Merchants of Andromeda Review: Dutch Auction IN SPACE
Transcript
Hello everyone and welcome back to the Dice Tower. My name is Chris Ye.
I'm Mike Delio.
Today we're taking a look at Merchants of Andromeda. This is a reworking and reimplementation of an older Riner Kitia game here. I'm holding up just the box lid, not the whole box, for I fear the contents of this game spilling out on the table, and I would like that not to happen. For this is uh as with many allplay games, there's a lot in a small box. And this is this is that.
Yeah, very much. There's a whole lot packed into a relatively small box. Putting together everything that you learned in school about volume, putting it to its test.
So, let's show you how this Dutch auction game works. Uh, with some some real new big twists to it if you're familiar with the original Merchants of Amsterdam, which I assure you you probably aren't, but let's take a look at it and then we'll give you our thoughts. Here's Merchants of Andromeda set up on the table. What you see, this is a Dutch auction game. Players start with a pool of money and they're going to try to win by having the most money at the end of the game. A Dutch auction is a type of countdown auction that we'll go into more detail here in a second. This board here is the event tracker where different things are going to happen, including scoring events. So, each of these different sideboards here will score when the correct uh mini event takes place. So, we'll talk about how this progresses over the course of the game. These are the different miniames, the little sideboards. It's all driven by this deck of cards. If it is my active turn, I flip over. I reveal this card and I see that each card has two pieces of information on it. It has a resource that you could choose to gather, or it has an influence action that you can choose to take. Or you may choose to put this card up for auction for both its influence action and for its resource. I will take take each of these things myself and then we'll proceed to the auction. After the active player has taken their resource and done their action, the auction is going to take place in which all players will place their finger uh if you're using the official Allplay app. You'll place your fingers onto your respective spots here. A countdown will begin and this is how much money you are willing to pay for an action. The first person to lift up their finger will pay the amount shown on the screen at that time. So,
let's all we see that as close as that was, the app can tell the green player was the first one to lift up their finger. they will have to pay nine of the space bucks and then they will get to both take the action and get the resource shown on the auction card. When you take a card for its resource, you'll simply move your tracker forward one step on that resource type and you're trying to have majority to be furthest along on this track. If I were to have done this as the influence action, then I would actually take as my action both of these resources, both the uh cube and the little lava thing. One important thing to note is that the resource board and all other sideboards both have the events of when you activate them and when you trigger a scoring event. Every time that you flip over from the deck of cards one of these exclamation point cards, you'll move this tracker to the next step. And this one says score the resource board. So, let's show that. The resource board is going to pay out first and second place payments to the players who are furthest along on the tracks.
The track that is furthest along is going to be one of these two, either the blue stuff or the red stuff here. and it's going to be the one which is higher up in the order here. You can see the numbered 1 2 3 4. So in this case, yellow is going to get eight of the space bucks and then second place green will get four. Then we go to the next track and we see that it's going to have a lower payout for first and second place all the way down. And this is the same type of payouts you will see in all of the sideboards. When taking the planetary exploration action, players are playing a little bit of a push your luck game over here where they'll come in from somewhere on one of these planets here and try to flip over tokens to get new sets of of things. They can either get this set collection here for these relics or they might flip over more resources for the previously shown resource track. They can choose to stop whenever they want, take up to two tiles and place their markers out onto the board. Or if they continue flipping and they reveal one of these curse symbols, then they must stop flipping immediately and can only choose to take one of the tiles instead of of up to two. When a planetary scoring occurs, you're going to go through the three planets. First and second is going to get paid out in money for having the most markers on that planet. So in this case, green has first on the large planet. On the medium place, uh green has first, yellow has second. Then on the smallest one, yellow has first, blue has second. When taking the Andromeda board action, a player can add their token to one of the space stations shown here on the card. Either space station 2 or four in this case.
