Arborea: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlock and today I'm doing a discussion over arboria which is I believe one of the first games by designer Danny Garcia and whether this came out first or Barcelona came out first I'm not entirely sure I could look that up but Barcelona was the game that put Danny Garcia's design like in my uh like kind of like in my whatever the word is wheelhouse to where I kind of pay attention whenever he's designing something because Barcelona was such a fantastic game of a the Euro styles that I'm kind of into lately that now whenever I see his name it's like I bet you that's going to be a game that's going to be for for me and with arboria um like you have this insane art style and this very colorful and bright game that gives me that gives off Boku Vibes like it's just very colorful and looks very busy that whenever I was reading it I was like oh no is this is this going to be like is it not going to be like Barcelona and I am proud to say that this is a this is an excellent game I really really like it and it's just a completely to me it's a unique style of a Euro game because you don't see at least in the games I've played you don't
see many games that utilize this almost like reverse tracks or this many tracks game with your workers like yeah obviously there's games that have tracks to you go up but the entire game here is designed around that so you have your workers your you have three different types but really they all kind of do the same thing um it's just they they have minor differences and you have four different sections that you can place your workers on and this game is always giving you something which is an excellent feeling whenever you're playing a game where not only does this game revolve around time meaning that you put your workers out and the longer you keep them out on that track the better your rewards are going to be but you're always doing something every time those tracks are moving you can decide to hop off to get the rewards uh you know larger Rewards or you could Advance it even uh quicker to then hop off immediately and get shortterm rewards but even when placing on the tracks you're getting something that helps you for endgame scoring now I'm not going to lie this game does initially come off as like all over the place and I don't necessarily think that that's a design issue I think the rule book is honestly just kind of way more confusing than it really needed to be and whenever you're you're playing the game like honestly like your second
you're like pretty much halfway through your first game you're going to completely get it and then your second time it's going to go that much quicker and what's fascinating and what makes me like this game a lot is that there are so many different scoring systems so not every game is going to feel different even though the tracks stay the same the routes you're going to go down them are going to be different because of the endgame scoring um but this element of being able to place a worker down you just take your worker and you place it on the on the a specific spot on one of the tracks that as it moves forward you have two sides that you can hop off and both of them like all of the the biomes that you're going on are themed to kind of what they so after you kind of learn the game a little bit you know where you need to go to get certain creatures where you need to go to get cards where you need to go to get resources and it's just a matter of how long do I need to stay on here because if I'm on here longer I'm going to get more rewards but if everyone else is hopping off before me they're going to take all the resources that I need to be able to fill out my my ecosystem and I just just think this is completely unique I haven't seen anything that was similar to this uh in any other game and after playing it multiple times you kind of get a different strategy for it it becomes
more just like well I guess I'll hop off now versus like okay now I need to hop off and then I need to wait because after you you know have someone go onto the path you can keep them there until you have someone else on a different path because at the after you're done placing your worker you can activate up to two of them to move down path or three if you pay a separate resource so what's fascinating is that you kind of wait for a better opportunity to combine where it's like okay now I'm going to move this person down because that's going to put a creature out that I want and then I'm going to put move this villager down to get a card that I want and then pay the spirit to be able to move so I can get the resources that I need and at the end of my turn spend those resources get get the biome and place the creature like it's you get a lot of really cool combos with this game now the one thing that is really weird but also really unique is this element of how you how the resources are managed so each resource is like split into this is like one hold this is water but it has a top half in a bottom half and when you gain the resource you move the top half up um and then you have a decision at the end of your turn do you spend the water or the resource whatever it might be do you spend the resource or at the end of your turn do you let other people potentially spend it but you gain victory points
because each time you move the top half up in between those the top and bottom half are Victory Point sections so if you choose not to spend what you just gained the bottom half moves up to meet the top half and whenever Victory Point spots it hit that's what you gain and this game is completely I wouldn't say a point salad uh because not every little thing you do gives you victory points but you get swings of victory points which I guess kind of attributes where Barcelona got it or where this game got it um that if let's say you just go up you you gain three water for example and you're like I don't need water right now but I'm going to need it and then the bottom half moves up you're going to get uh 15 points if if the bottom half is at the bottom it is diminishing returns so the more water or the more resources there are the less victory points you get but in a multiplayer game you leaving those resources out for other people to use can come back to bite you or you can look and see that other people don't have any cards to play to spend those resources on so you're like well I'm just going to gain the victory points because next turn I'll be able to actually spend it and I still reap the benefits of getting the victory points it's super fascinating it's a little confusing I think with the way the resource track works but again once you kind of see it in action it
makes a lot more sense this is unfortunately I don't think it's as clean of a game as Barcelona this one definitely has a lot more moving parts and kind of a first time learning game experience but then afterwards you're like oh okay yeah I get it cuz not only that do you have you have these different sages that you're giving gifts to and that kind of means at the end of a track if you have any gifts for that Sage you get rewards for it um and that could be really cool and then you also have this this Spirit track that is kind of I mean it's it's a liquid resource you spend it to kind of get extra actions on your turn but but there is an incentive to having a high Spirit value at the end because if you're all the way at the end of the track you get 20 points but it's also really easy to get spirit so I've never played a game of this where someone was at you know negative 8 and they got negative - 20 points like you'd have to I don't even know what you'd have to do to really stay that negative because biome cards that you play give you Spirit taking creatures from the Borderlands gives you Spirit um just spots on the board give you spirit it's um it's pretty fascinating and then that's all the worker placement stuff then you have this Hanami Koji thing over here where you have these different environment types and you're placing them in such a way that the biomes that
you're wanting are kind of adjacent to one another because each creature that you're inviting you place them on and they they gain points for being adjacent to a certain habitat like the red wants to next to Red this this part is honestly my least favorite of the game like it works it's not like it doesn't feel like it's left field and it has nothing to do with the game it clearly does especially because a lot of the scoring cards or the scoring endgame scoring stuff centers around it but it does feel kind of weird and disjointed whenever you have this Tableau terrain puzzle piece again I don't I don't despise it I'm just I'm not excited like whenever clearly whenever you have your environment cards you're using res that's the only thing you're using resources for so you're using them to be able to flip the card and place it in a way and it does have some spatial awareness because the creatures can't be directly adjacent to one another some creatures get more points if they're in the same row or column as another creature uh so it's it's fine like I I the the exciting part of the game or at least the part of the game that I like the most is the actual board and placement even though all of that is so you can complete those cards now one thing about the cards that I do really enjoy is when you're looking for certain types terrain types the resources that you
need um showcase the exact terrain type on the back so for example it's like I need three grass and one water well on the back there's going to be three grass in one water and the rest are going to be rocks uh I actually really like that I think that's a very clever design so you can quickly look at it be like hm I know there's a orange cat that I need and it's like out of all of those okay so that spot has two yellow but this one needs three so it's like that needs three flower resources therefore there's going to be three flower spots on the back of the card I I really like that it's just quick uh to be able to realize what you're getting and the fact that each time you complete one of those cards you get a bonus at the top which could be putting out more animals getting more gifts getting more spirit and it's fine like that part it's it's again serviceable but and maybe it's just because everything of this game is in service for this this kind of complements the rest of the game um but yeah it's it's there if you like Hanami Co I think it's called Hanami Koji yeah if you've played that and you like that then you're going to you're going to like it here I think uh and then on top of the fact that there are so many different scoring icons and this is also unique I haven't it to my memory I haven't played a game that had like a multiplier to the scoring so there are
four colors of scoring tracks uh you know red yellow green and blue and typically whenever you place a worker on the track you might land on a red and that means you go up on that red track and that goes up in a multiplier meaning that let's say this one that gives you a point for every Rock that's its base value and that base value is then multiplied by how high high you up are on the track and the base value of those can only ever be up to eight so it and it goes the multiplier goes from 1 to six so at Max you can get 48 points for each one of those and I think that's really interesting I like that a lot like you're going to kind of see those endgame scoring and you're going to hyper fixate on probably a few of them and see how if you can get your track up to that six multiplier but I think that that's really cool too um I mean overall the base game of uh arboria I think is completely unique it the art style is fantastic I really wish it was another type of game with the art style like this honestly it's just so wacky and colorful that it's like man I want a narrative driven campaign game with this art style I I think it's fantastic it looks so cool and unfortunately to me it's lost
on a Euro game where you just don't even really care about what the creatures are called or what the biomes are but other than that I mean it is still beautiful to look at I'll take this over just a dry gray brown Euro game so the base game I think is excellent and then uh there are two expansions that I um that I have one was called I think Winds of Change and that's kind of a modular small just a deck of cards and what you do is you shuffle them and you draw two and what they will do is they will modify the rules of the game so this stuff this is something I I really like as a small expansion because they can kind of flip the game on its head like one of them is um the extreme weather the eight uh Victory Point limit for each season tile during final scoring is removed so now instead of like the rock one for example like let's say you had 15 rocks in your in your biomes or your Environ IR M well normally base game that'd be capped at eight with that out now the 15 is there and so it'd be 15 times if you got all the way up to six it'd be 15 * 6 instead of 8 * 6 then there's uh score biomes generated by veteran villagers immediately you also score them again during step four of your turn as usual so um that allows
you to immediately get victory points for the for the uh resources instead of at the end of your turn because so it gives because like I said you had two three different kinds of workers um and your veterans are these ones that are shaded white so those would actually score you points immediately so I like um I just like that it's not a massive deck of cards but the fact that you would just Shuffle and pull two of them out and you're going to get a different combination is going to radically change your game like the last game we just played uh normally like I said different types of workers um they Advance the tracks at the end of your turn a certain number of spaces so the uh elders and the Younglings only moved the track one but the veterans move it twice but with that or with one of the ones we played it moved the track twice regardless of who was there and it was for each worker there so the tracks were rapidly advancing meaning you were getting to to the good stuff way sooner so the Winds of Change module I I thoroughly enjoyed I I mean you don't really have to have two uh I think you could if two is too much you could honestly just shuffle them and just draw one uh or if two is not enough you could just kind of pick and choose how many cards you want to add to really throw your game out of whack but this is a very nice expansion I think I think more games should do that like that would you
don't need a whole bunch of other stuff to give your game variety like just tweaking the rules making the rules completely uh wacky and you just get different combinations of just the base game would be would be enough I think and then there is the oh what was it called Midnight river is that that that expansion hey it was yeah the midnight River and this was the more this this was a bigger expans it added a new board um and it added some new creatures and kind of a boat track this this is fine I could take or leave this expansion the creatures it adds I I did enjoy like the the fish that you can place they can actually go adjacent to other creatures they go in the fish spots and they they're worth three points for each water habitat you have so they could be worth a ton ton of points if you go for water but water is hard to get because it costs you a lot of spirit but those are really cool they have these two types of Sprites bright Sprites and dark Sprites and bright Sprites uh make they go in a middle of a Terrain as well and they get they make it wild um as well as being worth victory points as well so and the dark Sprites also they
actually h hinder other creatures they make it worth negative points so the creatures I really enjoyed the boat track I mean it definitely can enhance the game I feel like if you're having difficulty figure out way to get gifts out um or advancing on the score track moving your boat up gives you that like if you wait till the very end to be to have your boat out then you get a fish you get to move up on the scoring track you get a gift out and then you the 's also another Sage that you can mess with um my only issue with the the midnight River track was basically and it could have just been this combination of of uh I know my dogs are having issues as well they don't like it um you every time that your track a track moves up your boat moves up so which is fine normally because it's like oh okay that just moves up once meaning my boat moves up but we had the card that every time uh the tracks move twice so it's like okay so no matter what pretty much anytime you move the track on your turn your boat moves so it was rapidly advancing the boat which again normally would be fine except we had to constantly remember like it just felt like it was bogging the game down just a little bit but at the same time it's just one extra track you get all the way to 12 you it acts as like another worker whenever you decide to move them down the paths you can
choose to move your boat down it it really is a minimal expansion I wasn't super thrilled by it but I honestly could see if you're playing arboria a lot then the midnight River would be kind of a breath of fresh air and then on top of all that they had these what are they just called sage tiles Sage overlay tiles you Shuffle these Sage overlay tiles draw four of them and they replace the the tracks of those sages so if you got bored of what the gift rewards are then four of the sages are going to be modified so surprisingly in this small box game you have quite a lot which I feel is becoming less and less as the as the industry kind of expands it's like you can't really just get a a simple Euro anymore it has to be overblow for no reason whatsoever and I really don't think this game is in fact like the storage solutions are clean the game honestly has four decks of cards and very minor tokens I was surprised actually when I was first opening it up I was like or you know putting these these trays together and then I you know I organized it and I was like oh wait there's not 18 cardboard punchout trays where's the uh yeah where's where's the 17 boxes of extra so it's a very nice compact game that has quite a bit
of variety and even with the expansions like after your second game you could start throwing them in and you'd be fine yeah I really don't have many like I don't really have any negatives on the game now it still is kind of one of those games that I'm I'm not jumping to you know to play like all the time but I was very very pleasantly surprised at at how much I just kind of was engrossed the entire time whenever I was doing whenever it was my turn so yeah this one's this one's a really good one I enjoy it quite a bit so on a scale of 1 to 10 I'm going to give arboria an eight I think this is a very very good game like I could see this potentially going up to 2 and N if I played it even more it just depends like again my mood as of late is not to jump out and play these kinds of games uh so that's not necessarily A Fault of the game um itself it's just more my kind of taste at this moment but there there are Euros that are coming out that I think are good or you know they're they're okay and I just even if they're good I don't really have a desire to keep them but this is one that I do want to keep because I I just I'm I it's Unique it's
I haven't seen it anywhere else so I think that's a testament to Danny Garcia as a designer his games are probably just going to be you know made for me more so than a lot of other games that I'm going to be playing of this type so yeah that is it that's my thoughts on Arbor let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time upd this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you