Battle of the Divas Review - The Sopranos
Transcript
Hello and welcome out to the Dice Tower. I'm Wendy Ye.
I'm Chris Ye.
And today we're going to be reviewing The Battle of the Divas by Salt and Pepper Games.
Designer here is Albert Reyes. Uh the artist Jav Dcastro and the graphic designer, I believe, is what this last credit is here on the box. Jo Silva. Uh I like the idea of graphic designers and stuff as well getting credit on boxes. I think that's cool. Uh, but overall this is I'm just gonna go ahead and say it a very very greatl looking game. So happy to shout out those who made it look very good.
Yeah. Yeah. I think it it has a very strong look to it in a in a positive way. So this is about uh two opera singers and two famous opera singers from kind of the 50s era. And uh one was Maria Gaas and she was known for having very like rich emotive performances in her opera. And the other one was Ranatada Tabaldi and she had just amazing technique like fabulous technique. Um and so uh this is a battle to see who's the best. Right.
This is the second game in Salt and Pepper's Battle Without Bullets series. The first one was Battle of Versailles, which was the fashion show that took place in the 1970s. So very intrigued by the theme. Uh knowing that I already liked the previous game in the series. So uh Wendy's going to show you how this game plays. Then we'll give you our thoughts.
In Battle of the Divas, we have Maria and Ranatada who are both trying to become the greatest opera singer. This takes place in the 1950s. And in this game, um they are going to be singing at different opera houses, trying to gain the most applause, gain the greatest reward, increasing their vocal um range. So, their tesaturator, their vocal range, and ultimately gaining the most victory points. Now, the turn structure on this game is a little bit lengthy. So players are going to each take turns and on their turn they're going to play out a card on an opera house. They're going to then affect the opera house and the applause level based on where their card is or like all the details on their cards. And then they're going to move their character up here on the white keys. They're going to then potentially add music notes to the bottom here in their color as long as it's within their range. And then they're also going to be taking actions based on the black keys that they're next to. Then finally, at the end of the turn, they'll draw back up to four cards. So, let's go ahead and talk about uh what it means when you place a card out. Now, right now, if I were to play this place this card out, I'd be gaining fame points. I'm sorry I have that moved over. Um I'd be gaining fame points for matching instruments.
This card could go anywhere. However, there are different instruments and so you get little bonuses if you match instruments. Then you're also trying to match the opera, the rhythms on it to the rhythms on the card. Now, right now, these don't match. However, if I were to have played um this card right here instead, the instrument would match. I would move this over one and then I would also gain a fame point for matching one of the rhythms. I'm not fame points, sorry, these are fame points. These are applause. Okay. The other way that you gain applause is by having different types of masks. So this card has two different masks. So she would gain two applause. So if this was the card I was using, I would gain none for rhythms. However, I would gain for masks. Now in the future, I could play another card down on a future turn and I could gain another fame reward for having the matching instrument and then I could gain a point for having a matching rhythm. Now, if you look at the player aid over here, um it does talk about the different ways that you gain applause. So, you gain it from the masks being different. You gain it from getting the two different types of of rhythms that are listed. And then also, there's going to be the musical notes, the do um and when you get those, they're just worth different amounts. Next, let's talk about this board up here. So, based on the rhythm that you play, that's how many movement points you can have on the white keys on this board. You can never be on the same place as the opposite color. And when you move on to a space, so if I were to move here two spaces,
then you can place out one of the music notes at the bottom in your color. Or you can flip it over to your color. Um, if you've landed it there, as long as it's within your tessatura or it's within your vocal range that's right here. So the C is totally within my range, I can place that down there. And now this is going to be available for the future to use. All right. So, let's go ahead and talk about what the actions do on this board. So, we have the tuning forward action right here, which increases your tessatur. You can go ahead and move one of them uh to make it wider. If you eventually make it to the end, you can get points that way. Uh it also allows you to put more of these music notes down as you move around. We also have the timeline action, which allows you to play cards to the timeline. Um as you play them, they will always play from left to right. And later on, you can use fame track bonuses to rearrange stuff because you want things to be in numerical order. And so if right now I where have these two out, they're not numerical order, which means yellow and blue would neither one of them would score. However, in the future, if someone were to rearrange them, they're in the correct order and so therefore they would score points. We also have this star right here which allows you to move any one of the four fame trackers towards your direction.
Finally, the last symbols on the bottom are the different symbols that match the instruments on the opera houses. And so, it's going to be a way to play an action into one of those four houses. When you take one of those opera house actions, you are going to be choosing whatever opera house you landed on or landed next to. So, right now, yellow would be affecting um the woodwind over here. And she has one of two choices in her interaction with this opera house. one, she can choose to add out one of the notes that's down here. So, we have C and soul. And right now, yellow doesn't have access to C or soul. They only have access to do. But let's pretend that this was on the yellow side. Then she could go ahead and add C out here. And then remember, um, we look at the applause tracker guide over here and we see that for the first one, she would get two applause. So, she go ahead and move that up to the two applause. Now, the other action option that she has is to score this particular opera. And the game is actually played till five operas are scored. And the way that she's going to score an opera is that uh someone has to have at least this amount of applause. So, this one's pretty small.
It's five. So, let's pretend that Blue's up here. They've got five and they've gone ahead and they're taking the action to score this. So, first off, everyone's going to score points based on their applause tracker. So, right now we have five and two. So, we'd go ahead and score those for both people. Then, we have the fame tracker over here. This allows the rearranging of up to two cards. And then, finally, the person who wins this, the person who has the most applause is going to receive a matching token down here in the orchestra pit. Um, so we have what? The woodwind obo. And in the rule book, it says closest to the stage, but in the example, it shows closest to the conductor. So, I'm going to go for what the example said. And so, this right here would allow me to uh play a card into the timeline without activating it. Once an opera is completed, you're going to go ahead and replace it with a new opera. And just remember that once five of these have been scored, then that means that the game will end. Then you go ahead and score up all the points, including all the endgame stuff. And then, whoever has the most is the greatest opera singer of them all.
All
right. So, coming back, I think the richness of the theme is where Salt and Pepper really shines, right? This is very much their thing. They love historically based games and they love just enriching the game with theme. So, obviously, Chris now feels like an opera singer.
Yes, that is what what is that's what it means for a game to be thematic. You have to feel like you're in a mech suit or that you're an opera singer.
Yes. No. Uh, so I I actually like vocal, singing, choir, all that kind of stuff was my world for like middle school, high school. I went to a fine arts performing high school. I I mean my senior year I took like seven out of my eight classes were music classes. I was required to take English, so I took that, you know, like I was so engulfed in this world. And so it's amazing looking at this game and being like, "Oh my gosh, I know all the soulfest. I know this. I know that." you know, like it's it's fun for me having this be a theme because I feel like we've seen more music games recently than we have before. Um, but this really goes more into that classical training side of things, which is more what I studied and less like pop and rock music,
right? Yeah. Yeah. Uh, and I I started my college degree getting uh music, a music degree. I switched later, but it was just kind of fun to see all these just, you know, like all these nice intentional touches they put in there. Uh, and and unfortunately what I cannot speak to that neither of us can is would this game be confusing if you don't have a music background,
you know, like the the different soulfed the domy fossil latte, right? If your entire background is just from say the sound of music,
you might you'll get it right. I don't think it's that conf. It's just a resource token.
It is. It's just a resource with a name. Yeah.
Yeah. But I can see why terms like the tessatura, your vocal range, why that's going to be
an annoyance of of like Okay.
See, I don't see it as an annoyance. I see it as educational.
Sure.
You know what I mean?
Yeah. Uh, so it's funny because there are certain times where the tessatura, your vocal range, has the little icon of the tuning forks. Also, if you don't know what a tuning fork is, you know what I mean? Like you're like, why is there
there's so many steps to this? Yeah.
Yeah. Right. Sometimes it's an icon, sometimes it's the word. Uh, mostly on when you play cards for powers. So, I think I think there's little things that even if you don't know music, they could have done to just smoothen it a little bit.
Sure.
But I really like that they went full boore into the music theme and especially this classical training, classical opera theming.
Yeah. And if you want to read, every single one of the timeline cards has an explanation. It's very brief, but an explanation as to why they chose that event in that year. And so there's just there's a lot of theme in that. And if that's very interesting to you, I think that that is what carries this game.
So this is a card driven confrontational game. Make no mistake that this is not just
this is a dual game for sure.
It's a dual game. There's there are definitely card effects where you will undo what other players have done. Um, but I I appreciate that for the most part when you play a card in like your normal turn sequence, like play one card. You're not looking at all of the different card effects that it could be. You're mo you're just looking to like match up notes and match up instruments and you kind of move up on these little tracks and you get some points and stuff. Uh but so like that part is kind of smooth and then you move on the you know you move your person on the keyboard on the side and then you take some bonus action and it becomes this thing where it's u a term that I've heard is that each decision in this game is chunky in the sense that multiple layers of decisions are chunked into one simple action. Play a card. Mhm.
And that's going to be both a positive because you feel like you okay well I moved up here got a little stronger in the majority so to speak of this opera house and I get to go over here I get to take some bonus actions. It's cool. So yeah I mean I I think people will like that but it does have a few drawbacks in my opinion.
And it's it's interesting to use the word chunky not clunky because I don't feel like the game itself is clunky. I feel like once you have that procedural turn structure down then it it can be very smooth. Right. Mhm.
I still find that I miss a few things here and there because it's like you do a chunk and you do that whole procedure, then you do another chunk and you do that whole procedure and then that chunk leads to another chunk which does a whole procedure, right? And that is what a single turn is. And so there are moments where I'm like, "Oh, I forgot to put my soulfetch token down or oh, I forgot to move the fame track or oh, I forgot." You know what I mean? There's there's definitely those moments. And I wish that the player aid had that procedure written on it
just spelled out. Yeah.
Yeah. It has like the applause points and you know I mean it has some scoring stuff on there. Um and one side is English and one side is Portuguese which I appreciate that there's player aids but I wish that instead it was like here's your single English player aid. One side of it is the structure of a turn and the other side is the scoring. So
I'm pretty sure it's Spanish on it.
I think so. Right. Well a Spanish publisher.
I don't speak either language so you would know he speaks Spanish. Um,
but yeah. So, um, but what I I appreciate, you know, you you talk about how it is a a dual game, right? It is combative. Um, I think that the actual opera boards in the middle, like that chunk of a turn feels very much like that twoplayer style game and it's got that kind of tugofwar of the fame. Um, but it doesn't feel too drastic because moving the cards and the timeline and stuff like the actual timelining lining of it isn't a crazy amount of points, right? So, the tug-of-war there doesn't feel too harsh. Um, and the gaining applause points that actually translate directly to points. Um, I really appreciate that if I've won the opera that you still get the points that you've earned. Like you still gain your applause. So I feel like it's very kind in that regard that you know you want to work a little bit on all the operas and it's not like I either win it or I get nothing,
right? And and if I see that you are at the threshold, you can almost score that opera and I only have you have like eight points and I have two points like well I know Wendy's going to choose to score that opera so I better start getting some more of the applause points on there otherwise I'm going to just be missing out. That five score, you know, like you score five rompers, that's the end of the game. That can catch you off guard if you are not, you know, I mean if you're like I'll just spread around a little bit everywhere.
Be careful with that. Especially as like after one or two are scored, the game can end very quickly.
It can
the Okay, so I I think my biggest hangup with the game is twofold. One is like sometimes you just don't have a very good card to play. You know, it's just kind of the the draw of the cards and the way the operas line up. But more than that, I do feel like when you play cards as like that bonus action, play cards the timeline and that's where you carry about the care about the text effect. It's pretty mean. Like it's and I know that this is a confrontational game. This is on purpose. These two opera singers
really feuded. They, you know, when when a music when a music critic compared the two their two voices, one of them said, "Comparing my voice to hers is like comparing Coca-Cola to champagne." They didn't get along.
Yeah. They didn't seem like buddies.
Yeah. So, this game I I I can appreciate. In fact, the the previous game in this line, Battle of Versailles, definitely had a lot of in-your-face interaction.
Yeah.
I feel like the interaction in this game, though, is a little too blunt. Uh, some of those card effects are not clever like, oo, I can turn this situation around. Some of the some of the times you play a card out there and it says, destroy two of your opponent's cards in an opera. They lose all the progress they've made. That's two turns that you've set them back with one of your turns as bonus action.
Yeah,
I I don't love that feeling.
And that can be attached to a scoring. So, I could be like, haha, you lose all that and I'm going to score that opera. Thank you very much.
You know what I mean? It just undoes. Yeah. And I think that you mentioned just briefly how there is just like such a drastic difference in cards. You can have these cards that do they feel like they do practically nothing and you could have a fistful of them while someone else is, you know, destroying everything you've done and then later you could draw a bunch of cards and you're like, "These are all great and now I have to waste some." Like, yeah,
it feels like it feels like a waste. And I I honestly just wish that some of those events didn't exist or some of those cards didn't exist because they're not fun. Like there's never a point where I'm like, I play one little thing. Yay. There's never a point where that feels good,
right?
I just hold on to them and they just gum up my hand until I can be like, fine, I'm throwing them out and getting rid of them,
right?
Some way, shape, or form. Maybe I'll throw the timeline because it's just it's not a great effect, but at least it'll be points if I can line up the
because I can take a turn that gives me four applause because it has both rhythms magically that I needed and it has the mask that I need or I can take a turn that gives me one and then another turn that gives me one and then a third turn that gives me one and then I found a card with a mask on it so I'm going to put that down like
Yeah. Yeah. Some of the turns just don't feel good based on your your draw of hands and everything. Uh, and of course this is a tactical head-to-head card game, right? Some of that is going to happen, but I feel like it's a little bit more than I want in this game. It doesn't just feel like a, ooh, how can I cleverly play around this? It's kind of a, oh, I'm going to have a bad turn or two now.
Yeah.
So,
whereas I think the clever moments come with the piano board up there. I think the the few moments where you're like, okay, I'm going to be in the way over here a little bit. You can't fully block someone because black keys have both sides, right? But I can be like, "Oh, I'm going to steal your soul and I'm going to flip it over to my side." Like, I feel like there's a few clever things over there.
Steal your soul.
The soulfed soul.
The soul fed Joel. Not
me soul.
Rip your heart out.
Kima.
Yes. No. Uh, so I feel like there's some clever things that go on on that board and you can get some really interesting points. If you can increase your tessaturur, if you can increase that range to the far edges, you can get points that way. Like I I think there's some interesting things going on because there's a few different ways to chase points, but I also feel like the game pushes you towards doing operas. Obviously, they're opera singers, right? That's how they're getting their fame. That's how they're going to get the majority of their points. And so I think the the other things that are out there almost feel like red herrings because you can get points from them, but they're not the meat of the game.
And I feel like you can get a lot of points from the other things as well.
But also, if you're leaving the operas to your opponent, you know, without focusing so much on them, then they're going to
do incredibly well. I do think
I was going to say at the end of the day, I just always want to play Ranata because I feel like her cards are just more interesting. There is definitely a nice symmetry to the decks and to the players, not just the one special power that some of the cards have, but yeah, just their decks are
very different. Uh, and it's going to take you a few plays to get used to the fact like, oh, um, Ranata's deck has a has an event card in the timeline that allows you to copy one of the other events that you played in the timeline, which can be brutal if you don't know that. So, you know, you have to familiarize yourself with the decks and that comes through play and everything. Mhm. So, you have final thoughts.
So, yeah. So, let's go into scoring. Final thoughts. I really want to love this game. I think that it's a good game, but I have several hang-ups with it that kind of frustrate me each time that I play it. I do like it, but I'm giving it a six because it's not one that I'm going to choose to pull out and say like, "Oh, man. Can't wait to play this one again." And whereas the the previous game in the series, Battle of Versailles, which we reviewed and we really enjoyed on this channel, that's one that kind of going back to it, I was like, "Oh yeah, this is why I love all these aspects and stuff. Oh yeah, there's some meanness, but it feels a little bit more uh clever within it." I feel like some of the meanness is a little too blunt in Battle of Divas for my taste. So, as much as I enjoy it, I also have have too many hang-ups to really recommend it. So, that's what a six means for me.
That's interesting. I think I like this one more than Battle of Versailles. Um, that one I felt like it just felt like there were so many tugofwars and you kept undoing everything that I did. And this has elements of that, but I don't feel like it happens every single turn. Um, whereas I feel like it happened a lot more in that previous game. U, so this one I'm going to give a seven because um, though I have a few hang-ups as well, I really love the enriching theme behind this. It's one of those that I just I gravitate so much towards it just because of my history and the nostalgia that I have for that. Um, but also I really appreciate that it's not all or nothing in so many regards when it comes to the points that I still get so much for everything that I've invested. And there are those few moments where your event cards can undo my points entirely, but I feel like they're not too all the time. They're not constantly happening. And so, um, yeah, this is one that I enjoy enough to give it a recommendation.
All right. Well, there you go. High score of a seven, giving Battle of Divas a seal of approval from us here at the Dice Tower. Thanks for coming out to this review. Uh, are you an opera singer? If so, tell us all about it. I want to learn more.
All right. Anyway, thanks everyone. My name is Chris Ye.
I'm Wendy Y.
And, uh, f la.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, you want to learn more about us, communicate with us, we have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. You can find that in our link tree link below. So, just click that and we'll take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook. Join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Bassel.
Follow law is not on the correct notes at all. How would you do that? So, what would be the proper soulfetge for deck the holes?
No,
that's it. There you go. We solved it. We saved Christmas. Big door.