Eleven Board Game Review - Relegation Dogfight?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings we generally like to talk a lot of bollocks so more top gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a football management board game we're going to be talking about 11. the football manager board game and in this game you will be taking control of a football club you'll be managing its resources you'll be silent players hoping to get enough entry points that will allow you to win the game so in this video I'm gonna be giving you a very brief overview to also tell you what we do like we don't like and we'll come back would say whether or not 11 is worth your time and bother today and in the future so remember if you are new here please consider subscribing to this Channel with the like button all right YouTube [ __ ] see you after this so 11 how to play this game so we are going to give you a very brief overview rules there's a lot of stuff to keep track of so it's just going to be a Bare Bones rules overview right in 11 you will be taking control of a football club you will take the three player max and put them in funnier you will have the central one which has got all your resources on it you will have the one on the left which contains your stadium and its upgrades and you've got the one on the right hand side that deals with matches you put all the tokens in the right space you put all the player jerseys on the right hand player board corresponding to the basic tactic card that you have been given and see that you'll start with a few add boards that you can entice sponsors to give you cash and you'll start with two resources there's a few types of resources you've
got money you've got construction which is the green one fans and you've got Fitness right first thing you'll do is you will draft some directors you'll take a number of director cards you'll choose one put it in front of it and take a bonus if it's got one associated with it and then you'll pass the director cards on you'll do this until each player has got free directors so some other stuff you're going to do to set up but to be honest with you I can't be asked to talk about it because we'll talk about it later on so this game takes place over a number of phases that are listed as days of the week you've got Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday some reason there's no Friday but then you've got the weekend which is Match Day right on Monday you will be dealing with your directors you'll each draw a director card and you'll read the flavor text this usually comes in the form of some sort of dilemma or crisis and you roll a die and then you'll look at your directors and whatever the majority color is on the director cards that is what happens so if you roll a six then the chances are you're gonna have a majority of red and then you read the red text on the red banner and you will implement it right so then you'll move on to the days of the week this is where you get to take actions you'll get one action per day a week so that's free actions a week and you've got a variety of actions that you can take you can hire a youngster or a player in which case you will choose a player card from the three cards on the right hand side of the offer and you'll pay the cost in your and then you will put them into your player area if you sign a striker you will change their Jersey to a striker and if you sign a Defender you will have their Jersey as a Defender if you sign a youngster they haven't got a jersey number so you'll substitute one
of the jerseys on your player board for a numberless jersey one but you can only have three numberless jerseys right so be careful what you pick next thing you could do is you could sell a player you'll get two Euros plus a few extra Euros depending on how skillful they are so you look at the skill and you'll get that number of Euros in addition to two you can hire some staff who look at the offer and you'll pay the cost and then you'll put the staff in your staff area and you'll get a bonus if there's one associated with it you might see the word action on some cards you'll be able to take action actions as an action and you'll also be able to spend some construction tokens to do a card action outside of your normal actions you can contract a sponsor you've got three options here you'll take the card from the what ad free on the offer and then you'll get to give them a shout out in which case you'll usually get money you'll get to stick them on an ad board in which case you get the choice between the cash value or the bonus in the box or you can contract them as a shirt sponsor which I should put the sponsorship card on the left-hand side of your stadium board and then you'll get both so you can build Stadium infrastructure you'll choose one of the tiles you'll pay the cost on the tile and then you'll stick it on your Stadium you've got add boards which later deal with more sponsors you've got stands which give you more fans if you don't like the result of a die roll you can spend two fans to re-roll the dice that's always handy and then you've got stuff that gives you extra Fitness which you need to put players into a game or I might just give you some extra money so some of the staff cards allow you to train youngsters or players if you decide to use the action and you want to train a player then you will flip their card over and they will either become much much better or they will become much much worse if they are a veteran
right but there's always a boon and a bane when you do this it's just a matter of maybe trying to remember which players are the best and which ones are pretty shitty once you get to the weekend you'll dive into the matches as part of setup you will have drawn six team cards read the Scout report and that'll give you some sort of indication to what the strengths and weaknesses of the side that you're going to play are right it's a bit like Pompey versus the scummers yeah you'll play a taxi card that will determine your formation you start with one basic taxi car but there are staff cards that will allow you to get more right give you more variety whether or not you want to play the tried and tested 442 or whether you want to go with that really annoying shitty Wing back system that Gareth Southgate always likes to play with so you have to assign a fitness results to all the players that you want to be in the game if you ain't got no Fitness resources then you're just gonna have to play level one players right which probably mean that you're going to end up like scunthorp United some trained youngsters will give you victory points dependent on whether they just start the game whether they might score a goal or whatever so you're going to get some video points for that so that's another reason to bring youngsters through your Academy thereby avoiding the pitfalls of Dario Grady once you have chosen your team you'll remove any injured tokens or any other suspension tokens that are on the players right so they sort of come back from a crucial knee ligament injury and defy physics basically and then you resolve any before match actions that were on the players right so you have to look carefully for that so this is probably the best tricky part of the game you're going to actually resolve the match you'll see that the pitch is divided into different sections you've
got the left wing right wing the Midfield the attacking Zone and the defensive Zone and you will match pairs of players in each of these zones starting with the left wing going to the right wing and then to the Midfield then the defensing in the attack I think Strikers will score goals if they've got a bear strength than the defense and the defense will block goals if they've got a better defense than the strikers you've also got goalies that you can get they'll have a skill level strength level and a number of goalkeeper gloves and it means I could stop that many shots at that strength and what we do to keep track of this because there is no sort of goalkeeper jersey just put a die on the goal and then move it down to the lowest pip until it's exhausted right if a team scores a goal you'll move the scoring Cube up one and then once the match is completed you'll resolve any after the match conditions on the player cards you'll move the team badges is up the league or whatever you get three points for a win one for a draw and you'll get some resources if you put fan tokens on your stands where you'll get money for doing that because more fans equals more Dosh unless you're Man City and you've got a Saudi Arabian owner you'll roll the dice full match consequences you roll a D6 consult the table whether you win lose or draw and that will give you maybe something pretty nasty like injured players or maybe your top Striker gets abducted by aliens then you roll the results for the other teams in the league and they will offer a legal stay where they are or whatever then you'll do a bit of cleanup and you'll go again you will do six rounds of this and after the last match and you cleaned up all the mess that you made then you'll do a bit of endgame scoring you'll look at your position on the lead table and get a certain number of victory points for instance if you finish top of the league you get 15
points you'll get victory points for mule youngster cards that you trained yeah you'll get points four sets of Staff cards so if you've got two of each colored staff cards that will indicate a certain amount of victory points on the card right you'll get points for building your office I didn't talk about this in the rules I review because it's pretty boring but basically you can hire David Brent to do your accounting for you and then you'll lose one point for every suspension token on your Castle just be careful in the final game right that you've got enough money to pay for all the staff all the players that you've got and all of the stadium infrastructure that you have built but never used and then the player with the most victory points will be the winner of 11. so what do we like about 11. so the first thing that we really like about this game is that it's football winner it's a football management ball game that is very very playable right there's not that many football ball games out there but it probably is but most of them are completely like dog [ __ ] last one that we played was dribble fiber designed by Stefan Phil and whilst it was kind of okay it felt like a Fireside game and it had more of a cartoony feel this is a serious football management board game not without its faults right but it's football and we love a bit of footy and this allows you to sort of semi-experience what it's like to be involved in the day-to-day running of a club right and that's got to be applauded in it because if you're a football fan like me this is going to be right at history it's the second thing that we look about this is it's got a fully functioning transfer market right not only can you buy players you could buy veterans on the cheap you can
get youngsters in and you can train them bring them through your Academy and turn them into star players and not only that if you go on the internet and you download the game failed Advanced rules you can even sell your players to your bonus this is an absolutely fantastic thing that's been implemented into the game it's probably by far a wider standout thing the only bummer is that the players aren't based in reality so it's like the old Pro Evolution Soccer where you've got like Alan Shira or maybe Michael Bowen in hot man so the first thing that we like about 11 is that it's not the person that wins a league that wins the game is supplied with the most feature points that wins a game several occasions when we have played this a lot of people focus on winning the matches getting up that League table beating your opponents getting into that prized spot in doing so they neglect the data they're running of their Club then it collects the financial machine that is needed to keep the club going and as such they don't have enough money to pay for their upkeep the staff go on strike the players get suspended and their whole operation falls apart right so you've got to be looking at all the other aspects you've got to build up your office even though it's boring as [ __ ] you've got to get those staff members in that are going to allow you to augment your business right just because you bought all the best players you've got the best goalie doesn't mean you're gonna win game and who doesn't like a [ __ ] on killing in the FA Cup you know what I mean but don't rely about 11.
so first thing that we don't like about this is It's a massive table hog right this has a bigger footprint than the [ __ ] Yeti I mean just look at the plier boards right why is this so much a new space on the stadium board right that could have been shrunk down into like maybe two or three columns on a tiny little board right and if you're playing this with four players there is no way that you're going to be able to fit all the [ __ ] onto a five by three table or if you've got a smaller table then forget it right you're gonna have to play it on the floor I don't know why they went for the flimsy horrible player boards where everything flops around and slides off and why once you put the three playables together it's like looking at a [ __ ] boogie board so yeah they could have struck this game down to a more manageable size right and as it stands it's a right pain in the ass second thing that we don't like about this game is that there are loads and loads and loads of unclear rules or maybe more accurately rules that require further explanation right some Geezer as produced an FAQ an unofficial FAQ but it's not really in any order so you're going to be looking through pages and pages and pages of [ __ ] to try and find the answer to the question that you want the rule book is a pain in the bomb it's a big flappy rule book which we hate with a passion there's loads of wasted space in it right there's just big pictures of these weird people laughing at you because you're holding a big massive broad cheat newspaper waiting for it to fall onto the table and not everything flying right someone could go back rewrite the rule book make it a little bit more clearer add in some decent examples because let's face it the examples in a book are bloody awful especially when they're telling you how
to play the matches that just drove me out a wall so yeah it needs a rule book revision more clarification and you know it's sort of getting par for the course of pool games in it yeah how many times have they made shocking rule books where people end up just burning the game rather than asking enough questions so the next thing that we don't like about 11 is that the match resolution system is shocking at the end of the day I didn't have a bloody clue what I was doing when I first dived into this and I had to watch a lot of videos and even then I didn't really understand what was happening the main problem is you've got a pliers on one side of the ball and you're gonna have to look at the jersey number look at your pliers match them up so you're holding three different bits of information in your brain and trying to match one bit of information with the other two and my brain just don't work like that it struggles to hold figures and numbers in my head and every time I play this I look at the sections on the pitch and then I think hang on a minute did I do that right so I've got to go back and look at it again if you screw up one you're gonna think you screwed up the other so you have to go back and do it again and even then I'm not 100 sure that what I was doing was correct here so the match day resolution isn't that great it feels like you are sawing off your toes right so the final thing that we've done about 11 is that this game has random die rolls in it here you're going to be rolling a die to decide what the directors are going to do and okay we can forgive this because you chose the bloody directors right but at the end of the game you are going to be rolling a die to see what the end of game effects are going to be right and you could end up with like a double injury through no full of your own and that is just unforgivable but it's got
to be a way to remove that from the game I've been looking for variants which get rid of this random die roll crap and I suppose at the end of the day just don't do it just leave that bit out right or come up with something on your own because you might find at the end of a match your Star Striker gets a double injury and is out for two games and that's what's gonna cost you a game right a level 4 Striker is out for the final two games through no 40 round through the unforgivable mechanic of random die rolls so to summarize is 11 worth your time of bother today and in the future so we're going to say yes okay it's not a perfect game but any stretch of the imagination right the match resolution system will drive you up the [ __ ] wall right it really will I mean look since I've been playing this game I've lost more follicles than you adult dinners right if you add to this the fact that it's not really a full season right you're gonna have six games here you can't really decide a full season on six games there's no options to play a full season and who would want to right because this game's going to take about three hours of play anyway however it really is the only option that us football Nutters have got at the moment right there's not really any other football management games to come anywhere near this all the other ones are complete dog [ __ ] or maybe a little bit too much dog [ __ ] it offers an in-depth football manager experience and it covers all the major bases of football management done it you're going to be able to hire players you're going to be able to sell them you're going to be doing up your Stadium you're going to be higher and start you're going to be making sure you've got enough money and I suppose you are going to be picking
the players and sending them out onto the pitch in the hope that you can do over the scum so I suppose if you can forgive the glare and emissions in this game like the fact that it's not really a football simulator right the match resolution is Bonkers fiddly and frustrating and the fact that there's not really any real player names in it if you could forgive all that you would definitely find it's still a fun descent into the inane world of the football management circus right just don't get sacked so there you go that is 11 the football manager ball game remember if you know it and please consider subscribing to this Channel with the like button already YouTube [ __ ] see you next time all right