Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hunt for The Ember Crown and Villains of Eriador Review - Journeys in Middle Earth Expansions

Transcript 14:39

all right for everyone who's just joining us I am Jack with the cardboard Herald and if you haven't seen it I have done a review of journeys in middle-earth both overall for the game and a post campaign final thoughts for the initial campaign bones of Arnor you can check that out but as opposed to the more tightly scripted version of those I have just last night finished the hunt for the Ember crown campaign the first DLC expansion ish campaign thingy and I have lots of footage I have lots of thoughts and so I thought I would take the time to talk through my thoughts on that campaign as well as the civilians of area door gear pack and that was sent to me so let's get straight to it for the overview what is this campaign so the hunt for the Ember crown is a campaign that took nine missions from my wife and I to complete it we played with two characters she was playing as Aragorn I was playing as Elena she's the captain I'm the bard and we played through nine chapters now what's interesting about this campaign is it felt like it could have been done in less chapters there were moments where you definitely felt like there were forking paths' this kind of felt like there were up to two kind of side missions within now the campaign itself is a story in which you

are searching for the amber crown a flower if you were expecting this to be Hindery in a dragon's hoard well I have news for you the amber crown is not a literal crown but you are doing it in the Blue Mountains which if you aren't up on your token lore the middle earth map has the Blue Mountains in the northwest of middle-earth beyond the Shire as opposed to the rest of the stories which tend to take place going from the Shire to the east and that alone gives it an interesting twist one of the things about the basic campaign is that it is very focused on having specific beats highlights of Toki knee and lower that you have to hit on right you know certain moments maybe they aren't literal moments that are replicating things from the books but they they are key moments where it's like oh if you're going to have a heroic campaign set in middle-earth and you have to do X and you have to do Y but by going to the Blue Mountains you're already setting it apart from the rest of the most well known stuff in at the Tolkien's library the actual nuts and bolts of the campaign I'm not going to get into the reason you're hunting for the amber crown but the other kind of guru the the other motif the theme that you'll be playing with is wargs there are a lot of wars in this and that's

going to take me to one of my favorite thing so we might as well get to the awesome stuff of this campaign is that the hunt for the amber crown gives you the first true villain or I guess antagonist would be the better way of putting it in journeys in middle-earth now don't get me wrong in the base game you had dole guitar and adder in which I mean they're fine but also pretty forgettable but in the hunt for the amber crown you have coal Fang which I love cool thing check out coal thing I actually painted coal thing which I haven't done a lot of painting in a long time so you can tell that I really cared a lot about coal thing now I don't think I'm spoiling too much because coal Fang is introduced from the very first mission and you get a lot of development of this character not to say that there's a lot of character development as in like changes like she's not a particularly nuanced character but for a board game and for a fantasy flight game this is one of the more intriguing characters antagonist or otherwise I was really delighted by that so already it has memorable characters that I'm invested in that aren't just to the player characters speaks to it being a more interesting story and campaign that you're playing through it was surprising because it doesn't have to replicate all of those

moments that you expect out of a Tolkien's outside of that the things I liked most are the forking paths' the the optional adventures but also the interesting things that you do within the campaign there are certain missions that were surprising in the victory conditions for the mission or the kind of twists and turns that it developed into something else that it wasn't initially it doesn't blow the whole game wide open and reinvent itself but I felt like pound for pound each mission was more interesting both from a setup perspective and it was more interesting in a tactical perspective with the two of us we were much more often working and I saying exactly what we needed to do in order to win and often it was by the skin of our teeth most often we did win in fact we won all but two chapters in this whole thing but they were very close calls and it felt like we had to be very smart in order to earn the wins that we had which feels really cool so I think that this campaign feels more interesting like an elevated version almost like a more concise and better version of the best parts of the base game campaign so that is really high praise now let's get into some of the things I think it could have done better first off this campaign while I think

the setting and the plot are far more interesting than the bones of our nor it tries to sound like toking himself which is fine like I'm not holding him up on a pedestal or anything but I think that he had a very particular sound to the writing and when it's done poorly when it's and when its imitated it's really noticeable and I wish that the writers FFG had kind of used their own voice yes he using the setting because I totally encourage and want to interpret middle-earth in any way that you can but I think it's a mistake to try to sound like the way of that Lord of the Rings sounds now speaking of this also seem to be a little bit less edited I did notice there were some spelling mistakes some formatting some typos in the text I mean there's a ton attacks and it's only 7 bucks for this DLC so I don't blame them because they had to get a bunch out and of course it wasn't the big main thing but it was noticeable compared to the original didn't hurt anything so I could care less the final thing that I would say is a criticism of this campaign is in some ways a little bit unfair because it's a criticism of the base game itself as well so that we did fantastic losing only one chapter up until the final confrontation we were a fantastic team I am a musician she's the

captain we're buffing each other constantly she can swing heavy I can do a lot of damage through Pierce and the people that I can't kill I can at least stun and when we got to the final mission I don't know what we could have done better but we lost and it's not because of bad luck because we crushed it like we were doing lots of damage and we were making full use of our capabilities and it wasn't because we sustained too much damage because we didn't die like we were surviving and making smart use of everything that we were doing and it wasn't that we made poor use of our actions because it felt like at least for everything else that we had done in the game with over 20 games under our belt leading up to this point we were making very smart and tactical use of our actions and yet we just ran out of time with only 24 possible threat that we could have burning at for a turn and nothing on the board that seemed to indicate that we would be occurring less threat we just did not have enough actions and I don't know if that's because we didn't have enough characters like if we were playing with a our character party would we have been able to do much better would it have scaled in a different way or was it because we just had a bad pairing of characters which seems ridiculous because like I said up until that point it felt like we were very powerful and

the thing about journeys in middle-earth this is it's a fail forward game and even if you failed the final mission you can't go back and redo anything and I really think that's a misstep on fantasy flights part it leaves you on kind of a sour note to finish this campaign and be like wow I guess everything that we work towards is all lost at this point and the only way that we're going to redeem it is to play through nine missions again and if you're averaging an hour to two hours per mission that's a huge amount of time and maybe their intent was that you were going to immediately play through again and it gave replay value but it actually I think does the opposite for me because if I had the ability to replay and study and learn and finish that campaign and feels fulfilled like my characters have a viable chance then I probably would immediately start again with new characters and be like okay now let's see what they do and see what these branching paths are and instead I'm kind of like I was a lot of fun and I really learned my characters and I liked that but I don't want to go through all the way again and then figure out that my two characters just don't really do enough at the end just make it so that if you failed the final mission that you have the ability to replay it I mean it's my stuff it's not costing Fantasy Flight anything for me to be able to do that I will play hunt for the Ember crown again I just don't know that it's going to be anytime soon I'll probably play it after I've played another new

campaign maybe I'll start through the whole saga all over again with some new characters maybe with some new expansion characters but speaking of which we need to talk about this here villains of area door now this is a figure pack that has three figures in it and if you remember from my base game review one of the concerns that I had with the game was that there weren't enough scopes and this gives you a unique for bull guitar and a Turin man they look super cool and then of course Kol Fang who we've already talked about and then there's also a couple of titles and some trinkets in here as a nice little bonus I really like this packet I think it's really cool that said gold guitar and uh Turin are not in the amber crown at all so I haven't used those figures yet I am surprised that at certain points in which there were work captain so that gold guitar wasn't used as an orc captain I mean come on he looks so cool famous he's like give us an option to use that if you mark that you have the content which is very easy to integrate then you have kool Fang who as I said looks incredible and I want to paint all three of these guys they are very well sculpted minis then the trinkets and titles I marks that I have this and I think the campaign itself the hunt for the amber crown is built in such a way that you are likely to get at least one of these things I didn't get

any of them I think I saw one moment in which I could have possibly gotten something and we weren't able to because of time left in that particular mission I mean I think this is cool and if it weren't sent to me I probably would get it myself but is it something that you are going to get knowing full well that if you've already played through at least the base game campaign you're not going to use two of those figures and the titles and trinkets might not come up if you are playing either campaign who knows they're just procedurally generated things that the system knows you do have and could possibly be something that you could obtain so I think they're cool and I think this pack is cool and I overall am really impressed with the amber crown campaign and think of it as the better campaign to play through and in fact would have no problem introducing someone to the game and saying you know what we're going to do ember crown because I think that's the cream of the crop but there are a couple concerns there that I hope you take into consideration when you're deciding what you want to get but if you like me you're a token guy and you already like it journeys in middle-earth I definitely recommend going through the campaign and then if you really really like your collections maybe you like doing a little bit of painting or you just want to have a little bit of everything or you really like the villains and intend to go through the campaigns again then well

villains of area door is there for you and that is it I know this was a little bit rambling but I had some Tolkien things to talk about I I wanted to just kind of run through my overall thoughts more of the videos like you'll find on this channel are much tighter put together and I think you will find something a little bit different there but if you liked this video you liked what I had to say or you have questions about anything poking middle-earth journeys in middle-earth anything around here let me know in the comments below thank you so much for watching I've been Jack the cardboard Herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard Harold calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Harold

Progress saved