Top 25 Solo Historical + War Games | 2026 Commentary
Transcript
Hey gamers, this is Liz David from Beyond Solitire and I'm here for one of my favorite events of the year. Uh we are looking at the results of the 2026 solo historical games list. Uh and I am here uh obviously with myself, Liz from Beyond Solitire. Uh we have Brandt Gillery from uh Armchair Draons who is my partner in crime for this and he is the person who handles all of the forms and the statistics and the numbers deep dives. And then we have not one but two mics. So, first we have Mike uh of Zilla Blitz. Uh and if you haven't checked out his Wargame channel, you should. I could say the same thing for Mike of my own worst enemy. So, we've got on two mics who are also solo Wargame experts. Um and we'll just figure out what we call them at some point during this. So, how are you gentlemen doing this evening?
Excellent. I'm excited to talk about this. Really looking forward to it. Uh, happy to be here.
Excellent. So, I think what we'll do is, so this is not like a countdown, everybody. This list is already published. It's on Arm Treons already. It's on a geek list already. There are a bunch of there going to be a bunch of links in the show notes. So, why don't we just go ahead and show the actual list, talk about it a little bit, and then because Bran's a stats guy, we'll look into some some deep dives. But um as we pull this up, uh Brandt, why don't you talk a bit about this project and how and why we do it while people can peruse the list.
Yeah. So, this started a couple of years ago with a hairbrain idea that Liz had, which she's she's heavily involved with it. It's the people's choice. Is it top 100 or top 200?
It's now top 200. It used to be top 100. In the last couple years, it's been two. Yep.
Yeah. I couldn't remember for sure. and and so that's a whole lot of solo gaming stuff, but it's like across all of gaming and not like war game specific. And so we decided to take a swing at doing a war game specific uh solo wargaming solo historical gaming uh list countdown top whatever because we didn't know how many votes we were going to get out of this. And so we just, you know, said, "All right, give us your top five and and we'll figure it out from there." Um, it's just straight like, you know, college football style ranking points, right? You know, you get five points for first place, four points for second place, that kind of thing. And, uh, and then we'd stack them all up and see what got the most points. And, and so this is now four years that we've done this. Uh, we've refined the process a little bit.
We we ask everybody for their top five. And then we have a couple of just for fun kind of optional questions at the end. How long you've been wargaming? what percentage of your wargaming is solo, that kind of stuff. We'll we'll swap those out uh throughout the years. Uh but but we've consistently asked for everybody's favorite top five. Um I I love the folks that'll remark on social media, well, what if you don't have five favorite solo games? Well, this survey is probably not for you, you know? I mean,
go play five games. Those would be
Yeah. Uh so so that's that's the general thing that we've done. And now that we've got a couple of years of data, we've got a little bit of of tracking over time. And that's actually the the spreadsheet that Liz is showing on screen right now is uh the one where we show some of the changes from the the very first year all the way up to this year. That spreadsheet will be published in total on the I'm looking at my calendar over here on the 23rd. So depending on when this video goes live, it it's a couple of days away yet still. Um, so, so that whole list will be there that folks can go look. Um, but that's that that's the general like we did [clears throat] it because the the countdown you were involved in that that survey wasn't really narrowing down on the wargaming and historical gaming stuff and we've done it for a couple years running because we can't help ourselves.
Yes. Um, also I will continue to beat the drama of it's just bugs me to watch historical games and war games slide down that most popular list. So I just wanted the games that are from our part of the hobby to like get the attention I think they deserve. Um, so you know uh the mics you know how do y'all I mean you know Mike Zilla Blitz Mike I know that you are uh I'll just go with Mike Zilla. uh you are um you're an omni gamer like me like you play a pretty wide range of games. Um so I guess like what's your feeling on looking at uh sort of like the war list versus like a generalized hobby list?
Well, war games clearly get no love on board game geek. You know, there's there's another person I know who's doing a he's writing ser he's diving into like some of the the weakest ranked games on board gamege geek and a lot of war games show up that he plays there and there's some amazing games that are just buried down in these list. So, it's really nice to to highlight our hobby in this way because there's so much goodness that you you wouldn't really find otherwise by just looking on Board Game Geek. So, this is a great thing, I think.
And then, uh, BB Mike.
Oh, well, I you know, I tend I play mostly war games. I do go outside of that, of course. I mean, my wife and I play Gloom Haven and some of the the Euros. We've got a couple of friends we'll play Euros with, but I kind of skew more towards into the wargaming stuff. So that's where most of my gaming is done and most of it is solitire.
Yeah. Uh do you feel that the games in our part of the hobby are underappreciated?
Yes, I think they are.
Without a doubt. I think they are.
Uh so I would have to agree. Uh however, before we go into some deeper dives into the statistics, I just want to like enjoy a little look at this list. Um, one thing that is interesting to me is, so Brand, I have one major like division of stuff question for you, which is we got Fields of Fire Deluxe Edition at number two and Fields of Fire.
I was going to ask the same thing.
So why
I saw that too.
Okay, so look, Ben Hull asked this question on Facebook. So it's it's not like you're the first one to raise the qu. So, one of the things that we've done going all the way back to the beginning of this is um we have always said we're not going to try and get inside the heads of the respondents and guess at what [clears throat] we think they mean when they put a specific game down. So, if you tell us Fields of Fire Deluxe Edition, we're going to go with the deluxe one. you tell us the original fields of fire, we are going to assume that that was an intentional decision and not an accidental one and you would have grabbed Deluxe if you had just kept typing on the autocomplete and and so there may be reasons why people pick one versus the other. The example that we've used over time around this is the varying versions of RAF is one of the examples. Um, one of the later versions of RAF. Um, it was originally just a solo game. One of the later versions gave you um, both the solo the original solo game plus the solo game from the other side so you could play the Germans or you could play it head-to-head all in in the one box. And so if folks were picking the original RAF, we assumed they did it intentionally, that they meant the one player Britishon version of it. Uh, another example, the I think
in BGG, some of the Danver uh, like the Thunderbolt leader or or one or the other that was originally published by GMT and was later republished by Danver Games, those show up as separate listings in BGG also. And so we worked under the assumption that whatever one you picked is the one you meant to pick. So so that's that's why those show up separately.
I I do think this time was the first year we did the autocomplete. Correct.
It is.
And I have a feeling because when I did the auto correct, I don't know how it was for you guys, but it was very slow and I got to the point where if it once I saw what I thought was the game I was talking about, I just hit enter. And it's possible that this happened with Fields of Fire, right? I mean, maybe people just
It is possible. Um,
but again, we're we're not the ones that should be judging what the intent of the respondent was.
Yeah.
And and I think I I'm not looking for a cop out here. I legitimately think that it would be a little arrogant for us to say, "Oh, yeah, this is what they really meant be because it's not." Um, it it, you know, that's not our call that we should be making. Now, are there some technical refinements we can make to the survey? Absolutely. Like the first three years, we had people pasting BGG URLs into the field and then we would go back and clean it up from there. Um, that worked. That got some very specific responses. Uh, but it was clunky and it meant a lot of work for us on the back end. This year we we put a new form in place that had that that connected to the BGG database on the back end so we could do the autocomplete very similar to the way you the the search field works on BG. Um it could use some refinement. Um not going to lie, but you know this is the first time we tried to do something different. Uh we were responding to complaints from before and you know we'll we'll get better as we go.
Fair enough. Uh, the other thing that I just find very notable about this list, I'm interested in y'all's opinions, is um, I think it's very interesting how many of the games that are on this list are still games that are like very out of print. So, Ambush very out of print. Uh, Rain St. Nazarea, very out of print. Um, you know, some of these are much older and then you've got some stuff that's like much more recent. Um, so what do y'all think about this spread of games in terms of the amount of time they cover? Uh, I I'll let one of the mics take that first because I've I've got some follow-up thoughts.
I mean, looking at it, I don't there's not a whole lot of really super old stuff on this list, right?
Well, uh, has been around
and Zill's got a good point. What is old? Yeah, that's right.
I mean, I think, you know, in the mainstream hobby, like something that's even like five years old starts to look old. So, one thing I love
P7, Queen of the Skies there,
that's
Ambush.
Yeah. Yeah.
Ambush for sure, right?
Raid on St. Nazir. That's Yeah. So, to to Zilla's point of exactly what is old, um, for the longest time in North Carolina, you could get a classic car tag through the DMV for a car that was more than 25 years old. 25 years doesn't get you back to the 1900s at this point. I'm sorry if I just depressed the entire audience and just gave most people extra gray hair.
You know what? I acknowledge now that I am old because I turned 40 in June and I've just hit I'm I'm entering that territory now.
Yeah. Um
I'm just going to pretend I'm aging gracefully and not worry about it.
I I think part of part of the reason you've still got some of the older games on here is that um first of all, they're not that hard to find. Like Ambush has been, you know, it was published back in the 80s, but you can find copies of Ambush for sale for not a ton of money and it still as a game still really holds up. Um, now some of the Ambush expansions are a whole lot tougher. Like trying to find Battleham or Purple Heart. Yeah, you're going to you're going to pay a good chunk of change for those, but the original Ambush you can still get pretty affordably. D-Day Omaha Beach has been out of print for a little while and it's it's, you know, approaching 20 years old or whatever. Um, but you can still find copies of D-Day Omaha Beach without a whole lot of hassle. Uh, once you get further down into the list down to where, you know, you've only got one or two votes for a particular game, that's when you start to get into the really weird, hard to find, obscure stuff. Um, but even a lot of the older ones that are on here, I think you can still the ones towards the top of the list that are reasonably popular, you can still find copies of those used without a whole lot of hassle.
And and to Bran, I'd like can I a clarifying question on how these are ordered, right? These it's a total number of points the game got, right? So, it's a combination of the more people that voted for it and the higher points they gave it combined into a sum, right?
Yeah. So the the list that Liz is showing is showing you just the ranking from year to year. The first of our results articles that we published. Um and and again all of the results and all the different number crunching we've got published over at the Dragoon site. Um you know as as Liz noted, there's the BGG geek list that just has like the top however many but not necessarily all the scores. the the more people that vote for it, the likelier it is to move higher up on the list.
But we do have some cases where you have games with fewer total number of votes but a higher score because it had fewer people voting for it but they all voted for it higher.
Um so the the primary sorting the the the criteria first criteria is what's the total score? what is the sum after that the next tiebreaker is how many people voted for it u which kind of gives you the average right how many people voted versus what you know what is the total score uh so that's that's how we sort it
because one of the things I was thinking the list to a certain degree is almost like a view like the same thing that happened to TV programs right so like 40 years ago there were six games and everybody played them right and now we have so many more games that the game playing hobby is fractur ed out over a larger sub a larger set. So those older games might be there from older gamers that played them and really liked them so they can gather a lot of votes even though maybe now there's some really good games that just not as many people are playing.
Exactly. And it and it's probably going to skew a lot harder towards the bigger publishers simply because they've got wider dro. The game gets in front of more people to garner those votes. Nothing we can do about that. I mean, this this this legitimately is a popularity contest. This is not us applying subjective evaluation to, hey, I think I think this is a better game. That doesn't matter. Like, what did the people tell us they liked?
That's what makes D-Day at Omaha Beach even more amazing, right? Nothing against decision games, but they don't really market. They make a game and they put it on this like really old website and then it's like an amazing amount of people play this game and like it.
Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah, it's really lovely actually. Um, so, uh, just a couple more fun questions about things that are up top, um, before we go into some statistical discussions. Brand, um, is there anything, um, that you really, really, really wish were in the top 25 that was on your list? I I mean, I have some favorites that never bubble up in these solo sorts of uh sorts of games. I I think there's a lot of great States of Siege games that have some really interesting twists to them. Um, that said, I think that series tends to diffuse the votes a little bit that that everybody's got their personal favorite States of Siege game and so none of them really climb the ladder just because there's a lot of them. Um, and not a ton of those have been reprinted either.
Like the one that that bubbled up on the list was the Ottoman Sunset one, which has been republished by Tycoon Games. Um, Hapsburg Eclipse and Otto and Sunset have both been republished by Tycoon Games. But like a bunch of the older ones, the Alamo game and uh uh Empires in America, the uh the French and Indian War game, uh there's a whole bunch of these. The uh the original Israeli Independence game, the first one that Darren Levoff did that kind of created the whole series. Those haven't been reprinted. So like you're hunting for used copies [clears throat] from Victory Point that's been out of business for
how long now? you know, so it's it I I wish those would show up higher, but that knee means somebody's got to republish these things.
Uh, Cruel Necessity was republished, and I I wonder where it fell out on this list.
Uh, I will tell you while you talk about whatever other game you're interested in,
I was happy to see uh Save South Vietnam there, which is a game that I really It made it to 39 this year, and it wasn't on the list last year. That's a It's a, you know, smaller publisher and the graphic design is probably very rudimentary, but oh, it's just got such a fun system for a longer solitire game. It's it I really enjoy that one. So, I was happy to see that one make an appearance there.
Yeah, Cruel Necessity is is tied among a lot of them at number 64. It had one first place vote, so it got five points for the one vote that it got, but there's a bunch of games in that same bucket. All right. So, we're looking at Save South Vietnam here at 39 for those of you who are tracking. And then Cruel Necessity was where?
64.
But there's a lot of games down at 64 cuz there's a whole lot of them that are all tied with one.
Oh, there it is. Yeah.
First place vote.
Yeah. So, I'm just going to scroll. Sorry for those of you who get a little bit motion sick. I'll try not to go too fast. Uh but basically what we're looking at in terms of actually looking at the statistics that are on this list is that you have things that multiple people voted for and then once you start to get further down uh there are a whole lot of games here that only some people like voted for like once.
Yeah.
And so
Okay. Wait, can you pause it for one second here because I'm I'm gonna point this out. Brent may know where I'm going here because I did a live chat not too long ago. Number 176. What does that say? Uh, here I stand.
Here I stand. The game you cannot play soliter. I hear that all the time and I'm I'm glad to see it on this list because I intend to do a solo playthrough of this pretty soon. So I it shocks me to see that. When I saw that in there, I was like, what is going on? So that's good to see.
It means
there are a number of like
there's a number of two-player games that are on the list here. That's
Oh, two-player games. Yeah, those are five. Here I stand as one and everybody swears you have to have six or seven. What's the maximum number? You got to have that many to play it.
Yeah. You know, Zillow, that's a good point in that, you know, this is something that that Liz has been very emphatic about pointing out in in for this survey every year. This doesn't necessarily mean just purpose-designed solitire games. This is any game you enjoy playing on your own, whether it's playing two-handed, playing with the bots, and and we'll get to it here in a few minutes, but that was one of the questions we asked was, "How is it that you play your your game solo?" Um, but but yeah, if it's something that you enjoy playing on your own, we don't care how many players it was designed for. And uh you know, BB Mike over on his my own worst enemy channel, you see he's had multiple games where he's two-handing a game um just playing on his own that that you
you've uh
the Civil War game that just came out from Pinkerton and the War Came. That's the one I was trying to think of. Um I mean that's a two-player game and you're like seven episodes into two hand in that thing. So
Well, Triumph and Tragedy, I did that one. That's four.
Three
players, I think. Three. Three. That's right. What am I talking about? That's the three. That and Conquest and Consequence.
Yeah.
But but here I stand is one that everybody says it's impossible to play solo. And I totally disagree. And I'm going to show how to play it solo pretty soon.
Just just so people know what they're looking at on the screen right now with uh with what Liz has on the screen. So the the first number as you go across
is the ranking from this year. And again, where where things are tied, they've got an identical number. Um, that next column is the change from last year to this year, whether it went up or down or wasn't even on the previous year. Um, then you've got the 2005 rank. Then the next column is the change from 2024 to this year. So, this is something that's that's important to note. When you see those change columns, that's comparing the year of that survey to this year. That's not comparing it to the, you know, whatever the next year might have been. So that's comparing everything from 03, 23, 24, 25 against where it is this year.
What does the plus number mean exactly?
Means that it went up on the chart versus down on the chart,
but not by 300.
Yeah, in some cases it did. Yeah. So, where you end up with a huge jump like that though is like if one person put it in fifth place, it is way the hell down on the list.
Oh, okay. Yeah.
Later on, you know, from from whatever that year was. And the next year if two people put it in first place, it's going to jump way up on the list, you know.
Yeah. I forgot about that.
Truthfully, you you almost need to ignore any game that doesn't have at least four votes. you know, once you get to four votes or more, you're into like actual like multiple people doing this and it's not just somebody pimping for their favorite, you know, their their one favorite game or trying to get an obscure one on the list just to get, you know, their buddy some press or something.
Although, allow me to note, I have a theory that the same person has put baseball highlights 2045, which is neither a historical nor a war game, in the same spot on their list two years in a row, which is why it's a shame.
Yeah. So, I've tried to weed some of those out and I just I haven't cleaned them all out. Um, the other thing you'll see the first at least the first year and I think it might have been the first two years, we did not explicitly include in the instructions, don't put fantasy and sci-fi games on here. I know we had that in the instructions in 2025 and and in 2026.
So, you're going to see Burning Banners show up uh couple of years ago. you're going to see some of the other sci-fi and fantasy kinds of games show up from previous years. We've tried to weed that out. And it's not that they're not good games. It's just not what we were going for with this survey.
Yeah. Although, let me note, even even things somebody only put once, I actually love kind of scrolling through this list and seeing what's here because I always learn about something new.
Oh, yeah. And I think that people just, you know, there's there's so many weird little hidden gems in the world of war games that, you know, just going for like the high point like, oh, I'm just going to play DD Omaha Beach, you're going to miss out on a lot.
Um, so it's it's really nice actually to like look deeper down the list and kind of see what's there.
Yeah. There there's one vote in there this year for a game called Archabald. Certainly not. And it's a World War I dog fighting game that's like on War Game Vault. It's it's a there's actually multiple expansions for it at this point. Um this is, you know, a a one-man shop. It's a very small press. Uh it's a pretty nifty little game, but it's one of those things. It's it's exactly what you're talking about there, Liz. It's, you know, and and what Zilla was talking about with Safe South Vietnam. You know, it's it's a smaller publisher. U it's not super snazzy production values. Um, but there's a pretty cool game underneath the hood there.
Well, like, you know, I've never heard of this Commander Romans versus Deans, but I'm going to look it up later because if I see something that's uh if Roman
I mean, you know, if it's got Romans, I'm I'm going to look at it. Um, so the thing that uh actually makes me the saddest actually is that there is not a lot of ancient stuff in that super high part of this. Like, you know, I'm a I'm a big fan speaking of Seeds of Siege, right? I love the CC's inspired, you know, silico less the Romans, Wars of Marcus Aurelius, and like they show up in here, but um, you know, I I I love my ancients and so I
Yeah. What is the highest ancients one?
I think it's Commanding Colors, honestly. I think it's it's it's up near the top. We got scan, scan, scan.
Which shocked me that I mean, Command and Colors I get, but I I don't understand why Ancients would be the one that would be picked. There it is.
But as a soliter game, you think?
Yeah, you could play it solitire. I mean, there's Joe,
but I think there are
doesn't have a dedicated solo system, right?
Yeah.
No, just the Stuka Joe. Uh, you can use that with it.
Right. Right.
But you could two-hand it. I mean, I've two-handed it and it plays fine two-handed.
Yeah. Commands and Colors Ancients got four votes and it's at number 32. Not far behind though, Pericles the Pelpeneisian Wars from GMT that actually got five votes. It only finished one point behind Commands and Colors Ancient. So more people voted for it. They just voted for it a little lower. Um so it's it it's not that far behind in in terms of the rankings there. Uh, I would suspect that one of the reasons CNC Ancients is up there is just it's very easy to find. It's very widespread. If you're if you're doing Commands and Colors, that's one of the easiest ones to get a hold of.
Um, and with all the different expansions they've had for you've got a wide variety of of armies and scenarios that you can that you can use for that.
Yeah,
I would argue to that one expands a little bit beyond the wargaming hobby, too. That goes a little bit more, you know. Yeah. Okay. So,
but here's my baby. Silico last the Romans. It's great. Go try it everyone. So, Brand, I didn't I' I've looked at a lot of your charts, but not all of them. Did you do any breakdowns by designer this year?
I did not break them down by designer this year. U it wouldn't be that hard to sort by designer and take a look. Uh but no, I I didn't do a breakdown specifically [clears throat] by designer. One of the things that is different this year, last year when we ran the query against the BGG database, the tool we were using only pulled back the first designer listed. So if you had a code design in there, like David Thompson designs with everybody. Liz, you know this. You're one of them. I do. Um, so I I think David Thompson other than those u valiant defense games um David Thompson like everything else is a code design and the they were only pulling back like David's name and not Trevor's name or whoever else or Liz for night witches at some point. Um, this year the query that we ran pulled back all the listed designers.
So, so we'd have more of them there.
Interesting. Cool.
Yeah.
All right. So, I'm going to take this down and Brent, let's look at some of your some of your charts. Also, where did Mike go?
Uh, I don't know.
There he is.
Actually from the stage. That's not on purpose.
I've got I've got a 18-year-old cat sitting in front of the keyboard and he hit something. I don't know what he hit. I didn't even know. Okay. Your own worst enemy. But then there's your cat.
Your reinforcements tonight.
Yeah. So So we've got some basic demographics we can talk about quickly and then we'll look at some of the comparisons um in there. And and I think there's there's two or three comparisons that I think have some kind of interesting things to to look at there. Um, so when whenever you're ready there.
Yeah. Let me put it up. Here we go.
Yeah. So, so we asked a handful of basic demographic questions. The one we've asked every year is how many years have you been wargaming? And we actually when we originally did this, we just did a 25 and up category. We the second year we had to add it to more than 40 years. We did like a 25 to 40 band. And even the more than 40 years, you can see like that is overwhelmingly who is responding to this survey. So, uh, you know, Zillow, when you talk about like it's a lot of older games on here still, um, look, it's a lot of older players. It's folks that have been doing this going back to the 80s. Um,
okay. Wait. So, so who here is on the more than 40?
Oh god, yes. So, um, but then this is the first year that we've asked specifically how old are you? Like if you go back and listen to some of the the previous podcasts and shows, like we were making some inferences based on how long people have been wargaming, like you haven't been wargaming for more than 25 years, unless you're like 30 years old. Um, this year we specifically asked how old are you? We did get one kid in the respondents in the 18 to 25 window.
Um,
love it. But you can see like the bulk of the audience has been playing forever and they're on the older side. It's just who we are.
You know what though? That actually makes me very happy that we've been collecting this data for several years because that means that we're capturing like some of the OGs in our data.
Yeah.
Um whereas if we were doing this in like another 20 years, we might not be. And I I really like that we get to uh to see what the old guard likes.
Yeah. Um, this question was asking, "What percentage of your overall war game o of your overall gaming diet is specifically wargaming and historical gaming?" And you can see like we got a bunch of folks in here that dabble in war games. It's not all people that are just hardcore all war games all the time. Um, which I think is nice because that gives us a little more insight into the kinds of games that uh folks that aren't hardcore war gamers would want to dabble in in the wargaming space. I think that's, you know, of our respondents. Again, this is not the wargaming hobby as a whole. This is the people that responded to our survey. Um, and then we asked, "How much of your wargaming, specifically wargaming, are you doing in the solo realm?" And again, this isn't trying to project across all of wargaming because this is a solo wargaming survey. The people that aren't doing a ton of solo wargaming are less likely to be responding to this. Yeah.
Um, but but that 75 to 99% like that's a pretty big chunk of folks, but that's who we're after, right? I mean, that's that's the target here. So, I'm actually very curious like of all of y'all's gaming, what percent would you say is war gaming? So, I would say that about half of mine is war historical and then the other half is just hobby.
Um,
I think it's a it's a Oh, go ahead.
I was just say I'm probably about 50/50.
I guess I would ask, are you talking about time or number of games,
right? Because like timewise, I am certainly more than half historical gaming. But total number of games, I can play other games. I can play five euros in the time often of like one organ. True. So
yeah,
I only have game night.
That's what I wonder how people
What's that?
I only have game night with other people once a week. So
Right. Right.
Yeah.
I'm 75.99 easy. I mean it's
Yeah.
Yeah. But I would say
probably more than half general board games with but timewise I'm probably threearters historical board games I think.
Yeah.
Oh, that's interesting. I would say that even half of my solo time is on on mainstream stuff these days, but of course I'm always like looking. I mean, I work for Leader. You know, I have a lot of games I got to be looking at all the time. So,
we do ask folks where they heard about the survey and and it's mainly either on the Geek or from us and some from Liz. Um Gary does a good job of mentioning it on his show when it's going on, but it's, you know, it's other social channels. Um, interestingly, nobody at Con World gives a So, this is not where they're hearing from. It part of that is the Consum World uh news page. CR has only updated that thing like four times this calendar year because he's been busy doing other stuff. Um, this is this was our first of the results articles and what's down below all this demographic info is just this is the list from this year. Um, I'm actually pageionated to page two right there, but [clears throat] that that's the list. It's the same thing Liz was showing a few minutes ago for the other numbers this uh you know we asked a bunch of different optional questions and so we've we've got some different interesting pieces here this year we asked what's your preferred uh solo method of of gaming like how do you of the different ways in which you can play the game solo what do you prefer and so I know BB Mike their multiplayer game two or more where you play all sides playing multi-handed That's our second most popular one. And
Liz, this is part of what you specifically were wanting to get at with the instructions on the survey all the, you know, all along is
if you enjoy playing it on your own, even if it's a multiplayer game that you play all sides, we still want you to count that. And people clearly have taken that to heart.
I was Go ahead, Mike. I was just going to say so for future surveys, I think this this needs a little more investigation. And I think what you would find is people like me that want to play all the sides of a game are looking for more of a narrative story than than trying to win a game. And I think the people that want the the purpose-designed solo games, I think they're looking to actually compete, if that makes any sense.
Yeah, [snorts]
I would say that's not 100% true for me. I like I enjoy purpose-built solo games because I don't always want to run multiple sides and if the AI is slick, you know, I like to just kind of play myself and then run like a very quick enemy turn.
Yeah.
Um
I like that too. Yeah, I Ben Madison games. I love Ben Madison games and that's all, you know, that's all solitire games.
But yeah, I get that.
Yeah, I was really surprised by how large that multiplayer games category was. I was
I would have guessed that before that.
Yeah.
I mean that it's it it's not far from from even dedicated solo game.
You know, Mike Mike's got a good point of
why are people playing them that way? And I I suspect in some cases it's people that are exploring the system or learning the system that just don't have a live opponent
regularly or handy. It's It's a lot easier to push counters around both sides at nine o'clock on a Wednesday night when you may not be able to wrangle an opponent to come over very easily.
I think too I think too though we've got a lot more two-player games that are very amenable solo like the highest two-player game if I'm not mistaken on the list was Most Fearful Sacrifice and and that has the you know the card draw really is what dictates the activation and I love that game solo. I love the blind sword system solo because it immediately throws you at something unpredictable and it's really easy to like shift the cognitive viewpoint if you would and say, "Oh, okay. What do I do now? I wasn't expecting this to happen." So, it's actually it throws a lot of fun problems at you as a person playing both sides. It's so unpredictable that I feel it kind of gets at a lot of that solo nature of the game. So, I wonder if maybe that's part of it too for some people.
It could be.
Yeah, it it could be. And and these are all really interesting questions to ask that we don't often get really dug into in this survey in large part because we're trying to keep it pretty lightweight. We want to keep it focused on that, you know, give us your top five in order so we can get the ranking piece of it. And the optional questions towards the end are are more intended as kind of lightweight fun than really trying to to psychologically profile the respondents. Yeah.
Yeah. Although I mean look, all of our psych all of our profiles would be terrifying because we play games by ourselves. But
um so so here's something I think is very interesting though is so okay like you know just from talking to people at GMT like there's a whole GMT1
Mhm.
outfit that is dedicated to making flowchartcard driven now bots. And you know people are saying that's not their favorite but that clearly doesn't make them not want it.
Yeah. Because if that were true, then that wouldn't be such a large part of our market.
A lot of coin games are showing up at the top of the list, too, though,
right? Cuba Libre is there. Fire Lakes up very up in like the top 12 if I'm not mistaken for both of those. So,
there's a subset that are liking that, you know.
Well, well, and and also too, the preferred solo method here was was a single vote. It wasn't like rank choice of like give us your top three. You you got to pick one out of this list. So, it may be that my preferred way to do it is a multiplayer where I'm playing everything. In the absence of that, fine. I'll live with a card driven bot or whatever else. We didn't ask for any sort of rank ordering of the preferences.
Yeah. [clears throat]
So, um continuing on here, let me get back to uh where we were. So, some of the other comparisons and and I'm sorry the tables aren't going to to really blow up that much. We did ask for your preferred solo method versus how much of your wargaming is played solo. So, just to kind of compare where that lands and and look, this a bit of numbers salad. You kind of hit the website and dig into it a little bit more. But playing multi-handed and event driven, you know, you you guys saw up above, those were both far and away those most popular options. But there's no set of solo war gamers in terms of slicing what percentage of your games are solo where those aren't the top two options. So, so regardless of how much you're playing solo, those are the two most preferred ways to do it among our respondents.
Um, but again to, you know, to the point earlier, there's other ways to do it and clearly there's a market for that. We just, we didn't ask what's your second favorite, you know. Um, and then we also asked your preferred solo method versus how long you've been a war gamer and so does the the kind of solo method you use change based on how long you've been playing? Um,
yeah.
And and not so much, although the the multi-handed ones tend to have a little more even spread uh relative to some of the other styles. One of the things that you find though is that the the rookies, first of all, we don't have as many of the folks that have been playing three or fewer years. Basically, folks that have picked up Wargaming since the pandemic, um, have really only discovered purpose-built solo or multi-handing the game. There's not a lot of the other adaptations that they've reported as being a a preference. Um, some of this may just be they don't know any better. Uh uh but again, we're drawing some inferences based on a limited pool of knowledge. Um
yeah,
and and I'm going to zip through a couple of these that we did add we did compare how much you play war games versus how much of your wargaming is solo. [snorts] And the folks that uh your solo percentage is on the higher end are folks that tend to play a lot more war games. Um, and and I suspect some of that probably just has to do with lack of opponents. Like if you're playing a lot more war games, but you don't have opponents nearby, you are stuck playing. I mean, like maybe Mike, you don't have any neighbors nearby, never mind opponents. So, you know, you're stuck playing solo. Um, and then what's your uh the percentage of historical in war games in your overall gaming diet versus how long you've been playing war games. Um, and and interestingly enough, the folks that are kind of in the middle there that between three and 25 years uh tend to have a pretty wide spread among our respondents of how much of their their their overall gaming is wargaming.
Um,
interesting.
I'm gonna zip past a couple of these because I I So, Liz, is Beyond Solitaire really the queen of solo games.
Of the people that found out about this survey from Beyond Solitire, uh, what percentage of them are actually primarily solitire gamers, and interestingly enough, a whole bunch of your respondents play less than half of their games, their war games solo.
You know what? I'm an evangelist. go right in there.
That's actually a good thing if you ask me. Um, no, I think it's um I want more people to be playing these games.
It was just a chance to have a little fun with where about it.
But also truly like I'm hoping that lists like this make people think I should try that. Um because that's the hope, right? Like we uh um I'm really glad that this is a part of the hobby that has like long running traditions. However, I also really want to see like new blood coming in.
Yeah. Yeah. Um, Zilla, you you mentioned the, you know, older games versus newer games. This is something that was kind of interesting. I I went back and grabbed just the people who have been wargaming for more than 25 years. That's the top 10, although there was a tie down at the end, so we ended up with 11. That's the top of the charts for the people who've been wargaming for 25 or more years. It is very very close to the top of the overall charts. That's kind of what you would expect when this is like half of your respondent pool right there. It's going to pretty closely mirror what the overall chart is. Interestingly though, if you look at the folks that have been wargaming for under 10 years, so that 0ero to one, 1 to three, 3 to 10 all combined, you notice just about all of these are ones that are still in print or only very recently out of print, but these are all ones you can find on store shelves. The folks that are relatively new to Wargaming, haven't dug up a ton of the really old games, D-Day Omaha Beach being the one semi exception. Like it's an older game, but it's had multiple reprints. The rest of these things are all pretty new.
That's really interesting,
huh?
Giant Company second edition is not even out yet, is it?
Oh, yeah.
Yeah.
Is it?
It's been out. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's the one that people think of now.
Yep. Yep. But these are all ones that that you've got a decent chance of finding on store shelves or if you place an order with the publisher are likely to get it in the mail fairly soon. So, the folks that haven't been wargaming for as long, um, their favorites are not ones that are going deep into the archives. These are all things that are pretty common and easy to find on store shelves. Now, again, some of these only got three votes within that category. So, it's it's tough to draw huge comparisons and huge uh descriptors from our respondents based on a very limited number of people we've [clears throat] got here. But I did find it interesting that the trend across all of these is
these are all still in print. I don't think any of these had an original publication date that starts with a 19.
I think these are all 21st century games. Um,
interesting.
Of the folks that play 75% or more of their wargaming solo, again, that's a half the respondent population. So again, this looks a lot like the top of our charts, which is what you'd expect with that many of them. Um, but we scroll a little further down. The folks whose solo wargaming is 25% or less. Um, first of all, there weren't a whole lot of them. Um, but it's these are primarily solo play games, not ones, they're not multi-handing games the way that, you know, BB Mike does quite frequently.
Yeah. And I would suspect that's because if they've got a multiplayer game, they've got other people to play with, which is why their percentage of war game of solo wargaming is so low. You know that that's 75%ish is not solo. So you can play those multiplayer games with other people that if you're going to play solo, you're playing a dedicated solo game. So, those were a couple of the things that kind of
I think this kind of ties back to my point though that these people are playing multiplayer games and they kind of want that competitive factor in there. And when you're playing these solitire only games, you're trying to look to beat the system. And I'm not saying that's the answer. I just that's the feeling that I have that just seems like there's a competitive element with people who prefer solitire only games versus somebody that likes to multi-hand. I could be totally wrong. I'm happy to be wrong.
That could be.
I I enjoy just the sort of narrative of games and I still prefer to play solitire Built. Um but I also think that, you know, I'm on the sort of outer edge of I don't really care if there's a real victory condition even depending on what the game is. Like I've been having a really great time with Amabel Holland Swords Against Recently. Um Beginner's Box. It's literally a fake found object that happens to be a partial RPG with a bunch of notes in it. uh you know so you know uh I think my tolerance for I'm looking for experiences
of various types I think that's true of a lot of gamers who are this deep in the hobby
yeah I think I'm I'm kind of both way like sometimes if I'm tired and you I just want something that's going to spin a story then I'll sit down and love to play something like but some if I feel like I want a challenge I'll jump into something like you know D-Day at Omaha Beach and say okay let's see if I can finally get off the beaches with half my troops or something like that. Yeah, actually for me the big one is, you know, I it's not that I don't enjoy games that are kind of chartastic, you know, like a B7, but um I typically prefer games where I feel like I have more agency and more choice.
Yeah.
And so that [clears throat] can come in any form. Um it's just that's not my type of game.
Yeah. I think some of that goes back to that preferred solo method, you know.
Yeah. And I think narrative games oftentimes are lacking agency.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
One of the common
not a criticism of it, but yeah, they can be. Yeah.
Well, but but for people that don't enjoy those kinds of games, one of the common complaints that you hear about something like a B7 Queen of the Skies is
I I'm not really playing a game. I'm just a dice chucker for the AI.
Yeah. you know, the the decisions are already made and I'm just picking which decision, you know, which which one on the tree, but it's it's not as much of an open world. Um, because it has to be predefined in order for it to be printed in the book, and it's just a matter of how many options do I have available to me in the book. So, um, but but yeah, I think part of that goes back to what's your preferred solo method and and you know, BB Mike, back to your point of what am I trying to get out of this? Am I looking for the competition or am I telling the story?
So, um, you know, the [clears throat] there are a lot of different ways to slice and dice the numbers on this and and folks that are interested in in sort of running their own cross tabs, pivot tables, and comparisons, um, reach out to me. That's fine. the data is deidentified. I don't mind sharing the data for you to sort of crunch your own charts with that and see what you want to see. Um, if you want to try and identify all the people that picked games of a, you know, certain set of titles and what's their preferred solo method or what are their ages or whatever, like cool, go crunch whatever you want. These are just the ones that we happen to pull as uh as kind of some broader comparisons uh just just to give some alternate views into the data. Yeah.
So, can't be all things to all people. Other folks got to step up and crunch some numbers, too.
I don't crunch numbers. I just make you do it.
Yeah. Well, there's that.
I taught Latin, not math.
I I got degrees in English and journalism. Why am I the number cruncher?
That is your fault. Um, so, uh, since we've kind of like looked at all these, uh, these very cool charts, um, Mike Zilla, BP Mike, do y'all have any thoughts about overall trends that you're seeing that have kind of caught your eye?
I don't know if I've actually seen a trend. Well, should I say that without digging into the charts more? I mean, it's interesting to see there's not much moving on the top, too.
No. Yeah, it's the same couple at the top of the charts. Hold on, I'm gonna pageionate us back to the first.
Although I I really think Builds of Fire is number one this year. I hate to say that.
Yeah, if you add number 23 in there, you add them together, it's far and away by its own little category.
Oh yeah, absolutely.
That's why Benhal asked.
Yes, that's exactly why Ben asked because he wants to be number one. And
and those those top two have been the same top two all four years. And there's a big gap between two and three.
Yes.
Yeah.
Like it's like the third one has like half as many as number two does. Right.
And if you go back and look, that's been pretty consistent over the years. Numbers 3 through 10, 3 through 12, whatever. Those will vary. It's there's a couple of the usual suspects that will show up there pretty commonly. Um, but that that the rest of the top 15 are relatively consistent, but there is definitely a big gap between those top two and whatever's next.
You can see it here, right? 132, 125, 62, right? I mean, that's it's like you can you can double that and it's still not passing Fields of Fire. Like Pavlov's house isn't passing Fields of Fire Deluxe Edition. Um, yeah,
but if we had Liz pull up the other spreadsheet and sort by like the 2025 rank, well, you you won't see the scores on that spreadsheet, so it wouldn't make that big a difference. But but Zilla, you're you're right. There is a big [clears throat] gap, and we've seen that consistently over the years.
Those top two, and then there's another block of
10 to 15 that are relatively common that show up on a bunch of ballots. And then it starts to get into which one happened to get multiple votes this year.
Yeah, I'll be very interested to see as the hobby hopefully grows um what what could change at the top of this list.
Yeah,
because you know, Mage Knight used to be impenetrable, too. And now Spirit Island is the one that's like at the top of the People's Stress top 200. Um, and so, you know, things look locked up for years and then suddenly you see a big change. And
we have a couple of big ones coming, I'd argue, too. Like away team.
Away team.
Is that a war game? I don't know. Maybe that's a whole conversation to itself. We also have Pacific Chase,
which
maybe thematic. Atlantic Chase is sitting at what 121
and Pacific Chase I think could be a bigger hit than that. So maybe a couple of contenders in the
Well, I don't know that away team would be one that would necessarily because again we we ask folks to leave out the fantasy and sci-fi stuff.
Oh yeah. Then it won't make it. Yeah.
So that would arguably not a war game.
Some jabroni is still going to put away team on there because they're going to ignore the instructions. Um but like Mr. president shot up into the top 10 that first year and and you know you could even go back to the podcast and and and listen the second year we did it when Mr. President shot up there the question was does this have staying power or is this just the new hotness it's had staying power now it's it the first edition's largely been replaced by the second edition this in this survey just because the second edition's out now and and has some significant fixes to it. Um, but it's it is one that is has shown some staying power and and we were curious.
Hey, is this just cuz it's the cool new thing? Um, it's stuck around.
I think it was curious.
I'm I'm curious about what your surprises are in say the top 20. Like you say, what why is that game? Not not that you're you're ripping on the game or anything, but
um
for me it was the the Comancheria. I I and it's a game I've looked at and it looks interesting, but I need to look at it again because it's way up there.
Commissioner and Navajo Wars as a pair are just have been hot
for so long and they're consistently pretty high year-over-year. They're they're up there pretty consistently. Um I [clears throat] I'm a little surprised to see John company this high. I know there is a dedicated solo bot that has now been built for it.
Yeah.
Um I just I don't know how you play that solo even with a bot.
I just I I don't see it there. Not mechanically you could pull it off, but I think so much of that game involves the negotiation and horse trading and discussion with the other people around the table. I just I think it's almost a completely different game if you're trying to play it. solo challen goes that way with like PAX Premiere goes that way with me too. I love it multiplayer. It left me a little flat solo, you know, and I know Liz, you love it solo, too. But, um, yeah, for me [clears throat] that's multiplayer is where it shines, you know.
I'm less enamored of John Company solo. I really like I I feel like packs from your solo at least. It's like you don't have to negotiate. Although, you know, uh, BB Mike, you know, here I stand is a very heavy negotiation game.
And that's why I watch Watch that video. Yeah, there's ways you can do it. I am curious. I'm gonna see if the filtering is going to work here because I am curious. Yeah. So, the Mike Granola games, I mean, a bunch of these are a lot of the same system that that solo area impulse system. Um, and he's got three of them in the top 50 there. U [clears throat] Cities of the Damned, like that's a a oneoff. It it's it's a magazine game. It got one vote from somebody. That's why it's way down on the list. Um, but the other three all got at least five votes. They're all in the top 50 on the list. Um, that's a system that you haven't seen other people try and run with at all.
So, that is that is one that is there. Um,
you know, I'm sure if [snorts] we went filtering just on Gregory M. Smith, we'd find like 40 games in there.
He's probably designed two just in the time we've been recording this video.
Yeah. I love that the search function is here, by the way. Like I highly encourage people to play with it and just see what they find. Uh because it's just it's just really neat.
Yeah. So
look at that. John Butterfield three out of the top 10.
Oh, there's D-Day at Peloo. See, I I have I do not own D-Day at Omaha Beach because when I was deciding between that and D-Day at Peloo, I was like, I'm a Pacific guy.
Yeah. Um
and and there are a bunch of folks out there that D-Day at Omaha Beach has been through four or five printings at this point. It's It's been through a bunch of different reprints. Um, and I think it's actually in the process of getting reprinted again like right now. I don't I don't know if that's on the boat or it's at the factory right now, but I think it's I think Doc said they're [clears throat] reprinting it again right now, but you do not have a hard time finding people who think that Taro or Peloo are better games.
Yeah.
So,
yeah.
Um, but yeah, there's there's plenty of Butterfield on the list. Um, which is not a big surprise. I I am curious. Let's just go take a look at there's there's your Gregory M. Smiths again. There's a bunch of them on the list. They're just not quite as high as the Butterfields.
Well, now do me a favor because I I do like to play solitire only games even though I said I like play multi better. Where's Ben Madison? That's my guy. There we go.
Uh, interestingly, the highest ranked one is one he did with Wes. Um,
but he does all these with Wes. That's kind of
But I will say he might have the most on here by number.
He's got 16 of them.
He's still turning them out. Yeah, he's still putting them out fairly regularly.
He He's got 16 of them and there's there's a handful of them missing, right? Like Death of the Trenches is not a purpose-designed solo game.
Um, but but there's still multiple ones that are missing off of here.
Yeah. even with that many of them on there.
Yeah, absolutely. Victory was on there. Yep.
All right. So, in the interest of um respective time, we do have to kind of draw this to a close, but uh does anybody have any parting thoughts?
I'm going to let this year
for me. It's just great to see all this data and information. Thanks so much for all your hard work in putting it together and for everybody that voted in it. This stuff is really helpful for the hobby. So, it's great to see And if you're watching, you probably voted, but try to encourage other people to vote, too. We need more people to vote. Get more data to crunch.
Yes, I want more data. And not in the creepy Facebook way. I just want to know what games you like. I don't even have to know who you are.
Yeah, we we're not asking for a ton of personal information here. We we do ask for an email address just to help deconlict duplicate entries. Um, one thing that I think we will do in the future when we ask for email address, we'll put like a basic checkbox right afterwards about are you okay if we email you next year to say, hey, the survey is open again. Uh, just to make sure that people know to come back again. Um, that is one thing that is a little frustrating is this is now the fourth year of us doing this. We do it at the end of the summer every year and we still get people that go, "Man, I didn't even know this was happening." It's like
it's been four years. How do you keep missing this?
We're trying everyone. But yeah, my hope for next year is I want to see more votes. Um it makes me happy to not only know that there are people like me out there. It makes me feel less lonely um and my solo gaming. Uh but also um I think that uh getting information year about what people are playing is just really it's just really cool. That reminds me of like what is what is good in our in our end of the hobby.
Yeah. I wanna I want to figure out a better way and and this is a place where I'm happy to take suggestions from the audience.
I would like to find a better way to track the games over time kind of going up and down and and I understand that there's a limited value in that because it is a very small population we're looking at. We we have yet to crack 300 respondents. So, we're talking anywhere from like 180 to 250 or so people replying on any given year. So, I I want to be very careful that people understand we are not trying to describe the war game hobby as a whole. We are talking about the people that responded to the survey of the people that responded to the survey. This is what they liked. This is what they didn't like. How long they've been wargaming, how much of it is solo, all that kind of stuff.
But it would be interesting to track some of those things year-over-year just to see the movement. There's a little bit of that in the spreadsheet that I've got, but like I would love somebody who's got better ideas of how to track those things uh to help us do that. That would be cool.
Yeah. Uh but for this evening, we will draw this to a close. Uh that said, I am super glad that y'all came on to talk to me. Brandt, thank you so much for doing all the actual number crunching. I really appreciate it because Lord knows I can't. Um, and um, everybody out there, you know, if you're if you've listened this far, uh, please go and play a solo historical game uh, of any type. Uh, because that's the reason we make this list is because we want you to be celebrating this with us and the best way to celebrate is to play. Um, so thank you gentlemen, all of you for coming. Uh, everybody else, please like, subscribe, comments, and most of all, happy gaming.