Skip to main content
Loading video...

Odalin: Dungeons of Doom - Discussion 2.0

Transcript 29:06

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and Brian and I are doing a interesting discussion 2.0 for Oathsworn: Dungeons of Doom. Now, I had this whole discussion 2.0 that was by myself. Um and uh that was before we were informed that we were doing the mind and spirit upgrades wrong. Um that it was indicate uh indicating the total cards that we could have upgraded of those types. Uh that was a huge um huge change.

Yes.

That was alone was worthy enough to kind of uh give this game another shot. But then, we wanted to try the balance track and up the difficulty. Um So, you might be why are we doing a discussion 2.0? Well, there's a couple reasons. Um the sections for this game, I think, take longer than I am wanting to put time into um to do a consistent

[clears throat]

kind of upload like what what we did for chapter one. Um and we're then going to be trying to juggle Gloomhaven. We're about to start Stone Saga if that's not already uploaded by the time this video goes up. And and then this one. So, three campaigns in is is just too much to juggle for the channel. Uh and I'd much rather focus on those two than this one. So, this isn't really this is kind of the first actual discussion 2.0 that we're doing that isn't we're done. Right. You know, cuz for anyone who's new to the channel, I do a discussion 2.0 for a campaign for two reasons. One, we finished the campaign and we're talking about it, or two, we're quitting the campaign. And this is actually the first one that I think we're doing where it's it's here because I want to get my final thoughts out, but also I think it'll just be more of a sporadic oh, here's we have time to do an up a video. So, with all that being said, um Brad, what do you think about

Total Land Dungeons of Doom? My opinion hasn't changed from discussion one.

Okay.

I mean, like I said, it's not the it's not a perfect game.

Yeah.

But it has a sense of like a nostalgia feel to me. It it feels like an older game, too,

Yeah.

in ways. Um you know, it has its issues with certain things, but um I could overlook those things cuz this is the type of game I'll just I would leave just set up.

Yeah.

You know, so having those long sessions are not a problem.

Mhm.

And with the multiple tables that I have to be able to use, and so

Yeah.

Um but uh doing the changes that we did, definitely it's it had a little bit more tension to it

Mhm.

because, you know, we were actually dealing with some damage stuff, some of us.

Yeah.

And then uh a lot of it's self-imposed. Um but uh and then um not having your decks super super powerful,

Yeah.

um I'm still I do like what this did.

Yeah. I'm not sure which one I'm going to use when I do my own.

Yeah.

Um because that whereas that did add some strategy to what cards you're playing, like there's also I also not like don't necessarily want to all the time have that layer of extra stuff on it. I just want to be able to play whatever cards I want and go without worrying about that, too.

Right.

So, I mean, there's it that one I is that was a good change cuz it did mix strategy. But when I'm playing it solo two-handed, I'm probably just going to use the other one.

Yeah, the interesting thing with the power track versus the balance track was it's the power track you then had to think of oh, this was an order attack compared to its chaos value um or vice versa on the enemy that you ended up killing. Um whereas the balance track was easier to manage in the sense that oh, this was an order card move it you know, so so many times. But then whenever an enemy died, you then had to reference the the rulebook. You had to pause everything and be like oh, okay. Now what's the back of the rulebook say? Let's roll. Oh, it's a 12 on chaos. And so it still is very fiddly. Um I still like the fact that the threat this game this game definitely still has has um balance issues because even with the changes of having elite enemies and the the balance track it's still I was never once concerned on ever losing.

Yeah. I think I was the closest to being I had lost the most health.

Right. You got hit cuz

I had like 60 health to start the match and I was down to 20.

Yeah, which for all if you're if you're taking that into consideration, it's like wow, you lost 40 health. Yeah, but never once was I ever like oh [ __ ] you are about to lose.

Right.

Um even whenever you took that massive hit of 18 damage or whatever, I was still like you still have more health than all the enemies.

Right.

Um but ah the what people will say is okay, we'll bump the difficulty up again. I that's not a to me, that's not an adequate um um difficulty spike. That's the To me, that's the equivalent of changing the difficulty in a video game, and all it does is give the enemies more health, so they're just bullet sponges. It's like that doesn't equate to a good feeling while you're playing.

It just makes it longer.

It just Exactly. It just makes it longer, and the game is not deep enough to justify its length. That's why I'm having us do this review because I don't want to sit here and do sections that are 3 hours long because you do go through the motions. Um we ended up calling it early cuz you kind of made the observation that, you know, there's always been multiple paths, and they give you multiple ways to get purifying relics. Originally, we had thought that was just in case you [ __ ] up somewhere. And that is still true, in case we didn't talk to the

serpent in the back I saved.

We'd have to go find the other one. And I like that. But your thing was, "Okay, well, we got the purifying relic, so we should probably just leave because there's no reason to continue off the other way."

Mhm.

Uh and I hope that's the case cuz it does shorten the sections. However, it does get to a point where every time you're doing a combat, the combat is more or less the same. Um so, yeah, the balance The balance track I do think is better than the the power track. Uh it does add more strategy. I think, honestly, the more tension was based off our uh corruption.

Mhm.

That because we were constantly gaining more corruption without a lot of ways to reduce it.

Right.

So, the fear wasn't the sense of, "Oh, we're going to lose because someone lost all their health." It was, "Oh, we are now at the at the odds of a hero becoming um whatever it's called where the the demon takes over. Yeah, possessed.

control.

Yeah, and then now they have to fight the the demon. That was kind of more of an interesting thing. So, it's still not balanced uh in in the way that I like, but it is better than what it was.

Right.

Um So, I mean, that's kind of honestly where where I'm where I'm sitting is the changes to the decks uh fixing it with the spirit and the mind.

Mhm.

That was the biggest positive change.

for sure.

Um because I think with the the the actually having to decide what cards are you're flipping um actually gives the characters some level of depth versus how we originally took it was that's how much you get to do at every campfire phase. So, I'm like, okay, so everyone just has their decks maxed out.

every deck. Every card in his was double almost double flipped.

Yeah.

Almost. Not all of them, but they were pretty close.

And now it's just, okay, I have for Vorlag, I have one attack or aura that is flipped and two instances or abilities that are flipped. And I mean, you have what, 12 cards? Two, four, six, eight, 10. You have 12 cards, 24 total flip. Yeah, that is significantly less. And each rest area is whenever you get to decide which ones. You're like, okay, this one isn't really working right now, so I'm going to swap it to a different ability. I like that. I think that that does give the game a little bit more uh strategic value. Um Was there anything cuz I know we did our discussion after the second section of chapter

I think so. I can't remember.

of chapter one and we've only done chapter section one of chapter two. So, we're still a ways out from finishing it, but was there anything that you liked more or disliked more um in that period from this discussion to the last discussion?

Um I mean I agreed with you about we were too powerful.

Yeah.

But we were also playing on normal difficulty. We were we were doing our deck our deck upgrading.

Yeah.

And stuff. So, you we were OP when it came into that. Um having those changes though, I mean I I still get the same feeling. I still enjoy what I'm doing.

Mhm.

So, I don't think it's it was really anything that big. I mean it just I mean

makes more sense after that corrected to do stuff.

Yeah. I'm still not a fan I mean cuz I apparently what from what a lot of people were telling us is that which I didn't know when we did our first discussion was that Grigorii Games had this stupid game found uh tracking number commitment where if they didn't give you your tracking number at a certain time that you I can't remember it was like some full refund or or something. So, what they would do is they would give you your tracking number, but then they'd still be months out from actually shipping it. But apparently what that caused was them to have this shortened development time.

Right.

Uh which is is very clear that this game I needs a a 2.0. I think it needs more refinement, more balancing. Um I think the bones of Odalys is here. I think

Series

I'm chewing on that. Um I don't think this game even from my our first discussion to my solo discussion to this, I don't think this game is bad. It just needs It just needs more development time. In my opinion, uh it needs more stuff to I want I say more stuff to do. Um but I guess what I'm really meaning is I think the the sections just need more variety. That was one of the original issues of why I wanted to stop was that playing in as frequently as we did, every section blends together.

Right.

You literally do the same thing and run around and interact and the enemies aren't as varied. So, yes, you can give them elite modifiers, which we'll talk about. That does change the combat um in a good way, but at the end of the day, it's like, man, do I really want to do five sections of chapter two and the only thing that changes is the numbers get higher. That's not interesting. Oh, with our next, you know, item card, who really cares because we're not going to change our builds. Um it there's a fine line with games like these that actually incentivize you to actually level up and change out what you're doing. And I don't think this game is quite there for me.

Um so, that's kind of why I think this ends up being one of those games that we play every once in a while and then upload the video, you know, whenever we we have a spare two, three hours or oh, hey, we finally finished Gloomhaven or this campaign ended up sucking or whatever we have a free day out of nowhere. Let's just Yeah, let's pop a a game of Oathsworn now, which I think why it works so well for you.

Right.

You have that capability of being able to leave it set up and be like, "Oh, okay. I'll go down and play a session."

Right.

And then leave it set up and, you know, walk away. I don't have that luxury. I have a ton of [ __ ] I need to do for the channel and other games and stuff. So, I don't get to leave campaign games set up. So, I have to be more selective with the ones I want to commit a full day of gaming to. Um what did you think of the elite modifiers?

I mean, I think they could the this the the abilities are nice.

Yeah.

Because that one that silenced us and made it where we couldn't we couldn't uh help play off of turn. That was big. I mean, cuz that's that's a lot of this is being able to use your instance on other people and stuff. So, that was cool.

And it being like the first room to where we were just a we didn't have a whole lot of room to move out of that.

Right. And then the second one, what was the

It was Yeah, it was if you were at half health, it was called killer, then it did it did double damage.

the abilities are awesome. I'm not sure I like how they did the where you kill them once and then they just come back to I think it would have been better if they just said this person has I know it's nitpicky and I know it's it's the same thing. Yeah. But, I think they should have done like this guy's going to have 50 health.

Yeah. It'd be like it it just doubles his health or something.

I know ultimately that's what it is anyway, yeah, but it just it just it would make more sense if it was just instead of you know, flip it tapping the ability card and continuing to do it again.

Yeah. Again, I agree with you wholeheartedly. I think the the elite modifier um changes or the effect is really nice cuz it does change how you were going to uh you know, solve the the combat, who you're going to target and stuff. But, I agree with you. I think having that again that bullet sponge effect where it's it it feels like a cop out. Of trying to pay like, okay, how do I want to do different difficulties? Uh whatever, we'll just give them they just come back. It's like, okay, that's just kind of cheap.

Um yeah, and if I don't know if they if you added or gave them a bunch of shield, if that would be better.

[snorts]

You would do the same amount of damage, but over time like if you if they had shield.

So you don't crit as hard or you don't you don't hit all the time.

I don't know. Like but the

Yeah.

The problem is though is it's it's very random also because just like that last encounter, the last combat we had,

Yeah.

the last well the two times we had the combats, it was a 25 health person. If it would have landed on the fatty,

Mhm.

he would have been 250. That changes a lot of stuff cuz then it's a 100 health versus 50.

Yeah, exactly. And then in that case, the the viper guy definitely leaves so we don't get the purifying relic which means we have to run to the other side extended out even longer, another hour and a half um of just combat just to get a stupid token that we could leave.

Cuz it's just the first thing that comes out

Yeah.

is the what gets it. So there was three enemies in that room. 33% chance we had a 100 health dude.

Exactly.

you know.

Yeah, [snorts] and I think ultimately the problem with the elite modifier doing that is because the enemy variety so low. They have very few actual enemies and because their initiative card has their health and their defense, it is the same. Um so you don't have that opportunity of having a ton of different types of the same enemy that has different defense and different health pools. It's just, okay, if we're fighting a vampire uh or a viper warrior, it is always going to be 25 health two defense. Um no matter what. I mean, I guess of course if a ability says something different or a sect section says something different.

Uh and I just again, I find that an inherent flaw with the the combat system. Uh if you're looking for a game that does feel like a video game, you can kind of see where that inspiration is coming from, but then you fall into the tropes of when I hear people reviewing video games, no enemy variety. That's you run into the same stuff or they're bullet sponges. And it's almost like he took the worst tropes of sub-par video games and implemented them into a board game. And instead of a video game taking 20 minutes to clear a room, it's 2 hours. And yeah, so I like the elite effects. Um yeah, I just I don't know how else they would fix it without completely just redesigning the game.

Especially with yeah, I mean there there's I guess the crit thing wouldn't really make a difference either cuz you have cards. I mean, we only have four characters we're using. But like my deck had a card that's just 20 damage.

Exactly.

You know, and it's like that that's not going to stop that. So

Yeah, and then again, even having it come back. I will say that having the balance track and having the elite modifier, the enemies actually did get to go more than once. They weren't just immediately glassed as soon as you open the door and you're JUST LIKE, "HA!" AND THEN THEY JUST pink misted everywhere. Um we did do that to one enemy, the fat guy, but that's because he would have just killed the viper guy we want to talk to. So we actively strategized to focus on him. Um but I didn't feel that that was cheap because we actually had to work to just try and one shot him. Uh versus how it felt in the past where we just did that to every enemy and it was like, "Why even bring them out?" You know? In this case with the balance track and the elite modifier, there was a reason to bring them out. They did attack. They we didn't have a bunch of instance and stuff. So, I do think that that is the inherent way to play this game which is what was told that the balance track and the elite modifiers are the correct way to play.

And then I mean the unfortunate part is if you upgrade the difficulty again it's the first two enemies get it.

Right.

So, then your sections just become even longer. And then if you upgrade it again

Then they'd both have abilities, too.

Uh yeah. Yeah, so so it goes to Oh, where is it? Um so, we played on hard and it's just the first person. Uh nightmare is one random elite.

A random.

To the first two. And then if you play on hell a random elite uh add a random elite card to the two first Oh, and all elite enemies take an extra turn at the end of each round.

Oh, so they like have two activations around?

Yep.

See, that would suck.

Yeah. And I mean even then I I don't Yeah, I mean I guess yeah hell because they would be going twice and that means because they have they would come back with you couldn't just one shot them. They'd come back. They'd most likely be going multiple times. Um you would probably yeah actually finally start to feel like you have low health. Uh especially because you don't fully heal at the end of combat. So, you have to do that the entire time. I don't know. Again, my impressions of the game are more positive uh with these changes, but it wasn't this drastic 180 where I'm just like, "Wow, now it's a game." It's okay. It's better. I don't still I still don't really I like the loot system in the sense that you actually get a bunch of loot, but I don't like the loot system because I find it still samey.

Um I like the combat modifications that we did. I think there's still more strategy. However, I don't like how long it makes it now.

Right.

So, everything that I like does is like hand-in-hand with things I don't like. Um But, I do still like the narrative. I think that's the better part of the game. Um I'm more intrigued by that. I don't what I wonder if this game would just be better with two two actual players.

And then you'd get two turns per player. And that's how I'm going to play it.

Yeah.

When I go through.

I really feel like

a hammer and they each get to go twice.

Yeah. I I think that that would one that might that would probably speed things up because then we wouldn't have to sit here cuz what I do cuz you look at both hands.

Yeah.

Um what I have done is who's first? Oh, Vorag is going first. I'm just looking at his cards.

Yeah.

And then it's like, "Oh, time for Tuscan to go. All right, what's he What can he do?"

That's how I cuz I play a lot of two-handed solos. That's how I do. I always have them laid out. So, that way I can kind of see what they do.

Yeah.

Back and forth that can do.

And I don't do that. Marvel Champions, Arkham Horror, when I'm playing I'm look I'm like, "Okay, whose turn is it? All right, this is what I want to do." And then if something happens where I'm like, "Oh, well, let me see if they can help in any way." Nope, okay, I'm done. I'm not even thinking about the second player. So, I think it might be better if you just had two characters. Um it gets less fiddly. You don't have to really worry about bumping into each other getting in each other's way. Um I mean, these games typically are better when you have a full party, but I think for just ease of play you would just be able to full full focus on one character and focus on the better build instead of having to manage a special ability on top of their build, on top of the initiative cards, on top of uh their deck, on top of upgrading their decks.

And I guess this game does kind of allow for a nice plug-and-play system. Hm.

Yeah.

That might be something we might have to try and to see. I wonder what this game

We get this We're going to get You would still get the same number of hero turns.

You would. Yeah.

It's just going to be more direct. Like you'd get through your deck more than once. Like each each of these last combats we did, we made it through our deck about Well, I think we ended our deck. It took about three rounds.

Yeah. True.

Each battle. But you'd get through your deck more doing two characters, two activations.

Right. Does no one have this game? Like this is the first time I've looked at the poll results and no one has said anything on who it's on the number of players it's best with or who they recommend it uh for. I mean, I do I do think this company doesn't have that high favorability with a lot of people. Um I don't know. I I don't I just I don't know. But that's kind of where I'm at. So, in case anyone's watching and they're thinking uh I know our um original discussion had a lot of people saying that they're glad they missed out on this one or some people saying that they've It was kind of a 50/50. People like, "Man, [ __ ] this company. I'm glad I passed on this." And then others are like, "I'm having a good time with it."

And that's kind of where we're at. Where you're like, "I'm having a good time with it." And I'm like, "Eh."

Yeah.

It's okay. So, like I said, it's it's mainly the my main draws to this game is because it feels cuz I've played the old school cuz I've gamed a long time.

Yeah.

And it has that feel of the old dungeon crawlers. I know it's got updated mechanics.

Right.

But as far as like the feel of it, just feels like old school

Yeah.

dungeon crawlers that came out like the you know, like the late '90s

Right. Yeah. and stuff like that. That's That I think I just get a lot of that feeling from this game. I think that's what bumps it up for me even more and I can overlook a little bit of stuff as just because of I played those dumpster fires back in the back then, you know, 30 years ago, 25 years ago, whatever.

Yeah, you get that nostalgic kick.

Right.

Whereas I'm sitting [clears throat] here and I'm more I'm just A lot of it comes down to I'm just more time conscious uh about stuff. And so whenever I look at it and I'm like, "Oh god, that was 3 hours and I didn't get much out of it." Um it especially with how many campaign games I play, I look at I know they're different games, but let's take a the feeling I get whenever I'm playing the same amount of time over Radia, I'm stoked the entire time. I'm having a good time the entire time. And here, it's like uh I don't even want to do another section. No, I think I'd rather play something else. Um yeah, it's just it's it's fine. Like I wouldn't It wasn't I will say definitely wasn't worth the money.

Like that That's

agree. I mean, that's this is one of the most I This or Marvel Zombies would have been my most expensive Yeah. crowdfunding projects. So, I'm not sure. You know.

Um yeah.

I think we spent over seven for Marvel Zombies and this was right at seven. You know, so I think that's

Yeah, so that's that's kind of also I mean the money spent gone so who really cares but yeah, when you look at it and you're like god for a $700 game and I'm I'm lukewarm on it. That sucks. But Uh okay, well on a scale of 1 to 10 are you still I don't remember what you had it at.

one night like an 8.5.

you were eight eight or 8.5. I think I was seven originally.

Yeah. I want to say I was an 8.5 cuz I didn't go all the way up to nine. I'm just going to keep it the same.

Okay. Like I said I'm I'm still going to play through my own cuz I'll just have it set up on a second table and I'll still play through it with two characters and see how that rolls and stuff.

Yeah, so Uh I think I was at a seven. Um I thought it was good. Then when I did my original or my second run-through run-through discussion by myself I it was at a four. Uh but I think with the with the modifications it I will bump it up to a five. I think I think it's fine. Um It's It has it has good things but it's tied with the bad things. I This would like I said we're doing the discussion now just pretty much just in case I don't ever upload another video for it then I have our I have this was kind of my true final thoughts on it but you know, if I don't get rid of it or if I just keep it around and we just play it here and there.

Um I think that is kind of a perfect uh encapsulation of my overall thoughts. Okay, yeah, let's just play a a section of Odolan but I'm not going to put a lot of time and effort into getting it done.

Yep.

Um so that's it. That's our thoughts on Odolan Dungeons of Doom. I guess keep if you like the this the videos for it. They might be uploaded sporadically but um I wouldn't hold your breath. You got anything else? All right. Well, that's another one. I hope you enjoyed Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved