Skip to main content
Loading video...

Why I Chose to Back Agricola: Special Edition

Transcript 19:25

Hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor. My name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor. Today we are in the middle of the campaign for agrical special edition as published by Awaken Awakened Realms. So the first off the bat, you know, I I wanted to talk about and I'm not going to bury the lead. I am backing this project as well as many other people. But I did want to address why, especially in light of the low ratings that are here on the boardamegeeek page, and to talk about some of the comparisons to other big editions of Agricola that have recently been released, namely the Agricola 15 box.

So, let's break this down for with what we know so far. So, the Agricola special edition um has I mean here's the game found page, right? We know that this game is going to have a lot of components added to it. Namely, the all of the cards, uh new artwork, uh a new expansion, etc. So, let's let's break down some of these first, right? So, the irrigation expansion is going to be a brand new expansion that adds uh I guess the mechanism of irrigation. Uh we I guess that picture doesn't show it, but uh I have seen and hopefully as was mentioned before uh the expansion will be playable on board game arena to test out and if that does become a reality I will show that on the channel uh because I am very excited to see what that will look like. So, there are a couple of ways that you can support this uh um this new special edition. You can go for the uh basically the core or the basic edition or the special edition, right? The standard edition includes everything that you see here, including all the cards and the farmers of the

Moore expansion, which is pretty big, as well as the stretch goals in and the resources are going to be cardboard based, whereas the special edition has the game in uh or the resources rather in a more wooden format, the uh wooden edition here. So, the uh thing that I also appreciate from this uh this uh campaign is the fact that you can upgrade some of the parts to a more 3D miniature version. Uh this family farm pledge, this is the one that I did. uh being straightforward. I think it would be fun to have the family p pieces as well as the animals and fences be three-dimensional as they uh you know I I I think the the three-dimensional aspect is more representative there than it might be with the um resources. But uh I I think that is pretty cool. There is also a separate pledge here. Let's go to the add-ons just to see. Um, you can also get some of those resources in acrylics, uh, specifically the, uh, fields, the houses, uh, and the, uh, water that you would use for the irrigation expansion. You

also have some opportunities to add on some new things that were not previously known. For example, the game All Creatures Big and Small. This is the two-player version of Agricola that was released years after. And you can uh play this game, obtain this game as a special edition. I add it. Uh I'm not going to um I think this is really awesome though to have this. And do note that it is the big box edition. So all the expansions are going to be included in that which is awesome. You have playmats that you can add on sleeves for your cards, an art book. Uh these are the 3D resources for miniatures that you can add on as well. Uh looks like secret 3D minis expansion that Yeah, we'll see what that turns out to be.

the fifth and sixth player expansion as well. Uh for those who don't know, this expansion does include uh some cards as well for the fifth and sixth player. So if you are a completionist, then this technically would give you some additional cards that may there are probably not going to be a part of the base game and all of the base game expansions that are released for that. So, I did add this on uh as a completionist myself and so I'm excited to see that as well. Uh miniatures for those. And yeah, so when it comes to and let's take a look. So, this is the first comparison that I wanted to make to the Agricola 15.

So if we come over to let's see um the content here. Yeah. So yeah, once again all everything they get here going to the existing expansions, right? So, Farmers of the Moore, the only big box uh expansion for this game aside from the new irrigation one that includes all of these nice resources, new cards and everything as well. And then you've got all of the revised edition cards from the base Eik deck uh from a Gricola base game, the Eparius deck that was recently released. Uh, it's the um I believe a lot of these cards were based off of the gamers deck if if I'm not mistaken. However, um I mean you look at all of these older decks too, things that are more promotional in nature, a little bit more wacky, perhaps not as competitive. You do have other competitive decks, too, like the Gamers deck. Uh the I think the the French deck, the France deck was probably Yeah. It was one of those uh decks that were uh that was very balanced, right? Or competitive back in the day.

Zdeck. Yeah. So, and then all of the promotional cards as well. So, when we look over to a Gricola 15, here's the board game page and what lookout says specifically about what's in this box, right? So, you do get the event cards. You have approximately 900 cards which includes the um let's see the uh A and B deck I believe as well as some of the uh L cards as well. And that's it. So So this has room for the fifth and sixth player expansion as well as farmers of the Moore. However, oh and I think we or it might not be there. Oh yeah. So, the um it it has room for all of the revised edition content, but it does not have room or at least not explicit room for all of the cards previous to the revised edition that is being brought back with the uh the special edition. Right. So, I've heard mixed feelings as well about the inserts and the sorting trays for this big box. And so that those were the major hesitations that I had when this came out back a couple of years ago. Uh I was very interested in having uh a

solution or a storage solution for my favorite game of all time. However, I one had all of the decks that were provided in this, but two um you know it it did not have some of the cards. I wasn't even interested in all the older cards because I I didn't know how compatible they would be with the newest set, but I was missing a couple of the other decks that were released like the C and the and the D deck. And so this not being able to provide that for myself was a bit of a let down for me and it was for a lot of people who already had all the content anyway. And that's where we get to the special edition as well. So, not only I mean, yes, I will have technically have repeats of the revised edition expansion decks. However, everything here comes out with new artwork and that has been a big contention for this new edition and and why people are not rating this game as high. A lot of people are put off by the fact that there is AI art. Now, for me, uh I mean, it's I see the reasoning why um AI art would be detrimental to real artists who work on projects for board games and otherwise. And and that,

you know, if it if that's stealing work from from artists now, then that probably isn't good. Uh, however, in in this particular edition, I I don't think I mind it as much because there are over 1500, you know, 1,600 cards that are being reprinted for this special edition. And and so even if all of that was AI generated, I don't think I would personally mind because while I do have the revised edition cards myself, I wouldn't feel as bad having duplicates of these cards because they look different, right? And so, you know, take that for what it's worth. But I and I've seen a lot of comments saying that this special edition, you know, I mean, if you are competitive, for example, with this this uh this game, you're probably nowadays, especially if you play on board game arena, not going to be playing with any other decks other than these first sets, right? And the Eparius deck.

The rest of these are uh older and perhaps obsolete in the direction that a Gricola is being taken and that does matter to me because I I do want to approach a Gricola from a more uh competitive standpoint. However, I this is my favorite game and I think a lot of people who enjoy this game a lot feel the same way as well. And I did not have an opportunity to play this game until right before the pandemic hit, right before 2020. And so all of these decks were already out of print by the time I was made aware of what a Gricola is. And so for those of us who are being introduced or have recently only been playing a Gricola, especially with only, you know, having the uh revised edition be available for for us, I think this is an an excellent opportunity to at least have in our collections or have the opportunity to have these these cards in our collections uh for the first time in a long time Now, I, you know, if you did want to back this game for, you know, just the cards essentially, uh, and some of the decks that are, uh, older, I mean, it it's $80 euro or $80, uh, for for that and just

the cardboard um, components. You don't have to upgrade to a lot of these, but, you know, I I I did want to do that myself. I was, you know, just really excited to um uh have a really cool looking product uh myself. And this comes at a point of of time where, you know, I personally don't feel bad doing this as kind of a present to myself. But uh but you know I yeah I do see the the the point of view from those who may be put off by the art or just by the sheer amount of these cards. Some of them duplicated from what is already available.

Um I I I totally get it and you know it's it's not for everyone. Uh, but I even if you love this game, you know, it's it's probably a product that uh wouldn't be uh, you know, it doesn't look the kind of way that you would want to or it's something that you wouldn't be, you know, pulling off of your shelf anytime soon. And so I I I I guess I admit that I am looking at this from a collector's point of view, something that I, you know, want to have on my shelf and and want to play as well. I think I would pull this one out when I do have folks over. Um, and you know, I have other my revised and my original edition that, you know, the original edition of of Agricola was the first game that I first board game that I purchased from purchased from someone online uh like through Facebook, right? And so that it's it's what started it all and really got me started with the hobby and with this channel essentially and and for my love of of Rosenberg games. And so I think that is so so the the way that this looks doesn't put me off enough to uh hinder me from backing this. And the collective the collector portion of me as well is very interested in collecting all of these as well as a lot of these uh stretch goals, right?

And so we I don't know much about what these are, but these are like little packs of cards that maybe are like minors or occupations that are new and uh focused towards this uh um this release. And so, you know, the more cards the the better, right? Um, we do have the um the new expansion as well that is a part of this. I did some looking into like for example if the special edition and the irrigation expansion would be available as a retail product, right? And I don't get the sense that they would be if if I'm basing this off of like how they approached uh the Castles of Burgundy and Puerto Rico, which were the previous uh reimaginings of these games. And so I yeah, I don't know if this will be available or not. And so I I guess that's added pressure to support this campaign is to have uh the opportunity to play this new expansion. And but you know this this would be available on board game arena if that is uh a location that you would want to play this game anyway. Uh so it's more of a focus if you want to play this in person. And so, and then also

having the opportunity for new artwork and a a new version of All Creatures Big and Small is pretty awesome as well. So, um yeah, so I I think there are some pretty cool highlights in this campaign as well. And so I yeah, I'm I'm excited to see what this all looks like. And uh I'm I'm sticking with, you know, with what I backed and at the level that I backed it at. And hopefully everything, you know, fingers crossed, goes through well and uh and that we are able to get a product that that looks great. Um, I know not everyone's going to be happy, but um, I will be happy to hopefully at least have all of the the cards that have been released and just to have it in my collection, which I think is something that is important to me as a nod towards my favorite game of all time. So, uh, pricing wise as well, uh, just to compare, right, if you were just to back this once again at the, uh, the standard edition with just cardboard pieces, I think this is still cheaper than it would be to purchase a Grile of 15. Um, right now that's about 140 bucks. It's probably less if you're just buying the box, but if you're buying the content in the box, it's still like 140.

And so I I think I mean not including that and shipping costs, but that's pretty cheap if you are just going for this special edition and grabbing the stretch goals, which would include the new expansion as well as all of the decks um past made in this game. So, we'll see how big this box is and how the storage solution is handled, but I'm assuming that it's going to be all-incclusive and manageable if uh if track records hold true uh with how the uh other editions of games are packaged and prepared and stored. So super excited uh for for this and if I learn any more information and once again if I have the chance to play the new expansion and explain the mechanisms there before this campaign is done then I think that will be a great opportunity to look into that as well. But, uh, other than that, uh, I'll leave it at there. And, uh, let me know if you have good or bad thoughts about this special edition and what your plans are for backing it or not. Thank you for listening or watching this video. And uh hope you schedule an appointment with me real

Progress saved