Salton Sea - Board Game Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and this time we are talking about Sultan sea which is designed by David Bernell and published by deve games who did Supply us with this copy but the thoughts in this video are all our own sultany is the latest in the Dee series of big games that come in small boxes and it's a heavier economic game all about Mining and let's take a closer look at how it plays you begin the game with four workers and a handful of cards and throughout the game you will be placing these workers either on your board or on those cards to do things like acquiring drilling licenses drilling down into your mind extracting brine from your mind processing that brine to make lithium and energy fixing your Machinery selling various products gaining contracts and then fulfilling them for big points buying shares in various companies and gaining research which helps you do all the other stuff as you do all of this you will also be gaining and spending money but the catch is your money cards are both your funds and your actions all of these actions are also on your board but the cards offer souped up versions of those actions the game ends once you can't refill the mining licenses or two
of the corporations have closed for business then you add up points for leftover money products in your Warehouse shares you gained research cards and objectives and then the most efficient producer of energy is named so that's how it plays and I think the most interesting thing is that your actions are tied to your money and I hadn't seen that before so it is a really difficult decision and anytime you have to spend money about what cards you're going to spend because then you won't have those stronger actions available you always have the base game actions on your board but their cards are always going to be better yeah it really is interesting having those because you want to keep those actions especially when you have the three and the $ five cards those actions are terrific but $3 or $5 is a fortune in this game because money is super tight it's tight in a good way but it's very very very tight and every time you spend a dollar you're losing an action and you don't get change as well so if you spend a three like if you need to pay a dollar and you don't have any dollars and all you've got is a three oh boy that is that is tough and if it's not in the bank as well if it's not not really a bank but the card row if there's no dollars there tough you just can't take a dollar right now and that whole system is super super interesting and also just what actions are available because you may not have what you want available for some time too which can make it tricky to only do the single action and you mentioned how tight this
game is it is incredibly tight and the first time we played it I did not like it I thought I don't want to play this again because it just felt so challenging everything felt so difficult but the more we played it the more like I just realized how to do things and it wasn't so frustrating I think by game three I was like oh it's a really good game yeah every play has been so much more interesting which I think says a lot about this game because if we reviewed this after that first play this would be we would be singing a very different tune because we were both like I don't even know if I want to review this I don't know if I like this game this is so hard and then I played it against solo because I thought maybe it's a bit better solo let me tell you the solo bot so hard it is oh my goodness it's such a challenge but that made me think oh I did a lot better this time than that first time and then I talked you into playing it again and was just like you know what I think we need to sell more stuff than we did at first I think I think the economy Works different than we thought it did in our heads and as we've done that as we've kind of started to like see those different rootes to how to get to everything it's just gotten so much more interesting every single game and this last game that we played I was like I think I really really like this now and but but you got to know it's going to you're going to go on that Journey it's going to take you
you know three games four games maybe two games if you're a lot smarter than us I don't know but it's gonna take you a few games to get your head around this system and those first games are going to be a bit painful but it's amazing how much they crammed into such a small size box because it is a really heavy game it's almost lerta style in terms of like the interconnectedness of everything but just with a smaller game box and a more kind of slightly approachable system I would say and a more approachable price tag too I'm just G to come out say we don't usually talk about prices of games but my goodness these di games they're like 25 pounds for so much game in such a tiny box and you know I think that's worth talking about because that makes a big difference especially for this sort of game too and I I do think the wrong kind of person could pick this up like if you're a new gamer and you were to buy this you would be like oh my goodness this is this is so hard cuz it is it's so hard but boy if you're looking for like a heavy a really intricate heavy system the the dollar for brain cell ratio of this game is pretty impressive and I think it is a little bit um outside of people's expectations because of red Cathedral and White Castle which I would say are quite a bit lighter especially they're still thinky games but I feel like you it still feels pretty rewarding on your first game even though for both of those you get better the more games you play this one is not rewarding your first
game so if you're coming in having played either one of those you would probably have a very different expectation so I think it is resetting those expectations right and let let's jump into some of the some of the stuff in this as well because I think we've already spoiled our final thoughts for this but you know we'll come back to that again but uh let's let's talk a little bit about the components and the components are a mixed bag so there's some stuff I love the meeples are terrific but boy those player boards and just kind of the overall whiteness of it this has got a little bit of the knock that I had on beyond the Sun and I think everyone had I'm not alone in this everyone had on beyond the sun where it almost looks like a prototype it's just so white but not quite in a Sleek way and a little bit of a plain way and I will say that is the case for some of the components here yeah and I think again this is growing on me a bit cuz when we unpacked it it was it did feel very very white but even our last game too we're like oh there's actually a lot more like color here it's subtle colors but it is color and I do like that the wooden pieces fit so nicely like you know when you're setting up is incredibly easy because everything has the perfect outline to put out all of the pieces and all the pieces are nice big chunky pieces other than your like little score marker which is just little oh yeah the score marker needs to be bigger it's way too small so I would say the overall look is is on the planer side of things but I would say the iconography and everything in general
super solid yeah and that is really important because also you're putting your workers on your cards and I found it a little bit counterintuitive that it's not just the money cards either because you're also putting them sometimes for like the research cards and sometimes well you have to put them on for the contracts and they did a really good job of having that really clear worker Space Border that makes it clear where your workers can go yeah it's just really simple and nice and just a little kind of what do you call that hatched hatched I just learned this word a little hatched line I don't know if that's a UK thing uh I would have called it diagonal now I've learned hatched is The Classy way of saying it uh other stuff in here I think we should talk about the player count because this is going to be a little bit of a negative for some folks as well because I think this is a two-player game I think it is it's so crunchy it's so a prone because you're getting rid of those work like every time you got to spend money you got to think which of these cards can I get rid of and you got to be kind of thinking three or four actions ahead thinking I'm going to need this and then I'm going to need that money to go here but then I'm going to get this money so maybe I can get that action back and all this stuff and because of that it's just it's very very like even if you're not AP you're AP in this game so there's not too much waiting with two but three or four this could take a while yeah especially because you you are sharing the card market and things so you can't necessarily plan out your turn on other
people's turn if they took the card that you were going to take for example uh your actions are just on your own own cards and Boards so you generally can probably be self-sufficient in what you're doing but it's so tied into like the next thing of like oh I was going to grab that exact drill card and now that's gone and I can't afford the next one so there goes that option and having to rethink things and so with more players you don't even get the benefit of the cards refreshing more you you start with like an extra card maybe in the row but for the money cards once those ones are taken they don't refresh so it's not an issue of a more refreshing Market at higher player accounts yeah it just goes away and those cards even in a two-player game you got four cards in a two-player game and I think it's five cards in a three-player game six in a four player game but in a two-player game we those one the one cards those go quick and even sometimes the contracts like will run out of stuff which is good like this is not a complaint but yeah it's it's just it's gon to run so fast um also there is the solo mode which I mentioned and it it works well like it's it's a deck of cards that you play out and that decides what the bot is going to do and it's a fairly simple again it is it is kind of thinking you got to kind of look through each of the actions once you've done them each once or twice you're going to know how that works and actually I think the way to learn it is just read the action as you come to it instead of trying to memorize the whole
thing at once so it works well and it's an interesting opponent but it is hard like everything in this game is very hard so you're gonna have to be on your absolute best to beat this like it is if you look at BGG you're G to get a sense from people's comments of how difficult this is but I still thought it was an interesting challenge I came kind of close but everything came together for me but boy you got to really on it if you're going to beat the well I think that ties into just replayability in general for this game is because it is so challenging that lends itself to replayability you're going to need a handful of games before you even like come to grips with it let alone like really start exploring all the various different strategies too and I think that is interesting because it plays a little bit like viticulture in that there's a path that you need to do because you need to drill then you need to extract then you need to convert you need to get contracts but there is so many different levers that you can still introduce in that because there's also the research cards that are going to change how things are going to go you might not do as many contracts and sell things to get a lot of money um we haven't really done much of the whole like stock market but that could be another Avenue too yeah the stock market it doesn't feel like it's the way to get points which is why we haven't done it a lot yet but it it could be and it is way to get a lot of bonuses too and so that is one of those ways when you're like oh I don't know how I'm ever going to do this and then you look at that and think
oh I could spend like two bucks move this little stock market token up once I'm going to get that token that token is going to give me this other action I've been trying to do for free and then you're off to the races so it is there are these different paths that you find and through those research cards as well and you find more of those pads every time that you play I don't know if we're going to play like our sixth oreven game and we're going to kind of hit that roof and be like okay we found all the paths we're good at this now and I think even if you reach the point that you're kind of as good as you can be it's still an interesting puzzle and efficiency to try and make it work with the cards that are presented because the cards are always going to come out in a different order too and I think that's everything that we wanted to cover so in terms of our final thoughts who do you think this game is for yeah I think this is definitely for for gamers who've got quite a few games under your belt that you want to have that like a heavy economic it's going to be it's dry it's hard so know those things there's a bunch of things to remember there's a hard learning curve there's all of these things that could definitely be bumps for a lot of Gamers if you're okay with all of that stuff though I think there's such an interesting satisfying puzzle in here I will say as well one thing we didn't point out is that there's very low interaction in this at least direct interaction so there's interaction through the cards there's some interaction through the stock market As you move those up but there's not going to be a lot of like take that back and forth directly um in case you wanted
that I don't think you would want that in this game it would make it impossible I think you'll be very happy that that's not here but if that's what you like it's not here yeah and I would say as well is because I first saw it and I really saw the stock market thing in the middle and thought it was really going to be more of like a market manipulation and it is a little bit because as you sell things and the price goes up people are going to be um influenced by the shares that they buy but that is I would say really minor part so if you are really interested in that aspect of the game that isn't the Forefront of it it's more of a a separate one and like say I said it before but I'll say it here in final thoughts if you have played red Cathedral and you have played White Castle or one or the other and you thought I love these games this is a step up so this is a lot harder than either of those so do change your expectations but it's it's it's a it's challenging in a good way it's a game that has really grown a lot on both of us it's a game that offers a lot of different paths and it's it's got a lot of room to grow in it so there's a lot of positives in there but this is it's going to be for a specific kind of people for sure and that is it that is Sultan see the latest in dev's terrific sized box this for my money this is the best Siz box in board games I I will buy them just because they're this size and
we can fit so many more in our shelves I love it thank you so much for watching please let us know in the comments if you've played salt and SE and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game what