Do you like drawing cards?
Transcript
Hello everybody and welcome to another video here at Playing Board Games. Today I'm going to be talking about card draw in Arkham Horror the card game. Card draw is very good in like pretty much every card game that exists. It's a card game, right? The more cards you have, the better you have a chance of winning. Generally, if there is a style of game that you're playing, interacting with more of the mechanic that is the name of the style is really good. An example of this is a worker placement game. the more workers you have, the more actions you can take, the more likely you are to win the game. It's like one of those things where uh it's just it gives you more resources, it gives you more things to play with, and it just generally makes you able to do more and face the challenges that you you get through. You'll find that most often the struggle the time you struggle most with Arkham is when you've run out of cards in hand.
When you are looking and scraping the bottom of the barrel desperately trying to find some sort of a solution to a problem. That's when you are not able to solve the problems that appear. So card draw is just the way for you to be able to stay at pace or ahead of the game and the solution and have solutions for the problems that it throws on you. Arkham is a very interesting sort of card game because it has a basic action to just draw a card. Uh it's something that is okay to do in a pinch, but you don't want to be looking at it for your main source of card draw. But if you ever have an a dead action, you can just like I'm going to draw a card. I'm going to just see if I can get some more options here. Maybe you're digging for a solution and it's just something that is is available to you. But it doesn't mean that it is the best form of card draw that you can have. You can do it. It's acceptable. You'll do it in a pinch.
You'll do it during downtime, but it's not the thing you're looking at the most. I think Arkham would be a much different game if the card draw action did not exist. I think we can all agree on that because then you would need to like have some like I think your deck would be more warped to running card draw than it already is to be fair. But it's one of those things where I actually think the draw a card action allows Arkham to be more open for how you approach a deck building. It it it requires less of a demand on finding cards that draw cards and allows you to have more ability to play crazy things and play efficiently and just like take risks with your deck building, right? Arkham is a game that allows players to take risks and I think a big part of that is the draw a card action that's available to players.
However, there are is a variety of different ways to draw cards that is kind of I think um getting to be a little bit I don't want to say problematic, but it's like one of those things like when we talk about this in the legacy environment, which is this video is going to be focusing on the legacy environment. card draw and card selection is becoming uh it's like it it's always available, right? It's like always there, always like functional, and it means that you're able to just find the best cards that you want. This is true for a lot of classes, right? So, like every class has some form of the card draw we're going to talk about here. They might not be able to hit on all of it, but there is just like these options. And when you look at them individually like we're going to be looking at here, it becomes very um it becomes very uh like it's it's very fine, right? Like you could individually you could be like, "Yeah, this is a great option for drawing cards." But when we start stacking them all together, our decks become way too consistent. And this is actually something I've talked about previously on uh a Hot Takes video where card draw is becoming too dangerous. And I think that card draw a has kind of stayed pretty powerful um pretty like a parody for power level for a long time. But I think that the actuality was that I think I said in that video was that this like the the
payoffs have become stronger, right? Like your payoffs are becoming stronger so card draw inherently becomes stronger. And I think that is generically true, right? Like an example of this is like survivors would just try to draw a bunch of cards, right? And they were able to use those cards to advance the game state. But now survivors are drawing cards and because they have a nautical charts in play, all of those cards that they're drawing are deductions, right? So like they can take the excess card draw and get there. They're also drawing for a copy of Laner, which is a very powerful card. They're finding um glassing so they can get more clues. They're finding lion weight, which I don't think is on the par the level of of glassing, but I think is still very powerful. And like this is when like card draw starts to become kind of a big big issue. So, this is kind of one of those things where I'm talking about um uh card draw in terms of what I think are like the healthy levels of card draw and what I think is the card draw that is beginning to become a little bit too powerful. And I think this is kind of assessment for like when you are playing and when you're deck building, you can kind of use this to control the power level of your deck, right? If you want to have a lot of um if you're if you want your deck to be super duper duper powerful, put in all the bottom the last category
I talked about. If you want your card draw to be pretty fair and reasonable at the pace that I think Arkham originally existed, you can go for the earlier tiers, right? So, it's kind of like an idea where if you are a a deck builder looking for a powerful deck, this is for you. If you're looking for how to make your deck less powerful and more uh in line with what you want for your Arkham experience, this video is also for you. This video is also I hope for
[snorts]
uh people who are designing custom Arkham content or even just like the the idea of what card draw is because I think that card draw is uh a good part of the game. It's a healthy part of the game and I think the basic draw action should be expanded, but I also think that there should be sort of a rain on what we view to be quote unquote healthy card draw and quote unquote unhealthy card draw, right? So I think that's kind of our thesis. So, why don't we dive in and start going first? We're going to talk about some forms of what I view to be healthy card draw. Now, this is not the only I'm actually going to grab one more card while we're here as well, cuz I think there's another card that I think is I scrolled right past it. Um, going to get this up here as well. Um, I think that like these uh examples, we we'll have the four examples here and we'll kind of talk about them are what I consider to be healthy card draw. Now, there are levels to this health uh where some of them might be stronger than the others, but I think that this is considered to be what I think is the healthiest form of card draw. This card draw is essentially enhancing the basic action, right? So, this is the basic action of drawing a card but expanded so with other things. Right? So, so example here we have scroll of prophecies. This is a is a a great card that I see Travis play a lot. Travis loves this card. It goes up on higher player counts. Uh during Major League Arkham, I've seen a lot of people play this card because Daisy, it's a toone for her to work with and this being free action is really
nice. But what does this card actually do? Right, you spend three resources in an action to put it into play. So already you're down one action, right? So you could have used that action to just draw a card. The second time you use this, you spend an action and you draw three, then discard one. So you're essentially drawing two cards, right? You have to discard a card from your hand. I'm not going to talk about all the edge cases where you can use that discard to your advantage, but the idea is that you have now spent two actions to draw two cards essentially with how we are. But then we get to our third uh our third action, our second activation of this. We are now up to four cards and then it goes up to six and then eight. So, we're kind of like slowly getting ahead. So, for five actions in total, we're up three cards. But drawing three cards and then discarding one is kind of like the edge of card selection, right?
So like this to me is a healthy card for card [snorts] draw because its rate is just slightly above the basic draw action, but it's up enough that it has the payoff of card selection that it becomes better. So, it's like the idea is I'm going to play Scroll of Prophecies with the intention of uh that dead action where I would draw a card. I'm instead going to draw three and discard one or alternatively help someone else at my table find cards as well because there is also the use case where that this can draw for other people which is also adds to the power. But again, I think that this is just a nice, clean, healthy way to draw cards that stays at a rate that is pretty efficient with um with what the game originally kind of existed. And this came out in Dream Meteor, so this has been here for a while. Another card that is very similar to this is Old Book of Lore. So, this one's from the original core. And now this one does have some slight issues where um the action for this part is like below rate for investigators that aren't Daisy Walker or uh let's say Mandy Thompson or in some worlds I could also see like Harvey Walters trying to run this card.
Right? So this is exhausted. Choose an investigation. that investigator searches the top three cards of his or her deck for cards and draw it and shuffles the remaining cards into their deck. So if we go back to the action rate, one action does nothing. So we basically have done none of the stuff that we want. Second action, we have drawn a card, but we get to look at three. So we have card selection. Card selection is stronger than just drawing a card because it's you get to choose the the best card of three to draw, right? like that just checks out. I want to draw the best of three cards. Uh so drawing the best of three cards is better than drawing a card generally, right? Like that's just generally how it is. But if we look at Old Book of Lore again, even with this, we're down in action to draw a card, right? So like the rate is still under, but it's balanced out a bit by the fact that it is card selection. And again, I think that this is a healthy form of card draw. This is the kind of card draw that we're looking at and being like, I can I can get behind this. A recent example of this one actually is very similar is the mysterious Grimmoire. This new card from the new core. I think this is a good thing to check out here. Three cost two experience. Uses four secrets as a lightning bolt. During your turn, spend one or two secrets and exhaust mysterious Grimmoire. Search top three or six cards if you spend two secrets of your deck for a card and draw it. If one or more weaknesses are among the search cards, draw them as well. Mysterious Grimmire and Old Book of Lore, which is
right here, are actually very similar cards. It's kind of like this is an upgraded version of Old Book of Lore. And there's of course also an upgraded Old Book of Lore that allows you to play the card, which I think is actually starting to get like again a very powerful card, but I think a very healthy card when it comes to terms of card draw, what you put in, what you get out. I think that this is like again healthy card draw for the game. And I think Mysterious Grimmoire also kind of lives in this space. Now, the the benefit is is you don't need to spend the action to to draw the cards from it. So, you're able to just put it into play and immediately start getting value, which is good for the experience that you put in compared to the level zero card. But, you can kind of see the difference between these cards and scroll of prophecies. But again, I think that for what you put in and what you get out, this card draw is nice and healthy. This is going to continue a bit more with another card here, Laboratory Assistant. I think Laboratory Assistant is a very powerful card, but when it comes to the terms of card draw, I think we can all agree that this is pretty damn fair, right? Like this is card draw that I think is cheap. It has soak. It increases your hand size. So like she holds quote unquote the cards that you draw, right? So, it's like one of those things where it's just again I think at a rate that is very comfortable for what we expect for card draw. Like it has a perk, right? Like the benefit of scroll prophecies is that you can draw a lot of
cards over time. You get to look at a lot of them. The benefit for Old Book of Lore is we get card selection for our action. The benefit for Laboratory Assistant is that she comes in with soak and increased hand size, which is really nice, but she only draws two cards. So, you're kind of spending an action to draw a card and then replace the laboratory assistant. Replacement draw is something I'm going to be talking about very soon. So, this she kind of kind of lives between both of these. Another ally that does a similar thing that has proven to be uh pretty good uh I think in the raid as well is Jeremiah Kirby. Jeremiah Kirby has four cost so he's double the cost laboratory assistant. He also gives you one book, but you also get a name, even or odd, when he enters. Reveal the top five cards of your deck and draw each card with a cost that matches the chosen option. And you can do this twice per game. He was tabooed to have that line of text.
Jeremiah Kirby is, I think, again, an example of good card draw because yes, this guy can draw five cards and five cards for four mana for four resources and a play action is very good. However, you have to build your deck with this in mind. So, you can't just like put Jeremiah Kirby into any deck and assume he's going to draw at a rate that is better than Laboratory Assistant, right? Jeremiah Kirby is part of a combo deck. And that's where this comes into play. But I think this is another example of what I think to be healthier card draw in terms of how we got through all of this. On to the last card of what we have here in terms of what I consider to be the the the the the basically enhanced draw action stuff. We have deep knowledge. This one is slightly above rate because the zero resource cost on two curses makes it free, but I still think in the long term this card has proven to be a healthy form of card draw. Maybe not when it first came out, it might have been a little bit too powerful, but I think with where the card pool is now, I think Deep Knowledge is in a very good place for its card draw. You get to draw three. You can combine them among players. So, you're essentially getting two cards above the rate that uh you are taking from the basic draw action, right? So, you draw one with the basic draw action. For one action and a card, you're drawing three.
So you're essentially drawing two cards because the deep knowledge is like a card that you're losing but it's replacing itself. So it's again that kind of thing, right? So like we see things like scroll of prophecies and old book of lore, they essentially replace themselves again. I don't think replacing themselves is fully accurate for cards like this one and even like deep knowledge because the idea is that you're getting a big burst of card draw, right? I think like replacement draw is more one for one, right? When it comes down to it. But you can see that these cards like this one is really drawing two. This one's drawing what is this? 11, right? I mean that I mean 11 11 minus four. So seven. This one's drawing seven. This one can draw forever, right? Like this one if you put on the first turn you're going to get a lot of value out of it, especially in Daisy. You can kind of see where like these are just like essentially limited uses or restrictive in their thing, but they're basically just enhanced draw actions.
our next bit of stuff that we're going to talk about here, which I think is the next very basic form of card draw that we have here. And I have a few examples. I just got to find them. My beloved, there you are. How could I forget about you? Uh D you. And then we have my other beloved. All right. So, this is the card replacement. So, this is just it's called in magic the cantrip, but I know there are a few people uh out there in the community who don't like when magic terms are used to describe cards. Um, but it's basically, yeah, it's card replacement. The card is going to replace itself when you play it. It's a free card, so to speak. Um, the most common form of these are you're going to find is the neutral skills, guts, perception, overpower, and manual decks.
Um, these are um nice things to have to smooth out your deck. These have a different function than deep knowledge, laboratory assistant, old book of lore, because those are burst card draw. Those are about digging into your deck to find things, getting options, filling up your hand, that kind of stuff. Perception, guts, overpower, manual decks, things we're going to be talking about here. These are ways to uh kind of just keep your hand loaded and you don't care what you get. You just want to turn this card into something else, right? Like that's the idea where you get the value from the card, but it turns into something else. This card represents another card in your deck, right? The nice thing about these cards, which makes them very powerful, is that they also scale with your deck in the way that like obviously all card draw does, but these ones do it that you don't need to upgrade these immediately. you can kind of just like let them be and they're going to just like make things work really well because of that. This is my favorite form of card draw. Well, actually that's a lie. It's my second favorite form of card draw.
Uh my favorite form of card draw happens to be the strongest one, but that's because I suck, right? Um but what I really like about like these cards is again I view these as less healthy than the first batch. Hey, damn neck. 60 months of the golden table. Thank you for your support. I view these cards as less healthy than the first batch, but ultimately I think that these are still fine for Arkham. I think they're still healthy card draw. They're still okay to have. I think they're powerful, but I think they're less powerful than some of the other things we're going to be talking about in the future and also less problematic in the long term. Uh so why are these cards good, right? Perception. We have a perception. We have emergency cash 2. uh gain three resources, draw a card. This commits for two books. If it's successful, draw a card. And then I have this new example here, established motive. This al also could be Eureka. But I think this established motive is actually proven to be a very powerful card. I think established motive is a very strong level zero card here. So this one is a wild. If this skill test is successful, the poor investigator searches the top six cards or deck for an inside event and draws it and then shuffles their deck. It's practice, too. I've always wanted to practice Eureka, so this is kind of kind of gross. But I think again like the baseline for this card is that this is again just a replacement effect. Uh Emergency Cache 2, I'm a I'm a big fan of it. uh if you're going to be playing emergency cache anyway, upgrading your the your eCash zero to e-cash 2 just provides
your decks with a lot of with just like consistency because again these cards kind of just don't exist. There was uh a card that came out in Inmouth Conspiracy called Tempt Fate. I know the alphabet. There it is. So, this card here, Tempt Fate, people joked when Inmouth came out that this card could just be in your deck to make your deck only have 28 cards in it. This has proven to not be the right choice in the long term because uh it's better to run 30 powerful cards than 28 powerful cards. Who to think? But the idea behind this behind these uh these replacement card draw is that they are essentially reducing your deck size, right? because all of these effects are stapled on to something that you want to be doing and then it's uh it's going to make that better, right? So like perception helps you get a clue and then it replaces itself. Emergency cash gives you three resources and it replaces itself.
Established motive is going to help you on any test because it's a wild icon and then it replaces itself with some card selection. Less of a draw card. It's less like one to one just I'm going to draw any card. But again, it's that same sort of idea. I'm digging for an insight event. I get to look at six cards and I get to find the best insight event of those six cards to draw. And generally drawing the best of an x amount of cards is better than drawing one cards. The reason why we haven't talked about it yet and we probably will end the video talking about it, but Lucky Cigarette Case 3 is the perfect example of why drawing the best of X cards is better than drawing a card.
And that's why effects like this are really good. They just passively let you play the game. Or this card's not here anymore. It's temp fates fine in bless decks, but you're not really you're running it more for the bless icons than the card replacement. But it's still one of those things where they smooth out your deck. They smooth out your game plan. And I think that they are nice, simple, not exciting, but they help your deck so much. Like, it's one of those things where I always say that upgrading into eCash 2 is not an exciting upgrade, but it makes your deck so much better. Um, and it's one of those things where it's it's just that simple draw one card. Draw one card put on a card makes it very powerful. And I think that this is an example of it. But obviously, I think this is like the number one thing here. Overall, I think that these are healthier for so they're still healthy for Arkham, but less healthier than the other one. We are now going to move into the next category here. Um, as we as we blitz through this, we're not gonna like there's not there's there's stuff to mine here, but we're not going to dig forever. This is now when things I think start to become a little bit less healthy. So, this is like um I I'm trying to find like a a term to describe what I'm looking at here, but it's basically like bonus card draw. I think that that's the way we're going to describe this. This is bonus card draw, right? This is card draw that when you
do something that is not drawing a card that gives you more, right? It's like uh well technically most of these things like the the first ones are card advantage like uh deep knowledge is card are card advantage like that like old book of lore is in card advantage but like scroll of prophecies is card advantage. Um but yeah I think card advant it's like this is like when the card advantage becomes stapled onto other things, right? So, an example of this one is Lucky Cigarette Case, right? Lucky Cigarette Case is what I consider to be the edge of fair card draw to the point where it's starting to dip its toe into unfair. Right? I think that this is the kind of card draw that in the long term is the more things we see like this, the less likely card draw is going to be healthy. when it's bonus card draw for doing things that are unrelated to card draw, right? So, yeah, it's just having an extra treat for progressing the game normally. Exactly that, right?
Like what if you just wanted to progress the game, but you wanted you wanted to just also draw a card on top of it, right? So, it's like I'm going to use lucky cigarette case and I'm going to use uh lock pickicks to easily succeed by two. So now I'm getting a clue and I'm also drawing a card. If Lucky Cigarette Case had uses, for example, that would have made it a little bit more in the fair category, right? Like if it was something limited like um Scroll of Prophecies or if it had like some sort of slight restriction like like uh sorry like Old Book of Lore where it was like you know it took a little bit of time to activate, right? It's one of those things where it became just a little bit too free. And this has actually been in the game for a long time. This came out in Threads of Fate, like ages ago, right? Like this is a I actually opened up the whole set. I wanted to look at the card there. But it's like one of those things where it's I think I do that over here. Yeah. Like this has existed for a long time. So it's like one of those things where I don't think Lucky Cigarette Case broke the game. But again, I think the Lucky Cigarette Case is on the line, you know, where it's like, are you fair or are you unfair? And Lucky Cigre says, "I don't know." Like maybe I'm maybe I am, maybe I'm not. You know, like it kind of gets a little bit attached to that. And I think that it's like one of those things where this is where it's starting to represent card draw that is um uh is is starting to get like into the
area where we have to like put a we have to clamp clamp down on it. We need to watch and be careful. Another example of this is Grim Memoir. This is bonus card draw, right? So, uh, three costs as an action, spend a secret, investigate, you get plus two book for this investigation. If you succeed by two or more, you may draw one card. Uses four secrets. This is just like better versions of Scroll of Prophecies, right? Like even though it draws less cards overall, this is card draw you get for going through the game normally, right? Like this is one of those things where this could potentially even draw you three cards in one turn. Like this doesn't exhaust. Yes, it has secrets. Like this I think is in theory better designed in terms of like a safety valve in comparison to lucky cigarette case, right? So I think it's less ubiquitous, but it is pretty like it is pretty like ubiquitous still, right? Like it's still something that like most seekers can just run this card. most highbook investigators in their pool can can get through it. It's one of those things where it's just like I think starting to again get to the point where we're starting to look at card draw that is just a little bit more unfair. This card is serving too many modes, right? Like what is Grim Memoir's purpose, right? Grim Memoir's purpose is to help you get clues, right? It gives you plus two book, but it's also purpose
is to give you value in the long term, right? And that sounds pretty benign, right? Like I'm not freaking out about a card that says, "Oh yeah, if you do this, draw a card." Right? If this was an event, I think that would be okay. But this card represents so many clues. It represents in theory four clues and four cards, right? And now we're starting to get the things that are just a little bit funkier in the right place. You can then stack these things. You can play Lucky Cigarette Case. You can play Grim Memoir. Put them together and card draw starts to become a little bit too free. You're eating so many bonus pieces of cake card draw that you're just like, "What the hell am I even doing, right? Like what what's all this?" You put a Grim Memoir all the way back with a card from the cantrip section that we talked about in the form of perception and you're like, "Okay, okay. I'm starting to get even more. My deck is super smooth. Grim Memoir is four perceptions, right? We sometimes joke on the channel that like this is just uh a ward of protection, right? This is just an emergency cash. We use those shortorthhands to define the function of a card, but Grim Memoir actually commits four perceptions to your deck. Like it like to your your test, right? Like it adds four perceptions to your deck for the cost of only one card. Then that is pretty spooky, right? Like that is pretty spooky when you kind of look at it. We were already talking about perception. Perception is a good card, right? These these cantrip effects, the
things that just like replace themselves are powerful effects to have in your deck. What if we had four of them, right? Like what if we just had four of them? And that's not even the case for Lucky Cigarette Case, right? Like Lucky Cigarette Case, I think, in a vacuum is stronger than Grim Memoir, right? I think that that's just the reality, right? But Grim Memoir still represents this terrifying thing where it's it's it's on that edge of things being fair and unfair. And I say terrifying with a little bit of hyperbole because, you know, the world's on fire, right? I'm not like actually scared of cards like Grim Memoir like I am a lot of things in the world, right? But like when it comes to the terms of design, these a a glut of these effects start to become a rolling stone, you know, that's just going to like like a snowball that's just going to keep going and going and going and it's eventually going to crush the village, right? Card draw is going to become too free, right? It's like one of those things where it's just so much value for so little. And this is the way that things start to become I don't want to say like I don't want to say like the decks build themselves, but at a certain point you kind of want to um you kind of want to have like a little bit more freedom in terms of things, right? Like where like decks are less consistent, right? Because I think
that games are better when they're not consistent all like like they're not super consistent, right? Like the players need to struggle, the players need to lose, the players need to face a challenge. And I think that cards like this make that less possible. And when there's redundancy in effects like this, things start to become a little bit rough. Another example of this that I think is actually the healthier one we've seen so far is a card like Stringalong. I think if we compare string along to something like let's scroll up here like pickpocketing. Uh pickpocketing too let's not talk about but pickpocketing. That's a different video. Gain a resource right like after you evade an enemy exhaust pickpocketing draw a card. Uh when you attempt to evade an enemy exhaust string along for this evasion attempt you get plus one skill value and that enemy gains alert. If you succeed draw one card and do not disengage from that enemy. String along, I think, is probably one of the healthier versions of this sort of bonus card draw. And I think that that's where things are like really, really interesting. Like, imagine a world where Grim Memoir said, "Investigate, your location gets plus one shroud. If you succeed, draw a card." Right? Like I think that that is a little bit more interesting in terms of clamping down on the sort of effects that like the this like bonus card draw should be put on this, right? like this string along has a downside, right? And I think that grim memoir doesn't, right?
It's like one of those things where when the card draw the bonus card draw is so free and I think that's also like the use case for like pickpocketing and like pickpocketing too, which is very very very powerful. These sort of effects I think are the bonus card draw that they should be aiming for. I think that overall this is like a healthy form of this card where things like Lucky Cigarette Case is in the middle and Grim Memoir is probably also in the middle but kind of stepping over into the unfair. So the bonus card draw I think is when we're starting to get things that are just a little bit too pushed but not the most unfair. Now, if you know me, if you watch me, if you've talked with me at all about Arkham, you probably know about the last category of cards that we're going to talk about here in this video. And the type of card that I think to be actually unfair card draw, unhealthy card draw, card draw that overall is bad for the game of Arkham for its design, its health, its card pool. and we're going to scroll all the way down to the skills and we're going to open up a few cards here. So, give me perception two, give me unrelenting, give me last chance.
I think that these three are examples of card draw that are ultimately unhealthy in the long term for Arkham Horror. I think that these skills, the perception, the perception two, guts two, overpower two, manual decks two, I think that these cards are over the line for fair and unfair. And they sound reasonable, right? Like I think that like when they came out every I was like, "Yeah, this makes sense." Yeah. Three icons, max one committed per skill test. If this test successful, draw one card, two cards instead of if it exceeds by two or more. This is totally reasonable. This is like I I I don't I don't see a problem with it. And you might even be as a player being like, "Yeah, what's the problem with this?" But like this is replacement draw with bonus draw, right? Like all of these effects unrelenting commits for a wild icon. After you committed, search the chaos bag for up to three nonautofail chaos tokens of your choice and seal them on unrelenting. If all three tokens sealed on unrelenting are plus one zero bless and or elder sign tokens, draw two cards. Release all tokens sealed here after this test ends.
Last chance has six wild icons. That's a lot. However, commit only to a skill test when no other cards committed to it. Other cards cannot be committed to the skill test. It loses one wild icon for each card in your hand. If this test is successful, while last chance is committed to it, draw two cards. So, you can kind of see where the the the through line is through these designs, right? We took the card replacement that existed on Guts and we took the card draw that existed on what am I looking for? Uh let's just go to like Labass, right? We took the card draw, the burst draw that existed on Laboratory Assistant, but we also took the bonus draw from Grim Memoir and put them together. Now, you might be seeing thinking, "But Justin, where's the bonus draw from this?" It's because all of these cards are connected to any other action, right? Let's think about the things we talked about previously. Grim Memoir is only an investigate, right? Still very powerful. Uh, scroll of prophecies is only a card draw. Laboratory assistant is only a play action. The only thing that else is like this is the replacement draw. Those are connected to other things. So, this is essentially taking the strength from each other card
draw category we talked about and is putting them into one sort of thing. Right? There's a reason why when you are playing the strongest investigator in the game, Amanda Sharp, these are the two cards you'll put in first. Perception 2 and Unrelenting because obviously skills are very powerful. Skill recursion is very powerful, but it's because their draw is so connected to anything else, right? So, I can play perception 2 with my grim memoir. I can play my perception too when I'm just basic investigating. I can play my guts defensively, my manual decks to evade with my string along. All of this also triggers my lucky cigarette case, right? So, I'm getting cards on cards on cards while also just generally playing the game and getting a clue.
Perception really in most cases says discover a clue, draw two cards, right? Like it's just like your investigate action is now also drawing two cards. And you might again be thinking that doesn't sound so scary, but trust me, it's very, very, very powerful. And to me, I think that these effects overall are in the unfair part of the card draw. When Last Chance was spoiled, this card I was like, "Oh, this is the unexpected courage too that survivors didn't have in their first cycle." And survivors can recur this, but this is a whole different problem we're not going to talk about here. But it's like one of those things where it it's it's all this card draw is just like going to compound and add up to the point where you're going to be able to cycle through your deck multiple times and then quote unquote recur these cards to get back there, right? It's like it's just kind of just a problem. It's just like it all kind of adds up and all these sort of things. You staple all this stuff together and you end up with decks that are super duper duper consistent. And it's like one of those things. I think the biggest example of why these cards are unfair is because they truly are every other form of card draw that we talked about put together. Their burst, their replacement, their bonus, right?
Like they're all these things coming together to a perfect storm. And of course it comes time to ask what if we just did all of that and had a lucky cigarette case three in play, right? Like this is like to me like the the kind of thing as well where it comes to and gets all this uh it kind of like comes to a perfect storm where it's it becomes a thing where cards are stronger when you put them all together. And that's kind of the basis for card games, right? Like how can I have my cards interact and card draw just becomes so efficient that you're able to see cards in your deck multiple times. you're able to um like draw through your deck multiple times in a way that the game realistically wasn't designed for at the beginning. And I think the best way to clamp down on this is to go with more limited burst card draw. And this also is for your deck. Again, if you want to build decks that are less less over the top and quote unquote more fair, um you want to look for less unfettered burst draw. So, sorry, a more yeah, less unfettered burst draw, more controlled burst draw. We want to limit our replacement draw. We want to really clamp down on a bonus draw, and we do not want to have the cards that put them all together. I think it's okay to make powerful cards, but I think that card draw scales with the game as a whole.
Um, which is uh kind of an issue when it comes to a legacy card pool. And I know that the designers rightfully shouldn't concern themselves too much with legacy as they're as they're going through and making things, which I think is entirely the appropriate stance to take, right? But I think that in terms of the the curated chapter 2 environment, that's a healthy place to be. So I think what we should do is let's like close this out by just looking at what is drawing cards in the chapter 2 environment. Right, we have our burst card draw. I think mysterious Grimmoire is healthy, right? We have Rabbit's Foot, which is like bonus card draw, but it's healthy. Lucky Cigarette Case is the bonus card draw that becomes a little bit unfair.
Laboratory assistant is healthy burst card draw. Arcane Initiate, I think, is uh it's like a it's like on the edge. Uh, it's a powerful card, but I think it's existed for so long and hasn't been too problematic because it's like card selection for a specific thing. We have Jim Culver, who is bonus card draw powerful. But I think the reason why Jim Culver is so powerful is because Mystics, they had only controlled like card draw like this for a long time. So, it's nice to get things like this. And it's obviously not super free, but like you it is pretty good. Uh, grapevine is just like bonus card draw. We have the um this is we're starting to get to like some free card draw. Gather intel is like burst card draw. We have bonus card draw, right? Like this card doesn't actually work for that. It just is here because it says draw. We have preposterous sketches, which is burst card draw, but probably one of the worst ones in the game. Probably like the most fair, right? Uh psychoanalysis and psychoanalysis 3 are good card draw that scales at higher player counts. They're also events, so they're one-time things, right? Like events like this that are connected to only playing the vent is kind of just like a scaling version of the basic draw action. So like they're generally a little bit more fair. You'll actually notice there weren't that many events all things considered. Our big explosive one again is burst card draw, but it's still only once onto these sort of things. We can see here, this is just the the replacement draw. And then we
also have the uh uh established motive which is also replacement draw but on the higher end. So overall there's a really good foundation here. I think there's only like a few things that are a little bit strange with everything else around it but I think that they have a really good foundation in chapter 2 and I hope that they make that their focus. While I don't think that they should worry about legacy because I think legacy is already gone. I do think that um overall this is a nice place for card draw to be for a foundation guardians. Uh I mean like yeah, there's no cardian card draw here, but in all fairness, I do think that some classes should be worse at others. I think gather intel could have been uh a guardian card. I think they could have had glory again, but I think that uh foundationally if the Guardians don't have it in Evergreen, I think that is a class choice. And I think even though people will disagree, I think is is healthy, right? Like they have they have the card search, they have right tool for the job. Like that's where they get their their kind of stuff. And they also will run things like overpower and guts to do card replacement. Like you can find it, you just got to flex a little bit to get there. Overall though, I hope you guys enjoyed this video. Again, I think that card draw is good for the game. I like card draw. As I mentioned, my my favorite card draw in this game is the broken card draw, but that's just because of how I am as a gamer. I like
doing the broken stuff, right? Um, but I think that overall for the health of the game, Perception 2, Unrelenting, Last Chance 3, and cards like it should probably not exist, and they should be very careful when they do the bonus card draw, especially in things like Grim Memoir or Lucky Cigarette Case 3. Thanks for watching everybody. Have a good one and as always GG's.