Noir: Automata - Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised everyone welcome to the discussion for noir automata now quick caveat to this review because there are in the in this game in noir automata back here this game small game by level 99 there are technically four games within the box so the first game you have is the one that you watched in the run through the two-player killer vers inspector then you have spy tag which is case two that's three players or you can do four with teams rival networks have spies of spies have infiltrated the city now pass the citizens while quietly observing daily life and awaiting activation the time to make your move has finally come find the neutralize of the rival agents driving them back into hiding in this game all players are spies with a few simple actions that their disposal hunt down the rival spies alone or with the help of a partner in order to win so basically I'm assuming you know relatively similar game and it's a for both cops yeah so then there's that one then you have buddy cops which is a more detailed one these all have the length and complexity so this one's 20 or 30 minutes complexity easy buddy cops a team of two cops will take on one powerful killer each player has two different actions available to them and must utilize these in order to claim victory so this one's a different different set up different way to play 20 30 minutes complexity moderate and then dragnet which is use your evidence
to build a complete row column or diagonal of five suspects including the secret suspicions of yourself and others propose your solution and use the information of the other players in order to win so Josh and I is actually only game I've played with Josh is or the only the only version we've played was the first case so this is what the review delivery linear effect editor killer vs. inspector so whatever we initially played this game we thought it was completely unbalanced yeah very much towards in favor of of the detective yeah they'd exonerate ability yeah that's literally hit like there's no no there's not really any theme to this game so it's it's kind of abstract they kind of have some theme you know the robot you know no water setting which i think is cool I'd really like to see like a actual board game oh yeah detective or Sherlock or yeah that would be crawling the crime that'd be a really neat neat setting because not a lot of games have to do with robots actually being you know or slightly modest and set in like a cop and investigation right because you have the moral ambiguity of like well it's a robot who cares you know to try to become human yeah there you go Detroit become human the board game make it happen yeah that'd be cool so the theme that is here it could be about anything oh it like literally but it's an it's a
cool idea rhythm attacked Isaac in the Batman with a spike dildo why I was programmed to another why so initially you're gonna think well it's it's the it's in favor of the cop and I would almost still say it is just because the exonerate rule yes like all they do is they always have a hand of four cards or three cards and they can just pop them down willy-nilly and that gives them some information like it's like I'm gonna pop it down here okay are you any of these eight people yes I am okay well that's that narrow so you can try and keep focus and then over and over you can keep accelerating to just eventually whittle it down and that doesn't give the killer anything you know like I gained nothing of where you're at like potentially you know like it doesn't give me any idea doesn't so pretty much it only helps the cop which is a really one way for the killer to win I guess technically too if you if you solve and you're wrong which you were 50/50 you knew it was Karl for sure only you never either between X and Yolanda in the last game so because of the people I exonerated right Lester Vernon first look yeah all right next up
both of them exactly so I was like okay so I switched to Karl and which doesn't help me if you already know it's Karl but so in all reality let's take the solve one out of it I could do that 50/50 shot so it's still kind of it's in both of our favors but I didn't do anything to cause you to first round first first way out you were ignoring that one even though that is funny but it is got kind of gonna come up so for the killer to win they have to kill ten people that is a lot of people in this in this game like to kill ten without you really figuring it out there's 25 people over time when you're exonerating off like ever almost every round then you're like okay well you killed this person so he has to be adjacent I'm exonerate the opposite side oh you are okay that pretty much the only way you really could not fight figure out who it is is if they continuously switched and their people were completely opposite side you have aboard yeah which I mean yeah you can train I tried we I even in the games because we played this a lot I try to may i tried many different methods i've tried the quick kill to try and kill as many people as quickly as possible before you can figure it out and that snips away it gives you away too quick because even only kill adjacent people so then if i try to do it a slower way that's just giving you more and more time because once you exonerate you draw so then moreover that the time of the game you
know who it who it isn't like if something because of the game when I was the detective I was like man he could be Albert when you get was down here and I drew Robert no he can't he can't be so then it has to be this character me make a rata to the rule to where you don't draw until your next turn yeah though having less cards in your hand with definitely helped but the fact that it says you always have have three and then I mean yeah you exonerate people and then the killer kills the exonerated ones it gives away where you already way but then also tells me where you're at potentially but at the same time if you exonerate somebody far away from you and then it's down there you're up here and they kill it just gives away who they are yeah even if I was all the way up here in the corner and Ewing Sun that just that tells you okay I'm not here so that cuts out those nine people so then like that sections off you know half the board's almost or it's like okay he has to be these people so the more we talk about it the more I still think that the exonerate is more broken because the only way for the killer to really win is besides killing the ten people is killing the detective and the first came I just got lucky yeah that wouldn't happen to kill that was horrible I'm just like okay well great that that's not that's not fair I didn't do anything that was just a shot in the dark my initial thought with killing ham was he's in the middle yeah that that's you know one two three four
five that's seven people that it could have been but it just happened to be you so I'm like great then again even the people I'm killing I don't know what's in your hand and that was the first time a killer had ever won yeah out of every game ever and ever in a luck fest so when you're sitting here as the killer you're either running around the entire board is constantly constantly moving constantly shifting I don't know I I still think it's in favor of the detective it most definitely is I didn't we did or at least I didn't know about the solve rule because when we first played we would solve couldn't figure it out and we didn't lose we just kept going right right yes that means games would have ended a lot sooner correct then there's the accuse which is choose a suspect as adjacent to your secret identity if it matches the killer's current then the killer surveilling declare you the winner you may accuse yourself so you can constantly accuse which also sounds broken because oh I'm exonerate okay next time I'm gonna accuse him no great I know it's not you and then I just get all your chains you potentially change secret identity I think that was their way of trying to help the killer out plug having games yeah it's been like oh good I changed it to well it doesn't help if I already know your I already know for a fact like in our game that you were Kirby so it's like okay I know perfect so either you continue staying
as him but you can't do anything with him because then it's like okay well I know it's you so I'm just gonna run towards you oh you potentially switched so I don't know I cannot see the killer are you saying besides getting a lucky shot and happening to win or because you wouldn't have solved had he known the game ended if you were wrong yeah I wouldn't have you would if I had known that rule was like that I would not have solved you would you would have kept going I would have and then at the same time had you kept going then I was I was going to kill Nick see yes which then I would have won because I knew from killing pearl that you weren't adjacent so it couldn't be awesome I mean I guess that's there also the way of balancing is I have to secretly dennings so if I figure out who you are you could it's a race to kind of figure it like okay can I can i arrest him before he kills me yeah I think to a proper errata for the game would be if instead of the exonerate to show the eight people you like pick four yeah so you're like I exonerate our Ockham I pick pearl Carl Verna and Dixie are you any of them yeah that I feel like that would be more fair yeah but then again if you do that in that particular case then it's like instead of those four then it's no longer like like if you had done well I
guess in that particular instance then there's only four adjacent to them but that definitely narrows it down quicker versus just placing it down are you on Theo and I'm saying yeah I'm near him which would be Carl Edgar Sam Zeke and Malone but in the first game it'd be those eight people that's true versus going okay are you Zeke Sam glory and Carl yes okay well then these four completely out all together I know for a fact that you're one of these four instead of oh you could you're one of these eight but I think that's true that do pick in the four becomes even stronger late-game oh yeah yeah you're early to get the pink okay then it's like I'm gonna do this okay are you seeker Malone yes great all right yeah I know you're one of them um I want to say that I like the game I do too like I'm not hating on the game because here's the thing it's 10:20 we played three games in 30 minutes it's got ten minutes again Oh gives you a slight um you know you know read each other you know 1v1 in this particular case so there is those those kind of mind games versus like the kind of heavier ones like Oni tamo which is a kind of oh man like you my likes yes I did don't care for that know why I really like but so if this was any longer I would hate you can you open up were you mini game where it's just like swing of that I like swinging the cards okay I'm
gonna exonerate Nick secret yep I'm near him okay no so it's it's a light game gives you that some some you know play your opponent I the game I actually don't know how much it cost because luckily level 99 was able to with gave me this review copy which was awesome because I love this company like my two favorite games by them or battle Khan and millennium blades and millennia blaze actually on Kickstarter did they do a temporal the Oh temporal Odyssey that's the Magus one really that game is awesome I'm the guy who I kind of Tron a blank on his name off to look it up they kept well it's he's not long that one the guy who made temporal Odyssey is actually the one who hooked me up with this oh this review copy I'm actually gonna look at though right but and side note he did say he plans on supporting temporal Odyssey good my game is obliged super great and it just means a little bit more like more variety with like the strongholds and stuff like that I think that game is definitely a 1v1 game uh-huh to be two was a bad there we go let's see the designer was all about rating Chris Chris soulless that's right so that's sad it's a six-point not
another 1000 this game is definitely no no no temporal Odyssey does oh but no war motto what is say this game is I guess it's all amount of noir but 7.1 say this game is at least a seven yeah so but that's the thing is whatever this cost you get the 1v1 and then the other ones just required three people three to four or on the last one so you get four games I'd like to try the other ones too but unfortunately we've only done the killer verse inspector um I mean that's that's pretty much it like there's not a whole lot because it is such a small game Brande Brande Talton is the I believe the lead designer or the creator or CEO of level 99 so yeah I think this is a great game if this was any longer I would despise it for its I would still say it's unbalanced but maybe there's a strategy we're missing as the killer there probably is feel like replated at night though all all people commenting you guys are stupid guys suck I mean tell us what we're missing yeah like this is the killer because I I can't think of a different way to try and play it besides killed constants kill switch kill switches I was doing that for a while yeah and then moving how many I got six kills I think I got six I guess um well I guess maybe collapsing because then that reduces your distance
away from me so if I collapsed here one it was that you would have dropped I mean I would add I would have been next to both of your killers you Lana Karl would have been right and then you have to guess which one I am so if you if I was sitting here and I was gone des and you're like I'm gonna accuse Karl and it's like okay no and then it's like great I know you're one of these people and then I'm gonna kill nixing and then you would have died so like I said there's some mind games in there one you did brilliantly and the other one by pretending to switch and on my crappy piece Kirby and I don't try to accuse him he'll kill me and I was stupid and didn't think it was a and then I'm like a kirby and then you're like no and I'm like crap I just gave myself away that's the only person it can be because everyone's like that one was exalted there was no one next to him and then at that point I was trying to roll no way so this game this game is fun a scale of 1 to 10 um it's I wouldn't give it anything higher than like any like the very top yeah but like from the first game or it's like ship shift oh I'm dead yeah i'ma kill leo oh yeah just because of that and unbalancing I'll give it a 7 it's a good 7 um so I well that's just from the one
one the one which we haven't we haven't tried these three um based off of their descriptions on how you want to play I like the idea of spy tagging bunny cops I think up my final one sounds ridiculous you have to complete five in a row that one just sounds kind of weird and a column a row or diagonal or diagonal I like the theming of spy tag it takes on one powerful killer so it's like to be one which could be cool and then the buddy cops a team of two cups will take on one oh that's the team of with the power killer so those sound cool will definitely forgive those a try oh yeah if we would not if when we do please let me keep this game when we do play these I'll probably do a nil run to review and talk about these just because they gave me the review copy and I want to cover it as much as possible but this might be the one that most people play is I don't know but I think it's it's a light game it's a gateway game and don't hate it I was gonna I was ready to [ __ ] all over it whenever before we played it again for the run-through I'm like no we played this enough there's no way the killer's ever winning yeah I'm I'm glad that we've realized that solve has a very heavy-handed downside right because if you're wrong you lose yes so and the first light we played this like five times before had to play it more men I'm saying at least five times yeah we
played it at least five times and each time the cop one yeah but that was because in multiple cases both of us would solve and then be like no I'm not either of them and then we would keep going and that's obviously said you know right the killer to lose right so I think it's far more balanced than we thought it yes I will agree there I think I'm going to give it I think I'm gonna give it a seven as well for a light gateway ish game soon obviously I can't rate as some elite you know strategy game this is on par with slice misses siphon few them yeah just yep just write it right right here right up there blood rage yep right there no uh but for a quick the two-player game it gives you kind of a it's almost a filler as well yeah it's a nice buffer game yeah so I think don't play something heavy an extravagant yeah and then you play this for a little while keep your mind low reset and then you do another big session yep yep I think I think it does just quite well because I mean you're not gonna come in if you lose like not oh my god I wasn't I was getting mad towards into the arts arts to red streak of losing because I'm like this this is awful but so I'm kind of as 6.57 more higher maybe six nine eight but I definitely it could go up
depending on how well these other cases are like it basically if these are fire then that's that's awesome then you get four games bang for your buck but so that is our thoughts on know our autumn autumn or autumn on the noir let us know what you think of this game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you liked this video and click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button it's a little bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you