Oakspire - A cozy tableau-building game of wood and wonder - Kickstarter Critique Review
Transcript
Ahoy there, YouTube. I'm back again today for another Kickstarter critique. We're taking a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. Give my honest thoughts on how the project is being run. And today, I am pretty excited to check out the eighth most popular project in all Kickstarter games. That's Oak Spire. It's a a cozy tableau building game of wooden wonder. I'm primarily excited because I love tableau building games. As for the main image, it does nothing to excite me at all because clearly it's just animals doing people things, which is just all the rage. But, I'd love some components or some mechanisms or some some more stuff here. A peaceful puzzly cycle of collect, craft, and build. Player link, time, count, age, mechanism, stretch goals, prices, shipping, something else here aside from a some sort of animal pulling a bag. Now, I'm also more interested because Lucky Duck Games went to Gamefound for a while. They were on Kickstarter, went to Gamefound, now back on Kickstarter. $23,000 funding goal, hit it, 65,000 bucks. This is happening.
Also, I I think another reason why I covered this was this had a bunch of people that were interested in pre-launch. Let's see why. As always with the video, I'm thinking three things. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? Let's see how they convinced 770 backers of those three things. Hey, welcome to Sunleaf Grove. You're just in time. We're hiring.
Appreciate the subtitles. It's no easy task to build a fully sustainable city for all animal kind. So, let's see if you've got what it takes to be the architect.
Nice little box with components. Oh, okay. Smaller cards, but a decent amount of meat on it. Looks like the cards like building requirements and whatnot. Okay.
to build a restaurant on the beach or the Museum of Natural History. Every project starts life on the community board. And there's a lot of projects in review. Okay. Every single one of them
Beautiful. But, we don't cut down trees here. You'll play cards from your hand to gather wood from the forest floor, float it downstream, process it into different qualities of lumber, send the finished resources down to the construction site. Oh. And then, you
build things that are going to make those actions even better in the future. Discard five of the deck, keep being Oh, yeah. I'm in. I want to play it. Use them to construct different Oof. Oof. Look at all the information on that card. Thank you.
French blueprints. And with every project you build, your reputation grows. And you'll also unlock new abilities and end-game scoring options. Oh, no time for a tea break. Things are always moving. Each turn ends with the community action. With the leftover projects on the community board grant free actions to everyone who wants them. Everyone moves forward together. Build the best reputation through gathering coins, constructing projects, and unlocking advanced Beautiful looking coins. And and just a nice job of kind of showcasing All right, here's what it's going to look like as you're playing through the game. See the play Oh, look at that. Looks good.
Scoring abilities become video. Sunleaf Grove's most celebrated architect. Now, let's get growing. I mean, going. After the video, I'm in. Do I want it? Yes, it looks fun. The artwork now feels like it's a nice icing on the cake as opposed to just the cake. Uh can you do it? Yeah, Lucky Duck Games, they've done quite a few things in the past. Now, I do believe they're not as uh doing as great as they were at one point. And I mean, particularly with outstanding Kickstarter projects, I do believe {slash} Gamefound projects. So, let's check out their most recent thing on Kickstarter, which was March 27th. Oh, okay. Well, let's see. When was this on Kickstarter? This is on 2025. Oh, so they came back a while ago. They came So, they never left. They were in 2024.
Okay. Well, you know what? I'm going to do what if. I thought that Well, they dipped their toe into Gamefound. I do very distinctly remember that. So, let's check out the last few projects on Kickstarter, make sure people got their things. How can I see the average of a fulfillment? They need to change it, so no. They haven't got it yet on this one. Uh okay. Hello, I've sent an email regarding my pledge. Should I not get a response back? Any update on any more languages? So, yeah. How about the Flames of Fafnir with 1,000-plus backers? Is this one out in the wild? I don't think so. We're trying to send many messages, but you don't answer to me. Considering my pledge and how you have collected my money, and yesterday was last day to do it, and now it is too late. Jared, the PM closes today, so there's no still Okay. So, 8 days ago, 8 days ago, they got stuff. Still waiting for shipment and tracking. Hey, Sean, nobody has those yet because we're not at the fulfillment station. So, this one is not at fulfillment. So, we have two outstanding projects. Moving on to God's Grave.
What do we got with God's Grave? This one raised 343,000 euros. Wow, you have pooped the bed on this timeline. Still excited for this, but my goodness, no way we should have been 2 years late on delivery. No wonder crowdfunding is dying, and my days of backing have become far more particular. I don't mind waiting a year longer for something like Kingdom's Forlorn or Lands of Evershade or many years in the case of Kingdom Death Monster, i.e. a large complicated system. But, this long for this is really unfortunate. I am guessing we won't don't see this in our hands until this time next year. Oh, well. Hey, Marcus, we know things should have been handled better, but we are here. Uh we are where we are and know nothing. Yeah, yeah, I got that. I know the journey is no longer than expected, but nevertheless, thank you for the lovely communication. So, this one not out as well. So, we need to keep going back to the Dark Quarter, which I do believe is out. And I think I have one of these on my shelf. I think I covered that one. I think this is Yeah, so this is where we made the jump over from Gamefound. Which makes me feel like we totally do need to go to Gamefound to see exactly cuz this is a valuable information. Right now, we're up to three Gamefound uh Lucky Duck Games.
All right. Lucky Duck Games on Gamefound. Yeah, they did the Oh, they did that that that that food chain magnet. That one That's such a great game. Still receiving the updates with the delivery of the notebook. So sorry that you still receive a notebook. It may have gotten lost in the mail. So, they're doing in they're doing customer service. And this one is out. So, three out. And then this is the Tranquility. This one's out. I've seen this one. I own this one, I think. Destinies: Witchwood. Are these in order? I guess it would be Divinus. That one? No, Dark Quarter came after it. Kingdom Rush. Yeah, so that was the one they did on here. I don't know. They did a lot of stuff. Let's just check these ones, make sure people got their stuff. But, it looks like three outstanding projects. And if someone in the in the chat or in the comments knows better, please let me know. I never received the game. I contacted Lucky Duck last year uh before the middle of the year. At first, they said they were going to send it to me.
They gave me a tracking number that never existed. Never received the rabbit pack. Really bad taste with Lucky Games. Not receiving promised translations. Any news about the Spanish translations? Uh Italian translations? So, no. Like, Kingdom Rush, yes, but a lot of people having issues in the back end. Have people gotten this one? Worst thing about this game is losing the campaign data after Okay, so this one I do believe is out. Okay. So, it looks like three-ish projects out. Not a great feeling. Not a great feeling. But, you need to know what I'm Can you do it? So, can you do it? Yeah. I'm going to give it the nod cuz this one's, you know, funded. It's got $65,000.
With the deluxeification. All right, one to five players, ages 12-plus, 20 minutes per player. Wow, I would put that on the marquee. A two-player, 40 minutes, okay. Uh good to see you, architects here in this. We got the cozy, peaceful, time to build stuff. What's the price? Hit me with it. Are you ready to build the What's in the box? One community game mat. Tell me in millimeters. Tell me in inches, please. Majority people probably going to be from the United States of America. Let's check. 376 France. 121. Ooh. Man, France not doing it nearly as big as France normally does for their own cuz I believe it says it's like it's it doesn't say it's from France here, but I think they're Maybe they're not from France. Maybe just France loves this game and the designer. I don't know. Either way, I would have inches in in addition to millimeters.
Five player boards. So, this is in the standard and the deluxe edition. Okay. 108 unique 108 unique hand-drawn illustrations. Five player architect tokens. 142 card sleeves. Yeah. Deck holder, that's nice. Coin tokens, they look delicious. 140 resource tokens. Okay, what's the price? Just hit me with it. Oh, and a rule booklet. Excellent. Is it clickable? No. Hopefully I see that later. There's so many different types of passive abilities, unique actions, the different combinations of who your specialist is. All those little things will really set the tone of what you do in this game. Yeah, they're very clearly going for like Everdell vibes, which is a good vibes to give off. So, a teach you play through, great. Exciting theme, cute critters doing your woodwork for you, and fresh mechanics. Production chain that relies on efficiency on yours and other players' turns. Very fun game.
