Dinoniche (C+) Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
But, let's get to it. Dino Niche, the accurate dinosaur minis game, final grade. And I hope it's good. I don't know. Do I want it? Yeah, I do. That video started off great. I really think that video exceeded my expectations drastically. When I saw a 4-minute 11-second video, I was like, "Oh my god, what are you doing?" And honestly, I'd say it but it was only about 30 seconds to a minute too long. Industry standard, once again, roughly around 2 minutes, less than 2 minutes people try and stay. So, you really got to be bringing it if you're going to put a 4-minute 11-second video, and they did. The The whole National Geographic going into terms and explaining this and that, it was very, very well done. Looks great. Do I want it? Yes, I do as both a board game fan, and yes, I do as a miniatures game enthusiast. Can you do it?
[sighs]
Well, first and foremost, you ask for $3,000, which is bullcrap, right? Like, unless you're printing this yourself, or you're independently wealthy, you're lying about that number. And then, you just ripped any potential excitement out of your campaign that you possibly could have by having just an absolutely abysmal stretch goal. Yes, if we hit 66 No, no, we have to go more. If we hit a little bit over 66 times our funding goal, then you get Huh? Drumroll. STL files. Okay. Well, don't worry. I did like just And if we get to 50,000, we'll get STL files. And then we get to 300,000, you can buy more stuff from us, but don't worry, it won't be in the all-in. Also, oh, did you buy the deluxe? Well, I you know, typically, the deluxe set has everything in the core set, but more, or deluxe-ified, and we decided we're going to buck the industry standard, and cuz maybe I want both of them. You're like, "How this one's just a better version of that?" Well, you let me make that choice. Maybe I want to try some crazy strategy where all my people have the same special ability. I'm going to have fun with that, right? But, you stripped that away. And when I found out about it, I was annoyed. Right? Because as a completionist which completionist which is most people that back projects on Kickstarter and Gamefound. It's not my opinion. That is straight up facts based on how people shop. Seven to 10 times to one. This pledge or that pledge should be outselling the standard
pledge. And they are nowhere near that. That being factored in with the fact that they're making six extra boxes or five extra boxes and they only have 129 print run of all those. Now granted, there's going to be people buying stuff in the back end. That's majorly concerning on the can you do it aspect. Like it's almost like I'd love to be like, "Hey, by the way, you know, I got I got I got money in the background." Like I have I don't know. They got $150,000. So we don't have to worry about that. But I will say, if they didn't if they were stuck at any Whoa. That's a really high number of new people. Good for you bringing Denver in on it. All right. Can you do it is uh I don't feel great. I don't feel great. I would read that rule booklet. I would absolutely read that rule booklet with a fine-tooth comb.
But it doesn't feel like you're going to get this after retail. So they do have that going for them. And then how much is it? Feels bad. And it it it feels bad because of what you did. Because you didn't tell me the size of these at all. Except for 148. Yet you all you did was focus on the minis. Just minis upon minis upon minis upon minis upon minis. I'd love to know THE SIZE. WHAT'S THIS SIZE? WHAT'S THE JUST tell me the smallest and the the largest. What's this size? What's that size? Tell me millimeters. Tell me inches. Tell me what this size is. And instead, like I'd love to know what more of these. Like these Zoom in on these cards. Let me know more more about the cards. And [clears throat] it's just nope, we're going to do minis. We're going to do lots of minis. And then they're going to like, "Well, you think we're done with the minis?" We're going to do even more minis down here. We're just going to have a huge section that's blown with nothing but minis. And it's just like, "No. Show me the meat."
Especially if you're trying to get that board game pie which I think you could have. I I you very well could have. Unfortunately, your $99 pledge does not feel Actually, that one feels It feels fine. Feels fine as a first-time publisher. Yeah, I'm just scared. I'm I'm I'm legitimately a little bit concerned. Cuz it's a lot of No, they're fine. They got 150 grand. Final grade is um I think I give them a third of a point grade bump up for the great video. I think I give another third of a point grade bump up for their didn't work hardly at all, but still really cool idea that I want to see more people copy because what's the risk of say, "Hey, we're trying to get these retail stores to back."
Right? And so, we want you to potentially just go talk to them about it. And if they they do it for 500 bucks, then bada boom, you get this extra thing. That's awesome. That is objectively just one of the coolest I I don't think I've ever seen a retail challenge before. And if I have, I don't think it was nearly this cool. So, that deserves its own third of a point grade bump up. But, there's a lot of bad habits, too. And I can't overlook them just because I I I do love dinosaurs and this looks fun and I I want to I want someone I own to buy the all in, the nearly $700 all in. That hurts to say. And teach me how to play it. But, those two third of a point grade bump ups, I think bumps this up to a B minus.
Yeah, I do. I think that video did so much heavy lifting. I think the retail idea, while it didn't it really didn't do much of anything at all probably, is still just a really cool idea that I love seeing anyone trying to do different things on Kickstarter and Game Found that aren't necessarily bucking industry standard. Like, I hate when people try and buck industry standard and just like, "Why did you do that?" Like, them putting three shipping sections down below. I was like, "Uh, one would be well one would do you perfectly fine." But, I don't think I've ever seen anyone really try and gamify the retail aspect of it. So, I'm going to go with a Yeah, I'm C plus. I can't go B minus. I I do legitimately have some concerns about just just how few people are buying the $600 pledge level and how much stuff is locked behind the $600 pledge level.
And just the rookie mistakes of like, "Hey, the deluxe is is like this, but it's kind of different." It's like, "No, no, no, no." And I'm also worried about your shipping, too. Like, I'm worried about a lot. Like, I wish you told me Are these Are these manufacturers or those shippers? I think if you know your manufacturer, it'd be nice to mention it, too. Just any sort of little security blanket would be nice. But once again, I'm going to go with a C plus. I think it's a B plus away from a I think it's a a B plus away from with that Jalop not there. And I can't help but wonder like what what impact Jalop had on this project like in that story because it's just 3,000 to 200,000. Just Oh, man. Yeah. C