Junk Art Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to jit games today I'll be reviewing junk art this is a box full of wonderfully varied colorful wooden pieces that you are going to be stacking together to either try and make the tallest structure perhaps the largest structure or just have the last structure standing there is a variety of different tweaks to the rule set I'll explain to you how this game plays and then I'll jump in my review in order to set up junk art simply pile all the different wooden pieces into a big pile of junk in the middle of your table and then you have these 11 City tiles you can randomly pick three of these out or you could choose if you'd like they have a variety of different rule sets what I'm going to do is explain to you three of these different cities we'll do Monaco Pisa and Tokyo that will give you a good idea for how the game plays before I talk about the specific rules for these cities let's go over the general rules for the game there will be a base either in front of you or maybe in the middle that you're going to be playing off of and I'm just going to refer you to the rules because this is the quickest way to go over them you're allowed to add new pieces with one or two hands you can nudge previous pieces on your structure with the current piece you're holding but you're not allowed to actually touch any of the pieces with your hands you can touch the base down here but if anything falls off you are going to remove that piece the last thing is if you ever have a piece that you are adding onto your structure and that one particular piece when you add it on falls off you get a redo and you can put this one back on if it's the one you're just adding then however if in the process of doing this you knock one off then this is going to be a penalty for you potentially depending on the different cities So speaking of those let's talk about them first let's cover Monaco up at the
top we see this lightning bolt which means that players are going to be all doing things simultaneously we see that it plays two to six players and it is going to end once somebody Hits 10 pieces built in their structure down here we have the victory points and we have a 10 and some cards and what that refers to is this stack of cards right here which is accounts for every single piece that is in this pile right here so you're going to shuffle this up and then you're going to deal 10 cards to each player once everybody has their 10 cards we will yell go and simultaneously everybody will reveal these and they will find them in the pile and they will start to add them to their structure and they're going to keep doing this until one person is able to get all 10 of theirs down on their structure so everybody's doing this at the same time and for this one in particular if something falls down that is fine there's no penalty for that you just have to immediately start putting these back together again because this round is going to end the moment somebody gets all 10 of their pieces on their structure not falling down at that point they're going to yell stop and everybody who has 10 pieces in their structure is going to get Five Points anybody with seven to n Pieces gets three points and anybody with 5 to six gets one point so it's a race to try and have the most on your structure when the round ends and hopefully you're the person who actually ends the round next up let's travel to Tokyo we see that it also has simultaneous play but this one is not going to be real time we see that players are going to get a hand of 10 cards this is slightly different than the last time because players will get to look at all these as opposed to having a personal deck we see it plays two to six players and the goal of this one is going to be to have the highest structure not to have the most pieces in
your structure you'll get five fans if you have the tallest three for the second tallest and one for the third tallest and this round is going to end once everybody has played 10 cards and any pieces that fall off don't actually penalize you but you don't get to put them back on your structure so for instance we could look at this hand here shuffle through and decide well I think maybe this would be a nice easy piece to do so we'll put it down over here we'll find the piece and we can add it into our structure and now what we're going to do is pass these nine cards to our opponent on our left and we're they get nine more cards from our opponent on the right so then we look at these nine cards here and we might decide thatth this one looks pretty good so we will find that in the stack and then we will add it onto our structure once again pass these eight cards and do this until everybody has played all uh 10 of the cards that are going to pass to them so obviously on the final round of the game you might just get given this and you're like okay well I don't have a choice I'm just going to have to add that on there and at this point you're going to use this handy dandy metering tape that the game actually comes with to figure out who has the tallest structure that person gets Five Points and then three and one point like I just mentioned for the people in second and third place and lastly Let's Travel to Pisa we see this Arrow which means players are going to be doing actions one at a time around the table it also plays two to six players and the way this one works we see down here we're actually going to put this out into the middle of the table and add another one so everybody's going to be playing off the same structure and now what we're going to do is we're going to take this uh deck of cards and we're going to deal out cards equal to one less than the number number of players so for instance if this is a
four player game we would have three of these out and the starting player would pick one of these and they'd add it to the communal structure so they might take this one right here find that in the structure and add it just like that and then the next player would pick from these two once the player after them picks from this one we would deal three more out and what we're going to do is we're going to keep going until one person has knocked off two or more pieces from the structure and again when you knock off the piece that you are actually adding so if I add this here and it falls off that doesn't count but if we knocked off another piece in the process of doing that I could put this back on and this would be a negative for me because like I just mentioned if anybody has two or more of these at the end of their turn the round is going to completely end and the way this one works is anybody who has not been eliminated gets three points so there's nothing to do with actually having a tall structure or a large structure here you just don't want to be the person who knocks too many pieces off from this communal piece of art and as I mentioned before there are eight other rule sets in the game we have Montreal where once you put three pieces down everybody stands up and moves to the next structure and then Builds on that so you're trying to put that last piece on so it all falls down for your opponent uh we have Amsterdam where everybody plays a little trick-taking game with a hand of cards and whoever plays the highest value gets to decide what everybody else gets to play we have New York where there's a cop card that gets put in there and it shuts everything down at a certain point and you're going for the tallest structure so as you can see tallest structure is somewhat common but there are also a few different ones where people just get knocked out and the people who are still in the game get victory points so there's a variety of different rule sets but the end goals are in general just have the tall
structure or don't be the person who ends the round I didn't show them before but these are the tokens for the fans we have five fans here and one fan there after you've played three cities or realistically if you want to play to six cities you can do that and once you decided the game is over Whoever has the most fans is going to be the winner let's now begin the review for junk art by starting with a few positive points the first of these relates to the incredible speed at which you can pull this game off the shelf dump the components onto the table Shuffle the cards teach the rules and start playing it's like I don't know 2 and a half 3 minutes between actually getting this thing off the shelf even if there's six people sitting around the table and that's because of the really neat way that they modularize the rule set so there's one core rule set which is so incredibly simple it's just add pieces to your little block whether it's in front of you or in the middle of the table with one or two hands you can't touch previous pieces with your hands but you can nudge them with the other pieces if they fall off something might happen to you okay now let's read the actual City card it's just so cool how simple that rule set is it's very it just makes sense for this kind of stacking game there's no like oh you can only use two fingers or you know that kind of thing uh I also really like the way that the rules are put in place for the different cities you flip open to that uh to that page in the rule book and then just read that page in fact I enjoy reading the flavor text along the top as well just to try to get people kind of into the vibe of what this one particular scenario is trying to make you do and it's neat because you just do that scenario and then once that's done you flip to the new one and you teach the new rules to that you don't need to kind of teach a whole bunch of rules before you start playing which is great for a game of this weight and it's
really neat to have a game that could play up to six players where you could just sit down and start playing pretty much immediately positive number two is simply the wonderful variety of these wooden pieces that you're going to be using to put your little structures together you have some really kooky stuff in there at first glance you might think that a game like this might just have tetraamino style things like a little L and maybe a little U and oh it's a block that kind of thing but no this one has you know curved pieces with flat spots on the same ones it's got both it's got like a flower pot it's got blocks with notches cut out of them and it even has little spindles with wheels on the end there's all sorts of these different things and it seems like from a production um component quality perspective they seem somewhat balanced like even the little spindle ones with the wheels on the end we've stacked like three of them on top of each other before and they're kind of rickety but it seems like they were produced well enough that they were somewhat symmetrical in like the mass and all that kind of stuff that goes into these different components there's really not much more to say about it really it's just it's a great pile of colorful wooden bits positive number three relates to the level of energy that this game can bring to the gaming table we have had some really wonderful moments putting these structures together where you know everybody's watching as one person tries to put the third or fourth one of these little skinny dowels on top of each other it's all Ricky and then they let go and it it mobbles a little bit and then stops and everybody's like oh and then it doesn't or when something unexpectedly falls down like everybody laughs there's just a lot of Engagement with people around the table with stuff that everybody's doing sometimes everybody's adding a thing all at the same time but other times everybody's watching is one person tries to do one
really precarious thing and it's wonderful when they're able to pull it off especially when you see the expression on maybe the next person's faces they realize that the this round is not over they now have to go and they're like oh no what am I going to do and it's just like this uh great escalation of emotion within each given game of course this is going to depend on the specific rule set but in general it seems like there's just a lot of good energy that this game brings to the table let's now shift into the neutral section and I only have one of these to cover and it relates to the potential for the occasional anticlimactic ending to a round and even to a game like I just mentioned that there is great energy at the table for the most part but there has been a couple times where you are playing in a city where the whole round is going to end the moment one person maybe knocks down two pieces or something like that the moment one person is eliminated then you just end the round and I have played uh at least one game of it where that our third City that we were playing we're playing three cities we started and somebody knocked down two pieces on like their fourth move so we're really just starting like nobody had really done anything crazy they fall over and it's like oh um the game's over then we like counted up the points and it was over and it was was not bad like this is not a negative Point by any means it just it it can happen with especially the the cities that just end the round as soon as one person does too much of a bad thing which is most of the different rounds and this is going to be rare and in general that energy is good but it's a little weird when somebody like acally fidgets a bit or just drops something
just slightly and their whole thing falls down way sooner than anybody else expected and it's like oh well that tension never quite built up for that one given round and hopefully you're in a situation where you're going to play another city and like get right back into it but when the Great energy of the game suddenly kind of tapers off right at the end it's kind of a bummer but it's not that big of a deal really and now it's time to cover my single negative point to the game which has to do with the variety of cities that of the game and how some of them really don't feel like they add actually that much new to the experience there are some really great varied things going on with the cities in this game but many of them kind of feel like subtle variations off of each other and some of them feel like they are overly complex for complexity sake like one of them has a little trick-taking game where everybody has a hand of cards and they put them all down you reveal them and whoever played the highest value card gets to choose who every who um which pieces everybody else is going to be putting into their structures and this is like an extra mechanical layer that in reality did not seem to add much to the actual gameplay around the table it wasn't like I was sitting there like oo do I go high or do I go low right now I'm not sure it was just kind of like I I guess I'll play the highest card and maybe I wasn't playing that round as strategically as I could have but this is not really a strategic game um and it seemed like many of the rounds are also just you know have the highest structure and here's a slight tweak on how you are going to be giving cards to your opponents maybe you are you know having a a hand of 10 cards you pull one and you pass the nine to your your opponent or maybe you are picking one card for this opponent one card for that opponent one card for yourself and they're all so
