Skip to main content
Loading video...

Detective - A Modern Crime Board Game: Discussion {SPOILERS!}

Transcript 27:33

viewer discretion is advised welcome to the discussion for fine

discussion for detective a modern crime board game Oh might be what I was going to say I was wrong on both counts anyway detective modern crime board game what do you think so we did we've only done case one Devin and I have actually done k-6 suburbia during gen con' said well that did make a Sun so then we technically got a better score this time you guys did bad time yes is our night clean bit what did we get for the August 6 data 40 it was Sue's [ __ ] abysmal it wasn't oh just got rushing it oh we got a 7 out of 40 ok on that one we got negative 2 on provided under 4 point we we went so generic on that and it was ruling and oh it's a tutorial how hard so just kind of yeah yeah and then as we ran into some guys who were doing it as well and we're like yeah yeah let us know where you guys got we never went back yeah oh yeah we got 40 40 would you but anyway so what do you guys think you've played one game of the Sherlock Holmes I was holding active we've done a bunch of them how do you think this game let's let's talk think this game compares into those well I don't like to

compare it because one we're not an autistic heroin addict it's just yeah it's a little it's a little different I mean obviously you're solving crimes you're just how was that different that's the same you're solving crimes at all in modern day but I mean the studying is completely different the technology is completely different well I think I stole this Jade out online mm-hmm and you don't have to go off of here say you can go off of like these prints match we know this yeah so um I I mean I I really like how they did this I think they did a really good job typically portal games does they were kind of a hit and miss company for me most of time their rule books are atrocious so they did the first Martians game the young man to take about six hours to learn I blow we buy so they did that but they've also done other really good games but this one I was like how is this gonna compare to Sherlock where they meet those tails or any other detective game that it's like Wow especially this name is bland and generic as hell detective a modern crime board game Wow I mean it doesn't look exciting in any way but I think they did a really good job like you said with Sherlock you just have the book to go off of so it sucks when you're like oh my go talk to this person yeah you read their paragraph or whatever

what's oral written Whitney written really well but it's like then you find something else later and you can't go back like oh can we go talk to that guy again no because it's Perry said there this one you are able to kind of trace back and and make connection yeah okay well we got this further lead so let's go back to the lab because maybe now we got some samples we got some fingerprints I kind of like the narrative that they give the world too because like you're actually interacting with people like the lady who had to do those papers in a week and we do yeah they did a lot of world-building yeah like they really describes the room since drinking nasty coffee yeah do yours like wait on those [ __ ] reports it's been two hours like you have to to computer towers a cell phone a laptop in front of you yeah actual detective work like it's yeah I think they did a really good job man you feel like you're an actual detective instead of in Sherlock work you just run everywhere you look dick it had the entire time Devon what do you think so far about how this compares to Sherlock the one game of Sherlock you played versus essentially the one that you to remember one man out yeah that's true so yeah I guess you have a decent comparison cuz we have like six or seven games of Sherlock under our belt so better about this one sure like that I felt like those grasping at straws this one kind of gives you a decent trail you get started on yeah I mean yeah it starts to sprawl and then you're

like okay now I have to prioritize what I'm searching for right I think this one yeah like we like this was a little more fun than the like the murder mystery yeah this one see it's funny to bounce off what you said I think this does a better job I don't know like yeah sure look I always do feel like I'm grasping at straws like I never quite feel like I know what what it's like okay the lines were killed there you go it's like uh so but this one I really did feel like a detective there was a lot of stuff where it's like we got these fingerprints and and whoop so we'll definitely talk about the big focal point of this game in a sec but it was like okay so we have this evidence oh hey the met they match so you're able to think about what the scenario could have been and or even then you guys decided to go to the courthouse I thought that was gonna be a bust but it turned out to actually help us later on because he's like those two guys they're a bunch of [ __ ] they couldn't he could have taken on handsome Horatio first why don't we and it was it was really really cool and yeah the world-building was there and you do have to kind of connect the dots but I think they bring it together easier than Sherlock does because every time well I do like and I kind of hate it at the same time about this one is it gives you a time line like so you're never ever II lead you go on actually has some weight

to it because you're like it's gonna take some time to do you're pretty much only ever gonna get maybe three hour or three leads in a day so the first case is like you need to finish this by day four tape okay crap well I don't want to go there like you didn't want to go to the funeral because you're like with this it's gonna take up yeah cuz I was saying realistically in real life I would go to the funeral right and honor unless some guy else we were working and it's like I can't I need to figure out this lead so I need to be at the office at 8:00 a.m. I can't spend time going I definitely was gonna try like if you guys wanted to go to the police station I was definitely gonna try and pull away from that because like we've already gone the funeral yeah and so and that's what this game does well because it's like okay fine if they're all but they're probably just gonna tell us a bunch of his old stories that doesn't that doesn't matter so you have to do some and waste time and then it'll be five hours later and it's nighttime and instead of doing that we went back to Richmond PD and you've looked up the files which got us this police report yeah alright which jumped on and found out that Michael Slater was involved and so I was like oh okay well why don't you talk to his friends anymore than definitely knows why and we got to see his handsome picture yeah man that guy was good-looking but who knows we could have talked to his wife and she could have been like oh you know again you get a weird report and you probably could have found out about that way too Oh those watches that one man who exposition like crazy morning Widow but

yeah so I I thank every every lead that you take in this game has more consequences versus Sherlock where you have no time limit you have a you have kind of a subconscious one because it's like okay we've done 30 leads and if you get to be an eternal it's done yeah [ __ ] yeah and we'll our score is negative eighty because we did more so you kind of her like well we've done 10 that's probably a good place to stuff but you never really know here even though I there are definitely more leads I wanted to go on yeah we have a deadline so it's kind of a job where where the dude rolls up in his wheelchair and he's like get in my office now what did you find out give me the scoop I also write for the press so yeah I I think this has a little bit more focus which I like because like I mentioned in Sherlock it was just like what do you know no get the right answers you're like I don't even know I don't know what we're doing here I thought we were on the right path a trail pretty much the entire time um I mean there was a point like kind of at day three after the funeral was like I don't really know yeah like but then we look through we look through this and we're like ok so we've done these fingerprints this is the leads that we have okay maybe the robbery that might take us somewhere because Horacio had the flowers had the soil so maybe that would lead somewhere which led us to yeah the whole thing breaking wide open it was kind of like

that point in the detective thing where you run into that slump and you're like I can't figure it out on your phone yeah yeah and then you're like aha so so I thought that I thought that was really great so the big thing of detective a modern crime board game is their database system which what you guys think of that you guys weren't really on it I think it's a really cool mechanic yeah and that's my laptop so it is it is your laptop so usually whenever a board game has any type of technology I always bring up the case of do you think this kind of stuff should be in board games oh it's actually a huge controversial topic within the board that I know with technology and more games should be separated like people believe that others are like yes bring all that stuff dude do the people who say that they shouldn't be involved also fear that one day the whole grid in my experience it is older people who tend to think that I'm spy I mean I do know some people who are not really our age but who are a little bit older who this is their disconnect from technology God and that I get to do it to a sense but and that's why they have games like Sherlock right right like III personally I like it I don't think it's deterring at all I would say maybe I wouldn't want to do it like after coming home from

actually working with the computer all day I might be like uh-huh yeah but like if you have a break I think it would be better if it's like a weekend thing and you're not just like staring at a computer all day right it's gonna be easier for sure but I like it I think it's interactive sometimes I do need that extra like something to keep me involved yeah versus just someone holding the book the entire time in reading even though I was on this the book most the time but it wasn't ever like even even the tidbits of stuff I was reading were never like books it was a snippet so most of it was filler like atmospheric stuff and then it was like okay go through through this deck yeah it's kind of had a time storage feel to it but better I don't know what do you think of the database I know you haven't really been on that either and I have it right on the whole line I mean it's interesting how it it really keeps the game gives you a lot more options you know you can actually look at images and write signatures on that grab it do you think do you think stuff like this has a place in board game so do you think that you do it's you know it just needs to be very clearly labeled yeah I think the only other game you've played that in curious is that a brain like that of this mentions yeah yeah look bringing goods essential is reading it for you right right this didn't seem too bad I mean if I was the one handling it I don't know how excited that would be yeah like

typing it in yeah so with with this so I think this is fantastic I think they did a great job creating this this website too because well Mike what I love about this is this is kind of your notebook more or less yes you're ready to write stuff down like the leaves and stuff and other details that this one but if can you imagine if they did this kind of stuff with Sherlock you'd have to write down the [ __ ] signature or the the signatures and you have to try and cross prints like now this does it all for you like you go into signatures and then it like has a perk like it'll do matching evidence if something pops up oh that's the case suburbia I was like what okay we'll do mystery of the golden watch so so we just go through this and we're like signatures and then it goes you know there's a percent ninety two percent I love another twelve fingerprints of Horatio Donaldson and it matches all of this for us so if we find something like Oh a chair with a fingerprint on them we type that code in and then we found a letter and with that code it'll sync it and be like hey this is a match that note that means oh this person's fingerprints were on that chair and you can then do more detective work which i think is awesome yeah like it keeps all of this in the neat orderly format which i think is more realistic and it also just kind of goes to show you like Jack the Ripper

that was today they feel like I did semen everywhere oh that's definitely that guy we found them I just think it's really nice because can you imagine even if they did try to do something like this in an older format like a book yeah it's like crap what page number was that this is quick it's just like Oh click signatures yeah and there is writing that's also I like this because I got streamline yes you're like the game and we played for maybe case one probably to two hours maybe I feel like it didn't really take that now yesterday actually so on remind you that yesterday last night last night but yeah you go the personal files and you actually it tells you that the cards will be like read this and sometimes will be numbers of cards but others will be like if I can finally read file 1:18 so you just click outlook file and then 1:18 and then you just search it there it is right there they didn't have to bring out oh here's another piece of paper and just bog everything down kind of like the escape or exit where you're like everyone's trying to okay where's but there's a there's been a little bit of stuff which I thought was cool so yeah I'm get that a handheld stuff and you get the the streamlined organized thing on on the website now some people are gonna be like well I can't play this game I don't have internet well first of all how old are you I think that with the times we don't have internet well when we should be sympathetic to X there are people who live in like buttcrack know where those who want internet but

they can't and and yeah that does suck you can't play this game if you don't if you can't get on this so a lot of people are gonna be like well they should have done that it's like why they built it they built this like this is what the game goes around right so I think the database works really well it is not confusing at all to go through it the rule book I think ladies not really well they even have a separate like a non tears guide that I didn't have to use but you can be like well I even tells you how to sign up tells you about the databases for personal files files questioning all that stuff that I don't know I just think they did a really good job this was my favorite part of the whole game um so yesterday you said that you thought this was boring a little bit yeah how did it end up for you so it did pick up I couldn't tell if like I can't even remember why I said it was boring so I think maybe I just I think you were hung up on the golden watch thing you're like what the [ __ ] it's a stupid watch show though who cares I think I said it at the end to like we can tell the Polish government I thought it was so dumb I'm like it's a [ __ ] wad ya know it's interesting because this is a campaign game the cases and stuff that we found will lead to other stuff like

I'm like Sherlock does out a little bit with the old newspapers where it's some questions and stuff in the second case you have to go older newspapers that you're like oh my god and I read about that randomly that murder at the Museum Wow so this one seems to be doing the same thing so I think this is kind of gonna have a young Nazi theme going I think so pretty Nazi it's getting pretty nice food so I mean I don't know but it seems like a curt blood holes escaped I mean it's a board game yeah Bart is gonna be finding oh the [ __ ] that's happening in behind the scenes whatever your dark is gonna be the weirdness that's happening with the non tears that could be it I was gonna say the hit and run Oh Michael Slater perhaps it might sometimes a bunch of different directions that they can go we're already theorists you know I think I was just born last night news I think maybe I was just finding yeah so from what the complaints I've heard about this game is that I'm like I and I disagree slightly but from what other reviewers have said is that this is the game that you have to like you have to be ready to play like I need to sit into here and then we need to think about everything I can understand I don't know if I don't think they compared it to Sherlock in any way because I think sure like you kind of have to be in that - like I needed some

breading Bernie I want to check down I want to put my own feelings have the [ __ ] you know beautiful binary with the strings and like circles of light - yeah and I felt like this one did that as well but in an easier setting but yeah this isn't one game that you're gonna make you know let's have five friends over and break out detective bottom crime board everyone will enjoy this but I don't know I don't know I think this has more draw I think if you break this out you open up a laptop and you're like okay let's let's you know do a case of this for us let me bring on but this one massive book and be like here's the case nope I'm gonna be reading the whole time and I think that I think the newspaper with Sherlock kind of gets some people's I think I remember playing it with Russell and he was into the newspaper I think I remember anyway but it was also kind of like oh you have to read it oh there's five more newspaper yeah you just hand it all to them and you're like read the nearest paper and you're like I don't know what I'm looking I haven't read one of these in yeah so um a couple things how do you feel so how do you feel about how the time we kind of talked about the time system idea I think that works or do you think it should be more open-ended no I think it's fair you like the hard number of you need to be done by this or you will be done by this right you give us a limit I don't like the you know I'm sure there's a time and it's just like oh you took this Malee's then you get this main negative point yeah time you don't get negative negatives what I noticed was from stress tokens because at the end it

