51st State: Master Set Review
Transcript
welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing 51st state the master set Edition in this two to four player game you will be in the post-apocalyptic niroshima world and this is a multi-use card game where you will be building a tableau in front of you as well as discarding cars to get resources and potentially destroying some of your opponent's cards as well first I will show you how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review the first thing you need to do is create the draw deck now this is the base game right here but the game also comes with two additional expansions you can Shuffle one or the other into this main deck and then play with that for now I'll just show you with the basic cards and now each player chooses one of the four asymmetric factions that come in the game and it's neat to note that they have a male side on them and a female side each round of 51st state begins with the lookout phase in which we draw cards from the top of the deck equal to the number of players plus one so if it was a two-person game we would have three cards in the middle and then the person who is the starting player would choose one of these cards for their hand then the next player would take one of these cards for their hand and the last card would get discarded and now we'll do that one more time but in this time the person who is not the starting player gets to choose one of these cards first then the starting player gets to take one of them lastly this is discarded and we can move on and now each player goes into production and I've skipped forward into the middle of the game where a player might have some cards played already and they're going to make all the goods that are on their player Faction board which are different between the different players then they're going to make goods for all the deals they've made and for any of the buildings that they have in production so right here they would get
three people they would get one scrap they're gonna get one gray contact token as well as one more random card from the top of the deck then when you look at their deals they're going to get a gun and a brick and then finally this assassin down here is going to make them one additional gun so this is all the stuff that they start with for this round this is a tableau building game so let's show you how you play cards down into the field now if you look at your hand you'll see that every single card has a distance value on the left hand side now this is the cost to do various things for the card but the first thing is if you want to play a card down you're going to need to spend gray contact tokens which look just like this equal to the distance value on the card so right now I only have the one gray contact token I could spend it I won't be able to buy any of these cards here because they'll cost two or three but I could buy this school here and put it down into my production area now you know it's a production card because down here on the bottom it says production and when you look at your player board you see it says production then feature and finally action and this just shows you how to sort your card so all production cards will go up here all features will go here and then finally all the action cards will get slotted down there one great thing about building these production cards is that they immediately produce so this says it produces one person that means you're going to get this now and at the beginning of every subsequent round in the game also many buildings have building bonuses on the bottom you get that one time the moment you place the card so for placing this card down we would actually get two more people to play with on this round now let's look at the four basic actions that come on the player board the top three are slightly different between the four different factions and the bottom one is
the same for all factions and these are essentially little conversion ratios we can see that the New York player could spend one Cog to get one gray token one gun to get two red tokens or two fuel to get two Bluetooth tokens and when they do this they take the item and they put it down on the board to show that they've done that action and then they immediately are going to make whatever it is that's on that line and it's important to know that you can do each one of these lines once per round so on a future turn within this given round I could take this Cog here go down here and evaluate that line there but I can no longer spend guns to take these red contact tokens down here you'll see that you can spend two people to gain one resource of your choice so that makes two people wild or you could take a random card off the top of the deck and the nice thing about the bottom one is you can do that as many times as you want in a given round in fact in a given turn I could spend four people right now to just take two breaks from the supply if I felt like it so we know what these gray tokens are for but what about these red ones here now these allow you to destroy things the easiest thing that you can destroy are cards that are in your hand so if you look at the cards in your hand once again you'll see the distance values but you might also notice that there are these spoils in the top right corner of each of these cards now in order to destroy one of these cards and get the spoils you need to discard these red tokens equal to the distance so I could spoil this fuel tank here by discarding a single red token back to the bank and then I would get two fuel from the bank and put it right in my area an alternate thing that you can do with these red tokens is instead of destroying cards from your hand you can destroy opponents buildings that are in
there to blows now if you look at the player board you'll see a three four and five this is the defense rating for all cards in that row so if an opponent wanted to destroy one of my buildings uh these production buildings they would need to discard three of these red contact tokens but if they wanted to destroy an action building it would cost five and let's just say that they did that they spent three red contact tokens to destroy the school now the reason they might do that is because the moment this gets destroyed they're going to get all the spoils on that so they would get two people but as a bonus to us and a bit of a consolation prize we would also generate a person because we would do whatever is in the bottom portion or the deal portion of the card which I've shown you before can produce things for you and I'll show you how to make those in just a minute so in this case this card will be destroyed I would get a person because that was on the bottom of the card and then this card will get flipped over in place like this it is now in Ruins and I'll explain why that matters in just a little bit now let's pretend that the player spent these two fuel in order to make two of these blue contact tokens so that I can show you what they do as I just pointed out a moment ago the bottom of every card in this game has a little deal section and you might notice that it's actually upside down in order to make a deal with the card you need to discard blue tokens equal to the distance value on the top of the card so we can make a deal with this Pub right here by discarding both of our blue uh tokens you're going to flip this card over now and you'll tuck it into your deals section and just like the production buildings the moment you make a deal it immediately produces and this one right here actually generates us a card from the top of the deck so we just take that we put it into our hand for your transaction you can also evaluate one of the cards that you've built that
has an action on it so this one right here says you can spend a person in a cog in order to get two victory points so you would take the person in the Cog put it on the card to show that you can't do it again on this turn and then you're going to get those featuring points and then you log all victory points on this track right here another action you can take is a development action and for this you have to spend a brick from your supply and then you could place a card from your hand into your Tableau all you have to do is match up the symbols on the left hand side of the card with the symbols on one of your face up cards currently and you will discard that card so for instance I could take this scrap metal spot which is a feature which lets us put three uh scrap Parts on it immediately and I put that down in my feature Zone and I can only do that because this card right here has the scrap symbol on it and in the process of doing it I'm going to be discarding this card entirely so this gets destroyed we'd essentially develop the Shipwreck into a scrap metal yard and each time you develop you get a victory point and coming back to this ruined card that we got when somebody destroyed our school earlier we can always spend a brick to do a development action and discard a ruins and this effectively matches any symbol on any card in your game it's a wild symbol so this goes away and I could just take this distance three gasoline drinkers then and place it down immediately so it's a really cheap way to get down expensive cards The Last Action type I'm going to discuss are these two connection piles you reveal the top card of each of these in the lookout phase of the beginning of each round and for your action you can take the card into your hand and then use it later as your action to get a bonus in this case it would be to get three blue contact
tokens and in this case right here it would be to get two red contact tokens the important thing about these connection piles is that once somebody takes this card into their hand you do not flip over the next card until the round is over and you start the next Lookout phase so only one person per round is going to get one of these two cards if you can't or don't want to take any actions then instead you can pass and then all other players will keep taking actions until they've all passed as well one nice thing about passing is that nobody can destroy any of your buildings once you've passed after all players have passed we then move into the cleanup phase in which you actually lose all resources that you were not able to use in that given round so all these are gone fortunately you do get to keep all the cards that are in your hand for future rounds and then you clear all the resources that are on the actions that you took throughout this given turn to show that on the next turn they'll be open and usable for you you may have noticed that on the score tracker the number 25 is a little bit different than the rest and that's because it is the threshold for ending the game at the end of a round if any player has exceeded 25 victory points then you will not go on to a next round and you will do final scoring and final scoring is really easy you just add up all the cards that are in your Tableau in front of you and add those to your score and then that'll be your final score and whoever has the most points is going to be the winner it's now time to review 51st state the master site Edition and I'm going to begin with some positive points the first of these relates to the great Tableau engine building that you're doing while you're playing the game now this is far from new to the game in fact from the same designer and publisher we've seen the original 51st state as well as Imperial settlers and there are a lot of similarities when it comes to those games and this one with the
Tableau building but that doesn't make it not great I love the organized style that this game brings to your engine building where you have all the production buildings along the top and they make you stuff then on the middle you have these feature buildings which are either ongoing effects or just One-Shot effects that just get you points immediately and you don't have to worry about them anymore and then down at the bottom you have action cards which let you use those resources and turn them into other resources or just turn them into victory points because at the end of the day this really is a cranked handle and turn raw resources into victory points kind of game but it does a really good job of displaying them in front of you and really just a satisfying experience watching this whole thing build up and you can easily see where your strengths are where your weaknesses are and I just the player board itself is great it just has vibrant art on it it's just a really good tablet billing experience positive number two relates to the satisfying feeling that solving the puzzle that each hand is going to be presenting you with gives you because every card in the game can be three different things it could be used as a production building essentially as you make it into a deal or you can discard it for some One-Shot resources or you could use it as the card it's meant to be as it's action or its feature or something like that so when you start the game with seven cards every one of them being three potential things that gives you a lot of different options and you right away start digging into what you could do occasionally you're going to draw a hand and it'll be obvious so like oh well this synergizes with that and then I could just do this and this and this cool but more often than not you have to think about it a little bit you have to fight to work out what this hand of cards is really wanting you to do and more often than
not I found that you will have something cool that you could do with pretty much any hand of cards even if you see Zero synergies uh when I've had that happen I've ended the turn and looked down and been like oh wow I did a lot more than I at first thought I was going to do when I do this hand I thought it was like oh crud I'm not gonna be getting anything done this first turn but no I got like three buildings down I have a deal or two and uh I got this going and I'm I'm okay with the way this game started so there is definitely some hand-draw luck where sometimes it'll be easier than not but I just like deciphering what my options are and then what the best path to doing a really good job with that hand is positive number three is the contact token mechanism and this is one of the larger divergences between Imperial settlers and 51st state Master set and if you don't remember what this is in Imperial settlers you could just spend resources to build buildings but in 51st state you have to use your materials turn them into these contact tokens and then use the contact tokens to build the buildings or destroy buildings and at first it seemed like an extra step like why would they just throw that in there that's weird but as I started playing the game I realized the Brilliance of it because it creates a checks and balances on just making lots of resources if you make tons of resources Imperial settlers you can always almost always find a way to spend them and just build your entire hand and be like oh cool I did a lot of stuff that wasn't very hard but in 51st state you really have to make sure you don't invest too much energy in making a bunch of resources that you can't immediately use so just making a huge production engine early game is not going to be the key to victory at all in 51st state
because you have to turn those resources into a usable product it's almost like having raw materials and you have to refine them in order to actually use them and it's a great extra step it really constricts the options that you have and I just love the extra thinking that goes in to again like I just mentioned the figuring out what you're going to be doing with your hand and that restriction makes it so you can't just like oh I'll do this which gives me resources to build that all do this give some resources to do that very often you're going to be looking your hand you're like I'm only going to build two of these cards like there's only enough contact token abilities for me to get one or two cards down but what am I going to do with the other cards to do good stuff on my turn and I just think contact token mechanism is the thing that really brings that all together and positive number four relates to the end game trigger in 51st state this is another big difference between 15 for State Master set and Imperial settlers because Imperial settlers you just always played five turns and that was it but in 50 First State you are going to keep playing until the end of a round where somebody passes 25 victory points and then you just total up and the game is over now I've played this game many times now and every single game I've played has been four turns there was one game that was almost three turns but none of them have even been close to going to five turns so right off the bat this is a faster game than Imperial sellers because in general there's an entire turn left off but also mechanically I just think it's a vast Improvement because one issue with Imperial settlers is I could see sometimes people would become a runaway leader and like that last turn was just Superfluous like it was obvious who was
going to win maybe you're going to fight for second or third place but why spend that extra 20-25 minutes when you could just end the game and be like okay he won over there in 51st day it just does that also it's a check on balance on somebody who's making a really good engine you might look across the table and realize your opponent is out engineing you but you might just decide okay I'm gonna just race the race to the end of the game like they are putting all these pieces together they have great synergies but maybe they don't quite have their Victory Point engine going just yet I'm going to just race forward end the game before they can really get that crazy engine that they built going and that's just a good thing you need to always be careful and looking across to see when is the game going to end although like I said every single game I played has ended in four turns so I'm actually kind of curious it'll be interesting to see the first game where it does go to Five turns or does go to three turns but in general I'm okay with four turns and I just like the idea that the end game is in the control of the players now let's cover a couple neutral points and the first of these relates to the amount of asymmetry there is between the factions that come in the game now they are different between each other but I was expecting them to be a bit more different than they ended up being pretty much the main difference is they start with a slightly different production token and then they convert their resources into contact tokens at different rates like One race will be really good at making red contact tokens one gun will make three of them and another race is really good at making blue contact tokens they can spend one fuel to get three of those and that will make that um blue contact race much
better at making deals and the red contact race much better at destroying cards in their hands or even destroying opponent's buildings but it does not feel like oh I'm only going to win this game if I destroy my opponent's buildings and Destroy lots of cards in my hand because I am this person who's really good at converting these red contact tokens it's more like just a little bit added variety like oh this game I'm gonna be doing a little bit more red contact tokens than the others but I'm I'm not going to be like this um vicious uh destroyer of everybody else's stuff because that's the way the faction is making me go it's like a little hint it's a little spice that adjusts the way you play a little bit but does not leave me jonesing to play One race or another because I don't think they all feel pretty similar and I am okay with that because it feels like a balanced experience and it is fun like kind of just taking a random one at the beginning of every game and just saying how this one plays in this one given instance and um so this is definitely not a negative but in comparison to Imperial settlers which was very asymmetric because every single faction had its own deck of cards this is a significant difference between the two games and I actually think I prefer 50 first date because in Imperial settlers it felt like oh if you're The Barbarians you've got to be doing this and if you don't do this then you're gonna lose and oh if you're the if you're Japan and then if you're not doing that then all you're going to lose it's just it felt like it was kind of on Rails forcing you to go that direction and 15 first state no matter what faction you choose it still feels like you can go in a variety of directions and still be very successful neutral point number two relates to the two expansions that come in the game you have the base game and then you have new era and you have winter and the game says you can Shuffle one or the other of those into the base
game and just have a slightly different experience and I have done both of those and the game was much better because of that in fact I would strongly advise you pretty much never play with just the base game maybe the first time you play play with the base cards but never go back there because it does feel a little samey and not quite interesting enough those expansions add a lot of variety of interesting cards and interesting synergies that really makes the game way better so I think the base game works but it's a very good thing the game shipped with these two expansions but it says you can only use one or the other and it is a bit frustrating at the end of the game sorting all the cards back out and putting them in the box so one time I decided I just shuffled all of it together even though I was told that it wasn't bounced to be like that and it probably won't be as good of a game but just Shuffle it all together this huge pile played a three-player game of it and you know what it was fun it was totally fine I didn't see any problems with that play of the game and it was kind of nice not having to worry about pulling all the cards back out again now I know this is not the way the game is intended to be played and almost every game I've played I've done it as intended I only tried this once but I will admit going forward I might do this all the time because I just love the variety of the cars like one deck um has you know that's the other thing I've looked at the two different expansions and they apparently have different Vibes but I have not analyzed each of them and it did not jump out at me that one was oh really good at doing this and oh one is really going to force you to do that more often it just seemed like a good variety card so when I just crammed them all together it seemed like even more variety I will admit it seemed like there were quite a few of the lower
value cards lower distance cards um but that was just a single day instead of one like I had a big hand of cards and most of them were once and I was like I wonder if that's because I'm playing the game as I'm not supposed to be playing it but I still had a really good time everybody around the table still had a really good time and I enjoyed the extra variety so I guess this is something you could potentially do and it speaks to the variety of the expansions that come in the game so now let's go into my one negative for the game and this is more of a pet peeve than a negative if I'm being honest that has to do with the connection cards the uh merchants and the punks connection cards that let you draw the card from the top of that stack and now nobody else can get to it and you can spend it later to get either more blue or red contact tokens and on the face of it I don't have a problem with these connection cards they mechanically work in fact it is kind of an interesting decision like when do you go and spend your action taking that card so that nobody else can take it from you because only one happens each round but my issue is it just feels tacked on like I think there's a reason it's there I feel like the game is probably better off with them in there like it's a better balanced experience but I wish that the game had been developed in such a way that they would not be necessary and the already established mechanisms could be bolstered to stop somebody from finding themselves in a situation where they really need more blue contact tokens and they cannot get them it feels like a bit of a Band-Aid mechanism that does help the game they saw an issue they threw those in to fix it but when I see that kind of thing it just it irks me like I just think somehow and I don't have the
answer I just think somehow maybe that issue could have been resolved without tacking on an extra little thing that needs to be added to the setup and put out every single time and explained while you're teaching the game it just seems like it could have been worked out better so let's discuss the replayability of 51st state and I've actually talked about this a little bit already in neutral point number two I think that it is definitely above average it's a very solid replayable experience because the game comes with those two expansions if the game just shipped with the base game it would have a big replayability problem because after even one play of the base game I was like okay I need more variety of cards in here but it's just it was really smart of them to put these two expansions in because you can mix one expansion in in one game and then another expansion in the next game and then come back to that first one and as I talked about in neutral point number two you could go crazy like I did and Shuffle it all together in one big pile and just have tons of variety like the the number of cards that are going to be in there is going to really change the way you play each game because you're going to be only touching a smaller and smaller portion of that deck the bigger the deck gets so I've been very pleased with the replayability of the game 51st state Master set plays two to four players and I played almost every game at a two player I've done one three player game and I've not played the four player game and that's because I don't really feel like I want to this is um at its best a two-player game it's a very very good two-player experience and the three player game worked well too I've only done one game of it but I've talked to other people in my play group who have done three player games and they have had nothing bad to say about it
they did not think it went too long but pretty much everyone agrees four players feels like it's not going to be worth it and the reason for that is because there is a lot to think about when you're playing this game and one cool thing about the game is is it has a simultaneous analysis Vibe and it just you are all thinking about how you're going to solve your hand in front of you so when it comes back to you usually you're like okay well I know that I'm gonna need to do this I'm just gonna do this and it's the next person's turn I'm going to go back to thinking about what I'm going to do in my hand so it's somewhat rare that you are just sitting there with nothing to do waiting for your opponents really wishing they would take um quicker turns but I I do feel like four players is not going to add enough to the overall gaming experience to be worth the extra time that being said if I was in a situation with four people and three of them really wanted to play the game I would totally play it at four I would not veto it in that situation but I think the game is best with you but certainly not bad at three in conclusion 51st state Master set is what I really wanted Imperial settlers to be it does seem to fix all the issues that I had with that prior game it has wonderful hand management where you're trying to figure out how you're going to crack the code of this hand up do something cool without having runaway leader syndromes it has the end game threshold that just stops when the the players want it to stop because you end the game after somebody gets 25 victory points not after a predetermined number of rounds you won't have situations where somebody is obviously winning and you're just going through the moves to try and end the game before it does you also have these wonderful contact tokens that restrict the options that you have
which enhance the decisions that you have to make because even though you're restricted it seems like there's always a way you always figure a way around the restrictions and it feels that much more satisfying to get really awesome stuff done I haven't even talked about the theme and the art but I will say that it's an interesting theme and the art is stunning in this game like almost every card actually no I take it back every card has different art on it and every card looks great as opposed to Imperial settlers that just every card was a different take on little houses and little TV people this is a much more satisfying experience to look at on the table the bits are wonderful they're all cut wood pieces that just feel great and look great but of course Imperial settlers had that as well like I said this is the game that Imperial settlers really wanted to be for me and it is fired Imperial sellers I'm going to be removing it from my collection and I am going to be keeping 50 first date because I've enjoyed it so much not only have I liked it so much more than 50 first uh than Imperial settlers uh my wife Jess really didn't like Imperial settlers and really enjoys 51st day and a couple other my friends who were not impressed with Imperial settlers have really enjoyed this game so it's funny how you can make these small differences and turn it into a much better gaming experience for a certain subset of people so uh yeah that's that's pretty much it I just been totally impressed with this game it's a wonderful hand management Tableau building experience and I strongly recommend you give it a shot if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support this Channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching