Beyond Solitaire Podcast 49: Mary Beth Looney on Monumental Consequences
Transcript
hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and i'm back on my podcast with a very special guest mary beth looney she is an independent scholar who is currently working in rome italy something which i'm very jealous so tell us a bit about your work maybe about my work so i'm an artist and an art historian i have a foot in both worlds which neither one of those worlds ever appreciates or understands um the funny thing is is that artists typically don't like art historians and art historians really typically don't like artists until they're dead um so uh i am a maker of uh two-dimensional art paintings drawings and then also uh i've been taking up print making in taglio printmaking while i've been here in rome yeah it was the thing i overlooked as an undergrad finally making up for lost time uh courtesy of temple university in rome uh and uh i also as an art historian and the author of a few games about art his art historical topics uh as well as um a professor of art history for uh students either online or here in rome on a kind of adjunct basis awesome so when it comes to games what are some of the games that you have previously designed before we talk about your your upcoming project okay um so i have two games that are under the auspices of reacting to the past which i know has already
been addressed at least a little bit in your your podcast series um and so uh the first one centers around art in the 1930s in the united states and so it really focuses on the works progress administration courtesy of fdr um communist party the united states of america as well and it has to do with these fundamental questions that artists were wrangling with at the time which had to do with what is american art because up to that point everybody had both eyes glued on what european modernists were doing and so that figures pretty heavily in a lot of the content of the game um but the players of the the roles that are there in that game are some of the american artists that we actually have a fair amount of familiarity with especially those from the 1950s like jackson pollock willem de kooning mark rothko all of these big bad boys of the abstract expressionist era who in the 1930s were still trying to find their footing and so the game in a way kind of chronicles some of the paths that they took and their exposure to not only european modernists but also mexican muralists i don't have diego rivera in the game but that's because he'd gotten in trouble for painting a mural that was
unliked in 1934 in new york city um but all of his compatriots that are well known are in the game um and the cool thing that i like about that game is uh that i paired it with radio programming so players have to put on a radio show um so that uh the the the glory days of radio which was an important backdrop the 1930s if not a foregrounding issue depending on who you are um that that that that happens alongside all of this visual art and it also encourages players to find ways to verbalize what they need to say about art forms that i think a lot of people struggle with how to talk about the other game which i just unleashed if you will ah a couple of years ago and that has to do with uh an era slightly later 1940s uh it's called monte casino and it has to do in part with the topic of really the point of our podcast today uh in the sense of it has to do with the destruction of a major monument uh in the slightly early 1940s the united states had already begun its progressive encroachment on the peninsula of italy it had already conquered sicily
and it was traveling up the boot towards rome and it hit a point geographically speaking where um the the fascists on the other side of the mountain range were waiting for them and a major battle occurred on a hilltop mon around a hilltop monument or monastery i should say at monta casino it is a repository of incredible numbers of original illuminated manuscripts it was founded by saint benedict it is it is it is no great slouch in the history of monasteries or or um we'll say cloistered communities of the christian faith um and the ultimate question of that game is is a real one that occurred in history which is the allies trying to determine if they can successfully defeat um hitler and and the and the italian fascists um without destroying this important monastery uh and in fact it was destroyed that is commonly known historically speaking um and so uh the the game largely involves personnel in the military so almost all of the characters
are are actual characters um and so you get a little tiny slice of what italian life would have been like there but it is mostly centered around the questions of of course the value of uh cultural property but also and this was pointed out to me by somebody who works in in let's say cyber security what is good intelligence because the the bombing of monte cassino was in part based on misinformation um that was yes uh and so in the game you have various role players stating what they think they know about the presence of the enemy inside that monastery um and whether or not the invaluable art and books are still there and how many people are living there and have we seen aerials on top of the building that suggests that the military on the opposite side has actually set up and set up shop inside so all of these things are competing pieces of information um and you can literally track historically speaking you can go online and find these um these assertions made by various entities about what was actually happening there what what was the truth um and the truth
unfortunately was that there was no military occupation of the monastery um and so bombing it was really unnecessary um but you can even go on youtube and see what that bombing looked like it was incredible um the footage of that and the loss of life was you could say somewhat minimized except that people from the town of casino had in some cases run to the monastery for shelter because they didn't know where else to be during all of this it was a raging conflict it went on for days it was it was muddy it was wet it was winter and so um all of these these poor people who had already dealt with enough were hiding out in the monastery because i where else would they go um and so there is loss of life but uh the art had been moved by nazis uh to rome uh weeks beforehand so it is it's it's fun it's i think um and i just had someone request uh a copy of it to play test it which i'm pretty excited about because i don't know it may maybe it's a niche subject for some people but it relates to what we want to talk about today definitely so before we get onto your current game i just want to ask what inspired you to teach about and express these ideas about history and cultural property
and you know art through games is that something that came naturally for you or where where did the idea come from i wrote about this for an online resource it's community um art history teaching resources um and i think that as an as an art history instructor in northeast georgia uh for a number of years i wanted to use uh the topic of an essay that i had read about as a graduate student myself called bomb the church what we don't teach our students in art 101 and i had staged it as a debate with students in class and um without revealing the the heart of the matter yet i will just simply say that it became clear to me that in these debates students very quickly made a judgment that seemed ill-considered or maybe not ill-considered i should instead say very quickly considered and without perhaps pausing to consider the ramifications i became acquainted with reacting to the past in 2010 um thanks to getting to know somebody who was already in the community and they're suggesting that i go to a weekend workshop for faculty members i went to one at the university of georgia and played a game about um
basically the title of the game is the ides of march um and so it's rome 44 bc uh and uh terrific terrific game uh concept of course the game begins just after julius caesar has been assassinated uh most of the players are senators um and i was quickly innervated i was just so excited about this idea of what this kind of role-playing game would do for my classroom that i very eagerly eagerly wanted to employ it and did i cut my teeth on their own game and i used the roam game a number of times as well as a few other select ones with students at my institution at the time there was only one game about art history at all and yeah um at the time it is now published um and it deals with the topic of impressionism in paris uh also a terrific game um and at the time i thought that you know well obviously there there's potentially a route to publishing but there is also there's so many other topics in our history that we could construct games around and perhaps bring art history to life or maybe just to more life uh than it already does i mean i i think it's fortunate in art history we always have something visual to look at while we're talking about these makers that are that are long lost
in most cases but um uh regular straight up history doesn't necessarily have that and instead they rely on art history to help sort of bring bring history to a more visual sort of realization for people um but i thought that the idea of of students being able to inhabit artistic characters initially with my american game in the 1930s i thought that being asked to
embody the persona of someone who has a certain drive or mandate would help fuel their understanding and if not empathy then sympathy um with various things cultural forces um uh influences uh needs you know a lot of the artists in the 1930s in america of course were on the bread line and trying to work for the wpa to at least feed themselves so those kinds of things struck me as an important important piece of it if i go back to the debate that i originally led with in terms of my answer to your question i wanted students to have to think about more things than just simply the most immediate choice that they were making in terms of the debate and i don't know about you but you know you ask a room full of students to debate a topic and sometimes you just hear crickets um sometimes you have people who are just simply you know i why do i care about this um and then why do i care about this piece is hard to um underscore at least initially my follow-up to the game that we're talking about today uh is a bit of a a lecture about okay so if you all chose x here's what your lives would be like
if you if you lived with that choice um and that's when sometimes i see you know the light come on um but uh the role playing aspect i thought would help this debate become more real and become more nuanced uh than they were initially taking it on to start with that's a great way to look at it i think and it's a perfect segue into talking about monumental consequence which is your upcoming game um that's not its original title you can disclose if you wish but um but um tell me what what inspired monumental consequence specifically as a game for you that that albert elsin article was really the the kickoff um the author describes something that i don't know if he he originated it he simply says we at stanford refer to this as the bomb the church problem um and the problem is the construct is you live in a small town probably a european one where you have a major cathedral in the center it is it is the hallmark of the town it is the thing that dominates dominates the skyline it has been there for centuries it contains important works of art it contains monuments
or or commemoratives to important people of the town and an invading army has set up camp inside that cathedral and so it is up to you as members of the town to determine what what your choices should be do you send in fellow townspeople to sneak into the church and attempt to roust out the enemy thereby risking their lives or do you just simply bomb the church and that is that is the conceit right there that is all there is to it um uh and so i would present that to my students in in class as i said and it ultimately the overwhelming answer was well we would have to bomb the church it doesn't mean anything it it in fact is you know it's a materialistic object some people would argue or it was um something that you could certainly replace um and so that that's something i would have to force people to like tease it out of them a little bit to say you know what what what do you do with your church if it's not there anymore um to turn it into a game meant that i could invest the the the conceit with um various players in various ambitions and so you have members of a civic militia you have townspeople widowed mothers
you have the sons of those widowed mothers who might be conscripted into said militia but you also have the church sexton i.e the facilities guy or or girl um you have uh the priest the town doctor and i wrote an expansion pack so that uh we could get even you know for people with big class rosters um you could have um the prioress and a young nun who wants to you know she's she's looking for love and all the wrong places and um so you can have you can have these kinds of like mini dramas um but you also have the town apothecary um and a number of other individuals everybody's got a stake in the game uh and the bottom line is that you're presented with this this scenario and then you must convince each other which way to go bomb the church or send in the militia and that is that is the basic description of it what else can i tell you about it so i'm assuming that you've been play testing it so you said that when you do this as a debate you tend to just kind of get an automatic knee jerk well obviously we will just destroy the property and preserve human life uh do you find that having people play the game adjust the results to an extent it adjusts the results because of the construct of the game in the sense that it is not a one-shot hit where you say okay everybody you know cast your vote
um there are there are limitations set up in the within the game so that um if you don't have a 75 percent uh agreement on one side then you have to go back in and do more convincing of each other and uh so certain players are advised not to vote um and others are encouraged to be to sort of like feel this out a little bit and see what other people have to say and so the argument for either bombing or not bombing the church unfolds if you will um and so people start to dig out some of those nuances um that are either in their role descriptions or are things that they have perhaps thought of on on their own um and so i have been struck by the fact that in play tests and this this game has been play tested in play test mode if you will for the last i think four to five years no i apologize longer about six years i wrote it before moving to rome um it is on the reacting to the past game library site which you have access to if you become a member of reacting to the past for a nice small
fee of say you're an independent person like me and you don't have a school to help reimburse you for that membership um i am told by site administrators that it is the most downloaded micro game of all the ones they have and they don't have a huge number to be fair some of the micro games they have and we classify these things as micro games because they are playable within one class session some of them are precursors to a longer game in reacting to the past series um that sort of set you up for more content acquisition um and you know micro games have a variety of purposes but in in my particular case what i learned is a i can always be surprised by people who report in the uh the faculty lounge on facebook for reacting to the past uh community members they themselves as game masters are often surprised by the outcome sometimes of people deciding that they're not going to bomb the church i have never kept tabs on how many have been for or against in the end um because i in the end i think that we you've got far too many kinds of groups using this game not just student groups but a lot of people have used this as a way of debuting reacting to the
past to a group of faculty that they're trying to sort of sell the idea to um and so you you've got a wide range of intellects you've got a wide range of people with cultural values and in operation there and so i don't i don't really know um but i am i'm i'm soothed really by the fact that uh it turns out that you can you can get the kind of outcome that ultimately suggests that there that we do understand the value of cultural property that's actually leads into i i guess me declaring my own bias and also into the next question so i wanted you on here really badly because arguments about cultural property have actually been a major part of my life uh my big job in college was photographing tablets for the persepolis fortification tablet collection um so when i was in undergrad i took pictures of elamite tablets for a professor and the project was forever in doubt because technically the persepolis fortification tablets are the property of iran and they were the subject of a lawsuit from families who had lost family members in a terrorist attack who wanted some sort of compensation from iran and the only thing they could think of to like get assets from them was the process for the fortification collection and so there were years of court cases before eventually it was decided that cultural property is not something that you seize and you put up for auction