was like how many stress tokens idiot oh my gosh it none so I actually do like that I also think that fits more thematically yeah I'm like Sherlock words like you have an unlimited number of times Sherlock already solved a [ __ ] case anyway so yeah here it's like yeah you work 8 to 5 and yep you can work overtime but you're gonna take stress by you by doing it oh yeah that's the mattock and the case gives you a hard number of okay you can work overtime but you ask you your stress limit is 7 sometimes you hit 7 you have to do the final report so you manage your time a lot better I like it a lot to meet those tales which is basically Sherlock Holmes with Cthulhu also has a hard ending no Josh and I did that was his taste into kind of like those kind of games and he really liked it and I was like that was because I played that before I played this with the hard you need to be done here and I liked it to him I like that yep I like deadlines I like knowing what I need to be done yeah where yep yep so what do you guys think of the the take the token system or the digging deeper kind of stuff so basically you get it from your ability and from consultants that you have during the you have those for the entire case what do you guys think I think that that is a good way to make sure that you are prioritizing correctly I I would agree yeah cuz I just can't be like oh we'll just do it because we have a zero yeah we have we don't have a time limit

we can just do whatever you don't want to blow them all up front and then at the you don't you're like oh [ __ ] I wish we'd go done that but we wasted our tokens yeah and everyone's ability I think it's useful we only ever did yours but mine could have been where it's like okay well let's not talk to his you know let's not talk to his wife right now but my ability we could have had yeah oh [ __ ] we should have talked to his life and hers was allowing us to do one of our abilities again yeah no I agree I I like those numbers it's just it's so it's just so streamlined and I like it a lot um let's see I think there was the there was the plot cases the plot cards that'll show up later I think that's pretty neat yeah I I can't think of I can't I can't really think of anything else I thought the police report was really cool yeah a scale of 1 to 10 ah based off case 1 which I thought broke open and got really exciting I was kinda wasn't bored but I was like not really seeing where this is I wasn't in game and then once remember like we hit the robbery it was like oh my god okay let's figure now after we talked to the guy the psychologist the forensic psychologist I want to go see is great I know right okay well [ __ ] or it is autopsy report which I may look at anyway just because well we're not gonna be able to play this that is true so I

mean wish your luck and also this one what do you guys think of the replayability replayability are you so I can't remember how much this game was I gather that Gen Con do you guys think there's five cases in the game I think that you have plans for the solo ones like they had they had they had standalone they can probably do single packs or yeah yeah what do you guys think of paying money to for a game you can only play once I don't see why not I mean I do it's good brain stimulation yes I mean how many times you actually break out like a particular game yeah legends play by [ __ ] yeah so yeah buddy there's a casual player a board game yeah I mean yeah for the most part especially with Emma I got yeah because all you have to do is whatever you paid divided by five if I also maybe by hours played yeah you do get your money back like this essentially took like it but everyone wants the movie yeah and I had a good time so scale one to ten I'm gonna give for my first impression by the end of this I'm going to give it a and eight and eight um yeah they did really good with the text how do you

feel about theme because I remember we played forbidden sky and you're like I need theme mm-hm do you think yeah this is I mean with the the way they run the text I mean that computer system they have police reports that you can pull from yeah you know I'll be McCarran eight I think i'ma sit at a nine one I very much like all of these games there's another Kickstarter I'm gonna be getting that it's this same milk but they use a uses your phone as a VR so you actually will scan QR codes and then virus but if you want into you if you want to talk to someone that virus isn't knowing the actor if the heck your phone gate or social No you'll stay in queue our codes and if you want to talk to someone it'll be a picture of a guy and then a QR code you talk to him through the app or if it's like this scene the park you scan the QR car and put your phone over like it has like glasses and you can actually look around also actually comes with a VR headset yeah well not like a headset but like a like a like a clip-on no like this as the goggles yeah it's like I'm really there no I'm not yes I am no I'm not yes I what's going on here but no I actually demoed it ajan where you actually look around and use like and someone will be able what do you see it's like okay I see a shovel I see a woman's dead body and then you'll like grab evidence and stuff like that cuz oh I very much love detective themed games I love the Sherlock games I love me those tales even though I've done one case for that I really like mystery yeah so this this

is rather my alley I love this I think I forgot this was a touch screen - yeah I've been using my BJ's oh I think they did a great job with this it's it's not a Miss for me at all so I'm good a nine out of ten so that's detective a modern crime board game everyone I'll list know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like I'm and share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time I favors for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button is a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day of this for you

Progress saved