Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Witching Hour Spoiler Free Review - What Happened To Her?

Transcript 17:25

Hey, I'm Alex from BoardGameCo, and today I'm going to be reviewing The Witching Hour from Post Curios. This is going to be a 99% spoiler-free review. I say 99% because I'll loosely be talking about the story and what's happening here, but for the most part, I will barely be showing you components. I will not be talking about the individual puzzles. I'll just be telling you about what this game is doing, my thoughts and feelings around it, how did it deliver as an experience? I'll be going into all of that. But, it's going to be 99% spoiler-free. Although, with that, I should note, this is All rules and components subject to change, and I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. With that said, The Witching Hour is the newest escape room in a box-style game from Post Curios. Post Curios is my absolute favorite company that makes escape-room-style games. I have played a lot from the Unlock to the Exit. Those are kind of the more more available genres. I've played a lot of others from a lot of companies. Post Curios continuously and consistently delivers the absolute best experiences in terms of the lore, the vibe, the components.

They're they're top-notch. But, I will tell you about The Witching Hour. I'll also tell you about some of my favorite ones and where this ranks within that because I always feel a little it's a little harder kind of trying to cover these things without being able to show you the individual puzzles, the elements, what stands out. So, it's more vibe. It's a vibe review. I'm talking about vibes. But, with that said, The Witching Hour tells you the story of, well, witches. You play as Theodora something. There's Lilly, there's Theodora, there's Clara, there's all these various characters. I remember half their names, not all of them. There's a whole family situation going on. But, it's The Witching Hour. It is the night before your 16th birthday, and you are going to start by Well, you're going to start by reading this. This kind of gives you like a one-pager of just how to experience the game. Then, you're going to have a little acrylic sheet overlay over here. You'll have your hint a little components. We'll talk more about these shortly. And then, you'll have a giant deck full of cards.

That's going to be this box, which is chock-full of hundreds of cards. I want to say there's like 300 cards, but honestly, what What mean to say is the numbers go up to 300, but they skip a lot. So, there might be like 180 cards. I don't know the number. Something like that. There's this random box of components over here that you all discover on your own. And then there's a whole lot of a marker for the acrylic overlays. And then a whole lot of envelopes you'll be opening. That's kind of what you got as far as components. What will you actually do when you start? Well, you're going to start by opening this deck over here and then reading the first few cards. You'll dive into it. You have the story. What is the story? Well, you are Theodora Rivers over here. That's the September 1999. Your name is Theodora Rivers and you are 15 years and 364 days. Or other words, it's your 16th birthday tomorrow. You can't wait. Children for your village always feel incredibly relieved when they turn 16 and know that they are safe from the maze forever. The maze is a local legend often whispered about fearfully in the school playground or threatened as punishment by angry parents. They'll be the next card and you'll be the next card and you'll be the next card and you'll go through it until you've read the first four cards at which point you have your first puzzle to go through. These first few few cards are going to be your first introductory puzzle. If you pause enough of those, you might be able to try to start solving things. Still no spoilers.

There's there's a thing to do. I'm not going to tell you more about it, but this is your very first puzzle. That's kind of the start of the experience. From there, you're going on an adventure. You're going on an adventure which is both going to be narrative as well as puzzles. You are Theodora Rivers. What is it? Theodora Rivers. Theodora Rivers. You are Theodora Rivers. There's a maze. Children go missing or at least children in the past have gone missing. Maybe you'll go missing. Maybe not. You'll have to start going through the story to figure it out. Along the way you'll uncover a lot of history. History about your family, your family tree, what happened to your grandparents, your aunts, your uncles, your cousins, who you are, what your relationship to everyone in the family is as you start to figure out what has happened in the past as well as what is happening in the present, who's the villains, what can you do to stop them, what what should you be scared of, what should you not be afraid of. There's a lot going on as you go through this from a lore perspective.

But then there's the mechanical aspect. This is a game full of puzzles. The game box says it takes roughly 6 hours. I didn't weigh up my time in it, but I'd say that sounds about right. If anything, I'd say I probably spent around 8 hours in The Witching Hour. Wait, I think the box says 6 hours. It's a one plus player game, 14 plus co-op, 6 plus hours. Again, I did not count up every hour, but if I had to guess, I think I spent around 8 hours in this, which might just mean that we got to puzzles slower than you otherwise can. There's a whole bunch of puzzles going on in this game. In fact, I can show you how many puzzles there are because of these hint things over here. These are great. These are kind of hints to help you out when you get stuck. Because in Post Curios, when I first started playing Post Curios games back in the day, if I recall correctly, their hints were mostly, if not exclusively, online. I think, I could be wrong. But in more recent puzzles, I've noticed they started doing more analog, which I personally prefer. I like this system overall as far as a good way to figure out what's going on. The way it works is you're going to have these hints. These going to have different codes. I guess this kind of tells you how many puzzles there are, so to speak, in the game. At least again, it's it's a loose feeling about how many how many they view. It looks like there's 18 1 2 3 4, five over here, but then they're double-sided as well with the other side over here. And the way it works is when you have a puzzle you're stuck on, this symbol will tell you, let's go ahead and start with the first one over here. This is the very first puzzle. And if you want, you can start to peek it out. I'm not going to go too far, but you kind of have the first line, and then you keep going through it. This is going to, as you pull this out more and more, it's going to slowly show you step by step how to get through the puzzle. The step-by-step part is important because if you are stuck in a puzzle, there's often a few reasons you could be stuck. Reason

number one is you have no clue what to do. If that's the case, these are very helpful for that. Reason number two is you do have a strong clue what to do, but you haven't really fully connected the dots, and these can help you do that small bit of connection. Or if nothing else, sometimes I use these purely to make sure I'm on the right track. I have a bunch of concepts that I'm working with. I'm pretty sure it's the right direction, but I could spend the next hour just trying to decode something, or it might be barking up the wrong tree entirely. Sometimes pulling one of these out and looking at the first few lines be like, "Yep, okay, cool. I am doing the right thing. Time to dive into it knowing with confidence that I'm not wasting my time on a wild goose chase." And I like these for that alone. The sequential steps of the puzzles being revealed as opposed to here's the answer, really guides you through them in a way that doesn't take away that that feeling of accomplishment you get.

Whether you're getting a hint to guide you on a starting path, whether you're getting confirmation you are on the right path, whether you're getting a connecting point between you figuring it out, it does not take away the full sense of accomplishment just because you looked at a puzzle hint. But, that's kind of the uh hint system over here. The puzzles. The puzzles, again, it's hard to talk with the individual puzzles too much in detail without getting into spoiler territory, which I'm going to avoid. Uh but, I will say that I kind of look at Post Curios almost as an ecosystem. There's a lot of Post Curios games out there and they deliver both in terms of their stories, as well as in terms of their components, as well as in terms of the puzzle complexity. And I'll kind of rank where The Witching Hour falls for me amongst their games in those areas. Let's start with the story. In terms of the story, I would say that The Witching Hour is possibly in my top three from a story for Post Curios games. My favorite to this day is almost certainly The Morrison Game Factory. I think that one I for whatever reason, I don't It's not the one I would have thought that I would most like as far as story goes, but I think I most like the story of The Morrison Game Factory. From there, their Malt series, Ministry of Lost Things. I haven't actually played the second one, but the first one I thought was a great story and it really really pulled me into it. And then I think The Witching Hour is probably three for me. Emerald Emerald Flame and Emerald Echoes. I I think Emerald Echoes did a better job with the story and Emerald Flame did a better job in other aspects of it as far as the puzzle and the complexity, but The Witching Hour I think is probably my third favorite in terms of the games I've played from Post Curios where the story is. They give you a good story overall. They give you the emotional heart tugs on your heartstrings as you

identify with the characters, as you learn more about her past, as you learn more about your family, as you involve and engage yourself with the happenings all around you, the twists and the turns of the who done it's, uh the way they navigate together, kind of giving you information, but also tying that into how that information is relevant to the puzzles you're solving. Overall, I think they did a very good job with the world building. Again, there's hundreds of cards over here. The vast majority of these cards are lore that also gives you an aspect that ties into it. Like, you can read whole sections of cards and they might be like one or two sentences that help solve the puzzle, that help nudge you in the right direction, but it's more about the world building than anything else. I think they did a great job with that overall, all the way down to the very end of it where there's again, there's unravelings, there's twists, there's turns, and then there's just the general general what happened along with the mystery of it all, and they did a great job with that. As far as components, components-wise, I think again, this is where I still have to trigger, I have to go through look through all their games a bit more. Uh Ministry of Lost Things, uh this one, The Witching Hour, they're all kind of in the same general sense. I think Emerald The Emerald Flame possibly to this day might be one of the best ones they've had as far as components go. Uh this one's pretty decent. I I I'd say that maybe it's a little bit more on the bare-bones side. I can't remember Emerald Echoes as much. I I'd have to really go through and think through it.

Like, they definitely have a range as far as their components. This one definitely leaned a lot more into cards over other things. And then there are a lot of these envelopes. And these envelopes are mostly going to have slightly nicer sheaths of paper. I don't think this knocked it out of the park as far as the deluxification of the components you get with a few notable exceptions. Uh there's definitely some nice pieces of this that will be nice keepsakes because when you're done with this, you don't have to destroy a single thing in this game. You could absolutely do it with no writing any components, no tearing, adjusting anything. You could simply and purely give this to the next person, assuming you choose not to write any components, which you absolutely can do so. I mean, you can write any components, too. Personally, I wouldn't recommend it. And when you're done with it, you can package it up, reset it, give it to the next person for them to explore and experience it.

Alternatively, there might be one or two nice components in there that I'd almost want to keep, but that would limit me from giving it to the next person. But honestly, some of the Without getting too much into it, there's a particular component that I almost would want there to be two of in this box. In fact, since I'm talking about this during the crowdfunding campaign, I think they should offer an ability to get another one cuz I think it'd be a nice keepsake to finish the game, enjoy it how that's meant to, and then still pass this on to the next person. And right now, I'd have to choose between those two things. So, I'd pass it on to the next person with a uh hey, I want it back when you're done so I could I guess give it to the next person and rinse and repeat and eventually choose for it to be done and have those components. So, there's there's that. But component-wise, it's mostly cards plus like glorified newspaper sheets of papers. It's basically, you know, an 8 by 11 kind of thing, but with like They're nice.

They're nice, don't get me wrong. This is better than you anything you're going to get from a Unlock or an Exit game, but it's definitely on the lower end as far as their component spectacularness goes. As far as the puzzles, one of the things that I've said in general about Post Curios is their puzzles tend to straddle line nearly perfectly where it is difficult enough that it feels satisfying when you solve it, but it's also not so difficult that you need to turn towards the clues. That's been my experience with most of the Post Curios games. With I think the main exceptions for me have been Emerald Echoes and The Witching Hour. Emerald Echoes and I I I always grant that with this part that it is tricky to get that balance perfectly right. If a puzzle is too easy, then someone Well, regardless regardless of what a puzzle is, there's going to be someone who finds it too easy. And regardless of how easy a puzzle is, there's going to be someone who finds it too hard. It is a delicate balance to get right. For me, their puzzles generally have been nearly exactly where my puzzle-solving ability has been. And I'd say as well, player count-wise, like most escape rooms, I think this plays escape rooms in a box games, I think this plays best at two, tolerable at three, and then my order in general for almost all escape room games is two, three, one, nothing else. I I I

once you go to four, with some exceptions, it is very rarely an ideal experience. Too many hands in the mix, too many people trying to puzzle over the same things, pass me that paper, or too little involvement in the story. I find they work best with two, where people can work on puzzles one at a time, uh you know, passing them back and forth when you're stuck in something, being able to communicate quickly and easily when you solve it, look what I did, and how this all comes together. Uh playing at one means you have the blinders of your own experience, and as soon as you get to three, I even three to be a step backwards as far as too many people trying to look at the same things at once, and four I generally just find intolerable for escape room games. So, I recommend this as a two-player experience ideally, three is tolerable, one's okay, four don't do it. Going back to the actual components aspect, the puzzle aspect, the difficulty, uh difficulty-wise, I think that generally Post Curios has nailed it for me. Emerald Echoes, I'd have to go rewatch my review. My recollection of Emerald Echoes is that that one I found myself leaning more into the hints than any other Post Curios game uh until then and since then. Uh this one I think was very close to great. Uh overall, uh again, from these 18 puzzles, I can try to think through this. There's 18 possible puzzle categories, uh therefore hints you can go down.

If I recall correctly, I'd have to look at each of these, but if I recall correctly, I was completely stuck on one thing, one thing I was completely stuck on, but I would say several of them, maybe three or four of these, I needed that hint aspect to be sure I was in the right direction, or where I kind of had the puzzles, but I need to connect the two, where I like I was like, "Okay, this goes with that, and that's clearly working like this, but I can't figure out how to get from point B to point D, and I need that help around C." And again, I have to look through each of these and kind of refresh myself, but I definitely had to pull these out a few times. So, and and and the tricky part is, when I pull out a hint, in any puzzle game, whether it's Unlock, an Exit, or one of these, something else, whenever I pull out that that hint aspect, and I'm trying to get a sense of things, there's usually one of two ways it goes. Way one is I look at it, and I'm like, "Oh, that's clever. Yeah, that's that's I should have I should have figured that out." And then way two is like, "Okay, like I I guess I get that that works. I I sure, but like I was never going to know that." And I'd say that for the most part, I guess for the most part it's probably too broad. When I think through the things I needed to help, the one that I was completely lost on, as soon as they they kind of gave me the hint guide in the puzzle, I definitely felt a okay, that was on me. I should have been able to connect the dots.

The ones where I needed hints were probably about 50/50. I'd say some of them were may have been like, "Okay, I should have been able to get that connection point." I mean, I got most of it, but I should have been able to figure out how it all tied together. And again, I can't really go into more detail without talking about the puzzles and the nature of them, but I'd say that there were at least two that I'm thinking of off hand, at least two, where after looking at it, I was like, "Yeah, I I get that you can get there, but in one case it was way too vague." In one case, I just think that the situational options for the puzzle felt too vague that I did figure it out. Like, I knew what to do, and then I went to kind of get the answer and I was like, "Okay, yeah, like, you know, I I guess that's the thing." I mean, I knew what they were going for, but I couldn't figure it out despite knowing what they were going for because of the vagueness of things. And another one was kind of like, "I just don't I don't see how any person would be able to connect two get from point A to point B." Again, I figured out the first section of the puzzle. I knew the last section of the puzzle, but there was an intermediary step where I didn't understand how to connect the two.

And with when I was given the answer, I was like, I I guess somebody probably figured that out. I just don't think that was This is I think that What bothers me about it I'm not getting too much into it. What bothers me about it, there was a specific line, there was a specific red herring that in order to connect points A to B, or whatever you want to call it, B to D, I was certain they were trying to point me towards a bunch of other things to make that connection point because they used some terminology that I was like, "Oh, it's about looking at this section of the puzzle." Uh but then at the end of it, um it wasn't about that section of the puzzle. So, I wasted a lot of time chasing after something else, and and they don't I don't see how somebody could have or would have figured it out otherwise. But I it was clever. I'll say that. It was definitely clever. I just don't think people would have gotten it. So, overall, as far as puzzle ranking goes, um it's pretty good. It's pretty satisfying. Not as good as their best, uh but certainly not the worst one I've played from them, either. That's kind of as much as I can give you about this without really diving into the story and the actual puzzles, which I'm not going to do. What I will say is, final thoughts-wise, uh The Wishing Hour was great. I had a lot of fun with The Wishing Hour. It is not my favorite Post Curios puzzle I've played to date. I think that still goes overall to um the the um uh the Morrison Game Factory. Uh from there, it is a little harder to figure out exactly what I like most. Ministry of Lost Things, like I said already, definitely had one of the better stories. The Emerald uh Flame is definitely one of my first experiences, and still to this day one of the ones I most, you know, have the most fondness for, as my first uh game from them. But I think The Wishing Hour is almost certainly in my top five. If I have to guess, it's probably coming in at number

four as far as my uh rankings for them. I think it would be Morrison Game Factory, either Emerald Flame or Mult, and then uh The Wishing Hour would probably come after that. So, that's both Oh, rating-wise, rating-wise, I'm going to give it a four out of five. A very solid experience. Uh definitely bang for your buck as far as the the the length of the experience. Like I said already, this is an 8-hour experience for me overall, broken up primarily into two chunks. I think the rule book said it's like broken up into three chunks, I think. But it kind of primarily felt like a two-chunk experience. Like I just left it set up. After the first chunk, I kind of left the set up for the second chunk, and then just kind of came back to it over two or three sessions. Anyways, a four out of five, very solid game, game from the from Post Curios. A great theme, decent enough components. I mean, top-notch components compared to, uh you know, more mass-market stuff. Compared to their own standard, pretty decent enough. And then the puzzles were very solid overall, with a few small hiccups along the way.

Overall, that's basically it. The Wishing Hour, check out the campaign down below. Until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hope you enjoyed this video and as always, I hope you have a good one.

Progress saved