Reviewing The Allplay Shelves - The Good, The Bad & The Ugly
Transcript
Hey I'm Alex from Board Game Co, and today I'm going to be reviewing the All Play shelves. Now we're going to be getting into the pros, the cons, what I like, my overall thoughts, opinions, would I buy them, all of that we're going to get into, but I think the first two things that are very very important that we need to get out of the way is number one, these shelves were all sent to me for free as part of my All Play sponsorship, which brings me directly to number two, which is this channel is currently sponsored by All Play. And take that into account because I'm calling this an All Play shelf review, and yet I am sponsored by All Play. Obviously that introduces just that bias aspect. Am I going to be too favorable, too kind, any of those things? You're going to have to decide that for yourself. What I can tell you is I told All Play, I'm happy to review the shelves, but it's not going to be a censored review, it's not going to be sent to you for approval, it's just going to be a review of the shelves pros and cons. Would you like me to do so?
And they said, yes. So that's kind of the context you need to have. Again, you have to take into account the bias and and all of that. You have to take all into account as we get into this, but I am going to go ahead and dive into the pros, the cons, what I like, what has worked for me, things you should know if you're considering getting them yourself. All of that we're going to get into, and I'll start with the biggest and most important thing. Honestly, the rest of the video is just details to this, which is my overall opinion, which I'll come back to at the end of the video, is I think these shelves are absolutely fantastic. I think they are a major step up from at least what I had before, which is the Kallax shelving. Technically I had the Better Homes and Gardens knockoff, and I had a few Kallax shelves. They're basically very similar. Anyways, it's a huge step up for me. I think they're fantastic, but they are very expensive. That is the biggest conclusion that this entire video is going to come down to, but I will get into the details. And so to that end, let's go ahead and get into the details.
The All Play shelves are well, they're a lot. Let's get into you know, I'm trying to think where I want to take this from. Let's Let's start with a little bit of a tour. Let's turn the camera around, start showing you things going on. I will link to my shelf building video. I did a full video showing the build that I did way back when I got these. I want to say in December, kind of doing a time lapse of me going through this, and this is where they are now, which is also the last 5 minutes of that video. And I'll show you some more aspects of this. I'll go ahead and show you like how it loops around and things that I've done with it. But the general idea is this is a shelving system that I've put together. I built this myself, meaning several things. First of all, I designed it myself in the AllPlay Shelf Builder. I measured my room, I put it together, I decided what I wanted to look like. I designed it, I got it all, I assembled it all. It's a lot to get into, which I guess starts bringing us into the pros and cons. And there are a lot of pros and cons to go through.
Maybe I'm going to sit down. You know, I'm going to sit down a bit. I'll show you some of the relevant things cuz there are relevant things to show you as we talk about different points. Let's start off with the fact that these shelves are beautiful. That's the first thing I'm going to say. The overall shelf design is absolutely beautiful. The look, the feel, it feels premium, it looks premium. They have thinner shelf rails, which I'll show you. But these shelves, I have been complimented a lot by people on these shelves. And I wasn't complimented the same way on my Kallax shelving. My Kallax shelving was functional. It did the job. I got compliments on my board game collection, but not so much on the shelving itself. Within the first few weeks that I had installed these shelves, I frequently got comments from friends, board gamers, and non-board gamers alike that this was a major upgrade. And they they they look like a major upgrade. At least to my eyes, they look like a major upgrade. They look premium, they feel premium. When you're here, it feels like hardwood shelving. The IKEA Kallax shelving or the Better Home & Garden shelving feels like particle board shelving. There is a visual difference when you are there. I don't know how much it comes through on camera, but at least there, there's absolutely a visual difference. A visual difference. Secondly from that, and a big part, is the modularity in design.
This is when I'm going to go back to showing you the shelves, but you can kind of make it whatever you want. If you have the Kallax shelving, I have one cubby kind of left back here, then you have these kind of fixed cubes. And there's two things I want to point out. First of all, is the thickness of the wall. That thickness over there, that is a very thick particle board wall, and that comes through when you have tons of games stacked on shelves. Over here, the thinness of the hardwood shelving over here, it makes it look much more visually appealing, as as the modularity. Yes, you can have a standard Kallax size cubby over here. The default cubby that you have with the all play shelving is kind of very similar. I don't know if it's the exact width and dimensions. I think it is though. I think it's that same 13 by 13 by 15 cube. It extends pretty back the pretty far back the same way. So, if you just want that kind of cubby, you can absolutely build them as as that. But, you can also go ahead and build slightly more rectangular designs, and you can also have them going in different directions. So, I have this one as a vertical uh design shelf over here. So, you have a lot of modularity as far as the individual cubbies, but then even past that over here I have a giant one.
This is kind of experimental. I don't know how I feel about the giant cubbies. I got a few of them, not many. I think I have maybe three total across all my shelves. And honestly, they kind of operate like big empty spaces. So, if you're considering them, I'll get into the things I would and wouldn't do differently. Uh but, you have just different variety of different types of shelving, but then you also have the variety over how you build it, and even including the empty space you can build into your designs. For example, over here I have a regular cubby like so, kind of one of those more rectangular ones. I have another rectangular one, but then in middle I left a gap, which introduces the ability to go ahead and kind of create a shelf within the gaps. That has two benefits. The first benefit is it gives you even more modularity. You're not just limited to the all play uh shelving uh restrictions that they give you as far as the types of shelves they provide, but you can create a lot of gaps of different sizes that give you a lot of flexibility over how you're building things out. And again, even small things. I'll show you another kind of a little cubby area I built over here. I have a few of these kind of small uh mini cubbies that are built by the intersection having a few cubbies align. And you can do a lot of things like that. Over here I have another one, another kind of it's a it's a shelf within a shelf. And again, there are two benefits there. I have a little miniature just kind of hanging out on this one cuz I haven't put games here, even though I should. Uh but, there's two benefits. Number one is you have more types of shelves. Number two is you're also save saving on the cost. As you build these, if the biggest con is the fact that they are very expensive, then anytime you can kind of build a fictional shelf by adjusting the ways you put these together such that it creates empty space that can be utilized
as a shelf, it is going to save you money, which again is a pro, especially because they are expensive. So, there's a lot of modularity in design. There's modularity to the the shelf types, the way you can structure it, even the fact that you can change it over time. If you buy a 5 by 5 Kallax shelving unit, you're kind of stuck with a 5 by 5 Kallax shelving unit. These you can do what you want with. You can decide that you're going to go ahead and completely redesign your space and then figure out what shelves you have and rebuild it. You can kind of plug them into the All Play Shelf Builder saying this is what I have, and then you can always, of course, order more if you need to adjust it, but you can rebuild your entire my case my set, uh in your case your your game room. You can move and you're not limited to how can I make these 5 by 5 Kallaxes fit in where they need to fit in, rather you can just as it go ahead and redesign your space around these shelves. Now, again, they're not the super I didn't say it I said again, but we'll come to it later in the cons.
They're not the super easiest to take apart and do that with. This is not a oh, I'm just going to clip this here and move that there. This would be a big project, but it is something you can do. They are very modular in the design. They're also modular in the various structures they can give you. So, I'll show you a few things over here. Again, some of these I use and like, some of them less so. We have the X unit over here. I have I mean, I debate taking this out all the time. I mostly end up with this as kind of dead space. If you have enough playmats, I think it's great to kind of what I'm doing there, but as far as board game boxes, for the most part, they don't fit really great. I did briefly at one point manage to put this Stag and Lion Dot game such that it was kind of just directly over here, which was very, very visually satisfying, but outside of weird games like that, you're mostly kind of talking about dead space with those X's, unless you use them for playmats. I think playmats is where you get the most benefit from it. You also have drawers. I have a bunch of drawers over here. These are very nice drawers.
They're push click drawers, so they feel very premium. I have a bunch of small box games kind of in here. I also have junk junk over here. This is a junk drawer. I need to go through it and clean it, but the upside of it is it's not in people's faces. I have a junk drawer that doesn't look totally messy because, well, it's not. And I have a bunch more of these shelves over here. Well, I've mentioned in another video, I'm actually even using these for non-board game things. I have my tools in these shelves. It's kind of in my game room, but it's in my game room in a way that's not visually obvious aside from the fact that I do have this tool chest here, which frankly I want to move to a different drawer. But you also have these. Again, these are going to be push-to-click drawers as well. So, you have that push-to-click aspect, and then you just pull out. And those are different types of things they have. I don't know if that's everything. Well, I mean, they have one more thing for sure. They have shelves. Let me go ahead and show you these. So, shelves allow you to break up a cubby into different kinds of sizes. So, over here, I think it's over here somewhere. Yeah, over here, I kind of put a shelf in the middle. This is a modular shelf. This is a big cubby over here that, like I mentioned already, I've been enjoying these less as far as the sizing. And I think I want to go through it. I think I want to replace this X with a shelf in the middle. And I think over here, as the same way I did this one and readjusted it, I think I'm going to do the same over there. So, overall, these shelving units, they are a lot more modular as far as the design, the approach, the accessories, all of that kind of stuff. The construction quality, I kind of touched upon that.
These feel premium. I've had Kallax shelves. I've had Better Homes and Gardens shelves. They always have that kind of like slight chip to them. I mean, I'm saying that poorly. When you build them and you assemble them, more often than not in my case, there'd be one area where some of the particle board edging got scratched off. I wonder if I have any on this shelf in the corner. Uh on the bottom, like it it felt cheaper. It felt cheaper. Whereas these shelves that I have, these All Play shelves, they feel much more premium. The construction quality, the shelf thickness I talked about that. Again, if you look back over here, that thickness on this shelf over here relative to the fact that down over here on the All Play shelf, you have a tiny line, all of that is a strong pro to just the kind of feel you're getting out of these. That's most of what I have as far as the the That's most of what I have as far as why these shelves are so good. They look great, they look premium, they make the game room feel better, frankly. But, they also are expensive. That's the biggest con. By far, these are expensive shelves. If you're looking at a Kallax 5x5, I don't even know if they make the Kallax 5x5s anymore. I think they stopped making them. But, if you're looking maybe that maybe they still do it. Maybe Better Homes & Gardens stopped making them.
Either way, a standard 5x5, depending on the brand you're looking at, is usually going to run you somewhere in the range of $150, if I recall correctly. They range in the size of 4x4s, the 3x2s. They have all different sizes. You're looking at around $150 for one of those. That same thing we can structure with an All Play shelf is going to run you closer to a thousand. I don't know the exact specs. It does depend on how you build it. It does depend on the empty space. But, that is a big jump up from 150 to a thousand. In my shelf building video, I had a lot of people asking me how much these shelves cost. I don't remember. I did build it in the shelf building. I have a quote. I don't remember offhand. But, if I recall correctly, it was probably around $8,000 of total material. And that's buying you a lot of things. It's buying you the shelves behind you. This is like a 30-ft wall, by the way. A 30-ft wall of shelving. So, it's a lot of shelving. Again, build your own game room out to get a sense of what it would be. It has those shelves over there, that wall back there with all those cubbies and drawers. And the cubbies and drawers do add to the cost. It has this entire wall. I didn't even talk about that, but you have these corner pieces over here.
So, I I one of the things I did, I talked about in my other video, is I was able to build my own kind of structure. So, I have my studio room over here, but I don't need my studio room to take up everything. So, I literally built a dividing wall and kind of a secret room where you can walk through into my projector room over here. It's a mess because the kids are here and all that. But, the projector room got a projector back here. We have more shelves. This is kind of just a hidden room obfuscated by the All Play shelves. When you go back to the other room, it's just it almost is if it doesn't exist, based on the way I built them. Again, you can look at your own room, but you can probably do something like this. If you were looking at this room at a glance, it kind of just feels like the room ends there. There's an entire separate room behind that. Uh what was I point? My point was I had a point. I was talking about a point. I just went into the modularity things. Oh, with the cost. The cost. So, the cost of all this is definitely not cheap. It is something that's very nice, but it's definitely not cheap. Other cons, and we'll come back to the cons at the end when I talk about, you know, would I buy them and all of that. But, other cons are going to be the assembly time. The assembly time, and this is a small con in my opinion. It's not a big deal, but the assembly time of the of a standard Kallax, I've done Kallaxes so many times at this point, that for me, I think the assembly time of a Kallax is probably in the range of maybe an hour to assemble a 5 by 5 Kallax might take me an hour. I've done it enough times. I don't need to reference the rules rules the instructions. I know exactly what to do. I know the tools I need. I'm pretty quick at it. Maybe a second person is helpful to be able to prop it up, but again, I'm pretty much on top of it.
But, as far as the assembly time of these, I didn't measure how many hours I spent doing it cuz I did it over several days, but it was definitely a lot more. There was a lot more time spent as far as putting them all together, putting every individual unit together, connecting them together. There were definitely some missteps along the way. Some things that I kind of learned by doing things wrong the first time. Again, I didn't even reference the instructions. I thought I could just do it, which resulted in some degree of disassembly. All things I've figured out by now, but there was a lot of time spent putting into this. I built this over several days. Granted again, there's a lot of shelving here, but the same way that the cost is like, you know, five to six times the cost of a Kallax, I think the assembly time is similarly five to six times the assembly time of a Kallax, if not more. The potential for human error. That's a big thing. There are definitely areas that I made mistakes in. Some of it could be not looking at the instructions first and just thinking that I could do it. Things like the orientation of which shelf goes by which, but even things like the way these shelves are, you may have noticed in some of the videos there's some minor degree of sag. And I'll show you what I mean over here cuz I think it is relevant for if you're going to be building these yourself.
But, over here, let me just go ahead and show you this over here. Let's pick up I'm trying to Give me a second here. Over here, you may notice things like this sag over here. This degree of sag over here is cuz I built this misaligned. The way I put this is you can you have to kind of have a supporting structure. And this all comes down to this area over here, right over here. I don't have supporting areas. I have a supporting this side, but not on this side, which results in a tiny degree of sag as all the shelves are kind of coming down to this moment, which results in this kind of pulling down and this pulling down and this kind of pulling out to the center. There's a small degree of like if I pull back, you'll be able to see. That's all something that I know exactly what I need to do to fix it. I know how to fix it. The problem is I have to disassemble all the shelves over there in that area, which is a project I will do. It's not like a end of the world project. If I had to guess, it's probably like, you know, 2 to 3 hours of time to take all the games off the shelf, undo the various bolts, redo the bolts in the right positioning, make sure it's supported in the right area. It's a 3-hour project and it's just not important enough for me right now to do it, but it does mean that I have a small sag in the shelf. There's a degree of when you're building them, you kind of want to make sure that everything is supported in the right areas. If you don't do that, then you are potentially looking at some degree of of shelf sag in certain areas. The shelf builder will let you build things, at least when I used it, it will let you build things in ways that are not necessarily the most optimal. You have to take into account that user error. My biggest recommendation is make sure that every shelf is always supported on both sides in some way or another. You shouldn't have an area where the shelf is supported halfway and that allows for tilt on the other side if enough
pressure is being applied from other areas. To be clear, I have done that in multiple areas. The idea that it's only partially supported, I've done it in multiple areas. It only causes a problem if enough things I'd have to go into and really show you breakdown. In most areas it doesn't cause a problem. If you have enough things kind of hinging on that one area and all tilting and pushing inwards, that's the one area where it caused a problem. And again, I know how to fix it, but that user error is certainly a possibility. I mentioned already that shelf adjustments, whether small ones or full design, are not as simply as just clipping creeps together. Yes, this system is modular. Yes, this system will allow you to do a ton of things differently with it. Yes, it will allow you to completely redesign it if you are unhappy with what's going on. You're not done with the shelf, you can do whatever you want. Moving, changing the rooms you put it in. There's so much you can do with it, but it is not a small project. This is not a simply moving a couch around the house. This is a disassembling all the units and then deciding how they go together, making sure to measure properly and making sure not to leave those supporting gaps and then rebuilding it. It's a full project, but it is something that is doable with the shelves.
And then lastly, I'll say the shelves are limited to I think two colors if I recall correctly. I think the Kallax has a few more shades, but you know, just depends what you're looking for over there. So, final thoughts, conclusion. Where am I on the Allplay shelves? I think they're amazing. I think they're amazing and the problem is right now for example, I've debated adding a full another shelving unit to my house over here cuz I game room I have a different uh system. I got rid of Kallax at this completely at this point. Uh currently my game room still have I still have residual I believe that the Billy bookcases, I'm not sure. It's a still an IKEA brand but not the um standard Kallax. I still have those. Uh I'm not sure whether or when I might want to replace those or not, but even down here I'm debating adding another unit on the other side to give me a full wall shelving internal side with another curve. I think it could be done. I think it could add a lot more while not cutting into the projector room too much. So, there's things I still want to do and these are things that I would be willing to pay for. But fully doing this for like again, an $8,000 build in your game room versus the same amount of IKEA shelves might be around 14, 1500 dollars. That is a big difference in cost. And so, the biggest thing if I'm trying to look at this as to what would I do? I'll start with the first thing.
If my house burned down tomorrow and if I wasn't getting Allplay shelves as a sponsorship, would I go out and buy these again? I think I would. I think I would because right now to go backwards would be a full step down. But I also don't know if I would do that in the first place. Well, I mean not, I don't know. I definitely didn't. I didn't go out and buy Allplay shelves in the first place. I was fine with the Kallax shelves. This is something that I've experienced in many aspects of my life where sometimes you're totally fine with the thing that does the job until you decide to upgrade and then the thing that did the job before no longer feels adequate. I remember the very first time I had a baby stroller a stroller for like my my first kid I had a $70 Graco stroller and only on my second kid did I upgrade to like a $500 stroller and I I can't believe I got by on the $70 Graco stroller. It's so bumpy, so rickety. It felt totally fine. I used to like mentally make fun of people who spend hundreds and hundreds of dollars on strollers. What's wrong with the $70 one? And then I got the hundreds and hundreds of dollars strollers and I realized that the $70 one didn't do the job. And to be very clear this is not a situation of like your Kallax shelves are $70. No, Kallax shelves are nice.
They've done the job for me for years. I'm not here to to to rip on that. The idea that I'm trying to go with is sometimes you're not willing to pay for the upgrade, but then once you get the upgrade it's hard to go back to the thing you were totally fine with before. And so that's kind of where I am on the shelving. They are expensive. There's no question. I think if you are someone that has a lot of um what's the word for it? Not residual income um expendable income there's a different word there's a term um I'm trying to search for. If you have a lot of disposable that's the word. If you have if you're somebody with a lot of disposable income and you aren't shy about buying games left, right, and center doing what you want, you have a board game table, I do think these are worth the price. But if you're someone who's more deal conscious, if you're someone who is more mindful about where your money goes and you don't have extra money lying around for a premium purchase like this, then I think you're totally fine with the Kallax shelving or whatever current unit you have right now. These are absolutely a step up in a major direction at least for me. But they are a step up with a seven times the price tag estimate I don't know exactly with a very a very big jump in the price tag and that does make a difference.
Anyways, that is kind of my review of the All Play shelving. I like I said at the very beginning they are excellent. I love them. I I don't want to go back to the old shelving, but they are expensive. That was the entire the initial premise, everything I talked about, and then the conclusion uh you have to decide if this is something that's right for you. In any case until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from BoardGameCo. Hope you found this video helpful in some way and as always I hope you have a good one.