Kathmandu Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
and finally at number one who would have guessed it's the Stefan Feld game with Catman do so this is the newest of his design from the city collection um so this isn't a reprint it's a brand new one um and it's a racing adjacent game and to be honest if I put um a few games out there to compare it to you're probably going to get a good idea what this game is all about so this is kind of Stephen feld's take on a game like the Quest for El Dorado and also a game like foot Footprints um for me these three games kind of feel quite similar um in this one it's as you'd expect with the Fel game it is a lot more Point salad um and it's also dice driven so unlike these other games I've mentioned this one doesn't use cards at least not in the traditional sense of driving the game it does use dice so basically you're going to set out this big map of these modular tiles which will show different terrain types different things you can visit and at the start of your turn you're going to roll six dice those dice are going to correspond to a independent Resource as well as showing how far you can move um in terms of the pit value so you roll a five you can move five spaces in a straight line essentially um now what you're trying to do is of course you're trying to race to Catman do the first player there will get a healthy amount of points but of course you are trying to visit certain things along the way by visiting these temples getting more points as you go and collecting maps and trying to slot
them together to get some extra points and you're taking photographs by landing on certain terrain types which will match this common pool of animal cards um I like the scoring mechanism there which reminds me of Glenn Mo where if you basically the player with the most is going to score points for each of their cards depending on the player the player with the least so for example if one player had one card and another player had say five cards the difference is going to be how many points each card is worth so you kind of want to stay up with a pack when it comes to taking those photograph cards um also you are collecting equipment cards which will give you gamebreaking rules such as traveling straight through mountains or taking a right turn or you know uh taking a right angle turn because again normally you are restricted to only move in a straight line um so I like the way that each of those equipment cards felt extremely powerful and they were definitely worth having um and I did like the way that you can plan your turn here because I suppose I think a lot of the thing that people will criticize with this game is is that it does feel a little bit rigid because you are again moving in a straight line so naturally it means that you might move this way and then get way to where you need to go and in order to get to the next um modular T you'll need to completely divert and spend your whole time just kind of straighten straightening up which can feel a little bit plotting at times but through the use of those equipment cards you can kind of get around that and make up ground on where your opponents might be
all in all the car the game is mainly driven at least from a points um sense in terms of set collection so again you're getting points based on the sets of cards you're getting um these y tiles you're shedding by um by landing on particular terrain types again visiting these locations um and so on so yeah it was very Point Solly getting points from here and that and here and that um but for some reason I am Charmed by this game and I you know I am a massive stepan fan Stefan Feld Fanboy so do take that into consideration but I like the way that it all comes together and it does have some interesting decisions to be made especially when it comes to trading off which dice to use because not only are you considering you know the the distance you're traveling but you need to factor in the resources that these dice give you because not only each the dice you select to move is going to determine the resource you get which is going to be a huge factor in how many points you get because you know if you need equipment card you're going to need to use the brown Dy if you want the animal cards you're going to need to use the purple dieses if you want to um move more efficiently across certain tiles you'll need to collect these Compass um the compass tokens because you need to shed them or not move at all and so there's lots of different things you need to balance and consider here to keep your supplies stocked up and I also like the fact that you're not always is rewarded to kind of travel the fastest because you're going to miss so many
opportunities along the way and also the more Pips you spend you go lower in turn priority the next turn so again there's different things you can factor in there as well so I think if you love Stephan Fel games this one still might be jarring because it's not his usual fair and if you like the higher end of the Spectrum in terms of complexity in in Feld games like you know your traion um your even your burgundies or even more advanced than that then this one might leave you wanting a little bit because it is a lot more tailored towards say a Gateway plus um group it's not I wouldn't say it's Gateway because there are still some felan know Euro bitty mechanisms but it definitely doesn't have the Strategic depth or the richness of some of the you know more famous F designs but it definitely does have his his trademark you know all the Hallmarks and when you play this game it does feel like a fail game I want I want that's probably the best way to say it um so all in all I like this one I think is a lot of fun it does get a commodation at this time is it going to stand up to the longevity of repeated plays um I think it will I'm not entirely sold on that and I think I will be doing a disservice if I don't compare this to these other games I've mentioned um like the quest El Dorado and um and Footprints because they are so similar I
think right now and maybe this is recency bias um I would put this one at the front of those because I do think there's just a little bit more interesting things going on and deck building isn't my preferred mechanism I do find it a little bit more um a little bit more laborious than being just selecting a dice and moving it that way um and I do like the different layouts you can have in this one and so on there's different that that modularity is there there um but I think this one can be or will be more polarizing and there's going to be a lot of Fel fans that will bounce off of it um because it doesn't have that richness as I mentioned before but still as it stands right now I'm I'm all in I really like it and I'm enjoying my plays a it and hopefully that won't change because I do find it very charming and I do like that tradeoff of racing to the end but also trying to visit all the hot spots along the way and there's even that additional pressure at the end of the round these clouds will start to encroach from board to board um and can even like overtake the players which will can actually start to um rack up these exhaustion tokens um to make your turns less productive and even waste an entire turn so lots of things go on here more than I can probably summarize but at the same time I'm sure you've got a gist of the game um so that is Catman do by Stefan Feld at number one