Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Great Commission: Chat w/ Dan Thurot

Transcript 56:22

Hey gamers, this is David from Beyond Solitire and today I am joined by Dian Pau because we have been sent to Jesus game and we like to do this. How you doing?

I'm doing great. How are you?

I'm doing all right. Uh so for those of you out there, we are here to talk about the great a new little card game about managing I would say um from Paul Snugs and Simon Amadeas. Oh, I said um I said this is game about managing a church, but

Oh, yes.

I was like, is that right? Like growing a church? Um

growing a church. It's like doing a doortodoor ministry out of your local mega church.

Um so just so y'all know, uh actually I'm just going to flag this here. I'm going to cut to an overview of what this game is now and then [snorts] when we get back you'll know what the game is about. Hey, it's Liz. I'm here to show you how to play the Great Commission. This is not a detailed rules guide all. It's just a little overview to give you a sense of what Dan and I are talking about for the rest of our video. So, here's the Great Commission all set up for one player. I have, of course, chosen to be the Church of Rome, which makes perfect sense for someone like me. But the basic point of this game is to try to get through this entire world deck. So, this is a mixture of people who you need to bring into your church and activities that you can do as kind of like special actions to help that happen. And then blocking you, uh, you're going to have a couple of things that you need to deal with all the time.

So, every round there's going to be an event. This is a mixture of good and bad events. So, sometimes an event will come up and you're like, "Yeah, awesome." And sometimes an event will come up and it really gets in your way. So, um, you got to be careful, especially because early on there may be more good events than bad or more bad events than good. you don't actually know because you shuffle at the start of the game and then one of those cards is removed. You need to preserve your spiritual health. So, you can pray to get this up. Uh, and there are things that are going to drag it down. But if you run out of spirit, uh, your church is going to fall apart and you will lose the game. As the game progresses, troubles are going to come from this trouble deck. And basically, you lose spirit for troubles that are face down. But there are other pendies for troubles that are face up. So, you have to solve your problems and you can't just sit there and ignore them.

Uh, but also while you're confronting them, they're kind of a pain, which does thematically make sense for trouble in in a person's life. And then when you pray, um, sometimes you're going to just boost your spirit up and then other times you can get these blessings. So, I will admit Dan and I are gonna laugh about these later in the video because they really look like they came from like, I don't know, some vinyl lettering for the wall or maybe like a fancy Bible cover for Bible study or, you know, a greeting card my grandmother would have sent me when she was alive. Um, but you know, cheesy though they are. Uh, they are here to help you and you will end up making use of them. So, the way things will work in order, just a quick talk through is the event phase. You're going to draw and resolve an event. Then you get your actions phase.

And actions are nice uh because that's how you're going to get anything done. Obviously, uh you get a base of two per turn. Uh but you can try to use your card powers to ring more out of everything. So, all of these cards will have different actions that they can do. Uh some of them will be need some of them will need to be commissioned for that. So you just kind of turn them horizontally. Some will be exhausted for that. So you got to turn them all the way. And then there are recovery actions that you can take later to kind of help them get back to full strength and use their actions again. You're also going to be using these uh faith and wisdom values on each card to try to pass certain checks in the game. So, if you want to get some more people from the world deck, you got to do like a faith check and you could pick a number of these people and you have to then guess how many of these cards you want to draw from the deck. And if this number is bigger than the, you know, resistance number on the on the cards for people that you draw, then they enter your church. But if you underestimate, then the check is failed and they go back into the deck. If you overestimate, then you've overpaid. So, there's a little bit of like a press your luck, think about your odds, you know, think about the people that might be trying to come in your church aspect of the game.

Other things that you can do are use some sort of mixture of faith or wisdom to deal with your troubles that are revealed. You can reveal your troubles. Uh, or you can kind of do freebies with your activity cards. So, this is really a hand management game that's being used to clear out this deck over here. Then, of course, you get a troubles phase. Um, and then your troubles come back to haunt you. So, that's really it. It is a simple game. It's got a decent amount of crunch to it for that. And so, that's an overview of how The Great Commission is played. Um, I'm just going to give you a glimpse at some of the cards in here so you'll have a stronger sense of what Dan and I are talking about. So, troubles sort of include personal things. So you can have like outbursts of anger, pride, sloth, pretty typical unforgiveness, apathy, complacency.

Um, so these are like, you know, self-righteousness, and you have stuff like demonic possession. This little blood spatter means that they think that you should remove it from the game if you're playing with a sensitive audience. I am personally not sensitive to de to demonic possession, so I think uh it's fine for me. And so the troubles are, you know, grounded pretty much in what you would expect people making a game about a church to talk about. Uh, and then the people are kind of fun. So you get everybody from farmers to priests. This guy would have been super resistant to joining the church if uh if I had drawn him from the world deck, but he's here now. Um, we got a lawyer, a rich merchant, a procelite. So basically so basically this game is trying to present you with a lot of different sorts of people from different backgrounds. And I think that is a good thing. Uh, for the leader here, there are a bunch of different leaders, including more famous biblical ones, but I went with Priscilla and Aquilla because I like them from the works of Paul.

Um, and the leaders do basically just work like all the other cards except that they are named and they have a pretty sick special power. Um, so be aware that they can get wiped out, tired out just like anybody else. Uh the other thing I just want to point out is that there are two like kind of races in the game. Obviously, as you can see, there's a real effort at representation in the art. Uh but what we have are we have Jewish cards and we have gentile cards and those are denoted uh by symbols on the bottom. And you get this like proite who's sort of a half and half, which is funny. So yeah, I think that's enough overview for you to get sense of what's in here so that uh you can enjoy Dan and my discussion in the following segment. All right. So, Dian, um, first, where do you want to start with talking about this game?

Uh,

can I Okay, how about this? I want to start with something I really loved about it.

Yeah.

So, in this game, you like you've done your overview, right? So, you're managing a church, you have a church leader, you have all these congregants who are in your church, but there are troubles that can afflict your church. And I was playing this game and honestly, I was having a little bit of a little bit of trouble with it because religion can be a hard subject for many people,

not just me, not just you, but I played this with a a wide array of people, some of whom found it a little testy. Okay. But there was a card in that troubles deck that I flipped to that actually made me appreciate the game a little more and I so I want to share that because I think it highlights something good about the game. Let's see if I can find it. So I have all the there's first of all there's like a billion decks here but let's see. So it's one of these trouble cards. So, these are the bad things that can happen to your uh church. And some of them are, you know, like demonic possession where somebody like starts turning green inside. That's that would be scary, you know.

Oh, that's not so bad.

Oh, okay. Well, it just means they're it just means their humors are out of balance. But like um let's see if I can find it. I know it's one of these. Okay, here it is. This card is called the spirit of self-reliance.

And actually, I really So, when I flipped this, I was actually kind of happy because one thing that I'm always interested in, um, as some of your watchers will undoubtedly know is you are a doctor of Christian history and, um, girl, same. But like one of the things that I loved about this game is that early Christians were always kind of creating their identity. And right now in the country I'm in that this would absolutely be one of the uh troubles afflicting many major Christian sects is this notion of like rugged individuality. Mhm.

And some outside Christian observers have noted that that's a bit of a that could be considered a bit of a heresy. And so drawing this spiritual trouble, this spirit of self-reliance, um, which is that other players can't really help you as well that that you're so obsessed with I can do it myself that no one can help me from outside. And it really hurts you because if you play multiplayer, this is a game about helping each other, about reaching out to other congregations, sending people to them, sending assistance, praying for them, which creates very tangible blessings, which we can talk about the cosmology of that and how weird that is, but like

I actually really liked that. Um, this game has a lot of issues, but there some of the issues I think um are very well-intentioned and so I was happy to see that. So, I loved that. And it has little moments like that where I that kind of even when I'm frustrated with it that they spark out and make me feel a little more warmly toward it. So, I wanted to start with that because I think maybe it sets the tone for my feelings on the game. Um, [snorts]

yeah. So, I will also say something that pleased me, which is that whether or not I think it's a successful effort at representing early church, I feel like there was a real effort, if that makes sense. like,

yeah,

the game made an effort to incorporate both Jews and Gentiles. Uh maybe not in exactly the way that I personally would envision thinking about early church history, but in a way that felt, I think, appropriate to the scale of the game and to the base text. Um, so I mean, there's real effort there. I liked the fact that there were women present among named church leaders. I actually would have picked different women.

Yeah. Um, so you get Priscilla and Aquilla, which that's a cool pairing. I liked that a lot. But actually, rather than like Mary, Mother of Jesus and Mary Magdalene, I would have liked to see like Chloe

or like a junior, you know? Like I feel like you could have actually gone for some more interesting picks, but I was happy that there was like an effort to have women leadership even if technically it might not have looked quite the way it looks in this game. Yeah, I I agree with you. I was really curious about why I almost wonder if picking Junia would have been too controversial.

Do you know what I mean?

Oh, yeah. I'm I'm the edge lord here for sure.

I mean, maybe um maybe we should explain. I I assume that not all of our maybe maybe your uh viewers are like the most New Testament literate viewers in the universe, but maybe it would help for you to explain the Junia thing.

Yes. Okay. So, first I'll just mention Khloe. Paul very explicitly like thanks Khloe's people and talks in ways that imply that Khloe is in fact the one who's handling out of business for him at a church he has planted. Um you can you're you're the expert on women in the ancient church actually hilariously. Uh but you know basically when you kind of dig into the material you learn that [clears throat] you know women were a major part of Christianity's early ability to survive and some of the earliest buyin and some of the earliest buyers in with money. But uh Junia is a favorite of mine and one of my friends actually has a kid named Junior because um there is a reference to apostles a guy and Junia. So Junia is our closest thing we have to a named female [snorts] apostle. And so her identity even though we don't have a ton of information about her is extremely significant. So, I throw that in there just because, you know, I like to push that edge a lot and this game does not. They're not ready.

And maybe we should clarify, you know, so Junia because of sexism was written out of most English translations of the New Testament where certain translators were like, "No, that can't be right." And so, they rendered her name as Junius. So, they masculineized her name.

But there's a few problems. First of all, we can look in older documents and there it's a Junia, but also there's no there's no name Junius in this time period. There there's no um there's no corresponding evidence that anyone had that name. So, so

yeah,

there's some there's some argument to be made that some of those translators were like, oh, this was this they weren't being malicious necessarily. It has been argued by many scholars that they were changing the name Junia to Junius because they thought it was an error. So it was more an internalized misogyny than you know explicit on their part. But uh a a bad change and this a this game designer is working from the NIV which does correct it to Junia. So

yeah.

Yeah. I think I want to point out that just the fact that we've already gotten off on this little tangent is a strong indicator that any game that's on this topic, if you are super keyed into the topic is going to like lead you in a bunch of places. It's very very difficult ground for anyone. Um, but especially for those of us trying to make a claim to like looking like an original early church.

Yeah,

I think that's fair. Yeah, this is real. And part of why I want to be a little careful with it and not be too critical in this format is because I do think I do think it's trying and I do think it does some very good things. Um, even if the designer doesn't seem to understand the Roman world or early Christianity in as much depth as I, as a scholar of early Christianity, would have preferred. Um, and it's hard. I don't want to be too critical because this is something that I've talked a lot about in terms of all board games and Euro games which love to take a setting and just sort of pillillage it and use it as an aesthetic and not so much for what that setting is about or what it says. And I think that this designer though doesn't want to do that

and and to his credit I don't think he does to the extent that a lot of board games do.

Yeah. and their credit technically we do have co-designs the codeesign situation here

my bad um and so like I I do think that I I do think there is a good faith effort here I just also am I'm am curious like what sort of like I haven't looked into this yet because I'm not ready to write my review [snorts] but I haven't looked into the the creator's background at all I assume they're religious I don't know what tradition but I feel like they are relying a lot on their own information. Like they think that the text will be sufficient like the New Testament text. Like I just don't get the sense they actually know all that much about what an early Christian church or its command structure for lack of a better phrase. Uh I I don't think they understand what they look like.

Yeah. And so here's the thing like we we exist in a culture and this is the fault of of Protestantism. No, but we exist in a culture where you know speaking of rugged individualism, right? Um people think that we can each just encounter the text of the Bible and that it will be clear. Like my favorite thing that I heard in my least favorite thing, but it's like this is a sarcastic favorite that I heard in Sunday school was the Bible stands for basic instructions before leaving earth. And like there's nothing basic about anything in here. Dan, have I tra have I retraumatized you as well?

I've never heard that, but I don't like it. Uh,

no. But so in terms of like if you are just looking at Axe, [snorts] I feel like what you're getting out of this is not crazy. I also feel like the scale of the game is small enough that it sidesteps some larger questions because it's very easy to personalize it by having this be a game about individual people that you invite into a community who have some personal problems. It all feels very individualized and very personalized in ways that kind of remove what I find the most interesting about this period, which is structurally what's happening. Yeah. I mean, so like here here's a big example is so first of all I want to agree with what you said which is that there is this notion that you can just read the Bible and understand it. And it's it's a notion that has been promoted by a lot of the wonderful translations that have been given to you. But first of all, we should clarify that none of us as individuals, not you, n could understand this without the work of thousands of scholars having done work before us. Um, you are not understanding the Bible on your own. You could not read one character of it without doctors and translators who have gone through before you. Um, you just can't. So first of all, even just to read the NIV, you were already relying

on scholarship and some of that scholarship is very good and some of it might have been flawed. Um, so I just wanted to say that to agree with you first of all, but beyond that, one of the big issues is so what was there there was a range of decades that apparently one of the designers said the game

Yes, I screenshotted this comment and sent it to you because I thought it would help inform us. Um, let's see. Yes, this is supposed to cover the period of 30 to 60 AD,

which I will let everybody out there know that's an eyebrow razor

specifically because we think that the letters of Paul himself were written in what, like the 50s, the Gospel of Mark 70 or later.

Yeah. And there's a lot of evidence for that. Timothy and like the the the pseudo Pauline letters, the ones that aren't actually him like Timothy and Titus, the pastorals, those are like solidly second century. They represent the church in a different state of development than what Paul would have understood.

Yeah. So just the way So this is one of my specialties in early Christian history is I specialize a lot in the way that Christianity changes. Um and so for example, my most popular course that I've ever taught is called transitions in Christianity. And the thesis of this course is that we look at different flash points and we analyze the way that the Christianity that comes out of that those flash points would be unrecognizable to the Christianity that went into them. Now an obvious example would be the Protestant Reformation, right? coming out of the Protestant Reformation, the churches and the traditions, even some of the like doctrine is completely like people going into the Protestant Reformation could not have conceived that those doctrines or those practices or that approach to priests would be the way that Christianity would operate at the beginning of that crisis. But there's a really telling crisis in this time period that happens in about the year 70. And this game I never would have believed had happened before the Roman sack of Jerusalem.

Um like I never because the game kind of is really wishy-washy in terms of it kind of is taking the first two centuries of Christian problems and persecutions and mushing them together. And I think I mentioned this to you. I would have guessed that this game was set starting in like 140.

Yeah. Um, even though it has all these named characters who obviously would have been dead a century before that. Um, just

because church location development and like the issues presented and the the current state of the Jewish Gentile question. Yeah, it's really later, but there's there are these weird hints of it earlier like it like it seems like the game like when is the Jerusalem council in relation to this game like does it happen like the Jew gentile thing

is so loaded like the game tries right and like one of the trouble I think it's one of the trouble cards that you can resolve is called racism and for instance I have a friend Adam who is really proud cuz both times we've played this game multiplayer, he has solved racism and we're like so proud of him that he has just like tackled this issue that afflicts us today. But like racism as as I think the game is conceiving it like it's just it's just a weird fology, right? Like there is this question but it's more a question of like practice than it is of like race. And so like the game I think is being very earnest in presenting you with some of these problems, but it's kind of like I it's like the equivalent of learning American history and talking about that time George Washington defeated, you know, um General Lee with F-16s at at the Battle of Wounded Knee. Like it's just taking all these things and kind of mushing them together without really understanding their context, which again is fine. um it just make like depending on how pmical you're you're reading this work as it it does present a rather false perspective of what the time period looked like.

Yeah, I think that the only reason I care about that, so this is very full disclosure. Uh Dan and I were contacted by Desires of This Game because they had enjoyed our video about Jerusalem an odominy where we had gone pretty deep and done some pretty serious analysis of um that game and like what it meant biblically and whether to hit the mark that way. And also these designers are involved in another project called the word for word bible. So these are people who are committed to themselves and seeing their work as like a real representation of like what went down in the church. And I personally feel that we were brought in specifically to kind of like push at those questions. And so my understanding of how I was supposed to discuss this game is very much informed by that if that makes sense.

And so I don't even know that I would be it actually I think made me think harder about it than I might otherwise have if that makes sense. Like when you play the game it just pretty much feels like a normal game. I actually do want to talk about that because they market this as like for anyone of any faith and I I want to put a pin in that and come to that later. Um, but like you know I think that in terms of our own feelings of authenticity based on what we today understand about Christianity and what it's supposed to do for you, you know, we're seeing a game with pretty good male female representation. We're seeing a game with pretty good racial representation as speaking of racism, right? Like there's people of different ethnicities clearly represented in the game. All those things are to the good and they're also people who are like working together to solve things that are like pretty real problems. Um, you know, like the troubles deck isn't going to like feel bad. In fact, I'm pretty sure it would feel relatable to most people who have thought about like religious life at all. Um, and so, you know, the game has this kind of like very like it feels mostly like a normal board game mechanically and it brings in things that when you look at them, you're like, well, why would this be a problem? Like, why would I pause seeing something like this? And so, you know, I feel like I dig because it's natural to me as somebody who's interested in representations of early Christianity in various pop culture, especially games.

Um but also because I feel like in a way we were asked to assess it this way.

Yeah. And and to be clear like there are two I mean not only two there are many early Christianities when we talk about like historioggraphy right like

and this game is kind of digging into

um Christianity as it wants to present itself

and not so much Christianity as it was. Um if you read a lot of those later period like epistles and including we should mention including the gospels which were written later um it's trying to present a very deliberate and um hand selected version of events and it's interesting to me that a lot of um a lot of this game where I where I'm trying to watch walk this tight rope between like accepting that this is a Christian product

Yes. where I don't want to be too critical when it misses it the mark a little bit historically, but also like textually like some of the history does sneak through the cracks and the game is still kind of turning a blind eye to them. And so I'm trying to walk that tight rope because I do have certain warm feelings toward this game. Um, but then the the historian side of me wants to and I feel like the reason I'm kind of qualified to review this game is because I can dig in there into those cracks and be like, "Aha." So,

yes. Yeah. I mean, I mean, the the pull apart exercise is just fun, too, frankly, I think, for people.

Yeah. Like, I I enjoy the game more. I I enjoy it more when I nitpick it. Um, which isn't to say it's a bad game. Um,

no the but it should not be a game that you just play and accept it as a depiction of how it was. Um, for me I think one thing that I'm missing in games about early Christianity across the board and I would love to see this change and like what maybe I'm the one to change it. I don't know. But I want to see more mess and more acknowledgement I think of like technical administrative problems if that makes sense. So, first of all, you should know when

you know when you're a world where like the the Bible as a collection of books does not exist.

