Skip to main content
Loading video...

Let's chat about the new release format! (ARKHAM TOWN HALL)

Transcript 1:03:26

Hello everybody and welcome to an Arkham Town Hall that I'm joined by Beard and Daniel from Quick Learner. How's it going everybody?

Yo, it's pretty cold.

It's Yeah, I hear it's

cold.

It's cold here too. I think it's it's a cold day on Earth which is great because we're going to have some hot takes as chat has requested.

Uh this is an Arkham Town Hall where we're going to be talking about the new format of releases. uh kind of just like hypothesizing uh what we would like to see, what we wouldn't like to see, any preliminary thoughts we might have because the reality is we haven't played with any of this stuff. So, we don't really know exactly how we feel about them yet. Um and uh we're doing this uh in the town hall format where we're going to have chat with us as well. So, we're going to be bouncing off some chat uh vibes here. if they want to add uh add points or ask questions, we'll definitely be here to uh let them uh let them uh share all that stuff. But this is going to be a nice little fun video where I get to talk about Arkham with two great people. So, it's going to be a good time. Um Daniel, Chad just gave you the first player token, so I'm actually going to throw this to you to start. No pressure, but um I can ask a question so I don't just throw you in. Is there of this new release format uh is there a product that you are most interested in of the five that they announced?

H okay. Um yeah I'm interested. So interested I'm going to define as like I am curious about because it's new and that is the deck building expansion. Is that what they called it? The thing that is not the existing investigator expansion with investigators all the time. like they said, maybe they'll have them, but maybe it's going to be something really neat where they can design some more thematic or mechanically interesting sets. Um, I mean, maybe it could go with either of these products, but I bet this is how we're going to get bless or curse back, right?

Mhm.

I mean, that just seems natural to have, look, here are some bless and curse things going on. we're not going to revisit this until we, you know, either rotate this one out or or or whatever else. But it allows them to design without having to worry about, gosh, we need some other cards in here that support the investigators in the box or uh the card pool in general. They can just say, look, if you love Bless Curse, here it is. If there's no Bless Curse stuff that you're interested in, then don't buy this. It won't matter. So, that seems really cool.

Yeah. Yeah, I think uh something that you've said in the past, Beard, and I've come to agree with you on is the Hemlock Veil in particular feels very like jumbled, right? Like there's a lot of different archetypes that are kind of just all competing for space in that box. And it probably would have been nicer if they had like instead of just having like Kohaku and Bless Curse, Kohaku could have just been released as a mystic investigator in this uh in this like Blurse pack.

Yeah. or have like Kate Winthrup and a weird science pack, which doesn't necessarily have to be all cards she can use, but just science themed cards for all classes.

Mhm. Yeah. I'm I'm very curious um because they said in the announcement article which they didn't say during the live stream was that these deck building boxes don't usually contain uh investigators which um to me implies that there's a chance that it could um which would be really neat, right? Where it's just like here's a small package of cards with an investigator that goes with the theme. But I'm also curious if they uh always stick to a theme or if they would also just be like here are cards that we want to release into the world for all of you.

Could be. Uh that is odd that they use usually though for a product that hasn't been introduced yet though.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I I I think that the designers and Fantasy Flight right now are in a battle of tempering expectations. um where everything they've they say right now comes with a don't worry, don't freak out, like but this is what's happening. Uh and I think we know why that's happening, like why they seem inclined that they need to do that. um they're very perceptive of the community and uh for the most part uh there hasn't been a lot of positivity regarding this change.

It does confuse me a bit because we're still getting like a healthy amount of content and there's plenty more to come. So, from me not involving myself in the drama too much, it looks like a kid complaining that their sandwich was cut into squares instead of triangles. Mhm. And like I I understand and respect uh the sentiment that because so for people who don't know, I'll I'll see if I remember to link the video to the article, but uh campaign expansions are are changing. Uh there's going to be short campaign expansions, which are three scenarios, and then the big campaigns um are five scenarios, which are three scenarios less than what we've always had. And the question that I I kind of push out there to people is is this um are you is it one of those things where like five feels small because we've always had eight and we don't know what five is like? Cuz I totally respect the idea of uh people worried about um like being able to play their deck less than they want to in a run of a campaign, right? Like that evolution that happens over the eight scenarios is kind of what become to be the norm. or even like the idea of people worrying about the amount of experience you get. But um that's I think pretty easy design-wise to kind of solve. Like that's just like a like very like a switch you flick. Um but like the amount of scenarios is definitely a thing. Um but it's one of those things where even I'm looking at this and being like five does feel smaller than eight because it is. But I wonder how much of

that is because uh eight's always just been the norm because 8 was decided to be the number at the start, right? Because that's what they did for Lord of the Rings and they decided that for reasons that we don't know.

Okay. This this is a different question entirely. Um should I answer this now? Do you want us to talk about this now?

Yeah. Okay.

To say but you go first. Um, so my take on this is that eight has been not normal for a while,

right? Both Hemlock Veil and Scarlet Keys had different numbers. Usually lower than eight. You could make eight happen in Scarlet Keys. Um, but usually it was going to be at seven. If you're managing your time, you could actually pull it into 10. I mean, Edge of the Earth was the same way, right? you could uh make it longer or shorter, but we've never seen five in the same format, right? Usually there's been like more scenarios in the box where it's like choose six of the eight. Um so I mean I feel like they've experimented a bit with the the length recently, so I'm used to varying length, but five wasn't one of those things that happened very much. So I've never seen five.

Maybe they're going to make five uh palatable to those that are used to seven to eight, but um it feels like it's on the lower end. And I wish that they had not made that jump from 8 or 7 all the way down to five quite yet and maybe left themselves more open to it could be anywhere between five and seven or eight and let them figure out what makes the most sense for the campaign they're designing. uh instead of locking us into five, maybe six.

