Skip to main content
Loading video...

Coalitions | Kickstarter PREVIEW | Should You Back It?

Transcript 22:14

hey everyone how's it going i'm carlo from all you can board and today i'm going to be previewing coalitions this is a game that is on kickstarter as of june 16th it's published by phalanx games and designed by first time designer andrew rourke so this is a game of area control and diplomacy set during the revolutionary and napoleonic wars of course in europe it's mostly a three to six player game but there is also a solo and a co-op variant which we'll talk about a bit later but basically you're going to be reenacting this period of history and of course you're able to kind of change the outcomes and rewrite history along the way a couple things i have to get out of the way before we get into this the first is that this is not a review and also this is not a paid preview we were not paid to do this however the publisher did send us this prototype copy of the game in order to put together the preview so keep in mind these are all prototype components if you check out the kickstarter page i'm sure you'll see all kinds of stuff that already looks different than this and the game will certainly look different in its final form and the other thing is just that unfortunately due to the pandemic and the restrictions here and how slowly i've been in manitoba to kind of get back to normal unfortunately we have not had a chance to try this at the higher player counts where it seems like it's most recommended so the focus of this video is basically going to be an overview of the systems um what you should be looking out for and basically just give you an idea of whether or not you want to back this so stick around and i will tell you all about coalitions so we're going to start by going over a brief overview of what you do in this game i'm not going to cover all the rules in this game for a couple of reasons first off there's a lot of little intricacies that you're probably not going to remember and the other thing is that there have been actually a significant number of

rule changes and terminology changes over the past few weeks even since we got the original copy of the game so i'm not sure what else might change from now until when the game is in its final version so i'm just gonna kind of focus on a basic overview of what's going on in coalitions players can play as one of the six nations france britain russia austria prussia or the ottoman empire france and britain are always at war with each other the other four nations can either ally with france ally with britain remain neutral or start a war of expansion which is basically armed neutrality and these allegiances and coalitions can switch throughout the game this is represented on the political status marker which we'll look at in more detail later all nations start with 17 influence which is basically your victory points the game can end in one of two ways if any nation reaches or exceeds 40 influence they win in which case any nations that were in a coalition with that nation would also win albeit to a lesser extent the other way the game can end is if any non-french nation that's not in a coalition with france controls the capital city of paris then they would immediately win so then how do you actually gain influence and gain those points to try and win if you're not capturing paris well it's mostly from either winning battles or controlling disputed territories so speaking of territories we're going to take a closer look at the game board now so the map is a broad representation and kind of a simplified look at the political situation in europe between the years in the french revolution during this period all kinds of borders were changing territories were won and

lost and the map has basically been distorted to minimize the size of the seas and maximize the amount of room for gameplay on land you'll notice many of the territories have a color on them that just signifies that's the nation that that belongs to you know blue being france green being russia etc there are also disputed territories which are these striped territories the color of the stripes indicates which nations can claim the territory for themselves these disputed territories have a number in black circle which represents the amount of influence a claiming nation receives for controlling it and only the nation whose color stripes are shown in a disputed territory can actually gain influence in this way other nations controlling these territories receive income instead of influence in order to gain control of a territory that doesn't belong to your nation you would have to have a garrison in that nation garrisons are things that you can leave behind when moving out of an area or moving into an area as long as there's no battle to be resolved first which we're going to talk about a bit later as well so in terms of the actual flow of the game it uses a very convenient rondelle system which they refer to as the wheel of war it has six different actions on this wheel and each round each of the six nations will be assigned to one of those actions so every round each player will take one of those six actions and then the wheel will rotate and each player will then get to take the next action available to them as i mentioned before there have been some minor rule changes lately and since the most recent version of the rule book that we were looking at for these rondelle actions um on the kickstarter page it seems they have been changed slightly so unfortunately i

won't be able to go into these in too much detail but a brief overview of what these types of actions can do is there's going to be stuff like either gaining and discarding battle cards which will help you to bolster your forces when you're challenging someone to try and fight over a territory another player might be doing things like gaining income for the territories that they control spending that income on all kinds of stuff whether it's adding more unit tokens to the board gaining more of those battle cards for the battle you can even do stuff like increase your nation's morale or national will which is used to spend on more battle cards to resolve conflicts there's all kinds of stuff you can do the main action here the one where most the game is going to happen usually is movement now this is where one of the most prominent aspects of the diplomacy comes into play with the game with the system that was initially called the enabler system there's a very good video on youtube from the designer andrew o'rourke called explaining the enabler system it is now referred to as the activator the way this works in short is whenever the movement phase happens let's say the nation that is supposed to move is going to move at least one time but might be granted a second and third movement so let's say i'm playing as russia and it's my turn to move the first thing i have to do is choose an activator i must choose another nation that is not allied or not in a coalition with me and i must basically ask that nation that player permission to be able to move now as i said you're going to move between one to three times you're going to get to do your one movement action first for free and the activator has no say in