but that was a live question and also you know i was in syria in 2010 ah before the arab spring so many of the things that i saw are no longer to be seen and i get pretty emotional about it so like for me you know i'm a historian i love ancient things like cultural property like i really believe in preserving the things that we have i do often feel that certain historical artifacts or collections are worth more than my life personally is that something that you hoped people would at least think about i mean i know that we always do things for a reason i know that you have to leave players in a game right free to make a choice but is there a choice that you hope for from the game the choice that i hope for is for at least people to be impressed with how much art actually impacts their lives on a daily basis i i live i live two blocks from the pantheon um so i walk past the pantheon pretty frequently and i try to remind myself that when i turn the corner and there it is and all of its monumentality that i i that it never becomes this backdrop for me that is just part of living in this in this neighborhood and oh the sea of tourists in front of the piazza i've got to swim through this
this this steep current um i i instead want to always try to look upon that as freshly as possible and remember um it's its import for all of the art historical reasons that i could i could name um but but also how much that that temple shape and construct then impacts so many others including the one that everybody wanted to argue about whether or not it was truly breached by patriots or otherwise on january 6th i'm not sure if people really think that consciously about how many members of congress said people were trying to destroy our temple of democracy um these things are real symbols and i'm not i i i don't kid myself um i know that uh that that symbol is not the thing that if it went down if it went down tomorrow then so too with democracy that's that's absurd um but i do think that it is there's there are a series of running threads for us artistically visually speaking um that are are deeply deeply embedded in our consciousness and i think to disrupt that uh fundamentally
disrupts us and our continuity with the past um so i at the when i when i stage this this construct as a debate and even when i now stage the game um it doesn't matter how it goes what the outcome is i ultimately say those of you who were on the bomb the church side i want you to think about how your life would be if you followed through with this this precept if you are willing to bomb the church you are willing to live without art so i want you to think about how many different ways art is in your life on a daily basis get rid of your radio your television your streaming um get rid of those pretty colors of your bathroom towels and your your really awesome funky shower curtain um your clothes your closet is full of nothing but i don't know name a monochrome white gray black that's it and it's all the same there is no differentiation i mean i enumerate all of these different things where somebody with some kind of creative uh outlook had an imprint on your existence and i've had people actually get all teary-eyed in front of me when i start to like really drive home this idea that without it you know this is your life so
um i i feel like i have to do it in a contemporary uh kind of framework um because in part american students in particular unless they come to europe or some other place where you get to see things that are of this considerable age it is hard to connect with the value of old old things because the united states is such a young country so when you meet someone who like i mean there are plenty of people who are just kind of not into art uh what would you tell someone who's kind of fresh to art appreciation how would they get started what would you tell them to look for to begin to nurture an appreciation for what's around them well um first of all i think what we have to do is destigmatize this idea that it's only for elite people um and so we have to talk about uh what do you what do you have on your walls at home um what what are your color choices i used to do this with art appreciation students and and learned crazy things that i didn't expect to see coming like the person who only preferred all of her interior um decor like bed spread couch cover cushions wall colors everything just needed to be black and white and gray that was what she was satisfied with but she loved reproductions of van gogh
paintings to be framed and hung on her walls and so you know in the end i was like okay so what we're saying here is that van gogh does for you what you would rather just not do for yourself but let someone else do which is bring in you know this riotous amount of color um and also uh i also had a student who uh brought in examples of her collection of work by serial killers that she um that she collected it's completely fascinating um uh but so the point is is okay what what what do you like and why do you like it i think it's the first first step that you have to take um because we do make conscious choices almost all of us and there there's something that drives that and from that point you can then talk about the language that we actually commonly use when we talk about art the elements and principles of design and how those things are manipulated by whatever kind of artist you're talking about to help yield some kind of an outcome and then we we take it from there we talk about art types and and then we eventually dive into history no so i actually wanted to pick up on something that you said at the beginning of that comment which is that you want to make art less elitist and you want to make it that's something more for everyone and that's something i actually also struggle with as a latin teacher a lot of people perceive latin
