Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 50 Games Of All Time! - 20-11

Transcript 53:16

hi everyone I'm Luke and this is the broken me a show where I devote my time to ranting raving about board games but buy more the latter part if any of the games on this list have taken your fancy then perhaps you might want to pay ATT attention to the sponsor because you might be at to bag of bargain as Gamers we find it hard to deal with empty shelves some worse than others you therefore want the supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time for me that supplier is Kender they offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future Acquisitions down the line if there's a hot title you're after chances are Kendra's got it wingman mine Arc no mine Eclipse actually hate that game it's terrible but you might like it if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection A F of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so we've entered the top 20 games for me this is like the creme Creme of games there are three new games in this selection you may call foul on some of them but I don't know these are definitely big hits for me there is also one colossal Riser one that's like gone from pretty much the bottom of the list all the way up it is really elev at itself and the rest are reasonably stable but there's a few risers and fallers so you know we'll see which ones have either risen up to the top 20 or fallen out of the top 10 perhaps um but otherwise these games I just love I mean these are a big selection of games there's quite a good variety here as well in terms of what type of game they are but I would certainly say that they

are more dominated by the Euro game category in this list so anybody who claims that I don't like Euro games uh look at these ones but you'll probably get an indication of what type of Euro games I really enjoy so 20 through 11 fantastic games here can't wait to talk about him you had my curiosity but now you have my attention for number 20 we are returning to a publisher who has published quite a lot of games lately and uh it's not a surprise to many that there are a lot of games from this publisher that I really enjoy not all of them make my top 50 and maybe not even all of them make my top 100 in terms of ones that I enjoy certainly the ones I don't like don't go anywhere near my top 100 but these that end up up this high oh man do I enjoy these games and this one has been previously fighting Architects for a high spot yes this is going back to Garfield games and it's VI counts of the West Kingdom this is the third one in the west Kingdom Trilogy and it's definitely now my favorite of the West Kingdom trilogy there was a period of time when Vic counts and Architects were kind of neck and neck they were very close and they were fighting each other for Supremacy for different reasons Architects is better with multiplayer perspective and can play a large player count whereas VI counts it's probably better with fewer players but you know has probably more interesting mechanics out of the two from playing them both a bit more lately yes it's definitely the case that out the West Kingdom Trilogy VI counts is my favorite it's just this really cool almost sort of Rondell map system of

circling around with your horse meeple and choosing kind of one of four ways to play the game you can divers a little bit but for the most part you're choosing to either build buildings collect manuscripts invade the castle or uh what's the other one oh yeah or do really heav heavy in trade and the mechanics in this though are just really enjoyable you know they've got this sort of conveyor belt card system of placing characters down that give you special abilities when they're played or fall off your conveyor or while they're on the conveyor and so your little engine is trying to manipulate these cards on your conveyor belt in such a way that you can utilize their effects you know as best as possible while doing all the various ways to get victory points it's a smallest sport of iconography but it still seems relatively easy to follow because your player board basically shows you what happens in sequence you can you know upgrade your board to get more abilities there's a lot of cool stuff that goes on but a lot of it is down to that conveyor mechanic it's just a very addictive system and if you want to get a a lighter version of what it's like look up the Bagdad Kickstarter the aliat games are doing the system they have for the cards is a very similar mechanic to what VI counts does in terms of the conveyor belt of cards how you acquire cards is different between the two but the whole thing of here are the cards on my belt and they do stuff that is still essentially the same and in both cases they are very enjoyable mechanics now there is one little thing with this one I will caveat the expansions for this this is kind of like the era when I think Garfield games were dropping the ball a little bit on their expansions Architects had Artisans which was brilliant and then the sequel was

not particularly great I'm not sure about the paladins expansion I've never played it but I'm hearing mixed the iions V counts their expansions are fine but the problem is I'm actually starting to get to the point where I'd rather play the game with just VI counts you know base game because the expansions add a little bit too much to the game and make it just that little bit over fiddly and I didn't like the fact that they released it in two separate expansions on the kickstarter that just felt like a bit like a money grab to me we've got to have money I would have combine the two into one big set but honestly there's some aspects of the expansions I like to use use like the revised manuscript board and stuff like that but then some aspects like the king order cards and particularly those um you know purple characters that you can grab for endgame scoring I don't find them quite as interesting but then having more leaders that you can have in your deck you know these special characters and stuff is all well and good and the chests aren't bad either so there's lots of little bits and I need to kind of figure out what my Prime way of playing this game is but even just base game form a few of us really enjoy V counts and it regularly hits the table with us when we go to conven itions or when we try meet up on Fridays it's just a really cool solid game shut up Wesley before I do my 19 I forgot to mention that the vi counts one rose a single place from last year so I actually entered this segment by raising a single place well this one is the brand new title yes this is the first of the new titles and um yeah uh don't ask me how they ended up right next door to each other but yeah we're going to stick with Garfield games for a moment and this one

is the newest game that they have released I only even reviewed it recently I must admit I think I only reviewed it in December but I was playing it a lot during November December and I know you might call foul that some of these games are a little bit too soon to make my top 50 list you can't do that you can't do that I really do enjoy inventures of the South tigress and I've got it here in fact because I'm taking this to the same people who like VI counts I showed them this last week or a couple of weeks ago they really enjoyed it and they want to play it again while it's still fresh in their minds so we're going to play this on Friday and have lots of fun aren't we but I I know it's like a recent release but I played this a lot during November and December and January and you know by the time I came up with this list I had to just admit that I really do love this game this is a really good one now it's the most complex one that Garfield games have done and you need to know that's going in okay no other game is close I I suppose way fair is to a point but I find this one is more complex like there's more stuff you can do more stuff going on but I mean it's a Tetris thing trying to get it in the bag I don't know what insert could possibly be made for this but this one has got a lot of really cool mechanics a lot of good engine building capability lots of different variety of paths to Victory but I really love the concept of these invention boards the idea is is that you'll it's kind of like a communal poor stuff and I like games that give you a communal thing that you're working on and there's going to be more examples

that on this list actually but these invention board WS they they've all got the same format but you put these cards on there which create all sorts of weird things like a reciprocating Helmet or horsepower toy you know like all sorts of weird names but the idea is is that these tiles slide across the main board and they start off as inventions players can then build them and then players can then publish them and they can also test them they smell like burning rees's monkey really I guess when you're around it all day you stop noticing but these are effectively like a constant shifting communal thing on the in the game so I might invent you know the miniature toy or whatever the miniature toy and somebody else could come along and build it I could come back and publish it somebody else might publish it I might not get to build or publish the thing that I invented but you're getting rewards and points and different bonuses and different endgame capabilities for doing the different aspects what I really enjoy as well is that this one has a very variable endgame scoring mechanic where there are things in the game that will always score you points but the primary thing thing you need to think about is that the cards themselves are endgame scoring cards so as well as giving you bonuses during the game and being something that you can discard for useful things it's also endgame scoring so you know if you build or published a card you have to aim to score for that particular aspect like having different color dice having influence having your royalty track High having you know rows of different Workshop tiles which is essentially the engine building aspect of this there's too much for me to explain in the top 50 frankly you're

going to have to check out my for more details on this game and that was a pretty hefty review that I had to do there is just a lot going on in this game but man do I love it this is a very good fun game and you know is it my favorite Garfield game well wait and see you know it may be my favorite Garfield game but you know this one is just such a solid title but seriously maybe tone down the complexity for your next Trilogy the Asian East Asia or whatever it's called I don't know but yeah this is I think they're going to make this like the cap like you know this tiger Trilogy is going to be their more complex Trilogy and they'll tone down the complexity for the next one I do recommend you do that because as much as I love this game it's got a good solo mode in it and I do like playing it with other players it's not exactly the easiest one to get to the table and it's going to be a lengthy Affair but I do look forward to the expansion coming next year which is going to give you player powers and a way to kind of use the player Powers while also keeping the game at a decent pace you know I'm looking forward to that but yeah this is a recent game I know and it's yeah you may call fouled that it's hit the list so soon but I'm really going to kick out of it what can I say this at the moment is my 19th favorite game to play would it remain this High next year well that's the whole point of doing this on a yearly basis I'm the doctor just accept it okay number 18 and this is the one that you're going to be most interested in I think because this one is the big Riser the big Riser that I said started at the bottom of this list has kind of been in the middle of this

list at times but fell down again and now is risen somehow to my number 18 this is risen 65 places shirely you can't be serious I am serious and don't call me Shirley from 83 I kidly not it really has and I think the reason this one fluctuates a lot is partially it FL it fluctuated partially at first because it didn't have the expansion for it and the expansion has really elevated this game but also recent plays of it because it was struggling to get it played for a while recent plays both solo and with some people I know in the Southampton group have really helped me to elevate this game because we all enjoy the theme of this we enjoy having a laugh with it and because we know how to play it we can play it in a reasonable amount of time and even if it does drag on a bit long which it can do it's still a blast you're probably wondering what it is it's right over there and you can't see it in the camera so that's not going to help all right come on I'll get it here we go at least I can hold it with one hand this time I'm not joking yeah this one Star Wars alter Rim has really just gone up in the world for me the expansion uh in unfinished business is a big help because that one introduced like a you know sort Paragon pass that you can go down which kind of tells your story and gives you an arc to go down so if you ever played this game and didn't know the first thing you were meant to do well these things help you do what you need to do it also made the UN you know the the whatever the Galaxy a lot easier

to Traverse because you can go from one end to the other now with the two end pieces really handy it's a ship that made the Castle Run in less than 12 par it introduced more variety which the game badly needed cuz much like the El Horrors and out of early you know these miniature decks full of different cards it really badly needed variety and frankly the game could still use a bit more variety it couldn't hurt but will Fantasy Flight ever print another expansion for this I very much doubt it but you know I I'll take with what I can get for now you know maybe somebody will do a fanmade expansion I don't know but this one I've now pimped it up even more to the point where I've now got a you know I've got a folded space insert for it so it's now very quick to set up but also I was very kindly offered some uh tokens I I forget what it's called Break the token or token D I've forgotten the name off top of my head I will find out the name and put it on screen though for you with a web link in the description but they have basically managed to provide me with these plastic tokens for damage you know these plastic well I say plastic you know like really the funky plastic whatever they call but you know these oh nice engraved pieces here it's got you know you know nice shiny pieces for your trackers for your factions and also somewhere in here I wonder if I can get it out without taking forever to pack this away it's ah I want to show them off because they are really cool where are they there they are I love these look at these These are the credits okay same token so these are the same sort of uh you know

special uh plastic that these ones use but look at them you can get them in two different types you can get them in kind of like light mode and dark mode I take the dark mode always because dark mode is just better but oh these look and feel like futuristic credits literally like bite them and say how much like carot gold they are these are so nice to handle and you know a few of these little bits have just helped me to pimp this game up like crazy that's not necessarily the reason why it's gone up 65 places is mainly it's just the fact that it's getting more time and every and the recent times I have played it have reminded me why I do enjoy this it now works solo a lot better because of the expansion the variety means that there's more things for you to do in the game and with the players that I can play this with we have just a good time just having fun with the Star Wars theme you can put on some music or you can just make references or whatever but yeah it's still a very enjoyable game and yeah maybe four players is a bit much I'm not always a fan kind of playing it with four but I've had some very good free player games of this and I still like playing it solo you know will it stay up here or is it going to keep boomeranging up and down constantly on this list who knows but yeah this one's probably the most unstable item on my top 100 list ever I don't think any other game has constantly fluctuated up and down as much as this one it's just something about it but yeah the fact that I pimped up and got the expansion and this insert means it's definitely here to stay that's not all the Voice works number 17 has fallen from the top

10 of all time it's Fallen seven places from 10 it is now 17 I mean yeah it is somewhat of a big deal if they fall out in my top 10 but it's not like the game is garbage at this point it's still like N9 10 out of 10 territory when you're in this section of the list but I really enjoy this one and some people will cry foul because it's a party game yeah they're like what a party game this high in your list that the sacrilege how dare rabble it's like come on party games can still be fantastic and there are some that I do really like but this is easily my favorite party game this takes a game that I already really liked Dixit with those art cards I already mentioned mysterium earlier but this is the party game one of this and it's not just Dixit now this one combines the Dixit cards with sple which was another little cool social deduction game that came out before I've been playing this a lot lately in particularly at the Bogner reges Club I go to it is detective club and they've rarely latched on to this one that and also um deception murder in Hong Kong which is spoiler alert not on my top 50 although it could climb back onto it at the rate it's going at my other club but detective Club never fails me this is just such a barrel of last I mean the boxes probably seem better condition because unfortunately this is that era when tins were a thing and tins are still to this day a dumb way to package games I'm sorry but this has got expansion in it so you got more cards but what exactly is it the idea is

is that much like Dixit if you've played Dixit before you've got these taros sized art cards which are already fun enough to look at by themselves I mean they're all sorts of weird and racky pictures like a mixture of Disney and Tim Burton on crack or acid I guess and you know there's all sorts of really cool stuff here but if you're familiar with sple you'll get an idea it's uh and it's also maybe a little bit like a fake artist goes New York the the premise is that one each of you takes and turns to be a clue giver and you're playing for points but by the end of the game you really don't care about the points you have a hand of six of these cards and you're going to pick two of them for each round the clue Giver will think of a single word clue and write them and write that clue word on all but one of these various little notebooks so one's going to be blank and one's always going to have a clue word on it hello spy you remember that one and they get passed out randomly so you look at it and some of you will know the word one of you doesn't have a clue from the clue giver and going around the table everybody's starts putting out picture cards that are to do with the clue word everybody who has seen the clue word has to try and convince everybody else that they're on the good side effectively but that's easier said than done when your picture is all sorts of weird nonsense and it also depends on how good the clue Giver is with their clue the person who doesn't know has to try and get an idea of the theme from the cards that come out or just you know try and play something that's similar and then once the clue word is revealed to everybody after all cards are out that person has to find the best way to how do I else do I put it BS their way out of you know

lie their way out of the situation so the the clue word I mean I forgot one here so yeah here we go so what do we have flow bird plant split and trap okay and so you know it could be like well let's try trap for example that was the clue word so clue Giver says what their clue word how their pictures relate to the clue word and everybody then in turn has to give their kind of mini Spiel of why their cards work it may sound like the person who doesn't know the word hasn't got a chance but trust me I'm a pretty good um um Hydra or what they called imposter in this game I'm very good at bsing my way out of these situations it takes a lot of imagination a lot of creativity by linking the cards to the word but even if you knew what the word was your cards may still be garbage the I said plant here for example or bird your cards might have nothing to do with flying or vegetation in any way shape or form I got a bunch of stuff that's to do with water well that's going to help me with bird isn't it you know I've got you know a bunch that I've got like this Castle I've got this tree with a bunch of you know red fruit on it I've got this uh you know like girl walking over a keyboard and then I've got a you know a rabbit defending itself from a hail storm of carrots yeah seriously that is a thing um I don't know if you can see it but yeah it is quite insane so how's that going to help me with the word split I don't know that you know you've got to come up with a clue word that's not too obvious but not too vague and doing that is already a hard business the reason this one always works me though is that this creates so much laughter that it's almost full out of your chair laughing scenarios because listening to people

try to describe why their cards work when you know that they're either lying or just I've got really dubious claims because my cards just sucked but I've got to convince you I'm on your side leads to some of the most hilarious stories and comparisons that I've I've heard that can possibly be done and the banter between the table gets insane because everybody even the clue Giver is trash talking everybody's ideas cuz the clue Giver does know who's the Imposter they're trying to make certain the Imposter gets away with it but they don't know who they are everybody sounds like the Imposter in this game and yeah it just makes everybody start pointing the fingers and you know you've got to vote on who it is you think it is and like somebody might explain it but in 10 seconds people just go y it's you cuz that is garbage you know come on man it's just so much good fun times I've talked about this for too long it's a fantastic party game if you get a chance to uh to own this one it's not expensive if you get a chance to play this with me though I would be more than happy to show it only cavat minimum five players and ideally played with six seven or eight if you play it with less than five this game does not work and even with five it could be better six seven or eight players though make this a big group party game and it's just hilarious are you serious number 16 down from 15 this is pretty stable it Still Remains a top 20 game for me and boy boy this the height of controversy at the moment particularly if this video comes out after my last review um which it

very May well do this is the game that came out first and despite two other spin-offs coming out afterwards none of them have been able to come close to topping this one for me it's in my bag at the moment so I can't show it off especially the fact that I've managed to get all the expansions for this in the same box with the folded space insert I kid you not I have managed it I think I might have sacrificed a player board to do that but why this with five that's just dumb it is the original it is the best wingspan I'll beg to differ sir yeah I mean there are good people who hate wingspan with a passion which is fair enough I can perfectly see why you would but worms span I did a review on this one thought it was fine but I don't care about dragons are fictional compared to real life birds and also it just felt like you were jumping through twice as many Hoops to do the same thing that you were doing in wingspan and adding tracks that you level around is like one of the most like lazy ways to introduce a new mechanic in a game seriously it's like it's uninspired so worm span is decent but I just don't really feel like it finpan that I've hopefully just reviewed by this point fine as well fish real life fish I'm perfectly fine with fish I particularly like to eat fish especially when I'm trying to Mediterranean diet a little bit the problem with this one is that it's not that much lighter than Wings band so it's not really great for new Gamers it strips out a lot of the cool stuff out of wingspan and replaces it with stuff that isn't that particularly inspired either and so you end up with a game that's fine but doesn't quite you

know does it gets a little rinse repeat it doesn't quite lift itself up to the same enjoyment factor I get with wingspan this one a simple Tableau Builder from left to right trigger all the different cards on a row try to build an engine nice and simple nice and elegant now not crazy simple you know but it's Unique cards and you've got to manage your resources so this is not new gamer friendly I can't teach this to my parents I tried it didn't go down well despite the fact my dad loves Birds but this is still a light game for gamers this is a nice light Pleasant way to sort of you know chillax for about 60 75 minutes 90 minutes tops but you really shouldn't be playing this game with five players and four even is going to have limited use you mainly want to play this with three great with two good solo as well but it's just such a nice smooth game you know and and GR Ed the base set has issues possibly with the egg scoring mechanic I'm not going to deny that but I've got everything for this game Europe oana and Asia and I do feel that this probably would have dropped a bit more if it was only Bay set I still think the bay set is the best out of all three but with the expansions particularly Oceana took me a little bit to get used to but Oceana is definitely what keeps this one up in my top 20 because as well as having more birds with game end scoring which is always nice I like the new player boards and the nectar not so much the scoring for the nectar but the nectar allows you to play more big birds it allows you to do you know do a lot more card playing which is supposedly the meat of the game but also the boards

are new player boards and they balance out the free rows better so if you thought that the base set was a little bit skewed towards eggs and not enough food Use the Oceana boards because now all three rows are nicely balanced you know you can try the egg strategy in Ocean if you like and it will work out just fine but my strategy I'm employing isn't egg related in oana will do just fine as well so it it definitely does elevate it but yeah they've tried worms span and finpan and there are going to be people out there who claim that one of those two is the better of the three you're not going to convince me I mean I can totally see what why you might prefer one over the other that is totally fine but for me I see no reason to own any more than one of these you're going to have to pick wingspan worm span or finin span maybe if you have worms span you could own finpan because between the two there is quite a gap in terms of complexity but if wingspan is anywhere in your collection I don't personally see the need to own any of the other two Liar Liar get back witch that's just the way I feel but check out the reviews for more details because I have definitely stuck to this Trilogy Like Glue to you know and none of these have been review copies I mean these everything I have bought in relation to any span game has been my own copy so yeah there's no advert going on here this is my honest opinion on these but yeah I've talked a lot about it I still love this game it's still good fun whether you hate it or not Birds ran

don't 15 down from 11 this is four places this one tried to creep into the top 10 but didn't quite manage it although actually tell me about it I have a feeling this has been in my top 10 before it's just dropped out of it mainly because it hasn't had a few play but to be honest this game is still going to probably stay in my top 20 because I love this and this is probably out of all these games on this list ignoring detective Club because it's not that well heard of I don't know if I could call that I suppose you could call it underrated but it's a party game you know it's not saying that but in terms of Euro games this is criminally underrated pretty much nobody talks about this game and it is one the bezier games best games they have put out fact you know it is see it's Pudo sequel to another game they did but it's not really related to it they just have the same title and designer and publisher that but this is probably this is well not probably it is cuz I think it's up here this is one of the best worker placement games I have it is you know communal it is interactive it is a cool idea a cool concept and has near infinite variety this is whistle mountain and none enough people are playing this game and they really should be bezier really didn't do a good job job of like advertising this and the whole idea of calling it whistle Mountain making people think it was a sequel of Whistle Stop was just moronic they really should have just made it its own game same designer same publisher fine but you could have kept the same style of artwork and just made it its

own game and that would have meant people would have gravitated towards it more but this is so good it is Silky Smooth in its mechanics it's that classic I I believe it's um yeah it's got Luke Lor's uh sort of blood in it as well as you know the main designer and Luke Lori does a lot of games with the whole dynamic worker placement system where people take their workers off at different stages and Trigger effects when they do but the you know the game itself is brilliant why because of this the board that you build is built you have a basic board with some spots that you can go to with your free little derable blimp things but the rest of the stuff you go on is built by the players You're Building scaffolding pieces up this mountain basically and you're trying to get these Meo workers as high as possible for points but what you do on these scaffoldings is if you make it nice in the entier you'll score more points but if you make it untiy you'll be able to reach higher and get more points for the me but as you make these like scaffold pieces on them are resources so you land your blimps next door to the scaffolding pieces to collect resources and then when you've got like a group of scaffolds together that create like a big enough square or rectangle you can build these machines on top of those spots which not only promote your workers but they also like give you more action spaces that everybody can trigger like I said this is a communal worker placement board that everybody builds that concept is

not something you see very often in any worker placement game but doesn't that just sound infinitely more interesting than a lot of other work and placement games you've heard of so the way the board is laid out is going to be fundamentally different every single game you will not use every machine there's level one two and threes the level ones are pretty Bare Bones and standard but the level two's are different and the level threes are very different I like gamechanging abilities but people could decide that they're going to be just scaffold Builders they could focus on a t a particular level of machine and might be more focused on their workers so there are some different paths to Victory you can follow but it's one of those games that's wonderfully tactical I mean you might have a pseudo strategy in mind like I'm going to focus more on scaffolds or more on these machines and certainly some of the um cogs that you grab that give you endgame scoring and some other abilities will gear you no pun intended onto those aspects but the the fact that you have all these different spaces opening up as the game goes on makes this a wonderfully tactical experience because you'll be you you'll by the time you've had your turn I'll do this and this and then two other players start building on this board and suddenly you go that's a particularly nice spot there that you've just made you know what uhop and I go and you start fighting over the really nice spots until you build up so high the water level rises and some of these buildings go you know go kaput and can't be used anymore so the spaces start dwindling at the bottom as you build further up there's just a lot of really cool stuff in here and yes it is dry as

a bone there is no theme in this whatsoever but the rules are so easy to teach it's not a it's a midweight game through and through this is the true neutral of new of midweight gam so okay it's not light it's not heavy it's perfectly in the middle but the rule book is easy to follow it is easy to teach it is smooth gameplay it is highly variable gameplay this is a fantastic Euro game and not enough people know about it B your games bring it out in a second edition or something you know rethe it whatever do something with it or just make a push for it you know raise do another Kickstarter for it like a reprint or whatever and put my review on the page cuz I know I've reviewed this game I'm pretty certain I have but do something bring it more into the Limelight because it always goes down well when I show it to people and many people have just never heard of it and not gone near it because the cover and the title and all that is somewhat uninspired you know you shot yourselves in the foot with that one but seriously if you get a chance to play this for me I will gladly show you but if you find this cheap on sale somewhere and that honestly pick it up you won't regret it thank you Mr Carboy I'll take it under advice okay 14 is a new entry to the list yes this is the second of three new entries to the list if you were calling foul with the last one um You probably call foul with this one as well although I have definitely had this game for longer before I did this list but what can I

say I've been playing it quite a bit and I do really like it I've even pimped it up with a new insert that was made by a buddy I know from the various conventions I go to locally and he's made a very good 3D printed insert for this game which is great and I know folded spacer getting in on this bandwagon but this publisher just works for me you know they do so many good games for me because they take their time with games they don't release 10 games at once they don't rehash the same idea all the time they actually try something a little bit different and um you're going to have to hold on this one one of the best games that come out of last year yes set has already hit my 14th favorite game I really do enjoy this and you know it was set in stone from the first time I played it at the UK games Expo and I must admit UK games Expo doesn't normally give me a lot of games to look forward to but I demoed this with cge I got very lucky with the demo I heard mixed reviews of the Demers that cge have they do have quite a wide variety of people I think I got lucky cuz it was very good and from that demo I knew that this was a game that was going to be my most forward to game at Essen and it didn't disappoint this one is so much fun you know this cool space themed game where it's not about going out it's not about going out into space and Blasting enemy ships and all that stuff it's about communicating with aliens from out to space it's a more grounded theme which is really cool but

it's got a lot of mechanics that just sing to me like nobody's business you know I mean it's already not a difficult game to teach the rule book may seem big but a lot of it is pictorial samples and when you go about it it's not you know there's a lot of different options that this game does and that's where the complexity lies it's not the rules being complicated it's that there's a smallest Board of options you can do on your turn and it may be overwhelming that is why this is definitely a heavy game okay but you know the mechanics that I love in this firstly these alens you've got I think there six of these alens in the game five or six and basically when you get to about the oneir mark and the halfway point these two alen boards that you've randomly selected will flip over and introduce some new mechanics into the game some new cards some new ways of scoring I bring you love it's bringing love don't let it get away yeah the scoring is mostly fill up a space and get points but you know the new rules that they throw in are still quite cool and interesting but I like that the board has got a variable setup and as you go through the game the board twists around so that the loc the asteroids and the planets all end up in different areas again all well and good but I said that this one had a new insert for me it does yep A friend of mine has 3D printed an insert for me so this is now nicely packed in and yeah it kind of needs it that's one thing that's it does kind of need an insert but you know the main thing I love though is these cards I love games that give you multi-use cards multiuse cards just work so well with me

and this one is another great example all of these cards are unique all sorts of different effects and ways to score and cool tactical things that you can do but then for one particular action where you scan out it has an icon for use with that for other like free actions they have different icons to use with that you can play them for their main effect they also can be put underneath your uh income slot in order to generate you income in each round so they've got lots of different uses for these cards and so just having those cards you know is a cool angsty choice of what it is you're going to do the Aden Powers throw in some extra cards as well I particularly like one Aden faction that frows in these cards where you mark a point ahead on the victory Point track and when you catch up to that marker you get the benefit of the card on top of the when played effect and that's a formatic element because it's representing an Aden race that's far off into the distance and it takes AES for the messages to get there bonjour crazy gibberish not all the alens follow quite such a fmatic tie-in but I like the fact that they tried with this and made it work it's just a cool game it's it's well produced you know for it's a typical cge production but ah the mechanics just work for me in this you know the fact that it's a heavy game while still being relatively smooth to teach and then going right here's all your options what the hell are you going to do I love that because I know it's overwhelming for some some people don't gravitate to those type of games I really do because I I have the perfect

opportunity to basically just go right I'm going to pick this route go with it and see what happens and then if I play it straight after I choose a different route and I have a fundamentally different game you know stuff like ker works on that sense you know you've got all these different things you can do on the farming in there I already explained it in that segment you know having that where you can just pick something and go for it it works for me that is the type of game I really like and this one you know it wowed me in the demo it red me when I played it so much so that when I got my review copy for this at essm we went back to the premier in that uh um yeah Premier in that Paul Grogan and the whose turn is anyway podcast were uh staying at and with a guy there and one or two guys there we basically played this three times in a row okay I taught it three times effectively or twice actually yeah to different people but we played it three times in a row that's how much we enjoyed it it was just that much fun and there are not many games that I'm willing to do that would I play this three times in a row now probably not but I could see myself playing this twice in a row in fact to be honest most of these games on my uh you know top 20 are games that I would happy play straight after and more more often than not have done as well it's just a really solid game I really do enjoy it I dare not take out any more of this insor because it's a little bit of a Tetris thing to get it back in but yeah I know it's relatively soon but come on I've had this for long good in inventes of the South Tigress already this one is getting a lot of Buzz and deserve deservedly so not for everybody I get

why some people would be you know not blown away by it or find it a bit too overwhelming or if you're not into these tactical style games with a lot of options probably not for you but man good solo mode great multiplayer even if four players is a bit long I hope they release an expansion where they cut the round limit from five to four find some way to do that CG that would be most appreciated I'm sure you can find a way of doing it CU if not I might even house rule it but yeah I you know other than that little blemish still really enjoy this well that went okay I tell you when when you know you can't scratch that's when you you really have to huh number 13 is another new entry yes and you might call foul on this definitely um I know I've been breaking you know reiterating that quite a bit but um yeah have a guess what this one might be you know it came out recently in 2024 also at essm I kind of put these two next door to each other on the same top 10 list yeah there's not much else I can really say this one is what I consider to be the best game of 2024 and it is now already at my number 13 on my top 50 of all time and that is black forest well come on black forest the sequel to Glass Road I really like and I know some people prefer glass road to it but then some people prefer this one to Glass Road I still have glass Road I still think it's a solid game but it's a bit too chaotic with too many players because of the card system it's much better to play it with less but I really

do love glass um sorry Black Forest cuz they are quite similar it's easy to tie them up but black forest for me is the superior of the two this one is another one of those examples where you have so many options the rules super simple to teach I mean man it's easier than whistle Mountain to teach this game it is so easy and that's not based on the fact that you've played glass Ro before it helps because then you understand the resource Wheels which are fantastic but you know it doesn't matter it's not too difficult to teach all this stuff it's just another silky smooth game but you are faced with this map with all these different trades people that do all sorts of different actions and you've got to move your meeple around the different villages to utilize these trades people to micromanage about 10 plus resources on these two wheels which are such a good mechanic because it's not just simply a tracker for the resources there are primary and secondary resources and on each wheel the primary resources make the secondary resources but it does so whether you want it to or not the little clock spindles will turn if they are able to so if you have a chance to make glass you will convert your wood sand water and charcoal whatever it is to make glass even if you didn't want to because it drains all your primary resources which you might have wanted for something else you've got to do a lot of micromanaging planning with your resources but that's so much fun these resource Wheels work fantastically in glass Road and they work brilliantly here but it's less chaotic because you've got all the different buildings like in Cera which you can flip to their bsides for just like near infinite

variety and again all the options in the world for the game which is overwhelming for some I can see why that would put off people and usually that tends to be the the biggest bug bear people have with this game is having all those buildings at the start I love it but I can get why people wouldn't um but you know all those buildings to pick from all these different trades people and then everything else is Silky Smooth you basically move your meeple pay Provisions if you have to depending on distance pay a gift to another player which introduces some level of interaction you know there's not a huge amount of interaction in this game but the fact that players can move move the Trad people around and you have to give gifts to players if you go to the same places them does introduce a bit of a blocking mechanism so there is a little bit here and there but it's just so much fun to build up your little mini map of all these different you know these trees and these lakes and sand pits and you know these different buildings and get animals and you pick your path to Victory and it's a very slow Point scoring game so every Point matters it feels like any time you earn a point it is earned and you don't have to jump through a million Hoops to get point but you just don't end up with that many points period so it's it's rewarding while still having a lot of options I absolutely love this game and I am amazed that it didn't get as high of review as I thought on the dice tower but uh I think the wrong people reviewed it honestly I think I think it would have been better suited to a few other people like maybe Mike and stuff but you know I adore this so they may not have found it that great but I do this was a 10 out of 10 for me in the best game of 24 you know not necessarily easily I

mean set came damn close Okay but this one is easier to get to the table and a shorter time frame and that just kind of elevated it above set but yeah you want to call fou at these two games on 24 suddenly ended up here then Fair D but you know you can call me out on it maybe next year when we do this top 50 again and you see where they end up you know will they be in the same position or will I've got rid of the games or if they just dropped you or will they even go higher you never know but you know we'll wait till next year and see well we're Bor number 12 is down four places from eight this has now finally fallen out of the top 10 and I think it probably won't return to the top 10 and not to say I don't like this game okay I love it it's definitely I think my favorite two player only game although you could argue there's another game that's technically two player only although that did upgrade itself but you know in terms of the like I suppose I can't call it my favorite anymore all right my second favorite whatever but this is a great two-player game small you know short easy to learn particularly if you've already played its Big Brother predecessor it recently had a Lord of the Rings themed game onto it which as much as I think it's an excellent game a didn't need to be made cash grab like but also the fact that it's decent but it's not as good as Seven Wonders duel which I can't seem to find where the hell is my Seven Wonders duel there it is point point to the wrong place here we go Seven Wonders do is still just such a fun little tube

play a game and I've got Pantheon in here which makes the like the original game even better I think Jewel with Pantheon is like the perfect way to play this I found Agora just too much on top of everything you know it didn't feel like it was that interesting an expansion so I basically skipped it there's a fan um sorry there's a sort of uh print andplay solo mode that you can print off the repos production website which is quite cool to play with this nice and quick got an insert so it's nice and easy to get out on the table but oh man this is just such a cool game I mean you've got the open drafting of the cards three different ages the two auto win conditions and then the victory points to fall back on but I find myself winning with the three different things relatively equally I mean victory points maybe a little bit more often than the military and the green but I still you can't ignore the threat of the auto victories they are there and they can sneak up on you when you least expect it particularly if you let the other opponent you know go go nuts with them and don't try to reel them back in it's just a wonderful open draft tug-of war game where you're trying to you know plan out the best combo of cards to use and with Pantheon you can summon Gods with these special powers that also allow you to mess up the order in which you draft cards and that throws another cool tactical element onto the game it's just super simple you know pretty quick but it's got a wonderful sort of like weight time kind of like time to weight ratio if you want to call it that you know there's a decent amount of meat in this game for a game that doesn't take that long and isn't that difficult to teach even to someone who never played

any of the Seven Wonders games before but if you have played Seven Wonders then you know 50% of the rules in here anyway or at least you can recognize the Ion on the cards pretty well apart from a few new additions you know the Lord of the Rings one is an excellent game do not get me wrong I can't say that one is bad and one is good because they are 90% the same game but I think the area control aspect of Lord of the Rings is a weaker mechanic because you with victory points you don't necessarily know who's going to win on the victory points with the area controlled if it falls back to that you can already tell like ages in like you know ages before the game ends who's going to win on that so it just feels a bit anticlimactic and the area control is be bones anyway it's just a few spots that are generic there's no special ability with them or anything it's just here's a few spots try and control them wow the military tug of war in this it's just a race in the other game fun but not as fun stupid fat H you know I think the science was done better you know the the science in here is still really good but the science in The Lord of the Rings one I think was slightly better cuz you got more variety with the tokens but you know there's other aspects of like differences as well but they are fundamentally the same game and as much as I think you can buy either one of them and be have a fantastic time I much prefer Seven Wonders door and if you want to say that they are pretty much the same but I prefer Lord of the Rings then fine make this one Lord of the Rings Jewel whatever pick your poison it's basically just a a aesthetic thing really but you know with a few mechanics that you may or may not find IR you a little bit or you preferable but for me I'm sticking

with the original the civilization field 7even wonders door just fantastic throw yourself in next time in rivers of your stupidity and my 11 has creeped up a place from 12 it is trying to Edge its way into the top 10 and maybe it will it's this close it could do next year you never know particularly when the expansion comes out for it because maybe that will elevate it even more I am now able to say as much as you might be getting SI tired of it we are finally done with the Garfield games publisher yes I do like a lot of their games three of them in my top 20 okay you know none of them are in my top 10 although this one is fighting for it who knows if inventors could climb you know by next year I don't think VI counts will ever get up there I don't think it ever has but this is currently my favorite Garfield game that there is okay it is from the Tiger's Trilogy and the tiger Trilogy is a free for free all three games in the tiger Trilogy I think are excellent games but inventors is my second favorite Scholars is my third favorite aha gotcha now this is wayf farers of the South Tigers this is my favorite game that gari games have ever put out and this one is not quite as heavy as inventors although it is still pretty heavy but I love the card play system in this you are collecting cards you know on land on sea in space and you in various other scoring cards in the different character with special powers there's so much Variety in what you can

do different paths that you can follow but you're customizing the dice you use in order to make them better for the game that's really cool there's a decent amount of mitigation for the amount of you know dice that you roll but I love this like card playay system of getting the cards getting the tags using the special abilities on said cards to create your own little mini engine of zooming through the uh what do they call it the tapestry track or whatever it is scholar I think it was journal the journal track you know suiting through those but the journal track has different ways you can Branch off the different bonuses so that's still rewarding you might Rush the game might take your time that's a consideration but I like the way that the MEO and the card system s blend together because you've got different ways to get the cards and these tiles but you also have these meeples that you can use for different actions where the card slots are but the mles go on the cards so if somebody takes the card and your meeple those mles are on it they get the meeples so suddenly you can have a ton of these things or run out completely and that's a factor you've got to consider you might choose a card that's subpar compared to another card but it's got a meeple on it you know what that color mle would still be pretty useful the cards have got such a good amount of variety I mean you've got the towns folk the space cards the land cards the ca cards the land and CA cards have got two different versions of them the towns fol have all got different abilities the space cards are got different endgame scoring potential and you've got another set of cards you know on one other side that can potentially double those space cards if you can meet their criteria you know the mechanics of this game are not complicated but it's another one of those here's a smus board of options

have fun with it now inventors is a little bit more constrained than this one is it still gives you a bucketload of options but there is more of a route that you take here you can be a bit more flexible and that's why this one elevates itself over inventors even though I think inventors has a better solo mode than way fars but maybe the expansions will solve it for both cuz neither one of them have got the best solo modes ever but you know I tend to play this with a group of people who really like Garfield games and you know I still enjoy playing them solo because I love the mechanics of this so much it is a wonderful game I know again not for everybody this is you know the fact that the heaviest of the trilogies ends up being my favorite of the trilogies and some people are having my head off already the fact that paladins is nowhere to be seen I whatever I paladins is one of the reviews I kind of regret I gave it an eight out of 10 when I first reviewed it that dropped down to a six faster than you can blink it was like yeah I kind of made a mistake with that to review it's a 6 out of 10 for me at best and even then now probably even a 5 out of 10 I just find Paladin's average okay it's too dry to rinse repeat it's just not for me okay although if somebody wants to show me it with the expansion I would like to try it okay maybe that can elevate it but yeah they don't it doesn't come close I mean there are other Garfield games I like as well Raiders on the North Sea the new ship rights in the northc I really like um I wasn't a massive fan of the spin-offs I'm not as big of a fan of and I played Legacy of you the uh the spin-off variant of you Raiders I think Raiders

is better and Ezra nemiah I just found a little bit me you know but you these Trilogy ones they just seem to make games that really seem to me and their mechanics and their use of the same iconography that make learning the next game much easier to do you know this one is just it's so much fun I love it and easily my favorite now but who knows if this and inventors could switch places cuz honestly those two are butting heads a bit but almost in the top 10 can you do it next year we'll have to see it's about how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward okay that's it for the 20 through 11 we're soon on to the top 10 hopefully I can get that done for you uh the next top 10 I'm not going to give any clues about it you're just going to have to wait and see what turns up so that's it for me on this video I hope you enjoyed it let me know your comments down below do you love or hate these games do you agree or disagree with what I've said by all means let all have a chat about it because I've been loving the engagement on the other three videos so far uh hope to subscribe to the patreon if you can to help support the channel if faing that just subscribe to the channel in General on YouTube because your views and engagement is what keeps this going and makes it as fun as it is until next time remember it's only a game and I'll see you soon

Progress saved