similar that not all of them but a good chunk of them are so similar that it feels like they don't actually bring that much variety versus another subset where you are doing some pretty ridiculous different things like building a single Tower in the middle or building three things and then everybody gets up and moves to the next spot and then Builds on the same Tower those are really cool so realistically my only negative is that out of the 11 possible cities it feels like you don't actually have 11 unique rule sets you have more like five or six unique rule sets and that's kind of a weird thing to be complaining about honestly so now let's discuss the variability to junkard and this is a direct Branch off from that one negative I just mentioned where I was saying I was bummed that so many of the 11 City rule sets seem to be kind of Samy but that being said even if like I said that five out of those 11 all seem like they're essentially the same city you're still left with like six or so very different r sets and that gives the game a very good amount of repay ability definitely above average certainly more than I would expect from a filler style 20-minute game like this so every time you sit down there's going to be a little bit of variety going on now as the person who maybe picks the the cities if you go randomly you might look down and be like Oh all three of these are kind of the same thing maybe I'll like ditch this one and bring in one of the realtime ones or something like that to make sure that the three that you have is a bit spicy and interesting and that means maybe going with random cities every time is not necessarily the best thing for you to do but all that being said every time you sit down to play the game it's going to be a little bit different I mean obviously once you
play this game like 10 times you're going to have played all these different rule sets but the variety and mix between them uh is nice having one round you're trying to build a really tall structure on the next round you're furiously trying to put all your pieces down and it's real time and everybody's going at the same uh speed I like that variety of play based off of the central mechanics so yeah the variability is quite good junk art plays two to six players and I think that it probably plays best at four but for most of those player counts I think it's going to be fine down near the bottom I think two I have not played a two-player game and I don't think I'm necessarily look to do it although I would give it a shot it's probably a fine experience but I feel like a big part of this game is that energy that's created around the table by having several people watching other people like almost fail and that kind of thing so at two mechanically I think it's probably going to be good it probably might even be more tense as far as an actual gaming experience like trying to just go one-on-one with those fans trying to have more than your opponent but uh yeah in general I think four is good uh the reason I say four and I think five is also great is that most of the cities in fact all but one play six players and I'm not actually talking about there's one city in the game that's exclusive to player people who also have the game flick them up which I don't have so that's why I'm saying 11 cities all but one play up to six players but um the one that doesn't is kind of interesting but also I just think at six players which I have played for certain cities it can slow down a little bit more than I'd want for this kind of filler Style game that you want to keep the energy going all the time and if you maybe you're doing a thing if it's a city where you do a thing and then you have to wait for five other
people to do a thing that can kind of bring the energy down just a little bit but I would never not play the game at six players it's definitely fine at that but like I said sweet spots going to be four in conclusion as soon as I first heard about junk art I became excited about it because I am just a sucker for Unique looking dexterity based wooden block kind of games like I uh really enjoyed hamster roll although eventually I was a bit frustrated and disappointed with some of the rule sets that's one with a big circular wheel on the table and you put pieces and the whole wheel spins it's fun but there were issues you could kind of game the system but with junk art the rules are so simple that it seems like you can't really game the system you have to just play the rules that are given to you and it seems like a pure wonderful gaming experience I really enjoyed playing this game it's definitely exceeded my expectations that were already pretty high for it and a big part of that is how quickly you can just play the game if it's the beginning of a game night and a couple people are trickling in you know less than six people or six people even I can just pull this off and like let's just play junkard until a couple more people show up and then we'll split off into a couple smaller games and yeah you just dump the pieces out in the middle of the table and people like what okay they start sorting you're like no no no don't sort it just Shuffle that real quick I'll teach the rules and we'll be playing in about two minutes from now and that's just really nice to have that especially when it's an engaging fun experience that brings a good positive um energy to the table like people are going to be laughing people are going to be groaning it's just a good time in general and I think from a mechanical perspective there is a really cool amount of variety here in general I don't like timer based games but there's a couple of the rule sets that are time
based where you're kind of furiously putting things on there and you know what even if I might not enjoy that one specific City and I I have actually enjoyed them by the way but even if you didn't guess what it's going to be over in like three to five to eight minutes or something like that and you move on to the next rule set where you're trying to build a tall tall tower or you trying to build a thing in the middle and not be the person who knocks it over there's just a really great variety it's really fast to get to the table it looks wonderful at the table every single time I've played it I've had fun I think that just really wraps it up I strongly recommend it it might be slightly pricey but I think for the components that you get in here and the potential for longevity as far as a filler game that I could see pulling out for a long time in the future I think it's a really great package I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting my channel through patreon including the producer level pledges if you too would like to directly support my channel you can do so at patreon.com get games I'd really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel thanks for watching