Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 28:02

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for machina arcana uh so that was a long one yeah oh boy yeah um all right so this this is gonna be this is weird because this theme sounds like something that'd be right up my alley like i love steampunk i think it's a super cool genre and mixing it with cthulhu or lovecraft is also uh seems like it's a match made in heaven however because of how long this game is and how similar it is to other games i would much rather just play those other games like arkham horror lcg eldritch horror um and uh educators like the ones over the yeah it's like the whole map yeah yeah like once or twice right um but so so those and the deep madness is kind of similar i mean through lewis it's not really cathedral arrest monsters but still in that same vein battler right like horror themed you know lots of reading a lot of little texts that's coming in uh so it's like i'd rather play those because throughout the entire of because in this one like it felt repetitive for a very long time every chapter that was coming out it was

just kind of like a ah here's a little blurb of of text and this little quick event that kind of happens but repeat doing the same thing definitely um has the skeleton of wants to be modular in a way right that it can you know okay your events your story is that deck yeah uh while everything else is uh you know interchangeable and they kept it vague enough in the descriptors yeah um so like their map titles are very interesting in that that you don't have individual tokens for every interactable space you know that you customize based off of like a blueprint right from a book yeah this one just like this is your plate yeah this is what you're working with this is it you just always grab a tile and they're double-sided doesn't matter which side you just flip it and okay yeah on here there's yeah you're right the the treasure chest and then you know the events so um but you kind of just do a lot of the same yeah well it's like yeah you're doing um like you're working through these like they want to keep it very vague yeah and it's like they're kind of letting your imagination do it but it's like okay that's only so much or we lifting there or they're text i mean the writing isn't bad but it's just it's it's a lot of nothing you know yeah it's it's definitely a lot of fun i don't know if i'm using like platitudes right but um it's yeah it's just like it says okay this is all happening i was like okay we're moved through a couple of squares right there's definitely a disconnect between like the story being read and

what is actually going on and what we're actually seeing yeah you're right because this is like yeah it's it's literally just the four tiles of of not necessarily gray but the square blocks so you can't even imagine like an eldritch for example you can imagine you're in tokyo or you're in you know the amazon and dealing with all this stuff in deep d i was gonna say deep space in uh deep madness uh you can imagine that you're in an underwater facility but they're yeah they're trying to be descriptors with the chapter text and at least they give you pictures of what you're seeing but you're not seeing that or interacting with that in any way right on on the tile so they wanted to be like minimalistic as well yeah i mean uh it's definitely not overboard with game uh like tokens and whatnot no but on fiddly little rules it is overboard like this this this rulebook and at least this is also the third edition by the way but they at least gave you a guidebook is this game uh i want to say the first edition came out in 2014. oh [ __ ] i think it's an old game yeah uh but then this came out this year like the third edition oh okay um let me see if i can uh making a arcana let's see yep 2014. this is when the first edition came out okay uh but yeah so they give you the guidebook which is definitely something you should read through so you can at least understand and it's not like it's complex like it's relatively uh straightforward we only ran into one

really big rules like issue and that was my little um uh the bot yeah the bottom yeah all right but yeah and then like so so you're constantly really just okay i'll spend my stamina and i'll move two and then i'll spend three get an essence and i'll draw two and okay these suck and then that was like you feel like they want this to be like grandiose and epic but your turns are so lame like for a lot of it like it's literally like okay i guess i'll move four spaces and i can't attack anything because that requires two stamina that require end okay i can definitely see their focus in this game and what they thought like the fun would be is definitely the you know i mean we're steampunk what's the coolest thing about stingbunk it's the gadgets and imagining your character and all this steamy nonsense right i do like their art is amazing yes i love the blueprint style i like i mean i like the gear i like that part and they make it very easy especially with my character yeah um i don't know if i could see him playing another character where i have to spend salmon every single time i get a thing right because in your case you're a crafter so you can just be like boom whatever i pick yeah in my case i could only do that with you know uh artifacts and unfortunately you can only have one artifact equipped so i never wanted to actively search through that deck so if i ever wanted to equip something i'd have to weirdly it's like i get what they were going for like but why why can you all of a sudden be like

oh man i'm gonna put this hat on i'll put this weapon in my hand and put these boots on for free and i'm over here like i don't know how to put a shirt on yeah like it doesn't make any thematic sense i mean it's like at least they have the mechanic where it's like you just do it all at once it's just three and it's like everything you have can be removed around so it's like if you accumulate some stuff you can do it in one bit and that's kind of what they're wanting you to go for i think they want you to hoard up so much stuff yeah i'm not 100 sure because definitely one of my frustrations with the game is they have so much [ __ ] and it's like if you want like a full kit you have to really dig through the deck yeah it's like you have to like okay i have to keep going for clothes clothes clothes clothes i want them to connect and here's where where it all kind of boils down to is if that's what they're wanting you to do you spend so many turns doing nothing and so many turns that are boring and or not exciting in any way and you play for four hours yeah you know so it's like i don't wanna play a four-hour game where like i'm like all right that was nothing because a lot of it is okay yeah so six stamina boom that's immediately all gone because i did two actions yeah all right now let's you roll and it's a lot of it's a lot of this it's a lot of constantly moving just you're not actually focused on the game other stressors that yeah you as the host you know have to deal with right so i mean i'm not dealing with all the fiddly bits which would be very frustrating which i mean that i easily could have just you know pulled them all out and leveled them up uh which i didn't do so it's like that makes it easier oh there here's a level two here's a level

two sack now let me just quickly grab it and then but yeah you're constantly like do okay so that's coming out let's pull this out oh it's like the monsters are doing a bunch of stuff whereas you are like yeah you can eventually do some cool things if you happen to get some neat gear whereas in all those other games i mentioned you have epic turns and arkham horror lcg you have epic turns elder tori you have a bunch of gear that you have that you could spend uh you know points on to actually use yeah and indeed madness is the exact same way whenever you're get because like if you're gonna go for gear everyone should be excited when you get a gear versus like oh man well i didn't get any augments so i guess like i'll keep drawing oh i mean there's a lot of [ __ ] cool stuff there's a reaper scythe in here oh nice but like at the same time they all kind of start sounding the same oh this is a three stamina range two attack two black two white pull one space three stamina attack three adjacent units three stamina and an essence attack one black one white adjacent units and push them two spaces and i mean it's like it's not bad no the gear is definitely the strong like like the gear and the building your characters definitely like mm-hmm they put a lot of work into this all the different and there's so much there's levels to it right but i mean i had like i had to [ __ ] work together all this right and keep spending a lot of my turns while you're killing and holding awful i'm like hold on let me put my helmet on yeah so maybe if they made it

cheaper or something with three stamina seems like a lot to work with your whole inventory yeah and nothing gives you permanent boost in stamina yeah uh or health or anything like that because i wanted it to also be difficult but i never really felt it was difficult because of the fact that oh i opened the chest i get an essence so in essence in and of itself is how we move from health but it's also extra health um and it's like when you're only in like a strict like final battle combat like we were it's like we're generating more essence than we're actually taking damage right i mean i was a little sweaty there for a minute but then as soon as we started calling him a little bit and it's like oh yeah you killed the monsters and you [ __ ] gain hell yeah and honestly i was more just i was just so over i wanted to be done like and for the record this game's not bad no but it gets it it naturally gets compared to the only thing that makes this unique is its gear it will it not necessarily its gear itself it's the upgrades and augments that's what makes the the thing unique like your um your gatling gun i mean well that's just cool because i haven't seen that really in anything else but deep madness you can get turrets you know so it's like the items themselves are replicable in all those other games i've mentioned so whenever you are unique but yet you have to dig through a deck and you spend a lot of times doing nothing for the game to be as long as it is it drags it down like if this game was two hours yeah oh man yeah i mean i'd be praising it

