Animals of Baker Street Review - a narrative adventure game for children.
Transcript
I received a review copy of animals of Baker Street from the distributor so thanks to coiled spring solve Mysteries by visiting locations in the buildings streets and Gardens of Baker Street use specific characters in specific locations to take advantage of their natural abilities and unlock new story elements solve seven unique cases finding lost items missing creatures and uncovering Mysteries a Sherlock Holmes storybook with cute anthropomorphic animals Center Stage an immersive interactive Choose Your Own Adventure in the form of a Cooperative narrative board game for families that's the hook I'm Adam Porter and design games and I review them on this channel with a focus on product design if you like what I do please subscribe comment and share the video animals of Baker Street is a late 2022 release from yellow the game brings together game designer Dave Neal children's author Clementine Beauvais and prolific board game artist baboon and frankly the three creators deserve equal credit because this product is truly an exceptional collaboration with the illustrations story elements and game mechanisms beautifully interwoven to create an immersive Little World baboon is known as the illustrator of dice forged deep blue and Ishtar Clementine bovet is an award-winning author of many books in English and French Dave Neal is one of the UK's leading game designers having produced
cases for Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective series The Sherlock themed Adventures for the unlock series and as co-designer of ravensberger's hit series of narrative games Echoes now I've run into Dave many times over the years at various game conventions and it's been a pleasure watching him carve out a niche as the industry's go-to Sherlock Holmes expert and a designer with a particular talent for creating narrative adventures in animals of Baker Street a group of players take control of a group of animals a curious Mouse who's great at finding stuff a swift agile blue tit a persuasive Charming frog and a slightly Psychopathic tarantula who reportedly arrived in Baker Street in a crate of bananas the group selects their mission though generally these are played through in order and then reads the introductory passage from the case book there are no real turns in the game the group simply decides which location to visit and reads the corresponding card they can then choose to utilize characters items and information in that location by combining cards and looking to see how the icons line up to determine whether new information is revealed however players need to take care because successful actions frequently cost the group time and there's only so many clock tokens to discard for the mission ends in failure as always we'll start with onboarding and this product is a master class the Box looks like a book pointing you to the narrative Delights within the cover art is glorious with
Sherlock's Canine Companion Toby up front and center beautifully captured and a fine example of the quality of illustration you're going to find on cards and components within Toby's dear stalker hat is an unmistakable reference to Sherlock Holmes and the Baker Street setting hammers this home I often state that a box cover should tell you what you're going to be doing in a game and how you're going to feel the box cover to animals at Baker Street tells you everything you need to know it's a substantial box so I was expecting a degree of complexity but I was delighted to read that you can learn as you play the first mission is a tutorial teaching you the tiny number of rules in the game and introducing them in sequence but the tutorial isn't tedious or mechanical the writing is allowed to shine from the very first turns and it's the writing which really hooked to me these characters just leap off the page they're distinct and quirky and very funny this is one of very few games that I've played which genuinely made me laugh out loud and not once but frequently the tarantula's dark view of the world in particular is always entertaining but the other player characters are endearing too and there are a host of non-player characters with their own memorable personalities as well I rate games using my own ladder engagement system a game is scored between zero and three and five different categories and each point scored climbs the game one rung up the ladder an overall score of 10 or above tops the ladder and indicates a real favorite with me animals of Baker Street is deeply immersive the theme is the
game you decide what action you think is going to help you which item or character to use in any given situation and you try it out learning instantly of the consequences the stories are not sanitized for young audiences they respect the resilience of young and so they never patronize as such there's an element of Parental Guidance required here these lovely characters will face significant Peril but it's never gratuitous or age inappropriate just a little grittier than you might be expecting from such a cutesy exterior the third mission for example has our detectives unpicking the circumstances around a poisoned fiancee along the way we discover lots of practical uses for arsenic and the intricacies of the relationships at Play for player interaction I'm torn on how to score the game it is essentially a solitaire exercise you could very easily play through these missions alone none of your actions rely on interaction between players but there's so much joy to be had working through this stuff together with other people discussing decisions and discovering the story together mechanically animals of Baker Street should score a zero for Meaningful player interaction but I'm awarding it one point because the experience is lifted when played collaboratively Challenge and stress is low there's some tension in that you only have a certain number of time tokens available for any given Mission so you're constantly aware that you can't waste time for fear of failing a mission but it doesn't really feel stressful because you can always play
again to reveal the missing story elements the game is relatively easy as you'd expect for a game aimed at families and the clues guide you through the narrative feedback is very high almost every action you take is going to reveal new information some useful some simply entertaining but you're rewarded or punished for your decisions with immediate effect the lack of player interaction is counted by a high degree of interaction with the game system itself of course a game like this could be far more complex and detailed with a digital implementation to handle all the bookkeeping but there's something so charming and wholesome about sitting at a table reading physical components to each other and discussing dilemmas before deciding on a path of action for Meaningful decisions again I'm struggling to score perhaps this is indicative of the product not really being a game in the sense of a competitive strategic puzzle that we win or lose this feels far closer to a Choose Your Own Adventure novel I can't honestly say that the decisions feel meaningful in that the game is largely on Rails the story is pre-written and you may discover story elements in a slightly different order depending on your in-game choices but those story elements were always going to be revealed one way or another nonetheless something satisfying about following a hunch I I think the squirrel had something to do with it let's interrogate him and then discovering that your intuition was spot on especially when your teammates were quite sure that you were barking up the wrong tree so I'm scoring it at one the
overall score of nine is great it doesn't quite top the ladder and I'm an amazed the ladder system is calibrated for board games this product is right on the borderline of being something else it's hugely engaging when taken for what it is a group storytelling activity but it's going to totally flop with a gamer who's focused on strategizing and Min maxing victory points moving on to my product design checklist is the game Innovative well not hugely no and I think this will impact on this commercial success there have been many of these narrative Adventures published over recent years and the novelty has worn off somewhat this is by some distance the best example I've experienced in a crowded market and the elements which lift it are not mechanical the cosmos Adventure game series stands out as being particularly clever in the manner in which you combine items and locations to discover new content and the Carter Ventura Series has a greater sense of Exploration with a much more epic scope as new cards are revealed to build a vast landscape but but neither can match the wit and warmth of the storytelling in animals of Baker Street so is there a need for a product like this well yeah I think there's space for this game henna Penny they're generally One-Shot Adventures once completed a player is going to look for another similar product because replayability is low or non-existent the market is crowded but not so much for children and this product serves as a fantastic Junior
companion product for the extremely popular Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective will the Game grow with its user well this is where narrative games struggle once you've played all the missions you're unlikely to return but is that true of kids I'm not so sure the writing and illustrations here are strong enough that I can see kids returning to the game in the same manner that they would a favorite book or movie where adults find repetition tedious children find comfort in familiarity there are only seven missions in the box but they increase in duration and complexity as you progress and later cases have pleasing references to earlier stories I guess the release of expansions would be entirely dependent on the commercial performance of the base product but they'd certainly be welcomed on my idea execution Matrix the strongest products sit in the orange red section of the grid but this requires an out Landing concept brilliantly executed by designer and publisher alike animals of Baker Street is a good commercial idea but perhaps not exceptional it's the execution which makes this product Stand Out by designer illustrator writer and publisher the game deserves to be a tremendous success if you enjoyed the review and you'd like to find out about another great Cooperative game for families follow the link