Wargame Archaeology: Reading The General
Transcript
oh my gosh it says we're live uh people out there can you can you see us can you hear us it's like a seance over here so normally they they should hopefully uh that's what we see and sorry for actually uh providing uh wrong information on different social media platforms earlier I was I was really confused about time zones so if you try to join the stream an hour ago uh I'm saying yeah I'm really sorry about that it wasn't my intention to to to confuse everyone we apologize okay so Meandering Mike is coming to say when he first saw the notification he thought that we're gonna do a live oh yeah we could do that that would actually be really nice you know for people to get to sleep like we get uh we we can we can we can read them like and we could alternate from one article to the other or when there was a q a in the in the in the letter section we could actually have the two voices and everything that could be like a really nice audiobook like sleep stories on the map yeah exactly yeah that we could actually maybe have a brand deal with them uh we should really definitely think about it sponsors who are looking for yeah
we called it war game archeology because it's maybe the first in a series so we're just experimenting and we're really glad that you're here uh but Fred and I wanted to like take a walk into the past uh oh no camera for me I do have camera on I'm almost lagging here uh well we're gonna keep rolling for now at this point I might come up and be laggy just kind of let me know everybody um I need to set up a power line in my apartment is what I clearly need to do but uh We've read the first three um volumes of Avalon Hills in general because we wanted to check it out uh and we wanted to see you know kind of what is the history that we're working with and like what is our war gamey passed um good thing I'm on camera I hope I'm moving is my mouth moving at even remotely the same time so you're if on my side you're just slightly delayed but it's uh but it's uh it's okay abolish all right so um uh do that but to look at Avalon Hills the general magazine which exists in PDF form online I'm actually gonna post the link in the chat so if y'all want to go look you could actually go see what we're seeing uh but we took some good clips from it and actually I think that's really so I don't know who did that but I think it's a really great initiative uh and I really I don't know who that person is but I want to say thank you I think it's it's awesome to be able to Deep dive back into the all of those issues from
the from the from the 60s I thought when I saw the link that you sent to me I was like whoa this is like an amazing resource and I I don't know it like it reminded me like the it's you know it's the good side of the internet the thing that you were before we had all of the social media platform we would find a shitty website somewhere that actually had archived something really interesting that you could just uh look into I think this is just the this website made me happy I would say so that was a good start for the experience yes I also want to give credit I didn't know it existed until I read uh Aaron trammell's privilege of play um so he's a professor who wrote a book about kind of how gaming is a hobby uh became very closely associated with like privileged white male spaces but he um you know had to do a bunch of research to do that is I have a podcast episode coming up with him so stay tuned everyone uh but this citation was really great because I wanted to go look at the general after seeing it he'd been able to access all of it online because I really wanted to see so here we are so Fred is there anything that you want to say in general before we start just kind of looking at and talking about these clips we just pulled some slides y'all well in general I think there is one thing that maybe we need to to discuss is like when you look at the age of the people working on that magazine I'm like you know child labor much like it's like they're all like some of them were less than 16 years old and you're like and I understand and they really so it really early on in wargaming it's like you really have company stepping
into the passion of the community to have underpaid if if paid at all like people doing work for professional like for professional stuff I think that was pretty funny but like the age of the editors in 64 when you look at they are basically those first three episodes we read them while we read those episode where they were actually setting up a first team for for that magazine and they were all kids and it's like this is this is something like it I thought it was yeah I thought it was uh surprising but apart from that um I thought it was funny in general that the tone was overall really Amorous like it they are not too serious they make a lot of jokes uh some of those jokes are bad but that's I mean it was the 60s and talk about it but at least it's it's it looks like a quite fun uh environment like they were not uh and I think it's it's uh it's really interesting and the other thing that I thought was interesting is how much things didn't change that much uh in the sense like you look at this magazine and you have more or less the same content that you have in the war gaming circles online today like you have a book club which is something that we do like uh from time to time there are discussions about play over mail it's that email but it's play over mail and they're looking for opponents There Are Rules discussions strategy discussion not much has changed I think it's actually quite interesting to see how like 60 years ago things were already kind of already there so that was yeah that was fun uh but apart from that that's my general yeah General comments what do you think Liz yeah well you know
it's funny you talk about you know the child the kids involvement with it aspect and you know what though I kind of feel like it reminds me of the Wild West days of the early internet do you know what I mean where anybody could go on and like make an account and talk to whoever and you don't necessarily really know who you're talking to you just we all just hopped on and live chatted right and I kind of feel like this is the print version of that and I think that sadly I would have had to be a boy I think to have access to but if I had been a kid in the 60s I would have been super into this and I would have wanted to like read these arguments about rules and I would have wanted to like you know be part of this if something that's really really Charming yeah and kind of Untamed about it that um you know I don't obviously agree with a lot of the content or like the way that things are discussed but you know knowing the age group knowing the time um there's also so much charm to it and it was like really fun to see wargamers in a different time trying to connect very very much like we do now yeah and I think that's uh that's a really good point but uh yeah there is definitely something really Charming about reading those uh we'll see how it evolves but for now I'm actually having a great time uh let's see that's for sure yeah we were thinking about doing more so yes this might be the first of the series but let's look at this first bit so this is from the very first page so I just wanted to bring it up so on the very very first page um we have a lovely quote actually this shows up in my uh in my podcast with Stuart Ellis Gorman on Monday because this was in his
wheelhouse of things to talk about so uh it's talking about the you know the origins of Evelyn Hill you know Africa core is a big deal right now at the time that this comes out in May 1964 but they're saying that Gettysburg is their first big game yeah and I just wanted to highlight this quote that there is no Mr Avalon nor is there Mr Hill the very first games were published in a Baltimore suburb Avalon High up on a hill literally overlooking at the genteel Plantation land of picturesque South Baltimore it was there that Gettysburg was conceived labor of love in which the famous Civil War battle was rehashed Time and Time Again by admitted Confederate sympathizer and then like on this next page you've got this guy who's in Alabama having the time of his life slaughtering those damn Yankees yeah so this is page one issue one volume one a very very first and you already have yeah and you already have losco's narrative in wargaming like it's it's already there and it's it so so that's the thing um and yeah I think that's that's that's quite a quite interesting I don't know if you've if you know the story of their Gettysburg game at all uh or I really don't feel free so I don't I don't know much but uh as I said in the in the podcast that we that that Stuart is doing on on homuri dance on on the um on the American Civil War I talk about this the fact that I don't know much about the American Civil War but I I have an
obsession for the Battle of Gettysburg specifically uh and I haven't played any of those games but Avalon Hill has actually released quite a few um this game they have been re-releasing it quite a few times uh and the 58 version was different than the one that they released a couple of years later then it was updated again and updated again then you have the the one that is in uh in the 70s for uh uh the 100 years anniversary and something like this or the late 60s or something and so they had this game that was the foundation a foundational game for them and they kept iterating on it and going in a lot of different direction it's really interesting to see how they tried different approach to war gaming and then finally resettled around the hex encounter approach so I think it's in through this game you actually see the history of a publisher trying to iterate on what is a model for representing what should be the framework for most horror game to come and how they are trying to approach it in different ways so I think it's it's a quite interesting game and actually already I think it's in the it yeah you can actually we'll talk about it for volume two but they talk about the fact that the original Gettysburg comes back so they did something then they tried Square they didn't like it they went back to this free movement approach something like this no they tried hexes it didn't work they go back to free movement and actually later a few years after that they would go back to hexes which is actually quite interesting so I'm actually quite excited to read those magazine and see how they're gonna navigate through the different stages to come to a uh the version of um of uh of Gettysburg that we uh that we know today
and that shaped most of the war games that we've seen afterwards uh but yeah sorry about that tangent no no I think it's a great tangent especially We're not gonna get to it just yet but in these slides there's already a lot of arguments about balance in the games about the rules about how they should work and it's really interesting to see how Avalon Hill was super interactive with its early audience yeah um in a way that you know I feel like we still have some of that on BGG but this just seems like such a fun little tight-knit group in a way um everybody really bonding over these games but first let's look at some of these early editors like we were talking about because we have a couple so this kid really like touched my heart yeah because if I had a student like this I would be so excited actually so cute yeah I love him yeah he's a junior in high school and he says I like to think of myself as the only 16 year old Field Marshal in the world and he likes basketball and stamp collecting like this is the cutest thing yeah and that's the thing that's the the Charming part I would say and and it's it's funny that you highlighted uh him because I also when I I saw him I was like oh God I feel like and he's older than my dad but like at this stage I have actually I feel almost like a a felony love towards him something like this like I thought it was really cute and the thing that I loved about his presentation is that at this time you say something that is not really a flex because it's not hard to achieve he has all the war games like it's like it's so cute like imagine saying this today you
have all the war games like yeah no definitely not but at that time you could say that like you can that's like five or six boxes so that's completely manageable and um and yeah I thought it was really cute and it's it's funny to see the so you have those presentations of all those editors uh in the first few uh in the first few volumes because they were trying to cover the the whole different regions in the US and they will have those nerdy pastimes like they collect stamps one of them goes to the finance Club I was like who the joined the finance Club after school like that's awful like it's amazing okay if I had if I had a baby board gamer show up at my game club and want to do something I would be like yes yes I'm gonna help you we're gonna we're gonna make this happen kid I'm gonna tell you about everybody I know I'm gonna guess you frequently whatever you need we gotta make you make this happen so uh Mike says put a mustache on the skin true there is something I must admit there is something he might be my father who knows yeah that's a amazing um but then um kind of this other guy I sort of I feel like the screen of humor is still very existent in wargaming yeah dear God okay so this guy is a 29 year old Air Force Sergeant named Blue Sashi I'm gonna guess um but uh he's from Chicago but okay he's an amateur musician teaches guitar and electric bass plays in a dance band and beats his wife for
amusement like whoa buddy like obviously this guy doesn't beat his wife right I hope that's obvious I really have this joke and I think it's pretty clear that it's a joke but it's just the type of humor and when you read these columns it's really like this in the sense that everything is a joke in everything that he writes and in a lot of ways like I must admit that his columns are actually quite funny like that's the that's the thing but when I read this I was like the level of cringe was pretty high and it's really already at that time you were saying oh it reminds me about the beginning of the internet and everything and that's actually exactly that this is a good example of that like this guy is just natural you know it's like he's just making those edgy jokes not really thinking about what does it mean what does it mean like if you're uh someone outside of the community reading this and it's like it's like oh that's funny right it's like yeah not really actually it's not very funny yeah and it's completely he also wants to make fun of himself right like oh the ludicrous patch of fungus under his nose rather than the lack of intelligence yeah when whenever people discuss pinheads his name actually comes up like this dude clearly yeah is just kidding yeah yeah it's it's really interesting to see like this is Edge humor of this era and how not that like I actually kind of feel like this guy is maybe like a forefather of somebody like Dan pinkaldi from no enemies here you know but if we have our ancestries in this
