Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mercado de Lisboa: Discussion

Transcript 22:21

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and today i'm doing a no run through review for mercado dayless boa which is the filler game designed by vila lasarna and julian julian julian julian julian pombo and as for most of you who would know uh if you've watched any of my other just review videos uh typically if i don't do a run through that means that i am not a fan of the game and as is the case here mercano dallas boa is quite disappointing i think to say the least it it had so much hype for me because i have absolutely loved everything that beetle has done and and whenever i heard that oh he's making you know he's doing a filler game okay well if his regular games are like way up here in complexity his filler games are probably going to be midweight at the very least and this game just doesn't have anything going for it at least for me like the the mention of like how it how it like kind of presents itself as like a fast pace easily learn but but deep game kind of is already a red flag for me whenever your game is is already trying to convince

the audience what it is it's like look how about you just explain what the game's about and let it show off oh man that was actually really easy to learn and there's a lot of complain don't try to tell me what it is ahead of time because then there's already preconceived notions and they usually fall short so i mean where it does it is easy to learn i think the the deep you know whatever they say the deep tactical choices is a little bit on the exaggerated side not to say that there's no choices here because whenever it's your turn you have a few actions that you can actually do and they're all relatively straightforward you either place a stand with your gate on it or your stand on it you place a customer um you place a restaurant or you gain a money and all of these of course have various effects but in doing so what we found in multiple games was that you're you spend a lot of your time doing setup like with your stands and then restaurants or p or you know placing stands next to other restaurants because restaurants increase the productivity i guess of your stands and therefore your value which at the end of the you know game whoever has the most money wins and turn order takes such a drastic effect in that if you're going first then you basically get a lot of dibs on where ever of

where you want to place so that's incredibly annoying considering the fact that there's nothing in this game that allows you to alter someone's uh you know presence to to swap factor not factories to swap restaurants to swap stands it's just i place here so for the rest of that game i am going to be able to benefit off of that placement and that's incredibly frustrating because if someone already has kind of a strategy of what they want to do then they're going to be the ones to capitalize on that and if they don't then it's because the other players hate drafted against them now you can't purely hate draft and by hate draft i mean take a customer place it on a spot to where they can't capitalize you know they can't gain as much money as they would if they're the ones who placed it um and because customers only give you the value of something based off a certain type of stand and so because they whenever someone places a customer they have to place one where there is at least one of their stands there uh of the type that they're wanting so it's like if you're looking at a row of you know five and oh there's me you know in the middle not gonna gain as much but oh man someone's gonna get a bunch of money if they find someone with fruit and tea it's like okay i'll take the guy who wants sushi and just plop him down on the one of two spots because there's two spots per row and column just so i

gain some i gain a couple bucks and that blocks one of their spots and i don't like that i don't like hate drafting just for the sake of hate drafting i'd rather my strategy be you know succinct on and on its own that i went through that not because i just i'm actively trying to be vindictive against the other players and it's very weird this game is weird because it it feels like it's trying too hard to be complex but also trying to be incredibly simple and by trying to have its cake and eat it too it it basically appeases no one i cannot imagine who this game is for because you're almost it's a marketing gimmick i feel like it's like okay here's liz boa you remember veto's game lizboa that is amazing and has so much you know complexity but yet synergy within it multiple different strategies to go for um yeah you recognize that name oh you also recognize one of the one of the designers names so yeah you're definitely gonna get this and by that it's it's gonna fall flat i feel like for me i mean i could be wrong but at least for me for hardcore vita la sarda fans but for people who aren't gonna go into that they're gonna be like well okay this game doesn't really seem to have anything going for it like i in in the multiple games i've played it's always come down to

since you keep your money hidden whoever gets that big swing move like whoever gets to place a customer and it's like boom okay i got 18 coins off that i got whatever uh i got 10 coins off that and everyone else is kind of doing four or five it's just like okay well now i know for a fact i have more money than everyone so all i'm gonna do for the rest of this game is not really build any more stands i'm just gonna keep taking customers and placing them on spots because i know how much you're gonna get off of any given spot and i know how much i'm gonna get so therefore i will always be ahead of you because you can't maneuver or mess with anyone the fact that if you set up in a decent spot really through no real effort it's just like okay well i this game is kind of in the bag for me and i very much don't like that and the other thing about this game that it doesn't do well at all is scale to the number of players a two player game is too wide like because this board is one board it doesn't doesn't shorten or grow depending on the number of players so a two player game is too wide everyone's able to place wherever you'd have to go out of your way to block the other person and even then if you're like oh i'm gonna go next to the pub it's like okay i'm also gonna go next to the pub like so they don't really ever actually stop you and in a three player game which actually i

found to be the best player count it it does change it is a little bit better than with two i don't think it works with two at all um but still once again that just that's kind of just more people in the way of whatever this game is like if someone is like oh i'm gonna place here and then the two people just kind of indirectly start competing with with stan placement without even really trying to once again uh a players was like oh great okay all my stands are next to the restaurants i need them too and they're kind of blocking each other so yay me and it's like okay well now they're either gonna gang up on the one person to make sure they don't win because they need to make money or they're both just gonna lose in a four player game then the game is absolutely too tight and way too short it's just like it doesn't i just don't understand why there's no scaling why there's no regular big board that it's like okay use the whole board for four use one row and column less for three and use one row and column less for two so if you want that competing tile placement that block one another to try and capitalize on getting gaining the most money then you would you think it would scale but it doesn't um the other thing that i don't really care for just in general is actually just the overall look of the

game the overall look and feel and theme i don't get market i mean it says yeah modern day markets offer their visitors various stands eateries and services yeah i i guess but it's like the fact that they have stands but then there's also restaurants that just kind of benefit the the nearest or the orthogonal stands that are next to it it's just weird like the the art i'm not a fan of uh for anything like the board layout the box art the the tiles it's just all it feels just half baked like uh the people i was playing it with uh his son was saying that this game just needed longer to cook which is a pretty good ass you know aspect of what this game needed it just i feel like there needs to be more to it after playing after i feel like after playing this game for i feel like after playing this game a few times you're already gonna be over it it's like there's not enough here and here's what we found after a few games we were like oh because the game ends whenever there are not four spaces whenever there are four or uh customer spaces left or four stan places left uh every other player gets a turn the wording in the rule says every other player so if i'm first player and the person like let's say we're in a three player game the person who goes before me ends the game places a stand okay

there's four i get another turn and the other person gets another turn and it's like well that just that's not fair because that means that i i get the i get an extra turn me and the other person get an extra return even though i started the game so it's not even it's not even go until everyone has the same number turns which is so that's already a mistake um but whenever oh where's that going with that um oh yeah so whenever everyone's kind of placing their stands it kind of comes to a halt because when that end condition causes the game when it's just like oh okay well now we need to start because everyone kind of places their stance or they want to or you can play some customers start off with some money then play sometimes you have some freedom there i guess or you can just take money and then buy a bunch of stands but whenever everyone's kind of placing to make an ideal you know row or column for the ideal customer so they can be like boom okay that's going to be this wine you know this wine stand is next to you know a wine restaurant okay that's times two or that's already two times two that's four oh same thing so that's eight money okay good for me so everyone's doing that and then it's like oh the game will end so now we need to start getting customers or everyone's kind of aware and it is one of those games where the players do dictate the length of the game which is something i

normally like is the fact that oh okay there is some type of strategy to try and end it whenever you think that you can win i've uh uh submerged does that um oh there was one i played recently where i did that and i was just hedging my bets that i was that i had enough points but anyway sometimes you can math it out and be like okay if i end it now i might win and you and you try to aim for that and it it could yay or it could boo but here the fact that that happens already takes their fast-paced game and lengthens it and now it's like okay well there wasn't enough depth there wasn't enough game here for it to be stretched out because your options don't increase at all it's just now this game's longer and i mean it does say 30 to 45 minutes that is actually pretty accurate but sometimes it could take an hour if you're just sitting there trying to place customers in a specific way and stands in a specific way to try and get your maximum money possible while also not trying to end the game and the other way the game can end is if every player consecutively just takes the one coin action which obviously no one's gonna do because excuse me they don't want the game to end and now it might be something where it's like the other players just kind of do it and you can be the one oh okay if i

do if i do it the game will end and then we don't have to play this anymore it's kind of that would be my thought process it just there's just nothing here for me like i if you're a fan of villa lasata and your fan for his other games on mars escape plan uh co2 vino's gallerist like if you're a fan because of those games i would say steer clear of this one it just i don't understand who the market who the who the target audience was i mentioned kind of graphic design something that's also quality quality of life that they could have done and absolutely didn't are these freaking screens now you take these screens only if you want to play with hidden money which it mentions you don't have to you can play with open money and if you're playing with open money just just put all the money in a bag everyone grabs a handful and pulls it out and just see who wins that way because the the game is only even remotely interesting is if you don't know how much everyone has because that's the point of the game if you can openly see then you can very much just map out this game and as soon as someone gets a good point you're just like okay well i can't catch up now so these screens are incredibly lame like i these are virtually useless in every way not only

do they just have a symbol of your stand what would have been nice is if you're gonna have kind of the subpar art at least what you could do is do kind of like a bargain quest and have like maybe your own unique market your own unique stand design on the back that would have been at least nice you have some uniqueness in a game where there's really nothing to it but okay fine you don't want to do that this is just a screen well at least then put some information on it this is i have never seen a bear screen like this it's been a while since i played the game with the screen but oh my god like nothing on these wings here and i'm not saying have freaking roll through the galaxy detail where it's basically the rules all printed here but you have your four actions here and the four actions are extremely simple what you should have on here in on the wings with where there's room is the actual math that is in this game because all of his games just happen to have like some weird like math to it on how oh hey what's the quality of your wine uh you know how much does it take to build you know a certain type of building in lisboa which i guess is kind of that's the parallel i don't i don't know um but in this game you get money two ways one building a stand in a location where there are customers already there who

match the stand that you're building and you get money that way or placing customers who uh in a row or column that the number of stands in that row we're called match the number of people there as well as at least one year stands has what they want and then they're the multiplier the num it goes one to four so if i placed this level three customer in this column of five and i was uh yellow or purple then it's like oh there's my sushi stand it's next to a pub and it's next to a sushi restaurant so that's going to be three times three that's nine i'm not saying the math is hard i'm just saying that it's easily the most complex portion of this game and so that's why it there's nothing here it could have easily just been hey stand money or whatever and then the two steps or whatever and like how much it costs and then you know how much you get for placing it and then customers money and did give you the three steps i mean i just explained how that works i just this is such a waste of of cardboard i when i first saw these i was like you gotta be kidding me they didn't even freaking try which is not surprising after playing this game it just doesn't seem like it it seems like a marketing gimmick i'm i mean it's in here the weird part is is

this game isn't even i've been kind of just on in the past 20 minutes this game isn't bad it's not the worst game i've ever played it's just an odd game to have been made like i wouldn't call it i would i definitely wouldn't call this game good but i wouldn't necessarily call it horrendously bad it's like if someone were to ask me hey do you want to play this i i'd be like no not because oh wow this game makes me mad that it's so bad it's more yeah i just don't want to be bored for the next 30 minutes like there's nothing exciting here for me it's not like oh wow this art it's just out of tile layers and fillers especially like when you have you know calico or or cascadia like to filler like i mean hell even some of the azules out there any polyamino game where you actually have at least some puzzle aspect of how you want to place things with different ways of scoring this game just falls way flat in in comparison to those so uh yeah it's um it's just not not the greatest and yeah all right well on a scale of one to ten i think if this was any other game

like if it did not have eagle griffin and it did not have the lasagna's name on it i'd probably give it a five i'd be like you know this is painfully average but because it is it does have his name on it and it is by eagle griffin and this is easily the worst of any of their games that i've played uh i'm i have to drop it down to a four i do not want to play this again and hopefully i mean because this theme could work for like a an actual heavy euro vlasardo game like i could see this being made where you have to run i mean i don't think he actually has any restaurant games he has i mean car you know terraforming mar or that he has colonizing mars he has global war climate change he has bank heist he has cars uh art reconstructing liz boa running a vineyard yeah this is an idea that i would say would work fantastic you know actually having to get different ingredients and bring in different customers who want different things have to do orders um have to i mean maybe even build your restaurant like i could see that being a fantastic idea for a big euro game from him i mean the new one i think that'll be coming out i mean well after this review is uh what was it weathertop or weather machine uh which looks really cool

so i don't know i could see this market restaurant idea theme working in a very grandiose typical veto game but that's a filler it's just very very very very boring so i'm gonna give it a four out of ten um so yeah that's my thoughts on mercado dallas boa let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved