A Balanced Game is Boring
Transcript
The The term balance is a misnomer. People think that balance means that every strategy should be equal and every card should be just as good as every other card. And if you made that successfully, you would make the most boring game of all time.
Exactly. You could interchange the word with boring.
Yes, it is not that is not actually what people want. So, there are different things that you actually want when you want balance. And by the way, I learned this from making stupid mistakes on that side, right? When I first transitioned from becoming a game from a game pro player to being a designer, I started working on the Versus System trading card game and I was working with a lot that's a Marvel and DC Comics trading card game. And I was with a lot of other pro tour players who came into this job. And we were working on the Superman set and we over nerfed the hell out of it. Everything was very balanced. Nothing was broken. And it was very boring. We just we made a mistake and I learned that lesson. That's just not how you design games. So, so uh I understand people having that instinct. But what I mean what you what balance means is a couple things, right? One, that there's no single strategy such that if everybody else knows that you're doing that strategy, they cannot defeat you, right? So, that there is a there is some counter strategy available.
Rock, paper, scissors being an example of a perfectly balanced game, right? If I know what you're going to do, I can always have a strategy to beat you. It means that the strategies that are superior are that are are generally fun strategies, right? So, it's one thing to say that like a giant fire-breathing dragon is a little bit overpowered and if I'm able to draw it and play it and kill you, that's like one thing. It's another thing to say like a stasis counter spell strategy where I stop you from playing any cards and deny your resources, right? If that's the best strategy, then that's a much worse game. So, you would balance if you're going to you're going to error one side or another, error on the side of fun. And so, it's it's a you know, no single degenerate strategy that can't be defeated. It's a push the fun when possible. It's a steady learning curve of discovery for players at all skill levels and within that I would also just add in a little bit of humility because honestly you're never going to get it all right. As good as I think I am at this job and my team of, you know, six people that are working on this uh they're not as good as the the tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands out there that are going to play it constantly. So, I do my best I I err on the side of fun but I also recognize that you've got to listen to your community and sometimes you're going to miss and that's okay.