How Adam Would Book... Eddie Guerrero's WWE Championship Run
Transcript
Hello, I'm Adam, your head of truth, fair play, and purchasing things for money at Blonko Incorporated having no more than three amigos since 2015. And welcome to how Adam would book, where I craft alternate wrestling realities and challenge promotions to do them better because soy unlisteo.
Can I pull that off? This time around, I have been commissioned by your essay and mine chop to rebook the WWE Championship reign of the late great Eddie Guerrero, one of the most beloved figures in wrestling history. No pressure then. Before we start, first things first, here is a Photoshop of what Freddy Guerrero would look like. Here's her with the European Championship. Here's her in a low rider. Here's her shouting, "Where the [ __ ] is Vicky?" at the top of a ladder. This is all very important content. With that being said, before we jump into the booking, I'm going to do a rundown of Eddie's time in WWE. And you know what feels truly insane about all of this? Eddie Guerrero joined World Wrestling Entertainment alongside the rest of the Radicals in January 2000, and he died on November 13th, 2005.
Eddie was in WWE for less than six years, and we're still talking about him. The Miz has been in WWE for 20 years. None of this makes any sense. In the span of just over five years, just over half a decade, he went from heel henchman to comedy mid-carder to fired to rehired to member of the SmackDown six to world champion to dearly departed legend. Obviously, his overall career was a lot longer. His career encompasses runs in AAA, New Japan, ECW, WCW. The guy packed a lot of professional wrestling into one life. To give you some idea of how much Eddie had lived, this photo was taken in 2004. In this photo, Eddie was 36. That is 2 years younger than I currently am. This is a man who has lived. This is a man who owns 250 board games and has a halfway decent skin care routine. But for the sake of looking at him through the lens of being WWE Champion, I'm not going to cover his entire life. I'm just going to look at his WWE career. On January 31st, 2000, on Monday Night Raw, the camera panned to reveal four men sitting in the front row of the crowd.
Dean Malenko, Perry Saturn, Chris Benoit, and Eddie Guerrero. A group of lads who were already well known in WCW. Three of the four had already formed a group called The Revolution with Shane Douglas 6 months earlier, but Eddie wasn't actually part of that group. He was in The Filthy Animals, but when Dean, Perry, and Chris all requested their releases from WCW for one reason or another, because he was close friends with them all, Eddie jumped as well. To give you an idea of just how much of a sinking ship WCW was at the time, Chris Benoit, they made him champion the day before he left. They were like, "Please, Chris, stay." And he was like, "No." And they were like, "We'll make you the champion." And he was like, "Aw, no." Things started bad for the group in WWE as they almost always did for anyone who crossed over from WCW to the WWF. They all lost matches to earn spots on the roster before just being given jobs by Triple H. They were dubbed The Radicals, spelled Reforticals, which sounds like the nickname that Nigel Farage would give his bollocks. And he would. With Eddie breaking his elbow almost immediately and almost immediately being relegated to the group's manager. They lost an Intergender 6-Man Tag at WrestleMania 2000 before things almost immediately turned around for Eddie Guerrero in particular when he won the European title on Raw after Mania with the help of Mamacita. The comedy pairing of Eddie and Chyna got Eddie over like Rover after a few short months causing the Radicalz to briefly break up for him to turn face before breaking poor
China's heart after showering with two of the Godfather's hoes. Boo this man. With Eddie back to his healing ways and cut adrift from China the Radicalz reformed the cause with Eddie winning the European title again at WrestleMania X-Seven before being sent to rehab a month later then being released in November after a DUI. Most people will probably gloss over this particular period in Eddie's life but it's worth mentioning because well first of all no fair appraisal of Eddie Guerrero exists without recognizing that he had his demons. I mean WWE actually made it a part of the storyline when he would eventually win the WWE Championship. But also in this brief time away from WWE he did some really interesting and fascinating things. First of all he wrestled CM Punk in IWA Mid-South. Imagine running that feud in modern WWE.
