first time. I love that you're kind of, you know, let loose in this university campus and there's like cool different locations. I do think it makes a very good first impression. Um, you know, I think flavor-wise as a scenario,

does it feel more grand than Night of the Zealot, like more grandiose or or or like the stakes are higher because it it it's not in one little space. It's you're running all over Arkham essentially.

Yeah. Well, I I will say the second and third feel a little more in line with Night of the Zelda. It's really this first one that I felt the the kind of different of of where it's set. And, you know, you're always trying to stop the the world from ending in in Arkham one way or the other. So, um I think I think the stakes are still there. Um but I do think I I like the story a bit more in in this revi in the in this chapter 2 core set.

The big difference that at least in feel to me and I could be absolutely wrong here because it's been a long time since I've played it. So, I've played the original uh Knight of the Zealot, you know, several times. they came out with these return to boxes which gave you alternate cards to flesh out the scenarios and that's the only way I've played that campaign since then. So, it's been a long time since I've played the original campaign in the original format. But in uh the chapter one, that first scenario, I feel like at least I remember it feeling much easier overall. In this one, the encounter deck in particular, the mythos deck, um, feels a lot tougher, but then they give you ways to get out of problems and it gives it a different level because the original game, I remember that first scenario feeling a little tame. It never really felt like, oh my god, we're in so much trouble. This one, it puts you in so much trouble,

right? But then it's like, okay, you've but you got out of it and you have a breather before it comes back.

So, and this is a definitely a spoiler alert, so go forward a few minutes. But it does Arkham Horror make it a habit of making things just disappear. Like you you hit you hit a checkpoint and then it's like, "Oh yeah, discard everything. You're all good. This thing's not even a problem anymore." Like that that to me is like it's like trying to manufacture the tension, but then it's like, "Hey, you're a new player. This is the first scenario. Relax. We got you. As long as you don't sit there and try to fight it.

Yeah. And and and since we we're getting into spoiler territory.

Yeah. More spoilers.

You know that.

I'll I'll mark the spoiler in the time stamp. So, have at it.

Yeah. Um I I cannot remember another scenario in chapter one where they put you against something so deadly that you're not at all ready for. because this happens very early on in that first scenario. Um, but then just make it go away. Now, that's not to say that I mean there's a lot of scenarios at this point between all the campaigns. So, maybe they have done that once or twice for dramatic effect, but the the hard part for us in our campaign is I saw that thing and it gave you the hint that you should not just try to kill it because

it might be good if you run. So I was like, "Okay, well in Arkham the way you do that is you evade. There's a whole mechanism around being able to get past enemies without them following you."

And that red token screwed that up for us. So then we spent a couple turns. That's true.

Trying to manipulate that because it's like, "Okay, now well now I'm stuck in the room with it. So now the next turn we have to evade again." But we don't have the cards to do that successfully.

Stunk cost fallacy there. We we shouldn't have stayed around.

Normally, at least from my memory, when Arkham deals you something bad, um you're it's either at a time where you should be ready to deal with it, or you have some good ways to either avoid it, get around it. Um it is rare that you're given something so bad with so little time to prepare,

right? That did feel odd out of the gates. Did you sus that out pretty easily, Jared? You're like, "Yeah, this is just like because I had no reference whatsoever." I was like, "Oh, is this what we got to do? I can only do one damage at a time. No way."

Yeah. I I think um so the the first chapter of the Night of the Zealot has kind of a similar like I don't know boss enemy like the ghoul priest. It's so like it's funny, right? I I think a lot of a little veteran talk I guess like if if you've been playing the game you know for many years like Night of the Zealot is kind of like it's like a a touchstone in the Arkham community like a lot of the cards and and a lot of the encounter cards and the characters in it. Um so I I think um what is it called? The servant of Ash, right? That's I think that's what the the enemy is that that kind of pops out.

Whatever his name is the the scary cultist guy. Um, oh

yeah, I think I think I kind of got the hint and I I and it helped that I was playing Trish in one of those where I kind of got a little wiggle room. Um, you know, she has a high foot, she's easier to evade, so I think I was able to to kind of hightail it out of there. So, um, yeah, I guess the the the chaos bag was just kind to me when I was dealing with that. So, it wasn't too big an issue. So, in Smok and Mirrors, you're now running around the city essentially. What? You're you're you're trying to I I guess you have the option of both investigating or fighting, which I think they're all elite enemies essentially, and you have to like um get all get six elite enemies uh in your player display. Was there anything memorable there? I know I I had already referenced kind of us trying to kite around the enemies and and manipulate where they're going to go, but did that uh scenario like hit anything for either of you? Mark, why don't you have at it first? Well, I uh as as Jared mentioned, you know, this mirrors the initial Knight of the Zealot uh campaign a lot.

This felt very similar to the second campaign there. And what I found interesting is it it did give you very clear choice with these guys. Like you can fight everything or you can kind of go through the steps to sort of parlay with them and talk to them and that's might take longer but there's going to give you a different outcome. And I really like how it didn't just come down to a you know you need to fight all the bad guys. you can absolutely I mean there are monsters you will have to deal with but when it comes to these interesting characters um you can absolutely choose to like you know talk to them and try to sus out what's going on and there might be some benefits there and the game state at the end is different if you do that versus just punching them

any thoughts from you u Jared on that second scenario

no I so I I mean I think um you know uh smoke and ash and and you know the the previous version of it. Like I think like like this is like one of my favorite like Arkham scenarios. Like it's such a core like it's such a good like um condensation of like what makes Arkham so fun where like again like like Mark kind of mentioned like you can approach this kill all the enemies or you can kind of do these like little side you know mini quests where you're trying to to win over these different um suspects that you're talking to. Um no I think it's just a standout. I think this is my favorite of of the three um pretty easily. So, no, it's just awesome and and you get to see a lot of those cool landmarks in Arkham, too. I think that the map's really nice. Um, it has a nice feeling of of running around the city and that like frenetic energy of trying to get around and talking to all these people.

And Queen of Ash is the third scenario and it's I did some research and it seems like people didn't love it. Like, it's near impossible. Does that uh mirror uh Night of the Zealot?

Yes, it does. Um, and and am I allowed to spoil a 10-year-old um scenario?

This is like spoiler, don't go here.

Not it's not just 10 years old. It's now impossible. Well, I guess it's not as impossible to get, but will soon be very difficult to actually play. So,

yeah. So, so the end of of that um chapter one, like you have a great old one similar to the the the Queen of Ash that's like this impossible enemy that you're essentially never going to be able to kill once you're playing perfectly. Um, but it had this really cool moment where you could like sacrifice this companion that you had in the story and like feed her to this great old one and that would like satiate it and that would be like and and you know that's mirrored a little bit in this one where you're able to like pull the sewer lever and like flood the whole thing. Um,

but be having to sacrifice this person you traveled like the last two scenarios with hits a little harder than like letting like a bunch of sewer water to drown everyone. Um, so I don't know. I I think it hits a little softer than I I think the the Ummer doth uh one from chapter 1. I just like that one a little bit more. And then the sewer setting didn't hit as hard. Um it was still a good last scenario, but um yeah, I liked it a little less than the the chapter one counterpart.

Well, it seemed like to get that secondary positive ending, right, where getting into the room was significantly easier than it's it just seemed like it was just like such a no-brainer. Mark, you and I got to that point and like the the road we were to take and I can't remember how that's revealed to you, but it's revealed as you play in, right? Like you don't know that you need to get into that room right out of the gates. I think you actually have to go to discover a location or something. Uh I can't quite

Yeah, it's it is something you discover and then it kind of gives you an alternate endgame condition you didn't know would be there. And in some senses it's great because it gives you a way to quote unquote win that doesn't feel impossible.

Mhm.

But um I think you know it's it it is great that it is there. It makes the idea that actually def, you know, winning in another way, it makes it almost feel more impossible because they've given you this solution that you can take and it's it's not necessarily the easiest thing to get to that position, but it's not terribly difficult to get that ending. No.

Um, versus defeating the ultimate evil

is crazy hard,

right? Did anyone do that or even attempt that in any of their plays?

I attempted it my second time through

and my the luck of the draw early on in that scenario was bad.

Um

it absolutely if I did not need the table for something else the next day, I absolutely would have just restarted and tried again. And it seems like it would have maybe been possible. Now granted, this was using uh a lot of the cards from the new investigator sets, not just the core game card pool. From the core game card pool, I would find it very difficult to imagine anyone actually winning that way. Not impossible, but I would uh a new player I can't imagine happening.

Yeah, the Reddit criticism was it was like a near impossible final scenario. And I I think to your point, Jared, it was impersonal. That was a that was you know some terms used there where it didn't feel like you're feeding a buddy to a beast. There was not that emotional uh you know pull whatsoever. Um but you know I do remember having kind of a sele a a collective like okay well at least we have that because we went into the scenario just knowing you even said you're like yeah we're probably only gonna get a few turns in here and then we're we're done. which kind of sucks going into scenario knowing that you're so far behind and the decision to go for that secondary ending was really probably made in the first scenario because we got ourselves so far behind.

Is that um second scenario option typical or is this just like a beginner's core set issue or feature? Do you mean like um alternate like ending or kind of

you're alternate out so you can say that you like had a had a you didn't die and you had some form of positive ending.

Yeah. Well, yeah. I think usually I think that's part of the kind of emergent narrative type thing where usually there is you know a couple you know at least like two different resolutions that you know give you a better result than the other. Um, but they do typically like to give you, you know, some options in how you resolve, you know, scenarios that's other than just like dying flat out.

So,

I will say that in Gohead

in some of the other in the older longer campaigns, I don't remember often you be giving kind of an easy way out. You're usually given the hard way out and the harder way out. Um, so the this core scenario, that sort of easy way out did feel not in the spirit of what it normally would be um, in a longer scenario or longer campaign. You keep segueing, you know, perfectly for me because I want to I want to move to the road map and what the future is here and and you know, so basically there's going to be two product lanes. It's an evergreen core set, plus starter decks, always in print. Um, rotating expansions, alternating small campaigns and scenario packs. In August, we get Children of Blood. It's our first, it's a small campaign, but I think it's typical now, right? The three scenarios. Um, I don't think there's longer campaigns any longer. And then there's, which I was confused at. I I don't know if there's there's been these in the past. In fall, we get traces to nowhere, which is a scenario pack. Is it slottable into other large campaigns or do you just play that individually? I wasn't sure what that actually meant on the road map. Anyone else more educated on that than me?

So my my understanding is that the two campaign lengths that they've kind of mentioned are either three or five. I think that's the two lengths we're getting. Like five will be the longer one.

Um and then standalone scenarios have been coming out yearly like for for quite a while at this point. And I think that, you know, I don't we we haven't seen rules for what the new campaigns are going to look like, but there were kind of rules for like if you wanted to slot in these standalone campaigns into your you were able to do that. But I'm curious with the shorter format how they're going to approach those, you know, plugging in standalone potentially.

Yeah. How's everyone's feeling about that shorter format and what was the longest number of of um scenarios before? So, my personal preference, I love the long long eight game campaigns. Um, because it feels like you've got enough time to tell a big story. You've got enough time to level up your investigators. There's a lot of work that goes into setting up the game. The first scenario, building your investigators, getting ready to go. Personally, uh, three scenarios seems far too short for the experience I want. I could imagine five scenarios feeling good, but a lot of it a lot of it is really going to come down to the writing and the decisions that are made. Um, because the I will say with the original Arkham and what is proving to be true now, the original Arkham, if I were to give a rating to just the core set, I'd say it's a six. like it was fun to play through, but I wouldn't keep it if that's all it was. But with the campaigns opening it up and the new investigator cards giving you this mechanical options, for me it becomes like a 9.5 to a 10. Like, I love it. So, a short campaign where you don't get to level up that much could still be well written. It could still be fun. I know for some people where the length is a problem, it opens up this as a you know something doable for them. Um but for me

the short especially three length campaigns is definitely seems like it's a negative.

Do you think they'll be giving more XP per? Because it does seem like leveling up twice is it's almost like why is it there? But I get six XP on the f on my first scenario, which was significantly better than I think the two, right? That was a huge upgrade to my deck.

Yeah.

Yeah. I guess Yeah.

Yeah. So, um I think I'm pretty much on board with Mark. I feel like three is is pretty short. Um you know, I think it's hard to build a I think like a satisfying arc to your deck maybe over over three scenarios. I think five might be a sweet spot. Um, and yeah, you know, there's there's a fine line like um some of the early um campaigns from Arkham like you would get like one or two experience in like a scenario and like that was just kind of like the common thing that you know that was just kind of where the game was at that point. So I I think there's definitely space to have shorter more compact campaigns, but how do you not lose that story you're telling with these characters? because like there's other like almost like not directly connected to to deck building but like the trauma you get from like certain scenarios, right? And like you kind of build this whole story with these characters and I just I I I fear will will it lose some of that identity from that part of the game with some of the shorter um campaigns.

And do we think that the two to three releases per year and I don't know what it was before, but is that too slow?

That seems to be pretty with what it used to be.

Okay. But you just got more scenarios per campaign.

Yeah. The the original release model was they put out a deluxe box which had two scenarios in it, the first two of a campaign. And then every month you'd buy a little pack for $15 that had investigator cards and the next scenario. So they were kind of drip feeding you the campaign over time. With the revised core, they switched to full campaigns being released all at the same time. And that when they did that then it was the equivalent of that drip feeding but just all given to you at once. So a new campaign every nine months or so with then a standalone in between and maybe some investigators or some other content sprinkled within. So a few releases per year.

Anything else you all want to uh kind of discuss around the road map and the future of the game that we didn't hit on? Yeah, I think what's what's interesting is so I think from from what I understand there's going to be three kind of type of you know Arkham Horror products coming out. There's going to be the um campaign expansion like the the children of blood that we're going to get um you know this summer. There's going to be I think they call them deck builder expansions which are just going to be like a flood of player cards and then I think they call them like investigator expansions where you're going to get new player cards less of them but you're going to get new investigators. So, I'm curious to see how they're going to the cadence of like those three different types of products. And I feel like in a in a way they're they're catering, you know, earlier in the video, we talked about how Arkham can be approached from, you know, more of a narrative uh storytelling perspective where you can be a hardcore uh deck builder. So, I think it's interesting that they're breaking off these products where like if you just want to deck build, you could just buy all the deck building stuff and just like keep collecting that. if you want to be the the storyteller, you can maybe keep a leaner deck pool and just invest in the story thing. So, I think it's interesting that they're kind of um breaking down these products into these um kind of three three separate lanes almost.

Yeah, I love that you said that because I was wondering are do you think they're they're catering more towards the hardcore player or the casual player and it kind of seems like both.

Well, I think one interesting thing about Arkham is it's difficult to be a casual player in this game. Um because you can buy just the core set and I feel like it's kind of a mediocre experience. It's fine. It's fun to go through once, but I couldn't imagine going through it over and over and over again. Um but as soon as you throw down a couple hundred dollars and get a couple campaigns and a couple boxes of investigator cards, it just flourishes. And so I think one of the problems with Arkham has been new players feel like it's there's no good solution. There's no good way to get into it and chapter 2 is giving them that. You know, here's a standalone point. You can start here, ignore everything else. So like that's fantastic. Shorter campaigns mean you don't have to give it the same time commitment. So, they're doing a lot of things which really definitely um they're conscious of the fact that they want to bring new people into this. Um, as somebody who's experienced and who loves to be able to just kind of lean into a campaign and watch that story unfold, I don't know that I'm excited about this way of doing things. Not to say they shouldn't. Not to say that the uh old format was better. It fits what I wanted more. Um, I do appreciate the idea that starting with a fresh card pool means you don't have to worry about

all this broken combinations or making the campaigns overly difficult to account for that. So, it opens up a lot of good potential design space, which could be exciting. Um, but I'm cautiously optimistic about what is upcoming.

Is anyone surprised that their in new entry point is so expensive? I mean, I think it's retail is 79 bucks. If you go to your FLGS, you have to spend 70 bucks for this corset. It doesn't seem like you're getting 70 bucks worth of content. Am I Am I off there? I know you're building to the future, but it's like it doesn't make sense to me to pay that much unless you're planning on making this your game and you're going to continue to buy. It's like you're investing in the future. You're not just like trying a starting point.

Yeah. I mean it, you know, and this is a greater conversation of like how how much how do you value how many times you play a game before it, you know, it's it's quote unquote worth it.

Yeah.

Um but yeah, you know, Mark has mentioned it. I mean, you can only play um you know, Brethren of Ash so many times before it's going to get a little stale and there is good variability in it, but still it's going to get stale. Um you know, you're almost paying for the fact of having the the core encounter cards and the the the tokens and everything. you're kind of just getting like all the pieces you need like you said to play this this bigger game. Um I I think it's worth man it is really a game where like it's almost like you want a friend that owns a boat sort of thing where you want kind of one person that to have like the Arkham collection and then you could just get one of the starter decks or you can just get the player cards and you don't have to go like whole hog into everything that's Arkham. Um

but you know that's not really a good solution for for everyone to have a game.

Yeah, it's like not the nature of that game, right? It it is it's tricky because it's it is built to go allin on it. Like I I I would not be

uh particularly happy with my purchase if I didn't think that this was going to continue into the future, which just locks me up to, you know, I'll probably spend hundreds if not over $1,000 in the end if I wanted to kind of keep up with this. Um, do you all have enough already or is there like enough here where you're excited about the future? Because you have tons of content like why keep going or is it just like the freshness is part of the allure?

I mean I I think one thing that that got me excited for after playing this core set. So like you know the story it's you know pretty much just Night of the Zealot again. But I want to say a couple things that I it kind of like caught my my eye and it kind of speaks to the maturity of the design of this game after 10 years. Um, you know, it's just it's small things like um from that second scenario where you have the the codec system where it has like the little read passage one for this card and that was introduced in the second to last campaign for chapter one, right? And they kind of pulled that out like that's a good system. Like now they can reuse those codeex cards, right? Because like it's not tied to any specific scenario, right? you can kind of repurpose those characters into other stories, which is really cool. Um, the design of the encounter decks for this, I think, is a lot better than than chapter one. Um, where where um I think we mentioned it at some point, but like a lot of these encounter cards aren't like the worst thing that could ever happen to you, but they they work well with the other encounter cards where like they start to weaken you and they kind of like start to dogpile you a little bit. Um, versus chapter one where it was like here's an encounter card, it's going to do three points of health damage. like it wasn't like necessarily the most exciting thing to to deal with.

And I feel like you could see the the maturity and how well they are at at designing these enemies and these encounter cards. And and personally that that what that's what gets me excited. Like despite having all this old content, I feel like the new content isn't just like rehashing old stuff, right? They they're using what was kind of learned in all this chapter 1 development into new stuff, which is kind of what keeps me engaged and excited to see what they're going to do next. You had mentioned the investigators being more interesting than in the first kind of goaround. Do you think that's part of it? They're like have learned lessons or at least some of them are more interesting and you're excited about the future of those five particular investigators you get in the core box.

Yeah. And and I mean I I will I will use one example. So the the rogue investigator in the original core deck is like notoriously just like an awful character. And Rogue as a whole was just like awful in the OG core set. Um but again, they they're all very cool. Um, and I think that might be my my one rule break of um, legacy camp current campaign stuff is like I wonder if I will just pluck out investigators because to me those are like my favorite things. Like that's your core identity of of the deck, right? That ability, that character that you're playing as. Um, so I I think that I I still may pluck out chapter one investigators and I I don't think it'll break anything too too awfully yet. Yeah, you you had mentioned imagining spending hundreds or even a thousand dollars on the game. Um I I don't own everything released. I didn't get the last two uh campaigns and investigator boxes because I felt like I had enough.