There is no New Testament. Maybe you have a scrap of a gospel and you've heard some sayings of Jesus from somewhere and you've got like a a letter of Paul maybe in your community. Like what does how do you interpret like how you're supposed to be? And so everybody interprets everything differently. There's a whole bunch of different, you know, this there's gonna be people who are like, yo, like what if we combine this like philosophy, man, and then like you end up with narcissism pretty soon. Yeah.

Um, and there are people who are arguing about,

you know, church hierarchy and who's a leader matters really quickly. Um, these are people who need money and who are dealing with false teachers, but like how do you know who's a false teacher versus just a different teacher. So like all those like really hot mess themes kind of get ellighted a little bit in here.

Yeah. And I I just kind of want it to be messy. Like

Yeah, I want it to be messy. And I think I mentioned this to you, but like when I sit down to play this game, the first problem with it is that it's cooperative. [clears throat] [sighs]

[snorts]

And um and I want to be clear that like you know the early Christian project first of all they're not even calling themselves Christian yet but like

the early Christian project is fascinating because like one of its first acts is to raise money to send to another church because of a famine. Um, so there are these cooperative elements, but this game is kind of doing, so this is something that I warn a lot of my students about, which is the assumption of orthodoxy, which is the notion that there is a practice or a doctrine that is so established that everyone is willing to do it. And in fact, we know that's not true because one of the first questions that the early Christian church has to ask about is circumcision. Because as soon as they are as soon as some of the people who are not already Jewish are coming into the church, they're like, "Well, I kind of don't want to do that part." And um you know, for reasons actually, this is one of the few places where I'm way more qualified than you, Liz, to

Yes, I think so. I you know, I'm I'm uncircumcised and it's really fine. You see, uh, so I I have opinions about people touching me there with scissors. And, um, and so it's this very relatable concern. And one of the first like tangible doctrinal questions is, do we force these new converts? Are they Jewish now or are they not Jewish? um if if this game is set in the year 40 to 60, it's still a Jewish movement. And so that question is very ongoing. And so like different Christian churches would be in conflict even as some of them seek kinship and are trying to aid one another. There is no notion of like heresy really.

No. Um, and so like when we're playing this game and we're all great friends and we're all sending each other stuff, that feels good. Like I have played this game so far only for a player where I have

Wow.

Yeah. So where we've sat down with me and three others which kind of raises some interesting notes too which I almost I I do let's put a pin in that because I want to talk about that but like you spent a lot of time like sending aid to one another and praying for one another and that feels really good and it is not an accurate reflection of most Christian congregations in this time period. Like you even get like Paul, you know, one of in a very famous and sort of elusive reference in in 2 Corinthians where he's he's sarcastically talking about the super apostles, right? That there's these evangelizing forces that he is encouraging you not to listen to. And we don't know much about them except that Paul is really strident in telling you not to listen to them. And the and that's one of the first times we really see like this boundary maintenance which is Paul who's really coming out here and being like only listen to me. Um other than but we don't get the these other people's messages. It's Paul who's establishing sort of this notion of orthodoxy. And so the game is just too friendly. Like like none of you are like the churches are very modern in that respect. But also it's wild because even modern Christian churches don't get along this well.

That's yeah that's deeply accurate actually. Um out of pocket future theory. I think that as like if Christian nationalism continues to rise in the United States I think churches will continue to get along less well. I mean, I think it's telling that we have seen priests be shot in the face with like pepper balls. I mean, so for instance, in my religious tradition, which is Mormonism, which immediately some of our our viewers are like, "Okay, well, now we can't listen to you." Um, because Mormons aren't Christians. Um, yes, they are, you silly goosees. Um like the I was raised on this atmosphere of like we have to hold the line because religious persecution is real because Mormonism had faced some early religious persecution. And right now in the United States we are seeing here it's here here's religious persecution of Christians and it's coming from Christians.

Yeah. Um, and so it's not coming from, you know, Bill Gates or whatever. It's not coming from Muslims. It's Christians who are shooting other Christians in the face with with tear gas.

Yeah. I mean, I think that the makers of this game did not necessarily want their work to be interpreted against this particular backdrop, but we cannot help the times in which we make our work.

Yeah. I sorry. Um but yeah, the other thing that was interesting about this one is yes, we do have a lot of sort of biblical stories of people getting arrested. Uh but the idea of extensive Roman persecution against Christians is also pretty questionable for a very long time in the history of the church. And um I just sort of enjoy noting that. Uh, my favorite piece of literature about Christians from Romans is Trajan writing to Plenty back and forth about them and Plenty and Trajan just sort of come to the conclusion of these guys are weirdos. They just seem like very obstinate and like I don't even really know what they believe, but for this reason they should be punished.

So, you know, the uh

we could have a a very extended conversation as a void about what persecution looks like and like what oddly like the desire for it looks like.

Yes. Yeah. A lot of the reports from this time period of persecution are exaggerated because I mean if you think about where this early movement comes from, it is coming from Roman persecution. And so a lot of these early efforts are to say, "Oh, look, someone who was a wellto-do Roman citizen who converted and then was punished by being thrown in prison." That that should be taken with a little grain of salt. Um, especially when there's just no corresponding evidence for those persecutions in that time period or in that format or to that severity in this time period. See, I'm adding a lot of qualifiers because history in this time period requires so many qualifiers. Yes.

And this game is just sort of lumping everything together in this sort of received wisdom way uh you know that Christianity looks at itself. Um but that as a historian is just so hard to deprogram.

Yes. Actually, I think this is the right place to kind of like conclude the historical part of this discussion, which is that this is a very, correct me if you think this is an incorrect take on like what we've just talked about. Like the TLDDR version of this is this is a game about an extremely complex time period that is highly messy. But what we're getting is like an orthodox favoring streamlined kind of individualized version of this that reflects the way that Christianity wants to see its early self in this era. Yeah.

And like that doesn't mean that it's bad, but it does mean that you have to look at it and think twice about what you're seeing in rel in relationship to like what really happened, which is full of qualifiers.

Yeah, I would agree.

Yeah. Um, so the other thing I kind of want to talk about just because we, you know, you and your group talked about this and you and I, you and I have talked about this. So, first, what I've played this solo, obviously. So, what are your uh group dynamic takes on this game because it sounds like some interesting stuff went down.

Yeah. So, I've played this with two groups. Um both times we had four players and which is you really are facing a jumble um because you're basically facing the entire deck and the goal of course um is to convert the convert the world um hack the planet as it were and it's it's quite challenging at least in our first game we got stomped and in our second game we did succeed but kind of by the skin of our teeth and I can see how once Once you figure out like the barriers to conversion, it gets a lot easier. Well, some of the people I played with, um, I don't want to say too much about them, but we did have, for example, we did have somebody who is queer. Um we did play for example with somebody who is an unmarried um adult man which who is considered to have kind of failed at his calling so to speak because in Mormonism you're being married and having children is deeply tied to like if you succeed and go to heaven basically that's super simple.

Um, you can basically everyone goes to heaven in Mormonism, but like there's degrees of heaven and kind of the Mormon cosmology is get married, have an eternal family, and there is a keen sense of like failure that kind of lingers over his life. Um, I played with a uh woman who has recently had deep struggles with Christianity that are very new and so are very raw. And one of the things that I asked them um when we finished playing the game to both groups was did you find this how did you find this game emotionally? Like usually every time I play a game with a group I ask what did we think of it? And this is one of the few times that I was like, "What did we think emotionally?"

Because of the first time we play, you know, the first question I ask is of course like, "What did we think?" And everyone gives me mechanical answers.

And then I said, "What do you feel emotionally?" And I got hit with a broadside. Um, which I was kind of expecting. Um, [clears throat] now I will also say I am planning I have it I have it set up to play this game also with some current Orthodox practitioners of Christianity because I'm really curious to see but but they're people who are very nuanced in their understanding both of their faith and the history. So I'm curious to see what they will say. Um, but the two groups that I played with, we got a wider range of answers including some hurt. Um, one person did say they found it triggering. Um, other people said they found it a little tasteless. Um, now again, I'm playing with heretics, right? Like the these are people who have had a great deal of hurt come from their Christian backgrounds. Um, but the notion that this game is suitable for everybody, I think, is very hopeful and that the hope might not totally reflect the reality.

Yeah, I will say that I as an atheist who deconverted back when I was a teenager, so I've now been an atheist for more of my life than I have not been. Um, is that accurate? Yes, that's accurate. Um, but um, but um, you know, I I wouldn't say I found the game like triggering. I will say that it brought up sort of an unpalatable assortment of memories because of its aesthetics in addition to like the point that it's making. So, um it's not that the art is bad. In fact, I think the art is very nicely done. Um and you know there that's a point of pride for this project and for the word for word Bible project to which it is really Yeah, we could talk. Oh, Christ. So, uh, you know, all the people are kind of like they're all a lot of them are like gazing up in amazement, kind of slack jawed, like lower teeth out, crying.

Like there's like the there's like a really big component of like I it it just really felt youth groupy to me in ways that like I don't know how to fully process without therapy. Um, and then yes, the blessing cards really look like they look like Bible study Bible book covers or like the kind

they look like they should be in vinyl lettering on the wall.

Yeah. Yes. A little uh live laugh blessed. Um, but you know, it's really interesting because like it's not that it's offensive. It's that it's aesthetically it is saying something very particular, I think, about who it's for. And it is for Christians. It is for a very specific variety of Christians who enjoy looking at faith art, who probably enjoy listening to Christian music, and who um and not the Bach kind. Uh, and

yeah, you should play this while blasting casting crowns. And I bet it would be like a whole thing.

Oh yeah. I I actually like you know it'd probably be pretty sick if you're the if if you're the target audience for this.

Yeah. Like you would feel those prickles up the back of your legs. You'd be like I'm being moved right now.

And I don't want to sl I don't want to slam it for that. It's just that like it feel I feel like it's being sold to me as this very universal experience and it's just not.

Yes, that's accurate because it's not that it's bad. It's actually like super well done. It is interesting. I do think the blessing cards are a little much just because they

they're like,

but everything else is like actually pretty cool. But it does have cultural signifiers that make it very clear that it's of and for I think a specific subset of people. And I think that this is exactly the sort of thing where you know um Dan, you're a Mormon. You know, you might have been through this, like somebody has tried to convert you to the correct version of Christianity.

Oh, yeah.

And they don't see anything wrong with what they're doing, and they think that their message is utterly relatable and that like the Bible's just this really great piece of literature that if you just read it, you would love it.

And like this game has those vibes. Does that make sense? That they could they just show you how nice they are

that you'll your pallet will adjust.

Yeah. And to be fair, I've done it, too. I I did a two-year LDS mission in which we spent a lot of time both converting and being the targets of attempted conversion. And this game kind of like even it's evangelizing mission which first of all is a little uh out of synchronicity with the time period. the way you're doing like the game feels like you're going doortodoor on a weekend

from your mega church to invite people to the bake off,

right? And also if you just have enough faith, you could overcome their lack of faith, which one of the reasons I tell people I I would say very technically I'm probably an agnostic or what you'd call a weak atheist. I don't like actively go there is no god like all the time. I just kind of live my life as if I'm not worrying about it. But I say atheist very specifically because I am trying to indicate that I do not invite this idea that if you had enough faith and you talked to me enough you would change my mind.

Yeah. There's a part of me that like so one of the things that one of my friends found a little triggering about it and I I say the word triggering because she's the one who specifically said it was this was triggering is this notion of so she's coming out of a Christian tradition that has given her a degree of what we call scrupulosity which you often find in high demand religions which is that the religion was that that you were raised with gave you this sense that everything is your fault And so so in so that's a therapeutic term

scrupulosity this notion that like everything is on me everything I'm doing wrong there are rules I must follow and I'm not following them it's a very specific type of anxiety and so the game as presented which is that if you can generate enough faith you can convince a synagogue leader to join Christianity and you know I don't want to say that that's I don't want to use the P problematic because there were synagogue leaders and Pharisees and Sadducees who were the bulk of the early Christians in

part who also understood themselves as Jewish.

Yes. See themselves to anything like

Yeah. Exactly. That's what I was going to say. They were still fully Jewish. There had not yet been this split between the way and Judaism. And so they would not have considered themselves to have converted. And once that split occurs, the notion of converting someone to early Christianity kind of disappears for Judaism because now that boundary maintenance has changed. Oh, you're saying I have to not be Jewish to be Christian. Well, then they stop converting in the same bulk. [snorts] And and so but this notion that like if you have enough faith you can now convert another faith leader to your faith was a little bit triggering for her because that's how she had been she had done a a mission as well um 18 months as women do in the LDS church.

And that's that's kind of how it's pitched to you. That if you pray enough and if you fast enough and if you're out there hitting those streets and if you're in tune with the spirit enough so that it can whisper in your ear the right arguments from the Bible, then yeah, you can convert anyone who has their heart in the right place. So there's no assumption in two directions. First of all, the assumption is that if you don't have that, if you're not in tune, you're flawed. You sinned. But there's also the assumption that anyone who doesn't listen to you, it's because they aren't good. They aren't chosen. Um they they've done something wrong. There's never the assumption that either you or the person who's the target of your evangelical mission. There's never the assumption that both of you might be right or okay. Uh that maybe they belong in their faith and you belong in yours for a variety of reasons. That is off the table. And the game presents that.

And again, I don't nec I don't, you know, this game, this is a game that is mechanisms. Um perhaps the people that are unconvertible just aren't in the deck, right? Like it's only presenting the people that maybe you can convert. So I don't want to read too much into it, but this player did find that triggering for that reason because she had done a mission. She had spent a year and a half being told she wasn't good enough or that the people who wouldn't listen to her weren't good enough. And the game feeds into that message even unwillingly. Yeah. Yeah. I think that this is a good example though of like you can never escape the context that you exist in. Um, and

you know that's both true in terms of like I think the subliminal and overt messages the game sends and also it's going to impact how it's received. Like mechanically it does feel like a game. Yeah, I think that like you know if you really don't care about theme you could probably play it. But it's harder to imagine a theme that people would not care about. Like I

Yeah.

You know, in in in a society that's so steeped with conversations about this material, um I don't

I don't think that you can

truly say that you don't care.

I mean, it's interesting, too. One of my players was frustrated with the game specifically because of the Christian nationalism movement that we are seeing in the United States. Now, it's my understanding the game designers are they they're from the UK, aren't they?

Yeah, I think so. Yeah, one of them was like at Paul Grogan Studio. I don't think they flew from the United States for that. They got to be British.

And so, I'm curious about that. Like I maybe this is getting too into the weeds, but I wonder how they feel about Christian nationalists liking and promoting their game.

I mean, do I put this dare I put this in the video? I mean, Sam Healey is a large supporter of the game whose name appears in the play test. I don't know how I would label him, but certainly in the conservative Christian in for sure.

I mean, I I will say this. So he talked about this game recently and he has been saying very publicly so I wouldn't say this otherwise that um people are being unfair to Christian nationalism and that he agrees with it. Now he might be talking about some imaginary version of Christian nationalism that is not what Christian nationalism actually is which is a hideous movement. Um, I don't know.

Yeah.

To be a to be Christian about it, I don't know his heart. But like, but the reality is is that people who are saying I do support the American Christian nationalist movement are also promoting this game. And as a designer, I would be a little worried about that. I mean like I interviewed um Paco Gradia about his game Anoda and one of the questions I asked is so uh you know Hiro Anod is used by Japanese nationalists to promote nationalism and racial superiority and things like that. And I asked him outright like how would you feel if this game was used by nationalists um to promote their views? And he was very forthright. He was like I would cry. He does not like that. He does not like nationalism. He doesn't like fascism. Um, and so there is the question that I would raise like this game is a blank enough check that Christian nationalists have kind of glombmed onto it and it's just barely out and I'm really only speaking of like one very tight circle of people who I don't think are like malignant evil people. I think that maybe they don't understand what they're talking about.

Um, but the game is blandly Christian enough that it can appeal to those sorts, I think.

Yeah. Yeah. And actually, you know, as much as I think you and I could go on about this forever because we're a bunch of dorks, um, I think this might be the place to stop it, just because we can't go any further without going firmly into the realm of just kind of air in our own feelings, if that makes sense.

Yeah. like this is a game that is historically questionable. I think it's a very I think it's a very accurate understanding of what Christians think they were,

if that makes sense.

Yeah.

And I think that your response to the game is going to be very heavily dependent on your own experiences of Christianity and specifically the type where you know you have [snorts] media that is for Christians as part of your life. Any other thoughts?

I mean, so I'll speak to this as somebody who was raised at least thinking I was Christian. Um although I'm, you know, in the wake of that Mormon church shooting a month ago, a bunch of Christians were very quick to say, "Yeah, that was bad, but Mormons aren't Christian." Um um I was raised with a ton of media about Christianity, but because it was Mormon, which has its own aesthetic, which is informed more about like frontier paintings of like wagon trains and stuff. Um

that's fantastic actually.

So even our biblical visual style in Mormonism is very different from like this style. So I found it quite alien. Um, which isn't to say I disliked it or something. It's just this is not the way that Mormon Christian media presents itself aesthetically. Um, and you know, I and I'm not trying to play persecuted. Like to be fair, Mormons also believe that other Christians are like not quite right Christians. Um, so like I'm not trying to play that game, but like the aesthetics were different for me. like I wasn't getting a Sunday school vibe out of it just because Mormon Sunday school imagery is very different.

Yeah.

Um from mainstream Protestant Christianity.

God, this is so interesting. But I do think we'll leave it here. Uh everybody look for Dan's upcoming review of this game because you're going to play it again and you're going to give us further perspective. Yes.

Yeah. I'm I'm trying to like Here's the problem I'm having, Liz, is that I'm still trying to decide how to review it because I'm like, this is going to be like a 4,000word review that will appeal to nobody but me.

Do it.

Um,

do it. Just give some subheadings or something.

I know. I got to split it into like like it it's such a fascinating game to me. And to be clear, this is something I actually want to see. I'm really interested in and the reason we did that Jerusalem video and the reason we've done, you know, the reason I've written about like Amabel's Games About Faith and Ben Maddox's Games About Faith and um

Oh, say Ben Madison's Games about faith for me.

Ben Madison's Games About Faith. That one. Ben Madison. Did I say Ben Maddox? The other Ben,

the the talkie Ben. Um but um yeah and Ben Madison's games about faith um is because I am very sincerely interested in people's expressions of belief. Yes.

In board games. I mean I recently reviewed a game called Usulli which is about saying your five daily prayers in Islam. And I don't think it's an amazing game but I did take away a lot from it. I I am very sincerely interested in that. So, in that respect, I am interested in this game and also a little concerned as a historian. So,

yes, but I feel like that's that's our job. Um, but yeah, I I do want to echo I also want to see more games like this. I enjoy looking at games like this actively. Um, because I think that it they hit at something that is really really important even if it's quote just a game.

I agree.

All right, everybody. Please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming.

Ta.

Progress saved