Bismarck Solitaire | Review
Transcript
hey gamers this is liz davidson for beyond solitaire and today i'm going to be reviewing bismarck solitaire book game from worthington games all right so here we have bismarck solitaire this is i think the first game book actually in the worthington game book series i've previously reviewed waterloo solitaire on this channel but bismarck solitaire is about the bismarck which was a german boat during world war ii basically what's gonna happen in this game is we control the bismarck the prince oregon and a u-boat and we go around the map trying to search out and battle and sink british ships and they're trying to do the same thing to us so i'm going to show you how that works in book form when you open up this book you get a table of contents and the game rules are coming up but if you look at the content you're also going to notice there's one training cruise but then there are actually only eight missions and there are three copies of each mission in the book so what's happening there is that some people are going to want to do things like scan or make copies of the maps in order to preserve these books for longer other people just like to write on the book and so worthy thought of that when they printed this and there are three copies of each mission so that you can essentially have three clean sheets to work on without worrying about making any copies or scans or anything like that because multiple attempts are built into the book that does mean that there are only eight missions but you're going to lose sometimes maybe you'll succeed the mission but you won't get the special medal at the end and you're going to want to try again anyway so trying again is built into the structure of the game including how the book is printed
i've been using a tablet to play so i'm going to show you what my tablet looks like but give me a moment before we get there so once again we have all the rules i don't like this horizontal format very much because it's irritating to read but all the rules are there it is fairly convenient and simple and they're short which i can't complain about after you finish the rules and you get some design and historical notes you're also going to get a little example of play and there are some things missing from this example play that i wish had been put in but i'll get to those in the final thoughts for now let's actually have a quick look at the game so you can get a sense of weather's for you so here's our training cruise and i don't want you to freak out when you look at it it looks like there's a lot going on it's a little crazy but actually it's not so bad these grids up here are things that can happen based on die rolls and where your boats are located and then this lower page is your actual search grid this is where you're going to be moving your boats there's a turn sequence of play to remind you what to do you get health information about each of the ships that could be involved in the game and then here you actually get some battle tactics because this game actually includes a little bit of variety in terms of how you choose to press an attack during ship combat this training cruise is super simple you're basically just trying to sync any british ships that you encounter and then get safely back to port it tells you how to win right here you need to return the bismarck to either bergen or brest which are safe ports after turn 15. on each of these games the game will automatically end after turn 20 so you definitely want to meet your goals before turn 20 or else you
won't be victorious however the goals get a lot more complicated as you go so let's just flip forward so for this mission it's open season on convoys and you're trying to engage and attack all convoys and enemy ships without discretion your goal for this one to win is to earn five or more victory points and then return the bismarck to berg in your breast after turn 16. you also get a medal if you sink to convoys so basically this mission is more complex you have more of a specific goal and there's also different conditions for winning and then winning with special honors well let's go back to the simple training cruise i'm going to show you how i like to do this so maybe you get a sense of what you would want especially if you have an ipad so basically here's my ipad what i did was take a scan of this page down here and then i put it in notability and now with notability i can make an erase notes with my apple pencil so i can basically play this game and then clean it up and have a clean copy anytime i want so basically as part of setup you get to put the bismarck and the prince oregon in row a somewhere between columns five to eight i can put the bismarck here and the prince oregon can start in the same spot and just write b and p and then the u-boat can start anywhere in columns one to four so let's say that i want to just put my u-boat here just kind of creeping off the coast of iceland so now that i've started with where my guys are i can start a turn so why am i just walking through a turn so you can see about how things go so the turn sequence is going to be over here i just keep the book open and the
ipad on the book while i play although i could shrink things down and see it here i like to have a nice big play space and then if i damage stuff i do it down here so you roll two dice to determine the event chart used for the turn they recommend you use a white diet and a black but let's just use a blue and a black and we'll roll them so in this case we have a blue six we'll say that's the white die and then a two so basically what will happen is you're gonna go to whatever the white six options are and then the two is going to tell you which of the events you're going to do so this is actually pretty rough this is event heavy cruisers roll two ship combat dice apply hits on one to three to the bismarck or to the prince oregon and i know that this is going to impact me because i'm actually in the part of the grid that this covers so the main thing to note is that different things will happen depending on what your die roll is and depending on where you are on the map nothing's going to happen at all so if i want to go into convoy hunts i want to be down in this part hoping to get a dive result like this so that i can get into combat with a british ship and hopefully sink it if i'm trying to hide out up here in the top corner i can have some rough weather but if i'm over here the rough weather won't impact me at all so basically you need to be looking at these thinking about what you're kind of hoping will happen in the game if you're trying to coast safely you might make different choices than if you're trying to get into it with a british ship and you're going to choose kind of what do you think your odds are
of getting certain die results and place your ships accordingly so basically what's going to happen now is we're going to resolve our heavy cruiser attack the yuba's just kind of cruising into the water and hidden but the heavy cruisers are going to attack the um bismarck and the prince wiggin since it says we can apply hits the bismarck or the prince then we're worried to choose so let's just roll these two dice so actually we lucked out because it only hits on a one to three so we have a six and a five nobody got hit no damage has to be applied but if it had been applied we would have come down here and checked it off on these boats so we're gonna come down here and talk about this in just a moment then now that we've resolved our event um if there were air attacks we'd resolve those if there were u-boat attacks so the u-boot gets to kind of torpedo people from afar we would resolve that there is no ship combat then we get to move our ships and mark their location so a lot of this game is just moving your ships around as cleverly as possible uh and then you'll mark the turn and repeat the sequence so each of these can move a different distance so let's have a look over here so the bismarck can move up to two the prince oregon can move to three and the u-boat can move one you have extra fuel barrels that you can use one per turn in order to kind of juice your move up just a little bit more if you really feel that you need to do that there is an event that takes away all your extra fuel so don't sit around for too long because you'll probably lose it so let's say that i want the u-boat to come here
and then i want to move the bismarck of the prince oregon just down a couple so i could do that and then that would be my movie for the turn we'd mark off the turn what happened and we would keep going so rather than turn this into a long tutorial basically what i want to do is show you the rest of this page i'll show it to you on paper so i've shown you how i use an ipad to mark my movements up here but basically you have different information about ship power so we know how many attack dice a ship can roll based on that red rectangle to the left of each ship we know how many hits a ship can take based on these little squares here so basically every time a ship takes a hit you mark it off uh on your page and here we have german ship movement these green circles are the victory points that each of these ships is worth when you sync them so basically most of the information you need is on the page as for ship combat basically what happens is if you happen to roll an event where you encounter another ship they see you you see them and you get into a combat the germans get to try to hit first then the british but basically what will happen is that everybody rolls dice according to their attack power and you allocate hits based on who is there so for example if we only came across the hms king george v and i had the bismarck of the prince awaken together then the bismarck and the prince of oegan would both hit this ship but the king
george v would attack the bismarck if you are in a two-on-two ship combat then the first ship will attack the bismarck the second will attack the prince oregon and if for some reason there are three attacks it'll go bismarck oygan bismarck if the bismarck is by itself then it's going to take all those attacks and you want to be sure that you're careful because the bismarck can take a lot of hits but if you lose the bismarck you lose the game the other thing that's sort of interesting about battle is that you also get to choose tactics so you can choose to close in which can be a little bit risky but it also gets you an extra die you can go long range which protects you a little bit more but you lose some firepower and in every round after the first you can try to evade and into the battle so you roll to do that maybe you escape maybe you don't but you can try the british ships will also attempt to escape once they have less combined strength than you do in a combat so this can look a little bit complicated but really all you're doing is moving ships around the grid hoping to encounter or not encounter various events that you can roll on each turn resolving those events and making some strategic choices when you're in combat and then usually the end of the mission you want to get the bismarck and hopefully the prince of again as well back to one of your safe ports in bergen or breast all right so now for some final thoughts bismarck solitaire is very good fun and i actually really enjoy it to be frank i enjoy it more than i enjoy waterloo solitaire and i think i know the reason why what i like about bismarck solitary is that you're moving around it's a less static game i enjoy trying to creep across the map
trying to avoid areas that i know are dangerous maybe being tempted by those same areas if i want to take a shortcut or if i want to like go for broke and i really enjoy trying to decide where my different ships should be so you know do you want to keep the bismarck and the prince oregon together as you normally would or do you want to split them up for higher risk but maybe the potential for greater glory there's a lot of good dramatic fun to be had just sort of slinking around the search grid and hoping for the best when it comes to die rolls i also really like that even though the game is a book it has a lot of drama and excitement to it i really love that in combat you get to choose if you want to just have normal combat close in or go after someone at range with various consequences for that and i like the frustration and satisfaction of hunting down a ship maybe across multiple turns and then finally syncing it this game also is good about encouraging you to keep trying if you don't do amazingly the first time because you might get the victory points you need to win but you don't fulfill the metal condition or maybe you do get a medal but you want to try for a different ship or you just want to try something different this game gives you space to try the game multiple times and it gives you the motivation to kind of keep coming back and trying something new so overall i really think bismarck solitaire is an excellent solo game especially for something that is just so simple and so portable is it the deepest
game in the whole world no but it's a really good time and that really good time is made with so few components that i really can't help be impressed that said there are things about it that aren't perfect one is that because events are controlled by die rolls you could have a whole bunch of turns in a row where nothing really happens and like that's just part of the game but it can also get very frustrating if you get too many rolls in a row where it's not even that you know the whole fleet is on you and you're in danger because you kind of knew that could happen if you go to certain parts of the grid it's more when things keep happening that don't affect you at all and your whole turn is just moving somewhere else and hoping something exciting will happen next time generally it doesn't get that bad but the fact that there are kind of a lot of wasted turns doesn't always do it for me especially if it happens a lot over the course of a single game the other quibble i have with this one and i got it worked out is that the rules for ship combat like it just took me a second to understand what they meant so basically for combat if the bismarck and the prince oregon are together on the search grid in the same grid then they can take on a ship together but if they're in the same zone only the bismarck engages in combat and nothing happens to the prince of again and having to read those instructions a couple of times frustrated me mainly because it would have been really easy to provide a combat example um they actually have a detailed example of play before you get to the actual games in the book and it would have been nice to have a detailed example of play that showed off some of the trickier stuff instead of only the
obvious easy stuff that i already got from reading the rules before i ever got to the actual game so i mean i just reread everything a couple times i got it figured out it was fine the rules are in fact all there the information is all there so you'll get there too but i just saw a missed opportunity to make something even easier and more accessible and it you know mildly irritated me and the other it's not a complaint it's more of a taste issue about this game is the fact is you are playing a nazi boat and if you don't like to play world war ii germany you're not going to enjoy this game so unlike waterloo solitaire we play both sides some is napoleon and some as his opponents you always are the germans in bismarck solitaire you're always in favor of the bismarck and there are little thematic elements of the book that really play that up it's like this sounds stupid but even the fonts they're very like nazi germany tastic in this book and the medals that you win look like some memorabilia that you feel really uncomfortable finding in your grandpa's attic did that stop me from enjoying this game no did it stop me from buying and playing this game i mean obviously it did not but if that makes you uncomfortable that's something that you need to take into account when you pick up this game because even like the little font and like graphic imagery choices really remind you who you're gonna be in this uh in this particular game and you need to be sure going in that that's going to be fun for you i will admit that there were times when i felt maybe mildly uncomfortable playing the game because i was thinking
about who i was playing as but overall you know i really enjoyed bismarck solitaire i thought it was a really good game i would actually like to see more games in this system maybe with like pirates or star trek or you know anything that kind of involves being a ship hunting other ships in a grid because i thought that this system actually worked really well and i think that you could probably do more with it because the game book was such a good start so if you're looking for a portable relatively cheap solo game that has some excitement and some sneaking around and some dramatic die rolls then i think the bismarck solitaire might be a really good choice for you i personally really enjoyed it of the two worthington book games i've played so far waterloo solitaire and bismarck solitaire i think it's the more fun of the two and i liked both and i'll be looking forward to more from this series and might be about to go check amazon for some more of these books so thank you so much for watching please like subscribe support me on patreon anything that will help make my channel grow but most of all happy gaming
you