Yeah. Uh in the announcement article, they said the the small boxes were primarily going to be three scenarios, but they said there could be some wiggle room. They didn't say that for the big box scenario in the article, but Duke implied it in the in the stream where he was like, it's this is like

uh not set in stone. This is just the expectation, right? Um because I I I do agree it is it is a pretty big jump all the way. Like I think I think a lot of people because uh our brains are are weird with numbers and stuff like that. Six would feel comfortable. Everyone would be like I could take six, you know? Like even Fen and chat a six with two episodes each part of it a traditional three-act structure, right? Like that is a thing that we're kind of used to because we like to like put shapes to things. Um I see five and I'm like, "Oh, that's like a like a fiveact play, you like those have existed as well. So like that's how my brain even kind like tries to like make sense of it. Um but the thing that I don't want to jump on beard's toes here. So actually before I say this beard, I'll throw this to you. I'll let you you can share some of your thoughts here. Okay.

It's I think more narratively driven than people think it might be because a lot of stories especially in early Arkham were very stretched to make it fit eight scenarios. And if the story you want to tell only needs five, then even going up to six is going to feel awkward. So as long as it feels like a complete cohesive story at five scenarios, I personally am not going to mind and I hope others don't. It's

I agree with that. Yeah, it's it's interesting and that's why I'm actually glad that the three of us were able to be here because I think we all actually have like a different sort of approach for how we view a scenario a campaign and its structure, right? Cuz like I know Beard, you're very voros, like you're like you're that's your big thing, right? I know like Daniel, you and I have talked in the past, you really enjoy the experience of upgrading your deck and seeing it play out over the course of the campaign. And I'm very much like individual scenario-to basis. I don't care about the number. I'm just like what is happening in this scenario. So I think the three of us have a very good depth of what we look for in a campaign which is why I'm excited to be talking about it here today.

So hemlock bail I think is super interesting to talk about because to me it doesn't feel like it was only six. It felt like it was longer and part of that was the preludes. Part of it was a lot of stuff happening in between with the uh the reading and then there was the extra scenarios. Um there's like the the mini scenario that's a prelude but not really a prelude. And then there's one that you just don't play because it's your um your playthrough is only pick three. But it was a really nice structure where it said here's three days. Here's a day scenario. Here's a night scenario. And it makes perfect sense. Like I don't think you can shave off anything to make that story happen the way that it did. I don't think you can add anything. Right. Six was perfect. Um, so I like that narratively five makes sense. It can make sense and so can three. Uh, but I don't see why six or seven couldn't. Uh, so to me, I'm a little bewildered by them saying chapter 2, this is what we're aiming for without I mean, no one asked for no one announced six

for Hemlock Veil. no one announced

10 for Edge of the Earth or however many that you end up getting in um

Scarlet Keys, right? Uh so like why tell us now? Why like so these uh issues that come up? I I I think it's because as I said earlier, they they feel like um they're trying to set expectations and temper uh reactions because as we see in chat, uh there's someone right now who is uh asking us asking how much money FFG pays us to defend it. Um which is a an an unreasonable take to have, right? Um like uh I think that that's just like crazy [snorts] talk where people who are like I mean like right now in this video Daniel's even criticizing the choice of five right I'm uh I'm very much of like uh I'm waiting to see and beard is all I mean you as well Daniel you're saying yesterday like all your thoughts are just like preliminary here like we're not actually like saying anything one way or another we're just giving our thoughts and the space that we have But when there are reasonable reactions to things uh in an unreasonable world, people assume that we're getting paid to to say these things. But this is just what we truly believe, right?

Um let me go on record saying right now that I have made $0 and0 from anything Arkham related I've ever done.

Yeah, I can't say the same. I actually technically have been paid by FFG, but not for this. like this is not uh what uh what is here. Um

but I I will say that like I'm not telling people be optimistic and just ignore all criticism and just accept as it comes. I'm saying we don't know everything yet. Mhm.

So, [snorts] why why get in the negative spiral before we even know everything or we even know like like I'd say once we have the whole course set um player cards, we'll know like 25% of what's coming in this year.

Mh.

I I'm not prepared to say whether it's going to be great or horrible when I only know a quarter of it.

Yeah. And I don't know why people are immediately jumping on like

even week one where they saw like 5% of the total cards that are coming. They're like, "Yep, I know now definitively this is going to be horrible." Like,

yep,

just just wait.

People need to be patient. That's it.

And it turns out there were a lot of great cards waiting to be spoiled, right? We we just saw last week earlier this week uh an ally that's going to change the course of Mystic card pool in all formats, right? and also investigators in all formats. Yeah.

Oh my. Um yeah, let me just sort of jump in on that and say that um while I have trepidation about like just the raw numbers of like five scenarios feels low, but it also is in the context of chapter one, right?

What are ways in which the designers can uh make the issues that we're at least that I'm I'm bringing up less of an issue? because I don't think they're uh they'd certainly have thought of all these things before, right? Maybe even they preferred to have longer uh campaigns themselves, but they're going to have some ways of dealing with the problem, right? My biggest issue with a smaller number of scenarios having played say Dream Eaters is the deck progression, but also just the scenarios are discreet things. You don't always see all the cards and it feels bad to have a short campaign and you spend a bunch of XP onto something and you never see it. Do you really get to know your deck? Now, there's some ways to fix that. Like, what if the scenarios are longer?

Mhm. Yep.

Right. We're used to scenarios being uh, you know, about average of of 15 rounds or so with lots of variation. But what if they say, "Look, we realize this is a problem and we're going to fix it in some other way that we don't anticipate yet because we've not seen the fuller picture."

Yeah, I think that's a that's a great point. And um I think as well um I I think they they really are intending for the standalone scenarios to be ways to also increase the length of a campaign. I think they're trying to give the players more space and modularity to play these campaigns how they wish. Um, the other thing I'm also very curious about is if these five scenario campaigns are truly five scenario campaigns or if it is like hemlock Veil, right, where it is um there's like more than five scenarios in the box, but you only play five in the campaign because that would certainly help like maybe not the length of the campaign, but it would make I think there is the idea that people feel like they're getting less for the same amount of money, which in all fairness, I understand the fear, but we haven't seen the prices of these boxes yet.

See prices at all. Yeah.

Yeah. And another thing to consider is that a lot of these changes are probably not creative choices, but they're probably logistical choices.

Because if you want to put out four products a year, you need to reduce development time as any way you can. And setting a cap on how many scenarios a campaign can be is going to help with that because the the dev time for a campaign isn't linear for the length of the campaign. It's exponential. Mhm.

So

like a four scenario campaign or let's see a six scenario campaign isn't going to take like an extra 50% of time that a four scenario campaign would. It's probably more like two to even three times as long because there's more factors for every single step you have to go through and account for.

Yeah. So giving themselves a limit of five is probably like not so much um like limiting the player so much as saying like we have to cap it at this so we can keep the ball rolling.

Mhm.

Yeah. I think that's like it's Yeah. Sorry. Yeah. You go Daniel.

I was going to say beard, you know, you're the guy here who has designed a bunch of campaigns. Uh, did you feel beholden to like this eight number or seven or or whatever the number of scenarios was when you went into designing things or did you say, you know, screw it, I'm going to do it the way that I want to do it?

It depended like like some of the campaigns I've made could arguably have been seven, but I felt like eight was the expectation, so I did play to that. But others like Jimanji, I wasn't going to stretch that into eight scenarios. is like, "Yeah, there should be four because that's more than enough for what the campaign is asking."

It's it's it's a combination of expectations and again fitting the story. I think the story plays a bigger part than people realize, even if they're not like all that invested in the flavor aspects of the game.

Mhm. I agree. Um, I think a big thing as well that I I talked about in uh my video where I I covered the article is I think the most interesting thing is that the designers have essentially said there is no more structure, right? Like for all of Arkham's life, we've been like there is a campaign box, a player card, and a scenario pack each year. That's what we've had for pretty much the entirety of the Arkham's life. The most exciting part of Arkham's release was when the investigator starter decks came out because it was a new unexpected product. And what is basically happening now is they're going to be saying they even said like we might not get like there might be a year where you get a small and a big campaign in the same year.

There might be a year where you get the investigator and the deck building. There might be a year where we don't get an investigator pack, right? They're basically now saying they're going to be designing. We get four products a year but this these products are going to change from year to year and there's no set structure. So like even the design team can be adaptable, go with the ideas that they want and there is potential for um just like different like each year is going to be different and it's going to be a little bit more it's going to be more interesting because the design is more open. I feel

I think they said that three things are kind of fixed, right? That you're always going to get a campaign, a standalone, and some kind of player card expansion. But you're right that it might not have any investigator cards in it, the player cards, right, that are the actual investigator cards. So yeah, you might have like your investigators from the previous year to hold you over for a couple years. But I don't think that's that big of a deal. People who are worried about that kind of thing, I'll just point to myself as having recorded a video a month ago or so, maybe two months, that was ranking all the investigators that I've never played before. And I'm a content creator. Like the expectation that some people might have that people who play the game a lot have played everything. It's just not true. Right. You're just the outlier, Justin. I think having played every investigator in in a year.

Yes. Yeah. Yeah. No, it's true though, right? There's there's a lot of game that you probably haven't tapped into and you should

uh worry you should worry about what you have versus what you you're not getting, right? That's just I mean that's just a healthier lifestyle like a like choice to live and perspective on all that generally but it's true there's a lot of game and one thing I do also enjoy

uh is that the designers stated that we don't expect everyone to buy everything right because now they're making four products a year so you as a consumer can choose what you'd like to buy and what you don't like to buy and maybe if they see oh these three scenario campaign boxes aren't selling to the extent that we were hoping to they might adapt, right? Like that's the thing, right? Like this is this can just change as well as time goes, right? So if you are someone who thinks they're getting scammed because you're paying more for less even though we don't know what the prices are, show show that by just not buying it as opposed to complaining about it and buying it anyway, right? Like you you put your money where your mouth is, right? and

take a while for them to change. But I agree that like some of this is feedback driven by feedback they've already had, right? So I do want to voice even though personally I'm not someone who's clamoring for shorter campaigns, I hear lots of people, you know, have a good reason for saying we can't play this game to the extent that we want to because eight scenarios is a huge time commitment. And I've been part of player groups that um have fallen apart because it's impossible to schedule. So I I actually understand this criticism quite well. Even though, you know, it you're you have to give something up for that, right? It's never as easy as, okay, let's add more players to our player base. We're done. We did it. There's a lot more that goes into how do we accommodate everyone without alienating everyone at the same time.

But I do think it's true that part of the decision was, hey, we can get more players who aren't going to commit to these huge campaigns. And maybe they'll love Arkham because of that. And then they're going to be like, we love Arkham. We want to play more Arkham. We'll buy the five scenario campaigns. And then maybe they'll say, we really want more than that. Please release eight scenario campaigns again because we'll we'll do them.

We don't know that yet. But that's kind of the opposite of like don't buy things because you don't like them. I think also if we add more players to the player base, they can then vote with their own wallets and say we actually like this content too and maybe we'll get into buying actually everything. So that's an upside for FFG here.

It is casting a wider net for players too because with more campaigns you have more different flavors of campaigns too. Mhm.

So, like an example I can give is I've been told that uh someone got their friends into Arkham not because they're interested in Arkham, but because they thought it'd be fun to play the Alice campaign.

And because they like that, they got into the rest of Arkham as well. Like the just the right theme might be enough to to draw you in. So, they can try a lot of different things.

Mhm. Yeah.

And we also don't know like if they'll try other things too cuz something I'd like to see would be like a combination of a campaign and investigator thing. Like you have a four scenario campaign, an investigator who features in that campaign and a smattering of player cards across all five classes that they can take for like trait build trait based stuff for example.

Mhm.

Just as like one package deal as a a boost on all fronts. Uh this is actually something that I also would love to see them explore what it what a three c what a three scenario campaign means and how that can be changed in terms of how design is approached. This is something that I don't know if I actually talked about this in a video but Travis Bern and I have talked about it a lot where I I would like love like a three scenario campaign where it's like an excursion down into Yth just as an example, right? So you start at the jungle and then you go down, right? And the first three scenarios is the descent. The first two scenarios is the descent down. The third scenario is in Yth, but then things go bad. And then there's a fourth and fifth scenario where you go to through scenario two and one again, but you're escaping, right? Like that's something that it could just be done with similar player cards, right? But like what does the how can the rules change in a scenario that we've already played with a map that maybe has slight variations but from a different perspective, right?

And now suddenly that three scenario box is actually really a five scenario box, right? Like that would be the thing that I've been I'm hoping that the designers are able to like discover and explore because I think that would be really cool.

Yeah, they've been focusing on replayability a lot in the pretty much since Edge of the Earth. [clears throat]

It would be weird to throw that out now.

Yeah.

Right. Uh, another idea that I've heard some people throw out is what if you have a campaign where there's Okay, so we have two like many many campaigns that exist, right? Fortune Folly has a two scenario structure to it already, even though it's a single standalone and you get to pause. I'm pretty sure you get to upgrade your decks, but I'm not 100% sure on that between the two. Uh, but the Guardians of the Abyss is exactly that way where they're two pretty hefty scenarios as one standalone. But the reason I bring those up is that both of them uh by the nature of their difficulty, I think Guardians of this more than the other uh require you to start with some XP. And maybe one way of addressing the this isn't long enough to actually see the upgraded version of Idex. Maybe they have something that says an optional variant of it where you start with 19 XP

and you then continue along with three scenarios.

Yep. Yep. Like Yeah. Even just the the concept of linking like a short campaign and a long campaign, right? Like that adds up to eight conveniently, right? Like maybe there is some design intention that they could throw in after the fact. And if not, maybe right now, maybe after the announcements are here, we'll see it in like two years when they've had the time to settle and like the reaction to this and work on that. Um because uh Magic the Gathering works two years ahead and I imagine it's pretty similar here for for FFG, right? Like it's it's one of those things where um

I I I there's there's a lot more that goes into this than just like snapping their fingers and having a set the next day, right? Like that's uh that's the the truth here. So everything they're talking about right now and the reactions that they have as you said Daniel when I said like they could react to like the increase the length of campaigns down the road. You wouldn't see that for a few years. It's not going to be instant. So it's like we can't expect it to be

okay. I can throw out this comment that I read. um that on Reddit because I was fed a a a topic while I'm avoiding Reddit right now. There was a there was a question that someone asked that actually was very intriguing to me where they asked if uh do we hypothesize that uh it's a five scenario campaign because that's what Marvel Champions has in their big box expansions. There are five villains that you uh go up against and there's five scenarios in the box. And while the game is different, um all the Marvel Champions expansions do feel very um full at um at the uh at five scenarios. Again, it is very different.

I'm going to actually get this uh comment on the screen, but I really enjoyed this person's comment here. So, I'm going to I'm not putting you on blast uh person who commented this. I actually think this was a very good perspective and it puts a lot of what I thought in here. So, I'm going to I'm going to read this here. Uh, I think it is less to do with Marvel Champion showing the way forward and more to do with the previous process not filling them with confidence or sales to continue. The last couple years had seen roughly a campaign expansions, investigator expansion, and a standalone. My opinion is that the move from the blister packs meant hype for the game died. Content creators often spoke about the lack of things to cover once new investigators and campaigns released. Standalones were never really a highlight in the year for Arkham as many of them worked well in convention setting and massive multiplayer. I imagine sales for standalones were less than other products. If you look at BG numbers, you'll also see over the last few years, the number of owners of the campaigns is less over time, potentially hitting that newer campaigns are receiving less and less sales. With 10 years of products and SKs and less sales, I could see why executives might feel the game need a little kickstart.

Also, the designers were being backed into a corner of card design and interaction. Chapter 2 makes sense from a business perspective. Designers get a blank slate. The game model LCG can start again and attract anyone put off by the amount of content. So, when looking at the one uh at what to release, more frequent releases make sense. Keep people engaged with the game. Content creator previews. New stuff always a couple months away. No getting bored and dropping the game from your rotation, but you can increase frequency with eight part campaigns. Also, is the eight part box a little on the high side for when the market will engage with? And why is eight the magic number? It's what the game is used. We are used to it. Doesn't mean it's the only structure the game could possibly work for. So, breaking the content down into smaller chunks may have the benefit of allowing more frequent products, releases, and hype, bringing the cost down for the biggest prices, items, or shrinkflation. New players can abboard on board with the game. Marvel Champions at Five Scenarios was maybe a better cost per product model, but I think there was probably plenty of reasons that the direction of the game changed.

Not sure how it will land, but I can see why they rolled the dice and thought the new direction would attract more sales than it would lose from disgruntled chapter 1 players.

Mhm.

It's also hard to weigh because a lot of the discourse online is only the people who are not happy about it. A lot of the people who are either happy or just waiting are not commenting at all.

Yeah.

So, a lot of the posts are negative.

Well, that's a really good comment. Um, I don't know much and or enough about Marvel Champions to to comment on that end other than look, it's the same studio, so it makes sense to maybe unify in the same way that we got the move to uh current environment versus legacy in Arkham and Marvel at the same time. So, this makes some sense to me if if it's true or not. U but yeah, from the business standpoint, this all makes sense. I I totally get it.

Um maybe I don't have much to say about it because I kind of agree with all of this.

Yes. Yeah.

Yeah. But at the same time, um, yeah, there's always some risk about changing your model with when something worked with the player base. How do you make sure that, uh, it still works and they don't have, as you mentioned before about uh, the lead time to release if they're working two years ahead, um, you have to make sure that the content that got doesn't have any feedback, right, does well in the meantime. Otherwise, everything stops, right? if this was such a bad decision, which I don't think it is, um that the game dries up in the next two years, they don't have a chance to fix some of those problems. I don't think that's realistic because I think the game is doing quite well.

Uh but I I think this is totally correct. I'm very like I'm very intrigued to see what five scenarios and and what and three even look like cuz I can imagine getting together with people and just hammering out a campaign over a weekend and I think that's very attractive to to a lot of people. So I I like that. Hope that it is true that the type of game that we're playing doesn't change significantly and I don't think that it will. I just, you know, we're used to a particular structure and change is sometimes scary when that changes, but a lot of other things are changing, too. So, we have a lot of things to get used to at once.

Yeah. Yeah.

We'll see if the narrative is satisfying because like even Jumanji that I made into four, it could have been three. I just felt like there was too much packed into that third scenario, so I extended it to four.

Yeah. And I see some people talking about um champions for the campaign. Uh I'm I'm I'm I don't play the campaigns for Marvel Champions. They also don't work for me. But it's five scenarios. Like you get like you just if you play them in order like the five champions uh you get or the five villains. That's kind of like the the intent. Like that to me is kind of the same as playing like a scenario a campaign in Arkham.

Um

but I also I I also want to echo the part in the middle where it's like chapter 2 makes sense from a business perspective. I also think it actually like even goes sense I think it also makes sense from a design perspective. I think that there is a lot I think there's a lot to be gained by looking at something that you've been doing for a long time and asking why have we done it this way? Are there alternate ways that we can do this? Is there maybe something that we can discover if we look at it from a different angle? if we just modify it slightly. Um where like to us an eight scenario like a three scenario loss can seem like a lot but maybe it's just like from the perspective of the looking at it they're still designing eight scenarios at a time. They're just splitting it into two boxes, right? Like and even just like how do we what are these small changes we can do and what potentially amazing things can we discover and what things can we learn from that, right? I think that that is more interesting than just always doing the same thing again and again and again because it's always been that way, especially when it comes to game design.

I've seen it happen for games before. Sorry.

No, no, go ahead, Beard.

Okay. I've seen it happen with games before where it'll have a longunning game like this where they keep having the same format and you get posts online. They're like, "Anyone else feel that the game is stagnating?" So that's a that's a risk on the other factor like if they didn't go with this new model, they'd have people disappointed that there wasn't enough new and interesting things and they'd stand to lose just as many players as they might lose from this switch.

It's so random business stuff that I have no head for.

No, absolutely. You're right. Um, I wanted to ask just out of curiosity since we have three different players here and just sort of demonstrate that I bet we have different answers here. Um, one of the issues about shorter campaigns versus longer ones that I've read about is some players say, "I've had enough with my deck after five or even after four. Like, I want to I want to move on to a different investigator." And like I said earlier, it's sometimes hard to build decks for every investigator out there. you don't have time to to run them through campaigns. Uh, at what point in the campaign, if ever, do you find that you are ready to move on to a different investigator or a different deck?

I actually have a pretty good answer for this already.

Go for it.

So, when I do a lot of testing for my own uh stuff, standalone scenarios especially, I test at 19 XP because it's kind of a mid strength. And I find when the decks get really powerful, what scenario you're playing doesn't matter. You already have the tools in your deck to succeed no matter what it throws at you. So, I think that mid-range of power is where I enjoy the game the most, where I have tools that can uh come out on top of the game in surprising ways, but I still have to account for what the game is going to give me. So, I'd say around that scenario four, scenario five mark is where I feel like I've had the most fun. And past that, either I haven't scaled with the game and it's going to stop me down or I have outscaled the game and I don't care about what it gives me now.

Um, uh, mine is less in the tangible XP space, but more uh, mine is actually by scenarios. Usually around like scenario six, I'm like still having fun with my deck, but I'm kind of like thinking about the next one, if that makes sense, where I'm just like,

uh, I'm kind of just now like I know people there's there's people out there who love XP, right? So maybe it is like I don't have a number like where I where I hover around, but at a certain point I'm like I don't want to upgrade anymore. Like stop giving me XP. I'm done. Like that's kind of the point. And it's usually around scenario five, six, maybe seven if I'm playing a rogue

or a mystic. Yeah.

Okay. So, maybe we don't have different answers for this one. So, my mind actually is about six or seven. And um the only spin I'm going to put on this is it actually depends more on the campaign and the scenarios I'm playing. I I am feeling it less that I want to move on if the campaign has some great scenarios at the end where I'm excited to see how does this deck do in this scenario. Uh depths of yacht being one of those, right? I don't I'm not like always trying to play for the secret ninth scenario of Forgotten Age. Like that's it doesn't matter as much to me because that scenario is like not that exciting after you've done it.

But Depth of Yth is a fun scenario. you're you're testing your metal and uh yeah, if you've got too much XP, maybe it's a a snoozefest, but we've had some great runs of it. Uh Justin, you and I have that really unexpectedly challenging run

when our decks were otherwise very very good. Um and that's where I don't feel it as much. If the last few scenarios are kind of dull or disappointing, then I'm like, what else do I need to spend the XP on? And and I'm I'm with you probably with both of you on this where I think the problem is more on the challenge of the campaign based on the scaling of your decks. If you have, and someone in chat said this too, like maybe there's too much XP, you start making your deck worse because you're spending all of it on things that don't really fit anymore or the level zero cards were perfectly fine for for your build. that that's where I'm like, "This isn't interesting anymore, and I'd like to move on to a new challenge." But it usually fits at about six or seven.

And on that note, I really hope that chapter 2 player cards clamp down on bonus experience on player cards, if not eliminated entirely.

I agree. It'd be nice.

I'm I'm still endlessly frustrated by people who have given me their final 80 XP decks for running through one of my campaigns that [snorts] only gives like 40 max.

Yeah. Um, I mean I I do feel like uh we've seen a trend at least in the player cards that have been uh spoiled in the uh the core set where uh things are slightly more expensive XP-wise. Like there was the uh I think it's like the Elos one, the augur of Elos or whatever it was called the the uh clue investigating spell.

Um where it feels a slightly overpriced at three, right? But I think uh as we saw also with Sledgehammer, things are are changing. You know, like that kind of stuff is different than it was before, which I think is exciting and kind of interesting to see here.

Which is why all of this to me is it feel some of these changes feel wrong for chapter one because we know what chapter 1 looks for in terms of your deck's power and what the expectations are on the campaigns. But maybe chapter 2 and a new design philosophy about what campaigns are, this will be totally fine.

Yep.

Yep.

Well, and um before we move on from campaign structure entirely, there was a lot of discourse in uh the PBG server yesterday about kind of superfluous scenarios where

like even though there are official campaigns that people love, there's still scenarios that people could take or leave or even skip over. So, is reducing the size of campaigns really going to hurt when pretty much every official campaign has scenarios that people don't want to play? Yeah, I think that's I mean I think there are uh so yeah, some people who love them all, some people who can cut. Um but I think it just shows that um sometimes maybe there is the perspective where the eight number was the eight number because it's always been the eight number you know like maybe even like say for example into the maelstrom uh like what if that had some more time because there was only five scenarios in inmouth right like what if the flashback for that one was like they it's like oh we don't have to solve this number in eight scenarios but instead it's We have Pit of Despair, then we get the three flashbacks in a row and now we're like going to fight Dagen, you know? Like that could be something that could have been um with hindsight and like in like looking back on the design like maybe campaigns that we have would work there. Like I think that um some of them like even though I'm not a big fan personally of Circle Undone, I think that there is like there's a there was a a a reason for each scenario in the order that they happen in. Right. But then I look at like um Inmouth or even like Forgotten Age and I'm like, "Yeah, I could I could cut this down, you know, like I don't need a repeat of the first two scenarios

halfway through the campaign, right?" Um, so it's like one of those things where I think it now that the five is here, looking back at old campaigns with that lens is a very interesting thing to think of yourself as a player and then maybe it puts it to perspective of uh in the theory that if there was less the five scenarios that were there get more time, polish, energy, does that actually lead to a stronger campaign experience?

Yeah. And again, it depends on narrative cuz we have like all of Dunich for example, but they could have easily started the story by Armmitage tell you uh Warren and Rice are gone and so is the book. We need to go to Dunwwich right now and there goes the first three scenarios.

Yep. Uh it gets problematic if you only have five scenarios and two of those are a dud. It Yes, that's a fair point because then in in if you look at the math more a bigger percentage of the box is a dud. But the thing you have to remember for Arkham is that it's a dud most likely for you. In like the recent Arkham, I actually like look at a lot of stuff. And

in the newer campaigns, there's less of a hive mind regarding uh thoughts on individual scenarios

where there is less of a thing where there are universal um like bummer scenarios, right? cuz like um I think like even in for example Drown City which has a lot of mixed um thoughts on it. Um I've never really seen a consistent pointing to what part of the campaign like what scenarios people don't like. So, I think it's one of those things where

individually, yes, I think that's a fine fair point, but I think for the entire uh like Arkham world as a whole, I think it that that that argument does lose a lot of value.

So, I'll just be the broken record again and say the balance between narrative and of the campaign and the narrative of your investigator itself, right? Because it's like some of what I've said before is, you know, deck building and mechanics that feels very much like you need enough time to let all that happen. There's narrative of your investigator, too, right? And having enough uh scenarios to progress uh I think is important. I mean, in fact, Drown City made that a key part of what the narrative was. Choosing the different tasks were supposed to add some backstory to who you were. and neat to see that develop over a larger number of scenarios too.

And one other comment I have about the campaign length is that for the average players who are probably going to play more like my group, we can only get together like once every two to three weeks. Mhm.

So when the campaign is already spaced out that much, whether it's five, six, seven, eight scenarios doesn't really factor as much. It's just another day that we finally get together and play.

Yeah. Yeah. I think that there uh there you even said this as well earlier, Daniel, I think there was a lot of truth to um the idea that eight is just too long. Uh it was this it was this interesting thing where I think campaign play um in the board game industry as a whole was really long and then I think now the reaction is that ooh it should have probably be shorter and I think a lot of campaign games that I've seen in other things are now tempering and like bringing down the length of their campaign play across the board. Um, and I think that like cuz like when we saw like Gloom Haven and Frost Haven, like those were those are big boxes with a lot of stuff like Kingdom Death Monster came out at a very similar time and that was also like that's a gigantic game.

You're like sitting down for like 25 sessions for that game, right?

Um, and then now now like some of the newer games in the similar space are um getting smaller. It's a big thing actually. One of my my big beefs with Earthborne Rangers is that like 20 sessions for a game is really good. And Arcup has always been on the shorter side for this. It's it's been eight, right? But maybe five is just following that trend of things shrinking down a little bit.

What's going on with Dn D? I don't play D and D at all. So, I mean, it's kind of a similar you have to have a group and you commit to doing something. Um, are those campaigns getting shorter, too? Uh, so C, so D and D doesn't really have like an end point. Like D and D is always kind of like it's it can go on forever kind of in a way. Um, I don't know about their official like campaign uh books because I haven't read one of those in a while. But um, I mean there's a big thing about D and D where they say part of the game is organizing the players, right? And that's ultimately true even for like Arkham Horror and stuff like that.

It is.

I know a little bit because I do play D and D with friends. Uh it it depends a great deal on what you're doing in the game because like Justin said, there are modules you can run and it'll tell you that this is a campaign that has an end point or uh multiple sections and it's for this level range of players. And when either you finish it or you hit that level and you feel like, well, we feel pretty satisfied with this, you just move on to something else. And if it's something original where it's just somebody's original story that you're developing, there really is no end point. It's up to whoever is running the campaign, like if there is an end goal or if it's just we're going out there for adventure.

Uh, according to Nick, official books have been more adventure anthologies and less big campaign since the new rule set released, which makes sense. Smaller bite-sized pieces to actually finish something as things go.

Hey, I know that guy. Also, uh, Jenny Barnes & Noble, yes, I have played Binding of Isaac. Thanks for asking.

I've noticed this with other games, too. Um, I play a lot of like other kinds of card games, trick takers mostly, and um, for a while like Trick Takers in the history of card games anyways, where like long you play a particular game for an entire night, maybe a couple games of it. Um, even just think of things like bridge. Um, and nowadays it's like you play the number of rounds or hands for the number of players that you're playing with and then you move on to another one. So like these smaller bite-sized pieces of games are doing very well. And you know, maybe Arkham needs to um situate itself in that larger narrative of of what gaming is like these days. That said, even just organizing people for a particular game like that is easier because you don't require any sort of setup. a lot of small campaigns in maybe different player groups and whatnot for Arkham means you need another session to discuss deck building and who's playing what. That's maybe not that hard, but I think that just means we

a session zero for Arkham.

A session zero for Arkham. That is a good idea to have more time uh [clears throat] uh experiencing the campaign together. I think that's a very good idea.

Mhm. All right. All right, I don't think I have much else to say on this topic. Uh, chat, I'll throw it to you guys. We can give some space for you guys to ask questions or I know Holly Holy Helicopter You said something that I've since gone by. Uh, here we go. I have a super cold take that I somehow didn't really see around. Uh, since I have all the old campaigns and replay them all in rotation for a while, the new campaigns will just be two, three, four out of my total 14 or something campaigns. In that context, any difference, length or otherwise, from old form, it'll just be fresh and can't ruin the whole collection anyway. It'll take 10 freaking years of old and new campaigns to be 50/50 in my collection.

Um,

yeah.

Yeah. I mean, like, I think that's uh again, I think that's a very like healthy perspective to kind of have for this. It's just like I mean like that's I don't want to sound like belittling when I say this thing that I say but like I view Arkham Horror as kind of like a toy that I get to play with, you know? Like that's not me trying to minimize that like all the work that goes into it or like even the amount of time I spend with it, but like it is entertainment. Like that's what it exists to be. Um so I'm like why am I worrying so much about my entertainment? because if it's entertaining, I'm going to like it. And if it isn't, I have a lot of Arkham that I still find to be entertaining.

Yeah, Holy Helicopter makes this other comment that I've made before, which is a lot of the people who are um complaining about this kind of thing probably already have a full collection.

You know, for the newer folks, it's a different question about things going out of print, but um you still have all the old stuff. And as I said previously, I play this game a lot and I'm still learning new things and enjoying things that I haven't gotten to. I still haven't played Without a Trace, the secret scenario in Scarlet Keys. Not trying to, but you know, maybe one of these days I will try to and then I get to experience something new. There's still a lot of stuff in the existing products that I think people aren't playing or they haven't played to the fullest extent. I know there's people out there who say, "Well, my group refuses to replay campaigns." Uh, but

that's not an Arkham that's that's not an Arkham design problem. That's a player choice problem. Yeah.

And if you if you don't like the the exact format of things, then build your own thing. You can dip your toe into homebrew and come up with something that you want to see. Yep. Additionally, as well, um, now that the release cadence is quicker, um, it's one of those things where if there is one a product that you personally view as a dud and you don't want to buy in 2 to 3 months, there's going to be something else you can look forward to as opposed to what we have what we had currently, which was wait sometimes a year, right? Like that's like a lot better as a consumer if you are interested in consuming Arkham, right? And if if you're not interested in consuming Arkham anymore, you don't have to, right? Like no one's making you you buy it, right? Like that's a thing that I think you also you can have some agency with as well. And I know that sounds obvious to people who are like who already think that way, but some people feel like they they need to because that like the sunk cost fallacy, right? But you can stop if if if you're not into it anymore. That's life, right? Like that's that's how things go. you can just you can just move on, play something else or as they suggested in the video in this live stream, only pick up what interests you, right?

And something that has really affected the community overall has been those long silences between products because like even when we know something is coming, they still have like eight, nine, sometimes 10 months before they actually speak on it. If once they get into this format and we know something's coming every 3, four months, then there will be news more frequently and they will speak up about it more often.

Yeah.

But one thing that I commented to u uh Duke and Ryan was that I think Arkham's community is set to be in the best place it's ever been be partly because of Olivia, the community manager.

Yep. And I know that she is the best community manager we've ever had because I actually know the name of our community manager. That's how inconsistent it was before then.

Mhm. Um I was going to say something on the first point. What was your first point before this? My Oh, when we were talking about um I had

the the time between communications, all that.

Oh yeah. Okay. Yes. Yes. And then this also goes to Olivia who is I agree is is fantastic. Um, but I've been playing Arkham since it released, like since like the the the first announcement article because we I I was playing Elder Horror when Arkham or the car game came out. We were like, "This is so cool. I can't wait to play this." Right? Um, Arkham has gone through um very little product changes in its lifetime, right? But it has gone through a lot of how the game was handled in terms of communication to the players. And I cannot stress enough right now that this is actually legitimately the best communication that Arkham has ever had in regards to what the products are coming. The players can be expected to know what those products could be and also the release windows for these products. It has never been better. And this is like 100% the truth as someone who is an Arkham Boomer and has been there since day one. So, it's one of those things that um when I was making the path carcosa video and there was those when I was looking back in time and I was seeing um that uh there was the uh the all the articles that were released for each individual investigator. I remember thinking this was so cool. I missed this because we haven't had this in years. And lo and behold, a month later, we started getting release articles for every investigator in the core box. Now, yes,

the core box is a specific thing that is its own beast and it should be covered um uh that it should be covered like um individually, but the fact that it's here and going beyond that we got a product road map. I said that this was like the best inflight report they ever had. This is me just speaking my truth from being here since day one. While I hasn't making I wasn't making content from day ones on Arkham release. I mean we were we played the game and released it like the night that we played it. But I have been here from the beginning and I cannot stress enough the communication right now is very good. We know so much more than we've ever known. It might not be what you like or agree with, but they're trying and they care. As someone who started midway, because I think I got into the game towards the end of Circle Undone, I didn't know what to expect because I didn't really see any live streams from the developers until they were announcing Endmouth.

Mhm.

Yep.

Yeah. Uh Liv has been awesome. I mean, I've met her in person uh last year at Arkham Con. Um and just all of the communication has been very good and when things don't go right, it's very quickly fixed. So, I mean, she's doing a great job, and I think it makes it more fun and interesting to be a a content creator when um the company that is making the product is interested in the content creators being part of it. But not just us, it's the fans, too. Um they're all very involved with um what's going on. It's not just a never listening to feedback about how to improve. So, I mean, it makes sense like the designers have been on this side of the table before. So, I'm glad that it's all going very well on that respect because yeah, like last year, the Drowned City uh reveal season, there was some turnover. You know, some people went on vacation and whatnot, and it was just very difficult to um know what was going on. And I think this spoiler season has been uh exciting because everything we're getting something like almost every day.

Yep. And it's also not ending like we're about to go, they said in midFebruary, we're about to enter the starter decks. I I it's one of those things where I feel like I've uh uh I got like the monkeykey's paw where I I was like I want to talk about Arkham. I wish there was more content and like more releases at a faster schedule and now I'm like no please stop. Like I I have to wait till like Friday to record my Sunday video. Please no stop with the spoilers. But that's my own perspective. Yeah. Even just subdividing it feels better because like every set of cards we see it's like this is what the the spoiler is going to be for the next two weeks rather than the old model where it's just like memorize all these dates for the next three months. This is all you're going to get.

Yep. Yep.

Yeah.

Also the fact that we're seeing lots of other content creators, right? Yes. It's not just, no offense, Justin, but there was a time when I think you had like six different videos of spoilers throughout the

Yeah. So, with Scarlet Keys, we got we got like seven cards. Yeah.

Yeah.

Uh but it is I I agree like um the amount of different content creators who have been able to spoil things is is is great, right? Like it's it shows just how deep this community is. And that's something that Livin said in the the stream just about like seeing all the awesome content creators that uh people should spend more time watching because you get more like opinions and thoughts on it and uh it's you get the more people you have giving you thoughts on Arkham content like the the more enjoyment you're going to get out of it as well.

That's why it's fun to do this with the three of you. Yeah, the three of us. Yeah, Jenny was in in chat was saying, "Who are these other two people who aren't Justin?"

Hi,

Daniel.

And every creator has their own way of doing it. There are those guys in Spain that had it printed on t-shirts and then unveiled it at the the convention or

I think for for the Scarlet Keys one, uh, Reed, who's now part of the team, he got basically uh, Whispers of Hypnos but good. So, he did his whole little skit based on that and it was great.

Yep. Uh there was the one that was also just uh spoiled by the um that just spoiled the the the talent for Rogue that like uh he built like the panorama and then like lit it on fire, right? Like that's like

everyone does it differently and it's it's really cool cuz I mean like I feel like I just take the easy way out. I just put the c the card on a screen and talk about it, you know? But like having different people do it different ways is also just really is just it's it's exciting and engaging. And even people who aren't like on camera even like they've gave one to the arkham. Yep team and they showed it off just

immediately as a here's how you can use it.

That was a cool way to do it too. Just

the like not just the the talking about Arkham but like the deck builders uh approach to it too.

That was also with like your name. You could put in the title of the card. That was fun.

Um

yeah by Justin's fingerprint kit. Yeah. I love that. Yeah. Yeah. Mine was kind of boring, but uh I also had unexpected courage to talk about. I made it fun in my own way. I love how many people I got with, "Doesn't this guy know that this card has been in the game for the past, you know, 10 years?" I'm like, "You're right.

That's crazy. My legacy decks are going to pop off."

Yeah.

But I guess I've gotten that reputation for the dry humor now.

Yes. Yes. Um, I think we can close out our town hall here. Um, I think overall, uh, we all are kind of waiting to see how it's going to be. It's hard to comment on things when we don't know how they're going to actually be. I imagine we all have individual um, desires and what could potentially be disappointments if things go this way. But, uh, we're going to talk about that more as we get more size and shape and actually see like Children of Blood in our hands. Um, it was stated that it was designed with, um, replayability in mind. Also, there's going to be like difficulty scaling, something that they've never really explored. Um, which I think is again cool and interesting and something that I've always wanted. Give a reason to play hard that's not just token worse, right? That is a very engaging thing.

So, I think it's going to be an exciting time to be an Arkham player. Um, and I think it's going to just be fun to have more Arkham to talk about as the release schedule gets as we fall into this new release schedule.

Mhm.

Um, so thanks for joining me guys.

Yeah. If you have anything else to say, I can throw it to you if you guys want any closing statements as going to say uh someone in the chat mentioned that do we not trust the the designers to do their best here and I do.

Mhm. Yep. I do too.

Yeah. It's I don't know. It's kind of silly where like if they just kept going with eight scenario campaigns people would be like the designers are doing great. They're wonderful. They're amazing. But with this slight hiccup they're like no we can't trust them with anything ever again. Yeah.

That's a good point beard. That's a good point. Yeah. Yep. All right. Well, thanks for watching everybody. If you want to support the channel, you can do so by liking, commenting, subscribing. You should also go subscribe to Daniel at Quick Learner. Um, Beard, you don't really have a home on the internet for your stuff. I mean, you have like mysterious chanting as all that stuff. So, you can check out the custom campaigns. Uh, you should play Jumanji. It's very good. And Beard has a lot of other great ones as well.

Um, yeah.

Otherwise, uh, thanks for watching everybody. Have a good one. And as always, a GG's.

Progress saved