Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 13:25

Hey readers, this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire. And today I want to talk about a book I just finished, which is Katabysus by RF Kuang. Uh I immediately bought and read this because I've read all of RF Kuang's novels uh because I think they're great. I think she's a great author uh and I really enjoy her work. So there's a lot to talk about in Katavis. Um but uh I want to start with just this book is so pretty. Uh it's got a nice velvety touch to the desk cover which I really appreciate. Um the sprayed edges are in fact beautiful. Well, I admit I'm a sucker for these things. Uh, but I think the best thing about the book print quality is actually that it lies flat when you open it. So, like you can eat a snack and just have the book open and not have to hold it. Um, fantastic page drape. I don't even know if there's a real word for that, but the book is a pleasure to read as a physical object. And frankly, I appreciated that.

Uh, so um there's a lot to talk about when we talk about Katabysis. I'm going to start with like the discourse about it and just kind of get that out of the way. Um, so the first thing is people I guess on Tik Tok and YouTube have been talking about whether this book is pretentious. It reads like a textbook and like there have been people who have been talking about whether maybe you need to do pre-ereading before reading the book. Um, I want to assure you this is not the case. This is not a novel you need to do prep for. You ain't reading Ulisses here. It's just a novel and you're going to have fun reading it. Um, no matter how much of the background information you go in knowing, like if you know what Dante is and that people have like written stories about going to hell, you're gonna be fine. Uh, and so maybe my perspective on that is somewhat different. Uh, because I'm post I actually also got my PhD from Yale. Um, which is where Aquang is going now. But no, seriously, it's just a novel. You're going to be fine. Um, if anything, I actually thought that the kind of like hell narratives and maps and, you know, kind of academic aspects of the book, uh, were not a full match with the story itself. Uh, which is really just a basic story about two people uh, falling in love and they also have a really mean teacher uh, whose relationships with them make them jealous and make it hard for them to connect. And I think that anybody could understand that story. I think that you'll be fine and that if that sounds like the kind of story for you, you're gonna have fun. That said, in a way, I almost wanted all of like

the scholarly references about death and like descent into hell and stuff to mean more than they ultimately did in the context of the narrative. Um, I feel like the story itself was pretty trit and could have been written without a lot of that. And so, what was it for? That said, like the magic system was super cool. I like the idea of paradoxes. Uh, I don't think it was quite as good as Babel where I really enjoyed like the translation magic and like the idea of gaps between meaning in one language and meaning in another. Um, but Katabus has had like a lot of really cool aspects. It was just that it was a good book and I think that Babel was great. Uh, I wonder if what was going on there actually was that because Babel is set in academia, but it's also like about I guess more social theory in translation, whereas this one is kind of going for academia, but like philosophy connections. I wonder if the idea of social theory and language like fit RF Kong's themes better than the subject matter of this book happens to. Um, I would have to think more about that to be sure because I did just finish it, but that may be part of what's going on here. I thought that um her points about colonialism and academia and privilege and distance between languages and you know those different things like really came across in Babel in this really rich way that I thought was super exciting.

Whereas in Kabosis I felt like I could have just read the same story without all of the academic stuff like it wasn't fully integrated for me somehow. Uh, that said, there's a lot of interesting stuff in there and I do think that you will enjoy the narrative a lot. The other thing I thought was kind of interesting is it I I really enjoy reading sort of dark academia themed things. Um, but it's because I like lived dark academia and I'm actually in kind of a sensitive moment right now because I just finished writing like a little inmemoriam piece for my own um, graduate adviser with whom I had a somewhat troubled but ultimately loving relationship. Um, so I know exactly what it's like to have a mean adviser who plays favorites. Uh, because I did. I know what it's like to really love somebody anyway because I did and I do. Uh, and so it was really interesting to see Alice and Peter's relationships with their adviser play out in the book. And it really made me think because I think there's some things that Arf Kuang like really nails and there were some things that didn't really match like my understanding of of academia and how one navigates that situation. Um so first the the very good I think that RF Kong is really really good expressing I guess power relationships. She's good at showing the gap in authority and prestige between one person and another and then getting in there and kind of exploring what that means in terms of how they're going to relate to each other. Um, and so I think

that that is on full display in Kabosis is very interesting and I think that she does a good job I guess of trying to present a a real answer to the question of like why do we stay in situations where we're not being treated very well? Well, how do you justify that to yourself? Because there's the premise of like, my adviser died, but I really want a wreck letter, so I'm gonna give up half my remaining years of life to go to hell and get him. Like, on the surface of it, that is [ __ ] crazy. And like, I mean, I I was never at this level of crazy, right? But I find it relatable in the sense that there were certainly times when I was in my graduate program where I was suffering or extremely stressed and I told myself, "This is going to be worth it." And even though this person was kind of mean to you today or even though you're had you had another fight today about your dissertation perspectus, it's got to be worth it in in the end. Um, you know, you want once you get far enough into a program especially to finish that degree to get through that dissertation and you want to do it with the fancy adviser that people respect because he's a respected person in the field. like all of those instincts and feelings are very very real and because the grad school teacher student relationship is so personal um it can be really really intense. So like, you know, I was a high school teacher for 10 years. It's very different then cuz it's just you and then like large batches of 35 kids who come through your room multiple times a day. And so you're

working closely with a lot of people instead of working very quietly with a very few. And there's also not the same kind of power relationship. Like your adviser really has a lot of say in the future of your career and you have a lot of time to focus on each other because there just aren't that many of you. Um, and so that relationship is like very intimate, but it's also a professional relationship and it is weird. Um, and it is like having a parent who is also your boss. And it is like having a hero whose weaknesses you start to see the longer you go on. Uh, because you become better at what you do and you can see more of what might be wrong, but by then it's like too late and you need to finish your degree. And so like I feel like Arf Kong is really good at capturing a lot of that. Um I'm also I hope that one day she like gives a much more personal interview about how all this is for her because I I'm really curious about what it's like for her to be a student. And I really would like to know what it's like for her professors to teach her. But of course professionally they will keep their mouths shut because they shouldn't say anything. It's her education. Um, but you know, she really enjoys being in the student posture and she enjoys being taught, but I want to know what her student experience is like because she could at her current level of success just walk away and be fine at any time.

Um, when I was a grad student, I was living on air and I had nothing and I it was unimaginable to just walk away. I didn't have [ __ ] you money. Um, and it was fine. Like the other thing is that you should know as I'm saying all these things is like probably there's some trauma in there but I really loved my graduate education. I would do it again in a heartbeat. I wouldn't trade it for anything. Like the experience was utterly worth it. So when I talk about things like suffering and difficulty with meeting adviserss like I am the person who came out the other side and will say it's worth it. Um but I also wasn't going to hell for nobody. Uh but for RF Kuang, like will she ever have an experience where somebody is treating her this way? One, I [ __ ] hope not. Uh but two, like is that even possible for somebody in her current situation? But I would just really like to hear what she's drawing on when she presents these relationships because I feel like it must have happened if this is personal experience she's drawing on earlier in her career.

um rather than obviously in grad school now where she probably is the one with the power in the room between her and an adviser um even if the adviser is the one who's nominally in charge. Uh the other thing I'm sad not to see actually in Kabosis and I just want to kind of point this out is that the best part of grad school is actually the other students and in a lot of dark academia work and Katabysis is actually no different. Um, I actually liked this about Babel, uh, was that students really tend to band together in the face of difficult professors, uh, and just in the face of the challenges of grad school anyway. Even if you're in the most like loving, wholesome environment possible, um, you're going to make friends. And so Alice's isolation made me feel really sad because I feel like my favorite parts of grad school were actually my moments with the other students in my cohort. And that closeness is something that persists late late late late into your life. And this is true even when your professor is playing favorites. So um you know just for wider context my adviser and I made amends with each other in the end. Um he gave me the closest thing he could give to an apology. I accepted it and you know we really did have like a wonderful intellectual relationship. Some of the best conversations of my life were with this man. But he did play favorites and he did prefer male students. And so I had to go through experiences where he favored um male students over me in

professionally sensitive contexts that were not fun. And so I have been through literally that. However, those students, even though we were kind of incompetitive and uncomfortable situations, were still my friends and we still worked closely together. And these are still people that I text and I'm happy to hear from and I check in with because that cohort bond is so strong because you have to be in the trench with somebody. Um, and usually you find that your fellow students are the people to be in it with. And so I would have liked to see a little bit more of that real tension, not just like a romance or like um, you know, somebody who kind of is in your life and then gone like kind of things that show up in Katabasis. I would have liked to see like more of that real cohort action. Um, the other students are kind of ghosts in Alice's story. And I guess that's realistic for some grad students, but man, what a shame because the opportunity to explore like those tensions as the favoritism is happening or like as like shitty things are happening and you talk to somebody about it, like that's all very very real as a part of the PhD experience. And I would have liked to see more of that in ketosis. like something felt hollow about the narrative to me because I didn't think that the studentto student relationships were quite on.

But of course, everybody's experience is different. Anyway, that's enough musing for me. I just kind of wanted to like talk about Katabysis because everybody is, I guess, uh, and I have my own kind of weird perspective on it. But overall, it's a very enjoyable book. It is really not that crazy. It's very accessible. You're going to be fine. Uh, but I think almost the trade-off for that is it's like got this kind of intimidating vibe to some people, but it's really just a normal story, and I almost would have liked to see it be pushed in like a more literary direction plot-wise. So, uh, thank you so much for watching. Um, I of course will be looking forward to the next RF Kuang project. She has something new coming up, um, in I think another year. So, we'll be back again hopefully in a while for some more RF Kuang. Uh until then, uh hopefully we'll talk about some books more soon. Thank you so much for watching and happy reading everybody.

Progress saved