because two hours is then then this all shines a little bit more did you was it like a how do you pick the scenario you just pick one you just pick it yeah i like do they have different lengths do they warn you nope they don't nope no i mean it's just based off how quickly you're able to kill monsters and gain essence and you know advance through chapters yeah because it's like i mean i definitely don't dislike this no i don't either it's definitely good i know we're really dogging on it but like the arts really good yeah art's really good i like the it is relatively streamlined i don't know how first and second edition was because i felt relatively engaged the whole time um but yeah there wasn't like highs and lows i'd say right it definitely felt very very very flat the only reason if if i had played this game before i played literally any like other cthulhu game i'd probably be raving about it more than i am but once again there's those three other games that i just owned that i'm like i'd rather play those yeah you have the highs and lows with elder tour and with arkham and deep madness uh that and if they're gonna take as long then at least i i wasn't engaged the entire time yeah like i i was getting a very glossy-eyed look when i was reading those chapter things and i was trying to put something into i was trying to really envision but the fact is these tiles just don't help me to envision what i'm trying to see they wanted to be able to reuse a lot of these right because they so they kept it and yeah that disconnect is there

from between the tiles and the story so it's yeah i definitely noticed that it wasn't too like horrible like i didn't then like throw me through a loop but it's still like that's noticeable it's like yeah okay this is not kind of what we're doing something right and you can't really strategize in terms of movement because it's it's like i even had an ability you could move through obstacles oh great oh wait because i can move diagonal i can just hop around it so it's the exact same i know it's like now that i played so many orthogonal games it's the best way to do movement it really is because you have to strategize it's like oh we have to get to him okay crap yeah we're gonna have to when you move diagonals it's like there's like no thought to your movement and i know diagonal movement makes magic sense like if you're in an open plane why can't why do i have to go this way then that way to get to it why can't i just cut across i i get where that's coming from but mechanically it's like yeah it's more accurate i don't know there's something to it like why have walls whenever you can just go boop like instead of you because that costs one movement versus having to go one two to get around the wall it would make the the monsters like a lot more probably aggressive because we wouldn't be able to get to them as quickly to kill them i will say like once again this game is extremely streamlined in terms of its rules the rulebook and all the little pieces and iconography makes it seem like it's going to be more complex than it is but it really isn't that is one of the strengths of the game but what's weird is that it's so streamlined in what you do on your turn that costs stamina you can look at it and be like i

know exactly what this does i know how many dice i roll doesn't matter what i roll i hit their target that's one damage there's no whatever there's no weird little oh actually if they're like this then this happens there's none of that and yet it's still four hours uh so it's just it's like disjointed everything is just kind of disjointed yeah go ahead i was gonna say not that like the it's not like there's like different mini games or anything everything is cohesive with what you're doing but for some reason i just could not get into this like i can with literally all the other ones and i think it's because your turns are so boring and so i'm not engaged in what i'm doing on my turn i'm not getting absorbed in all the action yeah i think i think yeah the issue definitely is the yeah how little we're doing on our turn and versus how much is going on in between the turn and you as the host definitely having to handle all that it's like okay so now horror comes out we do the hard card fiddly number details yeah um roll roll roll roll right monsters come out monster came out yep that's the thing here's the monster okay well he immediately does this yeah so now you've set him up he's on the board now he has to take his action well you do the horror or whatever yeah was it how did it go it was like okay so monster spawn yep spawn horror monster spawn and then we roll to see it yeah spawns roll okay white monster's coming out you fiddle to [ __ ] put them on the board yeah then you roll is there a

horror okay there's a horrible beat off the water this whole thing now this happens to us um this is the effect okay now the monsters are taking their turns and now we get to spend our piddly six stamina and then all that [ __ ] happens again exactly yeah so in terms of your actual turn it's like your turn to go like that and then yeah then you do all that other [ __ ] all for the sake of making the game difficult and i wouldn't say this game isn't brutally hard but it's also not easy like uh like we were hovering around one or two health there's a lot of things that just monsters come out oh they just do a damage and and i like that i like the fact that oh i have i mean i had four health doesn't like my max is four and uh but because of the way you can gain essence and you can kind of block and and it it for goes a long way uh because of the fact that there is player elimination which might also turn people off if a character hits zero they are removed from the game and now these guys aren't just dumb mobs now i'm sitting here like hmm how do i want the night gone to move you know really yeah it would be me versus you at that point uh it was a lot of advantage towards the monsters then right it becomes you get to ignore all the rules and [ __ ] they actually no because they still do their thing and then they can actually now uh they can interact with doors because normally instead it just takes four flat stamina to destroy a door now they can open them um what was it they could do other stuff it was yeah they can destroy it still and they can activate trap levers

for three but yep players of dead explorers become responsible for playing that monster's turn they form a hive mind that controls their every action at that point if someone's losing if someone dies that's just kind of like you're already losing so we're gonna make it harder on the other players yeah it's kind of like so it was their work around player elimination so it's like no you're still playing it's like yeah now i'm a dick to the my teammate yeah kind of like the pyromancy madness and uh there's another cthulhu one mansion's a madness if you want to go story driven oh manchester's lights are pretty stellar so it's like i i i just don't know i can't there's nothing here that i'm like i want this on my shelf because it does this like if you felt like a bass with all this gear like this looks cool theoretically like my four because i have you know the augments and i have the upgrades but it didn't do anything for me like uh yeah i can resolve any active thing this doubled my thing but oh a lot of it was um armor so my my iso isobaric battery does nothing i can move through obstacles it doesn't matter because i can move diagonal very true and then this one would have been cool but i equipped it at the time it didn't matter but when you explore a new map dial restore six stamina like that's good it's about three boom and then you can actually go in there yeah and they have a lot of cool items like really neat items but because of just the fact that you you're whenever you spend your entire time drawing two cards you can't even equip it and you're like yay level one

true you can't even [ __ ] equip them i know unless you're that specific type or a crafter like imagine imagining spin three to crack open the chest and then three to put it on yeah and then oh and then it's like you gotta do fiddly monsters right in between all this that's what i'm saying you get like two actions returns if you could innately just do other stuff if you just had a movement then i would under i would take stamina off everything else if you just had a base move whatever your character is hey artemis can move four whatever i have max of six stamina so at least i can run to a chest open it and equip it versus nope i have to move and i can only that's like wow a shotgun

it's like [ __ ] resident evil where you have like the six inventory slots but you can still pick something and be like can't use this it's like you're i'm poisoned no serum doesn't fit it's like it was in your hand it's like like why can't you just drink it just [ __ ] like i've got an egg in my inventory i can't i can't take this giant rocket launcher yeah it just doesn't work so it's overly long it doesn't shine compared to the four games now that i mentioned uh like and literally i have a lovecraft sleeve like it's it's i love that lore but this one was just so disjointed that i couldn't it whenever normally if you remember deep madness they have those same uh madness and consciousness cards where you're reading text and it's like finding a blurb in a video game um and those are all just sex i loved reading that because i was so engrossed in it but here it got to a point when there were so many horror cards coming out that i was like i don't care let's just see what it does yeah and i don't want it once we very rarely win for the events right because well that's the other thing it's like they're not event cards that you can now play so sometimes you just like you spend your entire turn running to an event space and let's say you happen to get the one that's like like this one like you run all the way spend your entire stamina run to an event spot and you get the one that reduces monster threat by two and let's say it's already at one or zero and

you're like i just wasted my entire turn it's not like i can hold on to this and be like oh now let's play it right so yeah i could do that or i could crack open a chest right you have to get lucky and hope that what you draw from the event so it's like they're they are good it's just that they're very situational and some of them were like no matter what they're going to be beneficial like oh destroy a spawn space cool but whenever you once again do nothing on your turn uh like killing five cultists like at the at the end of this one it was just so tedious yeah like you had to drag a gatling gun and once you finally got set and then all of a sudden it's just like oh the thrall runs up equip let me quit and then nope okay well now i can't even do that well i had to run and [ __ ] bonk them on the head and be like sorry i can't hit you twice so you're aware i'm here it's just i wouldn't say boring but tedious is probably exactly lackluster they need more of a balance between you know enemy turn and our turn right like we need more activity or the monsters need less i mean i make it more potent or something but just less [ __ ] i think i would much rather have like the monsters are fine like in fact i would take monsters to be harder if that meant we are badass on our turns as well or you can set up for badass turns no um but at the end of the day kind of like with steampunk i have all this gear and

i look like an idiot and i feel like an idiot because i'm not doing anything like it's just i mean elder torah probably takes about four hours and i'd rather play that deep madness is roughly the same yeah so and they're a lot more because because you're you're you're scenario based so what you're doing is like here's the scenario here's the tiles here's your objective based off that scenario it's not vague tiles with a story and they're trying to tell you what's happening and show you what you're seeing through back pictures and so it's like oh that's the corridor we're in anyway um how much was this game it's a good question because since there's no miniatures it must have yeah i think it works i think it was relatively cheaper and i like sandy's like i don't mind standees at all um let's see was this on i don't remember if this was on kickstarter i don't think it was on kickstarter um because i this is like everything mcna arcana third edition it's showing like a hundred yeah that feels about the point yeah and that's that's not bad though i guess it is on i mean we did a lot of cost saving measures i mean the sandys yeah and then the reusable tile boards without going with too much terrain yeah i mean and every character is relatively like the same like uh

i don't know i i just feel like even our our character abilities like i never was like super jazzed about yeah they weren't great i mean like the static stuff's kind of okay i don't know about yours i don't have a static stuff i mean mine did i did use mine move up to two spaces towards any action space to help you out uh and then of course they have a bunch of other characters in here but it's just everything is just kind of like subpar compared to others and even if it wasn't even if those games hadn't come out like this is still a four-hour slog of doing nothing huh yeah i mean i don't hate it i don't have the experience yeah well i played a lot of you you've played all those other games that's true that's true we do hit a lot of eldritch business right like if i was to bring literally all those games out including this one i'm pretty sure you'd play all them before this one maybe not but yeah i mean i would give this one a few more tries definitely i don't hate it i do like the unique thing i like the you know cards and i like his arts but yeah it's i can't sit through four hours of this no four hours was a bit much like the second map i'm like are we done yet right yeah i was like oh there's an end game and i knew it was and it's like don't be wrong like it wasn't until the very end that i was kind of like can we like move this along yeah but yeah ten ten chapters and really it's ten chapters of you just reading because nothing else about the chapter makes it unique it's just like oh hey this one

you could spend the damage to advance oh that's true whoa like spending damage yep that's you're right it's yeah it's definitely meh this is a solid in the middle ground game yep uh yeah so on a scale of one to ten um i'm out of five yeah like it's not bad uh but it's not good either i don't i don't think i'll give it six for its soundtrack it does actually have its own soundtrack no way yeah it does have it does i and i'm sure because once again i feel like they tried like with these lore books they wanted like so that might bring it up that could bring it up to six if i bothered to read these and this is stuff i would read because i do like i do like this stuff yeah i love it but the the gameplay just doesn't do it for me which is such a shame because searching through and getting cool custom items and and badass upgrades should feel awesome but here's the other thing about the upgrade this is actually a negative about these it's like whenever you have these together whatever these two are whatever like this armor this still requires me to spend stamina to do all these abilities it's like yeah i have more options but why doesn't like it should be like this costs stamina to do this by itself this should but if i combine them then this should be one item and this should be some badass

[ __ ] thing that this just cost me a certain number of stamina to be like to do it all that would be really cool but unfortunately no for me to even do my pulverizer and force alternator oh that takes my entire turn so i can't even move yeah um so yeah even that just kind of becomes lame uh but i'm still gonna keep it out of five like i wasn't miserable the entire time but towards the very end i was like let's get this over with and i don't want to feel that way right so that's our thoughts on machina arcana let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved