Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 31:05

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for meadow uh which uh which this was one of those games that uh whenever we played it i actually immediately went to my top 10 of 2021 and i was like is this gonna make it it wouldn't have but it got pretty close i think it was like sitting at like 14 or 15. yeah uh this is a theme that i i genuinely enjoy like nature like wildlife just the relaxing kind of with nature facts even though no one actually gives a [ __ ] i'm just like oh did you know that wood is good for building chests um it's just so much fun the art is absolutely stunning in this uh carolina all right it looks like the illustrator she did a phenomenal job um i wonder if they're scandinavian there's something uh but this and so like this one wingspan mariposas uh parks all those are just delightful games and this is one of many that gets included in that group of one that i immediately had to own my own copy it's wonderful it's a set collection game at its core um it's not the best set collection game i've played but it's enjoyable it's relatively fast um even though you're not doing a whole lot uh and i think at some point i think the game goes on a little bit

longer than it needs to because we saw it with you mainly um is that i felt like probably about i think it was around four for you maybe maybe five but just kind of going through the motions of boom card boom card and that's the equivalent of top decking to me which i genuinely don't like like i didn't i didn't like that about um dwellings of elder veil how you could just be like oh victory points victory points and then another one the the panda one that moves around thomas i'm gonna say tamagotchi it's a t uh it's only where the panda you have to build up bamboo and then the panda can move around i know what you're talking about uh takanoko okay that's it um that one you can top deck objective points uh be like oh hey look at that i completed that and then just and this game does have that uh granted you do have to kind of set up a little bit but that was really the majority of what you were doing um well there's um the game is very simple and it could do with with i mean we just reviewed our knack and we had an expansion that made it more complex right this could do with something that makes it more complex yeah people want it this is even more simple than wingspan yeah um because like the the strategy i always use is there are thematically there are certain types of prey that all the current the carnivores come out when you pull out the north deck and those carnivores eat certain types of prey the medium prey so if you span out a bunch of medium prey and get

ready for that north that come out you can just go boom boom boom boom um yeah i was wondering because you have played this more than i have and i'm like oh did he figure out the meta yeah and i'm like i think he did there needs to be more complexity yeah i like this part of it the campsite and there is i will say like if you hit streamline because putting out 10 land isn't necessary and if you streamline that time rather than because if you got really really good at this game rather than putting a land out putting an animal out and like narrowing it down to a point of like you're just getting pure points and you're only having the amount of like bass prey and bass land that you need you could potentially do far better than than i did or any squirming no you're absolutely right and that was a conscious decision on my part was i wanted to see how a different strategy fared because yeah definitely having 10 uh lands out and then kind of doing a wide pre or wide scope then yeah you're gonna have way more options and i'm like can you do well with very limited lands and very limited um scenery or whatever landscapes i think um i had four total sceneries and then the objects you can find and then six total things i was well short of both of you and i was like i wonder if you can do well you can do all right i was 11 points behind that which is like three cards away you know three high cards greedy hasn't beat me doing scenery cards yeah because they're typically the higher points yeah i think last time though i didn't invest so much in the

scenery cards but this time with the hand that i had um i couldn't really get a lot of those like mid-tier cards because i was just like with what i had i had to keep getting like a bunch of blame yeah and that actually brings me to my biggest complaint of this game they do it once in the game where the board gets completely wiped i wish there was an action like it i it would have been amazing with any of these tiles for you as a campsite action to wipe a row or column like whenever you um take an action here the same way that you can put your points here just one time during the game you can wipe the keyboard yes which would be i really take that for this chill-ass game yeah yeah i wouldn't go so far as the whole board but if you're like because there were times where west was ass yeah it wasn't there was no sceneries that anyone could play no no items to grab and it's like well the only way you can get those are if you take one of the actions and let you draw three and whenever i drew three i would i got one scenery and i couldn't play it yeah so i'm like okay i guess i got that yeah so at least there's that but it is annoying where there was multiple times i'm looking and i'm like there's just nothing here yeah like everything i wanted to pick a random card there were plenty of times around like even if i played my pick a random card like there's nothing here right like how many times did you like me just play down take a card just so you could play a card you got earlier uh that take three action is really good for getting your bonus requirements yeah

if it's a good time for you if there's not many cards over here that you really need i i needed a wolf on one game i think and i drew three from the north deck prematurely before it came out in the first three rounds gotcha and like yeah i didn't even know you could draw from the north with that ability um which that's also how i did a lot better too i think i took three multiple times um my last game and i ended up going to the north deck because i was looking for specific things i don't it was just i think i got one card specifically at the beginning that kind of helped me um set up the rest of my game yeah but i would have liked more like bonus objectives i don't i don't much care for bonus objectives where like when me when me and you both got it i'm like okay that's an immediate wash it doesn't matter yeah like like i me getting nine points is as if you and i both got nothing but there was a point where you were you were going for i was going for uh this one oh okay you had a i think you had a um offense at some point i could be imagining that i thought you were going for one that i was going for and i was like oh no maybe i shouldn't go for that and i like i took a step back because i was like maybe i should just prematurely react and start going for something else yeah i was going for i was going for one where you placed your four because that's when i asked oh can you place it after because i was literally one term behind you placing my four so then i had to search for a house got it and then once i placed it i was like well this was pretty much just to nullify any distance between you and i

yeah and i would have liked i like endgame scoring to be more unique yeah where it's like to be fair though karini didn't even put a mark on here and if she had a presence on here it would have made a little bit more cut throughout yeah trying to be like oh [ __ ] okay because you know not everyone can get there so someone comes down to who can get there first right um but i mean i would have liked i like endgame in-game scoring those bonuses just like all right yeah i got it something else that i can do but and that's not really a complaint that's just kind of neutral my biggest thing is the fact that there were multiple times in this game where i'm just like i don't want any of these in a set collection game you kind of want to build up and the cards don't so i have to hope okay i'm gonna take this card and then hopefully by the time it comes back around to me there's something else that i want yeah which did end up happening but more often than not in this particular game i was like and that even happens in like middle of the year isn't it over here uh yeah the other set collection no because nida velir the reason why that one is i like that as a better set collection is because every card scores you points even if it's not something particular that you want at least you're like okay there's a purple here i'm not going for purples but that's five points yeah here it's like that doesn't even get me anything like i would say almost all of them get you at least one point except for the base like lands right but the base allows you to diversify and there is even there's there's road cards that require three of the same land type

which happened in our last game i think i was like [ __ ] but you also i do think this game does have a semblance of luck yeah where it's like okay i guess i'll just go there and take that card i don't need it but maybe and then another because that's like perfect for you and you're like okay now i can't even take it and that can be annoying um where i think every time i reach that point i just go for a lamp card if i ever left without anything because they're almost always attainable early in the game they're they're more popular and then later in the game they get less popular unless you need them for something and yeah but even if you don't eat them that second you're gonna need them in the future right and even if you don't like the at least you can be like okay well i'm gonna take this one i don't have a berry but i have all these [ __ ] cards i've collected throughout the past three rounds at least i can burn two cards to ignore that because i do have a mushroom yeah that i think that's their way of mitigating the randomness um but it's still not fun like ideally in a set collection game you want to constantly be like building up with your sets and that's something i think the velir does um there they are completely different games in the velir is simple but the rule book makes it seem complex yeah this is simple right out the gate uh so it's it's depending on what you want and set collection isn't something i ever really gravitate towards i'm always like oh a set collection game and i suspect they're going for a family game it's not really marketed as a family game because this isn't even though it looks cute it's very artful um

it's not necessarily it's not like a smash up type thing or a tokyo that's gonna necessarily appeal to kids i feel like this will appeal to mom or something situations right but and like you said this is simpler than wingspan absolutely i could play this with my mom and i think she would pick it up somewhat after the first game where i don't think my mom will pick up wingspan yeah she's and they they have announced an expansion already the i don't remember what it was called but it adds aquatic folk if i had to guess that probably will add more complexity yeah i this is a very digestible fun game but for me like i would play this if anyone brought that but hey you want to play mothers i'm like sure but i'm not like itching to play it because i feel like already i've seen it yeah and whenever we were initially going to record this i was like let's just do that too because having a third person doesn't matter yeah having a fourth person doesn't matter it's just maybe i still haven't played with four i want to at some point i absolutely do not because it really is solitaire the only thing is as with drafting it's like okay maybe they'll take something that i might want but at the end of the day it's only about what you get and this does have another problem that other games have where you could look at someone's board and be like okay i know i'm not winning like you had so many more cards just sheer card amount i was like well it was close and i was like well maybe but like maybe if cranny jumped in here but even if you didn't get your four four players though you might see more variety of cards because i do think that

that was like the biggest issue this time around because i didn't struggle with that the first time but like looking at it right now you can see quite a few cards that require berries yeah um and a while like we just kept getting cars that like required a bunch of berries but i think i only saw maybe two or three i got a berry at the beginning and i coasted off that for a little bit and eventually i just covered it yeah this game rewards diversification yeah like hardcore yeah and i think in those four player games while you can't plan for what moves people are going to take you can plan for all right i have like i i was constantly looking at my board do i have any doubles let's get into that double a hawk a deer or a wolf that blocks out that lane because there's nothing that eats that right the most part right um there might be special cards that do it but really they don't very often i think in a multiplayer i can't remember is this board the same is there another board there's i know there's a different campsite for a number no that's the same board okay so that's that's one of the reasons why i might not like it at more players because at three this is this is pretty tight especially whenever and i love that aspect i love the what card you take as reliant on the the token you have because that is some element of strategy where it's like okay i want both these cards okay i'm gonna place a one there and then i'm a four over on that side because this side's already taken so you you are you do have some options that's what it is you uh you lose your question mark token oh in a four player game

first oh okay okay good deal that's because i was sitting there and i'm like that's super tight like you're not getting [ __ ] that's the only the only scenario where you don't get that okay so okay so it opens up for because you're one less token yeah um but because i was i mentioned it during the run through i was like this these games give me anxiety drafting games because i'm like i just need i want that one i want that one i want that one and then it's like can you hurt [ __ ] hurry up hurry up damn it don't take that spot [ __ ] i was only thinking of that one spot okay and then if no one takes it them like because that's that happened a few times where uh even the first time we played i'd sit there and look at what like you and cat were like fiddling with and i'm like okay please don't place the one don't place the one and then they three and i'm like oh thank god all right and then you place immediately i need this one so it does give some excitement to the game um but for me i i do like complexity i would like to see um i don't know what they could add i don't know what they could add to make this complex because if you add text you know if you add weird i think obviously i i don't know there's because this is so simple it's so pure this is a very pure game and i love it for that um so the only thing i can think of that from that might make it more interesting is if you still have the whatever the objective tokens but maybe like some sagrada ask public objectives or maybe private objectives that you have like

you have a card that's like hey if you have five butterflies in your entire thing that's worth you know 25 points or something like that yeah um something that makes you unique that you might be going for that could be like oh hey i actually completed this right or maybe another deck of objective that you could choose to pull from if there's nothing out on the board you could you know take from that and maybe aim for different objectives could be interesting for sure um i'm trying to think oh one gripe this game more than a lot requires you needing specific symbols which is on the back of the rulebook of where those symbols are and how rare they are in each deck that needed to be a player aid for every player oh yeah i commit and the first commit had a problem where it's like oh here's one pamphlet for everyone to share on all these tiles it's like well you can print more i didn't pay for the game for me to do stuff uh that desperately needs to be something in their expansion a symbol sheet and maybe they didn't do it because they had an expansion planned so then they would have just had to print another one yeah i hope that's the case but that could be very annoying where you're looking for a very specific symbol and someone else is also doing it so i'm sitting here like i mean granted it is an easy look oh i need a treat okay east yeah but this game could be a lot quicker if everyone could just easily do that on their own turn and then boom i'm gonna go search your turn boom and then

especially if you have it there like sitting with you you can like outside of just making those decisions in advance you can also just um like eventually learn it a lot quicker yeah i think it's sort of me constantly having to like look over there if it's constantly there like while it's not your turn you can look at some of the other stuff as well like that you might eventually need in the future right if they just added another they could add another point mechanism to the game that's slightly more complex so like yeah so like the the bonus points aren't to wash if if people you know compete because really what it comes down to is if creamy did jump out it's whoever can get their four on their first and at the end of the day four points didn't make a difference yeah if it did then i'd be like oh man yeah that's really tight but in this case it was you had 69.

it would have been 65 to 58 and it's like okay well it still didn't matter and i don't feel any better yeah um although i do think no i think in the first game you and i played we both got our points on there so it didn't matter then either uh so this game is definitely on its way um but in terms of like the nature style games it's definitely better in parks parks is fine very pretty uh but i think i do like wingspan and mirror poses better just because they are a little bit more complex for me and they scratch that same itch yeah but i do own this i did go out and buy it and i am excited for the expansion i might look into that a little bit more to see if they add anything because i would hate for them oh everedo i guess is another woodland forest which is that one's more complex i think out of all of them we played wingspan and mariposa but we haven't played everedah yet i think you guys played mariposa i played mariposa's is weirdly like complex we played it wrong but it was like you're sitting there and you're like okay i'm getting like we we messed it up and we didn't realize the butterflies had to go back yeah they do immigration yeah i mean none of us did it and we're like oh well that was fun yeah it's a really cool game i remember playing mirror poses and i was like i was flying all the way out there and i was like oh my god i have one turn to get them back i'm gonna get one i got one butterfly coming back yeah that one is weirdly deep everdail also has depth to it that you're like oh man i'm building my tableau and then i'm done i'm already in

the next phase and someone's like really just resource energy like at their engine and they're because you you advance uh the seasons on your own so if you pass you go into autumn but if people can energize and use their workers and resources efficiently they can be in spring and if someone is playing poorly they might their game might be over yeah it's one of those it's player based so like your game might be over before my game yeah if if i play better than you or however it might go interesting it's really really good also same kind of vibe in terms of theme yeah uh so this is it's still good like and i think the reason i'm being more hard on is just because there are other games that have come out before it and it's like i i really like this and i just want more out of it so we'll see or even with cards with abilities i mean they could take a note from wingspan i might make it too crazy but that's what i was thinking i was like that's why i was like well if you had text then the game down yeah because right now iconography would have to be the way that they would go exactly which also makes it weirdly complex it becomes seven wonders where it's like that's a gateway game no it's not here's your book of icons figure it out uh because that's what i was saying this game is so pure we can look at one card and immediately know what we need from that and how to grab it and how to play it which is fantastic especially with the game with icons for it to just be so boom and then play it but i would like some more where maybe prevention of

not necessarily top decking but essentially top decking where it's like i'm gonna go here and then just your turn go here and just like right it's like oh well it's a point engine we just played uh lost ruins uh of our knack totally different game but the same idea of i'm just buying cards for points at this point yeah i don't like that i'd rather you gain points throughout and then utilize everything instead of just being like bye bye bye bye yeah that's points right and this kind of has that um other than that like like solid game so we'll see we'll see where it goes uh you guys got anything else nope on a scale of one to ten uh what would you guys give meadow um i think i would actually give it an eight again even though it's like i feel like it has a lot of room to improve but and while you said it wouldn't be something that like you'd want to play a lot i think it's something that i enjoy playing and maybe it is because of just the art of it i think it's just enjoyable to look at it's so pretty this is this card man i was like man i had like i think i got rid of them yeah two fence cards i'm like should i just blow the game just to be like because i was like maybe i might have a chance uh i was like should i just get these two one pointers just so i can have this yeah it's so pretty and i don't know what kind of art style you give this but it's so good it's all watercolor right

it does it does it just kind of looks like watercolor it's like realistic illustrative yeah like it's very very colorful um but it is i don't know it's not cartoon everdell's not cartoony but it's different this has a semblance of like i don't know maybe it is because it's just watercolor that it comes out it pops a little bit more uh it's kind of reminiscent to like those audubon paintings you know but it's like not quite as it's not oh you know the what the ideal of what like nature illustrations are like those are a little more like print looking but like these kind of have that same feel where it's just like this like a thing in nature yeah that thing in nature like somebody sat there like saw this thing and decided to draw it yeah you're right it is it comes off more as yeah it reminds me this wasn't the picture that someone took of that part yeah yeah it reminds me of stuff that like they would try to have us do like an art school or whatever but yeah i don't know i think that's probably one of my main things and it's an easy game like you said i think the iconography is like um pretty like i don't want to say cut and dry but it's just like very easy to read and it's like pretty easy to understand but still has like different aspects there isn't a massive lag time in between turns which i think is important even though i was like yeah no and that's mainly on me in any drafting game i immediately and i usually play drafting games at lower player accounts because i don't want to

wait for anyone starting yeah role player i'm like when you're playing like a family game and you have like i could teach this to my daughter and that starts to develop those like planning ahead themes that are in other games yeah whereas wingspan you might be waiting 15 minutes and then i get to take this action this action right this action wait wait wait like hold on that lets me bury 15 birds because this is a murder bird reminds me of a story yeah this has no stories unless you read the the uh the almanac book which even still it doesn't really have stories it's just it's like a quick this is a [ __ ]

well that's the thing is like because wingspan has the little quick snippet of what the bird is i like the fact that they have it here it could easily have been on the card if they made the cards bigger yeah like if they were standard cards and i like the fact that they're smaller and at least i mean i'll take that like that gives some semblance of theme you get to at least enjoy oh hey i found i got a you know a bird or a butterfly now one thing we were talking about a thing that they could do and this is would just be straight stolen from middle ear uh i think that's how it's pronounced i think it's knit a velir that you could upgrade these through a system and yeah bonus actions when you take actions with them yeah that would be cool that would be interesting i do like the fact that you have to decide okay am i gonna need my one or my three at any point and you're like okay no i don't need my three and you pop it over there do its ability and then a new card comes like i need specifically a three and that's why i would never want to play this at four because the question mark gives you that coverage yeah uh so it gives it a little bit freedom versus a four player game where you would just be like you i feel like you would be at the whim of the deck a lot more and i wouldn't enjoy it as much um not that this is a game to be taken seriously but like i play respect the game try to win um and i like to have a little bit more control to token it because i'm never going to buy roads i'm just going to get rid of that that was my only hope because i wasn't getting any cards down here i'm like all right scenery that's that's my that's my chance but i think that's i even when i am like a little irritated

by some i'm never as frustrated as some other games with this because it is like i kind of just don't feel like i'm a pressure because i yeah it is what it is or i mean that's why that's why i like the dual actions because it's like oh man i use i used up the only number i can use to get that card yeah or it's all blocked off and even though there's three options to get somewhere well i still have my one i'll pop it over here and then that lets me just take any card yeah really the only control i'd like is be able to not wipe the whole board that would just be awful it would just like because then you have to set it all up again but maybe a row or a column yeah like instead of using one of these like it said you just don't take a card but you can wipe it or you can wipe it and still take a card yeah i that would be nice you know what i bet they could do is um oh i had it because i was thinking of um i bet you the water ones are gonna have completely different icons that only water so it might muddy up the depending on how they do the deck it might muddy it up but you're going to go more aquatic you either go aquatic or you go land and very few use each other i mean because you might get a bird that does eat fish because they dive in there yeah that's probably where the complexities get where you're really looking for so if they're gonna do that then they might have to find different ways for you to cycle through the cards a lot more yeah well i was gonna say i mean if they have like a two different iconography on them like newer cards i feel like it might make it

difficult to like incorporate like these cards into that i was almost wondering if they'd be a separate board yeah hey here's the land and then here's you know river swamp ocean like i said it's a separate thing um because it is an expansion and it doesn't seem like it's standalone so it has to tie in in some way yeah uh zach what was your score you give it eight um because you also played it solo yeah and it's it's really good solo um i i'll probably get i'll probably get bored with it myself um but it'll also probably get played because it's light and we can sit and drink beer and talk like while you're playing it it's also it can be very crunchy like there any game that gets you to the moment where you're like oh [ __ ] what am i going to do oh you took that spot right there's something good about the game if it's that if it's that right and that's why i'm not sitting here going like i'd rather play splendor than that you know like at least this has some thought behind it um but yeah i would probably give it a seven as of now yeah no that's that's exactly where i'm at as a seven it like if i was giving i'd give it an eight for art like to go up to art but in terms of than wingspan in this gameplay wingspan is definitely more illustrator i mean there's no scenery it's just it's just a bird um but like comparing it to all the other nature games uh everedell just kills it

with its art because it that tells stories the way you build your tableau because you're building a village uh obviously completely different games but same type of theme idea but i i i was kind of thinking the same thing i was like i play this a few times yeah i think that's it you know but if people would be like oh we're playing melees you won't play oh how many are there four no three okay i'll jump in i'll jump in and play with three uh but honestly i might enjoy this at two like it's a lot more i think it's not as tight when it's just two players right yeah so this game almost leans as if it wants it to be very casual so a two-player game where it's like okay like no one you're not taking any of my cards i'm not taking of yours we're just really just chill playing a fun beautiful game yeah yeah so i don't know if this was on anyone's top 10 of 2021 uh dice howard did a bunch of reviews with like the b team and the a team yeah that was the most it was on the b team i think it was um or the a team is whatever they call themselves what's the uh the pirate game pirate code pirates merchant's merchant cubs was that was a common one but this one was probably the most common i think so now that yeah i forgot about the the a team that did it uh this was on their list yeah so and i totally get it like it's very delightful so here's hoping the expansion brings some life into it uh but we'll see all right so that's our thoughts on

meadow let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved