Skip to main content
Loading video...

7 Hit Board Games DESTROYED by Publishers

Transcript 18:23

You know that feeling when you open a box and everything looks incredible? The miniatures, the art, the sheer scale of it, and then you actually try to play it and you realize the publisher had absolutely no idea what they were doing.

Oh, I know that feeling intimately. And today we're talking about seven games where the publisher was the final boss. And not in a fun way.

Today we're doing something a little different. No, by this, not that, no comparisons, just a straightup reckoning with seven board games that were let down or in some cases outright betrayed by the companies behind them.

And before we dive in, let's be honest about what we mean by ruined. We're not saying every one of these is a bad game. Some of them are genuinely brilliant. What we're saying is that the publisher made decisions around production, business models, licensing, communication that hurt the game in ways the design never warranted. The design was often the best thing about these products. What surrounded it is where things fell apart.

And where something is our interpretation rather than a documented fact, we'll say so. We're not here to drag anyone through the mud without cause. Let's start with the one that still makes me wse. Dark Souls the board game. Steam Forged Games 2016.

Okay, so the setup here is almost comical in hindsight. Steam Forged goes to Kickstarter in April 2016 asking for £50,000. They hit that goal in 3 minutes. The campaign alarm probably hadn't finished going off before they were funded.

And by the time the campaign closed in May 2016, they had raised 3,771,474 from 31,178 backers. It was the most backed board game on Kickstarter at the time. One of the top 15 Kickstarter campaigns ever. Full stop. Guinness World Records recognized it as the most money pledged to a Kickstarter board game based on a video game.

So you have that kind of money, that kind of audience, that level of trust in the rule book that ships with a game is a mess. Not just a bit unclear in places, actually dense, poorly organized, and almost devoid of useful examples. For a game built around a franchise famous for systems that reward careful reading, the irony is painful. You'd think someone in that building would have noticed the connection. [sighs]

And it didn't stop there. When Steam Forged later released the Dark Souls tabletop RPG in 2022, it arrived with errors so glaring that IGN and PC Gamer were writing about it. Knights couldn't wear their own starting armor. There were references to a paladin class that didn't exist in the game. Items contradicted their own descriptions. Terms were used throughout the book that were never actually defined anywhere inside it. Steam Forged apologized and committed to reprinting the whole rule book. Good. But this wasn't a first offense. Their Monster Hunter World Board game required a full reprint of all base game cards because of serious coloring and sizing issues. There is a pattern here that goes beyond bad luck or a single oversight. You can't point to two separate flagship products, two separate IPs, and call both of them isolated incidents. The criticism that stuck hardest wasn't about any single error. It was about what the errors revealed. That Steam Forged had secured a lucrative IP, launched a massive Kickstarter, and prioritized getting product out the door over making sure that product was actually finished. The game still has fans, and there are people who genuinely enjoy it. But when community members describe Steam Forged as a company that craps out games from well-known IPs and targets new fans who haven't been burned yet, that is a reputation built across multiple releases, not a one-time misread. And if Dark Souls is the cautionary tale about rushing development, Darkest Dungeon is the one about what happens when a

publisher bites off more than it can chew and then asks its customers to pay for the bite.

Right. Mythic Games launches a Kickstarter for a Dark Stungeon board game in October 2020. Goal: $300,000. First day, over a million. Final total, more than $5.6 million from 28,968 backers. An absolute runaway success on paper. Then July 2022 arrives and instead of shipping games, Mythic tells backers they need to pay more money between $18 and $69 extra per backer just to receive wave 1. They cited rising shipping costs from the pandemic in the war in Ukraine. Mythic said they'd cover about half the shortfall, and Red Hook Studios contributed $100,000, but that still left backers absorbing roughly $875,000 of the gap themselves. More than 80% of backers paid up because what choice did they have at that point? They were already committed. Then wave two comes around and Mythic breaks the very promise they made when asking for the first extra payment. They ask for more money again, up to $13 per expansion, plus additional shipping. Some backers ended up paying close to $380 in extra charges on top of their original pledge, nearly double what they originally committed to backing.

Wave 2 never shipped. The last Kickstarter update posted in February 2024 said miniature production would soon begin. It didn't. In October 2024, Mythic filed for liquidation. The company had slashed staff by 60%. The co-founders hadn't drawn a salary since early 2023. This wasn't a company that hit a rough patch. This was a structural collapse.

And then in January 2026, 5 years after the campaign launched, Red Hook Studios confirmed publicly that Mythic Games was no longer able to manufacture or deliver the game. As a final gesture, Red Hook released all game files to backers for free. Rules, 3D models, everything. They wrote that they understood nothing can replace the experience of receiving the full board game, which is genuinely gracious, but it doesn't change the fact that tens of thousands of people paid for something they never received and were asked multiple times to pay more for the privilege of still not receiving it.

Darkest Dungeon was Mythic's most expensive failure, but not their only one. Time of Legends Jone of Ark was where the cracks first became publicly visible and legally contentious. The designer Pascal Bernard took legal action against Mythic in late 2019 and early 2020. Two main grievances. First, he said they owed him unpaid royalties from the game's original 2017 Kickstarter campaign. Second, he accused Mythic of making rule changes for version 1.5, the 2019 Kickstarter, without consulting him as the designer. This wasn't a dispute over taste or credit. It was about contractual obligations. The complication is that Mythic had acquired the company that originally signed the contract with Bernard. So, they inherited obligations from a deal they hadn't originally negotiated. There were genuine disputes about how to interpret that contract.

The exact legal resolution isn't fully public. What is documented is the dispute itself, the nature of the grievances, and that all of this happened while Mythic was already managing multiple overextended campaigns simultaneously with finite resources. Joon of Arc got caught in the crossfire of Mythic's broader collapse. There were also reported legal issues around miniature production that caused additional delays for the line. Our honest read, a well- reggarded design caught in the wreckage of publisher financial overextension and management decisions. Not because of anything wrong with the game itself. The designer fought for his rights. The company couldn't sustain its obligations to anyone.

All right, let's talk about a very different kind of publisher failure. Android Netrunner. This isn't a story about companies that couldn't sustain their ambitions. This is a thriving, healthy game ended by licensing agreement.

June 8th, 2018, Fantasy Flight Games announces the end of Android Netrunner. 6 years of consistent support, regular expansions, organized play, world championships, a genuinely passionate global community gone. Not because sales were down, not because the community moved on, because a licensing agreement with Wizards of the Coast, which held the rights to the original Netrunner mechanics and name, was not renewed. And here's what makes it uniquely painful. The intellectual property was split. Wizards of the Coast owned the Netrunner mechanics and name, originally created by Richard Garfield in 1996. Fantasy Flight owned the Android universe. The characters, the lore, the art direction that had defined the game's identity for those six years. Neither party could recreate the full experience alone. A new Netrunner couldn't use the Android setting. A new Android card game couldn't use Netrunner's rules. The game existed only in the overlap between those two licenses. And when that overlap closed, the game ceased to exist officially. FFG's last lead designer was bound by a non-disclosure agreement. All he could publicly say was, "We're very sad that the license was not renewed.

That's all I'm allowed to say." So, the community was left to speculate. Did Wizards raise the licensing fee to a level Asodee wouldn't pay? Did Asthma decide not to renew for strategic reasons? Was it connected to Hasbro's broader business interests? Nobody said, nobody could say, and that silence became its own kind of answer for many players.

And to make it sting even more, FFG had just released a revised core set, an official update designed to help new players get into the game, released knowing the license was expiring. All products were then pulled from sale by October 22nd, 2018. All of it. What the community did next is remarkable. A fan organization called Nissi, NextRunner International Support and Expansion Initiative, formed within weeks to continue the game through community card releases, rules updates, and organized play. They've been running it ever since. The fact that fans had to build that infrastructure to preserve a thriving game is a genuine indictment of what happens when corporate licensing decisions override the investment of the community that made the game matter.

From a game killed by a license to a game some argue is being undermined by its own business model. Sean and Zombicide.

Zombicide is not a failure by conventional measures. The first Kickstarter in 2012 raised $780,000. Nearly a dozen campaigns later, the total raised across all Zombicide crowdfunding sits around $41 million. Marvel Zombies alone pulled in over 9 million. more than 2 million copies sold worldwide. By any financial metric, it's one of the most commercially successful board game franchises in history.

The problem isn't the revenue, it's the model that generated it. Sean's Kickstarter campaigns are built around exclusives, content, unique heroes, special weapons, custom miniatures, entire gameplay variants that is only available during the campaign window. When the game reaches retail, it ships with a fraction of what backers received. We've heard from players who discovered Zombicide through a friend's collection, hundreds of survivor options, exclusive crossover content, specialized miniatures, and then tried to buy it at a game store and found 12 characters in the box. Just 12. The psychology behind it has been studied and written about extensively in the hobby. The exclusives deliberately trigger fear of missing out. the anxiety that if you don't back now, you permanently lose access to content. It drives campaign revenue. It converts interest into commitment during a narrow window. And it works financially, but it fragments the player base between those who could afford to back large campaigns and those who can't. It creates a secondary market for exclusives where prices can be prohibitive. And it trains the audience to evaluate a game not by whether it's good, but by whether they're getting the full version. By 2025, the long-term consequences were showing up in Seaman's financials, a $3 million loss in 2024. Revenue from crowdfunding campaigns dropped nearly 25% from prior periods. And in June

2025, Seimon sold the Zombicide IP to Aszmidy, the franchise that had defined their identity for over a decade. The exact relationship between the FOMO model and Seimon's financial troubles is genuinely complex. Market saturation and broader industry pressures are real factors, but you can only release TMNT Zombicide, Marvel Zombicide, DC Zombicide, and Golden Girl Zombicide before the audience starts to feel like they're being harvested rather than served.

Let's talk about a game with a different kind of problem. Not exploitation, but overextension. Cthulhu Wars from Peterson games.

First, the game designed by Sandy Peterson, the person who created the original Call of Cthulhu RPG. The asymmetric area control mechanics are genuinely excellent. Each faction plays completely differently. The strategic depth rewards multiple plays and the production value, enormous plastic great old ones, detailed faction miniatures, is visually spectacular. This is one of the genuinely good games on this list, and that production value is precisely the problem. The US4 edition currently retails at nearly €200 in Europe before expansions. Each expansion faction adds meaningfully to the gameplay and meaningfully to the cost. The complete experience runs to several hundred euros for many players. Community discussions consistently describe it as prohibitively expensive and a promised cheaper miniature-free version never materialized in any meaningful way.

Then there's the Onslaught 4 Kickstarter. Launched May 2019, over $300,000 raised. Estimated delivery June 2020. Some backers were still waiting four and a half years later. Sandy Peterson said he had personally put the bulk of his private funds into fulfillment. And then the company found itself unable to pay US shipping costs for copies already sitting in a warehouse ready to ship.

What followed became known as pallet wars. Peterson Games listed individual pallets on their web store, asking backers to locate their own pallet and contribute toward a $1640 shipping cost in $10 increments. Only about 10% of the total was raised that way. What actually resolved the situation was a single anonymous individual who contributed over $143,000 to fund the remaining shipments. one person bailing out a company's Kickstarter logistics because the company couldn't do it.

The company newsletter in 2025 acknowledged their errors directly, misreading market demand, overp production of some items and underproduction of others, expanding too rapidly into non-hobby markets, and not aligning team expertise with business needs fast enough. They halted all new crowdfunding in 2020, calling it irresponsible to seek funding for new projects while struggling to fulfill existing ones. That honesty is notable, but it doesn't undo years of waiting or the ongoing pricing problem that keeps one of the hobbies genuinely great area control games trapped behind a cost that most players can't justify. And finally, the most nuanced conversation on this list, Gloom Haven. January 2025, Sephilofare halts Ocean Freight for Gloom Haven second edition after advanced copies reveal significant component defects, warped map boards, faulty scenario trackers, poorly assembled miniatures, issues that hadn't appeared in the samples and pre-production copies reviewed before mass production began,

which would be more understandable if it were a first offense. But Frost Haven's first printing had welldocumented scenario tile warping issues. The community discussion after the second edition announcement was full of people asking why Sephilofare hadn't changed manufacturers after Frost Haven. Encountering similar production problems on a second major release after the first had already flagged them clearly is hard to attribute to bad luck alone.

And beyond production, there's the product line question. Gloom Haven, Jaws of the Lion, Frost Haven, a tabletop RPG, the second edition, buttons and bugs, all real products with real development demands. Backers waited two to two and a half years for Frost Haven. The second edition delay added further months on top of that. Community threads documenting repeated delays and lack of bandwidth as explanations are not fringe complaints. They're a consistent pattern from people who backed multiple sephilofare campaigns and kept running into the same wall.

And yet, we want to be genuinely fair here. None of this points to bad faith. Sephilofare has communicated about problems and taken responsibility for defects. The game design at the core of each product is by any reasonable standard excellent. Our honest read is a small studio that made something extraordinary and then found itself running a company that the extraordinary success of that thing demanded. The ambition outpaced the operational infrastructure. The people who love the games most are the ones who feel that gap most acutely. Which brings together the thread running through all seven of these stories. Dark Souls, Darkest Dungeon, Joan of Ark, Netrunner, Zombicide, Cthulhu Wars, Gloom Haven. None of them failed because the design was bad.

Progress saved