Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 143: Hermann Luttmann on Designing Across Genres

Transcript 1:08:12

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to some amazing things their next game hydrologic cycle is scheduled to come to Kickstarter on March 26th clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con the next course classroom game design yes we can will be taught by one of my absolute favorite teacher Gamers Dr Christian hints it begins on March 4th and you should definitely sign up for it I'll also include a final plug for myself if you like the show and want to support it you can do so by going to patreon.com onol thanks to listeners like you I've been able to keep upgrading my equipment subscribing to stream streamyard and more but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond soliter and I am on the Pod this week with a very special guest this is Herman lutman a very famous game designer especially if you're in the solo gaming space so how you doing today Herman all right Liz thank you for having me on I really appreciate it yeah it's GNA be awesome so for people who don't know who you are um I'm not sure how that happens if you're listening to this podcast but it could uh what are some of the games that you have designed that you'd like to just highlight so if people want to match a game with a face it could be you oh boy well I'm probably for General Gamers I'm probably most well known for dawn of the Zeds that that started bo boy 2012 I think right about 12 10 12 years and that's been through three editions now so that's been around for a long time and that's

most of the most of the references I get are are associated with Dawn of the Zeds recently it's obviously the Plum Island hor which is is Don of the Zed's adjacent I guess it's uh it's funny I I I heard uh artwolf the other day and and Dan talking about it and they said well if they're talking about experts in certain fields of you know periods of warfare and they said well we can agree that Herman's the zombie expert of our group so I guess that's what I'm well known for is being the zombie expert um War Gamers will probably know me for the blind sword system I think primarily um so yeah most mostly that um there's others and yeah you have you had a very prolific design career so for those of you who are curious just a BGG lookup you will see many games to sample uh from Herman but I actually brought you on today because I thought it'd be kind of fun I feel like you and I share something which is that we both enjoy like a broad range of solo games so we're generalists and were historical War Gamers um so is that something that was always the case for you like did you kind of start in one end and then move to the other you know where did your gaming hobby start and how has it kind of spread I've always been interested in military history I was reading military history books when I was 13 or something like that um so that's always been in my DNA uh it's it's been there forever uh

oddly enough my first real war game experience as a routine warri was actually miniature ship alnavco 11200 scale ships and I had I mean I I used to bust tables in my father's restaurant and and all my money went towards ordering the next Destroyer or whatever and so it started there then I gradually found a group and got into board gaming Then I then in the 90s I diverted back to Miniatures again I started painting up actually have some of them left over there there a few that I have left over and spared um I painted Napoleonic 6 millim 7 years war some Warhammer 40K epic scale Warhammer 40K that's the only way to go with Warhammer 40K and uh so I did that for a while and then I gradually went back into board games again it's you know a lot of it's like who who's who's what's what are people playing around you at the time right so we'd go to this one store called waterl and there was a Miniatures club and there's a board game club and you know you just you just go with what the crowd's doing and you adapt to it you know and and and that's uh so I ended up mostly in war game I I can't see to paint and I don't have time to paint anymore so I've kind of given up in the Miniatures though I'm hoping that epic scale comes back one day and I can deploy my Orcs again um yeah so I mean it's it's now oddly enough just to give you a little transition my first game design with with Victory point games was called Gettysburg the

Wheatfield that was actually based on a set of Miniatures rules I designed called tattered flags and Alan Emer and I talked about System 7 napoleonics I don't know if you remember what what those were those were actually cardboard counters that were used as Miniatures so we we were talking about well how can we convert that into a board game and that's how my whole design career started actually with a miniature set of rules that was converted so basically your design career started when you fused two different sides of the hobby that were of interest to I guess yeah I guess you could say that sure I feel like that's really appropriate given that I would say that dawn of the Zeds is probably I would say it's probably the best St of Siege game uh thank you um Aaron levelof deserves a lot of credit for creating that that cool little system right as simple as it is it's still ingenious some of the most ingenious ideas are simple ideas right and I mean that thing's uh what is it there like 20 30 games now using that system and thank you for saying that some other people have said that too it did take that whole model and just kind of messed with it I guess you could say um but thank you very much I appreciate it yeah but it's fun to see like a fusion of you know I don't know what to call zombies they're I mean we talk about sci-fi fantasy I don't know where zombies fit I guess fantas horror I guess horror but you're right horror could be sci-fi horror could be

fantasy it's it's hard to say I guess it's its own little niche genre I suppose um the stoppable evil enemy that doesn't have any logic or Soul coming at you which by the way makes it nice and it makes it nice and easy to to develop an AI for it so this also makes me wonder so you talk about playing what the people around you are playing if that is true how did you end up being such a prolific solo gamer and designer that again is vpg's fault because they're they're they their shtick was develop was designing solo games that was their kind of little part of the market you know and and uh I mean obviously they did others too but they they seem to have this this gear where they were they were putting out solo games I find it and when I started designing I found it a particular interesting challenge to do as solo game they're not they're not easy to design good ones are not easy to design and I promised myself when I got into the designing thing that a I would not just pump out the same stuff constantly and and uh B I would challenge myself so I try to I do try to think outside the box because one of the ideas of Designing is that you want to challenge yourself right you want to be creative and I try to push that all the time so even with blind swords you know people ask me how come you only did three blind swords Civil War games and I

said because I was kind of I just didn't want to churn them out right right and I've taken the blind sword system and done other things with it i' I've you know Twisted it and tweaked it so that it would be for a most fearful sacrifice it was on a larger scale uh for shattered Union series it was smaller more obscure battles and simpler to play so I you know I tried to change it up a little bit and not just keep repeating the same thing nice so I'm gonna I'll turn this around to the History part later but for now the other thing I kind of wanted to ask is you you you made some really good comments in our sort of pre-at um where you're talking about playing everything and kind of managing to get it into your designs um especially in a world where we like to fight about what a war game is um please don't make me do that no no no no I but I want to like how do you I want you to talk about your approach because I think it's interesting um you know what kinds of things can go into war games without compromising what you see as their essential right so War you know again without getting into what is a war game but let's say it's a simulation of a historical battle let's say or campaign um the mechanics that have been used to simulate that since the 70s or even 60s kind of were like you know hex encounter Zona control odds based CRT variations of that lots of modifiers two hours per turn you know

that kind of thing and um I was I was one of those guys too I played all those games right but as we get as we get now a little bit more competitive in the market in the gaming Market you can see that you know there are games out there that are using all sorts of different mechanisms and and styles and and approaches I have them all lined up there back there you know those are none of those are a war game Defenders of the realm and Street Masters and all sorts of stuff like that um so a I like playing those games I'm I'm a gamer I'm not necessarily just a war gamer I am a gamer there are some games I won't play not because you know I think they're bad games it just might not be themes I'm particularly interested in right I don't like playing games about growing flowers or or farming you know and things like that fine look Herman anything can be a war game if you try hard I'm jok it's true that's true you could yes you could have plants fighting other plants you're right and I think somebody's probably done that already there's Plants versus Zombies actually if you're in ex that's right there's aliens or Plants versus Zombies yes um so a I like to I enjoy playing those other games and B I look for mechanical cues right so if I'm playing for example I'll just give you one example real quick so I had a game I just had a game come out called by Iron and blood which is about the Battle of kig GRS and I'm like okay well how am I going to do something different with this rather than the normal thing and I played a

game called Conan which had this river system of activation which I found fascinating and I adapted it to be used as the command system for by Iron and blood and it's very simply this this track and you have expenses to activate things and when you activate something it comes off the track goes to the end everything shovels down and now that becomes you know the the stuff you didn't activate is cheaper the thing you just activated is super expensive to activate again that simple mechanism actually kind of mimics command command and control to a certain degree and then I added a little twist in there where you can put a headquarters chit in there and wherever you put the headquarters chit it could activate the unit under it or next to it so it has its own little you know kind of range of command ability that worked out great and that came from a Conan game well also Batman Gotham City I think uses that system and uh I Tred that with all sorts of game Plum Island horror though not a war game but still you know a recent design is just chalk full of stuff from oh boy eldrich horrror and Clank and Defenders of the realm and I mean there Aon end there just but they all they all work they can be adapted to mimic in the case of a war game command and control quite easily and even combat you know you could fuss around with using custom Dice and things like you don't have to use a D6 on a CRT

in in a most fearful sacrifice I use column shifts because I don't like tracking long list of modifiers you know plus three to my die minus two to my die plus two on Wednesdays you know minus three on Thursdays you know that kind of thing I have people move the column around and then you roll the dice and whatever the dice are that's what that's what you're going to get and that works just fine and it's a lot easier to use so it's just little things like that that I try to make war games a little more accessible maybe a little bit more fun to play maybe a little more entertaining so that we get more people involved in the yeah I think we definitely share that goal so just out of curiosity I'm just G to ask is Dawn of the Zeds a war game um I would say dawn of the Zeds is because it was that was when I designed that I was still in a wargaming space in my head so I that was very War gamey at the beginning as a matter of fact the one thing I would change if I could redesign the game today is I would change the combat table and I and I knew it was too War gy because if you look at if you look at the CR if you look at that combat table it doesn't say two to one odds or three to one odds it says double and triple so I even try to get away from the odds ratio thing and just say hey is it larger then is it double is it triple um but that yeah I I would say Zed's is I would say Plum Island hor is not

oh that's interesting so for you it's kind of a mechanism based thing almost as opposed to theme based yes because there is still combat in Plum Island horror but there just so many other things going on uh to win that game that combat is not the central thing oh that's interesting yeah I have a I have a notably broader definition of wargaming but I mean I think that's okay I mean we're talking about a broadening hobby right with more people coming in um I think that really it only becomes a big deal when it comes to like award season I said I think we only really care about it when it's award season like how you define it but I've always wondered because you know um one thing I did want to ask is so for me because I come at things from such a historical perspective um I uh for me like historical and War Games have a lot of bleed um you know I'd say there something like endurance from Holland Spiel is not a war game because it's not really about a conflict it's just truly a historical game whereas you know once you moves towards like a more conflict thing maybe like I have a broader set of definitions but for me I've always wondered like when you have a Sci-Fi game What's the difference between a Sci-Fi war game and just a Sci-Fi game because to me it's never made a big difference yeah so just SciFi game would probably primarily deal with launching your Rockets getting your Rockets into orbit landing on a planet what do you find scientifically blah blah blah you know building Dome cities things like that so I mean I guess now if you have alien if you have

martians show up and start attacking you then I guess it becomes a war game doesn't it so for example um a g now just to prove your point a game like Australia by Martin Wallace I don't know if you've played that one it's Au Z TR great game but the first half of that game is all laying down tracks and farming and can making connections and then the second half of the game just becomes this sci-fi war game against cthulu it's it's a it's a fascinating design but I guess you know people don't refer to it as a war game I've never heard people refer to it as a war game it's just one of those Oddball things but I guarantee you people are gonna say that Plum Island horror is a war game because it came out from GMT oh I've already had that happen as a matter the fact it was Michael Kelly from onetop Co-op shop and he said somebody else got it and they don't normally play war games from GMT and I wrote him I go Mike this is not a war game all right this is this is a horror Survival game although I mean even Avalon Hill and its like original Incarnation publish a lot of different kinds of stuff I mean like baseball and you know sports games outdoor survival um yeah yeah there's a whole bunch of stuff and and that go you know that proves the point right I mean you know you and GMT is now I mean a lot of countries have done it but GMT particularly is obviously has it's not just with pal Island horror they've had they've got the what is it the space Corp and um Chad Jensen's games

right dominant species and all that so they've been doing it for a while yeah um I mean like for example Mr President right I mean I know that you know I've even talked to Ryan about this well Mr President what I mean is that gonna be classified as a war game I mean I haven't decided what that is yet that game is like I'm sure Jean appreciate no no I don't mean it's a brilliant like Des I know it's how do you C like there's nothing like it there's truly no game in existence that is like Mr President it's like completely outside of like what genre is that I don't think it's right you know what I mean it's um and you know yeah I mean the genre really is unimportant except if you're talking about lists yeah right best of lists and awards and things like that then then genre and categories become important but for us I don't really care what you categorize a game right I mean it's if it's fun to play I'll play it you know it's a whatever whatever category it's in so kind of speaking of that then so you got kind of a split design catalog between things that are like sci-fi fantasy horror romps and historical games do you see those design processes as fundamentally different and do you approach them differently even though you're bringing mechanisms across borders uh yes and thank you for pointing that out because that's for me personally one of the proudest things I've done is try to not be pigeon Hol into a certain type so I can do a game

like most fearful sacrifice which is a gigantic heavy Gettysburg game and I can do Invaders from Dimension X which is a small sci-fi silly folio game right um I I like that diversity of of doing different types of games like that for me as a designer I'm not saying that's for everybody I'm just saying for me personally that and it is as you probably you know as you know doing historical War Games is a lot of work even small historical war games are a lot of work the KX GRS game is a relatively small game compared to you know let's say an average GMT game that took me tons of research I mean you know you're reading multiple books even buying other games about the same battle to see if you can GA gather any angles and all that kind of thing it's just work and work and work it's research research research make sure you are presenting the history as accurately as you can I'm not saying it's always accurate you know and and you try your best right I mean I can tell you from personal experience and I did the most fearful sacrifice I got books all over here on Gettysburg and I got three different pieces of information about when a unit showed up let's say so you have to sit there and weigh all that and then don't make the wrong decision cuz somebody's going to write you online and say no no no no this battery showed up at 10: a.m. not at 9:30 you know that kind of thing

there's a lot of you know there's a lot of pressure especially for a famous battle like eddyburg coning gr's not so famous you might be able to fudge a little bit if you if you have to but um so the amount of the amount of research work that goes into a game like that and to recreate that period so the other challenge for a war game is you want to make sure that you're not just regurgitating Your World War II Mechanics for a civil war game or a napole game when somebody plays a napole game they want it to feel Napoleonic and they it has to have x y and z in it to be a napoleanic game you got to know the period and and do your best to replicate the fighting style the uniforms whatever the look of that period when I'm do doing well you want to take the extreme if if I did when I did Invaders from Dimension X that was literally a challenge by um Jeff melier of the gaming gang we were sitting around at a consum uh consum World Expo years and years ago and he just said to me you like chaos why don't you design a game that's totally chaos I said I accept that challenge and that's what the chaos do it's just totally random they just do stuff and you have to deal with it that's one extreme um you know games like Plum Island horror are you know fictional though we did a lot of research and

interviews get that game as accurate as possible um and then your your main concentration is to design the most entertaining product you can right come up with the best mechanics to let people have a great time and to challenge them game-wise and you justify everything later on right especially for a Sci-Fi game right where you're just now it still has to be internally logical right so if you're doing a Sci-Fi World well I'll take I'll tell you what I'll tell do a fantasy world we just um with Ryan Hilman and Fred Manzo we just designed struggle for Zorn the red blight for plue Panther games it's a big Fantasy war game it is a Fantasy war game but that world that we created though it's not as deep as you know if you're going to read a novel we created a world that is internally logical and appears in the game right so units act like you would think they would act in that fantasy world so there is still an internal logic but you could you still have a lot more freedom like if you decide that the bad guy Champion should do this because it's a really cool mechanic in the game and boy that'll be a lot of fun then you come up with a reason why he can do it later on right so designing non-historical games it's it's basically entertainment first build World later come up with cool stuff that people will laugh at or have fun with historical

gaming it's kind of the opposite it's like get get all your you know your ducks in a row get everything accurate make sure you're telling the proper story and an accurate story um they're both a lot of work u in different ways but rewarding nonetheless in in both cases so one thing I think is really fun when you're talking about history is that I mean for me I you know I say this often um when you're doing history you're telling what you think happened but then you're also by choosing the things that you prioritize and the things that you show interest in and the perspectives you pick you're also telling a bit of a story about yourself and so how do you I mean what kind of responsibility do you feel to represents more historically than just the time the uniform the flag uh are you also trying to sort of capture the essence of the period or on the specifics of combat as opposed to like sort of like a larger situation that the combats happening in I personally just concentrate on the on that battle or on that campaign that I'm doing right it's not you know A Treatise on on the politics of Napoleon III or whatever um I I worry about telling the story of that battle and the ingredients that went into making that battle what it is is is my first priority I do like presenting wh ifs so I do like doing that all right so if I'm

giving you the Battle of Gettysburg or kig grats or whatever what else could have happened what could have changed the tide of the battle one way or another and I give those as options and they're reasonable options they're not stupid options they're not like you know aliens land or anything like that so that I feel is is is a bit of a responsibility is maybe maybe go out outside the battle a little bit and say well what happens if this hadn't happened what if second Army doesn't show up for the prussians and can the austrians then win at the at the Battle of con garage so I don't go you know and in a game like for example if it's an obscure period or obscure to Americans let's say um at any cost was about the campaign around Mets in 1870 during Franco Prussian war and a game had never been designed on the whole campaign around that City even though there were two humongous battles fought there and I just took it upon myself and said well I'm learning about this period I'm going to do a whole Playbook with a whole historical detailed thing on this is what this period represents just in in that sense it was to teach people look this is this is a something that you probably don't play a lot of games about and this is what they looked like and the the uniforms they wore these are the tactics they used these are the commanders and their personalities and this this is how it win and this is why it's important uh you know arguments are made you know that World War I doesn't happen without the franor Prussian War and World War II doesn't happen without

World War I so you can you you can trace this all back so that kind of leads me to ask then so um you know you're very focused on battles and on interesting battles then why do you choose the specific historical periods that you do like how you I feel like you've got kind of a few threads uh I associate your work with a lot of Civil War gaming you've done some napoleonics I know you've got a Franco Prussian war game out what draws you to the periods that you choose to represent and like what is what causes you to decide this is gonna be a game I want to make a game about this that's a good question I I honestly don't know it's like I don't do a lot of World War II games I've done two I think Miracle at Dunkirk and crowbar I don't think I've done any others and it's I just don't find World War II on a strategic level that interesting right and it's been game to death I guess maybe now you could say Gettysburg's been game to death too and I have to agree with you on that um I don't know I guess it's just it's something it's I can't explain it's just something you're drawn to interest like I like I'm very interested in World War I and I've done number of games on world one and I'm got other games on world one planned and I find strategically that whole situation of World War One to be far more interesting than World War II more fronts more AR you know more

countries involved um the whole beginning of the war is just bizarre you know how this whole thing even got rolling um the franor Prussian War I kind of stumbled into because I played a game called blood and Iron by Rob Markham a 3w game back in the day just on a fluke and I said wow this is really interesting I didn't know anything about this look at these guys they're dressed up like Napoleonic guys but they're using machine guns and and modern you know some somewhat modern Weaponry I thought that was fascinating so the Civil War connection that's just that so that comes goes back to my Miniatures days that's what we were playing in Miniatures so I got very involved when you're doing Miniatures you get down to what color cuffs people are wearing because you have to paint them that way so you're doing a lot of research into the generals and the and the the tactics and all that and it probably stemm from that plus let's be honest silver war game cwell you know you know you don't want to produce games that nobody's gonna buy um especially when you start off um napoleonics is obviously very popular too and I plan to do a blind swords napoleonics this year hopefully it's been on the drawing board for I don't know how long I have to get to it um so why you know in ancients I don't find that interesting I can't tell you why canel canel I don't know maybe it's because because when I used to play the games they all look the same they were on a big open plane with two guys two lines

of troops facing each other I don't so much better than that but guess I know I know it is I know I'm coming I'm coming around I play some of the uh the PC games and the Ancients PC games in air fun um so I you know I don't know I don't think there's any any one particular particular thing I mean like we talked before I'm first generation German American I don't automatically tend to you know like we Wars that the Germans are in or anything like that or the Americans it's just uh it's just I guess it's unexplained it's something in your you know well I mean you mentioned that you reading history books at 13 like what were the first things that you were reading at that age well specific books I was read stuff were you reading about like I remember I saw a book about the pyramids as a kid and I was like enthralled it's not like you know my favorite childhood book was from the mixed up files of Mrs basley frankweiler it is zero surprise is about can't you run away and live in the Metropolitan Museum of Art like so this is so weird that you as I haven't thought about this book until you just asked me this question so was a book called foxes in the desert by Paul Carol I believe and it was about rumel and the North African campaign and I must have read that book three times I don't know why there was just something enthralling about it I I can't explain it and then he did a book called Hitler moves East I think which was about the Russian campaign so it was it was paperback book I guess it was compact you know it wasn't hard reading

it wasn't really long so it kind of Drew me in and then then it just went you know I I grabbed anything I could I did a lot of reading when I was a kid I thankfully my mother encouraged me to read a lot and I did I read Lord of the Rings one one summer when I when I was 15 I think you know it it just something I like to do yeah I'm always curious I I always wonder like how formative these things are because it sounds like you did a lot of World War II reading but then you didn't grow up and design a lot of World War II yeah well I mean my first my first war game ever was staling gr I remember pick I remember the day I picked it up and it just looked cool you know uh I you know and I don't think I just don't think I can contribute anything to World War II gaming I mean other than like I said you know I did the dunker game well I did two I did a spoiled Victory and then I upgraded it and I'm doing miracle at Dunkirk which will come out this year for by Legion war games that one was actually a suggestion by a friend of mine Paul Fish who said hey that would make kind of a cool solo game and I go yeah you know what that would make a cool solo game and and honestly that's not I don't I know it's a war game but I actually call it an evacuation game it's not so much a war game as it is an evacuation because your job is to evacuate the British expeditionary force from the beaches your job is not to beat the Germans you're not going to beat the Germans it's handling the perimeter long enough and efficiently moving the ships around to pick the guys up off the beaches and bring them back to England that's the game right there so that that that's

interesting crowbar was uh that was a suggestion from a long time ago uh after in magnificent style was to do that for the Rangers that point to hot because you need you need a very specific situation to use that pushy luck um wall of combat type of game uh and you know point to Hawk was definitely that but I mean those were the those were the two World War one two ones that I just attracted me because they were so unusual I guess that's really interesting so speaking of Civil War so you said you think you got into it through Miniatures interesting I so I've never really done any miniature stuff so I'm always was curious my grandfather has a lot of painted Miniatures though so like I can see it happening but I guess I wanted to ask so you do a lot of Civil War games and I think that probably over the course of your lifetime and really over the course of mine like a lot of attitudes about the Civil War have changed so I I mean you're a New Yorker who moved from Germany and now you live in in Tennessee so like I feel like you've adopted I was born in I was born in New York my parents came over from Germany got you so like you have adopted the South I guess as your home um but um okay yeah I mean I you know Knoxville you said you never you're happy to never go back I am am uh you know I'm born in Texas but I have a lot of family from the Carolinas my grandfather did a big genealogy project and like discovered a bunch of Confederate soldiers in our family and I feel like I have a much more fraught relationship with the Civil War like because of that if that makes sense um

as a designer do you feel like that's something that you need to take into consideration and do you think that's something that has to change more with time like whereas attitudes uh were different earlier in your career well I mean I don't think you can exclude gaming the Civil War no certainly now more like a how do you treat it like I think that um you know we're kind of in the midst of a lot of culture well that's goes back to what you said before I don't talk about the greater the greater scope I'm I'm concentrating on this one engagement uh like I said you know in magnificent style was about picket charge and you take the role of the Confederates attacking because for very simple gaming reasons you don't want to play the union because it's boring as hell and you know that that or any any of the Civil War Games you know it's it's it's hard to say to make a judgment on anybody that well you can't play the Confederates and you can't win as the Confederates because now we have a different look at that war now um I it is what it is and you know for me personally you know if if it's uncomfortable for somebody to play a civil then don't play a civil war game I don't I don't you know I I don't take a position on you know who should win or lose about if it's it's a historical battle whoever won or lost um Confederates lost Gettysburg I've I've done that game you know I've done I've done plenty of games where either side is one or you know yeah it's just sort of interesting in magnificent style in particular like you know I've reviewed it and so I mean I'm not gonna I won't shy away I thought it was a really really good game um I

felt uncomfortable with like come on boys Rebel Yale just because that kind of like had Echoes of my own childhood of things like I didn't totally feel comfortable with about the culture that I was in do you think that it's possible to make a game about something like pickets charge and not kind of bring in those narratives are they necessary like do you have to embody that role that hard to make you through that game you know what I mean like I I always wonder about these things from your perspective from my perspective I'm designing a game about picket charge I'm making not I'm not making a moral judgment about picket Tru and honestly if that makes you feel uncomfortable to play the confed says on the box you're going to play as the Confederates and pick a stars then just don't play it um I'm not sitting there telling everybody wow this is really great if you win you are role playing them yes I you know obviously you are but you're role playing any Civil War game you play as the Confederates you're role playing the Confederates you're trying to win as the Confederates and I find it interesting so I know that you you're coming from that angle because you have a history and I understand that by the same token I'm I'm fascinated by the fact that people can play Soviet Communists without a problem they can play VI Vikings are played by every gaming group every level of gaming mainstream gaming Euro gaming War gaming the Vikings raped pillage and enslave people that was their shtick and nobody has trouble

playing the Vikings so I don't know actually you know I I I come from a position so do you think that there's anything any game thing that should be off limits that's actually I would like to start there yeah I think genocide yeah you know I things like that yes I I will say there are topics that I wouldn't touch yeah yeah so I think that you know the other thing that's kind of mening right is it I mean I actually like to play things that make me uncomfortable I think it's important intellectually engage like for me it's part of the process but for me it's not so much that I think that any specific theme is forbidden I'm always just really interested in the persp perspectives that people choose to take and like the way they choose to construct that theme if that makes sense um it makes sense I and I and I I totally understand where you're coming from and that's that's fine for me games are games and and I know that I'm not supposed to say that but games are games and I I don't really want to make them much more than an entertainment method of entertaining one another or in some cases yes educating one another about a particular historical period but I I I personally don't design games to send messages or anything like that my main goal is to be for people have fun with it even even my historical games you're supposed to have fun with them and that's that's my goal other people can design games for other goals it's fine yeah so when you uh so

you talk about historical like need to be on theme uh do you ever find that that conflicts with your desire for a game to be entertaining well yes I primarily I want them to be fun I want them to be entertaining or interesting at least okay so for me to do a game like crowbar in magnificent style the only way you could make that interesting as a game is to create a system you know a solo system that challenges you in this case I picked push your luck you know against a basically a a wall of fire and that's what it is so I I only did I did so in magnificent style was originally going to be a trench game trench warfare game but for marketing purposes and all we decided to pick something that would sell right I mean you know a lot of people don't want it your first game to be about uh or the third game about you know trench warfare and for me that was a particular challenge the reason I designed that system was like well how do I make trench warfare entertaining I could make a very boring game about trench warfare and nobody would buy it right so my goal as a designer was well how do I make this interesting as a game and that's the system I came up with and I you know people seem to like it um and there'll be more coming with with that with those mechanics do you um what are some of the biggest like changes to history that you feel you've had to make to sacrifice as it were uh a most fearful sacrifice uh

on the altar of entertainment I don't think I had to do that um you know there's ways to create mechanics that are fun and still you know preserve the the simulation um I mean in the sense of in magnificent style let's say the fact that the the union doesn't is not an operating side right the units don't each individually fire like you would have in a normal war game the their effect is built into your dir rolles As you move forward so you don't have to resolve all that um but I don't know that that that's I mean that's a that's a sacrifice in in in terms of mechanics you uh I mean I don't recall offhand anything I had to cut from a game to accommodate the mechanics I mean maybe somebody could suggest something that I did that with but I can't think of anything off the top of my head um oh that's interesting I asked because so you know for night wiches DAV and I David Thompson I are doing a game like um you know the fact is that flying endless harassment missions and not having super powerful bombs leads to a fairly boring if also extremely dangerous in Adrenaline field Knight so to make Knight which is a more enjoyable game we didn't necessarily want to send players out for eight sorties that were super repetitive over the course of mission so we had to like choose maybe slightly more powerful targeting options like you

know they're maybe they're a little more powerful than they really were in real life uh in terms of their bombing or you know we made the nights we limited the time that players were like running sorties against some of our missions specifically because if you don't and you just let people go all night it reduces the tension of the game and makes it more repetitive and I think less interesting and so you know we're gonna have a historical consultant like write an essay about what's real and what's not in our game but we had to make some choices in order to bring the excitement out of a theme that is exciting because of the coolness of what the women did but maybe wouldn't be the best game okay that's interesting um maybe in that sense for example if you're talking about crowbar and you're talking about the preliminary bombardment by the Air Force and the Navy instead of having you sit there and like what you're saying you kind of abstract it right to make it more entertaining so what I do is instead of having you sit there uh resolving combat for every ship and every plane and every bomb is I have these chits right these packs of chits with different effects on the bottom and you decide how many you know they're all face down and you decide how many you're going to drop on on the enemy to soften them up but you really don't know what the effects going to be too much nothing there's too much nothing in there her so you don't and then you don't find out what you've done to the enemy until you actually move up there and they say oh look at that I devastated that

position thank God or they didn't do any nothing happened so I mean I guess that's what you're talking about is is is abstracting certain historical things to and making a little more inter so for me you know dropping chits unknowingly and saying do I put four on here to make darn sure this guy gets it or take a risk and put one here that's kind of what you're saying it's that's the more gamey entertaining part rather than sitting there resolving all the actual bombardments okay that's cool I like that um the other and I you know it's been kind of a thread throughout our interview but I've been waiting to ask but you mention often um that Marketing in commercial elements do at least partially Drive the game themes that you choose the types of games that you've said to design you know you're entry into solo gaming um to what extent would you say that your game theming choices and presentation choices are Market driven and to what extent would you say that they represent you and your passion for what you're doing so I have to work for Publishers Publishers are businesses that have to make money and they make money by selling games so I will design games that I think the publisher can sell I won't force feed them a game on some battle nobody's ever heard of or cares about and make it a you know $80 game that takes 14 hours to play because nobody's gonna buy it what are you talking about there's like a

whole everyone would buy that but will they play it no they unbox so as you probably know and I'm sure David told you you know nobody no design well maybe Dave's getting rich off this I don't know by now he's doing so well but look we're not getting this is not a career this is not you know we're not you know Richard lonus or or or you know what's his name um I can't think of um you know so we're not making a lot of money at this I mean and and this is a joyful thing I mean I would probably be doing this if if I didn't get paid so nonetheless I still have to I have to make games that will sell that's why they're doing it right so if I make a bunch of games and they don't sell anything the Publishers eventually going to tell me Herman stop making games unless I make them for myself and my friends or something right so to answer your question I have to present them with a game that they think they will sell or will sell reasonably I will admit that now that I've been doing this long enough and I have a few good sellers I can probably get away with saying hey I have a game about this coning GRS let's say um and you know i' would like to design a game about that and the publisher will say well okay you know we should sell a reasonable amount of them you know maybe people like your games and we'll buy them because it's your game there's a little there's a little

bit more way weight there okay still you know it has to be a topic that that's going to sell that that people are going to want to buy and and that's that's my obligation to the publisher I mean I can't ask a publisher to go broke selling game you know trying to sell games that I make be and they don't you know they don't provide any profit for them at all I mean fair enough uh but what are some of your okay so now that you're a fancy designer who has some good sellers uh here's the question then what are put my toe in the water on that one what are some of your least marketable design ideas that you'd still kind of like to do where do you come up with these questions oh kind of like my bucket list another baseball game okay because my first baseball game is my worst selling design was called high and yeah high and tight I did it for vpg and nobody nobody knows about it or well few people know about it but um a baseball game which might still happen um what else do I like I man I'm just I would love to do a lot games on the smaller battles of the austr Prussian franor Prussian and Italian Wars of Independence all the and the Crimean War all the 1840s 50s 60s 7s battles in Europe

that were cool battles like the Battle of magenta um you know stuff like that which which would naturally have to be smaller games because they're smaller battles but I just find them very interesting they probably wouldn't sell but maybe one of these days if I can package them properly and come up with a cool system you know I could do something like that I think Ryan and I talked about that the other day as a matter of fact um what else hasn't sold that well I did a game called dead reckoning which was a two-player zombie versus Humans game which which was a cool system and warped into a couple of World War I systems um that one hasn't done very well uh what else well I'll stay I'll stay with that for now okay I mean at any cost has only had one printing at GMT but there may be a second printing finally and that one kind of surprised me because it actually sold well and it has good ratings I I'm not exactly sure why they didn't do another printing but whatever they do they do it's fine and uh yeah that's about it I mean I you know and like even so you talk about marketing so even like the followup to most fearful sacrifice I had to pick a battle that was interesting to do but still would be popular enough that people would be want to get it and then we're doing Rocka chiga and chick which you

know is actually probably near where you live right it's in Northeast Northwestern Georgia and kind of near me it's two hours for me but I mean again that's an interesting enough battle and not a lot of games been done on it so that's marketing wise cool and that's interest for me wise cool and interest for civil war enthusiasts cool um see so is a balancing act I mean it really is I mean I I ask a publisher quite often well what are you looking for and if they come back to me and say something that interests me then I'll do that right if they say something else and I just well I'm not interested in doing that um or vice versa I could say you know I got this idea for a game and if a publish says to me that's not our thing that's fine I you know I I certainly don't take offense at it but that's one of the reasons I work with a lot of different Publishers different there's different Publishers specialize in different client you know have different customer bases specialize in different interests so I you know or have different production uh methods and policies and we can we can't do a game that big we can do smaller games that kind of thing so I like working with different people I mean they're all they're all great people and and and generally good business people too interesting I was actually going to ask about your range of Publishers that you work with and how you decide like which games should go where I mean it sounds like partially it's just what are these Publishers interested in but um you know yeah I never force a design on anybody

you know I and I honestly ask them are you interested in doing I don't want to do a game that a publisher is not 100% behind where I where I feel like I've you know jammed it down their throat I want them to fully support whatever design it is and if they give me any kind of read that they're really not you know oh we'll do it for you you know because you no that's okay it's fine I I want your you know I wanted this to be a mutual thing right you just said You' do for me when you came with this podcast so I mean joking um but no that's really that also leads to the question of how different are your relationship with different Publishers do you um do you get a lot do you prefer to do most of your own development do you like working with Publishers who you know pair you with a de a developer I know you've worked a lot with Ryan howman for example in in recent years um you know when you say that you want a publisher to fully support your game um what does that mean for you in terms of interaction with and having a relationship with people at that at that publication house right so the first level of support is moral support like Hey we're really excited about this right so that gets you jazzed up if they're jazzed up for then you're you get a little bit more excited about it if they come back to you and say well all right then I'm not that excited about doing it right um but they all have their different styles um so you mentioned Ryan actually Ryan

and I only met last year at WBC so we we've actually been working less than a year now oh man that Zorn game came out quick then yes it did it did um so what part of that is because Ryan and I found out that we're sympatico like we're like on the same wave length back and forth and and that can be bad because it's just too many ideas flying around um and and Steve Jones of blue panther I've known him for a long time because he used to do the he did the printing um he did he worked with Allen Emer a little bit then he did the printing for white dog games you know which I designed a few games for and we just he moved to Murphy's Boro which is only a couple hours away from me and you know we became pretty good friends and we started working together um um Flying Pig games tiny battle games Mark Walker I was enamored of Mark Walker because World at War right which and you want to talk about theaters um themes that I'm not that interested in even ever designing are moderns right because I know nothing about Modern Warfare I don't like a lot of Modern Warfare but his world of war game for Lock and Load that first version I absolutely loved because it was chit pull it was random Turn end things happened to you it was easy to play for a modern for a modern game that game was very accessible you know you could just play it you know you're talking about an era where Modern games were

enormous where you're measuring missiles going across hexes you know things like that so I remember going up to him at uh at a WBC when it was in Lancaster and crawling up there and going hi Mr Walker you know I'm such a big fan of yours and uh since then we just got together and now we're like best friends I go up there every three months or so we play games for a week and he's great to work with we now we we talk like we're friends now and but I still respect the fact that he is a publisher yeah right so I don't try to push anything on him that he doesn't want and vice versa if he tells me something's a bad idea he'll tell me uh GMT now it's interesting GMT you talk about a corporate structure and an efficiency machine so when I when I did at any cost which was a few years ago I was kind of on my own it was like Hey her whenever you get the design done give it to us okay now they've got levels of development right and play testing and I work with Ken on um on Plum Island horror and he's just a joy to work he is so efficient he answers Plum Island Plum Island horror questions on Board Game Geek before I get to them which I have to tell you and I'm sure David will tell you this too is a joy answering answering rules questions when you have you know 25 games in the catalog is tough I mean I forget the answers to most of my rules or I won't say most of mine that sounds

bad many of my many of my games and I'm sure David does too and having either fans that will answer for you because they really like your game so they answer or developers who will step in and answer is is just a gut this is why David has so many Cod designers like I'm the one who has so um yeah I mean that's so that's a very corporate relationship but still very friendly and Ken Ken does all that kind of thing with Mark my developers Fred you know Fred's been a friend of mine for years and years and years and he's always my first level Fred Manzo he's always my first level of testing right and he is very good the reason he and I work together so much is because he plays de Devil's Advocate perfectly when I bring him into design he immediately tries to break it it's the first thing he does and let me tell you and designers will tell you this that's what you want you want somebody trying to break the stupid thing right away and showing oh well this isn't going to work so that plus more professional development is is is is uh invaluable it it really is um Revolution games when I did the blind swords games over there same thing you know uh Roger and Richard are intimately involved in every design uh Roger actually played when I brought him Stonewall sword which is the first blind swords ACW he played that 30 times or something like that I mean he really

made sure that he wanted to sell that before he did and he does that with all the games as far as I know um so every every publisher is a slightly different you know some a little more professional relations some are friendly well they're all friendly I mean you never you never have a contested relationship with a with a publisher just don't work with them that's yeah but there's like work friends and they are friend friends you know right um I've only had a problem with one publisher in my entire you know career um and everything else everybody else has been fantastic you can spell it I'm only media well people people who follow me know who it is so um we talked about kind of history and looking at sources to kind of depict games and one thing I always like to think about you know because we can't one thing that's kind of interesting about doing a lot of history is that you can see the past you can't always see yourself um if you could choose one of your games for a future historian to have as evidence of your career or a game that you're going to be remembered for forever which one would it be boy oh boy you and your question

I would I would have to say I would have to say at any cost because that that was a labor of love for me uh oh uh oh I see you oh okay you froze there for a second um at any cost was a labor of love for me um it was just a period I was really really interested in I wanted to do it because it was technically it wasn't the very first blind Swords game but actually it kind of was it was the first one that used that system it was uh it was a campaign that's never been gamed before which surprised me one of the battles was a couple of the battles were but not the whole campaign the whole flow of those those four days um and for me like I said the the uh The Playbook was really important to me because I wanted to teach people about about what you know what this period represented what what how it was represented you know who's involved why they were involved what happened um what one of my personal proudest moments was when I was at WBC and I had uh somebody come up to me and tell me that they thought that Playbook was so good they used it in a classroom to teach the period nice and to me I was like stunned I mean there's nothing more complimentary you can say to a designer as far as I'm concerned that that you know that that was used for that so um plus plus the GMT production I thought was fantastic the map just

everything about that package was to me was perfect I just I you know so I guess it would be that um yeah I mean most fearful sacrifice obviously my most successful game as far as uh Awards you know I won the CSR won a three CSR Awards it's my heavy biggest and heaviest game by far uh so I'm really proud of that one too and many have called it the the best Gettysburg game and for people to say that is mindblowing you know there been so many games covering that battle so I really appreciate you know that but yeah I would say be those two nice and if people could look over the whole of your gaming career um what would you like people to say about you as a designer in 20 years in 50 years hopefully all of our games are still around then and they're not just

um I think that I would want people to say that they appreciate the diversity of my designs that I wasn't just doing one type of design over and over again or one subject over and over again I you know I took a I take a lot of pride in that I you know I can do a Plum Island horror and I can do a hardcore war game or an easier war game um solo games multiplayer games Plum Island hard is the first multiplayer cooperative game I've done and and that's something I want to see as the future for war gaming is that this idea of cooperation and playing on the same side I like that a lot you know um but yeah I would think that the diversity of titles you know that they couldn't pigeon hole me as you know that World War II guy or that you know well they kind of pitch him hold me as a zombie guy but I guess I have to live with that you know we I'll be zombies someday it's okay that's good point yes I was predicting the future there yes uh and then because all designers play games heavily uh what are some games that you've been playing recently that bring you Joy oh my goodness I got it right there Tales From The Red Dragon in what a what a cool little game um I just played for Glory which is the Glad Gladiator combat got card combat game that thing's cool um oh my God I got so some of my

favorites are let's see Street Masters Defenders of the realm Gears of War have you played Gears of War no but I did acquire copy I did I felt like I probably should make sure I got one before it was impossible oh my God that game is great why nobody's ever taken that thing and and and run with it a little bit and redone it or because it's out of print now um but I will now I literally will play ju just about anything I mean uh I'm not big into Euro games I mean I'm not talking about Euro you know War Gamers tend to call non-w games all Euro games they're not I'm talking about the real uh the real Euro Euro games you know what I'm talking about I can't think of one off the top of my head right now yeah no I know what you mean um you know a billion pieces a billion cubes a billion ways to score victory points and it's trading in the Mediterranean or of course something like that I I do like those twoo I like it all but oh okay um you know I like so just to give you an example my probably my favorite game of all time right since the I didn't't played this game since the 90s is Robo rally so I just think that game is so much fun I really do and I try to bring it we play it with the kids when they come to this day um so that good I don't know what that says about me but says something sounds fun to me uh and then

just one more question since you mentioned playing PC games earlier do you feel that those that your digital gaming and your board gaming are very separate things or do they kind of blend for you and like cross inform each other for me they're kind of separate because I play I play this one baseball game I've been playing this thing for 10 years and I just keep the seasons going and going fictional Seasons I have a team called the the Nashville hot chickens I like it actually and uh and I play this oh my God I play this game called Gladius which is Warhammer 40K um kind of a Civ type of style it is I have been playing I I can't it's embarrassing probably to see how many hours I've played this thing but it's the it's the closest thing to what I envision Warhammer 40K really being like I don't play Warhammer 40K Miniatures I don't like the I don't really like the game but I will play their board games and I play the the computer game and it's it just comes to life so that to me is a separate realm you know so I try to when I'm designing I try to play a little bit of this I'll do a turn or two of this then I'll do a you know 20 minutes of Gladius and then go back to work so uh yeah so I I I I treat them separately yeah also the mystery of how you got all those hours in solves itself the quick time well I'm retired now so and as you

can tell by my red face I've taken up golf so I played 18 holes before I got on here and I got a little Sunburn and everything I'm exhausted but I got two birdies my first two birdies ever so yeah well what else you gonna do you're retire you know the thing is I so I worked as an accountant for 40 something years I worked two jobs for 20s something years and my hob is at a desk so I work two jobs at a desk behind a computer my hobby design work is at a desk behind a computer and I said and Nancy said to me my girlfriend she said we have to find something else for you to do that doesn't involve a desk so I started taking up Golf and boy oh boy it's it's been very rewarding but very tiring you twist and turn and bend things you haven't Twisted turned and bended 40 something years I'm really I'm hurting man but it's great I love it fantastic all right so I guess we should let you rest now um but yes please but um thank you for coming on it's been lovely to get to talk to you and I do have thank you for having me I'm glad we could finally talk it's been I know know we've connected online a few times over the years like it's always been nice it's nice to actually like have a chat and uh I've got PL Island horror I'll be playing it soon myself so I hope you like it I thank God it's gotten really good reviews so far um and we have the as people might or might know we already already asked me for an expansion and we're putting that out on p500 this month and we got we I got some good surprises by the way for people are worried it's not it's not an expansion

that adds more rules or layer it's just a more stuff expansion okay so you don't have to relearn the game I I hate stuff like that where they put so many expansions on it becomes a different game and it becomes just bloated and I don't like that so you'll like what's in the expansion though it's a it um I'm glad I also want to say if I can I appreciate the fact that people like my humor because when you inject humor into games you're really taking a risk because what you think might be hilarious other people might go just groan and go that's that's pathetic you know so so far so far people have liked the humor and thank God that's all I can say awesome yeah we might actually talk more about that in the future once I have played it and can talk about your actually pretty fun um but seriously thank you so much for coming on it's been absolute Delight have you thank you and uh yeah best of luck with retirement and all the designs I'm waiting let's go I'm working harder now than I did when I worked for living so and everybody out there please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved