Horizon Zero Dawn: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audio book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audibletrial.com forward slash bg unlocked the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome to the discussion for horizon zero dawn the board game now before i go into the discussion i should mention that this is for the kickstarter edition of the game as well as just the base game uh because as far as i know they were doing split shipping and there's a lot of extra stuff that is coming with the campaign or with the kickstarter campaign like i i specifically pulled up the page because i wanted to talk about it because there is going to be like so much more for this and in the base game all you get is one quest to go after the sawtooth and even then the sawtooth is not that exciting even in the video game so if here's the thing this is by steam forge games where they also made the dark souls board game which if i have done the solo run through for that and i skipped everything except the final boss because the final boss was like the boss fights in dark souls was the best part of the the whole game and even though i didn't even like it so i was skeptical with horizon zero dawn because i was like well
they really kind of botched the dark souls board game but then they made the dark souls card game which i really like and i was like okay well at the very least i'll have some really cool minis which which i do the minis are really nice and horizon zero dawn is a phenomenal video game but this game at the ba at the base game which for the record because i was looking i was trying to look it up to get just the uh like just the board game is oh man it might actually not be that that expensive just because like actually they just have the seekers pledged which gives you expansions but that's about 130 but so for the base game this game is so freaking boring it is so boring oh my god is it there's very rarely a game that there's there's just nothing here i don't know what happened and once again base game because having all the extra hunts because like i said what is coming out like things that are probably going to be hunts like you get in the uh in the sacred land expansion you get a bellow back you get stalkers you get snap maws uh the
lo lollins lawless badlands as as bandits um and an extra bellow back you have like in the in the uh forge and hammer expansion it adds like ravagers and glint hawks uh the into the borderlands expansion adds uh mercenaries yeah the soldiers of the sun expansion adds a behemoth and tramplers um then you go into optional stuff which i went all in for this you get the frozen wilds expansion which uh like there's a thunder jaw and then a rock breaker um and then the storm bird expansion then a fire claw expansion then the heart of the nora expansion there's just so many other quests that in the video game everything that i just said all those all those massive stuff those are the real challenges the base game of this has no challenge the like i get that i played it solo but it says one to four and there's technically not even a solo rule set in this thing in the rulebook the the only thing i could take was okay well there's a cooperative variance so you really just do that you're not trying to get glory there's no beat your own score it's just kind of like in the in the video game where you have those trials there's none of that where it's like oh get this many glory points and you can get this uh there's no
difficulty challenge like you can't it's only you have to play as two hunters so you can't do that you're playing as yourself all the salvage goes to you and i knew that like just like the dark souls board game i knew playing it solo is the best way to play it um because i have played this multiplayer as well and it's not great then either it's semi-cooperative it's really weird how they do it with multiple people whoever kills the thing gets the glory for it if you destroy a component you get a glory so uh kat and i were playing as a two-player game and one from one to two players it the same amount of monsters are here so there was that but then uh so there was the board wasn't big enough for two people it was actually relatively sized for one so that's why i was like okay that's great and then three and four of course there's more monsters but anyway so i was playing the norah marksman as you can tell they're all about range and going after components and getting glory that way the whatever she was playing the the the car the carja card reward they're all about escaping and killing enemies without destroying any of their components getting glory for if if they're preserved so it's like one card they have is like if you kill it gain extra glory uh for each non-destroyed uh component so they can
kill like the sawtooth and get you know six glory or something like that um so you have the variety between between the different hunters and i will say this i do like the fact that they didn't use named people in this game like because you play a loy and there are named characters in the game but they're not really they're they're allies but they're in the game for like a second so it's not like you're playing with them so i'm glad that there wasn't one person playing a lord and then they just thought of three other [ __ ] named people and they're like okay you play asleep you remember them right they didn't do that you have the nora you have the karja you have the banuk and you have the osurum oh serum so the factions which which i like that but in a multiplayer game it's just like okay i guess we uh well i i happen to kill this before you did um so i'm gonna get this the the you know salvage there and then you come to the end of your turn and there's a maintenance step and you check to see okay how many times have we fallen or fainted which it's very hard to faint because the fact is like you can you can craft so that gets you three cards on the bottom of your discard pile back um in the so i keep that keep going to go on tangents so then you have
the fact that you'll almost never faint then you have the like the fact that okay well i have to go before you so i'm going to do that and they have a decent ketchup mechanic they have the fledgling and the leader tokens which if you're the leader you pick the tracking card which is the setup of the board and then the fledgling picks an event card so that you draw three as a leader and you pick a tracking card then the the fledgling draws three events and picks one of those and that uh and that's a ketchup mechanic for them and also what's pretty decent is when you go to the market phase where you you know there's always gonna be a weapon there's always gonna be armor components ammunition that's all fantastic that's all great the components actually for to buy cool stuff is relatively cheap um and if you kill everything everyone gets extra salvage uh everyone gets the you know buy stuff the fledgling the leader gets to buy first but they have to pay for it and the fledgling uh gets to take a card for free um and that's the that's like the kind of their catch-up mechanic which which isn't bad like but the problem is is that works in a two-player game because one person could be the leader the other person's gonna be a fledgling in a three or four player game well two people are just getting [ __ ] like now the glory the victory points go out a little bit different in in the way
the victory points work because you're you're going for points you're competing to be accepted into the lodge one person uh won't and so in a two-player game it's whoever has the most glory gets a sun token that's it if you tie for glory no one gets a sun token but then you swap leadership and fledgling all that is fine in the mult in three or four players there's a blazing sun which is two points and then a full sun then a half sun and they have different ways of getting points so if you're second or third you're at least getting some points but fourth isn't getting any but they get the fledgling token so that's their ketchup mechanic but it's just it's not that it's not that the game is bad like that's i i have to stress that the mechanics are solid enough the only thing that doesn't really work and there's a couple things because you you have two ways of moving you can sprint which is going to get you to move and you can move you know really anywhere you can you know move diagonal and stuff like that but if you move if you start somewhere if you start next to an enemy uh move past them or end your turn when you do a sprint action they're alert you can sneak which is just move one space and that alerts no one so but here's the problem there's almost no reason to sneak because you can't un alert them once they're alert they're alert and whenever obviously people are going
to draw conclusions or comparisons to the video game and in the video game yeah they're alert but you can run off enough and hide in in the tall grass and wait for it to come down like for them to not be alert or become suspicious or something um i get that there's really no way for them to implement that into a uh into a board game and the the encounters really shouldn't last that long so it's like okay well you you're not gonna run off because the encounters took five seconds you know but so i never really found a reason to sneak especially with my marksman where it's like okay my range is two you just range is almost always going to be there uh like because you can you it's just middle of the spot to the middle of the enemy so you can definitely almost always see them uh and yeah like some of the coils that you can get and the upgrades you get while it feels cool it's just like okay well that just seems super broken like and here's the biggest thing is you play four encounters up until the final one so the sawtooth is the final one and realistically i guess if you even won the challenge you're gonna go one two like level one because you have to and then do a level two and then do a level three and then do another level three and then you do a third level three because it's the final boss but that's the thing is like the hunter's cull it's there's nothing different about it from the rest of it like the board stays like obviously it has a thing this will always be
the layout for the the sawtooth this one card at least the encounters there's three different cards for each of the different levels and so it's like okay well i guess i'll just keep doing this and that allows me to get some more salvage and upgrade but i never was once like man i'm really low on salvage i always had excess and once i got to the sawtooth and i had leveled up and i had all these arrows and i was like wait i can just double i can play multiple ammunition on it and with this with this reroll any number of dice or exceed it it just is basically so the the damage coil negated his resistance so i was like okay so all i guess i'll roll that oh eight damage he only has 19.
like imagine that this was a like a multiplayer game like that thing would have died immediately with two people with three people here that's the problem is now of course they have two sawtooths in in the base game so in three or four players two sawtooths are coming out you know there's no way they're not as well as more more enemies and things like that but that's the problem is like the sawtooths are always going to come with sawtooth and striders that's it they're not going to have a they're not going to have more watchers to alert they're not gonna have the the scrappers to run around uh it's just gonna be those two and i find that extremely extremely bland like i have seen everything already from this and once again with all the extra [ __ ] i hope that there comes okay more hunter's calls for the different quarries there's gonna be hundreds calls you know obviously for the different you know the bellow backs and the rock you know whatever those things are called there's going to be those but for this to be the one for i would never come back and do this and what this game is missing is because this game is missing essentially a difficulty variant because or difficulty rules because even in a two-player game it stayed the same like yeah you're competing against another person but it's still kind of semi-cooperative because there's a phase
in here called the maintenance step where once again you check to see if you faint and then oh okay well we killed a watcher that's what we needed for a level one so we'll uh we can just call it here like both if if all players agree then you just call it and move forward but one person could be like no no nope i want to keep doing it and you technically have to because it's not a unanimous decision uh which is just a stupid rule anyway but so so the difficulty challenge i was like okay playing with another person i was like this is clearly too easy it's meant to be played solo then i did it solo and i was like even when the sawtooth hit me twice for six damage and essentially it has something called pursuit so it hits me for six you know i still roll my defense to evade okay that's three damage i have a resistance coil so that's gonna you know okay so four days so now i take two damage okay well my deck has grown to 22 as the norah marksman so okay well that's two cards and then i have to dodge away and then it pursues me hits me again okay well i got a crit and and that so that's six so no damage like but it's still so i have to dodge away but of course that's what the norah marksman wants it's like okay yeah hit me for two i'm gonna dodge away and now you're still two spaces away so i'm just gonna shoot you with my arrows and then i'll just you know oh okay well i have multiple things so i'm just gonna play
my hunter arrow and then my second hunter arrow and roll a [ __ ] ton of [ __ ] dice and oh okay there's a crit that's uh four five six seven eight nine nine damage in fact i could roll i can get really lucky the max for doing that roll is that would be three so before 6 12 13 14 15 that'd be 15 damage with one bow and the sawtooth has 19 health not whatever per player you know not 38 because in two players it's 19 for whoever and even if i was like okay well as an aura i can you know bypass a component or re-roll okay i'll just destroy the blaze container that's gonna do three damage on it um and then it'll suffer a fire so that's essentially four damage on it and uh yeah so with that it was four six twelve uh 15. so yeah like destroying its splice canister and a perfect roll with the combination i have killed it that is so boring there is zero incentive to play any other way except for you to be like i am mentally going to play with a trip caster or a a a sling
or they have a rattler in here which is kind of like their gun and it's just so boring like you play for so long to for that to be the final it's like it's the opposite of what dark souls was i think they were trying to course correct because dark souls you know is pretty much just dark [ __ ] until it's until it's uh boss and their bosses are awesome even in the in the card game their bosses are so much fun because they're they're thematic to one the bosses and two they are a challenge because there's actual damage it's not based around your deck um and because you have basically your stamina and your and your damage marker meeting like in uh in dark souls here it's your deck so the fact that as you level up your deck your life gets longer um like never once was i threatened that my my deck was gonna run out but here you play encounter by encounter and there's not a whole lot of enemies anyway so in a solo game it's like okay well i can just pick these off one by one which i guess yes is thematic to the video game you can easily do that uh but there's a difficulty variant in the video game you can make it whatever the hardest one and you do one you shoot it you should get a critical in the in that and it's like too damaging you're like oh no um here there isn't any of that so it's
