TDG: Battle Commander: Volume I - Napoleon's Italian Campaign
Transcript
Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know my printer doesn't always make music but when it does it jams. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Battle Commander, Napoleon's Italian campaigns from Sound of Drums.
In Battle Commander, Napoleon's Italian campaigns from Sound of Drums, two players take on either the French Revolutionary Armies or the Armies of the Austrian Empire as they do battle in the 1790s in Italy. All right, ladies and gentlemen, I'm not going to get in the weeds. There is a ton of stuff going on in this game. There's other great resources out there to kind of learn to play the game. I'm just going to tell you basics of gameplay and then tell you what I think. Now, the game has various scenarios that you can choose from, different battles and skirmishes and what have you. And you're going to go ahead select which one you want to play. Now, you have different kinds of units, both the Austrians and the French. Of course, you have infantry, cavalry, artillery. Uh many of these two have special characteristics and kind of different levels. They have different kind of ranks on them as well. So, there's a lot of different kind of units you're going to be having in this game, but broken down into those basic arms of infantry, cavalry, and artillery. Um, now the game board itself, the various maps that come in this game, and there's a lot of different scenarios you can play and a lot of different uh maps here are kind of unusual because it's not this is not a hex encounter game, but rather you have various squares. And the squares, of course, are adjacent to other squares.
Now, you have terrain, right? You have rivers, you have mountains, you have woods and stuff that that are all kind of intersecting these squares. So, your units have, of course, movement points as they move into these uh squares. They may cost more or less, what have you. There are things like zones of control and and opportunity fire when enemy units are moving into these things. So, there's all these kind of different basic concepts we're familiar with in war game, but it is kind of this new map with these with these squares. Now, basically how this game works is you have a deck of cards. Now, some of these cards are your commanders, and you have your own kind of player uh boards where you're going to put your commander card that may give you certain special abilities or things that kind of inhibit what they can do. Uh so, you're going to have those things there. And this, of course, reflects kind of the historical situations of these armies and these commanders. Now, you're also going to have uh another uh drawing cards that you're going to have. you may be able to replace commanders over throughout a scenario. Critically, too, these cards have a lot of information on it. They can be played for different things, different effects um during the appropriate time, but they're also going to have battle tables at the bottom.
More on that later. Now, as I say, you're going to have your own player raid. You're going to have here um places for cubes and reserve cubes that you can use. Um you're going to have little battle markers, these little wooden battle markers that you're going to use to kind of limit the number of times you can actually engage in a battle. But critically, what you're going to do is at the beginning of every uh round, you're going to fill up a cup or a bag with uh cubes, different colored cubes. These different colored cubes are going to allow you to do different things uh when they are drawn. You'll also have the ability to uh discard excess cards and draw more cards there at the beginning, but then you're going to move to kind of the uh draw cube phase. Now, as I say, when you draw different colored cubes, it's going to allow you to do different things. Now the French are represented by the blue blue cubes, the Austrians by the white cubes. So when you draw a white or blue cube, it means that particular army is going to have some options. Now if you draw one of your colored cubes, you can move. And if you're within range of your HQ, um you can kind of move freely. If you move further away, you have to do skill checks. Essentially, you are drawing cards and you're checking the numbers to determine if the skill of that unit. If the number on there is less, equal to, or less than the skill of that unit, that unit may move. If it's more, that unit is not going to be able to move as you want it to move.
Now, some of the cards you hold in your hand are going to have events that trigger when your colored cube is played. So, if you are the Austrian army and you have a card with a white cube on it, you can play that card for its event effect. you can gain an attack token, meaning you're going to have more opportunities to attack later with that cube. You can also put that cube kind of in a reserve, meaning you can be able to use that and, you know, to react and do other things later in that round. Now, because you do have the those cubes in reserve, uh, that will allow you to react if your enemy does something, you can react to that appropriately. Um, also too, if you want to, you can just choose to pass and not take any actions. Now you have the yellow cubes or the rally cubes. And when you draw a yellow cube, one of the things that happens for free is if you have any reserves coming in on that turn, uh you can go ahead and bring them in in the appropriate location as soon as you draw the yellow rally cube. Now, when the yellow cube comes out, you can also discard a card to either gain an attack token or a reserve cube. Now, with a yellow cube, both sides can take turns uh essentially trying to rally units, trying to get them back up to strength. Uh you do this by essentially checking cards against your morale against the specific skill checks there. Uh you can go ahead, you can bring your armies back up to strength, your units back up to strength uh until both sides pass. Now if a red cube is drawn, then you go to the attack phase. Now beginning with a player who has initiative the greater morale, they can go ahead and they can launch an attack and then the opposition can
launch an attack. And you can keep doing this, but remember your supply of attack uh tokens is limited. So, you may not want to spend them all at that time, but you can go ahead go back and forth uh trying to best your enemy. Now, in a battle, you're doing different things. You're kind of adding up your strength of both the attacker and defender. You are um looking at not only kind of the strength of that unit, but also if you've got wing support, meaning you've got people on your flanks that are also adjacent to the target, what can they give you? any kind of terrain effects or rivers, anything like that that might affect your strength and then your enemy strength. And then you're drawing a card from the top of your deck. It's going to say kind of depending on what the unit is of kind of their strength, if it's if it's, you know, what the effect of the attack is, and you can go ahead and cross reference that with the rule book, and it'll tell you what happened. Does the enemy lose strength? Must they retreat? Um, of course you're doing fire attacks and melee attacks. So you're looking at, you know, whichever chart there uh is appropriate and you're resolving the the uh effect of that attack. Now, with black cubes, you have three black cubes in the bag, and the first and second black cube you draw, you you draw cards. When you draw the last black cube, that ends the turn immediately. So the the the the turns, the rounds, I should say, these rounds, you never quite know which cubes are going to come up. So that kind of doesn't let you know what your actions are going to be. And it's entirely possible, you know, you can draw those three black cubes pretty quickly and
neither side can really do the things they need to do. Or depending on the draw, it could heavily favor one side over the other before the end of the round. Now, when you're done with that phase, you're going to advance a turn marker. You're going to check for victory conditions. If no one's won at that point, you can go ahead and give ground. You can kind of move yourself back a little bit. So that's basically how a round plays out in this game. Now, what you're trying to do in this game is a few things. Uh, you have specific scenario conditions that often revolve around victory flag locations, usually villages or geographic points, and you're trying to to take enough of those in order to win. But if you can force your enemy to get all the way down in morale, if they they lose the morale, then of course you will win as well. Also there may be some scenario specific victory conditions but if you are able to win the specific victory conditions of your scenario then you win battle commander Napoleon's Italian campaigns.
We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history books on history military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen, Battle Commander: Napoleon's Italian Campaigns. Uh, this is a game I was very interested in. I saw it, you know, on BG. I was kind of excited to check this one out. Now, um, right off the bat, I'm going to tell you I like this game. I think this is a fun and challenging game with a lot of really cool mechanisms going on here. Uh generally, um I think if you're a fan of Napoleonic combat games, uh you'll probably enjoy this one. It to me it was it it kind of felt fresh in a lot of ways in the sense that um you know, it wasn't a typical Hex Encounter game. The way the squares are on the board, I thought was kind of new and fun and interesting. The maps are all beautiful.
Great artwork here. So, I really I really appreciated that. And I think to me, um, I like also the the the card system here, the way the cards are used for the events and they trigger off of the cubes, but also critically too, those those combat tables at the bottom. That was a very fun way. You don't use dice, right? You you draw the cards and you look, that was fun. That was always fun. You're sweating every draw with that. Really, really like that bit as well. Um, now also too, I really to me what was most fun about this game was that cube draw system. And what I mean there is, you know, as I say, as soon as you get three black cubes, that's the end of the round. So, you never quite know which side is going to be favored in a specific round and which side is going to be able to get the the um advantage here. And you never you're not quite sure when the round's going to end. As soon as you have two black cubes drawn, you're really sweating. Well, I I want to get this done and I want to do this. I want to move these guys. I want to bring these guys in, but but am I going to get a chance before the end of the round? And you're and every draw is, is this is this draw going to benefit me or is it going to benefit my opponent?
