Skip to main content
Loading video...

Lewis Shaw on Why NOT to Go Into Publishing

Transcript 36:18

hey gamers this is liz davidson for beyond solitaire and i'm here for an interview with louis shaw from brain crack games how are you doing liz i'm good how are you i'm doing great it's so fun to have you on and we're going to talk about the topic of why you should not start a board game company yes because they're terrible yep you'll lose everything um i've lost everything this is my sort of dickens style tragedy and and my my moral fable of why you just uh shouldn't get involved stay clear all right so obviously we're kidding that was clickbait but we are going to talk about the kind of risk reward assessment when starting a boarding company said if you are interested in that you can get involved as safely as possible with advice from a pro yeah oh pro i've i've been doing it i don't i don't know if it still counts as professional amateur but i have been doing it uh yeah about five years now oh my gosh okay so how did you get started what what made you think i'm gonna have a boarding company and how did you start i made the classic mistake of um playing modern board games and then thinking uh yeah i could do this um and then designing a board game of my own the first one was awful so i skipped that one um and then made a card game called downsize which we tested over sort of like a couple months period so pretty pretty casually um and then put it on kickstarter it was one of those ones where i'd been reading all of the jamie segmeyer blogs and trying to

do as much research and kind of freaking out and pulling my hair i'd be like this needs to be like perfect one shot and then like uh my partner emily got really um just a bit tired of listening to it i think and one evening i sat there on my laptop and they were just like just just put it up so i did um and then it went really well and we got project we love and we got like 30 000 pounds or something um and oops got a board game company um without really doing huge amount of the groundwork or marketing or anything um and then kind of snowballed since then so for your first game project you basically did everything yourself all the graphic design sourcing materials finding a factory like how do you even start knowing how to do that um a lot of googling a lot of reading blogs and um getting sucked into the very useful kind of facebook predominantly community of um of people who are all having the same idea and wanting to share it and kind of share the pain and the joy and and help each other out um and that's something that is still useful still a part of like my process for a lot of things is um just asking people when i don't know how to do something um but yeah it's it's still a uh monumental task of like especially when it happens like that right and then there's not like something i plan to do and realizing on

the fly like oh now i need to become a logistics expert and now i need to you know deal with like language licensing and stuff that i never dreamed i would actually be doing um yeah daily challenge so what are some other games that have come from bring crack and also how did your process for publishing games evolve since that first one when did you start realizing that you needed to kind of share the load a little bit maybe bring an expert um so i the first two games we released downsize and mined out were designed by me um and the second campaign mined out if the first time we launched it did not go so well uh we managed to relaunch it and successfully release the game um but that was the kind of it was one title that like wasn't necessarily something people wanted as much it happens um and it was that kind of point i realized like this is a process i'm really enjoying and putting things down to the world and making stuff um but there are lots of people who want to design and release their own games without necessarily taking all of the risk and um are looking for people to help kind of bring their dreams to life and so that's when we kind of started taking pictures um and very perhaps over the confidently kind of wandered up to like um pitch meetings and stuff being like yes we're a publisher we're a games publisher or a company that you need to like bow to and respect and like show us your games um which all felt a bit ridiculous

but um like there we were we did it and people started pitching games and uh everyone sense has been designed by a another designer um and that's a process that's like that i've really enjoyed and and has evolved itself over time like how we approach things and the team has gone from just me doing everything poorly to uh i think i worked out the other day it's like 10 10 to 20 people um doing each thing that they are passionate good at you know adding adding a little bit of magic to the mix awesome so do you do you still consider yourself a game designer or do you really prefer the sort of logistical publishing end of things i like to make games that's that's the thing that like with the fullness of time the the goal is that i can get people who are good at slash passionate about doing the actual like you know the the things i don't want to do but still doing them like it's still doing a lot of them on the daily um i still design games from scratch um although i've not published one for a while now um and i have a hand in uh designing and developing elements of every game that we've brought out since i think the the last game i didn't really touch like rules wise was producer um that was just like components changes and stuff um but every other design i've kind of

been in the development cycle for and that's been something that's not in itself i think and it's something that's really rewarding not having to do that initial slog of like creating a concept that works um being able to just like dive in afterwards and be like change everything which of course people hate but that's that's off the fun oh that's awesome so you sound like you really enjoy this work so what made you want to talk about why not to do it um i think it's the case of a little bit of like from our own experience in the last couple years like how hard things have been so like there's been i mean i mean well the whole time we've we've we've been running it we've been facing like kind of challenges that we weren't prepared for and we didn't quite realize at the time how much of a kind of impact on our like uh like mental health and finances and stuff that it had um until we you know you know catching up with like friends a year later and be like oh what did you drove the last year and theirs included a lot less of like moping and crying and and they were going out and doing things i was like oh okay um so like first year um when we were printing downsides uh the brexit vote happened and all the currencies went a bit crazy um and then obviously since we've had like covered and everything um two years ago our son was born three months prematurely so that was like uh it was like right in the middle of like

venice like our big biggest project yeah and then we had to just turn around tobaccos and be like everything needs to kind of stop now um and then at the same time i've been uh processing like a like an adhd diagnosis um i had like about two years ago as well um and trying to improve the element of my life because it's something that's always it's had a profound impact on the business in good ways and in bad ways um yeah and is that an is that mixed with also like concern for the amount of people who um see the opportunities in the board game industry and want to meet that i think i feel like it's something that people naturally gravitate towards it's like i'm gonna start a company and start making things myself and take all of the responsibility and as exciting as that is it's something that has a poorly advertised uh cost i think both like financially and uh like lifestyle um and it's something that i not one it's not that i don't want people to do it but i want them to make it an informed decision um and really like know what it is they want to get involved in and what they want to do and um like find help people find the the best way to get involved and more in their hobby and yeah so what are some of the hidden costs that took you by surprise as you got into the process of publishing games

um so the i mean the big obvious one at the moment being the one that's affected most the people over the last year is like freight and logistics um the knowing not just like the the um regulation and the tax laws in like your own country but also in every country that you're then like selling to and shipping to um it's then also like the time investment of these things that you don't necessarily always realize up front like this is going to be something i have to deal with um and it's a they are things that can also be very like unforgiving uh if you don't know about them ahead of time you know like say your factory like sends out your games and everything's done and you're like yeah it's on its way and then it arrives in like a port and you have like you know letters in in other languages maybe or like you know things that you don't necessarily understand and you're being charged daily for storage until you solve a problem and it's just like it can escalate quickly right um and that's when things go well that's when things um when you have a project that funds and you have games that sell and people want um before that there's this whole lead up especially now with like having to um stand out in the crowd and like it's not a hugely like competitive industry but what people don't necessarily realize you're competing for is people's attention um and that can have uh a big cost if you want to like advertise or if you want to do like grassroots that's

accepts its own like cost of time and and effort and that's something that i mean just just recently right like in in november we launched our last project last resort um and we spent in the region of like a couple thousand and like promotion and and then it just didn't fun um like we go we we we cancelled it but we got a couple days in and we just looked at the the kind of projections and we were like this just isn't gonna happen and we had to pull it back and it was a big like shock to the system right because it was something where we had like three well i think five or six projects before that that had funded we'd gone into this real rhythm we'd raised about like half a million dollars in funding we were just like yeah okay we can we're not like shooting for the moon exactly but you know we can we can do this um so it was like a real like moment of like oh gosh yeah okay this is but like you know all of a sudden like more risk than we than we realized just because things hadn't continued as as planned so actually there's several questions i want to pull from this but let's go back a bit uh so how do you handle all the language barriers at different ports with factories that are probably not in the uk uh how how does all that work i've always wondered this how do you make it work uh do you hire company do you find just a liaison uh it's it's it's a lot of trial and error um it's also a case of immense privilege of speaking english as a first language and

that is the uh the international like you know language of business um it's something that like most chinese factories will have you know people trained in speaking english um at various levels better than my chinese at any rate um and then also just like finding people who are not just speak the language but have a good sense of what it's like to collaborate remotely and do that effectively and i've like worked with people who are you know very very good at it and especially like young people sort of growing up now who have like grown up with smartphones and they know that like that's a tool they can use to just like show you something remotely rather than having to you know express ship something across the world like be able to send you videos um and then all the way down to you know sometimes you you are emailing someone and relying on them for huge amounts of uh you know money or support and it's just just awol it's like i hope this person's okay um it's a frustrating situation to be in but it's that's the that's the way of it really it's um yeah that's interesting it sounds time consuming how many hours a week do you say that you have to put in to make a company float ah it's as with all of the like issues i'm kind of wanting to discuss it's a matter of expectation right like there are a lot of people who will

start up a um sole trader or you know sole proprietorship and they want to do like a small amount of of games and you know something that's like easy and homemade and they have a really good like well-defined scope for their project and naturally won't run into a lot of these problems because they're you know creating it at home or they're keeping their like goals really modest and their rewards really achievable um it's really when you uh or rather when i set this expectation of myself of being this like competitive international publisher that all of these problems arise um and that's a it's a ladder right of like finding new problems and then complicated solutions that are new goals and and then it's it's it's building a company right so it is a case of i know people who do this in the evenings after work and they make a modest income from it and they are sensible with their ambitions and i envy those people crazy you know a lot because i'm not that person um i was working full-time most for the most of the past five years um having to find jobs where i could balance braincrack and and staying employed um but yeah like it's a there's a thing it can be it can be a full-time job it may be a couple hours a week um at the moment um i mean over the last couple weeks over the last couple months because i'm we have a two-year-old now and he is crazy and at home and and does not like

me using my laptop and not paying attention to him it's been like not a huge amount of hours going in and i've been relying on our team a lot um but then like i think the plan is for this year to be mostly doing like three days a week you know that's what we can afford to keep him in nursery for and getting whatever else i can do done in the evenings you know it's this case of time's a resource and uh trying to align that with with expectations of myself and of the business is an ongoing struggle uh so if you're relying on the work from contractors is it i mean how do you even hire someone and also when you are dealing with the strain of your business i'm assuming that profits that you make good to them first and then to you how does that work um so we there are a lot of different ways of doing it there's like um i know a lot of companies that like lean really heavily on volunteers and have like really passionate community behind them i know people who have like full-time you know in the office with them teams um and whereas what we do is we tend to find people who have either had experience of setting up their own things in the past or they have like you know sole proprietorships and they're kind of self-led um so that they are kind of um responsible for the amount of work that they're taking on and not relying on us for an income we tend to be really like

explicit with people when when they you know join the team and say like this is what you can expect from us you know don't don't bet everything on this um and and that's i think the best way to like start those relationships honestly um it's been something we've done entirely remotely from like day one we're not interested in you know who's up the road um we we are always looking for like people who match our ethos who have experience and are self-driven and talented even if you know wherever they are in the world like our art director is in australia so like a lot of mornings i'm speaking to him like first thing so that he can you know know what he's doing the next day before you know he goes to bed and yeah like it's like there's lots of approaches to doing that but we've tried to find something that works well for us and works well and most importantly for the people who want to who want to join us and want to give their time nice and so all right so you recently had a kickstarter that didn't go the way you wanted it to go the game actually looked really fun so uh we can talk about that in a moment but you know i guess i've always wondered this because i always see it from the consumer end or maybe i did a preview right so for me um you know my involvement with kickstarters is very much about what am i going to get from this so um i'm pretty sure that what am i going to get from this is a question on both ends but i don't know how publishers ask and answer it if that makes sense how do you

engage how much you need from a kickstarter and also you know i know that if the first couple days of kickstarter are a little sluggish that's not a great sign for the campaign how do you decide when to pull the plug and how do you change things when you regroup because i know a lot of kickstarters fail and then do fine the second time around yeah i think like so again it's it's all a matter of like ambition and expectation and it's something that if we had launched this game you know three or four years ago when we were just starting out we wouldn't have had some of the problems because we didn't set that expectation of ourselves of still succeeding um so like to give some context our last three successful campaigns um took uh i think they all did like just about just just above like hundred thousand dollars um so we could comfortably expect uh i thought we could comfortably expect the next one to do maybe half that you know worst case scenario um but that was optimistic uh and the but like i say like this this was a case of us wanting to um print a certain number to achieve a certain uh cost oh well i may as well say we wanted to print 5 000 or more because that brought down the cost of the plastics that were in the game a lot more um meant we could achieve a more like tantalizing price um both for backers and then it's like a target like retail goal um and we were um

what we've been doing with each of our games now is like having a plan for language licensing from from the incept so when we start a kickstarter whether we're offering languages on that kickstarter or we have people lined up to take the license when it goes to print um that kind of boosts the numbers and it boosts the costs but those costs are really to just get a retail launch like these aren't money grabbing campaigns and in any sense of the word like if they if we hit our goal that's like if we if we held a goal and then a bit then we've covered up our costs you know if we um if we just hit our goal we'll be able to deliver it if we scrimp um there's not a huge like buffer of i need my paycheck out of this as well um it's uh it is a it is a speculative thing and that's why um we can well that's why we think it's the responsible thing to do when we get a couple of days in and things are slow and we think that you know with the financial and the like the mental effort of running a whole campaign and and keeping up all those like communications and and managing that community really quite intensely for like a month um if we think oh that's going to result in us just funding maybe covering our costs then we think okay we need to change something um