as sort of an elitist useless thing that i think is quite enriching for your life but it's it's a it's there's a lot of art of convincing so how do you give people a sense of ownership over something that is ancient and that maybe feels elite and like not something that's of them and not something that's theirs that is a challenge that we are going to i think perennially struggle with you immediately make me think of um the fact that when we invaded baghdad under under g w bush um or i should say underbush when we invaded baghdad i have to say the most riveting one of the most riveting presentations i ever saw at the college art association conference and in my history of attending those those conferences was a presentation actually written by but not delivered by the former director of the museum of baghdad donny george was his name he was too ill to make the presentation and so i want to say he had a family member deliver it but it was it wasn't a speech it was simply a recollection of what what that was like of knowing that u.s military had already set up in baghdad um but that conversations with certain individuals in uniform at
various points in the city yielded this unfortunate fear um that they did not even understand that they needed to be barricading and protecting that museum and as you know it was uh broken into and looted um and it was such a moving uh story and it led me to think about how you know what what do united states military members what do they learn about the places that they wind up being in um and uh i can send you information i'm sorry i don't have it on me at the moment but i have been in contact with somebody who actually uh is is an employee of the federal government who helped drive this making of playing card decks that have photographs of major works of art in the middle east and other other yeah other other far-flung places so what do you do when you're not flying your planes uh in the air force you you hang around and maybe you play cards with your buddy and so on the backs of those cards are ways to sort of get military members to connect with it so so i and i don't approach this exclusively from the standpoint of whether or not to to outrightly damage or leave something unprotected so much as i think that the other piece of donnie george's story
that that you made me just think of was the fact that looters were not the only people who who broke into the baghdad museum there were also just regular citizens who went in found something that had been liberated from their glass case or whatever and they took it took it home and waited and they waited weeks and then when things finally calmed down they came back to the museum with those objects to say we we we were afraid that this object would would go away into the black market and we would never see it again and so we just held on to it and we're really sorry but we thought this is the only option that we really could think of and so there was this this effort to save art but embroiled in donnie george's presentation was this running theme of how do you encourage because these are baghdad residents looting the museum for good or for not um but they they're they were disassociated from those objects they did not see them as anything other than other examples of the ways in which they were disenfranchised somehow in their own in their own society the museum was the thing that that wealthy elite you know
smart people go to not the the working guy who sells you know his wares on the street um and so how do you how do you get that kind of connectivity how do you get that sense of ownership is a super steep struggle i think um i i have to say when i went to the national gallery of art um years and years ago uh to go i was just on a vacation trip to washington dc and i was walking around the museum with my canon ae1 uh analog camera around my neck and a security guard walked up to me and he said very sternly looking down at me and he said kind of film do you have in your camera and i said well i have 200 speed film 35 millimeter but my lens cap is on my camera so please don't think that i'm just taking photos randomly because i had in my head the usual rule which is no photography which museums have largely uh been doing away with lately much to my happy surprise but at the time i thought i thought i was going to maybe be in trouble and instead he said to me his smile broke out on his face and he said well why aren't you taking pictures and i said well i didn't think i was supposed to and he was like this stuff is yours you own it and i never thought of it that way
so i mean on you know i guess what i'm saying is is on a massive level how do we how do we connect people to to the objects that are part of their cultural heritage on a one to one level how do we encourage people to have a connection with objects of their cultural heritage those interactions are capable in a variety of ways and i think that bottom line is if we all share some of that vision it can happen more frequently i don't think we can institutionalize this um i don't think that we can take people from the slums of the city to the fancy museum and necessarily drive home that idea that it belongs that what's in there belongs to them um i i don't i don't think that that is that there is no easy answer except that if we all share this vision that these things have some importance we can have the one-to-one or the group or somewhere in between uh kind of success so this discussion of how to create appreciation for artifacts of your own culture and create a connection with your own past is i think one aspect of the discussion but i also wonder you know for something like bomb the church um can you also use it to help create appreciation for other people's art for artists from other cultures that maybe you don't feel a personal connection with one thing that was really interesting is that you know we have talked about
monumental consequence as something that maybe is assumed to be in europe what if it's somewhere else um do you think that you would get different results from your play testers and also how can you change that if it's you know if you have a lack of sensitivity towards art from somewhere else i i have thought about that simply because in play tests particularly with faculty members from a wide variety of institutions and backgrounds they have said um sometimes derisively and sometimes uh from a more open-minded point of view that you know my students at my school wherever that happens to be they are predominantly whatever faith um or or they are high income low income you know all of those kinds of demographics um play a role in informing how people will respond and whether whether or not they will embrace that kind of topic and so at one point i remember doing a play test and all of the feedback i was getting from the participants again faculty academicians uh was it well what if you did an expansion pack where it was um a mosque or what if you did an expansion pack where it was i don't know something that wasn't religious at all like a library that was important you know i i at the time i said i don't know why you can't just adapt this to your own needs um and it it wasn't so much that i i didn't want to do that kind of work it
was that i couldn't see an end to it if you if you create uh you know one kind of option or five kinds then you will have five more pop up and go yes but what about our special interest um i think that in the end the to to borrow uh to borrow drug terminology getting in touch with the object that is that is of cultural importance to you and your heritage may be the gateway to then being able to translate that to another another culture another another place in the world and and i i'm saying that because of what was clearly this interest is that everybody seemed to agree that we should care about cultural property in some capacity but if you made it religious then that might you know that might ostracize some people and especially if it's one kind of religion or there there was there was an agreement on one level and then everything else became much more end of the law individualized and specialized but that the running theme was if you make it something they can connect with then you will see greater investment so do you have a hope that people will take your game and adapt it and recast it and just make it however they want is that your intention as a designer um it was never my necessarily it was
never my intention it strikes me though as a realistic outcome um and this is something that i i find is interesting among academicians you are either the kind of person who will take that core idea principle pedagogy whatever it is and simply manipulate it to your needs or you will be the person who sees that same thing uh and think well that just isn't going to work for me um you you either want to take the chance and do the work and and and make it yours and make it good by making it yours um or you just find it not applicable and you're going to move forward and do something else or do what you always do i don't know um so uh i will say that the design of monumental consequence right now has very much a euro-centric aesthetically speaking a euro-centric kind of feel um i've just been shown um a mock-up for the cards that will be the role the role cards for players um that the the fine fine folks at central michigan are uh designing and there's there's still there's very much a kind of gothic cathedral-ish kind of feeling to it um i i don't know i don't know how to encourage anyone and everyone
to be willing to say okay i like this idea it's not exactly what i had in mind but i'll just adapt it because i feel like in my world i have to adapt a lot of things i mean i use obviously i used a drug analogy a minute ago but i also use food analogies a lot when i talk about art and art history we're going to talk about roman concrete then i you know and the roman concrete ingredients for the the dome of the pantheon it changes as you go from the base all the way up to the top what they use in the way of particulates changes in order to help with that weight distribution so i talk about rice krispies and rice krispie treats you know i mean it just to me that's that's an easy leap and most people go oh yeah okay right um and then they started thinking about rice krispie treats um but other people are just they they're just not built that way i had a faculty member a very sweet colleague say to me once you know when it came to using reacting to the past games in my classroom and then also designing and just using games uh that i'd heard about or thought i might tweak a little bit and and use on my own she's like well some of us just don't have that same kind of confidence and i never really thought of it as confidence i i suppose you you can i mean you could fall flat on your face um uh