So, I I really like that. I thought that was just very tense. A lot of fun. Outstanding. Really enjoyed it. So, there is a lot of stuff I really really like about this game. Now, having said that, I do have some non in not insignificant issues here. First of all, um I feel like the rule book was a little over complicated for what it was trying to do. Um I don't think it's a great rule book. It's not certainly the worst rule book I've ever read, but I just feel like it could have been a little streamlined, could have been a little more concise. uh Sound of Drums, you know, I uh I remember I played their 1793 game, which is a fun game, right? An area control game with some war game aspects to it, and I really I enjoyed that game, but again, it's the same thing. The rule book in that was really not very good. I was really disappointed in the rule book with that game. So, I I don't know, maybe Sound of Drums meets better editor or something. I don't know. But but the rule book did not impress me. So, that was an issue. Another thing, too, I wasn't wild about is the size and shape of the box. It is ginormous. Now, they did send me the expansion with more scenarios in it, and I just played a couple of the scenarios from the from the base game. I do like that that it all fits in in the core game box. You can put the expansion in the core game box, which is what I did, and that's pretty cool. But I just I feel I mean, it's big to to accommodate the maps, and I get that. These are mounted maps, so that is awesome, but I just I don't like
games that that that are this big physically and give this big a footprint to my shelf. I'm not a fan of that. And then um to I think maybe one of my bigger criticisms here is this is because largely because of that rule book. Um this is not an easy game to learn. It's not intuitive. In fact, I sat down with Ry to play this game and I had read through the rules and I sat down with Ray to play it and I'm thinking when I'd read the rules, there were some things I had some questions. I'm like, well, as soon as I get it out, soon as I start playing it, I'll be good. So, I did that. Uh we started playing it and we we were just scratching our heads about some things and we're looking at the rule book and we can't find good answers and we're not so we ended up just packing it up and playing something else that night. Al, who had bought this game, he'd been playing it largely kind of solitire, which is not super easy just playing both sides because there was some hidden information here, but he was kind of doing it to the best of his ability. And so he kind of came over and he had figured out a lot of these systems and ideas. And so where where I bumped up against something, he's able to know, Cody, this is this is how you do it. So I kind of learned from a teacher. And I'm not, you know, I'm to the point now where I read a lot of rule books and I understand, you know, I'm not omnipotent, omnisient. I'm not going to um know everything about a game, but I feel like if I can't even get the basics from reading the rule book, if there are some significant things that prohibit me
from playing a game when I read through the rule book, that can be an issue. And that's something I've talked about before on the channel. And I I I I don't necessarily like games where I feel like I have to be taught by another person after I've already read the rule book, you know. So, there's that. So, all told, this is my kind of my final verdict here. I think this is a fun game once we got it going. I really enjoyed it. But for me, the [snorts] the learning curve and really quite frankly, the teaching curve, I I would not want to teach this to somebody because of some of these issues. Um, I'm probably not going to hang on to this one. I'm probably going to donate this one or see if a friend wants it or I'll donate it. Um, and it it's not because it's a bad game because like I say, once you start playing it, it's pretty fun.
But there are these other issues that kind of mitigate my desire to play it again and and to hang on to it. So that's kind of my final verdict on the Cody scale. Despite the issues I had, I am going to give it a seven. So I think it's a pretty good game. I think it's a game if you get a chance, you should try it. But I think you have to decide for yourself if some of these negatives are justified by by by the fun gameplay because it is fun gameplay. Uh so that's my final verdict. A seven on the Cody scale. Um it's a very interesting game. Thank you once again for joining us today on the discriminating gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on board gamegeeek, on Facebook, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. Uh we'd ask you to please like this video and subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you really like what we do here on TDG, I would humbly ask you to click on my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where I talk about books on history, military history, fun things like that. I even post some of my lectures on there. It mean the world to me if you'd subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do really like what we do here, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. Are monkeys good at combat? Only if it's gorilla warfare.
Please somebody on my feet again. And I DON'T KNOW WHERE I'M GOING. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody.
Okay. I didn't understand that law. It just