yes there is a bit yeah maybe there is a bit of something maybe physically also there is a there is a point of resemblance but uh but that being said I I don't know what you thought about these columns but the comments were pretty fun like the the the how to win without really playing yes I think yeah that was really really good like it's uh like I think it's uh like one of the government that I had the most fun reading it reminded me of uh like the like like I don't know I thought it was it was really cool but yeah this was yeah and I think it's it really feels like a boys club uh when you because you have actually the list of all the people who are subscribed to the magazine at the end and like I've looked through the first three to see if there was a change but no it's clearly uh uh like all the same kind of people like you look at the names and you're like yeah I guess those are all uh uh 16 to 18 years old boys that go to a finance club and connects and collect stamps like they are yeah they're all the same uh which is uh cute but also a bit like you already feel like the the community is is a bit of a niche and hits a specific demographic uh already pretty hard this is like we're joking about seeing our ancestors in this but like I kind of don't see my own does that make sense yeah like where are the people that lead to me direct I don't know like these guys in some sense right but it would be really
fun to be able to joke that like one of these people could have been my dad or that you know what I mean yeah or like you know maybe it will come uh in in future in future issues but yeah in that time actually for me it was easier I I look at jean-pierica and it's like yeah I'm I'm John you know it's like it's uh I have that Derek lineage uh definitely yeah and we've also got the family man Thomas LaFarge from New England yeah um but this is also just cute like it's just this nerdy dude and his kids so this one I wanted to highlight so it's not his kids I think it's either his uh brothers and sister or cousins or something like this because really if it sees kids that's pretty uh crazy because he's born in 47 so at the time that picture is taken in 17 he's 17 years old so it means that those kids look three four so I expect that he didn't have kids at 13. that would be a bit much uh but the thing that I loved about about his description first I find a picture really cute uh and the other thing that I really liked is that um and that's something that is a recurring team that you have in those first issues is they love talking about variants of the game that they play because actually they don't have that many games to play with uh they have maybe half a dozen Avalon Hill games at that time that they can play and and and it's we know we buy that's the number of games some of us by in a weekend you know and for them it's that there it's the entire collection of games they can have access to and they do a lot of
variants and I think this is actually a really interesting part of those magazines and actually when he presents himself to my staff there was I thought was really really cool is that he likes to play um uh Gettysburg but with an Umpire variant uh to play it more like Richfield which I think is like something really cool and connects back to a lot of discussion that we're still having today about how do we Implement fog of war and I think it's really like it's it's it's quite funny uh to see that and to see also some of the consideration and the discussions and the thing that they're creating is already so close to the things that were already you were still talking about today so maybe I hope you didn't move that that form in terms of game design but I think it's yeah I thought it was it was really cool and I can see that uh quick speed is also coming coming uh I don't know if it's coming back but I see more and more people try and get it online and everything and I thought it was funny to to point out oh like creating variance was a big part of the hobby at that time I'm not sure it's that much the case anymore but I think it's uh it's really really interesting chip says that back in his day we only had three games so they had to play variants uphill both ways yeah yeah that makes a lot of sense yeah it does and I mean so if you've only got so much to play so much creativity in these early issues that's really kind of fun to see like if there's no we mentioned charm there's a
huge charm to it but first so the other thing that's very interesting is also very I put this in here because from the very beginning like the very Foundation of words from like the general number three so this would have been I'm looking at the year uh this would have been September of 1964. yeah still 64. I think the first yeah the first three yeah yeah I love yeah no I I was just thinking I think we get to 65 at issue number five if I remember correctly but that's yeah that's really not important but what I really liked was that they talk a whole lot about research and double checking of events right there's there's already that kind of desire for I guess kind of chrome you know for like oh let's get down to the nitty-gritty let's check these details let's do these cross references and then also from very early on we have this valuing of being interactive with actual people in the military who enjoy and appreciate the games and who see them as like legitimate expressions of what happened or what could happen or war in general you know we're gaming in particular among branches in our hobby right is extremely attached to the realism and to kind of that interaction with like the people who really do it and I think that that's kind of cool that like as of September 64 that was already on the front page of the general because I think it says a lot
yeah and I think that's yeah that's actually super interesting that it's already there and in a way it's not super surprising because I think uh rent Corporation was uh like a lot of the Innovation that they were doing at that time actually went through Avalon Hill uh in the in the commercial Market I guess there must have been quite a lot of informal Communications or like overlapping or like I don't think there was that much distinction between the people who were making wargaming for the uh the defense industry and the people who were playing and making who were gaming for for Commerce so I think it's it's funny to see that it's still it's already interesting for them but not that surprising but I think it's the fact that they put in on the front page shows that it was important for the community to have that kind of uh almost validation yeah validation exactly yeah yeah and I thought that was that was really interesting to see that it was already there seeking it like uh and and making sure that the games that they play are not just games they are actually games that are like a work to represent something that actually happened uh which is actually quite interesting um because you wouldn't see that in any other board game magazines because it wouldn't make sense but it is something that is important for the hobby so I thought I was it was pretty cool yeah and I I really like your emphasis on it's not just a game it's a gaming out of something that really happened um I feel like we're all kind of dancing that line like a lot of conversations on my podcast on your channel right or
about like oh is it just a game or like you know what's a game versus simulation or like what is um you know is this play is it serious and it's really both and it's always been both yeah always yeah at least from from from from issue two so that's that's pretty early on again yeah and I I find that really charming and cool uh and it's still true right because you go through like you know SD his con or somebody see you know there's so much crossover even now between like the hobby War Gamers and then the ones who are doing like professional War gaming for the government and like the games don't always look the same but there's definitely a ton of cross-pollination yeah and we're gonna have for example uh connections uh in the UK next month and that's a good example of that and within the same convention it's a professional convention a lot of the people who are going to attend or professionals from from the defense sector uh but you also have um actual like commercial game designer that are going to be there so for example connections UK you're gonna have Brian train he's going to spend a bit of time actually here in London so we're going to spend time together but then he's going to connections and like it's I think this cross-pollination is needed also uh at least for for for the defense sector and is looked for in in the commercial sector for the advisation so it's a weird exchange and maybe there is some work to be done here to talk about and see how this evolves over time but
um I think it's yeah it's an interesting relationship um and I don't know how much it really shaped the hobby but I would like to I don't know if anyone really deep dived into it and when I think about like a book like zone of control talks about it but not you never really had a systematic historical analysis of what were the interactions of the two um I don't know signs of uh of War gaming I think it would be an interesting thing to explore oh yeah I would also be really interested in how many people who joined up for this time and wanted to be sort of like officers strategists how many of them had had contact with this kind of game in the past like is there some sort of mentoring pipeline from people who play these games as kids and then people who do certain kinds of jobs or have certain kinds of Career Connections when they get older because you know one thing that's also really tremendous about the general right is it you know kind of in these days um you know I don't really see and I think basically because I'm a teacher and I just don't interact with kids outside of work because no um but uh you know this is really interesting too because this is like kids who are 15 16 talking to full-on adults and being treated in I guess with parity right they're contributing equally into this community and there has to be something that's really empowering about that and something that I think would be really motivating and I'd be really curious if we could figure out how to grab those
results yeah but maybe in the future issues like if we keep an eye for that specific angle we'll see this creeping up in some of the discussions maybe some of the letters or some of the articles but I think that would be interesting for us to have that angle to follow if we keep reading them uh over time but yeah I think it must feel it must have felt pretty empowering uh definitely um even if they make jokes around the fact that those military people often don't really understand who they are and what they do and you also have this in the article so they don't take themselves too seriously but it's still yeah it's still pretty satisfying I guess for for them it makes a lot of sense yeah yeah well one thing I do notice about teenagers in my life right is that they've like to be acknowledged and like to be heard they like to feel like they're taking them seriously yeah um and this is just just a neat little vehicle for that I really I love that in a big way I just wish that there were girls also maybe maybe we'll get a surprise in episode uh four to six you know maybe we'll get so the the first uh women editor uh I went up to number five I haven't seen any so no spoilers but I don't think that in if we do an episode 2 covering the next three uh volumes I'm not sure we'll find uh them yet but we'll see yeah and like I guess I'm saying this Magazine's also very white so far and I'm not surprised by that but it was very white it's totally white like it's really nice to see like this but with everybody because it's great
um so let's see chip says that he enjoys game so the future fantasy settings uh but the ones based in reality offer a sense of competing against the professionals who were there on the field I think yes and actually we're about to get to that because in these next slides we have people talking about realism versus playing but Play balance and like this one absurdity of Africa core is the one that I decided to excerpt because I thought it was really funny you got somebody Avalon Hill dislikes the Germans these so-called rule changes and play Bad suggestions are the biggest farce ever imagined and I kind of feel like you could just go on BGG and go yeah but he's like confidence the the thing that is cool with that that I really enjoyed about that one just to because vgg is it can be a random like uh sometimes you have someone who didn't understand the rule properly and is making this whole paragraph about the game being broken and you're like dude you play the game once and obviously when I read your comments you didn't you didn't get the rule that's not the case it's not just a rendo it's one of the editors so jean-pierica is the is my Dad yeah he's my it's super for different to follow so he's actually an editor in the magazine it's his column and uh in volume one they actually propose some balancing um rules to make Africa corpse a bit more uh challenging in terms of uh of player balance and and so it's not just anyone he's like the guy is actually potentially paid by them and he actually criticizes fronted is something that they pushed out and it's super
refreshing how open it is um and uh and how free they are in the tone that they use and how critical they can be even if it's all in good spirit and there is a lot of jokes there to actually tone it down and that's completely fine but yeah you have the same Vibe as yeah someone complaining on bgd about the rules but first of all it's really well informed you know that the guy that he wrote this he really has played the game a lot and they actually reviewed the rules seriously in a way it's what BTD should be and that's that's maybe maybe something about this uh but I think it was it was really interesting the debates that they had they were talking about so much variance and what those words mean and everything and I thought it was yeah it was really really fun what did you what did you think about the tone overall I I it was one of those things where I think that depending on my mindset I think it's funny but I've also spent a lot of time in these spaces I think that if you are a little more reticent or you don't feel totally comfortable in the space this would come across as super aggressive and like rude so like I didn't necessarily perceive it that way and I thought it was funny but I also think that maybe somebody who's shy and like new to wargaming is never coming back if they come in it's like this is the conversation that's going on you know what I mean yeah um you know we have to figure out how we're gonna bounce that group to group person to person but um you know it was also really interesting though like oh they really disliked the Germans well like I should hope so like getting all the sort of historical arguments that we have right are are not
even present here this is very much about like can I win the game how's the game work the other thing that's really fascinating is that there's so much interest in realism right but and we'll get to this probably there's not a whole lot of interest in like the historical context of what's going on yeah it's very very very much about like I need Supply I want my you know tank to do this the um these hexes represent how much space again you know there's a there's a lot of that kind of cross-referencing in historical checking but there's not a lot of the kind of work that I would say that you and I are currently trying to do I think it's a divide that still exists today and why some people are sometimes to be fair annoyed by the work that you do sometimes the the things that I do is because we like to talk about the wider context and we acknowledge that war is political and in a way a war game is a political historical game it's just that it focuses on kinetic Warfare but it's part of probably something that can be wider and cover more topics um and I think it's at this stage they don't even have those discussions the games that they have or just purely World War II uh uh or American Civil War purely kinetic they don't even think about this and yeah they talk about realism uh not really historical context or historiography and actually at this time in the US they have a like a lot of the history of the second world war is is is shaped by the Cold War itself so they actually probably have in universities and in the books a lot of sympathy for Roman because it's the
least Nazi of the Nazis that's why cases as yeah this this position they have this positive perspective of him like and you can feel that um and and actually jean-pierica puts together a list of books uh like 10 books to read to actually get the context from Africa core and really high under this you've got the the the the Memoirs from Romel himself and stuff like that so I think it's it's really you can see that and they're not really interested in yeah historical context at all and it's interesting that they already have this part of the hobby is discussing basically the same thing as they were discussing today uh they talk about simulations about realism about all that stuff and they are already then really narrowly focused on okay what is about the game and what is about uh making it a proper simulation and adding some details and making sure that you can do this and not do that and introduce additional rules about encirclement and and all those things and I think it's really interesting to see that yeah it's it's always been there and it's for now it's very narrowly focused on those kind of discussions that we still have and that I thought that I think are boring today and when I read back I think they were already pouring back then which is which is which is quite fun uh but yeah yeah so we have a comment from manic so I actually have a different take on this but he's you know he's saying military history is all about arms and armor strategies tactics especially that were used by famous generals and that is what they are trying to replicate I don't think that's wrong
is it like I mean I think that that's always part of it right but academic history at least which is the background I'm always coming from right I can't I can't shake that out of myself it's very much also about like what were the consequences what was the leader how what impact does this have on the world around it um and I think that military historians today are also looking at those wider contexts as well it's like why we have people who are wargaming things like code yeah and I I think if you I don't know I think like when even you read like things about midi story about the Hundred Years War for example I feel like they always talk about the social context the political struggle and everything like for example if you look at the campaign for Henry V uh that he does that finishes with azankur like it's like the political context is actually crucial to understand the military history behind it and it's like the the way he raised the money for it what were the objectives and everything and I feel like it's uh I think it's a very narrow view of military history to think that it's all about arms armor strategy and tactics uh because first of all sometimes the tactics themselves they are influenced by politics uh and I think it's the case if you look at the history of world one uh the evolution of the French military Doctrine it is actually highly political and like it's it's not just uh that and and I think this is definitely what they're trying to replicate so I agree with many 23 but they try to replicate a very narrow view of what military history actually is uh and I'm pretty sure that at that time you already had
people who were thinking well meter research is probably a bit broader than that and we need to take into consideration other things than purely kinetic aspects if we want to understand those conflicts uh but yeah that's at least my point of view but yeah yeah what's really interesting about this too is that like I also think you know part of it part of at least these origin discussions right part of this particular focus on detail is very very typical of the kinds of students I teach and also the way I was when I was in my late teens and like going to my early 20s so like these people are in the age range where if you're not a trained historian who's doing like academic style history uh it's very normal to like kind of want to know like facts and details and like tactics of battles and feel like that's where you want to display your knowledge and your ability um it's very very natural like I have I teach like Latin quiz bowl and that's all about knowing myth facts like whose parents or who's and like what year this battle happened and you know um who was the General in X battle and this the year and you know that's I think that's all like foundational but then you know there's always that next step that you can take yeah um when you're doing history and uh you know that's that's what I would like to see is what I'm trying to bring right like I can't I can't help myself so Mike says that for him there's two main aspects understanding past worse you can win future ones and then understanding causes and consequences you can avoid future Wars
yeah and and I think that's true uh but I don't think that understanding past Wars uh is narrow to uh uh arms armor strategies tactics I think that understanding past Wars is is also understanding how wars were LED and there is a political aspect to it uh like if you look at yeah exactly if you look at World War II the decision of strategic bombing over uh over Germany is a political one uh and understanding why those decisions were made is is more important than knowing what was the type of bombs that they use exactly and everything so I think yeah it's like more important in a way uh so yeah I don't know so that's that's another debate for everybody for yeah for another stream yeah and then we have an amazing I love this you're not reading the rules yeah this is pure this is Peak BGG like that's the thing like this is this is sometimes that sometimes the way I feel about some people making comments and it's like dude read the rule book like it's like it's here like people are asking the same questions over and over or making an assumption about a problem in the game and you're like you haven't understood the rules and it's yeah I thought it was really really fun um and the way it was written and it was like nothing much has changed like it's it's quite funny um but uh but yeah what do you think about this one oh I was so tickled by it um just because it's so blunt yeah and it just really does feel like an argument that I would see in a forum somewhere or like if I made a mistake on
a YouTube video I feel like this is what a comment would look like yeah it just really has that like being a familiarity to it that you know it's one of the things that's so funny about doing any kind of historical work right like this is 60 years ago but it feels like somebody could have written this yesterday yeah and um I'm really Charmed by that uh because you know it's it's very it feels so like oh yeah like I understand how our community got the way it is like our community started out this way and I think a lot of people who appreciated this magazine and their youth are still around too so like the culture was set and like the Traditions are maintained right by by the people who were around when this was born or soon you know yeah actually and that's I think that the people from that generation shaped the the hobby quite a lot and that's also due to the fact that I feel like the hobby is more on the old side and actually a lot of the people that were reading this back then or the first 10 years they were still around and we don't have a lot of 17 years old today uh getting in and let's say maybe part of the problem because when I read this I I can understand it without I've never I've never seen a copy of Africa corpse in front of my eyes but I read the comments are and I know because the games haven't changed that much like you understand the references I see 447 I know it's attack defense and movement like it's it's hardwired in my brain and I'm like it's actually quite interesting to see that things haven't changed that much uh but uh but uh but yeah
yes absolutely oh this is also you know this is actually something I want to talk about too so we talked about variants a little bit earlier but this like design your own games thing so one of the first editors calm is about how he and his friends are making their own board game and like the kinds of materials they're using and the way the rules work and maybe the rules are a little messy so they're trying to make them tighter it was so cool actually that these kids were just out there making a horror game inspired by these war games like what a neat creative activity like I would be not even worried about my child if that was like what they were off doing at their friend's house it's cool yeah and I think it's amazing that it was a product for Avalon Hill and I think it's probably something that maybe Publishers could think about uh like helping people to actually make physical prototypes of things um I thought it was like as you said that that one of the of the editors talking about his experience making a a Warrior game uh representing all of the European theater of World War II and the different iterations that they went through and how they work with it Avalon Hill was super helpful with them providing them with some material to actually help them making the game and everything and it's that's also one thing that I think is really cool and I feel is still here today maybe not as strongly but the fact that the distinction between being a player and being a designer is very blurry uh and it's a it and that's one of the things that I love in this hobby is that it's it's such like you're not just consuming content
you have a lot of opportunities to actually make your own and it'll take part in The Hobby and then contribute in it and I think this is um this is super super interesting and and to see that it was actually part of a business strategy of the main company at the time I think it's really cool and maybe some Publishers they should look into it and say well maybe you should do that you know what a GMT should maybe have a like a small pack for uh DIY kit yeah DIY kit for make a CDG make a hex encounter make a con game you know uh just uh just a few things I think that would be that would be yeah I would want that for Christmas so I bought a bunch of spi blank map sheets in the 70s mid games he still has some of them you need to send us some uh some of the pics if you find some and that's the thing I'm pretty sure that watching this stream right now or people that were probably reading this in the 70s and the 80s you were at that time seeing all over this and it would be awesome to have I guess some if you can share them on Twitter or something like this with some pictures of some material that you have from that time if you have those um design material or copies of those magazines I would just love to see them in their physical form I think it would be really really cool yeah I would love that I would like I want to see all your old Maps like please tweet us pictures yeah if we can see your prototypes from when you were 16 years old that would be awesome I would want to see that and yeah I think you're right there's something really beautiful about boardgiving and that there's so much bleed um between
doing like creating and consuming within board game yeah and I love that I really think that one of the joys of human life is that we don't just consume things we make them like people make things is like the best thing about us right um and so I I think that that's one of the most exciting parts of board gaming and you know it's funny like I never thought I'd be a designer but like oh well that changed um and you know you caught on to that much earlier right like oh I like to play I should make as well um but I feel like we're all just trying to find ways to talk to each other about stuff that we're interested in and that you know we start by playing and talking about what we play and you know creating content like this is the generals the content of the 60s right um and you know it turns into something more sometimes but we we don't just play right we have to talk about it we have to make stuff about it we have to make our own responses to it and it's all just part of one like big cool conversation that's been happening for a long time based on this like you know you and I have like popped into the chat decades in you know yeah exactly yeah yeah it feels like it's a really long thread of a really long discussion like it's uh but it's hard it's that's also what I I thought was a brilliant idea from you to actually do that because it really feels like oh we're gonna read the beginning of the discussion and and and and and go back to the original uh
topics I think it's it's a really cool experience to do because we are taking part in this in our own ways today um and it's yeah it's super exciting to do uh it's really really cool yeah so we got jump oil he says I didn't create Maps but would create player AIDS especially as varians were published in the magazine so like this is before this is before we like had BGG for people to upload them that is cool yeah and how did you share them Joe then that would be the question did you uh send them to the magazine did they publish it because for now the only thing that we see in the magazine is actually Pro people uh propose variance but we don't really have like material to print that much or erratas or stuff like this so for now it's just rules clarification rules variant but uh we haven't seen the the playwright section yet uh but that's uh yeah yeah but that is like I I love also that's also something that's true if like one of the things I think that made solo gaming so doable for me is that people don't just go solo game and then not talk about it people play games solo and then they just show up and talk about it online and it's so good yeah it's really really cool and speaking of this is a a lovely example of like that search for connection because you know there's personal ads when you're looking for somebody to date but maybe even more Intimates and important is looking for somebody to came with example they had looking for players ads into bags of these magazines also by the way they had everybody's name and address at the time of all the subscribers printed in some of the early
ones yeah that was like privacy was was not a concern at all like it's yeah it's pretty nuts I mean wow yeah if you looked a bit at the at the at those of those um some of those ads the types of games and uh because I haven't looked at them and I was I was curious about what's the tune of it what games are they looking for I was curious about that so by the way Joe's just updated us really quick he says he had an A4 he shared with his gaming friend across the road oh I love it that's like the purest playering making in the world I love it so like so these are really fun actually um so for example isn't there anyone in Midland Texas who plays Avalon Hill games can Crush you in Africa core DJ style and Crowder Midway anyone who wishes to be slaughtered please note five Birds uh but they've also got wasn't more like hey I need to play by male opponent or like I'll play anybody um two undefeated generals need opponents right to Larry Joe burstin let's look at like are they undefeated because they refuse to play each other and they just want to team up on you like I really wonder about this yeah we just have to match them up clearly but it's it's really cute and the thing that I would say is that reading at all of those it actually made me want to play Africa course and I think that's maybe something that we could do on the side list maybe to really be in the spirit of this time is maybe play some of those games just to try them out
it could be working archeology part two right like we could play but yeah we could play by mail we should no I I cannot do that it's like about email but like you would see you would see on the server ask anyone who's done like like pvm or with me like I can already see Stuart typing a comment uh in the in the in the comment section hopefully is that here I think he's he's role-playing today uh but like complaining about the fact that how many games he started with me that I never finished but again it's probably the fate of a lot of these games yes yeah probably yeah that's fair enough that will be actually the most perfect experience um yeah yes but I think it'd be really fun for us to try like we could I would just nag you on Discord I'd be like hey it's time for you to take your turn like we have more modern means right but it'd be really funny to each get a copy of one of these that's like affordable yeah and so how much we could try this by mail and maybe there is a I would like to to play the 64 version uh let me check so Africa they had personal ads looking for players my heart is breaking yeah it is full actually I think it's really really cute it's pretty cheap if you are in the US um so you can find copy in good condition for 25 bucks oh that's cheap but then that's what patreon money's for yeah but the 75 version but we don't want the 75 version no war version it has to be the one that we yell about the most like there is one in the UK for 60
pounds uh a bunch of those magazines also used to include requests for rides to conventions oh we didn't see that I don't think there were um necessary conventions I'm not sure they were really present at conventions that much yet but I guess we're gonna hit that point even in the last late 60s or something like this um also also funny is that there's some people who are requesting adults only opponents like 20 or over and then you've also got high school student which is to engage able opponent in life and death struggle oh very very cute anyway I found a copy of Africa groups in the UK I know the setter it's a good seller so um uh yeah I'm gonna try to get this unless someone in the chat has a couple of copies of Africa curves laying around from the time Eric says he thinks they have it in TTS yeah but that's not the experience we're looking for Eric we're we're looking for having it I'll download my own mod of it and then you download a separate one and we'll do each other exactly yeah we'll play virtually but in the in the feeding of of actually having our own game set up on this side I don't know how big the game is because I'm saying that I wanna I wanna play it like this uh it's actually Second Chance game that is setting it uh in the UK I'm just I'm not sure how big it is let me look at some pictures because I I have a small apartment so I probably cannot while you're looking Brent has a good point so these old magazine persons aren't terribly different the people on BGG looking for nearby players just to
change in distro mode yeah definitely I think that's yeah yeah on like BGA or whatever and if there's a module in there I can find something to play with but yeah it's actually a pretty big map so maybe we have to to play it on on on on uh on vessel or something yeah if I says old Avalon helgers that must be
thinking I kind of do too yeah because the thing is that I was reading so many of them discussing about the rules arguing about the balance and I was like actually I would like to give it a try to see is it that hard for the Germans with that variant can it be done some people complaining about the fact that the Germans don't have uh supplies on round one uh because they are not occupying the city that is at the pace of their soup line and I was like actually I would like to try this it looks really interesting and I was and I'm not sure it's that heavy um a game it looks like pretty light hex encounter it's just that the it looks like there were a lot of hexes that's the only thing uh but uh but yeah I would be happy to uh Crush you uh Liz at Africa course two undefeated generals
oh man and then I think that's why I couldn't do this because Dan Bullock and I spent a bunch of time talking about gorgeous on our last stream and I just had to include the Bulge unveil the toy fair but that's really that's really a funny headline I think it's I'm I'm having a childish laugh at this yeah it shows the the spirit of the of the magazine which I think is pretty cool I you don't expect Evelyn Hill to do something like this today uh but uh yeah who do they yeah this is funny at the time I think they do they do right yeah when you see the whole tone of them the magazine is super tongue-in-cheek they do a lot of play on words so I I'm pretty sure this is a this is obviously yeah that's a good one though I gotta get I got a huge kick out of it yeah it's really funny I I enjoyed it um but we talk more about this I guess in episode two uh if uh if that makes sense and if people are enjoying this um but yeah and I really hope are enjoying this so like I guess it's time to kind of do some final thoughts so Fred you got any so I must say I enjoy it so the thing that I told you before we started the stream is that I felt it like in those three volumes there were a few hints of things that I thought were interesting and it was nice to see how things were already kind of the same and and and seeing how much the discussion that we have or Echoes of discussion that existed before I thought it was really interesting but those first three volumes I was like I
don't have much to discuss like there were a few things that are interesting but there is not that much meat uh I would say so after the first three I was like well I don't really have any differentiation between the three it's just interesting to see them build up so I don't know if in the future if we do it maybe we should have six volumes as a whole and maybe try to highlight specific articles that we see I guess we'll have to think about the the format and the number of volumes we want we want to see but I didn't learn much I thought it was just interesting to see but I felt like I I was a bit um not frustrated but I wanted more uh in a way uh even if I was Charmed uh I thought it was really interesting to see how um we took also part in a conversation that started 60 years ago I think all those fonts were really really cool uh but uh but yeah I still missed something so I guess we see but I want to keep on doing it that would be my final thought I really enjoyed this and I would like to keep reading more I think it's a good motivation for me to read them because if I was just reading them on my own that would be pretty boring but knowing that we're gonna discuss them and and doing that I think that would be pretty exciting yeah no I agree I think I think what makes this kind of a specialty to do to you is it you know there we got people in the chat who've been reading this since the beginning right but you and I are comparatively new if that's the comparison and so it's fun to go back and look at like oh what did the ancestors do you know like how how did our how did our our branch of the hobby starts and what were the earliest
conversations like and I think you know there are certainly things that are in here that we're still kind of raging each other about today right like Lost Cause stuff or like maybe being really comfortable with playing World War II Germany you know we have these conversations right but what I really see in this magazine that makes me happy is there's just so much energy like there's so much connection there's so much people looking for friends to game with who are just who want to explore this together in this really wonderful way and who have all these jokes and who are just like part of a family yeah and I really love that I love it so much and so you know I didn't know what I was gonna think after I read these I guess I wish you know we talk about inclusion I think the the reason that we talk about inclusion right is that I love this and then I also feel like if I had been a child in this era that you wouldn't have been able to yeah I've been able to be part of it and I'm definitely wired juice right but I would never have known that if I had been this age or you know teenager in the 60s probably and I'm not sure you would have been that I'm not sure how welcomed you would have been that's also the the thing that I that um yeah I don't know I don't want to make assumptions but when you read some of the tune you're like yeah I'm not sure I would want to be a woman in that space uh but uh but I do
love the energy I think it's really exciting I'm curious to see what are the discussions that are going to come up uh like I guess some recurring topics are going to appear and in the past I've really enjoyed also reading articles like more foundational um articles from from other magazines with they're really talking about design and and all of this and in the 70s they thought it had pretty refined discussion about the Hobie and I guess we're gonna see this start to creep in uh and that's the thing that I would like to to see without Maybe I don't know if I want to read all of them but I think if we could cover the 60s and the 70s that would be that would be really really interesting yeah I would really like to do that so um for those of you who are out there if you want to join us on that little journey please let us know in the comments uh those of you who watch this later oh and Jester showed up but um sadly dude you made it in at the end but I will see you on the War Room in about a month yeah it sounded like you were gonna be able to say in in like a few minutes but it's like it was a bit antique game I think yeah but hey we're gonna be streaming on your channel next week so we should plug that before we stop oh yeah sure uh maybe one thing we could say is that if you're interested we could make it a series this and I could keep on reading those uh debrief every three or six uh volumes in and maybe try to play some of those games in parallel so and we could and we're probably gonna alternate from one channel to another if if there is interest uh but at least there is interest for me so actually if no one is
interested I don't really care how much you want us to do it but that's a another discussion and uh we will be playing at the same day same time right yeah we're gonna start at um 3 30 EST so yeah so it's half an hour earlier yeah and we would be doing um well we'll be attempting to play uh honest um uh from uh ideas so the the miniature ancient miniature game that plays with uh with cards um so so yeah we should be playing this on TTS and uh and we'll see how it goes none of us has played it yet uh right or you have the rules yeah so it will be just us going through the rules and trying to figure it out and I mean if Alex likes it uh and he's interested that's enough for me Alexander is enough of a of a an audience for for yes yeah we like you Alex we like you have to make these videos just for you yeah exactly the whole series will be dedicated to uh Alexander Russo yeah Fred thank you so much for coming on and doing this with me I feel like this has just been a fun project and I'm glad we're gonna keep keep at it because I really I just I'm sort of curious about what we'll unfold next as we continue through the history of the general yeah but if we excavate on the next episode of war game who knows Mysteries uh but also thanks to everybody who came we love it when you stop by we love seeing your comments and um thanks for letting us have a great
Wednesday afternoon slash evening depending on where you are thank you everyone see you soon well it's it thanks guys