There are layers and layers, and every time I play it, I appreciate this game more and more as well. It's a gamer's game. As soon as I saw this cover, I'm like, wait a second, what is this? Multi-use cards, tableau building, I'm like, yes. Yes, I must try this. Let's do this. Okay. Lots of quotes here. Relatively solid quotes. Like, none of them have been like, "Spurt was flop. Tell me more." They feel decent. You're not just chaining gaining resources, you're moving them, upgrading them, watching them flow across your board like a real production line. It's smooth, it's intuitive, and honestly, it just feels really good. Yeah, the video showed it look good. Different language. You can convert these. It's not against the law. Collector's Edition explained. Ooh, an art book.
Okay. Oh, metal pins. Why? Why? Why this is this is bundled with the deluxe components? I have to if I want the deluxe components, I need to get the art book. Is that Is that what it is? And Oh, man. All right, I'm very interested to see uh how this does. Like how many of the standard versus the deluxe. Uh 7 to 10 times one is is typically. So, for every 10 of the deluxe you sold, so here we go. So, for every one of these of the $33 ones, in theory, 7 to 10 of these should be sold if they're doing a a good job on it. Like at least based on what I see every day Kickstarter averages, right?
Not my personal opinion, just that's like, okay, they're crushing it. Uh collector's pledge. Okay, so this is different. So, there's a deluxe pledge, and there's a collector's pledge. Oh, delightful. So, I don't have to buy this stuff. That's just the diehards of the diehards. Good deal, $79. Deluxeified game, I'm in. Feels reasonable. 33 bucks, I'd put this on the main image, honestly. I'd put it on there. All right, can you get me to do the $46 price jump? I think most people will. So, 76 here, 564. So, yeah, that is What's that? Like seven times, eight times? Good deal. So, they did a great job on it. And then this, 72. Awesome. That was a great decision not to force people to buy that, and sure enough I'm sure they're probably not the most unhappy with that, right? It's a $40 price jump, but they made 79 plushies, 79 of these art books, 79 of these, and counting. 72.
Cuz I'm sure there's going to be people who do the Cuz you look at 72 and you're like, oh, that's not as great as you would hope it to be. But then at the same time, it's like people don't want pins, and people don't want the the plushie, or people don't want the art book, but they're going to get it on the back end, on the add-ends, add-ons. Not to mention Lucky Duck Games definitely has convention presence. So, this is the kind of stuff that you can really loot the deal with when you're trying to sell stuff in person. Uh and it just is little add-ons and stuff. So, 13, 15, 15. Okay. So, $95 or 46. So, the 95 doesn't feel great. If it doesn't, you go get the 13, but most people are getting the 95. Oh, it's 108. Oh, man.
That was before I converted the currency. It's 108 bucks. Ow. Doesn't feel great for the deluxe, but for the non-deluxe, 52. Very reasonable. Very reasonable. Uh stretch goals, Raccoon City District, funded. Okay, so we got a bunch of these. I'll put these up higher. Mr. Snake. Oh, alternate portrait token token now. Okay. Timeline campaign, so we're hoping to have this out December 2026. Wow. I would mention that on the marquee. Have this for the holidays potentially, right? Shipping before the end of the year. Anything like that is better than, you know, just a lot of artwork. Hexy Studio. Fantastic job on that video. Like top-notch stuff. Uh all right. So, they splurged out a decent chunk of change for that video.
And it shows. I think it did a lot of a lot of the heavy lifting. All right, FAQ updates, comments, Kickstarter grade. Shipping. Oh, they organized it like reload from Colossal Games. That's nice. Is there solo mode? Yes, the solo mode has a small deck of seven cards to automate the community board with a variety of different challenges for you to face. Cool. Didn't feel like that was really celebrated on the main story. Might want to do that. I've seen that done quite a lot. It just It's nice when it's like, oh, yeah, there's a special solo mode. It's got its own separate components and stuff. That just feels good. Especially if you're solo enthusiast. A huge thank you from all of us at Lucky Duck Games. Stretch goals, Raccoon City District. Is that going to be a uh Resident Evil? Okay. Uh end game, one VP for each different icon in the instant reward. Cool. Any questions? Oh, just check the FAQ tab. Also, uh questions. Cool. Reaching out. Looks like some good customer service here.
Let's check out the updates here. Oh, that was the first one. So, this just launched yesterday. Okay. I got to put the stretch goals higher now that they're funded. Very excited for this game cuz that's honestly that that big It's a feels like a decent price jump. Like 110, 105 bucks for a tableau building game. It just doesn't feel great, but, you know, deluxeified is deluxeified. Hi, just saying that I would really love for the stretch goals to be included with the Kickstarter gift, therefore included with the standard pledge, especially for extra cards and things like that. It's annoying that they're not included with the standard pledge. Hey, Laura, totally get why you'd like all the Oakspire goodies. However, this is the way we've structured the pledge. Uh there's no shipping estimates for Asian countries. Uh all right, different languages, French. I've just backed the all-in pledge for Germany. Cool. Final grade. That was a quick one.
Do I want it? I do. Tableau building, I don't feel like you did a very good job spotlighting yourself. Like now that I'm like really starting to just step back for a second. They could have spotlighted a lot of things, and they just chose not to, and that feels so odd to me. Like how many awards has Lucky Duck Games So, first let's check out the designer cuz they didn't mention that I felt like hardly at all. So, For All Deckspire So, nothing here. Like you're not going to But the company itself, the publisher itself, you know, if we're talking about how some games they put out that are super highly rated. Now, granted, some of them are them bringing them from other countries, but just saying like, hey, these are some of the games that we handle. Food Chain Magnate, Sky Team, Final Girl like And it gets weird, but they also have their own games, too. Like the Chronicles of Crime series and stuff like that where they 100% were nominated for tons of awards and all sorts of different things. And there's It'd be like, oh, yeah, I have this game in my collection from, you know, five, six, seven, eight years ago. And I don't feel like they really did a great job with that at all. And that's feels like a missed opportunity cuz they could have a very impressive chart. So, do I want it? Yes. Can they do it? Yes, but this would be their fourth outstanding project that I could count.
There might actually be three and a half-ish is what we we ended up with. So, four and a half-ish. But they're saying they're going to get it out before the end of the year. Can they do it? Yeah, I'll give them a I'll give them a tepid check mark. Then how much cuz they got 65k to make this game already, you know. Then how much is it? Uh it feels good. It feels fine for the standard version. It does not feel great for the deluxe version, and the all-in version is is a continuation of not feeling great. Final grade is a B. No rule booklet. So, that that kind of sucks. Like they talked about the rule booklet, but not having it there. Pretty disappointing, but there's also tons of videos. And they did everything like like a lot of good-looking stuff here.
Feel like they should have got to do this way earlier. Like just hit me with the $33 just immediately, and we're done. Like I'm Like, okay, I'm back at 33 bucks. That's fine. I would convert that Uh but putting it all the way down here, I'm going to go with a B. Definitely feel like they could have accentuated a lot of positives, but let me know in the final the comments below what's your final grade for Oakspire, cozy tableau building game of wood and wonder. And on May 11th, I'm going to be launching my own Kickstarter to sell Kickstarter critiques. If you want to buy one for your favorite publisher, or for an upcoming game, or your friend who is a game designer, or just because you want me to check out something really good or really bad, or who knows. You can do that. And it also I'm trying to raise $3,000. And if you want to sponsor the entire channel, it's a three there's one pledge, $3,000, and you sponsor the entire channel for a year.
Every long stream Every live stream and every long-form video. You'll be like, I'll spot I'll I'll spotlight whatever you want. Um but yeah. Also, oh, yeah. And And there's a buy one get one right now. And like, god, I'm so bad at shilling. Goodbye. Goodbye.