Dusting the Cardboard - The Case for Lords of Waterdeep (Mini Review)
Transcript
classic what a strange word to describe something from the 2010s but here we are reviewing 2012 Lords of Waterdeep so what makes Lords of Waterdeep a classic it's not the first worker placement it wasn't the seat here D&D artwork and it wasn't the barely indistinguishable hidden roles to me it's that Waterdeep was among the earliest games that married traditional euro style gameplay with a distinctly non-traditional theme and while at the time many of Mero thrash gamers going in accused Waterdeep as having a paper-thin theme the game does a remarkably solid job of portraying thematic concepts in the mechanics or as I've said on this channel about a thousand times how's the mattock resonance check it out players are rival business owners vying for the most influence over the fantasy metropolis of Waterdeep each round you send your agents to vacant locations throughout the city obtaining contracts and hiring adventures who you will send to fulfill those contracts reaping rewards in the form of influencer treasure and even additional recruits or persistent privileges on top of this players can purchase at businesses that agents can visit though the owner gets bonuses if a rival agent takes a spot I just described the game in almost entirely thematic terms and yeah it's also a damn good summary of the mechanics of the game sure this could be a modern conflict in a war-torn nation replacing warriors rogues clerics and wizards with gun dude and other gun dude gun lady and nerd but that's not the point almost always you're given just a little
thematic nudge to imagine why this array of adventures are needed for this quest what benefits you're gaining out of it and how this would help you firm up your hold over water thee but all this would be meaningless if it weren't also a really solid game sure by modern standards water deep is a bit dry you get your quests get your peeps spend your peeps get your stuff collective workers at the end of the round an or a Pete but it's fair and built like a brick a perfect introduction to resource management and worker placement concepts largely absent two games about kronum answers and owl bears and yet isn't without its flaws the influence cards while largely brilliant have a subset called mandatory quest which are played on the other players forcing them to fulfill that lows Qwest before all else which if time to write can throw a real wrench in your game it also doesn't have a lot of options and how you interact with the game giving it a real narrow feel after a few plays also its components and insert while luxurious at the time are super dated by modern standards that's why dedicated fans or deepers as we call ourselves have a whole host of third-party upgrades that are widely available so know that buying the base game your units are going to be little cubes speaking of add-ons though Waterdeep is one of those games that are good but made great through an expansion scoundrels of skull port well it doesn't get rid of the mandatory quests it does add just enough extra systems that the narrowness of the game is a blown away and combined it stands as a respectable choice even among modern offerings the
true secret to Lords of Waterdeep is that it is accessible with its a light D&D theming a simple rule set and well integrated thematic resonance it exposed so many people to the world of abstract strategy gaming while showing how tight thoughtful mechanisms could be used to portray rich themes though not as exotic complex or flashy as many games that have come out since it remains one of the most solid and approachable worker placement games to date oh and I know I made fun of the artwork earlier but this has the best city map on any board game out there come at me if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard Harold calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Harold