I felt like for as often as I played it, uh I had enough to come back to just I could play through all of the old campaigns. I think I have nine campaigns. By the time I play through all of those, if I play it a few times a year, you know, then I will have forgotten enough of the details to come back and replay them. Um, had it not been for chapter 2 and the possibility of things being different moving forward, I probably wouldn't buy any more into the game because I did feel like I had enough. And I think if in this new wave, if their first campaign does not knock it out of the park, then I probably will say, "No, I've I've got enough." Um, but I fully intend to incorporate everything in with everything I have. I think, you know, I might try the new campaign once with the current system of only using chapter 2 stuff. Uh, but you know, there's so much content available and because I don't play this as a lifestyle game, um, I certainly could use what I have and enjoy this the rest of my life and probably never get to the point where I'm like, uh, this is no fun anymore.

Are you the Do you when like the new stuff comes out, do you go on Reddit or BGG and like see what people are saying about it at all?

I do not. The only reason I know what I know about the chapter 2 is because it is such a departure from what was done before. I was curious where it was headed because I was going to avoid the chapter 2 core box completely. Um but you know in the end decided well I'll give it a shot and see with the first campaign and if it all comes together and feels exciting again then maybe I'll keep up with it. But I will probably only be purchasing the campaigns and avoiding most of the investigator focused releases and just using my old car poolool card pool playing the legacy version rather than um keeping current.

Don't worry, I'll likely have it and we can play. Um so for me it getting something at the same time as everyone else is sort of intoxicating. In the video game world, this is super easy to do because, you know, you don't have to worry about things shipping to different regions at different times. Board gaming, it's a little more kind of sporadic, but there is something super exciting about kind of like having that experience, especially in like a solo experience. Knowing that other people are doing it, going online, seeing what did you guys think about that final scenario? Did I play something wrong? People are talking about it. Like that is to me super exciting. The other thing that got me to stop Marvel Champions is the release cadence was so quick. I didn't have time to play everything.

I love it from a casual perspective that there's less and that I'll be able to get through it easy. For me to be able to every six weeks go through three campaigns or uh every three months I should say or whatever it might be or or three um scenarios, super easy. But if they're constantly like, you know, the turnurning out stuff and they're these really long um scenario or long campaigns with tons of scenarios, I'm way less likely uh to get it played and then I fall behind and then I'll just be like whatever. I have enough already. I can't justify going and getting anything else because I haven't played the last scenario set that I got. And that's exactly what happened with Marvel Champion. So for somebody like me seeing like what's to come, um I think it's kind of excited exciting. myself. So, like from the newbie perspective, I think it's a pretty good time to jump in. I do get like the if you're a little bit conflicted uh from like a veterans perspective, do you all like from like a uh a veterans perspective, do you think this will be widely adopted or a lot of people like Mark were like, "Hey, I'll dabble, but I have so much of the stuff I'm going to probably just play with that."

I don't know. Um, I I feel like it was a lot of negativity when this was announced, but I feel like as people have gotten their hands on it, it's been kind of better received than I kind of anticipated. Um, I I think there's going to be a camp of, you know, chapter 1 people and like that was my Arkham story and I'm stepping away from it. And, you know, if you have the, you know, whatever 10 or so campaigns that came out like Mark mentioned, like you can go back to those and there's so much variability like you're never, you know, you can play those forever. Um, but again, yeah, like you said, there's that in intoxicating fact of like being current and like being in that that excitement of people sharing these stories with these new cards and these new campaigns. And, you know, if you love Arkham the Guard game, like you're you're probably going to end up with this this Chapter 2 core set.

It just sucks. You have to go spend 80 bucks to go get it if you're especially if you're

Well, that too.

It's It's not $80. It's $80 this time. I think the magic of Arkham comes with more. Um, and had they released a an additional campaign along with a core set or you know very quickly soon after, who knows when it will actually show up, but um that is going to be kind of the defining point of what is this new chapter really look like? because the core set has to have staples and we don't know where they're going to lean in on the design. But it will absolutely be easier for somebody to stomach spending $80 now and then $50 in two months and then $60 two months after that and then $70 or whatever every couple months versus we got to the point with chapter 1 where if somebody wanted to come in, it's like, oh, I really enjoy this. To catch up to where it is now is going to cost $800.

like that's not a feasible easy startup point for somebody who's excited and that naturally put a lot of people off because there just was too much content.

Yeah. Hopefully it brings more people to the game, you know, with this this system because there is not that that that

that FOMO pressure of past sets as long as they're in rotation, you know, you could just say, "Okay, it's not in the rotation. That's all legacy content. I can move on from here."

Yeah. I think that's another I'm at it, Jared.

No, I I was just going to mention um and I think that's one of the the kind of non-tangible things about the the card game is that like the community support for this game is is pretty wild. Like the you know, there's very active um like you mentioned Arkham DB where people are making decks. There's a lot of great uh content creators that are focused on Arkham the Card Game. There's, you know, the subreddit's very active. Um this has a very robust community. Um, and it's going to be interesting as chapter 2 continues if that's going to stay strong or if it's going to lose people because I think that's a very important backbone of of Arkham.

Yeah. And I think the first campaign better really show something special because the number of new players who are willing to buy one or two campaigns and play it for a little while until they get tired of it pales in comparison to the potential income stream of those people who want this to be a lifestyle game and who will buy every single release that comes out. And once you start losing that core of people who are want to stay on that train forever,

um maybe this new release model will bring in enough new players to offset that. But if their first campaign out of the gate is kind of hoham, I think that is going to cause a lot of people to say, "I've had enough. What I've got is good. I'm out."

You know what? As much as it's a good starting point, it probably is a really good stopping point to that point. You know, there is a lot at stake in the content for that that we have coming the rest of the year. For sure.

Yeah. And then when you think people who have been playing this game for a decade, you know, the new stuff that's going to be released because of the new format, there's going to be a certain amount of repeated content, either the exact same cards that they released before or cards that do the same thing ever so slightly different. So the value proposition for these new releases diminishes for experienced players. So you've got to offset that by making them excited to keep going.

Jared, are they going to succeed?

I mean, yeah, Mark, I think it's hard to overstate like if Children of Blood is not like an awesome campaign, like they're going to lose a lot because, you know, there there this is also the proof of concept of the new campaign, you know, length, the three chapters. Um, and again, I maybe I'm I'm just being a fanboy here, but I want to believe that that they know enough about the system. They've developed enough of these campaigns that I think there's going to be more than just

the core, you know, like like we have in the core just three straight scenarios. Like I think there's going to be more to it.

It's just the argument of is it still going to be enough to justify the the continued purchase of these campaigns and and that shortened length. So I I'm very anxious to see what that's going to look like. And I think it's worth noting the core set also comes with a three scenario campaign, but the first scenario of the three is sort of eh. It's fine. It kind of introduces you to the game. The third scenario of the three is overly difficult and punishing and it it ends the story, but it's really only one of the three scenarios in the core game feels really satisfying to play the entire way through. The second scenario feels like a good Arkham Horror card game scenario. And if the new campaign can have three of those with a story that ties them together, that will bring people in to want to keep going. But if the new campaign feels like the core campaign where the first scenario is kind of fumbling a little bit, it's not necessarily that exciting and it ends overly difficult, then I think that's going to push people away more than it brings new people in.

And that's it. Those are our two veterans. That's the perspective from the new guy. I'm really excited. I don't I don't know what to miss, so I'm excited about the future of it. I've been I've played just a few games. I think it's uh I think it's great. I had a feeling I probably would. I think I told Mark this as I walked in. I really don't want to like this. I really can't afford to like this thing. And unfortunately, I was like halfway in and I think I turned to you and goes, I think I kind of like this. So, um so yeah, I I see the potential. Gentlemen, we were way over time. Uh, I said, "Oh, yeah. We'll probably like do an hour." Maybe hopefully I'll cut this down to to like an hour. I don't know. But it's it's a long video to cut. Either way, Jared Board Game Apprentice, go and subscribe right now. Mark Evil Machine, go buy some inserts on Etsy. The links are down in the description. Gentlemen, thank you very much for partaking in this lengthy conversation on what is my new love, Arkham Horror.

Oh, thank you.

My pleasure. Thanks for inviting us. Bye, guys. Bye-bye.

Progress saved