by adapting something and it not going well but i also argue that if you tell the people that you're doing this experiment with on a given day that this is an experiment let's see if we can break this thing let's see if it actually could work you get that conspiratorial sort of spirit happening in the room and people tend to be all in uh you're trusting me with the idea that maybe we can oh okay um and so maybe you do fall flat on your face in the end you've all reached a collective agreement you've probably learned some stuff uh and uh it's all good awesome so you are having this game monumental consequence published through cmu's academic press do you have any comments on how that experience has been since this is sort of a new thing like this academic games press this is uh this is new i think it's new for everybody including them um jonathan truitt has been extraordinarily supportive he was really partly the inspiration for my creating this game in the first place because he debuted his game which included some of the same mechanics um at a at a game development conference that i had attended a few years prior and so i've known him a long time um but i only see him you know maybe once a
year maybe maybe once every two years so i mean that's how our friendships work i guess in a lot of ways um in in today's world um he has an assistant andrew devaney who has been working with me on the design of the package and um i have appreciated every step of this experience so far because if they are talking with other game developing companies and sometimes they are um i get the fully honest rundown of why bomb the church as a title was a was was not desirable for instance and the support and encouragement to to and to pursue changing the title but still being given permission to if i really like had to hold on to it that that we would we would try that anyway um so uh they've been supportive they've represented me well in in the few instances where they've needed to so far and uh it's a it's a long process but i expected it to be uh we're feeling our way and and i'm okay with that fantastic and i have one more question for you this is either the easiest or the hardest question of the whole interview i guess um so you are very concerned with the preservation of cultural property for us for future generations what is the piece of art or the monument that you personally think would be the the greatest loss what would break your
heart the most oh wow what would break my heart the most okay this may not be the answer i would give you in in two months i don't know but um it well so i talked a lot about the pantheon and in some ways it's been kind of a touchstone because it was the we we learned about where we were going to live before we moved here even though the embassy the u.s embassy assigned this apartment to us um and so i spent a lot of time looking at google maps so you know going wow look where we are um and being all starry-eyed about the the things that we were close to and that i would get to see on a daily basis but there is a church in the neighborhood of trustevery the medieval church of santa maria and trustdevery it is arguably the first church dedicated to mary in rome santa maria maggiore is the other church that people of course tend to think of and many feel strongly about being the first church dedicated to mary nobody's ever going to settle that argument i don't think but that church is it is at once on a grand scale maybe not like st peter's grand scale but still pretty good sized basilica that is still very intimate in some way
for me um and so there is a an emotional quality to being in that space um some people of course i think would argue that it's very spiritual in the sense that it is dedicated to mary and the mosaic and the apps which dates to i want to say the um 10th or 11th century is unique in the sense that mary is being crowned the queen of heaven in this mosaic uh and she has this super familial kind of pose with christ in in that portrayal they both sit on the same throne together um but that church is also a polimpsist of rome its beginnings date to maybe the fourth century with the miraculous fountain of oil that that came out of the ground and the location um the the the church's floor dates from one era the columns some of them come from the baths of caracalla um the there there is almost every century that you can get your hands on in this in this city is somehow represented in that church and um they say rome is it's a lasagna it's a layer cake of of all of these different um of these different eras and that church in particular is it's it's a neighborhood place the piazza in front where kids are playing soccer and
people are having drinks and talking um the university students who who occupy the neighborhood are very much um they're part and parcel the fabric at that place uh they're present and then you have you know all the pilgrims who are coming to this remarkable church um that uh is so remarkable because in some ways it has this unremarkable um kind of of placement it is it is not the pantheon of roman temples it is not the the christian church of all christian churches it is just special and its accumulation of those layers you could never repeat that you could never repeat that and that i think is what makes it um so remarkable and it would impact me emotionally if it were lost i like it i like it a lot so where can we find you online you can find me at www.marybethlooney.com all one word there and you can also find my essay just by googling my name you can find my essay in art history teaching resources about the church or about sorry about bomb the church as its original game title uh name and yeah that's it fantastic and everyone i can be found
anywhere as you know as beyond solitaire thank you so much for listening to this podcast and especially thank you mary beth for coming on it's been so wonderful to talk to you it's been a blast thanks thanks everybody and happy gaming
you