and it was a horrible decision to make like especially where like you know that whole build of like excitement and and putting like all of the work in beforehand just to get you know two days in and think oh okay need back to back to the drawing board let's do all of that build up again um but then like i think the the reason the reason they do tend to do well the second time round is like being it gives you a really strong idea of what that expectation is and being able to say like if we're going to go back we can change our numbers to kind of meet that goal you know you use what is there because there are people who are really passionate about last resort and people who you know whether they did beforehand or after the campaign cancelled like sam played it with us and they were like oh this is really good this definitely deserves to come back and they're excited for it um so it was a case of um like capitalizing on that in a sense and and being like okay and knowing that okay we've got something here we just need to manage our expectations of it and put it back into the world but a bit more a bit more carefully this time so what kinds of things can you tinker with in a campaign to make it go better the second time is it all in advertising word of mouth are you changing like what you're gonna charge per unit right you know i mean stretch goals aren't a thing if it's sluggish so probably not that um what what goes into making the changes and what changes have you found get the best

results it's uh it all depends i mean it's how close you get the first time right like if it's uh if you are you know 90 on the last day of your campaign the first time around like like i said sometimes it's really worth going the full the full length of the campaign the first time and to like build up the audience and then if you can end your account your your first campaign on like you know 1995 funded you don't have to change as much when you come back the second time um in our case we were way off um so it was a case of really revisiting everything about the campaign and talking to the people who backed it the people who have backed our previous campaigns but didn't return and really asking them like be honest you know this is this is your one thing i love saying to backers is like this is your opportunity to make your impact this is where your footprint will go so you know step on it um and say like what drew you to this what didn't draw you to it um what seemed off about it so that that initial pitch can be refined more because i mean like you know anyone anyone watching can go and look at the last resort kickstarter page for the first campaign it was i thought you know really professional and and came across well but it's if that is what it was aiming for if it missed the mark it's you know yes it all goes to waste um and then yeah that we've we've revisited the uh price point as well and changed some of the things that are in the box so that they are is easier to manufacture a lower quantity and more affordable for

the people who want it and the people who are on the fence and thinking you know i'm not sure about this i don't want to necessarily risk you know like 30 pounds but i can go for 20 or whatever it is gotcha and so since i'm on the immediate end of things um i'm just curious about this because i'm curious about it uh i don't really do a lot of kickstarter previews and i never charge for them but i always wonder uh what money how do you decide how to spend your ad budget where are the best places to drop some cash to get the word out about your um about your game and do you do static ads do you have um you know video makers that you go to again again you know where are you getting the most results this is one thing i'm really bad at um when this is this is this is one thing i do like you know pay someone else for advice on just because like especially because the uh whether it's like social ads or um people watching various youtube channels it changes so much over time um anything that i did say now if i could actually bring anything to mind which annoyingly i can't um would be useless in a month's time right because you know an audience may have dropped off or you know facebook may have changed something about the algorithm that rewards one type of ad and and gets rid of another and that's where one that's one element where even if it's whether it's paying like a marketing consultant or an agency to get some help even a small amount of help you know

like an hour's conversation to know what the kind of way of the land is can be a huge help um or just like reading you know reading blogs like the the hootsuite do a really good um regular blog on what's working and what's not working and it's that's based off of work that they're doing as well you know like spilling the tea on you know why why are our facebook ads suddenly doing nothing um so that's really is yeah but my advice there is listen to someone who's not me uh because i am very like i'm very people led um when i have been doing it myself um and here's a case of if i can send the copy to someone and they can say something nice if not nice than informative about the game that's useful for backers then that then there have been a yeah a couple people who i just will send a copy to regardless um because it's it's trying to not just figure out what's going to get us like um traffic and people looking at the page but also what the people who are already looking at the page uh want to see and want to know about the game and want to hear it from someone who's not us um because like kickstarter itself has a huge amount of inbuilt traffic um and making the most of people who are there and making a decision is really the i think the best best way of spending it but results may vary that sounds like the results may vary is basically the i think the summation of

this whole conversation yes yeah so what would be for somebody who wants to start publishing games or maybe they have designed a game they want to publish themselves what are your best starter tips for people to get into this based on your experiences um if you haven't already play it with people who don't care about your feelings is a harsh way to put it but um people who have nothing you know invested in in it and who will not hesitate to be like oh this is june imperium or you know telling you whatever other game it is that they've played recently because that that that that is a huge amount of like knowledge and wealth and and it's information about how whether you're publishing it or or someone else is publishing it for you what people will think when they look at it you know like a lot all of our platforms ask people we've got a bunch of questions we asked before the test has even begun we're just like look at it on the table what do you think is this going to be um who do you think it's for um because that really shapes not just what people what people want to buy and want to play but what they think their friends will play it's a huge amount of like perception goes into that um see a play with other people get you know get honest opinions from people um and share it as much as possible like i think like there's a lot of um i encounter a lot of people who have kind of kept things very close to their chest or maybe not realize that there are places where they can share pictures of their design

um and equally there you know i've i've encountered a couple people who've like just posted something in a group or on reddit and gotten this like amazing response and overnight they're just like oh my god how do we help this and suddenly they like want a publisher to help them or or point them in the right direction because there's just something about it that has attracted people you know from like a really like top level uh viewpoint and that's something that's like incredibly value invaluable just to even just from um from a publisher perspective you know if it sounds sounds really stupid right and superficial but if you can come to me and say like not only have i designed this game and i think it's good and then my friends is good but i posted a synopsis about it on facebook and it got 100 likes in a public group you know like that's something that's something to show that oh there is actual interest in this and it's not just a that's not just a um business thing either you know that's a it's a does this match what people's idea of fun is um because those games don't always necessarily make the most like money but they can they can really like help grow an audience and and give something credentials if if people don't if people want to like something from from the outset that's like a really really valuable asset that i think i'm trying to pay more attention to interesting what about on the sort of business logistics end of things um so i mean if there's

uh if people are wanting to self-publish um what they need to look at is really uh what their options are just for starting a business in their areas and it and it will the liabilities and responsibilities will vary wildly within each like country um in the uk the big thing is like whether you are a sole trader um or whether you are a limited company i think it's similar in most countries um and it's a case of what are you taking on as a liability if something goes wrong with your product and you know you are in debt does that affect you personally or does it affect the company as an as an entity that's something that's that's huge that everyone needs to understand um that that's like you know that's the losing the house over my card game kind of angle um and the i've said that a couple times i need to iterate that hasn't actually happened to me i feel i feel like i use it as an example too often um and then it's also yeah like kind of the the liabilities and the responsibilities so then like you starting a company is more uh safe from a personal perspective um but then there is a lot more admin involved we very um uh meekly thought like oh we can file a company tax return that's easy enough and then we tried doing it and we're like all of a sudden needed to

hire an accountant which we didn't expect to have to do um yeah it's it's uh there are there's a host of hosts of good books and literature on just just not even board game stuff just like starting a company and keeping yourself safe um yeah awesome so first of all thank you so much for coming on here and sharing so much of your experience i think that for people on my end just the player and this is always like super fascinating here but uh before i let you go why don't you tell us about last resort and and what's going to be different this time around it would be my pleasure um last resort is a game that we're all really excited about is a um tile placement uh hotel building game about building a hotel in space um you've bought this sort of discount defunct space station and you are trying to fill it with uh you know big neon signs and and attractions to get people to uh who are dabbling in space tourism to come and visit your station um there's a multi-use card element where like everyone is playing one advertisement per round that dictates like who will come to your station and what tiles you can build and more importantly who you clear off of your station to get them to pay their bill and leave and make space for new people um but it also uh introduces a malfunctions element of the game where if you're playing the same adverts as other people uh the wires

cross and malfunctions start appearing on your station and you get different um you know like you know pipes leaking and robots malfunctioning and trying to you know kill off your guests um and yeah i think things are wrong in your station which is like really uh fun to see which ones come out each time there's loads of different ones in the box um but the real like the bit that makes people switch on when that when they're playing and they think oh okay right this is this is what's cool about this game is the drafting you have these um you're drawing out these little meeples each round to see um uh what tourists want to come to your station and the color of them dictates like what kind of attractions they want to come and see um and the drafting of that being able to like look at what spaces people have on their station um and what ones you're trying to fill in your one is where there's a lot of like uh it leans heavily on hate drafting if that's something people don't like in games don't come and play last resort because it's it's it's a the main attraction and it's hilarious because if you are drafting someone who wants to come to your station but you don't have any space that matches their color you have to eject them off into space and you lose lose rankings and things go poorly and yeah it's just just a really silly uh like sci-fi game a lot of like douglas adams references in there and and a lot of like yeah references to sci-fi movies that we love um as a kind of almost a bit of like a

thematic antidote to the three like mediterranean euro games we've just done we're like let's do something silly again excellent if people want to find out more uh where can they find you online uh you can go to braincrackgames.com um and we are on uh bangkok games on facebook on twitter on instagram um yeah come and come and have a look and uh come build a space hotel with us fantastic blue thank you again for coming on it's been such a pleasure to get to know you get to know your business and uh for those of you who are out there uh please do you know like subscribe comment ask us any questions that you might have and any any last words um take care stay safe play ball games alright happy gaming everybody bye

you

Progress saved