that but after you finish that first movement you have to ask the activator can i move again if they allow you to move you're going to be able to do a second movement action and as a result of them allowing you to do that they're going to gain morale so there's this kind of give and take where you're trying to decide as the activator how much do i want to let this person move because they might move around the map and do things that may or may not benefit me we don't know we're not allies when we're agreeing to this but as the activator the more you allow that movement the more your morale can go up the other thing i'd like to mention at this point real quick before we move on from the wheel of war is that in the previous rules that we had read it had mentioned there's a diplomacy phase where you're basically going to be deciding uh whether you're going to ally with the british ally with the french remain neutral or go on your own and start a war of expansion so previously the rules had indicated that once the rondelle or the wheel of war had done a full circle after all those six actions had kind of been taken and it had reset the diplomacy phase would trigger and all players would take part in this however on the kickstarter page right now it looks like the diplomacy phase has been um kind of moved into one of the areas of the wheel of war but basically what's going to happen is it's going to be an open discussion phase where players can decide whether they want to ally with the french ally with the british or go off on their own however as the british player or the french player you don't have to accept that coalition someone can say you know what i'm gonna go and ally with the british and the british player can say no you're not i want nothing to do with you and that's kind of where it ends then

you might be just stuck going on your own or then you might start to beg the french to see if they want to be in a coalition with you so now let's talk about player count and downtime and all that sort of stuff so again i mentioned the game goes up to six players and in my opinion that is definitely where it's going to shine the most because these six nations are always in play so if you play with let's say five players one player is going to be controlling two nations and everyone else is going to be controlling one and if you playing with three or four players then there's going to be multiple players controlling multiple or one player might even be managing three nations so in a way a player that's managing two or three nations compared to someone who's managing one they're gonna have a lot more to do they might take a lot more time in that uh you know wheel of war phase because they're figuring out actions for one nation as well as another nation and there's an opportunity for someone to feel like maybe the person who's playing with two factions is maybe playing the game more but i think there's one thing to keep in mind about this is if you're the person who has played this game and knows and you're introducing new players you should be the one probably taking on that second nation playing those extra roles and in that way who knows might that might even balance it out more for a first play giving you that challenge of managing two or three nations the one thing it does though is that because you know you can't be let's say you're controlling two nations they have to be basically having similar intentions along the way you know you can't be um attacking you know using those two nations to attack each other for example so or go off in different directions you it kind of forces you to pigeonholes you a little bit in terms of

making you go in one direction with both of your nations there's still some room for expanding but overall i think the game is going to be at its most interesting and it's most interactive by far when it's at six players or at least five now let's get back to this wheel of war for a moment because when we were first sent this prototype and the initial rule book a couple months back originally the rondelle and wheel of war system didn't exist and there wasn't a sequence of turns where basically this nation would do their movement and then the next nation would do their you know mobilization then another nation do their movement and you were kind of going turn by turn by turn watching everyone do their stuff and you know i think there are some issues some people complain maybe there's a little bit of downtime a little too much of it so they came up with this wheel of war which allows again you can you know they're kind of offering it as a simultaneous play option and they encourage this should eliminate a lot of the downtime in the game by allowing players to take their actions simultaneously in theory it sounds excellent in practice i'm not sure yet how well it's going to work because a lot of these actions are dependent on each other and there is an order listed like the you know this one will technically trigger first second third fourth fifth and sixth if you do need to if you prefer to go in order rather than playing them out simultaneously and movement's always going to be that sixth action so let's say on the player who's moving sure i could start doing my movement and playing simultaneously but how am i going to know where i want to move or who i want to potentially get into a battle with before i see you know where players are spending their income who's you know doing what other actions on the board who's going to potentially ally with someone

so although in some ways it can create for simultaneous play and i think with groups that have played it a lot there might be certain aspects that can be done simultaneously or maybe certain actions but ultimately again if i'm the movement player and i need to be asking picking an activator and i'm saying hey you over there can i move again and they're saying hang on a second i'm spending my income like okay so then i'm waiting then there is going to be down time so i think again it kind of will eliminate some of the downtime but don't be mistaken there will still be downtime in the game and it's not going to be entirely simultaneously because ultimately i don't think it would work all that well for the game now i want to talk about asymmetry in this game because it's done in a very interesting way and something that totally caught me off guard when i originally read through the rules and the setup and everything i remember thinking these don't seem that asymmetric there aren't any special powers this isn't a game like root or the voyage is a marco polo where you know you feel like you do something that breaks the game or you're playing the game in a completely different way from everyone a lot of it is very subtle and has to do with either the setup or you know little things that come along the way i would say the two most asymmetric ones of course because of the big players here are gonna be the french and the british obviously the french are kind of you know have everyone coming for them uh it's napoleon's army so i mentioned before that one of the main win conditions is if a non-french territory or nation that isn't allied with the french controls paris that they would win the game so because of that the french will start off with the most powerful armies on the board by far you've got your general tokens or your general your general standees

and underneath those you've got your unit tokens and you can see the french are kind of stacked at the start they're ready for battle they also start with a bunch of morale right off the start so and they start with a bigger card of hands you also have a bigger hand limit size with the french you can hold 10 cards whereas the other nations can mostly just hold six or seven the british have some other interesting stuff too because the british have a very weak army at the start if you look they've got three generals but they've got barely any unit tokens under them they're very very weak but the game starts with russia and austria in coalition with the british and the british also get additional income that no other nation gets they can basically subsidize some of this income and give it to other nations uh in exchange for gaining influence points the basic idea being that the british are just desperate to find anyone who will ally with them to take down the french and even if those coalitions fall apart they'll find another way to you know bribe someone else to join their coalition and just stubbornly keep trying to take down the french so the british start off weak but they have these all these little incentives along the way so the i would say the most complicated ones to play are probably the british and the french just for the little rules intricacies otherwise the other four nations are a lot more similar the main difference has to do with the setup i mean you know the prussians start as neutral the ottoman empire starts at war of expansion also the ottoman empire is kind of in this corner off on their own and the prussians and the austrians are kind of in the middle of everything so there's a lot of these little subtleties a lot of it's not going to be immediately clear on your first or maybe

even second play there's going to be a lot of depth to explore here from the asymmetry you might even notice oh hey the russian player tends to be able to get that really important territory on that side of the map earlier so the game is going to take on this level of depth uh and and level of kind of like rewarding you for exploring the different strategies and the different asymmetric starts and the little you know things that they can you know different directions they can send you in throughout the game i also want to quickly talk about player elimination because you know in these types of games there often is player elimination and there is no such thing in this game um basically when you are eliminated you become neutral and one of the things i didn't mention before about being neutral is that in the income phase your income is doubled so that is a way to kind of keep you in the game allow you to claw your way back in um either by just kind of getting more income and or forming alliances because players might want to form an alliance with you if they think you're not much of a threat so i like that for such a long game a player who falls behind still has ways to you know offer other people to be useful they can still find their way to claw their way back into the game and i think that's an excellent thing to do for a game of this level of complexity and also the the length of the game so speaking about complexity i have to touch on this because i believe it is on the phalanx games website in the coalition section or perhaps on the bgg page where they've referred to this as a light euro game and with all due respect to phalanx personally i don't think it is accurate to call this a light game um i mean the rulebook and its current iteration that we've seen

is about 6 000 words it's about a 24 25 page microsoft word document to me that looks like it's going to be if i had to guess there's no wait listed on the bgg page currently i would think it's probably going to fall somewhere between a 2.5 and a 3.0 maybe even 3.2 3.3 kind of thing i would say it's definitely at least a medium weight game might even be pushing over medium definitely not in heavy and i think once you get to play it a couple times you know it doesn't seem as complicated as it does at first but again there's a lot of little intricacies along the way things that might not necessarily be marked on the board that might you might need to consult the rules to be reminded um again some of these issues also might be you know might go away because again these are prototypes so there might be player aids that come with the game there might be more stuff indicated on the boards so now the most important questions of all should you back it is this game for you it really depends it to be honest with you it is a fairly niche game in many ways i know a lot of people who this game just wouldn't be for their group regardless of how good it is then again i know a lot of people who would love this if you like the history if you're really into this historical period you like war games you like learning about this kind of stuff i mean this is gonna pull you right in it's gonna if you especially if you really know this history the idea of making these different moves these subtle moves along the way is really interesting and even as someone who i'll be completely honest i know very little about this period in history it's been a long time since i learned about this and even as someone who normally wouldn't gravitate to this type of game i was intrigued enough that i totally took the publisher up on receiving this game because i thought a

game that kind of focuses on this and has these diplomacy aspects and allows you to explore this and go in these kind of alternate historical routes is really intriguing so if you especially if you're playing with other players who you know you might just have a friend who's like a history major or something and they might be able to make the game more interesting for you so i think that definitely helps the other thing i want to mention is if you're the type of person that collects tons of games and most of the games you have you play like once or twice a year i don't know if this is the right game for you or your group i mean it's one thing if you think that again if the history is interesting enough for you and that maybe even the solo you would be happy enough for the solo mode then maybe that's worth a few already otherwise i think to really get the most enjoyment out of this game you're going to want to play this with the same group of players or at least similar players and you're going to want to play it fairly frequently at least a few times a year fairly close together so that you're not forgetting all the rules or you know you get an hour in and realize oh yeah i forgot about that i should have done that differently and you kind of feel like you're behind so um i think it's definitely something that has a lot of appeal for groups that want to really dig into this explore the history explore the different strategies so even though there's a lot to like here there's a lot that really interests me i have to mention there are a few red flags here that you guys have to know about if you're going to consider backing this the first being like i mentioned before there's been quite a few rule changes recently when we first got the the game sent to us we had an edition of the rules learned how to play through the game started putting together our material for the video and shortly maybe a day or two before shooting we realized there was an update to the rules and there was some you know

the there are some changes so we reached out to the publisher and credit to them they got back to us very quickly and answered almost all of our questions that we had um however then i started preparing again we rescheduled our filming and since then actually just today before coming right over the studio to film i noticed there were some other changes on the board game geek page as well as the kickstarter page that unfortunately had not been made aware of in time so again it's unfortunate that i haven't been able to give you guys as much of a detailed look at the rules but because there have been so many changes recently and it still doesn't seem to be a final version of the rule book i just don't want to confuse you guys by getting into this stuff and this is for you to know as well i mean if you have concerns about you know the level of play testing with the new rules or is the game going to be you know is this close to a final version of the rule book that's something that you you know have every right to be skeptical of if i was going to be backing you know a game that requires this much of a time investment and financial investment as well i'd like to have some assurances that the game i'm backing is going to be you know that's the game i'm going to get i don't want to back a game and then find out later that the rules have changed a whole bunch i don't think it's going to change enough to you know make the game play significantly differently or change your experience but i mean if the game has been you know this game has been in the works for for a few years now and it's been play tested extensively with those previous rules and so i just i am a little concerned when there's this many rule changes so close to the launch the kickstarter campaign i mean i know the game probably won't be shipped and fulfilled for quite some time still so there's plenty of time still to kind of refine everything and get

these rules to a more you know finalized state um but it's just something to keep in mind if you're kind of on the fence about that um you know don't be shy to ask questions in the comments on the kickstarter page from the publisher the other thing for me i don't know if it's really fair to call this one a red flag because it might just be a personal choice um i know a lot of people don't mind this kind of thing in games but for me the activator mechanic that i mentioned before there's a bit of a thematic disconnect and maybe this is just my like lack of historical knowledge maybe there is an explanation for this that i'm just not not really getting here but so again as i mentioned before the activator you're basically choosing a nation that is not in an allegiance with you or not in a coalition with you and asking them if they will allow you to move beyond your first granted movement action so let's say i'm playing as the austrians and i'm asking the ottoman empire if i can move from a thematical standpoint in in real life you know asking a potential enemy if i can move and they gain morale out of it there's just a bit of a weird like why why are they gaining morale and why are they the ones why is an enemy potentially on the other side of europe granting me access to move especially because the move doesn't even necessarily have to do with the ottomans i can say hey ottoman player can i move and they might say well that depends where you're going to move and i can say oh well i'll probably go over there and then i can do something different or i can you know try and make a deal with them on where i'm moving but you know one player might be moving three times on their turn another player might only move once and the difference has to do with the other players basically allowing you to

move and again just in a kind of more real world context i just don't understand the kind of thematic integration of that and as this campaign is going on you know details might change feel free to leave a comment below if you have any questions anything you want clarity on i'll do my best i'm going to keep you know an eye on this game i'm going to be trying to answer questions if i can to the best of my ability again because of rule changes and things like that i might not be you know at the forefront of being the best person answer but you know we're putting this video we want to help you guys decide if the game is for you so let us know if you have any questions you can send us an email as well all you can board at gmail.com or leave a comment below otherwise that's it if you like this video please consider subscribing to our channel we do all kinds of stuff how to play videos reviews kickstarter previews list videos all kinds of stuff like that really appreciate the support thank you so much for watching and i'll see you next time

Progress saved