Nemo's War: Ultimate Edition Review
Transcript
this video is sponsored by game toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody welcome to drive through review 748. today we're talking about nemo's war ultimate edition and this is kind of the third edition of the game although i don't think it's technically a third edition now i actually reviewed this game i think 10 or 11 years ago and it was originally published by victory point games who's now been purchased by tabletop tycoon who then has published believe the last edition and then also this new ultimate edition the designer is chris taylor he just done a couple other uh board games i believe he's the designer of the original fallout game the original fallout one and then alan hamrick who was formerly or currently with victory point games used to own victory point games now i think he just does some work uh he actually designed a lot of the extra stuff here and then the artwork is actually by ian o'toole who is now kind of like a world famous in the board game world i think this was his first sort of job as a graphical designer in the board game world the last edition of this uh so it's mostly a solo game now you can play it cooperatively you can play competitively uh this has kind of like all the expansions that have come out and i believe some new stuff kind of bundled in to this ultimate edition from what i know i have never played the second edition of the game the rules have not changed between second edition and this ultimate edition there may be some small changes that i don't know about but it's largely the
same now it has changed from the original of first edition which i played like i said 10 years ago uh but uh mostly minor i mean i think the changes are significant but from like a gameplay perspective it still kind of has the same v feel and vibe as that original one i mean almost identical it's kind of cleaned up a little bit and that kind of thing um but uh yeah so what it is mostly solo game you're playing captain nemo uh sort of driving around the world's oceans in his super sci-fi submarine and the kind of the linchpin with this game is you are at the outset picking sort of the style of victory that you're going for so you can try to go for a science victory a war victory an anti-imperialist victory uh there's things there's like eight different ones so you choose that at the outset and that will dictate how you score points and how much those points are worth so if you're doing like an exploration type of victory for example then you will try to discover different like monuments and things and little kind of hidden treasures and islands and stuff like that around the world those are going to score you more points you might still do that if you have the war victory for example the anti-imperialist victory but it's not going to give you many points if you pick one of those victories versus the other so you set out with sort of a plan and then that will kind of dictate how you want to play that particular session next time you can you know choose a different victory and have a new totally different kind of adventure doing all
the same kind of mechanics and things like that but you know weighing your decisions a little bit differently so let's jump down to the table i'll give you a somewhat brief overview the rules are relatively involved we'll talk more about that in the review part but i'll give you a general overview of the game uh if you've played any kind of co-op or solo game it has a lot of those same kind of trappings uh if you will with some nice unique quality so we'll jump down to the table take a look at it and then come back and i'll give you my impressions on what i think okay so i've got everything set up here and here is the main board that you're going to be interacting with it's kind of a long board so kind of hard to get into the frame here but you can see a couple of different parts here on the left hand side we've got kind of a draw pile and i'll talk about that in a minute with kind of a player aid sort of built into the board here and then you have sort of your map here so if we take and zoom in over there we can see this nice plastic miniature there representing nemo and his ship and then they have the various different oceans there so this is the european seas uh the north atlantic and so on and we have some hidden ship markers and some other ships that we've revealed through the course of the game so be interacting with them there and then you've also got these different like little pathways so when you move your ship you can go to the joining different regions there and then there's also some like land areas here and these where you might put your uprising cubes onto if you're going doing some you know anti-imperialist activities you might stir up some uprisings by putting some cubes out in these spots here and a couple of things to note as you can see
there are dice depicted on each of these so you've got the five and then the three there and spots for the treasure tokens and let's see what some other things will make uh some of the regions adjacent for terms of placing out new ships like this but not for nemo's movement so when you roll dice at the beginning of the round you can be putting ships out uh based on the some of the numbers that you rolled there or possibly if you roll doubles putting out treasure in the spot that you roll doubles if you roll double threes you put a treasure token out there and so here's where you spend most of the board kind of driving your ship around fighting uh different ships whether they're merchant ships or warships or inciting you know the rebels and so on the anti-colonial forces and then above here we've got a couple other things a couple of tracks so this top track here your notoriety track and so as you do combat and other actions that might happen this is going to move up and then this will start to unlock you know more powerful ships that will go into this draw bag of ships here and so as you you know do different actions that the harder ships will come out and depending on kind of the like i said victory mode that you choose you may actually lose the game and become defeated if you get your notoriety too high whereas if you do other modes then that's it's good they could you raise the notoriety in a way and then you have these three tracks here let's take a zoom in and these sort of represent you know
your capabilities to a certain degree so you've got nemo which is sort of like you and then you've got the crew and the whole of your ship and so through different tests or during combat what you can do is you can exert maybe one or more of these and give yourself a dice roll modifier and you're almost like gambling that resource when you do that because if you succeed then you're fine most of the time and then if you if you lose you're gonna lose that resource so you're gonna either like lose points at the end of the game uh you're gonna get closer to defeat for example so like first pretend nemo goes all the way down here then you've lost the game and then also your dice roll modifiers are going to start to get weaker so you can see here nemo starts with plus two plus two he actually goes up i should say and then the crew goes plus three down to plus two and so on now you can take actions to rest and and repair and that kind of thing to bring these back up as well but you're kind of like taking a turn off in a sense to do that so this is where you kind of manage you know your crew and your ship and so on and then over on the right hand side of the board we've got some other things here so you have here a deck of adventure cards you'll set these out aside you'll sort of prepare this deck over here it won't be this many cards i'm just going to set some out here as an example so just prepare this deck shuffling in the act 1 act 2 act 3 cards and then any
other special cards based on the again victory condition that you go after and so this deck here that you end up with is going to act as kind of a turn timer so once you run out of the deck then you're going to get to like the finale there and have to do uh there's some finale cards here which i said aside yep so you have some of these finales and stuff that you won't necessarily know what it is until you get to the end of the game so that acts as kind of a game timer as well and then some of these will have you put out a certain number of cards in this adventure deck which come out of the same deck you will take in-game actions and events to trigger those and so over here we have a collection of treasures so when you get to one of these little treasure tokens marked here you actually will pull them out of this treasure bag and then put them out here and a lot of these are just straight victory points if we zoom in a little bit you can see like that one there's worth three points there we go and some of those one and four other ones will be like monuments and stuff that you might try to seek out so for example in this little setup i have the explorer option and you can see there we have the not monuments the wonders here so it's going to be x times 7 so you're going to multiply that number by 7 in that case whereas if you did the other victory here for anti-imperialism you would only multiply the monuments by 3 but some of these other ones will change and then when you draw treasures out here you get sometimes special effects
that i tell you you know something like discard a treasure and draw two more treasures stuff like that so and then over here you've got like a victory point track and you can kind of keep track of your victory points during the course of the game there with some of these other little special tokens and stuff and then down here you have some events will bring some of these special ships into play these are different colored ships more powerful ships and then as you defeat ships you've got a few different things you can do with them so if you defeat a ship here you can start to put them here like so and if you fill up these columns here and these are showing the different regions where you defeated the ship so you know you might kind of get a different stack here as you defeat them in different areas i'll just kind of grab these randomly you know like so and then as you fill up the columns you're going to get more points at the end of the game for filling a complete column so you in effect want to be traveling and defeating ships in various different locations all over the board but if you want to you can also set these aside over into kind of the salvage yard and set these here and you can spend these ships here that you did not score for points but you can use these to buy up these cards here and there's this deck off the side there of these different upgrades and you'll always start with one in play that has to do specifically for your objective so here's the explore one and so once you purchase this one and there's even variance to like start with this one
in play and there's a lot of different variants which i'll get to but you get this so each time you perform a move action you can move the nautilus that's your submarine up to two consecutive oceans because typically you can move one for an action point so that's kind of the general overview of the board now what's going to happen on your turn so on your turn you're going to go and draw a card off this deck and resolve it and these are 9 times out of 10 gonna be a test so you're going to roll your 2d6 there to try to match or beat that number and that in this case would be a 10 this shows you you can exert nemo and your crew right so these show you which ones you can exert to try to keep the dirl modifier higher and then if you pass in this case you're actually going to keep this card and keep it in front of you and then if you pass before any future tests you can roll this to add the plus three so but you can you keep this card or it'll be some other kind of event that happens uh i'll show you another one if you fail and lose one nemo or two crew so if you fail you've got to lose that or sacrifice then land character so you can see this is deadlands temper and so it gives you a little kind of background story this is based on the 20 000 leagues under the sea uh book and so there's some of the characters and things like that from the book and then at game's end you put it in the pass pile if unused so one thing to note here is you can see has kind of an icon so it's going to match one of the kind of scoring possibilities
here right so it's going to match one of those i was with one or more of the icons that are actually on the card there and then if you pass it as you draw these tests and play them they're going to go into the fail pile or the pass pile but in this case you actually kept it so if you if you pass it you keep it and then you can you before any future tests use it but at games end passive unused so if you didn't use it it will just go to the pass pile so if we take a look at this one here example there's another one so you can do a test here in this case you exert nemo or the hull and if you pass you gain one hole so you kind of repair a hole and then if you fail and lose one name or one hole so then you would put it in the fail pile and so any icons in here on the upper left will not score obviously if it's in the fail pile but in the past pile you're going to take and multiply that base again on over here whatever multiplier you have to do with there so that's the first step your turn is to go over here draw an event resolve it resolve the test and then move on and then you're gonna roll some dice and this could vary but usually you're gonna have two dice rolls and the number of action points that you get is gonna be the difference in dice so let's just pick a random thing so that's pretty good so we have a two and a five so we're going to look at the difference that means i get three action points because five minus two is three so we're going to set up here and have three action points now you can
hold one action point over uh from your previous round you can't hold more than one you're always going to reset down to at least one in this case let's say we had held one over we got three we're going to add three so we'll have four action points to spend and you can spend these to do a number of different things moving uh doing rest repair refit where you can kind of try to rest your crew repair your ship and refit is basically using that salvage action like i showed you over here to spend some of that and then do a salvage and then this dice roll here is also going to dictate where new ships or possibly new treasures come out and stuff like that now you can also have a lull turn we have a limited number of actions but some of the actions actually cost you less action points everything kind of defaults to one action point but you can't quite do as much as as you want there now let's just kind of quickly talk about some of this stuff so you can see there's two different types of ships you've got uh the warships which have an attack number in their upper left so there have a number here in this case six they have a defense value nine and then some other things like this as you can see is this type of ship now sometimes uh through the course of the game this is gonna go up right so the nine now is the defense and the seven of attack uh if these start to come out flipped on their purple side and the game will indicate to you when that happens now other ships here don't have an attack value these are just merchant vessels here they just have a defense value like so but you can see here you're going to get a notoriety
when you fight them because you know you're fighting a merchant ship and you can see it's got a merchant of one it gives you plus one treasure so on and so forth so what you're going to try to do is roll your 2d6 and try to beat that defensive number and again you can exert your various resources up here to improve your diastrol modifier of warships obviously attack back i should say they attack first and then you've got to make a roll there and then they might start to destroy some of your upgrades and hull and so on now some of your other actions are off to the side here so you can search for treasure try to rest your crew kind of get that crew marker back off to the left repair get the hole up refit and then in sight is the other one down here and that's the one where you try to get some of these uprising tokens out onto the board specifically if you're doing the anti-imperialist then that can be important and here this is just a nice little chart you can see the result here and again you can exert your summary resources to improve that so if you fail miserably you might actually hurt yourself so for example if you're going to repair and you basically roll snake eyes which is always a fail no matter what uh then you'll actually lose a hole instead of repairing a hole that kind of thing so again search for treasure rest your crew repair your hole refit your your ship and incite uh some of the anti-colonialist forces and that's kind of your general uh game arc i just want to talk about a couple other little details here that are that are kind of important in terms of like the tactics and strategy that you can do one
other thing is the special characters here you have the special characters some of these will give you dictrol modifiers actually after you've rolled or give you extra action points and so on and these other things will possibly uh score you points or interact with some of the different event cards and that kind of thing when you use them let's see this one here for example you use that one you'll gain a notoriety this one here your nemo will have to go down by one the special one nadine here if you it's basically kind of signifying the end of your um uh your life there because if you use him that's defeat okay so this is a new addition that they didn't have this from what i remember in the original edition so this is a nice kind of get out of jail free card to use some of these we've only got a handful of these to help you there the other thing to note is there are a few different types of attacks i'll just show you these here so you might get eventually access to torpedo attacks and diplomatic attacks here and then there are rules for that and you can you can kind of do this in lieu of your kind of normal attack and there's also here the idea of like a stock attack where you can just kind of stock and fight one ship in the region that you're at and you get a plus one there or you can do the bolt attack which allows you to attack everybody in your region which you might want to do because maybe there's a bunch of weak you know merchant ships there or something and you want to kind of build that up and and and take them out maybe in a region where you don't have a lot of ships on that tonnage track which i showed you and you keep doing that until you use one of those ships to salvage and then you have to stop there so there's kind
of two different styles of attack so you're kind of juggling a lot of these different things and that's a lot of what this game is about which you talk about in the review is juggling this sort of real basic game loop with the sort of goal that you put out for yourself at the start of the game so just one last uh quick mention here we have two rule books for the game and i'll probably open the review of this because i don't really like this how they did it so you have the basic game rules here which which tells you kind of all the step-by-step stuff that i just kind of went over obviously in way more detail and this is written in kind of like a old wargamer style with like you know rule 15.6 and all that stuff which is not terrible and then you have here this other one which has rules for the expansions and also kind of all the different ways you can set it up based on you know the victory point approach that you you chose and so on and how to build the decks and all that and then some of the expansion stuff in here and then also the cool thing which i wanted to show you here is at the back is let's say you did i just opened this randomly here's piracy and here is science right and so based on your score um you have different sort of outcomes so you'll win the game you could lose the game and not even get to this point and then you'll win the game and see what your score is and then based on how well your score is you may actually have well defeat failure inconsequential all the way up to triumph and then have that that sort of scale for each of each of the different victories so science has
defeat failure inconsequential notable success triumph all of them have that so you're going to win the game and you can see how well you did so the idea is that you would play through this multiple times and try to get a triumph for each of the different victory conditions that gives you a lot of replayability so that's also in the back of this book here okay gloss over some details but that's pretty much your core loop of the game the kind of the gist of how you play let's go back to my talking head okay so that is nemo's war ultimate edition a little bit succinct and brief overview there but hopefully get the general idea the core loop is pretty basic and simple it's just kind of all of the window dressing kind of around it in this case now typically do three pillars of review where i talk about player time play count and then kind of a general touchy feely you know what is this game like uh well play account i've only played this solo i know this new edition has you know multiplayer in it and i think the original even you could play two-player but this game is really known for its solo play recently over the last couple years i've done a couple of top 10 solo games and by far this is the number one game where people say why is nemo's were not on your list and well i mean the reason it wasn't on my list is because i played it like 10 years ago in the original edition i really liked it i really liked that original one and i just hadn't had a chance to play the new one and it's kind of been out of my my thought process you know for the last little while and actually the publisher reached out to me after my last uh top 10 solo games and said hey we'd like to send you the ultimate edition
take a look at it and i was like oh yeah that sounds great because i remember really enjoying uh the original one so i've not played it with all the extra you know versus mode and cooperative mode and stuff like that and i think the game to be fair is probably mostly known for solo game now in terms of the play time i would say it takes what does the box say does the box give you time i didn't even look i would say it takes about an hour this is 90 minutes it seems to take once you kind of get the hang of it you can get it done in an hour now getting the hang of it that will move us into my third pillar is i think it'll be tricky so when i sat down to play this i was a little bit surprised at how like difficult the rules were to parse now once you get through the rules i think it's fine but half of me is like i'm really kind of conflicted about this to be honest with you because the original was dead simple okay it was much not much simpler it was simpler than this um in terms of the amount of rules it was just a very easy to quick sit down and play like in a 30 45 minute type of time frame it was a very small footprint game nice little like pocket size i think it even came in an envelope sit down and play and the amount of game that it had in it for like that small period of time was just immense and i really really enjoyed it back then now they've sort of fleshed it out expanded it i think overall the game is better than it used to be um the way that the game end sort of
triggers and some of the different uh ways that you deal with the events is is cool because before you you maybe or maybe didn't get an event so the game was sort of on a different sort of turn track at the end there everything else is pretty much the same the combat and the you know the way you use your hull and your crew and nemo and the events that you keep in the upgrades well the upgrades are actually a little bit cooler here because you have the different cards and different types of upgrades and stuff like that which i don't think they had exactly like that in the original but the basic gist is the same but the problem is i wanted to play this game it's maybe it's an expectation thing but i would really like for this game to be good as i don't know a gateway game or something or like good for new players that aren't really familiar with uh board games and rule structures and stuff because even for me who's been doing this stuff for a while i was like man this is really tough to parse and then it was also very hard to find things to go back to whereas like and i hate the monday morning quarterback you know stuff i don't like to do that but the way that fantasy flight does their stuff with the general overview and then you have like the fully indexed extra book that was like i want to go look up how nadine's power works or this other power it's all every little bit of the thing is index and you can just go find that thing but your general core loop which is pretty straightforward and basic here is in that basic like eight to ten page
rule book where here you've got like this 30 plus page book and then the setup is in a different book and you know like that's i don't really like that at all but i knew going in i was like okay i know this game is going to be good it should be good because i really like the original and everything that i'm seeing is going to be better and so once i was able to kind of get through and go like okay this is actually pretty straightforward like this stuff is like getting in the way a little bit um and so actually one thing i did is i went and watched there's like two really good um how to play videos and i was like okay i am reading this right you know i'm getting this right this is as simple as i think it is and i watched uh one of those and like a little bit of the other one and if you go to boarding geek on the page for this you'll see them they're like at the top of the list and they're about half an hour long or so or even longer which you know but um if you can go through that because i really really really want to recommend this game to just about anybody including people that are new to it because once you get into the game and play that core loop of resolve a test play some ships place a treasure you know then figure out what you want to do with your ship so simple do i want to move over here don't want to move here and then fight these guys or do i want to rest and then do this and that's really really simple in terms of the mechanics of it and everything is laid out really well on the board once you've tried to figure out like whoa i should probably repair my hole you know because things have gone south okay how
does that work look down here a little chart roll boom exert whatever and then you're done so once you get into the cadence of it it really flows smoothly um so i don't want to hurt too much on the rule book but like that to me is going to be a barrier from even maybe like you know not even just new people but just general people that are like you know they got a new game and they want to play it and then like open their book and it's like oh man this is crazy and it's a struggle to get through so that's a kind of a huge negative but if you can get through that i would highly recommend the game because it's really really fun and it does the one thing that it does that it's just a i have a hard time thinking of a lot of games that do this is the narrative immersion of the game is just so hooked into that initial goal choice i can't think of a game if i sat down and like searched the board game geek database and jogged my memory for an hour i could probably come up with a game that did something similar but i love the idea of you choosing your goal playing the same game you did yesterday but with a completely different sort of agenda in mind right you have this whole like outlook of the same world the same sort of concerns and problems and stuff the game is going to throw at you but you're reacting to it in a totally different way based on i don't care about fighting so
much you know maybe i want to go incite the rebels or this game i want to just tear up the sea and just destroy every ship and sights or maybe i want to explore and find these artifacts or maybe i'm really into the technology of my ship and getting the different upgrades this time instead of doing it where like oh that'll help me so i'm going to try to squeeze that in as i'm doing this other thing now i'm really focused in and dialing in on that and so again that whole like again it's a game loop but it's also like a juggling loop so you're constantly juggling and juggling and juggling and that loops different right for each roll that you pick so you all of your decision making even though it's super simple except for the rules this decision making just morphs and and then you know ticks and tacks and goes left and right based on what you chose as your role at the beginning and that's just a really really neat thing and it also adds to the theme and the immersion of it because it's like you've set out for yourself a psychology like a map of who you are as nemo and what kind of person you are what kind of character you are what are you about like at a fundamental level like are you about just ransacking everything are you an investigative curious person that's into the exploration in the science are you out there you know for kind of just the you know the joy of it you know to explore are you trying to free the different people that have been oppressed by the imperials or you know what are you trying to do and you can sit down and
play the game not only like with those sort of strategic ideas involved but also it's like just your kind of mental space and that's a really really really neat thing that you just don't really see in a game because if you sit down to play a game let's talk about co-op games like eldritch horror like you kind of trying to do the same thing as you were the game before and i love eldritch horror or defenders of the realm like your goal is the same your basic same thing as the is this is the same and here the game doesn't really change so much but the decision making changes there's a little like right on the edge sort of like well should i do this or that it's like well this is what i'm about this game so i'm going to do this instead that's such a neat little concept that i really want everybody kind of to get a chance to try it so if you can jump over that rule book hoop and get into it that's not so complicated really at the end of the day and there's going to be a lot of replayability here like i didn't even mess with any expansion stuff or anything i was just having fun picking a roll and then going through and just doing the same thing so the nice thing with the ultimate edition is this got all this extra stuff in that i don't know about that it's probably really cool too so again if you can get over the rubric hump it's going to be fantastic i think it's a great addition to anybody's collection even if you're not into solo games like i can see why i get sort of pestered a little bit about this not being in the soul game because it's this is one of those where it's like solo only you know even though they've added extra stuff
like it's really kind of known for that so and i think that's where the game for me is really excelled it's like i said a whole marriage narrative thing um and uh so yeah i think even if you're not into solo games is my point this is a good one to get into and play it because some of these other games that aren't just solo they kind of have solo in addition to where this is kind of the reverse they're fine and they work well solo but this is the nice thing about where you kind of sit um you know pour yourself a cup of tea or coffee or whatever a little whiskey or something i don't know and sit there and just kind of be in this little space by yourself this does that like i said with all that narrative stuff and choosing your goals it gives you that kind of little cozy moment there and so i think this could fit in a collection with somebody that doesn't necessarily you know play solo games a lot but this is going to serve kind of that little niche maybe that i think everybody kind of has a little bit of that sometimes um so i would i want to really recommend it for that kind of thing but uh that rule book man so again i'm harping a little bit on there because once you get through it i think it's it's doable and if you just know as i think as long as you know it going in then i would recommend like just no going in because you don't want to open it up be disappointed but if you know beforehand give yourself that extra couple of hours um to to jump in and i would recommend
it 100 in that case so anyway that's nemo's war ultimate edition definitely take a look at it again i recommend it with just a little caveat so thanks you