Skip to main content
Loading video...

Disney Villainous: Treacherous Tides - Review

Transcript 6:39

Welcome to Allies Arene Enemies. This time we are talking about Disney villainous Treacherous Tides. Our copy was provided for review, but the thoughts are all our own. Designed by Mike Mulvahill, Treacherous Tides is the latest game for the villainous system. This time adding the dreaded pirate Davy Jones and the shiniest of crabs Tamatoa to the mix. Like the rest of the characters in Villainis, these two baddies are competing to be the first to complete their nefarious schemes by playing cards, fighting heroes, and unleashing the fates upon their rivals. We'll get back to the two new characters in a second. However, first, let's start with how it plays.

At the start of the game, you will choose a character and take their cards, realm board, and miniature. On your turn, you move to any empty space on your realm board, and then take all of the available actions on that space in any order you want. These include gaining power, spending power to play cards from your hand, using allies to vanquish heroes, moving cards in your realm, discarding cards, and using the fate action. This last action means that you draw two cards from your opponent's fate deck and play one of them, which will either cause immediate trouble or add a hero to any space in their realm, covering up actions and getting in the way of their plans. Every villain's goal is a bit different, but the game ends once one player has completed their objective, and they're named the evilst of them all.

So, that's the overview, but let's look at what the new villains bring to the table. First up is Davy Jones, who has the distinction of being the first liveaction character added to the game. Not surprisingly, this booty collector's goal is to pill for treasure by placing and then grabbing five treasure tokens. To do this, you first need to attract heroes to your realm and then when they get some treasure, flip it and steal it from them. The problem is, like the black pearl, each of these treasures also come with a curse that will set you back when it is revealed. However, if you can weather the storm and grab all five goods, you win. The other half of the battle is Tamatoa, who was a drab little crab once, but is on his way to being happy as a clam.

This famously fashionable crustation needs to collect two of the shiniest objects in the sea to add to his collection. Maui's hook and the heart of Teiti. The problem is Maui and Moana would rather not give them up. So, you will first need to lure these heroes to your realm and then defeat them to jack their jewelry and take it to your lair. Also, when Maui is about, you have to flip cards from a second deck, which much like the trickster god himself can be unpredictably good or bad. But once Tomatoa has both bobbles, you win. We've played a lot of villainous and have most of the boxes to date and this one does feel a bit different than the others. The main difference is that using the fate action is a lot more nuanced here. With most villainous villains, you want to play fate cards as often as you can as they jam up their rivals actions and get in the way of their plans. But both Davy Jones and Tamatoa actually need to have heroes in their realms in order to complete their evil plots. So playing a fake card can sometimes play right into their plans.

This doesn't mean you don't want to fade at all. With Davy Jones, a lot of the fate effects move heroes around, making their treasure harder to take or shuffle and flip tokens, setting things back a bit. And for Tamatoa, Maui time is a huge thorn in his oversized pinser as it brings Maui back again and again, grabbing his hook each time he bounces back. The difference, however, is players need to be a bit more careful about when they choose to fate and when they focus on their own plan, picking the right spots. While these two villains play styles are in some ways similar, they also do have some big differences. Most notably, their pacing. Davy Jones kind of methodically moves towards his goal.

Once he has a treasure, he can't lose it. So, while his potential fastest win may be a bit slower than some others, you do have to work quickly against him as he is a bit harder to set back. Tamatoa, on the other hand, can win quickly with a bit of luck in his draws, but he is likely to be set back often. Fittingly for their characters, Davy Jones feels like he's got a plan and the patience to see it to the end, whereas Tamatoa is grabbing at anything shiny, but has trouble keeping it in his claws. In the end, if you like Disney villainous, these are decent additions. But if you haven't been sold on the franchise yet, don't expect a wild deviation from the triedand-true formula. That said, we did appreciate how these two play against each other and how the fate action feels like a bit more of a nuanced decision, but even still, this is Disney villainous, so you have a good sense of what you're getting. Also worth noting is that the chunky minis continue to be great. And though we do miss the three hero boxes, we actually like this game best as a two-player head-to-head battle. So, as a starter set, it kind of shows the game at its best count. And while these may not be our top tier characters, they are both solid additions that would likely fall above average in the overall villainous pantheon.

And that is it. Have you played Stranger Tides? And what did you think? And what are your favorite Disney villainous characters so far? Please let us know in the comments. And please like and subscribe. And hopefully we'll see you all next time for another game.

Progress saved