Skip to main content
Loading video...

We Review (nearly) Everything Arkham Horror: The Card Game - Part 1

Transcript 26:06

excuse my lack of energy but I just finished all of Arkham Horror the card game and if you don't think that's a big deal then let me show you what all of our kimura the card game looks like

I suppose we better get to it Arkham Horror the Kagamine gets the honor of being the first game we have reviewed twice originally published in 2016 by Fantasy Flight game studios it was the second stab at the living card game cooperative formula type of collectible card game where each new pack has a non-randomized set of cards Elaine why don't you give us an overview like in all collectible card games you will use cards that you own to build a deck except here the deck is your investigator and instead of playing against each other you play together and when I say investigator what I mean is that you could play as an occult librarian an artist that paints themselves out of bad situations or a musician that casts spells with his trumpet which is of course nonsense imagine if I blew into this harmonica and conjured up a FRU that would never work see nothing happened no fur each time you play you and your friends investigators will try and beat a scenario that is itself part of a larger campaign set in the Lovecraftian universe which in 2020 fills as fresh and as underdone as Nicolas Cage's acting each scenario has an act deck and an agenda deck each round you'll placed doom tokens on agenda cards until they eventually reach a threshold advance and

introduce more nasty surprises advance too many and you've lost the game which is a fair place to start because you will be losing a lot winning on the other hand is more nebulous sometimes you'll have to place clew tokens on the app deck other times you'll be given specific objectives most importantly when you start you won't really know how to win much like the rules to curling it's something you'll have to figure out after you started playing I'm pretty sure that's wrong Elaine I have it on good authority that nobody actually knows the rules to curling that's not being around the tentacle bush when we initially reviewed Arkham Horror the card game we didn't exactly love it whilst we found it to be full of exciting ideas the poor campaign structure uninspired implementation of luck and uninteresting card choices left us wanting for much more but we were working from what at the time was just a single call set since then it has spawned five deluxe expansions each containing extra six scenario packs free return to sets five standalone scenarios including one that asks free groups of Arkham Horror players to play at the same time and an April Fool's joke that got so popular that the canine version of Arkham Horror is about to become reality and whilst her opinion was what professionals call mixed Arkham Horror steadily became a fan darling and one of the most successful games to come out out of Fantasy Flight which prompted us

to think maybe with the additional expansions the game gets better and is worth revisiting not to mention than if you're in lockdown and struggling to keep yourself occupied a nearly endless source of adventuring might prove of fruitful distraction so we bought it all of it and some 700 pounds and over 40 play sessions later we are here to deliver the verdict remember we do this so you don't have to if you're interested in Arkham Horror the card game thanks to our diligence you know exactly which cycles you should get this sort of work is only possible because viewers like yourself supporters we're happy to announce that we have just launched our patreon and we would very much appreciate your support please pledge if you can we have some lovely perks to reward you with you'll find the link in the description certainly there's just no way we could pack everything into a single video so we decided to split things into two in this first part we'll revisit the corset and cover the first expansion cycles the Dunwich legacy and the path to Carcosa in part two we'll cover the other three cycles and explore the implications of Lovecraftian theming in the 21st century we decided to omit the special standalone scenarios because they're a bit niche and hard to come by and we're not covering the return to expansions because frankly playing nineteen more games of largely the same thing doesn't

sound very productive and we hear they're actually not very good breaking out the course again after all these years reminded us why Arkham became such a compelling game loved by so many but it also reminded us that devotion comes with a clause just because you love this game it doesn't mean that it's gonna love you back regular collectible card games come with a resource economy you have mana and whatnot you can spend it to play cards here you also have resources that in an innovative twist are called resources but you're also facing an additional restriction each investigator can do a number of things you can try and fight a monster or just run away from it because often you'll be fighting a Dwayne the rock Johnson sized glob made out of mouths and teeth with a shovel and a fly Skov liquid courage you can search a location for clues you can move to a different location or you can move away by leaving declaring you've had enough of this scenario because sometimes things really are that bad there's also a few ancillary actions like drawing a card getting a resource or just activating an ability but most importantly you can only do three of these things on any given round couple that with any card worth its salt being very expensive and you constantly coming short on resources and then couple that with cards frequently being one use affairs that disappear like fleeting

mirages of an oasis in a desert infested with giant tentacles you're thrust into the shoes of an incompetent buffoon that is surrounded by otherworldly monsters desperately searching for anything that is remotely in any way shape or form useful and then you turn to your deck and your deck says to add insult to the very robust injury of a game system that frequently renders you ineffective your deck is designed to work against you most of the cars you can build your deck with are useful but more importantly they paint a broad picture of who your character is if you play as mark Harrigan the soldier then your deck will feature such items as a trusty police buddy a trusty dog a trusty 45 automatic and a trusty buddy named Dario who wears a fancy white suit has the subtitle unscrupulous investor and every turn will just give you free money unless of course there's monsters in your area in which case he'll trust you get the [ __ ] out of there these all give you the tools to push you above your character's natural limits whenever you want to do something useful like shoot a monster read a book or cope with the existential dread of realizing that the world is about to be eaten by careless alien gods you'll have to pass a test simply calculate your relevant stat like brains

books fists or wing and then add that number to a modify a token that you draw from a bag that I'm convinced is composed entirely out of content for you and your friends that token represents what is very usually an awful negative penalty to your stat and then you'll see yourself not get past that target number and fail and if you haven't failed that's a heck of a moment because you'll feel like you've climbed Mount Everest even though all you've actually done it's just busted out a door without you know breaking your elbow so then your deck is what makes those odds better know very good at fighting your derringer will let you swap out you might skill for agility whenever you fight very handy if you're of the nimble persuasion better yet each card in your hand has symbols matching your statistics even if you haven't had a chance to play them you can spend them as a one-off effect for free to boost the relevant statistic if you have the matching symbols bottom line cards are great so let's draw lots of bangles what I just drew is a weakness which can range from potentially annoying to utterly debilitating if you're lucky you'll draw your Brandon Bass ik weakness which you were forced to include as part of deck construction and if you're even luckier you might have been assigned one that's not particularly crippling and that's good

because you're stuck with this thing for the rest of the campaign or you might draw your characters specific weakness which was designed to completely undermine any advantage you've had in summary you need cards to be effective you can't draw that many because you're limited by how many actions you have a turn and dipping into your deck is a bit like dipping into the wirings of a live c4 charge and I've been told by my health and safety advisor than that and I quote not advisable all of this provides the evenings filled with anxiety and dread as you try to untangle the mysteries of each scenario but I say that as a good thing so then why did we not give Arkham Horror the card game a glowing review the phone time because the Corsa is just about the worst example of what this game can be nothing is more disappointing than what this box presents as a campaign and if you're one of the people who picked up the core set thought yourself this is a bit rubbish and never played any more of it you'll know what we mean there are three interlinked scenarios in this set and I understand what a struggle it must have been to weave an ongoing affair with such a limited number but here's what we're getting in the end how about I just show you scenario one is daft and easy although it's understandable that there has to be something that smooths you into the kind of exploration this game it's gonna get you to try and do nevertheless it feels

like a wasted opportunity scenario two is bog-standard Arkham Horror the card game that feels like it offers a decent challenge one that you just about scraped through or you'll fail miserably with potential consequences for the final chapter consequences that are stupid because the final chapter is ridiculously hard because I guess the designers thought that this game needed a boss level it's not so much the difficulty itself that's the issue here we don't mind the challenge the issue is with how the difficulty scales imagine that you've been employed at the zoo great animals on the first day you are told to look after the guinea pigs on the second day you care for the Anteaters and on the third day you're thrown into a den of lines that also has some bears in it and by the way you don't get bitten by the anteater on day two because you'll get an infection and it'll make it harder to fight off the Lions with your bare hands campaign structure isn't the only thing that feels clunky here our investigators already feel like shadows over their former selves and the game hasn't even started yet you're offered pre-constructed options for each of the five investigators which is fine but then once you actually set out to build your own deck you find out that there are almost no more choices to change anything up unless you purchased a second corset which when this game was published was very much what Fantasy Flight Games was trying to get you to do especially if you wanted to play this more than just by yourself and if you you want to play the solo then good luck

playing any of these investigators because you'll be eaten before you even leave the door and the cards themselves feel particularly uninspired yes there's tools in here that might excite you but if you compare the cleverness of card design to other collectible card games then in the words of Courtney Barnett these feel pedestrian at best when we were done with our initial free games we were glad we could move on although filled with dread at the prospect that we just spent seven hundred pounds on a lot more of this I would not recommend the Arkham Horror card game corset to anyone but the sad joke is that if you want to play this game then you need one and if you want to really invest yourself into it then you'd likely need two of them to get a good array of starting cards what difference a cycle makes done which legacy represents some of the best that Arkham has to offer and when I say Arkham I don't just mean Arkham Horror the card game I mean pretty much any Lovecraftian themed game out there as soon as you open the booklet included in the deluxe expansion box you realize you're going on a very different ride and not just because one of the blister packs promises a murder filled romp on the Arkham's version of the Orient Express first you're offered a nonlinear start picking which scenario you want to begin the game with and then based on that decision which scenario you pick

the choices you make in that scenario will inform how the other one will play out making this sort of a weird roundabout circle that I'm very into because it's fantastically neat and very rewarding second you're finally given room to breathe the difficulty starts at a comfortable pace allowing you to do a bit of bumbling and exploring you finally given time to get a feel for how your characters work and which cards work better under which circumstances but more importantly you're given a clear vision of what it is you're trying to achieve overall each scenario feels like a distinctive chapter not so much from a out of perspective let's face it these investigators will never win a Pulitzer for their riveting yarns but how the narrative informed the game decisions time and time again we found a different spin on a game element that transformed the entire escapade into something representative of the story it was trying to tell based on how we engaged with the games mechanisms here is where I would give you an example to illustrate what I mean but I'd love to spoil the multitudes of delightful twists and turns but let me try and cobble together a spoiler-free analogy imagine a game where tentacles attack your workplace great let's grab a magical trumpet and kill it except what's happening to your dozens and dozens of co-workers only fine do they need to be looked after better yet what's happening to

your bus and is it perhaps very rewarding and cathartic we heard that the done rich legacy expansion was good so this wasn't at all a surprise what I didn't expect there was the mechanisms that initially seemed annoying now presented themselves in a different light for example the bag of tokens and when I say bag of tokens I mean the concept of a bag of tokens because whilst the course that did give you cardboard tokens it cheaped out and didn't even provide you with the drawstring bag although to be fair we also cheaped out and instead of getting a nice bag we put the tokens in this pouch that f.cuz shaver came in like we mentioned before each time you attempt a task you'll draw a modified token from it kind of like rolling a die except here you can pose the odds for each campaign and potentially make them worse as the campaign goes along in our initial review we felt like this was wasted potential because every time you draw a token you put it back in the bag making it about as interesting as rolling a die the odds were always static and never changed gaming this bag became easy if you wanted to take a calculated risk you gave yourself a bonus that would allow for a minus 2 token to be drawn if you wanted to be certain you'd allow for a minus 4 imagining what this bag could be with a constantly changing composition was a beautiful dream that would remain a dream instead it was mostly just annoying new drew a token it was probably going to be bad if you had cards or ability to suspend you would

and if you didn't you just let out a big sigh and go for it but now even though nothing on the surface has changed because the campaign is much wider and it allows more scope for failure instead of being frustrated we just laughed at the situation did I really just try and banish a winged demon by chucking my magnifying glass at it of course I was gonna draw a minus 4 did we really just interpret the mad scribblings of the Necronomicon by drawing a painting how does that even work we'll never know I'm just happy the designers of Dunwich legacy understood that the story presented by the prism of game affine Lovecraft's work is pulpy nonsense and didn't take it seriously one moment you're in a university then you're in a speakeasy suddenly you're on a train or maybe a creepy village the whole thing feels like a globe-trotting romp that changes locations faster than a Bond movie but with a cast that's ten times more ridiculous if I had one criticism I'd maybe knock off a point for how they approached the ending the penultimate adventure in the campaign presents an opportunity to lose the entire campaign this concept seems to pervade through all future campaigns as well meaning that if you didn't succeed you were barred access from playing the last scenario in the campaign a bit of a bummer if you payed 12 quid for it and have to play seven scenarios all over again just to have a chance at having a

go of course you could cheat and say that you have won or you could play it in standalone mode but both of those options feel a little bit cheap otherwise the down--which legacy is a fantastic expansion that's well worth the entry cost as long as you can get your hands on it a lot of the praise that we heat on done which legacy can be repeated for path the Carcosa a delirium infused wonder inspired by the short stories of Robert W Chambers centering around a fictional play called the king in yellow which warped the minds of those who watched it without a moment of hesitation the very start of the campaign thrusts you into the play that so far no one has escaped unscathed and things only escalate from there once again the first to scenario surprise and delight with clever twists on adventure design and there's illusions that things are only gonna get much much worse the narrative never disappoints keeping things intriguing and mysterious until the very bitter end but wait what's this there's even a new investigator that seems a perfect fit for those playing Arkham Horror by them it's not that the previous set had poor options for solo play on the contrary you had some great options for all-rounder characters like ashcan Pete here but you end up having to cover so many bases that your investigator is good at a lot of things and great at nothing and some of the harder scenarios

demand greatness enter stage fright Lola Hays a character that lets you dip into the entire card pool without restriction where as usual characters can only select from two of the game's five colors although she has other restrictions Lola Hays is an actress and as such much like celebrities who have played doctors she can accomplish anything like spinal surgery but since we're talking about new investigators let's return to mark Harrigan the soldier who first appears in this cycle his character weakness is shell-shocked and his unique heart is a picture of who would presume is his ex-partner that he looks at whilst he physically hurts himself to push further these are two serious mental health conditions and whilst I absolutely believe that games should explore serious subjects like mental health Arkham reduces everything to a punchline and this one's stinker this lackadaisical approach to mental health issues continues as we explore the scenarios further soon we discover an enemy type which is simply a person that has the tag lunatic a term that's out of place now and as revealed by a minimal amount of research wasn't that widely used at the time when this game was said either I'm not gonna go on berating the designers for the careless approach because games that treat serious subjects with a frank touch of cultural stupidity are a dime a dozen but I will say that it wouldn't have been hard to rename it to something like possession

which wouldn't have just been more automatically appropriate to the narrative but also would open up intertextual illusions between Robert W Chambers and all the way to William Friedkin alas the design seems to be bound by the types of call of Cthulhu the very first to use glove crafts work as the basis of a tabletop game your characters usually have normal professions such as librarian teacher or even accountant their thrust into paranormal situations beyond their capability to defeat which will either kill them or drive them mad or worse and that's always the ending your loss is the inevitable crescendo I imagine that felt very innovative in the eighties and it still felt innovative when I played the board game version of Arkham Horror more than a decade ago but now more than ever the campaign structure of the path to Carcosa made me realize that maybe it's time for Arkham to unburden itself of this tired old robe the initial scenario started at the same pace as Dunwich legacy challenging but not insurmountable they asked you to make concessions but offered a real chance for victory I was specifically intrigued by the doubt / conviction mechanism the narrative would ask me to make decisions and as a consequence tick one or the other later depending on what I had ticked this scenario would take that into account and adjust itself great I thought until I played the first scenario that

actually included repercussions of these decisions repercussions that battered us so hard we didn't even have a chance to let out a single fart not to mention putting up a resistance to the many dangers that sprung out like murderous wakka moles that never went away looking at what would have happened if we'd ticked things the other way I realized that this scenario would have been easier than grilling some cheese on toast nevermind I thought this is just the pendulum swinging one way and soon will be rewarded for our choices that reward never came as things just got harder and slipped out of our control path to Coco's design ethos changed from let's give people a rump to let's give people a gauntlet that they'll have to play and then replay and then replay to learn all its secrets which on the surface seems fine let's give people a challenge and value for money right except where Arkham Horror shines is its sense of discovery in individual puzzles rather than trying to figure out how to string this all together in the correct way if I replay a scenario to get a better outcome that's not fun I'm just applying past mistakes to make the right decisions but those right decisions no longer pose a challenge I'm just breezing through it would I recommend path to Carcosa it's not at all bad it's just that there are five cycles and the object of this is to find the best if you don't mind sludging through the same grounds and layered in obstacles that are made out of treacle

there's probably a lot you'll appreciate here but there's three more cycles to explore three more chances to greatness although these will have to be the subject of part two and if you're watching this video at the time of publishing it's going to have to be a bit of a wait until it's finished yeah these videos like take a lot of work can't just magic itself into existence watch me whilst we wait for a lane to tire herself out why not give our patient page a visit we'll need some money because we won't be able to resell our game because the dog will have even altered by then did you know we stream on Twitch we'll be streaming this first day will be playing memoir 44 come watch us this first day how long is this going to take

Progress saved