Autobahn Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hi everyone today I'm taking a look at Autobarn which is a 2022 release board game designed by Fabio lopiano and Nestor mangone this one accommodates one to four players and takes one and a half to two hours to play on average before I get started on my review of Autobarn I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so Autobahn is going to look like this when it's set up and this is kind of halfway through again here so we have developed the map somewhat here but this is the main map of Germany here with all these connecting roads um in the top left hand corner here you have this kind of round structure breakdown so the game is basically broken down into three phases and at the end of each of those phases there's going to be an admin phase and each phase becomes longer than the last and it's determined by how fast these roads are built so the first phase will end as soon as 10 roads are built the second one when 12 roads are built and the third one when 14 roads are built now each phase is also going to differ in terms of the value of taking actions or the cost of taking actions so for example in the first era to build a single piece of road is going to cost you six coins but in the third one it's going to cost you 12 coins but also different things are going to uh you know vary in price as well I'm in the top right hand corner here or in the separate board you have these offices where you are trying to get your workers into to score you end game end game points um in fact
this is the only way you can score points in the entire game and below that you have these different kind of offices or these different councils relating to each color of each Auto button so whenever you contribute to a certain Autobarn you'll generally put one of your workers here to show that you've done that which can um definitely be important when it comes to getting money during those admin phases and for endgame scoring you have this track here that you're trying to go around and where you when you hit certain checkpoints you'll get different bonuses and we'll talk about what they do a bit later and you've also got your own personal player board that look like this so generally this is going to be a bunch of upgrades that you can get however when you unlock these things not only are you going to get the ability on them for the rest of the game but they'll also allow you to start pursuing the different Offices here because these do kind of time with each other and you can't kind of climb up on these different points scoring criteria unless you have the matching blocks unlocked on your player board here um you have these Keys which are used to unlock these here you have these little service stations at the bottom which are important to get out on the board to give you kind of passive income and bonuses as you go and you've got a couple of these trucks here one you're going to start with the other one you're going to have to unlock and I suppose more importantly each player person is going to start with a bunch of action cards and there's going to be an action card for each color of Autobarn so there's going to be six to start with however during the Final Phase you're going to unlock the yellow water barn and the other card is going to come into play now each player is also going to get given at random one of these
delivery boards which shows the different Goods you're trying to deliver to the different countries and how much money they're going to offer you if you choose that option so let's talk quickly about what we're trying to do and then talk about how we actually try to obtain that so let's go back to the point scoring board here so essentially these are the different criteria that are going to score your points at the end of the game so these will essentially give you points based on how many people you have on the benches here so if you have or someone in this office it's going to give you a point for each person and this office is going to be two points per person and this one three points per person but you can have multiples in each to really up those multipliers this one here is going to give you points based on the different countries that you deliver Goods to based on that ball that I mentioned earlier and this one here is going to give you points based on your different service stations you build and the final one is going to be relating to the money that you have left in your supply now how do you actually take actions and what are the actions so what you do is that with your hand of cards you're going to select one of them and allocate it to one of these action slots to the top of your player board and these are the five different main actions you can take the first one here is to again deploy the card and then take one of the keys of the matching color so bear in mind there's only one of each to start with there are some bonus ones you can get here but I don't think that's really worth talking about um and you're going to take that key and put it on one of these bonus actions which I said will give you bonuses when you do things and allow you to get into those better offices that end game scoring
the the other ones here are such as building these roads which is kind of one of the main actions you can take and bear in mind that all of these different actions have a limit on how many times you can do them so they're going to start with um like mostly doing being able to do it once but as the game progresses you can potentially upgrade them to doing it twice and then even three times if you do it the third time but yeah let's talk about how we build roads so when you build roads you are going to have a look at somewhere on the network that's stemming out from an already established place so for example um you know this this road was built earlier what you're going to do is that you're going to have a look at how big that link is between the different cities so for example here between Dortmund and Hanover there's a two-piece Road there rather than a single piece like like this one here and when there's a two-piece Road you're going to have a look at this figure for how expensive it's going to be but for a single piece Road it's going to be slightly more expensive and then you're going to pay that money you're going to build the road with a single carriageway and because another action is to upgrade it to a dual carriageway which again we'll talk about in a minute and when you do that you're gonna pay your money you're gonna put the road on the board and then you're also going to put one of your workers on that matching Council like so so say um you know say someone did use this Council here um they'd put their worker on the farthest right bench and push everyone along and potentially pushing someone off the bench and putting them in this lobby area here meaning that they'll be ready for promotion later and anybody at the in the lobby at the end of the game
is going to give you two victory points the second action here is to convert a single carriageway into a dual carriageway and when you do that just like any other action you're going to play a card on that spot you're going to have a look at the matching Autobarn so this one's the white you could have look at that white Auto One find a single piece of carriageway and flip it over to the reverse side like so paying the cost based on the reference here now something that's important is that when you do upgrade into a dual Carriage Way if you have a two-piece Road you're gonna have to do them both at once that's going to be quite expensive now in the first phase costing you you know 12 or then 14 and then even 16. and much like the standard build action whenever you upgrade a um a carriageway into a dual carriageway you are going to put your council member or your work out onto one of those matching benches the next action is to bring the trucks into play and when you do that just like any other action you're going to play a card and then if your truck is on your player board you're going to remove it from your playboard and put it on one of the good locations on the matching colored Autobarn so this is the again the black Autobarn therefore I'd have the choice of Hanover or um you know bad hersfeld or even like krillshime down here but let's just say I put it in Hanover like so now when I put it on that on that um Goods location I'm going to load my truck with the resource type of the matching location say for example this would be the automobiles I'm going to put it on my truck like so and then whenever I play a card and this relates to any action not just the um the truck action if that colored card
matches the location where my truck already is then I get to move it a number of spaces to equal to the round it's on so in the first round it's going to be two spaces and then the second and third round or phase it's going to be three spaces so again you're gonna move it piece by piece moving on along the roads like so and bearing away you cannot end on a spot with another piece um and with the idea here is that you're trying to deliver these specific Goods to these specific locations so you can see here that if I delivered a car to France here then I would be able to take one of these little delivery markers cover up this spot here to show that I've done it which is important of course for this end game scoring because again every different country I deliver to is going to give me points here but it also means at the start of any future round I can actually choose to slide this across here like so and take the bonus action and these bonus actions could be things such as going around this track here it could be things such as getting a replacement card for my deck getting money getting an upgrade and so on and something worth mentioning is that if you deliver a good type that doesn't match the country it's preferred good here you get the money instead however you can only do that once and the final action here is to build a service station and when you do that it's going to be free of charge of course you're going to play a card and then you're going to take the leftmost available service station at the bottom of your player board and free of charge you are going to place it somewhere on that matching Autobarn so I play the Black Card therefore I could put it on this available black service station
space here now these service stations only appear on the double Road spaces and not on the single ones like so and the important thing about these are again not only do they correlate to one of the in-game scoring criteria but also it means that whenever anybody drives past your service station whether that's you or another player you will get a bonus now if another person drives past your service station you always get the smallest available coins and value of your revealed um you know of your revealed spots here so this would be two coins in this example if I had these spots covered up it would only be one however if I drive past my own service stations I will get to choose any of the bonuses that I've unlocked yet so these are a nice way to get some passive income and some passive upgrades now there are a couple of alternative actions you can take the first of which is to pick up cards from your player board and put them back into your hand and each time you do that for every card that you pick up you're going to get a coin for so that's a nice way to get some extra money and to redeploy the cards you've already used now if you've played all of your cards you're going to be forced to take them all back however you do not get any money if you play through your entire hand now the second alternative option you can take is to deploy one of your workers onto the spot here and get this amount of money however you can only do that once per phase and something else worth mentioning is that at any time during the main action phase you can cash in one of these bonus tokens you've collected to take that action and you're going to get these bonus tokens in different ways such as by building on
certain locations like for example if you're the first player to build on this part here then you'll get this bonus token added into your hand and the same applies to making deliveries to the different countries you'll get to take one of these bonus tokens that are still available and these bonus tokens do lots of different things such as you're getting new cards into your hand um they'll let you kind of shift your action cards around we'll let you do bonus actions like this such as you know building a dual Carriage Way moving your truck more and even like promoting your um your workers from the lobby here into the offices now whenever you see this symbol here you're going to be able to move along this track and when you land on these certain locations or certain um icons you'll take the corresponding action which again like promotions but some of them will allow you to upgrade the amount of cards you can play on a certain action so as I said as the game progresses you can potentially flip these over you pay for you know four cards on this column or even five cars should you wish to do that and this applies to all the different ones as well so you know you get more freedom to play cards without having to spend time to pick them back into your hand so we've talked about the actions you're going to take but let's talk about what happens when an admin phase is triggered once all the roads of a certain phase have been built so what will happen is it will have a look at every single Autobahn and calculate the numbers here now these numbers are going to be dynamic and they're going to change as more roads are built so basically they are going to correspond to the amount of different autobahns that they are connected to and to other cities so for example this one here in crow'sheim is connected to a city on
the white Autobahn and it's also connected to a city on the black Autobarn now for each time you do that it's going to be worth two points so that would be a base level of four but they're also going to get upgraded for every single dual carriageway they're connected to so therefore that's going to make it to a six and that's going to make it to an eight therefore this one is a value eight and that applies to all the different cities so this is going to be a dynamic thing where the more connections the more valuable that location is going to be now the value relates to how much money you're going to get at the end of that you know admin phase of during the admin phase so you're going to calculate all of the values of the cities on those Auto buttons then you're going to divide them up to who's sitting on those Council benches so without doing the maths here you're going to add up all those figures and divide them you know the blue player here is going to get three quarters of that money and this player here is only going to get one quarter of that money and after you've worked out all the money you get from the benches here you're going to have a look at your personal root card that you're allocated at the beginning of the game and which relates to a specific route here so you can see that mine is to get to Dortmund to Basil here so bazel is here and Dortmund is all the way up here and then basically for each Road section you're going to add on a 0.4 however you're going to reduce a point for every Autobarn and every service station on that route so the idea is you want to be getting to as low a figure as possible because the lower figure you have it means you're going to get more bonuses so let's just say I ended up having every single Road being a dual
carriageway and having loads of service stations and I got to a value zero here therefore I'm going to get I'm going to get to promote somebody I'm going to get 20 coins and I'm going to get to promote somebody else and during the third and final phase of the game these roadblocks are going to be removed meaning that East Germany is going to be available to play I'm going to introduce this brand new Autobarn representing the fall of the Berlin Wall okay so that's a very brief overview of the rules of Autobahn now let's go into some personal thoughts on the game and we're going to start with some of the key mechanisms here starting with the color coding hand management system here now in theory I think this is a very neat idea I like that restrictive nature of yeah I want to do something with my white card maybe I want to build a white service station because I think that there's a route there that loads people are going to pass by and I want to get all that very juicy passive income there but it means that once I've committed here with my white card I'm not going to be able to you know upgrade a white Autobot I'm not going to build any new road on the white Autobahn and so on so again I like that having to foresake one thing to do another but in theory it actually does make the game feel very slow because I'm gonna have to waste a whole turn to pick all my cards back into my hand and to be able to redeploy that card again yes I understand that's a pivotal part of the game but when ultimately you're just strategy I suppose is linked to your root card which will generally tie to um to one or two autobarns because you know you want to keep on building the same one and build a quick route there
um it means that you're going to have to keep on using those cars and you're just going to be in a position where you're not going to want to keep on playing a card picking it up playing it playing up playing card picking up and playing it again it just feels like you're going through the motions at times and it would be cool to have you know several colors of the same types and that even relates to the actual number of cards you can play in each place anyway because yes I want to build some you know some service stations however I can only ever build one so it's like well I'm gonna have to pick up my cards again just to build another service station so again it just feels very slow in its nature and that also applies to the way that the trucks move around the map yes that's also color coded and I like the fact that it's not actually related to the truck action so no matter when what action you take as long as you're playing that colored card you can move your truck if it's on that Autobahn but again normally you want to go kind of a key route there especially earlier in the game you want to be you know flying down the Blackwater Barn for example but you've already committed to your black card therefore you can't do it again until you pick up your trucks now this should be dynamic it should be a free-flowing thing just in its nature I should be making deliveries left right and center but it just takes a long time to get things moving and it feels like you're pulling teeth at times now that being said I do actually like the way that when the game develops and there's more and more roads being built you can quite strategically start maneuvering your trucks around like for example if you played say a block a black card and then you move it a couple of spaces and move it quickly onto this color Auto button and then you play that card in your next action then you start moving
on to this Aussie button so you can actually start stringing your moves together and strategically planning the logistics of your track to get the most moves out of it so I do like that but again particularly earlier in the game it just feels like you're really dragging your heels with those trucks now I do like the fact that it is kind of counteracted by the fact that one of the upgrades is to bring a second second track into play which I definitely think is worth doing because you know the more actions you're going to take it means the um you know the more movements you're going to get and you're not going to be wasting so much time there so let's move on to this offices and administration part of the game so I do actually quite like this conflicting mechanism of wanting to have people on these seats because when that admin phase hits that's potentially a lot of money to be had there if you are dominating you know one of these benches with a powerful Autobahn with all those valuable cities there um but in contrast if they're sat here you're not going to be able to be in a position to promote them to the other offices spaces here now again that's in theory but in practice um people are just going to be going about their business and passively they're going to start removing you from there and moving you into the lobby now I always found that you've always got plenty of people just sat there doing nothing because especially during the first you know two-thirds of the game there's not that much opportunity to promote people because generally you'll be promoting people in the third and final act when um you can start delivering these Pharmaceuticals to these um different locations so it feels like there's a lot of stagnant parts of the game here where they're just sat here not doing much yes they're going to be worth two points each but it doesn't really feel that
rewarding especially the amount of Hoops you have to jump through to get them there in the first place I also wanted to touch on another problem I had with the game and that was the flow of money or coins in this one but it really did feel like money was way too easy to come by not once did I struggle to pay for any single action I wanted to do it really did always go back to how many cars I had and how many action spaces had already been taken so yeah the cars were the Restriction not the cash at all and considering cash is a big part of this game because that's why you're actually building the autobarns and getting on these seats in the first place it felt somewhat inconsequential so yeah I would have liked to have seen it being a bit tighter in that respect and again not always being able to do whatever I wanted at any time I thought there were some very strange choices made here from a mechanical standpoint the first of which is how that money gets allocated to the players during the admin phases by adding up all those cities and dividing them equally to the people on the bench there just seems like it was jumping through a lot of Hoops and it could have been made way more streamlined by having a fixed amount and maybe even ramping that amount up depending on the phase you're in I thought that maintaining the values of the Cities was a little bit confusing and not totally intuitive because it's not actually the amount of cities they're connecting to but it's having at least one city on each Auto Barn just again more fiddly Rules by Anusha there um especially I thought that this part of the game here were these um root cards was an absolute cluster so difficult to explain by you know trying to get to Value zero that each Road counting as one but reducing one for
each dual carriageway and Service Station you have there just an absolute just yeah mind-bending on the way this worked it could have been so much more simple and again this was not jailing with anybody I was teaching you know I teach a lot of games and I like to think I'm pretty good at it but this just did not resonate with the players at all and I also thought there were some weird balance things as well like if people passed through your um your service stations that would have been a really cool part of the game and it would have been really like a cool decision if people had to make that decision of am I going to go past their service station or am I going to divert around it but in reality you're only getting like a couple of coins if you do so which is next to nothing considering how much money you have in the game anyway so yeah just some weird choices here a bit of imbalance and just some things just didn't quite sit right I really do feel the game could have benefited from having some decent player AIDS and there's a lot of times in this game where we forgot to do certain things like for example we forgot some of the upgrades that we already bought I know this is kind of a general critique that and it happens to a lot of games but for some reason it happened more in this game with any other one and we just forgot yeah I forgot things we unlocked and forgot to use these powers and forgot that we could use some of these upgrades here um sometimes you forget to put people on the council you think oh did I do that or did I not do that yeah just lots of Little niggly Steps there that get in the way of the fun I must admit that I was not a fan of how all the points are allocated at the end of the game it felt like there wasn't enough incentive or enough to motivate you through the duration of the actual gameplay itself it would have been nice if you got points by you know building your
Autobots as you went because you know although you get points by having people on the councils and then hopefully getting the bigger multipliers there it felt like well this state of play is always changing and those points aren't going to be in the bank so again two two Dynamic there and two temporary rather than you know I've put all this work in I spent all this money and all this time and effort I should be getting points for doing that I feel like the game takes way too long to play I mean yes the box does say it an hour and a half to two hours which I don't think is completely unrealistic if you're familiar with the game but my problem is with the engagement I felt like after those first two phases of the game are finished I'm ready I'm ready for the game to be over with I don't want to play a whole new third of the game before the game comes to an end the player interaction in the game is relatively minor I've already touched on the service stops here um you know you're going to do what you're going to do who cares if you pass by somebody's service stop you're going to give them a couple of coins let them let them have it so be it it's not really going to affect your game there's a little bit of jocking position for the um officers here especially when you know an admin phase is coming up and you want your big share of the money there but generally if you're not in one seat you're probably going to be in another one so you know it's generally going to balance out somewhat equally the game does scale pretty well there's going to be more or fewer bonus tokens depending on you know the player count there the same applies to the office seats here so again you're gonna get the full experience no matter who you play with or how many people you play with let's quickly talk about the production choices here I actually think the game looks really cool when it's set up I like the way the board looks I like the
way the offices look Etc and the player boards are pretty decent you know I've got no issue with them at all there are a few little production issues in terms of some of these tokens being very small and fiddly to play with and moving your trucks around the map can be a bit fiddly as well because the goods don't fit in nice and snug they actually do just Loosely lean on the back there the roads are a bit too small for the truck so they don't quite sit on nicely either so yeah a mixed bag here generally I like it I like the wooden pieces they look really cool nice and bright and vibrant but yeah the roads themselves are a little bit small and fiddly Etc and um the board can become a little bit convoluted once you start getting the roads um you know the different types of Roads The Tokens The lorries Etc just just a little bit busy there but still minor critique I actually generally do like the way it's produced and put together okay so let's share some final thoughts on Autobarn so it goes without saying really I did not enjoy this game one bit which was a huge surprise for me considering that the designers here are lopiano and mangone made some fantastically beautiful elegant games such as caramalla and Newton you know amongst my favorite games of all time this is just pulled apart to designs like that it's fiddly it's convoluted it's busy it's confusing very unintuitive in the way everything comes together and it just feels like you're jumping through a lot of Hoops without really getting anywhere the money is just flows to too easily you can always do what you want the card management is just frustrating rather than you know puzzly
and taxing it's just annoying if anything um the cars that you could upgrade with didn't come into play enough everything just took too long you know to move your trucks around and yeah I just did not enjoy the experience one bit which as I said this is generally my cup of tea you know I like economic games um you know Euros are my forte um I play tons of them and this one just did not work at all when I was expecting it to be so good it's got too much work and too much effort needs to go into this one for very little dividends back you know you can play games that are so much more simple than this that offer tougher choices and just are more fun and ultimately this game was not fun for me which is really sad to say because I was very much looking forward to this one so it goes without saying that I'm not going to recommend this one you know maybe I'm missing something but I don't think I am you know I'm very experienced when it comes to games like this and I'm not going to look at playing this one anymore um very sadly actually because I like the theme I like the setting I love the designers I like some of the choices here but um yeah the execution was just way off me I just know what I'm looking for anymore so those are my final thoughts on Autobarn