And there's any combination of these shown on these cards. The blue player is going to add this out here because they will score by having larger groups contiguous of their player pieces together. Now, let's say that we triggered a an Andromeda board scoring event. You're going to see which of these space stations has the most player pieces on it. Well, there's a tie here and number four with three pieces and board number two or station number two with three pieces. Then two and two. Tiebreaker is ordered by the number of the space station. So two is going to score first place and then number four is going to be in second place because this is a lower number. And the chart for payout is just like the resources shown below. Uh, and so blue is going to get first place for eight and then green is going to get paid four of the space bucks. Then we come over here, green will get paid six, so on and so forth down the line. When playing the little space invaders miniame here, the active player is going to roll the five dice and then they are going to assign those dice out to different spots here. Three of them are going to have the invader move forward and then the active player is going to actually take actions in number five. What this means is that the two, two, and the five enemy spaceships are going to advance. So in this case, it will destroy the green player token off here and then destroy the yellow player token off of here. So those are not going to score now. And then the number five advances forward. Now the active player gets to defend when twice in the number five zone, meaning that they will place their marker out. If they cover up one of these resources, they'll gain that resource on the
resource track. If there is an enemy spaceship there, they will defeat that enemy spaceship. If it was covering up a resource, they won't get it. And then they will continue to put their tokens out. They'll collect this destroyed spaceship for scoring. And then a new enemy spaceship will come out here. Now, let's talk about scoring. Why are players doing this? Well, it's because at scoring, every one of these lanes that are completely filled in with player tokens is going to pay out a larger amount. Any of the tokens or spaces here that are not completely filled in will pay out for a smaller amount. And people are going to get paid based on having majority. majority being broken by being higher up in the track there. Then the player who has destroyed the most spaceships will earn money and the player who has destroyed the fewest is going to lose money. When a voting action takes place, players will get a certain number of vote tokens that they'll get to place into these ballot boxes here. And the idea of this is that when the voting board is scored, we will reveal the votes in here. Whichever of these policies got the most votes on it is going to affect an end game or the next time something scores. So you see in this case, this policy here got the most votes, meaning that set collection for some of the planet board flipping over is going to be increased. Now players are going to get paid out money for having the most votes in the other policies. So in this case, this is the policy that was most voted except for the one that passed. So they uh yellow will earn money and then second place will split money and then the smallest
one is going to pay out to the majorities as well. As more of these event cards are revealed, players will trigger different types of scorings. Then at the very end of the game, once everyone has taken an equal number of turns, the deck has been exhausted. You'll go through and you'll score every one of the areas again so that every one of the sideboards will score three times. Whichever is the player that has the most money at the end of the game is going to be the winner. Now, I joke earlier that not a lot of people know the original game. This is based off, Merchants of Amsterdam. Actually, in fact, it's not one that I've played, and I don't think it's one that you've played either, right, Mike?
No. And I do like to uh call myself a big Cania fan. He has, you know, to be fair, hundreds of games, but I was aware of it. I was aware primarily because of the component, the Dutch auction component that was in the original version of the game, but I never actually had played it. So, what I'll say is that focusing just on that really quick, the uh the original game came with this big mechanical windup clock that kind of ticked down and then people slammed on the table. And it was the it was definitely the interesting main hook or gimmick of the game. Uh, and the way that it does it in this version is that you can use any countdown timer and you shout out a number or uh in the allplay app there is a there's a a version that is kind of like the reverse of that first player marker where the first person to take their finger off of it wins the auction at that price. And I find that that works actually incredibly well.
Yeah. And it's a free app uh that is part of just their regular allplay app. And it works very very well. I know they made a couple little uh improvements to it. when it when it was from when it was first released and it works very very well. It creates that nice tension that you're looking for in the Dutch auction.
Now, that being said, I so I think that part works out great. Um, let's talk about kind of the the theming, the setting, the artwork, and everything of all of this. There's a lot going on mechanically in the game. And I think that that a little bit of how overwhelming it looks is kind of exacerbated by the art style and kind of that maximalist everything going on uh in in the artwork and the cards, you know, all the icons and stuff. Has that also been your experience, Mike?
It's very much been my experience. It's it's a game that when it's on the table is um almost visually exhausting. That's kind of the the the term that I that I've kind of landed on. It's like there's so much to focus on that your eyes kind of get tired at trying to differentiate what is what. Um there's so many little bits and pieces and chips and the artwork itself is very maximalist as you said. And so, yeah, I have a hard time with uh the visual uh everything the play the visual sp on the table.
And I think that unfortunately it's not just like, oh, busy artwork. But sometimes I look at things, I go, is that in-game iconography? No, it's just the background of a spot where I can put my chip. And I think that for me is where it turns from kind of like a whoa that's a lot to oh man now this game is like harder to teach and I have to try to remember little parts here and there. Uh and but but I what I will say is I find some of the stuff in there very funny. There's a lot of humor. There's a lot of personality to it. So I think that's kind of the upside of it. Uh but in terms of the actual game play where where to start with this, right? Because I think that there's there's kind of two main areas I want to touch. I think when it's your turn and you're the card revealer, I think that's kind of like one main part of it. Uh and and the auction and then the other part of it is like all the different mini games going on. I'll let you drive. Mike, where do you want to start?
Well, um I guess I will say this. The visual maximalism, if that is such a word, and if it's not, I'm coining it as one right now, carries over into the game play. It is a game that it's very hard to focus on what is happening at any given time because you're constantly being pulled in different directions. If you're the person that is the active player and you're drawing the three cards, to me, that's when it's most interesting, right? Because it's impacting not only the other players, but it's impacting you and you get some sense of agency in what you're doing. um to some extent, not perfect, but but to some extent. Um but you're you're not only thinking, okay, what what resource do I want? And you're having to pull these cards one at a time. So, there's a little bit of a pusher luck there as well. Um what action do I want to take?
What board do I want to manipulate? And then what am I leaving for for the other players to to bid on? Um, that decision process I think is interesting, but it is connected to so many things that I think are are the exact opposite of what I expect in a game by this designer, which is it is very inelegant feeling to me. It It feels like it's everything and the kitchen sink and the box the kitchen sink came in and the shipping label on that. It's like everything you can possibly add to this game I feel like has been added. When I typically look to Riner Kinesia's games as you've stripped everything out of it that doesn't need to be there and you're left with this finely tuned engine. This does not feel like that. It feels like the polar opposite of that.
I I I look at that card play when you're the active player and you're flipping things over and you're kind of putting them into one of three different slots. That feels that feels to me the most clever and and fairly clean, right? As you're suddenly going, "Oo, I'm going to put this one for the action." You reveal another card and go, "Oh, I kind of wish I'd taken that one instead." I like those moments a lot. My favorite part of the game is when I am the active player and I have that little bit of control. And it's still not even perfect control like you said, right? So, I agree there. I like the mini games of the auctions when you or when you uh take an action or when you win the auction and you get both parts of the card, you win. I like individually a lot of the different mini games, but it is kind of an over um an oversaturated feeling of of looking at all the different things going on.
There's the voting board over here. There's the little dice space invaders miniame on this side. And each of those aspects I find actually very fun. I really like the voting. I really like this idea that you're doing this secret majorities bidding and it's going to that's going to put out a policy that affects scoring in some way, but then also you want to vote for the things that aren't going to pass so that you get payouts and you're trying to remember all of the I think that's a very fun miniame. I think the the little dice space invaders thing is a pretty fun miniame, but having all of those different mini games in the same game makes it a bit overwhelming. They don't feel connected to me, Chris. I think that's part of it is that they don't really feel connected. Um, you mentioned that one of your favorites is the voting. I'll tell you that's the one that I felt like was a bridge too far for me. It's like I felt like they could have completely removed that from the game. I don't even feel like it needed to be in there. Um, does it make it more gamery? 100%. Does it add some spice to the scoring? 100%. But at what cost?
That That's the thing is that the cost benefit feels off for me in this game. It feels like it should be a more streamlined experience. To me, the star of this game should be that Dutch auction, and I feel like it can't be because it's being overwhelmed by all of these other things that are happening. And I agree to you agree with you in the sense that some of those mini games I think are are relatively fun and it's so odd because you know I tend to really enjoy Roritia games. I love games with mini games. This should be right up my alley but there is something about it and I just feel like it maybe it's the sense that it doesn't feel unified. It does not feel elegant. Um it just feels like this unwieldy beast that it shouldn't be. Um that that that just really brings it down for me. Um, this is very off the cuff. In fact, this whole conversation, Mike and I have not, you know, practiced this or anything.
And it's interesting that we have a lot of the same takeaways, I think. Um, a RER kinesis game that comes to mind that has kind of mini games within it is uh, Miller Fury.
Yes.
Right. And I think that you would agree it kind of feels like lots of little mini games. Is the difference for you, Mike? Cuz I know that you really love that game. I don't actually personally like it much,
but I I I would venture to say each of those mini games feels a little bit smoother and a little bit more interconnected.
Absolutely. And just so much so much smoother, right? And there's even little um like little kind of bonuses and combos that you can feel. And while there are, I guess to some extent some of those things here, they just feel again it feels bloated. This whole game feels bloated to me. That's probably the one word that you know that that would boil everything down is it feels like there's more there than should be more there that definitely than needs to be and it it takes away what I feel like could have been an interesting uh core uh design with a unique auction element. I think Rhonda Kitia does auction games better than anybody else and in this one it just feels off. It feels too much.
Milifi did not. It was smooth. It was breezy. All of the the the kind of the little mini games were all part of an interconnected hole. This does not to me feel like part of a connected hole.
And what I'll say is that as much fun as I have with some of the mini games, right? I like the little push your luck the the planet exploration one. Uh the problem is that some of the mini games for for me feel rather bland and unfortunately those are the elements from the original game, right? the the four space stations, what used to be Amsterdam, uh, and then the resource track just they don't feel like resources. They don't feel like much. It just kind of feels like move ahead on the track. The all the other ones have a little bit of a flare to them that are kind of fun. And I think that the idea of keeping some of those things from the original game made it so that well, you have to have the original things, right? Otherwise, it's not it's it's not even a re-implementation at that point. Uh, but then having all of these new extra mini games in there is fun, but it kind of pulls focus like you said from that auction. And I think unfortunately to the point it does affect the auction for me where I see players when they play this game at some point, especially with higher player count, they are waiting to take a turn. They're waiting to do something fun to the point where they'll over bid in that auction because they're kind of getting impatient and they're waiting to to just I want to play I want to play Space Invaders, right? I want to roll the dice finally. Let me do it. I will overpay by five, six, eight uh space bucks. And it really hampers them.
And it kind of throws off the value of things because an auction kind of depends on people knowing how much to spend on things and having little surprises instead of people feeling like, well, I'm bored, so I'm going to over bid so I can at least participate in some of the action. Yeah, I'm really glad you brought that up, Chris, because I actually found that in uh my plays through of this too as well with other people being like, "Well, I just I haven't done really anything for three turns. I'm going to do something." You know what I mean? So, that that is something you don't necessarily want in an auction game.
Yeah. Um and and I it sounds like there's a lot of negative to this in part because there was unfortunately a lot of negative to this. Um, what I will say in the positive of is that I find with three players, you get to be the card flipper more often and you get to win auctions a little bit more often. And so you do feel like you're participating more. I think the tension is maybe a little bit higher at four players. Uh, and I have never and will never play this at five players for that concern of of going too long between turns. But man, when I do get an auction or when I do get to secure an action that I'm for sure going to take, I have a lot of fun with it. I love seeing the tension of like that Space Invaders track of of seeing people messing with each other like a I'm going to send these guys down. They're going to, you know, eat up your ships off of there and then then I'm going to come in and blow up the enemy ship and I'm ahead now. And I think those are the moments of tension that really shine in the game and are the most fun. So, I want to make sure that I I speak to some of the positive of what's in the game.
I have played it at five and yeah, I I think you your your gut instinct is right there. Um, for positives for me, it's it's about the Dutch auction. I do think that that is a very clever way to handle an auction. Um, and and I do think that it feels unique in that way. This does not feel anything like the other RER Cania auction games I've played, which are many. And so I will give it that. It does feel unique from any other in his catalog. Unfortunately for me, it feels unique in ways that I don't particularly like. And so yeah, this this is a rough one because, you know, I I have to admit, and this should be stated as part of this review, that I probably do have higher expectations for a RER Kinesia auction game than I would for any other auction game that I come across. So, um, my expectations were not met. And perhaps that means I'm being a little bit harsher on it than I would otherwise. So take that into account.
Uh coming out to kind of wrap up every here everything here. What would be your final thoughts and score on this one, Mike?
Yeah. So I I don't want to belabor the point. We've mentioned uh I've mentioned the particular issues I have with the game. I also do want to point out that production-wise, it can be a bear to set up because there's a bunch of little bits and they can be fiddly to mess around with those bits if you have uh you know larger hands or fingers. That's another issue that I that I kind of see with it. Um this one just didn't work for me. I I I mean it's it's uh a bit heartbreaking because I love Cania auction games and this one just is the worst of his that I've played in that genre of of of an auction game. Um, I'm giving it a five. It is certainly not broken. There's nothing about it that necessarily feels unbalanced. I don't think that's even possible in a Ryder Kitia game because the math is usually so inscrutable. But this one just lacks the the fun that I'm looking for. It it it lacks the the the snappiness, the elegance that I look for in his design.
So, unfortunately, you know, you know, is five too high of a score for as negative as I've been? Maybe. But, you know, even the the the lower end of the Rhiner Kinesia games, I think, are better than many of the other games I've played. So, I don't know that I feel comfortable going below a five, but I definitely could not recommend it.
I am a little bit higher. And like I said, I I I know that I've said a lot of negatives about it. I'm coming in at a six. It's a game that I would still play, but with a few kind of little caveats. I am kind of tired of teaching the game because there's a lot of little things going on to it, a lot of little nuance to catch. This is a game that is more fun with the same group of players because it gets rid of some of those those issues of like not knowing how to value uh a particular card that's up for auction. Players are going to be able to hone in a little bit more at reasonable prices. You're not going to get someone paying 19 just because they're like, "H, I haven't gone in a while." Uh, I think that that goes away playing with people who are more experienced and playing with a three or four player group, finding your ideal kind of player count for it. I like the exploration. I like the flipping uh tiles and trying to set collect and stuff. And I think that there's these mini games done in good ways. I know Mike, the uh the voting didn't work for you. For me, I find that to be tremendously fun as you reveal the box and stuff. Is it a little bit too much? Maybe it is, right? Uh, I wish that this game had stripped down a little bit more and found just like a a more unifying core identity, but it still is fun, but I still can't recommend it broadly. There are many other games from this publisher, many other games from this designer that I would sooner say to go check out. Uh, but but you are right that it does have a unique feel to it and that that Dutch countdown auction and especially with that app, it works so it that part works so well. So, all in all, my thoughts are
a little bit kind of all over the place, but it's it's a six for me. I wish it was higher. So, there you go. That is our thoughts on uh Merchants of Andromeda. If you've played it, please tell us what you uh what you think of it below. And I hope maybe you've enjoyed it more than us. Thanks for coming out to this review on the Dice Tower. My name is Chris Ye.
I'm Mike Delio.
And uh have yourselves some nice blorbs burgers in space. M. Hey, uh, thanks for watching another video here on the Dice Tower. Uh, we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at the Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support the Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video, and we have links to lots of other things we do down there. So, definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassel, and I hope you enjoyed this video.