like okay well i'm just going to crit this guy open said oh okay well he that killed him so he's not going to alert anyone else okay then i'll move i'll sneak over here shoot him to kill him and then i'll fight the boss and uh wipe him because it's apparently a joke man what a disappointment and and here's the other thing when it comes to the merchants like the i like the fact that okay you buy a weapon or if someone buys a weapon you're not just out you're like you don't get a weapon or something you're like you draw from the deck until another weapon comes out i like that but the problem is if you're playing like if i'm playing a norma marksman i need to just buy bows that's it you can buy a different weapon but don't because your deck is filled with arrows and i bought a sling and my arrows don't work in the sling so therefore i have to wait and hope that slings come out in the other decks and to replace the arrows and by that time you're still not going to get enough slings because it's random chance that but those come out anyway so then you're like okay well it's not like okay i bought this hunter bow uh or i bought this sling and now i can replace the arrows in here with other bombs nope it's just okay well if you're gonna buy that weapon then like you're you're essentially wasting your time because you better start using your other other
weapon until you can hopefully get some other equipment and i get that they probably wanted to keep the four factions the same because the carja used a sling you know one of them probably use a trip master and then or trip caster and then the other one probably uses a rattler or something like that and so they want to keep it within the four factions but if you want to play like the video game you don't have to stick as as aloy you don't have to stick with a bow just because that's what the nora use you can use everything you can use a trip caster to set those up and then shoot them to make them run towards you into obviously the video game is way more immersive and and has that type of variety to be able to do that kind of stuff and they had to sim like simplify it here but i don't know like that was one of cat's issues was the fact that she wasn't liking her sling so she went for the trip caster and luckily at that time there was also a trip line like a shock a shock trip line that she could have also bought but if i was being a dick i could have just bought that because just so she couldn't have it but that's a douchey thing to do so she bought that and she was actually able to use the trip thing um which did pay off it worked it worked uh in the through the mechanics of the game but she was like well i guess that's that i'm like nope basically what you do is you set a trap and then you use it and then you craft to get that back into your deck and you just keep doing that so you're
really railroaded in the way that you're gonna play like as the nora this is like the optimal way to play against this um and in terms of the enemies the watchers will play will always play the same way the everything is going to play the exact same way except for two in the base game it is the well they [ __ ] call them shell crabs shell walkers the shell walkers and the sawtooth they are the two that are going to play different because they actually have a deck but the problem is that because there's a variety of these types of enemies there's never really a boss in horizon zero dawn the only boss based off of what's gonna come out in this game is the where is it the heart of the nora expansion and the fire claw and the storm bird and probably the rock breakers like and i think you go and hunt a thunderjaw as well those things are really your bosses a sawtooth i wouldn't consider a boss um like i think it is a boss at the very beginning of the game but other than that not really and so uh i don't know where i was going with
that oh yeah so and and so the sawtooth has four cards that that's their behavior deck so you're not quite you're not quite gonna but i got through two before i killed it the uh shellwalkers are there um but they're not ever really a threat either and i love the fact here's the thing i love the fact that they have components because that is thematic to the game the some of the hard bosses can be crippled if you can aim for their their weak spots and break those off because then they can't do certain attacks i i really do like that like the fact that with the scrappers it's just like okay well how am i gonna kill or stop this thing from doing its beam attack okay well i'm gonna break that that component and and then now i can't even do that attack but it can just run up on me i do like that that's really good but just the fact i think everything should have had at least a few cards for them because then you don't know how they're gonna react they could like the watcher for example no i they do have like the the tree but it's like a non-alert enemy within two squares yes it moves one space towards it no it moves towards you and attacks you if it's in your spot what would be cool is if these behavior cards there was like two or three like the show walker has three that's more than enough you're not going to remember exactly what it's going to do so what could be cool for like the
watcher is that it has this but then it could have another one where all it does is run three or four three spaces towards the nearest non-alert enemy because that's that's the whole point the watchers whole point is to alert everything that's nearby um but the fact that it only does that if it happens to get near it and they're spaced out enough that uh that this this thing is going to die before it ever you know gives off any type of hint and so if you then know exactly what it was going to do or you're like man if i hit this thing and not kill it and then you're like okay well maybe they'll just move the one space and you draw the card and it's just like move three spaces towards the nearest non-enemy and alert them uh or a third card could be alert all enemies within a two square radius or and and it's like oh [ __ ] it i hit it didn't kill it i mean because it at that point like you might not always one shot it and so then you're like oh [ __ ] uh now that sawtooth and the uh the scrapper and the grazer those are all alerted now and i'm the only one here the fact that there's one card is extremely just extremely boring uh for everything oh the scrapper okay well i'm just gonna always go for a try and break that component so it just basically if i'm always two spaces away it's just gonna always run up on me
the grazers uh i mean yeah you destroy their antlers it's the same thing i mean they're gonna run towards you if they're in your spot they're gonna hit you for potentially six but if you destroy their antlers it's gonna be four and then they move away um the shell walkers that's the only thing there's three cards and some of them it's okay it's gonna attack you for one space and then it's gonna move towards you and it's gonna attack you for one space and then it's gonna move uh so then it depends on if it's cargo holder is destroyed if it's not then it's gonna it's gonna attack you but if you're not in range one then it'll do its range attack which is gross and then the other one was if you're in within one square so the shell walkers i mean i just don't get it i don't get why they would just go so basic i think it's because with dark souls they went too hard into it the game was virtually unplayable uh because he played forever until you got to the final boss and even then there wasn't a guarantee you were going to have any good weapons um but if you play a solo all those souls went to you so you can at least spend them and get good gear and [ __ ] uh but the bosses every one of them had their own deck and then they had a second phase to where it's like okay well like yeah like to where it's like all right well now like i got them through half health now they're gonna heat up and now their cards are getting shuffled each turn so you don't know how they're gonna act
i just i can't i can't believe they just went so bland with this one like they totally totally [ __ ] the bed on it um as for man yeah it's just it's really all negative i'm really just trying to think of positives i mean the minis look good they look great painted of course the board looks boring and like [ __ ] i don't know i don't even think these guys played this game like because the game isn't it's not all desert there is a desert area now that's probably all in expansions where there's different types of boards uh you know with the crocodiles there's there's water there's mountains and things like that so there's different types of terrain uh this base game is as bland and as boring as it could possibly get um and here's the other thing playing solo was significantly faster like oh my god like it says 60 to 90 minutes on the box that's actually pretty accurate solo if you're playing with two like it's it's easily two to three hours like because you both are you both are buying you both are running around trying to kill um and then you would think it'd get shorter but no not really um because that's the thing is you you don't like with all the salvage that you get it doesn't all go towards you in a multiplayer game you share it okay well i killed
you know i killed that watcher you killed one we both get one card uh okay so you don't have a plethora of salvage materials to use to be able to buy the good stuff so it's just it's you're not as strong so the fact that they played say one to four but they don't make it any more difficult that's probably with the multiplayer because you're all battling for resources so you don't get as gross as as i did because i had all the resources to be able to buy all this stuff uh the fact that that's the way that they balance it is is extremely just like basic and beginner like i just don't know i don't i don't know yeah i mean i like the level up system for each of them there's at least a tree for you to go on i like the fact that your cards you get a bigger deck they have that in um the dark souls card game where each bonfire rests you get more cards to build your deck up and home a little bit of deck building i kind of like that i like the coils i like the the rpg feel of upgrading your weapons and with coils and upgrading your armor with weaves um and the fact that you can get like some trade abilities i i do i like that i like the component part where you can break those off and it does damage to them and they suffer you know conditions um it's just they're missing variety
and and this is once again still still the base game like i would not like i would not buy this like i would buy a full pledge of this because you get everything i just said you get all that stuff and more um and then the fact that almost every one of the enemies are going to play the exact same way out and the fact that they put in minimal effort into the bosses where it's like they just have four cards okay that's kind of what they do there's zero varying difficulty variants on this the only variants that are in this are a cooperative mode and trading items so that's it technically no solo mode um this rulebook is piss poor i hate it now that could just be me on uh on like the way that it's formatted because it's one of those formats where it's like okay here's the components all right let's start explaining what every single component is every single one oh and then the way conditions are and all that oh there's enemies and then the salvage deck okay finally you get to set up i don't like that i don't like that but that could just be me um i don't like the tiles the tiles are
extremely boring and it's not like they're double-sided i mean they are technically but they literally the only thing changes about them are the icons uh this is for and so like if this was the case if i was playing with three or four there would be two striders here and then a rock um yeah uh i don't like that i don't really like the fact that you're kind of railroaded with your class there's no versatility where it's like okay i'm playing nora bow that's her that's the bow uh if i'm playing karja okay sling sling in the melee weapon um so you're not really versatile in that way um the dice are okay they're there they the crits feel good when you roll them i like that you know if you roll multiple crits you can use them for multiple things i like that i mean i always like the your deck is your health i think that that's pretty i always like that because if i'm i mean the the risk would have been okay i'm gonna be burning through a lot of my arrows uh to try and kill a sawtooth but the fact that i did that twice and killed it is pretty pretty sad um yeah i mean i'm excited for all this extra stuff that i'm that that i'll be getting literally extra people mercenaries uh glenn yeah glenn hawks just extra equipment uh there's a
aloy on an overridden strider um i think i got extra dice so yeah the heart of the nora expansion that thing's a massive just [ __ ] machine gun thing the fire claw is going to be cool the storm bird is going to be cool the rock breaker is going to be cool the thunder jaw is going to be cool uh there's the frozen wilds expansion which adds four things um let's see yeah it's just so so blah and i'm glad it was relatively cheap the behemoth the tramplers yeah broadheads every every enemy is gonna be in this but it's just this base game is not worth it in any way just oh my god so on a scale of one to ten for the base game i'm going to give it
a [ __ ] [ __ ] i want to give it a 4 but i know that every all those extra [ __ ] is coming but i'm worried that all that extra stuff finding a storm bird for example by myself is going to be just as easy as fighting a sawtooth and that's ultimately the kick in the teeth is you play this game for about an hour and a half or two hours for the final boss to be just as weak and he's not that's the thing like he has 19 health which is the most out of anything here but the build in a solo game is just that it's just that crazy like that easy to kill him um i'm gonna give it a 4.5 out of 10. i was going to give it a 5 and call it an average game but at the same time i just i i can't give it a five it's just it it has no meat to it at all it has does it even have the heart of horizon zero dawn it sure looks like it but no no you do the exact same thing as with my hunter's bow i did i did the exact same thing kept my distance
shot multiple arrows the reason why horizon zero dawn is such a fantastic game one because there's story and it's a fantastic story a in a phenomenal world but for a game to just be boiled down to the fighting and the fighting in the video game is so much fun because you can plan set a trip caster shoot it with an arrow runs towards you gets shocked you throw a sling freeze it you know then start shooting it then run up and hit it with your thing to back out while it's also oh and then something else comes at you you have to dodge manage your health uh it's just so quick vibrant fast-paced versatile and in the board game it is by god the bear bare minimum it's you have your items which you see in the game you can do a lot of damage with them if you build it right but you're railroaded to build it a certain way anyway so i cannot even call it an average game and this is what i was worried about i was worried that it would it would be like this that steam forge would [ __ ] it up again because they did with dark souls and they did it here with the zerodon but this time i'll have some pretty badass [ __ ] minis that i will keep because that was my one regret of not keeping the dark souls board game is that uh is that i wish i still had those dark souls minis but here at least the minis are cool
they're not they're not cheap but they're not like amazing either so if i can just take the bosses and uh and just get them painted or get get one of everything painted i'd be pretty happy with that so that's it in the future when i do get all my horizon zero dawn stuff uh then i will play those i will do no run-through reviews for those expansions and then give it like an overall final horizon zero dawn ranking uh to see if it goes up at all but as of right now the base game for horizon zero dawn is a 4.5 out of 10. and that's it let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you