Skip to main content
Loading video...

BoardGameGeek's Advertising Manager Just Got FIRED for this email to Posess Me, Satan publishers

Transcript 29:01

Ohoy there YouTube. I'm back again today for another episode of Bower Rides the News where I take a look at a hot tabletop board gaming news story, put it into my eyeholes and your eyeholes at the same time and give my honest feedback about it after being in the hobby for 15 years and seeing it from a lot of different hats. But two days ago, the most popular thing on all of Board Game Reddit was tried advertising on Board Gamegeeek and got this as a response. It's listed as humor. I don't know if it's going to be humor. I honestly don't know a lot about the story. I'm very excited. It's from Painful Banana. So, this is the message. Thanks for submitting your ad campaign. We'll review it and contact you if we have any scheduling conflicts or errors. This is from Board GameGeeek, which is the pretty much the only board game website on the planet that matters. I mean, Reddit's fantastic. There's some other websites that have fantastic board game resources like Board Game Arena.

But if you just want information on board games or to schedule a meetup or to get house rules or, you know, ask a question to the board game designer, Board Gamegeeek is undoubtedly the best place that you should be on to do that, even though they didn't want Willy Whale games on there, apparently. So, um, once your ad campaign is approved, you'll receive a confirmation email. Contact me if you have any questions. Best regards. I don't think it's Willy Whale. It's just it's blocked by three three whale games. We'll call it that. Here's a repost with the actual emails for proof. I've cropped out the name of the individual. This is for my game. Possess me, Satan. We tried to advertise on board game but was denied for this reasoning. Oo, pi popcorn. Oh jeez. I love it. Bro, you have your back of the box quotes. Bro, you h have Bro, you have your back of the box quotes. What people are saying, I can't in good conscious approve this. It's beyond what would even dare be depicted in a horror film. Made me sick to my stomach. This is not friendly content. Incredibly triggering. Okay, [sighs] we're going to have to go there, aren't we? All right, so that's the top comment. That's 4.2,000.

Now, I appreciate that bit of knowledge, so I will also give that a thumbs up. Banned on BG. Agreed. Lean all the way in and hit me up with a link when it's ready. Yes, this is what I always say on my my 1:30 p.m. Eastern Kickstarter critique. If you have a controversial anything, you lean into it. There's no point in going soft. If you're already going there, go there hard. I saw a serial killer game like a month ago that was on Kickstarter. They could have been doing a lot better if they would have leaned more into the gruesome dark theme of it. But let's continue on this email chain. All right. Uh, you could possibly imagine putting up So, how do I Oh, I can click on it. It's still block uh this. What? How do I How do Oh my god, I feel like such an old fogy. These aren't they're not actually clickable on my side. A shame. Okay, so let's try and read this.

Uh what am I? I just wanted to follow up and see if this ad campaign was approved or not. Last time we did ads with Board GameGeeek, we got a confirmation email the very next day. I just need to make sure the ads are actually going to run on time since our crowdfunding starts on May 19th, my wife's birthday. Cool. Falling whale games, not three whale or Willy Whale, even though I like Willy Whale. Um, I wish we got I wish we got this little bit right here and you gave us a chunk of it, but it feels like that would have been a nice thing to know. But anywh who, this is useful information. They're saying, "Hey, we have in fact advertised with them before. We have given them our money. They were fine with our money the first time. Um, we just reached back out to them. Okay, you're telling the story." I am going to read the bottom part of this because I do want to know the other bit of the story that I'm not seeing and we'll probably get to it hopefully. I don't know. Scott runs a pretty tight ship when it comes to letting things slip on that. Uh oh, by the way, uh just in case you're wondering my opinion on this, I do know the person who owns Board Gamegeeek. I would say I'm friends with him. I've played games with him before with my son at a convention. I've spent quite literally hundreds of hours with him on a podcast before and I think he's a fantastic human being. So, uh but that that's not going to cloud my judgment.

We disagree on things and we discuss that. All right. Uh, this composed eventually putting on a good face, usually enabled by disassociation, but suffering terribly behind the scenes. Are you describing? I want to know what the rest of that was. Uh, response was more than But I wanted to be 100% honest about where I'm coming from rather than just ignoring the request. Even though you may not be on the same page, I appreciate your understanding. Yeah. Okay. So, this there was a request that that's the that's the bite-sized bit of information I'd like to know as well. Just because I like to have the whole picture uh before I go running my mouth and I and I run my mouth when I don't have any of the picture. Sometimes I don't even know the picture's coming. I'll run my mouth. Thanks for the followup. To be completely transparent, I've been sitting on this one and praying about what to do in this instance. Okay, like spoiler, the advertising manager was fired.

Okay, because I was gonna I was going to do that, but now and I have to say I can't disagree with it at this point. Like this is a professional email that you were sending to just another nameless, faceless company that wants to give you money to advertise their board game on your board game website and leading an email with the praying on it like that. Just like and I'm not like I wouldn't be offended. I wouldn't care. I'd be like, "Wow, you must have a very you must have a very open work environment, I guess, would be the thing that I would say in the back of my head. Like your boss is like, "Wow, okay." Your boss is cool with that. Like I don't I wouldn't be right. Like I we're not bringing any religion into this. Like I don't like it's not an anti-religion thing. It's just we're going to be dealing with people from all around the world and there's no need we don't need to bring that up. Especially like just lean leading with the I've been sitting on praying. I've been just just that's just wow. I've been sitting and praying on whether or not we should allow you to advertise on our board game website which has hundreds of board games listed on it that are like gruesome terrible the most edge lordy games there are. I've covered some of them. Right.

Yeah. Not great. And I'm and I'm not trying Yeah. I'm off the soap box. I guess I just got on there. But wow, that just punched that hit me really the wrong way of like this a business email. I don't I don't hopefully it's redeemed the next couple paragraphs. Uh as a follower of Jesus that was not that was I guess thank you for clarify. Do I need to know you're following Jesus? Like you're praying that's one thing like cool everybody a lot everybody prays. It's religious, right? Like I don't think there's a lot of religions that don't pray to a certain I don't know. Wow. This definitely feels highly unprofessional. That's coming from a highly unprofessional person. As a follower of Jesus, I routinely help people suffering from demonic oppression and more occasionally possession. And it's absolutely devastating the damage he does to people's lives. There are other games where people get possessed by demons, by devils, right? like how many games with minis where you delve into the underworlds or hell or people getting possessed. I it it just and I know they're leaning into it more, but it's it's still it's the same line in the sand. It's just one person is on, you know, this side of the sand and one person's on this side of the sand on how much they're they're Yeah. Wow.

Because I was hoping to be like defending like Yeah. I I was hoping that I'd I don't because people getting fired that sucks. But it's like you can't lead with this. And I understand backing it up, but it's just tmi. I guess this feels like one of those ones where you talk to your boss thousand%. Be like, "Hey, this is what I was thinking about saying to him." Um, and they'd be like, "Yeah, no, just just just deny or approve, but this should be 17 words." Um, okay. It's sometimes beyond what would even dare to be depicted in a horror film. The amazing thing is that I get to see Jesus completely heal folks of even the most severe effects. We've walked with one lady who was diagnosed with 32 distinct personalities as a result of horrific occultic abuse. And she eventually was one whole complete individual healed by Jesus with no fragments or need of all of her psychological meds. Oh, you you want mass shootings? This is how you get mass shootings.

like like this. It can't get worse, right? Like we I don't even want to read. I don't want to keep reading. But this is Bower rides the news. So, let's keep riding. But it doesn't change the terrible reality behind the theme that this game is depicting. So, I just can't in good conscious approve this one given what I've been firsthand. So, I understand I'm denying you, but I feel like I really need to tell you completely why. open, honest, transpar trans transparent. And I am I am that kind of person a lot. And as that kind of person, it will bite you in the ass sometimes. And this is this is those sometimes. And that sucks because I imagine knowing Scott that this was a very nice job. And I know he treats his employees very well. And this sucks that somebody's going to lose their job. But you can't you just can't like Whoa.

Sorry. No, it doesn't meet this parameter of guideline C, section 6, paragraph 4. Um, we look forward to working with you in the future on your next game or with some minor modifications or whatever it may be, but like and I that's not this is oh [sighs] okay, I don't begrudge you personally as many people don't uh just plain don't understand the reality of it, but I'd strongly urge you consider these things. In my opinion, the responsible thing would be to pull the entire projects. Hey, hey, come here real quick. Come here real quick. I know that you are launching your dream and you're trying to chase your dream of becoming a board game publisher and carving a niche and bringing joy and happiness to tens of thousands and hopefully if you're lucky millions of people's lives with your amazing creativity in these board games. But I disagree and I've had experiences religiously. So, I am going to put this log jam between you being able to advertise on the number one board game website on the planet because of my personal life experiences. If I were a different person, this would have been approved three days ago and you wouldn't have had to stress about it. Like that is like and that just sounds that sounds pretty crappy when you put it like that.

That's one thing I do with my kids sometimes is I try and like just paraphrase exactly what they said or did, but like really break it down to its core elements. And that's what just happened here. And that is Yeah. Like I don't see how you defend not firing that person unless you're going to point to something completely completely different and be like, "Oh yeah, but look at the track record, right? Like this has never happened before in x number of years. Um, but this is it's it's just and there's the receipts, too. Like you you wrote the receipts like you were like, "Let me let we're our machines broke. Let me hand write out these receipts for you." Oh, man. Uh, in my opinion, the responsible thing to do to pull the tire just cancel your dream is there are way more people that suffer that this could possibly imagine. Uh, wow. Just and I can't read that part, but it's pro. Oh, it just keeps going.

Oh, here it is. So, I can't just in good conscious approve this one given what I've been firsthand. The thought of displaying this subject matter makes me sick to my stomach. I don't begrudge you personally as many people just plain don't understand the reality of it. But I'd strongly urge you to consider these things. In my opinion, the responsible thing would be to pull the entire project as there are way more people that suffer. Uh yeah, yeah, yeah. Uh I know this response was more than what you bargain for, but I wanted to be 100% honest about where I'm coming from. So glad I'm glad they did give this tidbit because that tidbit, that's why I wanted that tidbit because that tidbit felt pretty important. Holy crap, was that pretty important. H. Oh my. Uh, there. What is this? Is this more? It's not more, is it? Uh, it's very disappointing to hear that you were denying on service based on religion. Yeah. Is this the decision of Board Game Geek as a company or just you personally? Is there an advertising policy rule WE ARE BREAKING? GOD, THAT'S WHY YOU DO your job with numbers. And you say yes. Paragraph six, section C, blah blah blah blah blah. You don't put the life experiences into why I'm trying to log jam your dream.

And that's I feel like that's a duh. A with a capital U. DUH. YEAH. CAPITAL U, NOT capital D. Is there an advertise? This is currently ads on Board Game Geek for a game called All True Believers, which is themed to the occult. So, it seems strange that our game is being singled out. everything. I'm sad. We are definitely not going to we're definitely not going to pull the project due to individual people not liking the theme cuz you know there wouldn't be any games ever if that were the thing like raise a hand. We got this trading in the Mediterranean game. No, my grandpa died on a boat in the Mediterranean. It's just it hurts too much. Okay. Like it's it's just keep in mind it's not over religion but reality.

HOW MANY PAGES DO THEY JUST GET WORSE? This this this legitimately feels like just something someone created 1 billion% for clickbait. I can't imagine that there is a human being that would be like this is the good response to pick. like that you type these things out and then you reread them and then you send it and that happened here I imagine right there had to be a lot like at this point in the email exchange you have to be concerned for your job to a certain extent and if you are not I wish I felt that financially comfortable as well uh keep in mind it's not of religion but reality Wow. It's the same reason I would say a game would be in very poor taste but featured being a sexual predator or something that would directly trigger someone that's being harmed by the subject matter. It's about keeping BG welcoming to everyone. And since I'm privy to this subject matter, I know firsthand that this is not friendly content incredibly triggering put in front of some of the population that visits BG. Similar to site moderations, there of course judgment calls to be made when it comes to displaying ads on the sites. If if it were just my personal preference, all true believer wouldn't be approved either. But I have to factor in if something being displayed is going to be overtly triggering in the game. It's a bit less obvious from the title, whereas you went for the shock value. Of course, that's a business decision on your part.

But it also means it's not responsible of me to put in in front of a diverse community of gamers. So essentially, they said, "Hey, what specific rule are we breaking?" And they were like, "Yeah, we got a different answer for you." Wow, that was Man, I need a cigarette after that. We also have two more to go here, but I do want to see the top comments on this as well. Um, these are like these are one of the box back of the box quotes. I I'm waiting to have a strong opinion because sometimes you see the game and it is a bit much. This is so tame. I'm also confused. And here's the thing. Does it, And this is honestly just a legit question. Is it the game itself or is it the advertisement for the game?

Right? because that's those are two very different things. And that then implies that every single time you are approving an ad for a game in the future that you are going to check to make sure that there is not this shocking content which feels like it is adding a very large layer to your game. specifically with the obscene number of cards and artwork and everything we have in our hobby in these $300 Kickstarters and game fountains that are launching all the time. And I don't think that's what you're doing. I think this is it. Oh, possess me say on game found. Ironically, the backlash here has probably done more advertising than the BGG ads would have.

Undoubtedly, I was waiting to have a strong uh this is so tame. I'm almost confused. One of the most popular social games ever has you playing as Hitler. Yeah, that's a great point. Another one has you executing executing people Salem style. That BG moderator needs a reality check. Lol. It's not a moderator. Like this is the game. This is the game. This social deduction looking game. This is This is Wow. [groaning] Yeah. People are going to be really triggered by this grues Oh my god. Look at the Wow. Okay. I'm glad I saw this now because for a second I was like, man, maybe I'm going too hard. And after seeing that, I'm like, nope. Nope. That is the appropriate amount of hard. Wow. There's I need to do this live as well. I'm looking for the chat. I want people chatting in. I always do these. I'm going to start doing these live every once in a while. Wow. There's nothing overly offensive about this game. It's a clever take on social deduction games whose only apparent fault is they use the name Satan rather than go with something generic for the entire entity possessing the player. It's not overly gory or edgy. It looks like a good party game for pretty much anybody. And then also the quotes on the back of the box feel stupid now, right? Like that's I was expecting so much worse when it was like it's beyond what would even be dared depicted in a horror film and then you're like AH [screaming] AH GOD MY CHILDREN are home. I shouldn't even have this window up. Look how can I

zoom in to look how terrible. Look at this. Oh it's so look at the face. It's like are we serious? This this is the onion. This someone lost their job because that was too controversial. That game was too controversial. Wow. Oh no. Now it looks like I won't be able to get advertising traction for my game. Settlers of Satan. [cough] [clears throat] Settlers of Satan. Lots of debate whether it's pronounced Satan or Satan. Yep, there was the joke. I love it. Uh, well, I think it's okay for private sites to choose a stricter ad policy that might reject your game. I routinely help people suffering from demonic OPPRESSION IS A HELL OF a line to drop in a customer support email.

Yep, that's why it's got five. Okay, I want to look for the first defense. I guess it was the person saying, "These are the quotes on the back of the box." Uh, BGG is met as the board game resource. It's not okay to base their ad policy on a specific individual's religious belief. It is. It is the It is the Omna, the uh the Omega, the everything pretty much. Even though Board Game Arena's taken a chunk with with that and I think if they continue to grow, specifically their pages about the board games, they could they like I think Board Game Arena I think Board Game Geek needs to purchase Board Game Arena. I think that would be very smart. Uh unfortunately, after reading this, I wouldn't be surprised if they mean a family or friend who has mentally health issues or autism. Wait, wait, wait, wait. Uh, unfortunately after reading this, I wouldn't be surprised if they mean a family or friend who has mental health issues or autism or something.

Yeah, that was just the just the um I'm not a big reader, you know. Okay, so we're going to go over here. We're going to see the backlash. BG's advertising manager was fired. This was one day ago due to a situation in which BG's advertising manager responded inappropriately in a business email to a designer. I've decided to let him go. His response does not reflect or represent our company or the way we conduct business. Simple, clean, clear, short, to the point, and most importantly, 1 billion% justifiable, which like once you see those emails, [clears throat] that is a very hard defense. Let's see what people are saying. That was quick. Yeah. Yeah. I'm sure as soon as he read those emails, he was like, I'm sure I'm I shouldn't say I'm sure of anything. I imagine that Scott would then I imagine Scott's going to take a look at the situation and see if that if he's potentially become too comfortable as a boss, right? And and I and Scott's an amazing person. I love talking to Scott. I love his personality. Like, but it's just if you have an employee and and a highle employee, right? Like this is the person who has the power to gatekeep advertising for your game on Kickstarter or Gamefound. And I cover Kickstarter and Gamefound every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. The Kickstarter critique. There are roughly 350 crowdfunding game projects on

Kickstarter and Gamefound right now. There's probably like three on Backer Kit, too, right? you and that's that's a super important position like in the entire scope of the hobby, right? Being able to advertise your board game on the number one board game website on the planet. That is a massive amount of power that you weld. So, I I think it's important because somebody was just like, "Yeah, this mod's getting too No, it's not a mod. This is like this is someone who wields a lot of power in the board game industry that you might not actually think about, right? Like getting that turned down sucks. I would imagine. That was quick. Best ad campaigns I've seen in years. For real. More people know about the game now than than the adage just ran.

Oh no. If this isn't the consequence of my actions. That's good. I was thinking that myself. They couldn't possibly buy better advertising than they got out of the controversy. I would have never heard of the game otherwise. I'm curious type. So I looked it up to see what on earth would provoke such a response. And then I saw it was another werewolf variation and I was like uh okay. Okay. So, the only problem was the theme of the reskin. Yep. Secret Hitler seems to be more offensive if you're going to go that route because he was verifiably real. But could it be Satan? I'm pretty sure that character is referred to daily in everything from TV commercials to cartoons. Yes. Like it's [sighs] arguably the guy seemed to believe that satanic possession is also verifiably real. Fair enough. Uh okay. Okay. And then we have one more results of the BGG ad fiasco and it is rare fry air getting yourself on the BG hotness. So if you're not familiar with Board Gamegeeek, one of the first things you see all the time when you log in the website, you get like their pictures up here of the social media people. Lots of people never made though. They they showcase a lot of people. I just want to say that your boy never gets mentioned, right? like you go down here. They'll have spotlights of tons and tons and tons and tons of independent content creators. Never this guy. Uh but anyh who, uh what do we got here? Yeah, possess me, Satan. It doesn't take long, but yeah, the BG hotness. So, you have the giveaways and then you have Yeah, here it is. Where is it? There it is.

The hotness. Yeah, it's literally right there. And it's now number five. Good for them. And this is like upcoming games. Hot Gabes. Smooth Colony Bud Bath is is nominated for the spiel as Yurus. Legacy of Mars makes it like a million bucks on Gamefound. One of the most popular games of the year. Alissium, which hopefully is an expansion coming out. I don't know why that's top 10, but that's a spectacular game. It's got this super cool element where the gods never mind. Uh Lands of Eversh like Yeah, this is this is awesome for them. So, that is the Fallout because of someone and and I and you know, I don't norm I kind of believe in karma a little bit, right? I feel like you do good things, good things will happen somewhere along the way. And I feel like that's kind of karma for them, right? Like this something objectively really crappy happened to them. They were not expecting that in any way, shape, or form to be completely kneecapped by someone right before their campaign and say, "Hey, we're trying to GIVE YOU MONEY. WE WANT TO give you money." And this person's like, "No, no, no, no, no.

We will not take your money because I have had experiences with demonic possessions in this werewolf game. I don't think people are going to I think it's going to make people too mad. That's objectively. And so, and what do you do? What do you do at that point? Like, all right, do do we pivot and put this money to advertising elsewhere? Like, what do we do? And they did the perfect thing. They This is what I always tell people to do when you have a problem with a company. Just drag that out into the yard. They don't want you to drag it out in the yard. Nobody wants their their business dragged out of the yard. They dragged it out of their yard. And thanks to that, they are now number four on the BGG hotness. Up from number 34 18 hours ago, and you got me covered.

I was planning on it already, but I want to see if there's any more shakeout from it. The best advertising they could wish for. What better? It was free. I guess you could say it was a good ad manager if you think about it. Just not any longer. Oh, [snorts] dietm server. Easy for you to say. Just looking at this makes me all triggered because of the very real cases of demonic possession I totally have to deal with. Just give them a snicker. I love Reddit. That BG marketing person needs to look up Barbara Stzan. There is no better way to call attention to something than to try to bury it. They got fired. Youch. Hope they learned something from this experience then. Uh yeah. And then let's see the BGG post about it. See if there's any more information here. Once again, it sucks someone got fired. Like I don't I don't want it to be like that. Oh, that's just a no. That feels like a very Scott move.

Like here it is. Here's the thing. We have you will you have nothing to say about it. We have nothing to discuss about it. Bye. And that and honestly that's the best way to handle it 1 billion%. As someone who has been involved in a controversy or two in the board gaming sphere over the last 15 years, nothing major. um it it they they they they quickly dissipate and he's like, "Yep, we'll just this one will quickly go away because someone somewhere in the board game world is going to do something stupid in the next three days and that will be the new hotness." And that was Bower rides the news. Possess me daddy all possess, excuse me, possess me daddy. That's a whole different That's the expansion. Uh even though I do think sexual deduction is totally a genre that needs to exist. Like I I've thought about it so long and I know it's incredibly niche, but I think for for like alternative lifestyles, you could most definitely come up with a really cle c creative and clever game. And I think you just you need to know how to market it properly. Um and and and have realistic expectations about your first print run, right? Because it's not going to be a massive print run you wouldn't expect. But then again, if you got yourself into those those hobby shops, right? like the not the hobby shops but like you know those shops. Okay. Any who that was B rides the news taking an interesting turn there. Let me know what you think about it in the comments below. Also, if you have a news story or if there is something that breaks about this news story in the future, please

drop it in the comments below. I check all the comments and uh I might do a followup on it. But either way, congrats to Possess Me Satan for saving some money on their advertising and getting their social deduction game pushed across the finish line. Hopefully I get to try this one at Origins of Gen Con. Give them even more coverage because yeah, this one's also coming up in an upcoming Kickstarter critique because quite quite literally I do not particularly like religious oppression and so I want to support anything that you know has to deal with religious oppression. And that's going both ways by the way. If you got some, you know, if you got some website that turned down your Christian themed game about Noah's Arc, hit me up and I'll do some coverage on it as well. I don't think that's good either way. Anywh who looks fun. Roll them bones. Uh yeah. Bye. I'm really bad at the outro and I Oh my god, so many tabs and I don't need any of them. I just go here down to OBS. Hit stop recording.

Progress saved