Skip to main content
Loading video...

For All Mankind Review: Quick Take with Tom Vasel

Transcript 5:15

For All Mankind is one of my favorite themes, strategic space exploration. And I don't know if it's one of my favorite boxes. It's like a callback box, but this is a game of rotating planets, which is honestly so few board games do the rotating planet thing very well. But I'm always a sucker for it. Oh, the planets rotate in this? How does that work? Well, let me show you.

In this game, players are trying to get 10 victory points. Put a spaceship on the board, get a victory point. Buy some research, get a victory point. Get a colony on a planet, get a victory point. Get a bonus, which is having the farthest planet out, or having the most research, or having the most of these special cards that you can draw, and you get a victory point. Each player is going to start with one colony on Earth, and you also start with the ability to build a tactical nuke. And then players are going to take their turns going around in turn order. After everyone has taken a turn, then all the planets will rotate one in a clockwise fashion. And so you see some planets are going to rotate faster. On your turn, you're going to do a bunch of actions, and when you're finished with your actions, you're going to collect all the things you have. So, if this is my Earth thing, I'm going to collect these resources. There are four different resources cards, water, oxygen, iron, and fuel. So, here I get two iron and one each of the others. And if I have a different colony, let's say I have this Jupiter water colony, I would also get a water at the end of my turn.

And then you can spend resources to do various things. I can buy an espionage card, and you can see it cost an iron, a water, and an oxygen. And you'll draw espionage cards, which with you do all manner of things. Add a tactical nuke to your stockpile, uh get rid of use a espionage card someone else has in their pile, build a colony without paying the fuel cost, steal resource cards from the other players, etc. You can also build a colony. When you build a colony, there's a cost to build a colony plus fuel. For fuel, you're going to pick one planet that you're on, let's say it's Earth, and you'll go to the planet you're going to. So, that would cost me four fuel. Well, no, sorry. That's an outer planet, so that would cost me eight fuel. It costs two fuel per spot on the outer planets. And then research has different costs depending on what type of research. Each one comes with a card that will let you know. Here, I can do espionage cards in the same turn. Normally, you can't play them the same turn, but if I have executive privilege, I can.

And you can also play a tactical nuke on someone and get rid of one of their colonies, also losing the tactical nuke in response. And that's pretty much it. You're going to take turns and keep going till someone gets those 10 points and wins. I should mention in the rules that you can trade anything for anything at any point. I can trade this to that. And when you have all the properties of a a all the colonies of a planet, you get bonus. You're going to get double from that. Hmm. So, this is Catanopoly because this game definitely feels like those. You collect resources based on the stuff you have. There's no die rolling, but you collect resources. You then spend those resources to build colonies and or buy cards that let you do things. You get a bonus point for having the most cards. And that's very Catan-esque. The idea of trading and getting a monopoly on the colonies of planet, that's a little similar to Monopoly.

And the production of this game is is nice. The cards are nice. But at the end of the day, I why would I ever give you a monopoly on a planet unless you also gave me a monopoly on a planet? Why would I ever trade in this game? For the most part, I'm just trying to get things as quick as possible. That little fuel thing that moves around and measures, that's interesting, but not that interesting. The rotating the planets is just a thing. It happens. You're not sitting there going, "Ooh, I'm going to wait four turns and then Neptune and Jupiter are going to be pretty close together. I'll be able to get a cheap fuel." But by that time you'll have collected enough fuel that you could have gone there anyway. It's, you know, the planets move and you go, "Oh, well, that one's too hard to get to this turn. Okay, I'll do something else." It It's not a whole I mean, I guess I mean, don't get me wrong, you could probably plan it out, but this game is very, very simple. So, I give it that. But it's also way too long for what it is. It's 60 to 90 minutes, that's way too long for this style game. It should be 30 minutes.

I like a lot of the ideas of this game, but it's just kind of boring and you're also just grabbing tons of cards every turn. And then spending cards, and then grabbing cards, and then spending cards, and then grabbing cards. And so, it gets boring pretty quickly. It's not better than Catan and it's not better than Monopoly, but it tries to mix them with a fun theme. And I applaud it for what it tried to do, but it can't be a game that I say I enjoyed. It's a five out of 10 for me. For All Mankind.

Progress saved