Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 5:24

Hi everybody.

Hello, I'm Ryan.

I'm Bethany.

And we are Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews.

And today we'll be talking about Book Club. This is designed by Peter C. Hayward and it is published by All Play.

All right, so this game is called Book Club, but that's not just the title of the game, it's also the audience for the game. I feel like this is a game that is made for book clubs to play together. It's a cooperative party game. Basically, you were going to be naming off books that you all know. Uh and you're going to be given categories. So you can start off with a category of some this book does have this thing. And then somebody says a book name that matches that thing. But then you have another category called it doesn't have that thing. So then you're given another card that has a random category, but that makes you have to name a book that does have the first thing and doesn't have the second category. And you can try to figure out a book that does that. And you keep on adding cards to either side until you eventually have five categories out there and you're it's narrowed down the pool of of books quite a bit at this point. You have to figure out, can I figure out a book that has all of these things, but none of these things?

And you're all trying to cooperatively think of it, but you only have 5 minutes to work with. All right, there is a challenge mode where you can go up to seven cards and you get 7 minutes to work with it, but I couldn't even see how that could happen unless you were like a serious book club book club group of people. Like you know that knew all of the books. So yeah, that's it. It's categories. What does it have? What does it not have? Name the book. You have 5 minutes.

I thought this game was really cute. Um like Ryan said, it plays super fast, just the 5 minutes. I do want to say it definitely lends itself well to people who read a lot of like fiction um fiction, sci-fi, mystery. Basically just not non-fiction. Does not lend itself well to people who play non-fiction, but if you read a lot of fiction, I think it will be a little easier for you to come up with book titles that fit all of those things.

That being said, even within the world of fiction, I feel like they did a great job of picking a lot of different categories that were all over the place. Some had to do with the the literal word in the title. Some had to do with characters. Some had to do with plot. Some had to do with uh setting. They're all kind of scattered throughout liter- you know, literary everything. Uh how is it how is it a category and it sells all together?

I think that book clubs would enjoy playing this game with each other. It's almost like when you're waiting for that last person to show up, you can just whip this out and play it a couple times while you're waiting for your last person to come. I just think that works really really really well. Um I do think that this is one of those games that has a very specific audience and maybe those outside of that audience aren't going to enjoy it as much. I liked it because of that. I think uh my book club would like this because of that, but I don't necessarily think it's going to jive with everybody.

Let me expand on that a little bit. Uh I'm just going to set this down really quick. Um

Are you the everybody?

I am the everyone else in this scenario. I read I read quite a bit. I read primarily non-fiction or theological stuff. I think this might have been my most miserable game that I've ever played.

He was not having a good time.

I was.

I saw how it was interesting and I saw how within book clubs and things like that, there is enjoyment to be had here. I could not contribute anything. Anything. I was just at a loss for

game with Ryan there.

Yeah, I was at a loss for words. Every single time I played this game, I was just like Well, what else you got? Uh never heard of that one. Okay, keep going. Yep. Sounds good.

I uh I I don't recall titles well, so even things that I did have read fiction-wise uh I just couldn't come up with the title of it or at the right time, you know. It was just I just never I never had anything to add to any of our game plays. Um this was a bad time for me. This is probably my least favorite game to play ever. It's That's not to say it's a bad game.

Yeah, that's Yeah.

It's just my least favorite game to play because of my where I'm at with books.

Because of my relationship with books, I wasn't able to enjoy the relationship with this game.

Exactly. Bethany works at a library, has several book clubs that focus on fiction. She did phenomenal in every way played this. Me, I was just along for the ride.

Well, everybody, thank you so much for watching. Don't forget to subscribe so you can see our videos as they come out. Until then, you can find us in all of these places.

You guys, thanks for watching. We will see you next time.

Bye.

You guys, thanks so much for watching. Uh this game was provided to us by a publisher for an exchange for a fair and honest review.

And if you want to see more stuff, check out over here to see something we think you might like.

And over here, we think that YouTube has picked out a great video for you you're going to love. Thanks, guys. See you next time.

Bye.

Progress saved