Hey SA have a tequila. Loosen up. No. And back in February 2002 Eddie also wrestled in the very first Ring of Honor show. He took on Super Crazy at The Era of Honor Begins a show main evented by Low Ki versus Christopher Daniels versus Bryan Danielson and that's [ __ ] cool. Anyway Eddie returned to WWE in April 2002 before moving to SmackDown shortly before SummerSlam and becoming part of the fabled SmackDown Six alongside Edge, Rey Mysterio, Chris Benoit, Kurt Angle and Chavo Guerrero. Five top lads and Chavo who'd wrestle in various combinations throughout the rest of 2002 and make everyone very pleased indeed. During this time Los Guerreros debuted their absolutely mint theme song Viva La Raza. Viva La Raza da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da da burrito with laxative.
Just one of the many ways Big Show would mortgage his dignity in the Ruthless Aggression Era. Do you remember that time when Kurt Angle [ __ ] trunked him before shaving his head? Eddie killed Chavo with a 2004 Royal Rumble. Then he began his road to No Way Out 2004, a pay-per-view where Eddie Guerrero would via cheating and Goldberg pin Brock Lesnar to become WWE Champion. And everyone was so happy. Look at all these happy people because Eddie had gotten himself well and truly over with a combination of reliable in-ring excellence, joyful comedy cheating spots, and a mischievous uncle who bought you your first beer character work. In a period of transition for WWE when The Rock had gone, Stone Cold had gone, and now Brock Lesnar was on his way out the door, he helped fill the gap at the top of the card with his mid-card genius. It's like Bret Hart all over again. Eddie successfully defended his WWE title against Kurt Angle at WrestleMania 20, the same night Chris Benoit won the World Heavyweight Championship, and the two best friends who once wrestled each other as Wild Pegasus and Black Tiger, who wrestled each other in Japan, Philly, and Atlanta, who entered the company together, who plowed their way up through the mid-card together, they embraced each other with their world titles as confetti rained over the two best workers to ever do it. And a picture that at the time was simple and triumphant, and now looking back is complicated and deeply somber. The SmackDown after WrestleMania as Eddie wrestled Booker T in the main event, a newly besuited
Bradshaw would interfere and attack Latino Heat. In one of the most unexpected glow-ups in wrestling history, Bradshaw, the man who looked, smelled, and wrestled like a spittoon, became pampered stonk peddler JBL. And after a bloody match at Judgment Day that saw Eddie do one of the damndest blade jobs of all time, the two faced off one more time at The Great American Bash 2004. Handily, one of the worst [ __ ] pay-per-views WWE have ever produced. Not only is it a show main evented by The Undertaker versus The Dudley Boyz and Paul Bearer being drowned in cement live on TV, but the penultimate match of that show saw Eddie Guerrero lose the WWE title to JBL in a Texas Bull Rope match that saw Eddie's initial win reversed and JBL win the belts on a [ __ ] technicality. Eddie would never again win world championship gold pivoting into a feud with Kurt Angle at SummerSlam which he would lose.
Team Eddie did beat Team Angle at Survivor Series before Eddie and Rey Mysterio began a months-long saga that would see them win tag team gold, wrestle each other at WrestleMania, see Eddie turn heel, reveal he was Dominick Mysterio's father, and even though that's still kayfabe, my god, he does look like a young Eddie, doesn't he? Then the two men wrestled a ladder match to see who got to take the little boy home, and I unapologetically love that match. A few months later after SummerSlam 2005, Eddie Guerrero would pass away in his hotel room from acute heart failure at the age of 38, which is literally the age I am now, which is unbelievable. It's been disputed, but someone creative, mostly Stephanie McMahon, claimed that Eddie was on the cusp of being booked to win his second world title from Bautista in November 2005, but with his death, we're never going to know that. What we do know is that the way he won his first and only WWE title was great. The way he retained it at WrestleMania was great, but as for how it all ended, the man deserves so much more.
And I can do it better. Also, if you want to commission booking like this one, you can over at patreon.com/blomka. We have absolutely [ __ ] tons of patron exclusive fantasy bookings over there. There's just bloody loads of them, and we also have exclusive watch-alongs, all the pay-per-view coverage, exclusive lists. There's so much stuff over on the patron. Give it a watch. Anyway, on with the booking. So, even though this feels like it should be a huge character-encompassing single storyline, you know, cuz it's Eddie. It's actually a pretty simple case of just booking a decent title reign for someone who is A, already over, and B, really good at professional wrestling. That is the easiest task in the world. When you have a world champion who's largely immobile like a Kevin Nash or a, let's be honest, JBL, that's when you have to throw character and storyline bells and whistles all over. Like that time that JBL pretended to be high and stripped down to his underwear to wrestle an inflatable dinosaur in Japan so that he could get the drop on the Big Show, and that's an entirely accurate sentence. He's He's calling him Godzilla and asking him if he eats pizza. Point is, booking some world title defenses for Eddie Guerrero and having them be not [ __ ] that doesn't feel like it requires a PhD. In this case, PhD stands for pretty huge
dog. Look. Do you want to do the Eddie Guerrero thing? Viva la raza. That's cultural appropriation, Freddy. Come on. Nor do I actually mind him being dethroned by JBL. If I'm honest, my first thought for this story was that we just keep the belt on Eddie until WrestleMania 21. You can turn him heel, probably against someone like Undertaker to keep the title reign fresh for over a year, and this way, the Mania match will be Cena winning his first title from heel Eddie Guerrero. And I thought, "Oh, that'd be good rather than JBL versus Cena, which was, you know, in itself JBL, but in this case JBL stands for just bum lumps. But I ultimately went away from that plan for two reasons.
One, I don't think people actually want to boo Eddie this soon into his title reign. Like literally the crowd can't stay mad at Eddie for too long. And two, I actually think the SmackDown roster is better for having world champion JBL at some point. He's a good, interesting, entertaining character. And I just don't think you need nine full months of him and his crap world title matches. And all of them were. I also want to be a little bit more careful with it and feel like I'm keeping most of the narrative journey that Eddie and Rey went on in 2005. I know people make fun of the concept of a custody of a child ladder match as an example of the grand base stupidity of wrestling, but that's actually one of the reasons why I [ __ ] adore wrestling. It is fun to make fun, but I also love that kind of silly bollocks. And I think the eventual feud they had was great, so I don't want to tinker with it too much. So we keep all the stuff from the build to No Way Out all the way to the Kurt Angle match at WrestleMania. The build framed Eddie as the hopeless underdog, someone whose demons would prevent him from ever winning the big one. And then he does win. He wins by cheating. Then he outsmarts Kurt Angle and gets his moment of celebration. The real question for this booking is then what? What I like to do is have with Kurt continue into some big stipulation match at Judgment Day, but Angle's neck was [ __ ] And I know that because there's actually a simple trick to remembering it. If the year has a zero in it, then Kurt Angle's neck is [ __ ] But he was taking time
off to rehab at this period of time. He was becoming sort of like the general manager guy. So instead, let's pivot first of all to Eddie Guerrero versus Triple H. Fun fact, in the 2004 draft SmackDown had just done the very funny and very stupid thing where Kurt Angle as acting general manager had Triple H on SmackDown, but ended up swapping him back to Raw in exchange for I'm not making it up Booker T and the Dudley Boyz. So instead, you just keep Triple H on SmackDown at least for a month or two. If he stays on Raw, he's just going to not beat Chris Benoit anyway, so instead have Chris Benoit have a singles match with Shawn Michaels at Backlash. Even more fun cuz it's a Canadian versus Mr. Montreal Screwjob in said Canadian's hometown. And that then leaves Triple H versus Eddie Guerrero at Judgment Day.
It's a really fun match up. Trips taking on the other guy who celebrated in the main event of WrestleMania 20. Use another main event heel to make Eddie look great. And it's also unpredictable cuz you can never seriously predict against Triple H winning a [ __ ] world title in the ruthless aggression era even if he's doing the unthinkable and working Tuesdays. So Triple H strolls into SmackDown all entitled. the top guy on Raw for the past 2 years has that same entitlement especially with Eddie Guerrero because you know, we're only 1 year on from the people like you don't win world titles feud that he had with Booker T. What you mean people like you Triple H? Oh, tag team guys? WCW guys? Do you mean any other kind of guys?
Yes. So you have that still fresh in people's minds. Also, he can reference the fact that at least in kayfabe Eddie wouldn't have a job if it wasn't for Triple H. Have Ric Flair walk down to the ring with Trips say that a world champion that needs to cheat to win is a disgrace. Triple H goads Eddie to put the title on the line on SmackDown. He agrees, but he ends up handcuffing Triple H to the ringside area and wins by count out. Kurt Angle, because he hates Eddie so much, then makes the match a Judgment Day, Triple H versus Eddie Guerrero with Rick Flair as the special guest referee. Eddie does some fun shenanigans in the match. He hits Rick with a chair while his back is turned, throws the chair to Triple H, playing Flair and Trips off against each other. Eventually, Rick Flair gets taken out, Triple H gets hit with the belt, then a frog splash, new ref counts to three, Eddie Guerrero retains over Triple H of all people. Triple H quits SmackDown, heads back to Raw to rejoin Evolution, embarrassing general manager Kurt. Vince tells Kurt that one more screw-up and you're fired. Fuming at Guerrero, Kurt then gleefully announced at The Great American Bash it's going to be Eddie Guerrero defending his title going one-on-one with The Undertaker.
And Teddy Long sees that and writes it in his notebook saying, "This is gold." Even if SmackDown has a slightly anemic roster in 2004, at the very least, you can make the main events of the pay-per-views good. Eddie versus Triple H, Eddie versus Undertaker, rather than, I don't know, Undertaker versus The Dudley Boyz in an opportunity to murder poor Bearer on a pole match. The opportunity's on the pole, not you know I mean. The feud between Taker and Eddie is face versus face. They successfully team together against Angle's hired goons, Luther Reigns, no relation to Roman Reigns, and Mark Jindrak, also no relation to Roman Reigns. But, the tension is there between the two baby faces. Undertaker tells Eddie that he can lie and steal all he wants, but the one truth in life is you can never cheat the reaper. Eddie tells Taker that there's only one thing that's true about Eddie's life, the way Eddie has always lived his life, is that he does not fear death. Viva la raza. At The Great American Bash, Eddie Guerrero tries to overcome Undertaker's strength, frog splashes him through the announce table, but the dead man rises to get in the ring for nine. The referee goes down, Eddie goes to grab a chair. As he's about to swing it at where the Undertaker's lying, Undertaker sits up, looks pissed Eddie, throws him the chair and then lies down as the ref comes to.
The ref is about to ring the bell when Undertaker just grabs him by the scruff and says, "I wouldn't." Eventually, Kurt Angle comes down to the ring. He tries to run interference, but accidentally hits Taker with the belt instead of Eddie. Eddie gets one more frog splash. He pins the Undertaker to retain the WWE Championship. Afterwards, that's one mistake too many. Vince fires Kurt as general manager. We head to SmackDown. Two big matches for the pay-per-view. Kurt Angle versus the Undertaker and Eddie Guerrero defending the WWE Championship against Rey Mysterio. So, you begin their story at SummerSlam. Have Rey win the title shot in a four-way. It's not the main event of the show. That'll still be Chris Benoit versus Randy Orton, but that frees it up to be a face versus face work rate match. Play up their history. Have Eddie flirt with a little bit of the darkness that will come. Rey asking Eddie in the build-up, "You wouldn't cheat to beat your best friend, would you, Eddie?"
"That's the thing, Rey." Eddie replies, "I don't need to beat you." At SummerSlam, the two have their match. Hopefully, Rey wears a decent mask that he doesn't need to keep adjusting every five [ __ ] seconds like his one at WrestleMania 21. [ __ ] pack it in. Eddie thinks about hitting Rey with the belt while the referee's back is turned, but ultimately, he decides against it. He beats Rey clean instead. After the match, Eddie's then attacked by JBL. You got the beat down. You have the clothesline from hell. The feud begins now. We've given Eddie longer with the belt. He's retained over two top guys, and you have the Rey SummerSlam match. We've got all of that ready and waiting for future context. So, now we weave JBL into the larger story. So, on SmackDown, JBL talks about how as a hard-working American, it makes him sick to see SmackDown's biggest prize contested for at SummerSlam by two illegals. Rey's like, "I'm from San Diego." "Two illegals, I said." "It doesn't have to be true." says JBL, "because it feels like it's true." Have JBL do his uber dastardly right-wing police the borders [ __ ] beat up Rey Mysterio, beat up the Mexicools, claim he's bringing the WWE Championship back to the real America. At No Mercy, Rey Mysterio runs in, hits JBL with a 619 while the ref's back is turned. Eddie hits the frog splash, pins JBL clean, then drapes a Mexican flag over his corpse. This in cell builds to Survivor Series for the
feud to be settled in a Mirando match. Mirando being Spanish for I quit. When Eddie makes JBL quit, he's going to say it in Spanish. At Survivor Series, Eddie and JBL go to war. Big bloody affair. JBL handcuffs Eddie to the ring ropes and while Rey Mysterio again tries to run in, save the day, this time JBL counters his attempt at 619 with a clothesline from hell and spends the next few minutes just victimizing Rey in front of Eddie, beating him with a chair over and over and over again, taking a belt, wrapping it around Rey's neck and choking him until Eddie finally quits to save his friend even if it means giving up the WWE Championship, ending his reign in this reality at 274 days. At Armageddon, the feud ends with Eddie versus JBL inside Hell in a Cell with JBL retaining thanks to his newly formed cabinet and Rey teams with Eddie to beat the Bashams at the Royal Rumble to become tag team champions. However, they then lose the titles at No Way Out and maybe it's because Eddie is in a bad place mentally because No Way Out is the anniversary of when he won the WWE title that he no longer has or because he's harbored resentment for Rey because he gave up his title to save him, but after the match which sees Rey get pinned, Eddie loses his mind and attacks Rey Mysterio turning heel and making their
WrestleMania 21 match a more heated heel versus face best friend versus best friend war. Eddie wins that match at WrestleMania. He puts Rey on the shelf for a bit then heel Eddie can be one of the first guys to feud with John Cena over the WWE Championship before Rey returns to cost Eddie in that match and set up their feud leading into SummerSlam and Eddie revealing that he's Dom's papi. And looking back, that is how I would book Eddie Guerrero's WWE title run. These aren't seismic changes. They just make the most of the limited SmackDown roster. Give Eddie a run of five solid pay-per-view defenses. Prove he can actually hang with the top of the card rather than losing two straight matches to JBL on pay-per-view cuz remember he lost the first one by [ __ ] DQ as well. Jesus Christ. Then at Survivor Series, he can drop it to the new top heel. He's still then got like five months to be insufferable and build to a match with John Cena with Eddie transitioning into another top heel to make way for Cena as the number one babyface. I don't know. It all just kind of fits together and it feels like it's doing Eddie justice whilst then making his WWE Championship run lead into the big heel turn and the big story with Rey. So, it's not like he's been demoted. It's more like one thing leads to another. What do you think of my booking? Let me know in the comments.
Thank you so much again to Chart for commissioning this booking over at patreon.com/Blomko. Until the next time, I am Adam from Blomko Incorporated. Get back to work.